Budhha dal myth exposed!
The Observer · 28 Dec 2005
For years, some people have been brainwashing sikhs about nihangs and prataan maryadas. Claims that akhali nihangs know all, eventhough their maryadas have been ripped to shreds upon detailed anaylsis.
When this happened stories were made up against Singh Sabha, AKJ, and others claiming them to be products of British, when in fact Bhai sahib went to jail fighting the British occupation.
So what about Niddar and his budhha dal lineage going back to Baba budhha ji? Amritpal singh Amrit rips its apart on his site. So when did the current buddha dal start. Below is one explanation.
The Present Budhha Dal
(Amrit Pal Singh 'Amrit')
During the times of the British Raj (rule) in India, a group of a few Sikhs from Punjab had been residing in Gurdwara Mata Sahib Kaur Ji in the city of Nanded, where the holy Takht Sachkhand Sri Hazoor Sahib Ji is situated. Jathedar Prahlada Singh was their leader, who originally belonged to the Krorhiya Misl. When he passed away, Jathedar Giana Singh was selected as his successor.
These Punjabi Sikhs did not enjoy good relations with the local Sikhs. A few clashes had taken place between them, and the local Government, as would be expected, sided with the local Sikhs. Over time, this made it difficult for this group of Punjabi Sikhs to remain in Nanded.
The Punjabi Sikhs resolved to return to Punjab and approached the Nizaam (King) of Haidrabad state to seek permission to enter Punjab, who in turn approached the British Government, which refused them entry.
The Punjab Government had reservations over these Sikhs, as they suspected them to have anti-British sentiments which may lead them to raising a rebellion against the British Raj. In reality, these Sikhs had no such intentions, they realised that their weapons and armaments had caused the Governmental bodies to view them with suspicion. As a result, they offered their weaponry to the holy Takht Sachkhand Sri Hazoor Sahib Ji, taking only a Nishaan Sahib (flag or standard), a Nagaara (kettledrum) and the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji they returned to Punjab along with a handful of Sikhs under the leadership of Jathedar Giana Singh.
Upon their entry into Punjab, no one was there to welcome these Sikhs. They wandered like Nomads. During this time they met with Bhai Kooma Singh of Satlaanee, who gave them a cart, two bulls and a 'Manja' (cot). Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was installed on this 'Manja' and the Sikhs would travel by this cart.
One could deem this to be the re-establishment of the Budhha Dal.
After the death of Jathedar Giana Singh, Jathedar Teja Singh became the next chief of Budhha Dal. When Jathedar Teja Singh died, Jathedar Sahib Singh became the next chief.
Jathedar Sahib Singh had served in the Patiala Royal army. He was an educated person. He joined the Budhha Dal and worked as a head Granthi. When he became the chief of Budhha Dal, he made efforts to purchase properties for the Budhha Dal. He met with many Sikh officers and inspired them to help the Budhha Dal. Thus, he succeeded to purchase properties, horses and other articles for the Budhha Dal's members. He was popularly known as 'Kalaa-dhaaree'. The Budhha Dal developed to a large organisation under his leadership. He passed away in 1942 in Sri Amritsar Sahib Ji and was succeeded by Baba Chet Singh Ji. He passed away in 1968.
Jathedar Santa Singh was declared the next chief of Budhha Dal. He hailed from Gujranwalan district, now in Pakistan.
Re: Budhha dal myth exposed!
Harcharan Singh · 03 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh
Just a few points:
1 - Who was in holding the seat at Akaal Takht before the creation of SGPC who now appoint and pay salary to the present Jathedaar?
2 - If members of the Krorhiya Misl and other Misls have were around up until the authers claim of the "inception" of the Buidda Daal, then how could the Budda Daal be new?
The various Misls were split between the Budda and Tarna Daal, so as long as they were around, so were the Daals?
Were the the Shaheed Baba Deep Singh and Shaheed Baba Gurbakhs Singh amongst many others were part of the Shaheedi Daal, thereby be part of the Budda Daal, may be this is why Taksaal and Budda Daal still have some common grounds today (agreement on Santhia etc, and the fact that Baba Gurbachan Singh highly respected by Budda Daal...)
The above research is very short, very weak and does not cite any references.
Also the above note says they took only the Sri Guru Granth Sahib from Hazoor Sahib, seems strange as Nihangs always recite from the Dasmi and Sarbloh granth also?
As for Akali Nihangs I think that people should stop associating "a person" or people with history and writting off history to promote their jathaa etc.
Akali Nihangs were bounty hunted by the British, because apart from Namdharis, they were the only other Sikhs (sect, whatever makes you happy), that carried on fighting the British after the 2nd Anglo Sikh war. They were virtually wiped out.
And it is a fact that since SGPC took over they have not preserved many Sikh traditions i.e. the keeping of the Damasmi Granth at Darbaar Sahib, preserving our Guru's saaj and Raag kirtan etc.
There needs to be some "real" research done into this topic.
We need to stop slandering people or history of one body just becasue we don't like one person, it is a very childish attitude.
Although I don't personally agree with all Niddar Singhs says, he does have some valuable information, which is cross referenced, is proven to be correct, I would advise that we ned to learn as much as we can, because our history has been changed and manipulated and we as a collective need to have sensible and adult discussions and research undertaken to save and revive the truth.
Sat Sri Akaal
Harcharan Singh
Re: Budhha dal myth exposed!
Harcharan Singh · 04 Jan 2006
To correct previous posters:
Nawab Kapur Singh Ji was the leader of Budda Daal (who was was later replaced with Sardaar Jassa Singh Aluvalia as the head of Budda Daal), and Nawab Kapur Singh appointed the Bhangi Misl as leaders of the Tarna Daal.
Before this there was no Daal system.
Going back to the original point, about re-establishing the Budda Daal, how could it need re-establishing when it had not disappeared in the 1st place.
Akalis were heading the Akal Takht upto the point the SGPC, Singh Sabha etc got the keys from the British (and it was Jassa Singh Ramgharias great grand son?!?) who actually recieved the keys to Darbaar Sahib (just mentioning this to show misls hadn't disappeared).
So if various misls were still existing (be it in a small form) and more importantly, if Akalis were heading Akaal Takht and Darbaar Sahib, how was the Budda Daal re-established?
I would like to know the names and history of who headed Akaal Takht before SGPC, if anyone could be so kind as to enlighten me.
Satnaam
Harcharan Singh
Re: Budhha dal myth exposed!
Harcharan Singh · 06 Jan 2006
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh
References:
Tharam Singh, Sikh Struggle After Banda, Sikhism: Its Philosophy and History, Institute of Sikh Studies
A History of the Sikhs, Volume 1 By Khushwant Singh
Khalsa Generals?!
To be honest the history is not clear cut, there are many slightly differing accounts, I have also read references stating both Daals were dissolved.
We can but search and learn!
Sat Sri Akaal
Re: Budhha dal myth exposed!
Harcharan Singh · 06 Jan 2006
Dear SinghSingh,
Thanks for the comments (I think).
Although, I take offence to being called a "spin doctor", this implies I twist the truth.
I do make mistakes, but I never knowingly twist the truth.
Obviously, anything I state will always be my personal interpretation or findings, so doesn't mean to say I am right all the time, but I try my best with Guru's guidance.
I am opened minded, and not affiliated to any jathaa/group (only my Guru's Khalsa - not todays many versions and claims on Khalsa), I intend to follow my Guru's hukum, remain independant and only bear allegiance to Guru Gobind Singh Ji, this is what our Dastaar represents, to be a non-conformist to any wordly powers, we are our own leaders and should report to Akaal Purkh only.
Unfortunately Sikhi is not what it used to be as you may have noticed, many things have been lost, histories changed and divisions made, we need to stay independant and open minded with our allegiance and trust in Guru Ji only in order to recognise the truth.
I have taken a vow to uphold the truth, I intend to do as such until my last breath.
Waheguru j ika Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.
Re: Budhha dal myth exposed!
BirRaas Singh · 06 Jan 2006
UK Nihang, how do you explain the takeover of budhadal.com by Nihang Niddar Singh if he isnt recognised by them?
Re: Budhha dal myth exposed!
Harcharan Singh · 07 Jan 2006
I don't think Nihang Niddar Singh is taking over the website, he is creating it.