Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Fake Saints - their Causes, Traits and Significance

Fake Saints - their Causes, Traits and Significance

Panthic weekly fan · 16 Jan 2006

Fake Saints - their Causes, Traits and Significance Sunday 10th April, 2005 Manjit Singh - Panthic Weekly Columnist (KP) Last week's clash between Singhs of the Tarn Taran vicinity and the followers of the Ashutosh sect raise a number of questions on the situation of Sikhi abroad and at home; the very Ashutosh who was been accused of crimes such as placing his feet on the Holy Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, and disrespecting Sikhi, has centres nationwide in England, as well as in California, New York and Canada. Such cults, in a similar fashion to those such as Narinder Grewal, Darshan Dass and UK Sanatanism, all appear to be short-lived ‘trends’ which are either dying out or are now relatively obscure. However, the phenomenon of such personality cults is an interesting one to examine; its causes, effects and traits are ones that we reflect upon and compare to our own Sikhi. Firstly it should be noted that the importance of holy personalities within Sikhism, and perhaps all religions, couldn’t be underestimated. A true Saint is held in the utmost esteem in Bani; a Sikh is told to do Seva of the true Saint, keep Sangat of the true Saint and learn from the true Saint. In my own bedroom, the wall is plastered full of Sikh martyrs and holy men of the past; the home libraries of many Singhs and Singhnia often contain many biographies, sakhis and descriptions of Saints of the past. However, capitalising on the tendency of human beings to either slander and discredit, or idolise and venerate others, there are some who manage to move themselves into positions of essentially God-like figures. In our modern society, we live in a consumerist culture where desires must be quickly fulfilled and problems need immediate solutions; many will take advantage of this and what are known as Nakli Babeh pose as those who can provide universal salvation for mankind. Such people are elevated to that level of God; many innocent Sikhs, not putting their faith in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj, end up believing this, feeling that they can personify God and all their devotion towards a single being. Indeed; it is more of a comfort factor for a human to seek refuge in a walking, speaking being; the famous saying of Sai Baba was “Why fear when I am here”. Throughout the ages, a faith in a higher being, afterlife or later reward has always provided comfort to the masses; the concept of God incarnate in a human form, who can easily dispense salvation to all is perhaps a continuation or extension of this. When I recently travelled to Panjab I realised that the number of similar cults and Deras that existed were far more numerous than I had seen or heard of elsewhere. Is it possible that Panjabis are more prone to being duped by a Nakli Baba than a western person? It is surely a fact that in the Pinds of Panjab information is nowhere near as easily available as it is in our modern western world and in addition, high poverty and drug abuse levels may indeed turn people more towards the aforemented ‘quick-fix’ solutions. Nakli Babeh also tend to plan out their organisations and what they say, they say very cleverly. Sikhs, despite having such a beautiful religion, seem completely inept at explaining or preaching it to others. A good attempt at informing the masses has been achieved by groups such as the Sikh Federation and BOSS, in explaining to our Youth what happened in 1984 and the period of unrest around this time period. However, beyond this point we have not managed to capture or unite the minds of the youth on topics of spirituality or the metaphysical discussions of our beloved Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. Examining cults such as the Noormalias, we see that they tend to widen their target audience by declaring their aims are transcendent to organised religion; a good way to not only avoid contradictions with any faith, but also a good way to unoriginally borrow elements from all of them. We can even see a similar trend arising in UK Sanataism; at a Sanatan talk it was claimed that Sikhism was in fact not an a religion at all, ignoring the numerous references to the institutionalisation of Sikhism at the time of the Khalsa and the documentation in old scriptures of Sikhism being “the Third Path” (separate to Islam and more importantly Hinduism). These techniques of evading the idea of belonging to an organised religion may perhaps also have given Sanatanists the leeway to drink at weddings, commit adultery and other similar irreligious acts. The traits of fluidity in concepts and a personality cult being set up can actually be applied to huge events in past history; one may be interested to note the similar personality cults being set up around past dictators such as Stalin, Hitler and Mussolini; all spent huge amounts of effort devoted to their personal image and ensuring that the public saw them as some sort of demi-God figure. Historical study can also lead us to see the same sort of fluidity in the concepts, laws and ideals of the above dictactor’s policies; there can be no doubt that such movements are based on persons rather than ideals; often the ideals themselves are tailored by the person to appeal to the masses. However despite the fact that many of these groups are founded on what are essentially lies, fraud and a thirst for power, it is impossible to label every misguided follower of a similar group or cult as completely devoid of positive qualities in every way. A Singh I once met whose beliefs were very similar to that of the Radhaswami faith, displayed so much love for his form of ‘Naam’ that he had received from his Baba, that it put my own piaar (love) and devotion literally to shame. Many Nakli Babeh do try to promote love and harmony to promote their own credibility, and many have surely done some charity work for mankind. Once I spoke to a follower of Sai Baba and asked him, if the allegations of child molestation were true, would he still be an ardent follower. He replied that even if the allegations were true and Sai Baba was a paedophile, it would make no difference to him as he was still for him God Himself. Whilst others may scorn or be humoured by such a reply I was in awe that such strong blind love could be displayed, no matter who it was displayed towards. In this manner, we have a lot to learn from such groups; not only in how to recognise them and avoid them, but also so that we can take any positive aspects they have apply them to our daily lives. Manjit Singh can be reached at [address removed]

Re: Fake Saints - their Causes, Traits and Significance

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Jan 2006

baba-following fools are not a "sikh" monopoly.... I just met a "hindu Ph.D. in Aeronautical Engineering who came from USA, where he works in nasa. He called me over the phone and invited me to a talk by a famous Hindu Swami from India.....and the Swami mentioned that during the Marathha Wars of Shivaji, the Marathha Army actually had "Aeroplanes" flying high that dropped "agni bombs" on Aurengeb's armies...and that someone gave away this secret to the British (sabotaeur) who then used them to conquer the world. According to him IF this secret had remained in India..it wouldnt be colonised at all.. My NASA friend had no trouble beleiving this rubbish...in fact he tried to "convince" me of it and the CLASSIC... BABAJI SAYS..so MUST be TRUE !!! was his final take on the subject. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Fake Saints - their Causes, Traits and Significance

Harcharan Singh · 17 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Jarnail Singh Ji, Could I put one thing to you kindly and with all due respect. Could you please refrain from being so judgemental and using derogatory language against people who may or may not be following the correct path. Although I am highly amused by the Royal Maratha Air Force story also, we should be compassionate and take pity on people who cannot see fact from fiction, not isolate them further by calling them fools. Love, compassion and respect always wins, even in war. See Guru Gobind Singh Jis treatment of the panth's enemies, Guru Ji would put allow Mughal Soldiers to put their turban back on before passing away and ensure they had Islamic burials. Guru Gobind Singh Ji has also said: Dushman naal saam, daam, bhaed, aadiak, upaa vartnae - Treat the opponent with respect I have no problem with your mission on exposing fakes, but you would double the number of people who listen to you if you did so in an intelligent, respectful and civilised manner - a Gur-Sikh manner. Sat Sri Akaal Harcharan Singh

Re: Fake Saints - their Causes, Traits and Significance

... · 17 Jan 2006

Well said Harcharan Singh!!!

Re: Fake Saints - their Causes, Traits and Significance

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Jan 2006

Point accepted veer Ji harcharan Singh Jio. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Fake Saints

satnam · 18 Jan 2006

i would like to ask mr swaran singh panesar were his daughters wedding was held, which gurdwara sahib. was it by any chance guru nanak nishkam sewak jatha leeds UK? and he also has had various akhand paths and other programs to,so why the sudden slander of the jatha?