Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

modern technology and sikhi

modern technology and sikhi

modern technology · 14 Nov 2003

what place does modern technology have in sikhi? I was thinking today if a singh and singhnee are married and have problems conceiving a child, is it wrong for them to use modern technology methods to have a child. example, test-tube babies, or artifical insemination...when a womans egg and a mans spern is taken and technology is used to have a child I was wondreing if this process is allowed in sikhi

Re: modern technology and sikhi

s!nghn! · 14 Nov 2003

I was thinking about this before as well. I don't think artificial insemination would be in-line with Gurmat because how would you obtain the sperm sample?

Re: modern technology and sikhi

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 14 Nov 2003

man its ok.. medicine ppl medecine.... sperm sampls woiudl be obtained the conventional way

Re: modern technology and sikhi

univ. student · 14 Nov 2003

in my opinion, there is nothing wrong with it.... they are all medicinal procedures to bring life.... they use the egg and sperm of the parents of course, just help with the fertilization....

Re: modern technology and sikhi

Singh · 14 Nov 2003

I have heard so many stories about Gursikhs who couldn't have kids and went and asked guru sahib for kirpa and guru sahib did bakshish and they had children. why do we need to rely on others for help when guru sahib is sada dayal. Not being able to have kids etc. is a consequence of our karams and the way to deal with the situation is doing guru sahib's sewa.

Re: modern technology and sikhi

my thoughts... · 14 Nov 2003

I couldn't have said it better Singh...how dare we take on the responsibility of Vaheguru?..we get this life form based on our past lifes actions, and in this life we have to face the cosequences of our past actions....however, the severity of the consequence can only be reduced through sewa of Guru Sahib, through keeping rehit, naam and bani....we need to have more faith in our Guru Sahib rather than seeking easy solutions to our problems...there are Gursikhs out there that don't even believe in the healing power of medicine...they believe, with guru sahib's kirpa, as we should as well..that naam and bani is the medicine for all sicknesses and problems...may Guru Sahib ji bless us all with this kind of faith.

Re: modern technology and sikhi

thought · 14 Nov 2003

although I'm not certain about reproductive technology, I'm quite sure that medicine is not against Gurmat. For certain, bani and nam are the greatest powers of healing and the greatest medicine, but I really doubt that Guru Sahib rejected medicine. Guru Har Rai Sahib had one of the most famous dispensaries for medicine, one that the even the Mughal prince (Dara Shikoh) came to and was cured by. This was such an amazing dispensary that it was known all across India and the emperor had to go there to get a medicine not available anywhere else. Nirmalas have always kept knowledge about medicine and a number of chardi kala gursikhs in the Jatha like Dr. Basant Singh, Dr. Surinder Singh and even Bhai Kartar Singh Canadian gave out medicines. I think that it's perhaps a bit overboard if we decide to reject medicine outright. It might be easy to preach in theory, but in practice, it's much harder live by such a standard. I think that physical medicine working together with spiritual medicine is something Guru Sahib would advocate.

Re: modern technology and sikhi

just my opinion · 15 Nov 2003

I've always thought and still think that "my own child" is such a twisted concept in all societies.. your child is yours based on love, not based on sperm or egg or DNA. You might have had 10 kids and then you became a drunk gambler and left your wife and never came back to your family. Are they still your kids? Will they still consider you their father? I think a real parent is the one who natures and loves their child and brings their child on the true path. Of course our true parent is Guru Gobind Singh and Mata Sahib Kaur. Are we all their blood children? No - but why does each and every blood cell of ours remember Guru Gobind Singh then? Why is our every skin cell a sacrifice to Guru Gobind Singh? Because our bond with our real father is stronger than blood. Keeping all that in mind, I think rather than lower your head to technology for conceiving a child, adopt a child. Bring a less fortunate child into your life and help him grow in Sikhi. there are thousands, no.. millions.. no... probably TENS OF MILLIONS of children who need to be adopted.

Re: modern technology and sikhi

sikhni · 15 Nov 2003

are we playing god by taking chemotherapy to increase our lifespan or hiv drugs?

Re: modern technology and sikhi

RS · 15 Nov 2003

This is an interesting topic, with a lot of complicated issues. Now before I say anything, let me clarify that I'm not taking a stance for or against these procedures (at least in this post). My basic question is, if a singh and singhnee aren't meant to have a child, then is it possible for them to do so through reproductive technologies? Is it possible for them to 'cheat' their karms using technology and have a child? If a child is concieved through such means, who is the one putting life into the child, god or the scientists? Or is it all part of god's game? Now the issue of gursikhs accepting bhanaa and rejecting these techniques due to reasons associated with bhanaa and depending on naam and banee is different. Maybe that's what some veers are trying to get at, about accepting bhaanaa. But that's a whole discussion in itself. Basically, what I'm trying to get at is that all these types of technologies aren't in any way, shape or form a challenge to Vaahiguru. They may be a challenge to our feeble minds and our belief in the power of god. But in the end, only vaahiguru has the power of life and death. Thinking that some doctor who clones some lifeform has 'created' life or challenged god is delusional. It's all part of Vaahiguru's game. Whether these technologies are according to Gurmat and should be used by Gursikhs is a different matter and something that I personally haven't given much thought to thus far. It would also depend on the exact technique under consideration. But in the end, the force behind everything is still vaahiguru. We can't cheat his hukam and 'create' a child on our own. Everything is in his hukam. This isn't to say that everything is okay then. He gives us choices. Some will be according to gurmat and pleasing to Vaahiguru, others will hinder us. (Sometimes it seems as if our past karms make us lean towards one option more than the other, as if we really don't have a choice - it's already determined. Maybe that's where the power of naam and banee come in - to erase these bad karms.) These technologies may not be according to Gurmat. Or maybe they don't go against gurmat either? I don't know. Anyway, I've gone completely off track now. If I've said anything against Gurmat, which I quite easily might have, fer maaf karnaa.

Re: modern technology and sikhi

just my opinion · 16 Nov 2003

waheguru ji, the same way that you have said (RS) that it could be because of karams.. well .. on this forum we learned that Guru Gobind Singh Ji adopted 4 sons in addition to the 4 Sahibzadae. Now could we have the nerve to say the 4 adopted sons were not in Guru jee's karam and Guru jee was going against Waheguroo's bhaanaa? Not at all. Waheguroo jee has created this wonderful play - and children should have a mother and father. The orphan children of today were not test tube babies. They have a biological father and mother. They are legitimate children. I wouldn't have the nerve to call a test-tube baby illegitimate because when he/she grows up how would he/she feel about that title... but still the orphan children of today they did have blood parents - they were produced by a male and female. So we are not going against bhaanaa by adopting them. Behind the scenes sanjog vijog is in Guru jee's hands. But in front - on this jagat tamasha - this world play - we must take actions according to GUrmat. Adopting a child is not against gurmat.

Re: modern technology and sikhi

RS · 16 Nov 2003

Yes, I agree, adopting orphaned children is a great seva. How could it possibly be against gurmat?

Re: modern technology and sikhi

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 16 Nov 2003

yah, adopting is the best way 2 go