Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Keertan/Katha & Money

Keertan/Katha & Money

question · 14 Nov 2003

I was wondering what everyone's thoughts are on how when a ragi's doing keertan, people give money or same with Katha. Sometimes they get a donation to do an ardaas as well. Is this alright? I'm pretty sure having prices for akhand paaths like most gurdwaras do is wrong too, but does anyone think it's ok to have like a price of so-many dollars for an akhand paath and another price for keertan and another for sehaj paath? If it's wrong then why is it so common?

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 14 Nov 2003

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Kee Fateh There should be no price in doing kirtan, katha, ardaas, or even akhand paths. Doing kirtan shouldn't have a price on it; we do kirtan for our guru ji and not to make money. Same goes for katha, ardaas, and akhand paths. If someone is doing kirtan and the sangat comes and puts money in front of them, that money should be put in the golak right away after kirtan. No one should get paid to do kirtan for sangat, a kirtanee does kirtan for themselves, guruji, and for sangat to listen to and inspire them to come into sikhi. If someone wants to give money, put the money in the golak. The golak is there for the sangats money. And the money in the golak should not be given to anyone for there services, it should be put towards the gurdwara or other charities out there. Paying people has just become a tradition that just started not to long ago, and this should be stopped. Singh’s in Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji time never took money to do kirtan, it was all pyar for guru ji. Same goes for Sant Jarnail Singh Ji, he never took money for his katha. if someone came into sikhi, this was enough of an award for both these chardi kala Singh’s. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Kee Fateh Dalrajkaur Khalsa

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

S Singh · 14 Nov 2003

no keertani or sevak comes onto the stage of the gurdwara to ask for money, the sangat gives them money because they want to, it depends from sevak to sevak, some donate the maiya to the gurdwara sahib, some take the maiya a late family member of mine used to do katha, and they used to take the maiya received from the sangat and use it to fund a school for underpriveleged children in india. you can sit there and think "oh hes taking the money to run their house, how can u make money like that" but do you know the full story, how do you know where the money is going to be used? when we mutha tek infront of sri guru granth sahib maharaj, leave ur bad thoughts and nitpicking in their charna, so we may be able to see good in all rather then viewing others with a narrow mind sorry if i have said anything which offended u vaheguru ji ka khalsa - vaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

my take · 14 Nov 2003

I think that the custom of going up to a stage and putting money in front of a Ragi or Kathavachak is wrong. There's no real price for bani and if someone is singing it or explaining it, then there's no real amount of money we can give for it. But this practice has corrupted a lot of our parcharaks. Sometimes now our ragis and parchaaraks set a fixed price that they want X amount of money before they'll come and do a program. Many 'big name' ragis have a fixed hourly rate. I also read a story of famous ragi Bhai Hira Singh who went to meet Sant Attar Singh once. He said to Sant jee, "baba jee, save me, I've wasted my whole life." Sant jee asked how this was possible since all his life he was a kirtani and did kirtan. He replied "Baba jee, I may have done kirtan, but the entire time, my eye was on the sangat looking for someone to make a move so they would come and give me money on the stage. " Sant jee ws very happy at his honesty and helped ragi Hira Singh out. I think parcharaks should do seva but not have any greed. Nor fixed rates. Whatever the sangat wants to give is fine, but sangat too should recognise that these are sevadaars who need financial help and be generous. But money should be given before or after the program, not during. I think it's legitmate to give money to full time parcharaks so they can survive, but there has to be a better way, not going up and placing money in front like that. Setting rates is wrong, be it for kirtan or akhand paaths or katha. How is it any different than the Brahmins bani condemns for selling their services?

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 14 Nov 2003

My intentions were not to diss up anyone that does take money while doing kirtan, katha, etc. I have been told by someone that goes to gurdwara all the time and know the 411 on what goes on. This person told me that most of the raagi’s only do kirtan so they can get paid. The money that they get paid with is from the golak. No person is suppose to be getting that money, it should be put towards charities or towards the gurdwara itself. That’s good that your family members used the money for a school for underprivileged children. How many people do you know that take the money they got from doing kirtan, etc and use it for good causes? Some people might, but majority is that most don’t. The majority is that people do take money for doing kirtan, etc, and this shouldn’t be happening. I can also ask you the same question how do you know where that money is going? It can be used for a good cause I’m not saying that, but it can also be used for dumb stuff. My main point was that no one should get paid to do kirtan, kirtan should not have a price on it.... Bhul Chuk Maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Kee Fateh Dalrajkaur Khalsa

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

S Singh · 14 Nov 2003

i agree with ur points dalrajkaur, i didnt mean to say that we should be payin for bani or katha, guru ki bani is amol, and to try to put a price on it would be rediculous i would happily give money to a kirtani or to a kathavachak, not because im payin for their service, if i donated or didnt, it wouldnt make any difference, to a real kathavachak they would rather see people adopting what they have told the sangat with the kirpa of sri guru granth sahib ji maharaj to their lives, rather then see a pile of money infront of them i think people are very quick to bash a granthi, kirtani, or anyone else who does seva, bottom line is, we give donations to kirtanis etc cos we feel that we have been touched by what we have heard, and in return watever money we can offer we should wat happens to this money after it has left our hands shouldnt really be bothering us, if that money is used for further seva then thats great, if that person misleads the sangat and uses the money for wrong things or just does kirtan for money then they will get their punishment when time comes the whole idea behind seva is to do it cos u want to and for free, if any money is made out of it then in return do the seva of others :D well, thats my view on it vjkk vjkf

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

i just wanna say · 15 Nov 2003

Ur opions are ur opinions Dalraj kaur tHEREs no price on bani, i agree with u but yo, people give money cuz they wanna give it, and keertanis and katha wachaks and gianis are allowed to take the MONEY if the need it and if they dont need it, then obviously they can mathetek it

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

UnjaaN · 15 Nov 2003

WJKK WJKF Taking money for doing keertan is selling Gurbani (only if you don't use it in the right way). Ex: Its like selling your mother for like 50 bucks and making a living out of it. If you are going to do bhala of others who really need the money (poor,homeless,etc.), then its like 'greeb da moohN, guru dee golak' WJKK WJKF

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

my two sense · 15 Nov 2003

I just wanted to say that Dalraj kaur has made a good point. no one should get money for doing kirtan, kirtan isn't something that you can make a living off of, What ever Dalraj kaur has said is true.

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

lol · 15 Nov 2003

yea i agree with dalraj kaur

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

froe · 15 Nov 2003

We all agree it is wrong to set a rate on gurbani, but where I disagree is that it is not wrong to accept donations.

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

Bikramjitsingh · 16 Nov 2003

WJKK WJKF Just my penny's worth 1. Yes, It is wrong for Kirtaniyas and Kathavachaks to have a set rate for doing Kirtan and Katha. If a Kirtaniya is more interested in the amount of money he receives then the Gurdwara should not use him. This problem arises because we have made many Kirtaniyas and Kathavachaks into celebrities. The Gurdwara committtees latch on to this fact and they realise that if the get the most well known Kirtaniya or Kathavachak then more Sangat will come to the Gurdwara and the Charawa will increase. The Kirtaniyas know this and they through their greed want a bigger cut in order to do Kirtan at the Gurdwara. This is how the commercialisation of Kirtan has taken place. 2. Kirtaniyas and Kathavachaks also have families to feed. For a part-time Kirtaniya who works during the week in another job and only does Kirtan at weekends then the theory that they should do Kirtan for free would hold good. Even so the money given to Kirtaniyas is given voluntarily. No donation bowl is sent around the Sangat for them to make their donations. The ones who want to give money do so voluntarily. It is not for us to decide how the Kirtaniyas uses that money. The vast majority of Kirtaniyas are full time and many have families to support. So the money given to them goes to support their families. 3. This is very wrong but the present set up of Sikh institutions is such that doing Kirtan is considered an occupation and therefore as with all occupations there is a monetary consideration for doing it. If you look at other religions such as Christianity their Vicars get free accommodation, a salary as well as other benefits. We have no such system. So it depends on the Gurdwara in question as to how they choose to deal with the Kirtaniyas. Some will give them all the voluntary donations given by the Sangat to the Kirtaniyas, other will also give a percentage of the Charawa and others will give them a set rate. 4. Probably the only way to counter this commercialisation is for each Gurdwara to have a Kirtan Jatha which does Kirtan solely at that Gurdwara and they like the Granthis get a salary enough for them to live on. In such a situation it is possible for the Gurdwara to make all money given to the Kirtan Jatha to be put in the golak. GurFateh Bikramjit Singh

Re: Keertan/Katha & Money

khalsa · 17 Nov 2003

well said by Dalrajkaur and Bikramjit Singh. they both have made good points.