Chaur Sahib dee Seva
still crawling... · 15 Nov 2003
Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa!!
Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!
Sadh Sangat Jeeio,
I was reading a previous post about who should/should not be allowed to do keertan..I've been wondering the same (for many years!!) about who should/should not do 'Chaur Sahib dee Seva'.
Should those who cut their hair be allowed to do this seva?..
I have seen many at Gurdwara Sahibs in my area and I don't wish to judge but I feel a bit strange..Perhaps this is their way of learning, but then again it seems disrespectful for me that someone who cuts their extension of love (hair) is doing this seva.
Are their any hukams/rehitnamas/bani that relate to this? Directly & Indirectly...
Please pardon my ignorance...
s.k.
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
just a thought · 18 Nov 2003
GurFateh,
Just a thought but imagine Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji sitting on their throne in front of you in Diwan and someone with cut hair walks in and, with shardha wants to do the Chaur for Guru Ji, do you think anyone would stop that person?
I may be wrong in thinking this but I think everyone should be allowed to take part in things (sewa etc), as that little thing may spark of the reaction for them to start taking their Sikhi seriously. If certain people are literally banned from doing certain things, its more likely to put them off than encourage them.
Example (sorry for going on!), at my local Gurdwara there is a weekly Simran programme and a little boy with cut hair used to come every week. One day out of the blue he came and sat at the waja and did some very simple simran but it was something that touched everyone heart and afterwards all the Aunty Ji's were congratulating him and encouraging him. Slowly he learnt to play new tunes and got better and better and he became one of the highlights of the programme. One day he announced that he would no longer cut his hair and was going to take his Sikhi seriously. This boy now wears a Damalla with pride. Imagine if on the first day this boy had sat at the waja and someone had ran up to him and told him to move away because he had cut hair, I very much doubt that boy would be where he is today.
I understand that we need to have Pyaar and Satkar for Guru Ji, but should not literally ban people from doing things as thats more discouraging than anything else.
Phuk Chuk Maaf.
GurFateh
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Sarbloh Soulja · 28 Nov 2003
GURFATEH
true say, I would just like to know, when no one else is doing chaur sahib over guru sahib,do shaheed singhs do it?, i heard this somewhere, is it true?
GURFATEH
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Jugraj Singh · 28 Nov 2003
>>>>>Just a thought but imagine Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Ji sitting on their throne in front of you in Diwan and someone with cut hair walks in and, with shardha wants to do the Chaur for Guru Ji, do you think anyone would stop that person?>>>>>>
I agree that a lot of people who cut their have a lot of sharda towards Guru Sahib. Infact there is a hindu person i know who does Sukhmani sahib da paat everyday because his dad told him that doing so will benefit him in business etc.
Having said that we should keep in mind that Guru Sahib has strictly forbidden people from doing 4 kurahits. Please keep in mind that Guru Sahib's hukams are for everyone.
cutting hair,
eating meat,
intoxicants,
adultery
The reason is not so that people who do the kurahits are discouraged from Sikhi, but we are showing respect to guru sahib and as a consequence certain people can't do certain sewa's. There are many sewa's at the gurdwara that they can still do.
For example when you go to university, you are given certain priviliges that others do not have. No matter how much one believes in higher education if they are not enrolled in the uni they are not allowed the same priviliges.
There are many other reasons. I don't think it sends the right message when someone who does the kurahits is allowed to do keertan or certain other sewa's. We are sending mixed signals to the sangat. On one hand we have established that Sikhs refrain from the 4 bujjar kurahits on the other hand we are saying that even if they don't it's okay because they have sharda.
Then why refrain from the 4 bujjar kurahits???
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
just a thought · 29 Nov 2003
GurFateh!
Jugraj Singh, I totally hear what you are saying and like the university analogy :-)
Just another thought, isn't doing Kirtan like doing Paath? If someone is not allowed to do kirtan, should they be doing Paath (in public or in private)?
Phuk Chuk Maaf.
GurFateh
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Jugraj Singh · 30 Nov 2003
Singh said the following:
>>>>>>>>>We seem to drown ourselves in a sea of ritualism. We now preform acts so obviously ritualistic with SIKHI pride
WE NEED TO REVALUTE
turn to bani
bani bani bani>>>>>>>>
could you please elaborate on the rituals that you are referring to.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>IT IS THE MEANING WHICH IS TIMELESS, that is what should be respected.>>>>>>>>>>
So "the book" can be kept in your closet. Having ramalas and doing chaur sahib is meaning less. ?????
ARe these the rituals you are referring to... ARe you aware that there are Singhs alive who can actually see the light of Guru Nanak in the guru granth SAhib ji.
Is this how you want to practice Sikhi. If i claim to understand the meaning of paath then will you think of me as your guru.
Please consider the implications of your claims. And also provide a basis for them. I don't know if you recall but when Guru Gobind Singh ji passed down the gurgaddi to the guru granth sahib ji he did it with the utmost respect. You should read the sakhis etc. to get the details.
Just because all you see is a book doesn't mean there aren't Sikhs out there who see the jot of Guru Sahib.
Also, according to your logic... what need is there to matha tek to a book. I mean the meanings of Gurbani are not a tangible thing you can matha tek to. So you will stop matha teking.
How far will you go?
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
gabroo khalistan dah · 30 Nov 2003
Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji should not be labled it, or adressed with the.
that is utter non-sense. Guru sahib is our Guru, is a jagthi joyt.
Guru Sahib should be treated as a living king, because Guru sahib is the shahensha of the universe.
How would u treat Guru GObind singh ji maharaj?
the same we should do with Guru Granth Sahib ji
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Jugraj Singh · 30 Nov 2003
Singh said.
>>>>>>>Respect the meaning of the SGGS. Do things out of practicality>>>>>>>>>>>
Practicality.... indeed. How is is practical to have faith in an invisible God. I can't see him. How is it practical to live your life by the words of guru's who lived hundreds of years ago? How is it practical to dedicate one's life to selfless seva? How is it parctical to want to be the son of a guru who lived hundreds of years ago?
How is it practical to initiate someone into the brotherhood of the Khalsa by giving them sugary water.
How is it practical for the 40 Singh's of Chamkaur to fight enemies hundreds of times greater in number?
And Bhai Taru singh must have been an idiot giving up his life for the sake of his hair. If he lived i'm sure the hair would have grown back. What was he thinking???? Obviously wasn't thinking practically.
OH in case I forget. It was definitely more practical for the chali mukte to not come back wasn't it???? They were another impractical bunch.
And please explain to me how it is practical to believe that Gurbani can wash away one's sins. Or that naam can merge one with God that can't even been seen.
"JAO TAO PREM KHELAN KA CHAO
SIR DHAR TALI GALI MERI AAO"
Guru SAhib wants your head for this very reason... so you aren't led astray by your own mind. A mind with many lifetimes of mael. A mind indulged in kaam krodh lobh moh akankar.
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
gabroo khalistan dah · 30 Nov 2003
aa said it
guru sahib is ur master slave over him day n' night
dont' call it ritualisim
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Jugraj Singh · 01 Dec 2003
When guru sahib is concerned we should not look use our own mat. We should do everything to honor guru sahib and do everything to live up to his expectations of us.
We are given this life for only one purpose. This is our chance to meet Waheguru. We want to show utmost respect to our Satguru so that we get kirpa.
Any discussions of this sort should not be tolerated.
Puratan Singhs didn't look at practicality or anything else. they did what they had to do for their Guru regardless of the consequences.
They followed to hukams of the guru to the best of their abilities. I recall seeing a picture from the 2nd world war. A sikh regiment was marching and at the lead of the regiment a singh was carrying guru sahib da saroop.
How practical was it to do this during war time????
Baba Jarnail Singh at one time was sleeping and some gutkas fell from the storage space and at his feet. He had trouble sleeping and eating for days after the event.
We should learn from such singhs and not entertain discussions with people of questionable integrity.
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Mandeep Singh Khalsa · 01 Dec 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa||
Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh||
I am writing on this website for the first time and first of all would like to thank the singh's who have such a seva for putting a site like this for the betterment of sikhs worldwide.
Now,
Putting a toothbrush and cup next to the SGGS is a ritualistic behaviour (in my opinion though i may be wrong) HOWEVER doing seva and having the humility of doing the actions selflessly must also be taken into account.
Using milk at Sri Harmandir Sahib + other gurudawara's is NOT a sign of ritualism, Milk traditionally is seen as pure and good and that is why my guess is that milk is used. Also bhaji u make the point that India is a poor country and using milk that is valuable in a starving nation is wrong and the behaviour is ritualistic. One must see that:
1) India does have the resources to feed it's whole nation and we mustn't blame the sikhs for this (tho afterall sikhs in punjab are 'feeding' India, it is the Indian Governments internal problems which have led to this situation.
2) The said actions are Seva and not done out of pure tradition and ritual behaviour, and in life we must do seva selflessly no matter what is the cost of such seva, so if we are for argument sake using 4-5 gallons of milk (dont know exact) what price is this to 'pay' to get to Maharaj?
Sorry i have gone on a bit. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karni
Daas
Mandeep Singh Khalsa, UK
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Jugraj Singh · 02 Dec 2003
Firstly allow me to explain the reason i used the examples that I used above. I do not believe that those things would have been doable had the singhs not had the love and respect and sharda for guru sahib. IT was guru sahib's kirpa that they were able to do what they did.
This kirpa came from bhagti and bhagti was made possible by first the fear of Guru Sahib and then slowly the love.
The way I look at it one can not have any substantial spiritual progress until we learn to have the utmost respect for guru sahib. Treating maharaj da saroop as merely a book shows very little sharda.
>>>>>>Firstly in your argument you have totally missed my point......which is to focus on the meaning of the SGGS........to me treating it in such a ritualistic manner is not only not needed but disrespectful......>>>>>>
I did not miss your point. It is just that your point will eventually end up placing guru maharaj da saroop on a bookshelf somewhere.
I reiterate what I said before
>>>>>>>
They followed to hukams of the guru to the best of their abilities. I recall seeing a picture from the 2nd world war. A sikh regiment was marching and at the lead of the regiment a singh was carrying guru sahib da saroop.
How practical was it to do this during war time????
Baba Jarnail Singh at one time was sleeping and some gutkas fell from the storage space and at his feet. He had trouble sleeping and eating for days after the event.
>>>>>>
I personally have never seen the tooth brush thing and it is ritualistic. (Besides shouldn't it be datan : ) ) Mandeep Singh has dealth with the issue of milk.
I am an engineering student in my fourth year. The profs are continuously impressing on us the fact that "design in theory is very different from real life". This is because the application of knowledge comes from practice and experience and not from discussions in class.
Sikhi is a prime example of this. Unless one wants Sharda and love and Sikhi jeeven, simply discussing it doesn't get us very far. One has to try and practice it.
A lot of things we have to experience for ourselves so that our faith slowly builds up. It is easy to claim that I belive in one God and loves God but the truth of the matter is that if we really loved God we would be Brahmgiani's.
Any and all Chardi Kala Singhs have always showed the utmost satkar for Guru Maharaj da saroop. If we want to get where they were we must also.
>>>>To me respecting the SGGS is to learn and understand its message.......read, understand, discuss.......don’t just sit there "basking in its glory">>>>>>>>>
what do you mean by "basking in its glory"???
Secondly, I agree with you and that's why people take Santhiya classes etc. Having curiosity and willingness to learn is crucial. Also discussing bani is a good thing.
But the basking in its glory...i really don't understand what you are trying to say...
"Satgur darshan aghan nivari Satgur bhetat haumai mari Satgur sang nahein mann dole amrit bani gurmukh bole"
Also let me ask this quesiton. When we do ardaas we mention that "dasaan patshaian dee jot"
If one believes that Guru Gobind Singh ji had guru joti and passed it down the Gur gaddi down to the Guru Granth SAhib then we must acknowledge that Guru Granth Sahib da Lareevar saroop has Gur Joti.
When in presence of Guru Granth Sahib we are in presence of that Joti. We must show the utomost respect to the physical form containing that joti.
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Jugraj Singh · 03 Dec 2003
I forgot to mention this in my previous post.
>>>>>context which you have placed ideas of practicality are in themselves not relevant.
>>>>>
I hope my post above clarifies how they are relevant.
Very rare people can jump straight into the depths of gurmat and live life on the level where they only see the jot of guru sahib.
The rest of us must start with the physical saroop.
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Brampton Singh · 11 Dec 2003
why not
whats the difference
your angry about "the"
how about this
STOP saying Guru Granth Sahib Ji maharaj
instead one should use
Akali Baba Sant Khalsa Guru Granth Sahib Ji maharaj
and dont put it on the same line as other words......cuz it must be respected
dont get caught up on foolishness...honestly...being concerned bout using the....or refering to the SGGS in short form
Respect the SGGS by studying and understanding its message.......treat it consistently with is message
non ritualism
love of god
Fateh
Re: Chaur Sahib dee Seva
Sarbloh Soulja · 13 Dec 2003
WJKKWJKFATEH
what kindof discussion is this?, surely 'singh' must know that Guru Granth Sahib is the living emodiment of the 10 gurus!!! Its stuff like this that split us up. Its all about respect man