Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Overriding Hukamnama

Overriding Hukamnama

ns · 09 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh I would like to know when in histoy the Hukamnam from the SGGS has been over ridden by the sangat including the Panj. I would also liek to hear views as if this is the authentic can sangat including the panj over ride the Hukamnama from SGGS ? For e.g there is talk over a wide specturm of Sikhs and Katah vacheks who claim that in 84 the Hukamnama -- translation was over rideded by the panj and the sangat to make a decision ? What are the sangts views please?

Re: Overriding Hukamnama

ns · 10 Jan 2006

anyone???

Re: Overriding Hukamnama

DAljit S. · 10 Jan 2006

i don't know if this ever happened but i know for saka nankana the saheedi jatha singhs got a hukamnama - same one "koi an milave mera pritam piara" and they got this hukamnama TWICE... but the sgpc or somebody there.. in the akaal takhat said no... don't go to nankana sahib... we have issued panths hukam you can't go and get shaheed there will be too much bloodshed... but the singhs from the nankana sahib shaheedi jatha said no... we got this hukam from guru jee.. in fact TWICE we asked guru jee and we got same hukamnama... so we are going to defend nankana sahib... and what was in the hukam "tan man kat kat sab arpi" this much actually happened with those singhs as they were cut, and cut, piece to piece, and burnt alive for protecting nankana sahib.

Re: Overriding Hukamnama

cyber singh · 10 Jan 2006

elaborate please. what hukamnama was taking in 84?

Re: Overriding Hukamnama

ns · 10 Jan 2006

Daljit S Jeeo You are correct indeed, I recall Giani Jaswant Singh Ji parvana mentioning this a few times, our Guru Ji speaking to us all the time whether we believe it or not. However my question is cab the panj and the sangat over ride the Hukamnama from SGGS? and has it happened in history??

Re: Overriding Hukamnama

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 11 Jan 2006

No. Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee is DHUR KEE BAANI. "Bhullan Andar Sabh Kau, Abhul Guroo Kartaar." --- We are all fallible (imperfect), only the Guru and God are PERFECT We cannot change Gurbani because its revealed Truth sent by God. The Panj Piaare and GURU KHALSA PANTH are the "INTERPRETERS" , "PHYSICAL MANIFESTATION" and PHYSICAL REPRESENTATION of the SHABD GURU (Infinite Wisdom Guru). Guru Granth + Guru Panth.... you cannot have Guru Panth without Guru Granth.. period! Guru Gobind Singh jee being asked to leave Chamkaur Sahib was not overriding ETERNAL TRUTH or tampering with HUKAM of Waheguru (i.e. Gurbani).... its on a temporal/worldly state that they asked Guru Sahib to leave for the betterment of the Panth. Hope that clarifies. Quick Note: the Khalsa is the Guru, not the SANGAT.... Sangat is GURU PIYAAREE but not GURU ROOP.... this is apparent from Gurbani.... GUru Sahib says "Khalsa Mera Satgur Poora... no-where does he say Sangat is Guru.

Re: Overriding Hukamnama

ns · 12 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Manvir Singh Jeeo thanks for trying to clear the air if I were to reprahse and ask can the PANJ Pyare override Guru Granth Sahib Ji's hukamnama? If so when has it been done in Sikh history? further views please

Re: Overriding Hukamnama

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 12 Jan 2006

No Panj Piaare cannot ovveride the PERFECT GURU, the Word of God's Hukam. I think you need to look into the relationship between the Panj Piaare or Guru Panth and Guru Granth. Due your confusion of the relationship and role each has to play, you are asking this question. Bhul chuk maaf. Daas, Manvir Singh

Re: Overriding Hukamnama

LionKing (LK) · 13 Jan 2006

Author: ns Date: 01-10-06 20:58 Daljit S Jeeo You are correct indeed, I recall Giani Jaswant Singh Ji parvana mentioning this a few times, our Guru Ji speaking to us all the time whether we believe it or not. However my question is cab the panj and the sangat over ride the Hukamnama from SGGS? and has it happened in history?? *********** Recommended: Katha of Saka Nanakana by Bhai pinderpal Singh on gurmatveechar.com

Re: Overriding Hukamnama

khalistani · 13 Jan 2006

i dunt see an instance in y a panj pyarai wud want to go agasint guru je bhula chuka maf