Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. I came across this message in another forum... <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< QUOTED MESSAGE: :Gur fateh , Guru sahib gave preference to Rag Siri to be taken first in granth sahib , but Ragmala says "Pritham rag Bhairo ve karee" , which is main contradiction with Gurbani .The fact is that in 991 Hijri a Muslim Poet "Alam" composed a Granth named "Madhav Nal Kaam kandla " .This rag mala is on page 13 Chhand 63 to 72 .There is a story behind it also but the we drift from the subject if I give that story here .The story pertains to a Rasika (Dancer) NOTE:-"1 After Hijra" or "1 AH". The first day of 1 AH, corresponds to Friday July 16th, 622 CE in the Julian Calendar." .This period comes to about 21 years earlier than Compilation of Granth sahib , The writer himself writes that " sambat nau sau ikanvey aahi ! Karon katha abb bolo nahi !!" in his Granth .The only witness in support of Ragmala is the "Gurbilas Patsahi-6" , in which it has been mentioned that when the 5th Guru completed the Pothi sahib , The Rags reached there with all Dholkis, Chhaina , Taus , Khanjri and Jodian and requested Guru sahib to take their care and give them some representation in this Pothi .Guru Ji had already closed the Pothi at "Mundavani" . (as Rags were in Human form) My father Giani Niranjan Singh Journalist who mentions in they darshan of book that he had darshan of this Bir at Kartarpur (Fake or original) in 1944 and saw that on page 973 there is Mundavani , 874 page and there after was blank which clarifies that the last bani is Mundavani .There were so many other mentions like Ratan mala ,Siahi di Bidh , some pictures of jotijyote samauna , mention of the looting and Burning of Kartar pur , a reference about the visit of Maharaja Ranjit Singh to Kartarpur . All these mentions are not part of Bani at all .I have so many more refences which prove that Ragmala was not part of Granth sahib . avnindersingh>>>>>>End of Message. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> My query- Can anyone explain how from Aang 874 ( where MUNDAWNI is recorded)...after about 100 EMPTY Pages...the so called Raagmala is recorded. ???? solid proof that this is an after-thought addition/adulteration by some unknown person. Jarnail Singh

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

LionKing · 16 Jan 2006

2 Issues. 1 - From What I understand Alam is a poet, not a Raagi/musian - how could a poet write a bunch of stuff about Raags - to me it does nto make sense. 2 - How could these hundred pages be included without any major notice being made - i.e how can you attach 100 pages into a completed pothi, without noticing any marks.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Jan 2006

1. Its not such a big thing..a poet can be a musician..a tabla player...a writer. And anyway Alam is NOT "playing the raags or writing mucial notes..he is just LISTING the Raags..their wives, sons daughters etc etc as if the Raags are "human". I am NOT a "musician". or even a poet....but i can write out a LISt of raags anytime..in poetry !!BUT i cannot write a "musical note"..or play a raag ( not even a harmonium except the Saregamapadanesa..ssare..rrega..etc.) 2. The way the Kartarpuri Birr and most Granths of the time were written is like this. The SCRIBE ( in this case Bhai Gurdass Ji) would Prepare a SHEAF of Pages ( much like an "exercise book as used in school)...and then as Guur Ji would recite..he wuld fill up the empty pages....and ADD a new SHEAF as and when required. Those who have examined the Kartarpuri Birr say that there is evidence that soemtimes the SHEAF had too many pages.... thus many left blank..and sometimes there was a shortage...then the margins etc are also filled up. Many AAngs throughout the Birr are BLANK..but not as much as 100 as in raagmala case. In this case the Last SHEAF....AANG 874 has MUNDAWNI and Slok mah 5. Then the REST of the SHEAF is EMPTY (BLANK) Simialr to a student writing up on the first few pages of his exercise book....and the rest of it is left blank. In this case after Aang 874.....the Raagmala is On PAGE 973. In between there are recipes for INK, some extra poems about Shah muhammadah shabad etc ALL of WHICH have been effectively PROVEN to BE NON GURBANI and REMOVED from the Printed Birrs except for Raagmalla whcih comes 100 pages later after Mundawni. Jarnail Singh

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Tandoori Ram · 19 Jan 2006

Mr Arshi: Do you consider yourself a Sikh of the Guru? Guru Granth Sahib is are Guru, Correct? You think of Guru Granth Sahib as A Book? Not a Guru. The Guru is not stupid, there is no way that he would let anything else other than his bani in the Guru Granth Sahib. Why do you think that the Khalsa Panth is suffering. People have started questioning Dasam Granth, now Sri Guru Granth Sahib.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Jan 2006

so Tandoori Ram jio, Does YOUR "GURU" have all the 100 ++ EMPTY PAGES ?? and how do you 'read" them ?? WHO decided to REMOVE them from the copies present in gurdwaras ? Why were SEVEN other Utter NONSENSENSE compositions, REMOVED from "guru" ?? Did those people regard the Guru as "stupid" and removed them ?? Guru is NOT "stupid" that is Blasphemy..But many of his Sikhs definitley are...those that READ EMPTY PAGES, READ INK RECIPES, READ nonsense poem about Shah Muhammed, read notes about Birthdays of Gurus etc etc..and read that Raags have wives, sons, daughters, grandchildren..and like the GORAY in Western Hemsiphere..a "child" can have many different Fathers...mothers etc.. Actually GURU KE SIKHS are not stupid either..its just those sant baba followers who are dastaardharee sikhs...and who follow their sant abba and not the GURU..who puts final seal at MUNDAWNI...but we co ntine to read on like a faulty gasoline engine that refuses to stop even after the key is taken out of the ignition... No offense to anyone..even...

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

khalistani · 19 Jan 2006

there is an article on damdamitaksal.org if anyone wants t see on raag maala or was it .com? aint sure go take a look if u want bhula chuka maf

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Halwa Ram · 19 Jan 2006

> Raagmala is recorded. ???? solid proof that this is an > after-thought addition/adulteration by some unknown person. > > Jarnail Singh Do you know who Sant Baba Ishar Singh was? Are you familiar with the letter he wrote to Bhai Randhir Singh? In the letter he tells Bhai Randhir Singh stop saying raag mala's not bani. He also later said that, that is why he had to get punished in jail. For saying Raag Mala is not bani. This issue has split the khalsa panth. Open your eyes and Embrace the Guru Granth Sahib as a living Guru not a book. In the olden days khalsa panth was talking about changing the Dasam Granth. Bhai Mehtab Singh said that if he came back with Massa Rangers head that they are not to alter the Dasam Granth. With Guru Sahibs kirpa he succeeded. If the Raag Mala was not bani Guru Sahib would have made sure that it would not appear in the Guru Granth Sahib. This is waheguru's bani recited through the Guru's. There is no way that any inferior writing would be in the Guru Granth Sahib.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

:S · 20 Jan 2006

probably a stupid question but is there not a mathimatical system with the numbers at end of each pauri, etc... If so can we not use it for its purpose...?

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Gajjar Ram · 20 Jan 2006

Guru Gobind Singh called his Granth the chotey granth. Having 1428 pages on purpose. While Guru Granth Sahib has 1430 pages. If there was no raag mala why would Guru Gobind Singh refer to his baani as the chota granth? [%sig%]

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

singh · 20 Jan 2006

Gajjar Ram you are confused guru ji never compiled dasam granth into a single granth himself. if you actually read the bani you will see it in itself was meant to be split into seperate granths. furthermore the number of angs was standardised only recently. the sizes of writing etc would mean that number of angs varied. and 1429 is still bigger than 1428. and there is no 9th gurus bani in saroop at kartarpur. if there is then this proves furthermore it is not authentic. finally i would be interested to see this baba isher singh letter, perhaps it is another keeray type story :)

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Karnail Singh Barshi · 20 Jan 2006

Author: :S Date: 01-20-06 06:16 probably a stupid question but is there not a mathimatical system with the numbers at end of each pauri, etc... If so can we not use it for its purpose...? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< That perfect system..is not utilised in the raagmala...instead the person who copied it ( cut and paste 17th century style) tried to be clever and used the same numeral [1] throughout the raagmala from beginning to end...ha ha ha...can anyone beleive that.( but lots do actually !! surprising) If any one cares to note gurbani in Guru Ji carefully...you will not fail to notice that guru ji has put in a 150% fool proof iron clad method to stop any such nonsense. Guru ji counts..each mehala, each shabad, each pada, each rahao...totals of each and running totals etc etc are all in place. no one can even add or remove one single panktee without upsetting the entire numeral sytem - its that good. but raagmaala comes at the end..after 100 empty pages...anyone can add anything after that....commercial printers like chattars have added their own names and shops addresses before gurbani !!..and so can anyone add raagmaala or ink recipes etc after gurbani----no big deal actually. if its not a "sin" to write ones own name and address in GURU JI...and no body protests about this..who cares about a bippar who added raagmaala in a different mail singh ji has provided authentic sources like maha kavi santokh singh and gyani gyan singh that categorically state that ragamal is not gurbani--its not. ks barshi

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

singh · 21 Jan 2006

the same "1" "1" repetitions also appear in other kachi banis like siahi ki bidh.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

LionKing (LK) · 21 Jan 2006

Author: Gajjar Ram Date: 01-20-06 10:07 Guru Gobind Singh called his Granth the chotey granth. Having 1428 pages on purpose. While Guru Granth Sahib has 1430 pages. If there was no raag mala why would Guru Gobind Singh refer to his baani as the chota granth? ******************** Veeray this arguement does not hold for several reasons. - As Veer above says even if it was 1429 it would be more than "chota Granth" - It would imply Guru ji cared about how many ang - he didn't he only cared about getting the mesage through. If it woudl take Dasam Guru ji 1569 pages- I'm sure he wouldn't hesitate - As Veer above says Dasam Granth was never compiled into one by Guru Ji himself, but it is said that Bhai Mani SIngh ji did that on the order of Mata Sahib Kaur (or was it Mata Jito jee?) - Lastly (If I'm not mistaken), Guru Granth Sahib Ji's saroop did not have 1430 angs to begin with, but each Saroop had different amount of angs depending on size etc. The fixed 1430 angs per saroop came during the Singh Sabha Movement when Singhs were removing false stuff added into Guru Ji, like Rattan Mala etc (Perhaps they had a reason for not removing Raag mala???), and fixed the numer 1430 whether big Saroop or small, in order to prevent dodgy people to add dodgy stuff... One wonders that if they wereable to remove the false stuff, they must have reasoned about Raag mala too, yet they decided not to remove it...? Bhull chukk maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa VAheguru Ji Ki fateh

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

... · 21 Jan 2006

Giani Gian Singh writes that there was a Panthic decision to remove it and a saroop with Ragmala in it had Hartal used to erase it. It was the Mahants and other Sadhs that refused to get rid of it.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

... · 21 Jan 2006

Ragmala NirNiya By Prof. Piara Singh Padam Sikh Missionary College, Amritsar Just as in Punjabi literature, poets have written love stories of “Sohni-Maheevaal” and “Mirzaa-Sahibaa”, in old Hindustani literature, “Madhavaanal & Kaamkandla” is a story many poets wrote. Prof. M R Maujamdar (Baroda College) is the main researcher in regards to the old literature related to Kamkandla. He has written me a letter in which he says that Pandit Anandhar had written “Madhvaanal Akhian” in a mix of Sanskirt language in the 11th or 14th Century. Prakrit can also be found in this work. The story has been presented as a minor play. After this, Gurjarti poet Ganpat, who was a resident of Baroch Gujarat, wrote a long poem Madhvaanal Kaamkandla Prabodh in 1584 Bikrami. There are eight chapters and 2565 verses in it. From a literary view, this is important to read for a researcher. After this, in 1616 Bikrami, Kaushllaabh wrote Maadhvaanal Kaamkandla Chaupaiee. Both these books are written in Rajasthani language and have been influenced by Prakrit. Based on Sanskrit and Praakrit books, poet Aalam, a contemporary orf Akbar, in 1640 Bk. wrote the book Madhvaanal Katha in Hindi. This has 353 verses and most of it is Chaupaiee style. This story was first very famous in Gujarat and so, after Akbar had conquered Gujarat, he had it translated into Hindi. Aalam has hinted at this in the start of his work. Prof Maujamdar in his book writes: “This story appears to have been popular mostly in Western India, only very a late period it came to be adopted in Marathi. The version of the story in Hindi by a Muslim poet, “Alam” styled “Madhavnal Katha” was composed in Hijri samt 991 (1640Bi,. 1584 AD) only a decade after Akbar’s conquest of Gujrat at the expressed desire of Raja Todar Mal for the pleasure of emperor Akbar.” This belief has been supported by Missr. Bandu Binod, Ram Chand Shukal, Ganga Prashaad and Dr. Hira Lal. This belief by the academics is not based on some hearsay, but based on the book’s internal evidence. [gurbani] Jgpq rwj kot jug kIjY[ Swh jlwl Cq®piz jIjY idlIpiq Akbr sulqwnw[ spq dIp mih jw kI Awnw[ Drm rwj sB dys clwvw[ ihMdU qurk pMQ sB lwvw[ AwgY nYb mhwmq mMq®I[ in®p todr ml Cq®I[ … dys dys ky Bupiq AwvihM[ duAwry Bir vwr nihM pwvihM[ sMn nO sO ieikAwvn AwhI[ kro kQw ab bolo qwhI[ kCu ApnI kC p®wik®q coro~[ XQw Skq kr Acr joro[ [/gurbani] After this, the story in the book (briefly) follows that a singer by the name of Maadhvaanl is a resident of Pushpaavti. All the women of the town are attracted to him. The King exiles Maadhv and from there he goes to King Kamsain’s town of Kaamvati. Here a dancer by the name of Kaamkandla is dancing in the King’s court. Here, poet Alam takes the opportunity to show his knowledge of Raags, and has Kaam Kandla sings the family of Raags according to the Hanumant school. It is important to be a good storyteller so the poet keeps both things in mind. First he paints a picture of many instruments being played and then he begins the singing of the raags. The poet writes: [gurbani] BIn auPMg bMsrI bwjY[ FwfI jMq® Amim®qI swjY[ surmMfl vwjY Gn qMqI[ rud® bIn swrMg bhu BmqI[ aJlqwl kT qwl bjqvY[ agnI qwl q®Mg aUpjwvY[ jlq qrMg AMim®q kuMflI[ kuMBr bwjY iml Duin BlI[ dohrw- bwjY srb sMgIq gq qMq AqMq Gn qwl[ bhur AlwpY rwg Kt pMc pMc sMg bwl]33] cOpeI-ip®Qm rwg Byrau vY kreI[ pWchu kwmin muKhu aucreI].... [/gurbani] After this, the entire composition is that which some fan of raags has titled “Ragmala” and entered in Guru Granth Sahib. It should be remembered that the Aadi BiR was put together by Guru Arjan in 1661 Bk. And Ragmala was written in 1640 Bk. For this reason, it is completely baseless for supporters of Ragmala to say that Alam stole this composition from Guru Granth Sahib and put it in his book. Supporters of Ragmala say that a contemporary of Akbar, Jodh, wrote a Sanskrit book, “Madhvaanal Kaamkandla” and no Alam was around at that time. This Alam, they claim, is from the time of Dashmesh jee. He has translated that Sanskrit book into Hindi and stolen Ragmala out of Guru Granth Sahib and then put it in his own book, because Alam, being a poet of Dashmesh ji, knew Sikh literature very well. They claim that the date in the book of 991 Hijri was put there accidentally and is a translation of the date in the original. They say that the real date of the composition is 1774 Bk. To support this claim, they cite the Dohara: [gurbani] byd dIp muin ieMd Dr sivqw juvq gqwn[ hMs vwr iQq AstmI swkw ibk®m jwn[ [/gurbani] This is the total evidence of the supporters of Ragmala. We want to reflect on this evidence here. Firstly, the above Dohara that gives the date as 1774 Bk. is not found in any old hand written copy. Two hand-written copies have been found of this composition. One is at the Nagri Prcharni Sabha, Benaras and the other is at Bikaner’s Fort Library. This Dohara is not in either copy. One copy in Gurmukhi script is found in the Guru Ram Das Library in Amritsar. This Dohara is not in that one either. S. Shamsher Singh Ashok, in the copies he found at Punjab University Lahore also did not find the Dohara there. Where the Ragmala supporters are citing this Dohara from is beyond me. Even if this Dohara is in some book’s end, it is the date that the copy was made, not the date of the composition itself, because the date is given clearly at the start as 1640 Bk. However, the real date of this composition is disputed by the supporters of Ragmala and they it is the creation date of Jodh Kavi’s Sanskrit work, which was accidentally copied by Alam. I want to ask these people, is there even any Jodh Kavi who wrote a Sanskrit work “Madhvaanal Katha” during the time of Akbar? The truth is that in the list of Sanskrit writers at the time of Akbar, there is no mention of any Jodh Kavi. For proof, the books “History of Sanskrit Literature”, Sanskrit Kavita Komdi” and “Sanskrit Kavio(n) Kaa Ithihaas” can be checked. Prof. Maujamdar in a letter to me has aid that “No mention is found of a “Madhavnaal Katha” by any Jodh Kavi in old records, nor have I ever heard of a Jodh Kavi.” Supporters of Ragmala should tell us where we can find this Sanskrit “Madhav Katha” in either published or unpublished form. The truth is before academics: there was no Jodh Kavi and no literature by him. Though, if someone now creates some fabricated saloks, they could become a “truth”. Even if we accept for the sake of argument Shiv Sinh Saroj’s word, which is wrong, that Alam was born in 1712 Bk. this story by him was written in 1774 Bk. This would mean that at the age of 62 during his old age, he liked to write the story of a prostitute. And this would be the same Alam who had spent much time in the Guru’s Darbar. This does not seem possible on a psychological level. Such love stories are generally only written in the time of youth. Secondly, if Alam had written Madhav Katha in Hindi during this time, he certainly would have mentioned Dashmesh ji or Bahadar Shah. But the Kavi only sings the praises of Akbar or Todar Mal. It can be accepted that during the time of Dashmesh ji, there was another Kavi Alam. However it is certain that the Hindi writer of Maadhvaanal Katha was contemporary of Akbar who wrote Ragmala in his book. This composition was then stolen and put at the end of Sree Guru Granth Sahib by someone and labeled “Ragmala”. It is possible that Bhai Banno added this composition just like he had added RatanMala, because in the Bhai Banno BiR, Ragmala is found at the end of all other extraneous compositions that were added. If Guru Arjan had added Ragmala, then it was important that it would have been after Mundavani in the Bhai Banno biR (before all the extra compositions). Because, Bhai Banno only added his extraneous material after copying all the bani Bhai Gurdas had written. In Bhai Banno’s BiR, Ragmala comes at the end of all the Banis. This proves that perhaps Bhai Banno heard this from someone and then added it. This remains an issue for research that who added Ragmala. It is possible that even in Bhai Banno’s biR, someone else added Ragmala. But this is clear tha the biR Bhai Banno copied did not have Ragmala in it. Even now there are 8-10 old hand written BiRs that do not have Ragmala and others that have Ragmala added even after the “Siahee Kee Bidh”. Supporters of Ragmala are unable to answer why these biRs have been left without Ragmala. Up to here was the historical debate on Ragmala. Now I want to look at the internal arrangement of Ragmala to see where it is from. Firstly, the pronouns in Ragmala show that the nouns have appeared somewhere before it in the composition, which becomes clear when Alam’s Madhvaanal Katha is read. But if we consider the Ragmala in Sree Guru granth Sahib to be an independent composition, the pronouns do not make any sense. Bhai Veer Singh, in his knowledge, has said that the Ragmala refers to the “rwg rtn prvwr prIAw sbd gwvx AweIAw” in Guru Amardas Sahib’s Anand Sahib. From a grammatical standpoint, I do not understand why nouns used by Guru Amar Das would be referred to in the pronoun form by Guru Arjan Dev jee. If we accept Bhai Sahib’s view based on him being an elder, that “vai” and “oun” ec. Are pronouns for the “Raag Pareeaa(n)’s” nouns, the question arises that what would the meaning of “p®Qm rwg Byrau vY krhI” be? That the raags first sang Bhairo(n)? Meaning the raags came and sang raags? Only Bhai Sahib knows the answer to this problem. The verbs that follow should also be kept in mind: [gurbani] 1) p®Qm rwg Byrau vY krhI] 2) pMcm hrK idsqK sunwvih] 3) duqIAw mwl kausk Awlwpih] 4) auTih qwn klOl gwien qwr imilavhI] 5) sb imil isrI rwg vY gwvih] 6) iqh pwCY isMDvI b]AlwpI] 7) aUcy suir sUhau puinkInI] Kst rwg auin gwey sMig rwgnI qIs] [/gurbani] From these verbs it is clear that some singer is singing these raags. Who is doing this all? If Guru Arjan Dev has given this only as a list of raags, then who is being referred to as singing loud and mixing melodies? A smart scholar like Pr. Jodh Singh writes “Guru Granth Sahib has been written in raags and so it was necessary to tell which “mat” singing these raags is appropriate in. Dr. Charan Singh has reached the conclusion that the mat in Guru Sangeet is different from other mats and they have created Ragmala to showcase this.” (August 25, Khalsa Advocate). 1) From this Ragmala, can it be discovered which mat (school) it is right to sing raags in? Can someone intelligent tell which notes for raags and timings/venues are discussed? 2) Secondly, if this has been written to show how to correctly sing the raags, why did Guru Sahib start the pothi at Sree Raag? 3) Why is Bhairon left for 24th spot? 4) Why did not all the raags used find their way into Ragmala? 5) Why were those raags not used also listed? 6) It should be remembered that 9 raags used in BaNee are not found in Ragmala. The truth is that Guru Granth Sahib contains spiritual truth not information on raags. This is just a fictional composition. Beyond this, the mistakes in Ragmala also show that the person who added it did so after hearing it and did so very quickly. Bngaal is written as Bangaalm, Kalaekhi is Kachaeli, kalingan is kalanka, sindhri is sandoor, barbal is prabal, maalav is saloo, kukani is gungani, kaukhat is khoukhat and jaalandhar is jablidhar. There are other mistakes as well such as “raag raag sang panch barangan” is written “raag ek sang panch barangan” ; “malkaus raag sang laiee” is “maal rag kousak sang laiee”; “kaval kusam panchan kay nama” is “chanpak kay nama”. These mistakes show that this is not written by Guru jee, but written hurriedly and after being heard only. Ragmala has a line, “Asht putar bhairav kay gaavehn gain patra” Patr here means prostitute ie. Kamkandla and her friends. Pr. Jodh Singh has written after considerable stretching of meanings that patra does not mean prostitute. But using examples from Maadhv Kathavaa(n)” we can show that it has been used for KamKandla ie. “Nirt karehn nvli gtai kaam kandla paatr” (ch. 5, verse 35) At any rate, it becomes clear that Ragmala is being sung by a prostitute and Alam is the writer. Those who say this is a composition of Guru Arjan, why can they not explain why it does not have M: 5 in the heading? Why is Nanak not in it? Why is the language different from Guru Arjan Dev jee’s simple and clear language? Where Alam writes “Asht putar mai kahay savari” why is this writing style not found in Guru Arjan Dev jee’s bani anywhere? Then, the numbering system of Ragmala’s verses also expose it. Instead of 1, 2, 3…the ignorant writer has written “1” 12 times. The person who added it did not put the correct numbers according to the original work, nor are they independently correct. Has Guru jee used such a method anywhere else when numbering verses? The truth is that such a baseless thing that it is weak on all sides. To call such a composition Gurbani is not only a disrespect to Gurbani, it is also a blow to the Sikh faith. Guru jee has clearly said : [gurbani] bwxI gurU gurUu hY bwxI ivic bwxI AMim®q swry] (982) [/gurbani] Banee is that which contains the truth and naam amrit. This GurbaNee has been concluded at Mundavani. After adding this final seal, there is no question of adding anything after it. Bhai Veer Singh, defying all traditional meanings, defines Mundavni to be a “riddle” to make Ragmala baNee. Bhai Veer Singh says that Mudavanee found in Sorath Kee Vaar is replied to in the Mundavanee. The truth is that there is no Mundavanee heading there no the word “Mundavanee”. It is there without a tipee as “Mudavanee”. Guru Sahib himself answers this riddle “Eh MudavaNee Satguru paiee, Gursikha(n) ladhee bhaal”. Then why did Guru Arjan Dev jee need to open It further? If it was an answer to the riddle, it should have appeared in Sorath Kee Vaar. Anyways, the Mundavnee found at the end of Sree Guru Granth Sahib is based on “Mund” or to close. It is the closing seal. Guru Granth Kosh, BaNee Biora, Mahan Kosh and the Faridkoti Teekaa all define it as “seal”. However, in the newer editions of BaNee Biora and Guru Granth Kosh, Mudavanee and Mundavanee have been grouped together and defined as “riddle”. This is not appropriate for a writer but to make Ragmala baaNee, it has not been considered wrong. Here we also give a list of names of those who did not believe Ragmala to be GurbaNee, which shows what learned people believe: Mahakavi Bhai Santokh Singh; Pandit Tara Singh Nirotam; Gyani Dit Singh and Prof. Gurmukh Singh of the Singh Sabha Movement; well known historian Gyani Gyan Singh; Sadhu Gobind Singh Nirmala; Prof. Hazara Singh; J. C. Cunningham - the author of History of Sikhs; well-known historian Macauliff; Bhai Sahib Bhai Kahan Singh Nabha, the author of Mahan Kosh; Master Mota Singh; Master Mehtab Singh, Master Tara Singh, Gyani Sher Singh, Babu Teja Singh, Giani Nahar Singh, Principal Dharmanant Singh, Prof. Teja Singh, Principal Ganga Singh, Dr. Ganda Singh, Prof. Sahib Singh, S. Shamsher Singh Ashok Research Scholar of S.G.P.C., Pandit Kartar Singh Daakhaa, Principal Bawa Harkishan Singh, Principal Narinjan Singh, Prof. Gurbachan Singh Talib; Principal Gurmukhnihal Singh and many others. G. Gian Singh has said that at the Deepmala of 1906BK, a Panthic decision was reached that Ragmala is not Gurbanee. Giani jee writes: [gurbani] SMmq aunI sO Cy mwh[ ibk®m pwvn kqk Awih[ sMq idAwl isMG ky fyry[ pMQ iek~Tw Bxo vDyry[ ies pr Bxo vicwr Apwrw[ dipmwl pr inrnyvwrw[ Bxo inbyr vicwria Xw hY[ rwgmwlw gurbwxI nw hY[[/gurbani] After, this when writing the “Rehit Maryada” draft, the Panthic scholars decided to have the bhog at Mundavanee, but despite this, Bhai Veer Singh wrote at the end of Guru Granth Kosh that Gurmat Sangeet is different from other Sangeet traditions and Guru Arjan Dev jee wrote Ragmala to show this. Thus, Ragmala is Bani. Khalsa Samchar newspaper repeated these baseless statements many times and scholars refuted these each time. But because of Bhai Veer Singh being an elder or some other reason, no scholar wrote against him.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Frank · 21 Jan 2006

"""Do you know who Sant Baba Ishar Singh was? Are you familiar with the letter he wrote to Bhai Randhir Singh? In the letter he tells Bhai Randhir Singh stop saying raag mala's not bani. He also later said that, that is why he had to get punished in jail. For saying Raag Mala is not bani. This issue has split the khalsa panth. Open your eyes and Embrace the Guru Granth Sahib as a living Guru not a book"""" Can you give more details on this letter? Is there a copy anywhere? Is this the Nanaksar or Rara Sahib Sant.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Prabhjoyt singh · 22 Jan 2006

hold up wasnt Giani Gian Singh was an opium addict who stated that Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj also took opium in order to justify his addiction and when he was about to die ( "core ho gaya si"- leaporsy i think it means but i aint sure)he admitted his mistake So you guys believe the words of an opium addcit. And also you guys talk of Kavi Santokh Singh- he was a kavi meaning poet, wouldnt that be kuchi bani in your eyes?

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Jan 2006

Author: Prabhjoyt singh Date: 01-22-06 09:00 <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Kachee Bani..is NOT poetry/kavita/dhadee varaan.... BUT "Bani" that tries to COPYCAT/MIMICK the Real Ilahi GURBANI as a GURU. Practically ALL puratan Literature is in POETRY/Dohras and Chhands etc...Vaartak ( essay style) of writing only came very recently..20th Century. Even Mahabharat/vedas/ramayan etc are all in POETRY. Not a single granth is in vaartak form. Kachee Bani came about when the "anti-sikh forces began to compose such copycat bani to RIVAL the Ilahi gurbani from the House of Nanak...That si why GURU Amardass Ji warns us about Kachee Banee in Anand Sahib. The problem of kachi banee became so widespread that GURU ARJUN JI set about compiling the AAD GRANTH Ji to separate the Ilahi Gurbani from the spurious Kachee Bani of the FRAUDS. Now a days most Kachee bani is written by the so called "DEH DHAREE GURUS" of the radhsasomais, Narakdharees, etc. They need to write such banee to prove they are also as much "guru" as Guru nanak Ji. They have granths like "Avtar banee" blah blah blah...read that and see how tasteless and useless that poetry is. Many Sants and Derawallhas also read "kachee Banee".. a few lines of self composed or copied jingles, that they claim are EASY to understand rather than singing KIRTAN of Ilahi Gurbani which they should as they are doing KIRTAN and KATHA. What could be more simpler and easy to understand than the Punjabi of Guru Arjun Ji....Mitth bolrra ji har sajn mera...bhaag hoa gur sant milaya..Juthay jahe baheh mera satgur so thaan sohava raam rajeh....compared to "uh dharetee nu bhaag lagg gayeh jithey mera satgur beth giya..."" blah blah. Its just a lame duck excuse NOT to learn GURBANI./Sing GURBANI.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Singh · 22 Jan 2006

Prabhjoyt Singh all your posts are ever about is Khalistan, 1984, and anti AKJ. It is worrying. You dont appear to be the brightest bulb in the box. Giani Gian Singh and Kavi Santokh Singh are those traditionally not associated with the SGPC/Tat Khalsa camp. Their disapproval of Raagmala thus blows the "it was only British agents who opposed Raagmala" theory out the window. The "all or nothing" approach you are trying to take is one which cannot be applied to ANY historical literature from the 18th or 19th century. You are a just a young child but you sound like you have so much anger inside you. Do some Simran Veer Ji. Apologies if I have offended you

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Guru Ka Sikh · 23 Jan 2006

Arshi, You don't have any other work than do nindiya of something that not true... If you want to discuss on this matter further, we can meet someway in Kuala Lumpur to have discussion... You have mention last time on this forum one story about your experience in small town Malim Nawar in state Perak Malaysia that degh used to be missing from gurdwara and one snake used to come and eat degh...you are lying Mr. Arshi...my aunty stay just near to the gurdwara and she is amrithari said no such incident happen at that gurdwara regarding this snake eating degh... Can I see you to clarify more on some of other experience that you have mention in this forum............ Guru Ka Sikh

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Prabhjoyt Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Singh Ji what makes you think you know my age? and what makes you think that i have alot of anger in me? Its true that gian singh was an opium addict even Jarnail Singh Arshi has said it on the other thread about Raagmaala. look you guys dont want to read raagmaala thats your decision as you can say Sri Akal Takhat said yo dont have too BUT it was also said at Akal Takhat Sahib that no one can do parchar against Raagmaala. And also if Mundavani is the closing seal according to some, would that not mean that Salok Mahal 5 is also not bani?

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

LionKing (LK) · 23 Jan 2006

Two observations- - Those who completely ignore Raags and show no importance of Raag are trying to be the masters of raag and do a comparative study of Raags in Raagmala and Guru Sahib. - "ਮੁਦਾਵਣੀ" appears on ang 645 twice, and means according to Sant Singh Khalsa "Riddle" http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=645&punjabi=t&id=28049#l28049 ਮੁੰਦਾਵਣੀ is the name of the raag, and without the thingy it means riddle... Just an interesting observation but completely irrelevant =P

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Panthic Ram · 23 Jan 2006

Whether Raag Mala is baani or not does not matter. People who oppose it are a bunch of bafoons. If I want to read it tera ki janda. Second If in my heart I believe it is baani then I will still get an imense faida because I am reading it to please god. That is the main point of life.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Jan 2006

ਮੁੰਦਾਵਣੀ is the name of the raag, and without the thingy it means riddle... Just an interesting observation but completely irrelevant =P <<<<<<<<<<<<<< the Thingy is TIPEE..and yes there are two different words...mudawani on aang 645 is "riddle" and it is NOT a TITLE..but used as a word. MUN_DAWANI with Tipee is a different word..and it means Chhaap/Mohr/SEAL. No where does it say mundawani is a Raag ?? ________________________________________________________ MY Dear "Guru Ka Sikh..." What nindiya has STUNG you ?? MY my..after so many MONTHS..now the Malim nawar incident you brought out..and what FACTS have you brought out ?? your aunty stays "near" the Gurdwara..I STAYED INSIDE the GURDWARA..... Just ask your aunty who was the PRESIDENT of the Gurdwara at that time ? IF your answer is CORRECT ( I have the Facts)..we will proceed further. Another "Guru Ka Sikh" recently "LIVED NEAR" the SELAYANG GURDWARA....and his aunty/aunties... told him no such Jarnail Singh Arshi ever existed in SELAYANG....he then went public on this Forum..blahing and blahing....he claimed he asked the GRANTHI at Selayang Gurdawra..NO ONE seems to know me ?? FYI...when he came to know that the GRANTHI at TAPOBAN SAHIB...20,000 MILES away from SELAYANG came to Visit me and knew me..he then tried to blackmail me by saying, the "sevadaar" who brought Bhai jasboir Singh jI to my house was his friend..and that Bhai ji never ate or drink anything in my house as i dotn follow Sarbloh rehit...but he got a SHOCK when I told him i KNEW this SEVADAAR even better than him...thats the last i heard from him..moot dee chhuggh waang beth giya. FYI he was going to EXPOSE ME, My evil character etc etc in PUBLIC...but wehn he came to know that the Best Criminal/Defamation lawyers in Kuala Lumpur are just waiting for his "public expose"....SILENCE. Anyway First and Foremost the GURU KI SIKHI teaches us NOT to HIDE Behind..aliases..nameless IDS. I am well known..IDENTIFY YOURSELF on thsi Forum...and I am more than willing to discuss my ideas....which are already well known to all everywhere. Show mw even one line or one mail..where I have done "nindiya" of Gurbani/Guru sahibs/Guru granth Ji/ Shaheeds///etc etc.... I hold firmly to my belief that exposing fake sants and derawallahs is NOT NINDIYA. IF you want to beleive in them its your RIGHT..but not my cup of tea. Love Jarnail Singh. PS. Sorry to all other readers for having to waste YOUR VALUABLE time on personal matters yet once more...Some JUST CANNOT discuss ISSUES..but insist in dragging in PERSONAL

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Jan 2006

Mundavini anywaycan not mean seal but it is more to do with Mundna ie closing.Like we have antika or Samapti but that could be of verse and not of book. ......<<<<<<<<<<<<<< BUT Mahan Kosh karta Bhai Kahan Singh Nabaha CATEGORICALLY states that MUNDAWANI is SEAL/MOHER/CHHAAP/CLOSING STATEMENT/STAMP of Closing.....and Declares BHOG of Guru Granth Ji is at Mundawani Mh 5. This is a PUNJABI word and language cannot be so easily "adulterated" or denied as perhaps additions and extra stuff into Granths can be wished away.... Mundawani always meant seal and it still does. No two ways about it. Jarnail Singh Note: the MUNDAN ( seal holder) was usually the chef who tasted the King's food BEFORE the King ate it and PUT his MUNDAR ( SEAL) on the food so as to prevent any additions like poison etc. This is referred to as the Mundawani Shahad also has FOOD simile in it. Please see Mahan Kosh.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Jan 2006

Leaving aside the raagmaala issue for a moment...anyone who cares can do a google search for "The Goindwaal Pothis or Ayu Pur Pothis" read article at: http://www.sikhpoint.com/religion/resources/roleofgoindwalpothis.htm as well as other articles on the net. These "pothis" have been traditionally described as Guru Arjun Ji singing the Mohan Shabads and "begging" them from Mohan eldest REBELLIOUS son of Guru Amardass Ji, so Guru Ji could compile the AAd Granth Ji. These pothis obviously written by the enemies of Sikhism..have a totally different version of the MOOLMANTAR of Guru nanak Ji. The "Kachi bani" that Guru Amardass Ji warns us so strongly in Anand Sahib. This is proof that the enemies of Sikhism....the sons of the Gurus that were not given gurgadhi were at it FULL TIME trying to subvert and sabotage. The FAILED ATTEMPT to SABOTAGE and destroy the MOOL MANTAR is the most dnagerous of these. This entire Fairy tale of the Mohan Pothis of Goindwaal has been proven FALSE and misinterpretation of the Shabad on Mohan (Waheguru) IF these people can produce false pothis and adulterated versions of Mool mantar..whats so difficult to adda few banis in the Bir that is IN THEIR POSESSION from the Day Guru arjun Ji was martyred and His Maal asbaab forfeited to Prithi Chand. Jarnail Singh.

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Singh · 25 Jan 2006

There was no such incident as leaving 100 pages in Kartarpuri Bir to be filled later etc. Today there is no real Kartarpuri Bir to be studied to begin with thanks to the english enslaved Sikhs who sold what is today their 'Eternal Guru' to the British. So Jarnail Singh 'Gyani' Arshi Superstar 108 buddy, is Raagmala Gurbani or not? Can you ask your Guru that and let me know?

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Jan 2006

Author: Singh Date: 01-25-06 20:57 There was no such incident as leaving 100 pages in Kartarpuri Bir to be filled later etc. Today there is no real Kartarpuri Bir to be studied to begin with thanks to the english enslaved Sikhs who sold what is today their 'Eternal Guru' to the British. So Jarnail Singh 'Gyani' Arshi Superstar 108 buddy, is Raagmala Gurbani or not? Can you ask your Guru that and let me know? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<,,,,,, what the heck are you talking buddy ?? i suggest you re-read the original post. The way of writing these ancient granths was in the form of FOLIOS....a pack of papers folded in the middle to double them..and sewn ( like an exercise book stapled in the middle..having an equal number of pages on both sides of the staple...and then many such Folios are held by their edges and sewn together and then bound in hard cover... ( just remove the hard cover spine of a book and see how its done..even today.) Those days paper was very very very expensive and hard to come by....and YET Guru Ji wanted EACH NEW RAAG to begin on a NEW aang...( have a look at any Sri Guru granth Ji Bir and see IF any NEW RAAG is begun on the bottom of a preceeding aang that has some empty space...so there are many empty aangs in the handwritten birs as the angs were NOT standardised as in PRINTING - which is UNIFORM unlike handwriting. sometimes the writer overestimated and sometimes underestimated. And "EMPTY aangs" cannot be REMOVEd by tearing them out as the Correspondign aangs from the other side will FALL OUT ( try tearing out some pages from the back of an exercise book..and note IF the corrsponding front pages fall out or not ) Reading research articles on this clever deception....it has been noticed that someone REMOVED ENTIRE FOLIOS 587/588 and 589 and REPLACED entirely New folios 587/588/589....so that the "HANDWRITING" can begin say around aang 1200...and no body would notice....unlike IF only the 1430 page was added .... the change in handwriting would be too noticeable. Anyway, Guru JI Himself has declared that GURBANI is "GURU"....not any particular bir...THAT is WHY GURU TEG BAHADUR ji returned the Kartarpuri Bir that His Sikhs had gotten by force from dhirmallis....GURU JI DID NOT WANT his SIKHS ATTACH too much "importance" to only "ONE" Particular Bir as "GURU" !!! Guru Har rai Ji and other Guru Sahibs also wrote many other copies of Pothi sahib AAd Granth... SO what do you mean..ask "my" Guru ?? I was under the impression that MY GURU is also YOUR GURU. or is it ?? IF not..MY GURU is GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB and no other. i am no super, no star..and certianly not sri 108..and also not buddy. Thank you. Jarnail Singh

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 Jan 2006

has the "original" writer of this message ( that i picked up from the net) replied anywhere ? I beleive he uses the pseudonyms.."Singh", and sometimes signs off as...adsmangat, andyM, avninder singh. IF he is reading this i wonder if he ahs naything more to add to this discussion.. Jarnail Singh

Re: 100 EMPTY PAGES in KartarPuri Bir ??

Buddha Ram · 28 Jan 2006

I do. What was the point of the disscussion/argument?