Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Stop the Meat ASAP

Stop the Meat ASAP

Jay the Paapi · 22 Dec 2005

Heres an email i was sent a while back ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Stop the Meat ASAP im gonna sum up what sri guru granth sahib ji says about meat in my own words, then im gonna give you the actual words guru ji says: a person who kills animals is a butcher, a Ruthless killer, a murderer.(Sikhs r punishers and may punish an evil person to death , but that is destroying not killing) Flesh is meant to transport the animal’s soul; when an animal is dead, it is a carcass and was not invented for the humans to consume. Guru Ji says: This is guru ji when he was chatting to a Muslim who said killing and consuming halal meat wasn’t a sin: "You kill animals (living beings (god’s creatures)) and call it a righteous action. Tell me brother what u call an unrighteous action? "You aren’t a saint you are a butcher" pg 1103 Sri Guru Granth sahib ji. If ones clothes are stained with blood, the garment becomes polluted. Those who consume blood in the form of flesh (meat) how can their conscious be pure? pg 140 sggsj Those mortals who consume intoxicants, meat and alcohol. No matter what pilgrimages, fasts and rituals they follow they will go to hell. Page 1377 sggsj Would u have your throat cut so that someone can have meat on their plate? (So why should the animals) page 1374 sggsj The world eats dead carcasses, living by neglect and greed. Like a goblin, or a beast, they kill and eat forbidden carcasses of meat. So control your urges, or else you will be seized by the lord and thrown into the tortures of hell. Page 723 sggsj Stop the meat Sikhs. Pass this on. (Protecting the panth from eating meat campaign) [%sig%]

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

ss · 27 Dec 2005

yeah yeah we know all that but you forget is that bhagat sadna ji was a butcher and he has his bani in the SGGS, why is that? If the Guru's were so against killing animals than why have butcher bhagat's bani in the SGGS?? Answer that one please,.

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

Sabji Ram · 27 Dec 2005

I concur, people are a bunch of idiot when it comes to the meat eating debate, how much more evidence are you looking for. Science has proven the 67% of cancers are caused by meat.

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

Swinder Singh · 31 Dec 2005

Author: ss Date: 12-27-05 20:12 yeah yeah we know all that but you forget is that bhagat sadna ji was a butcher and he has his bani in the SGGS, why is that? If the Guru's were so against killing animals than why have butcher bhagat's bani in the SGGS?? Answer that one please,. """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" Gur Fateh ji Sadna was a butcher till he did not come across to an incident that reversed his life and he thrown away his butcher knives. Thereafter he attained that spirtual stage that his bani was entered in SGGS.If we talk of previous life of Kauda, he was a cannible before meeting to Guru Nanak Dev ji, but he later turned to be Sajjan thereafter. There are so many examples that can be put forth here Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

Sikh Enkilaab(Sikh Revolution) · 31 Dec 2005

Why do we discuss silly little issues, when there is so much happening to our Panth that we don't do anything about. Eating meat is an individual choise. If you don't eat meat, good for you. But don't start enforcing it on other people. Individuals realise on their own accord. At the point of Amrit, there are 4 Bajar Karetha. One of them is not to consume Muslim Halal Meat. Guru Nank Dev Ji, never once started his parchar by telling people you have to to stop eating meating if you want to joing my crew. Theres a shabad that come in the SGGS Ji Maharaj that says ' Maas Maas Murakh Chagareh'. In short it goes on about people who go on about not eatinng meat are hypocrites. Baba Nanak when he went to Kurukshetra, he cooked venison. (nOT TO EAT), but to prove a point. By stop eating meat, you don't become closer to the Akal Purukh. You need to carry out all the other righteous actions. We all know of the so-called Singh's, who won't even have langar served to them by an non-amritdhari, but if they do, they want it in steel plates, but you'll see them the next day in town, munching on packet opf monser munch crisps. These are hypocrites. Be vary. Let Akal Purukh lead you to your own righteous path.

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

Jaskaran Kaur · 31 Dec 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear SS... i think u got mistaken there... if u knew BHagat Sadna Ji's Saakhi then i dnt think u was ever gnna post tat post. Plzzzz now in offensive way i urge u to go and ask Bhagat Ji's Saakhi from any gursikh in your area. Thank You. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 31 Dec 2005

what causes the other 33% cancers ?? Saag and Makee dee roti and perhaps Ganna ??

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

pj · 31 Dec 2005

67% eh? wow, that science is getting better and better every year. Next year hopefully they will give us a couple decimal places too. :p I mean no offence, just found that random figure kind of funny. But as a suggestion, if you are arguing the for the anti-meat side, don't bring science into it because you'll get whooped ;) Now, the topic at hand. First and foremost, people have scrutinized bani over and over and to this day there is no consensus as to whether meat is prohibited. Why does this guy (not the original poster, but rather the guy who wrote the email) think that he has suddenly figured it all out definitively? Furthermore, what is the need for a "Protecting the panth from eating meat campaign" This is ridiculus. I am not trying to argue for or against eating meat. But I don't understand why Sikhs tend to become so polarized over this issue. Each side is trying to "convert" as many people as they can. This is the way I see it. As always, some may agree, others may not. But I do think it's the healthiest stance regardless. As I have previously said, bani has been interpreted both ways and hasn't yielded a consensus. For this reason I have not included any. Everyone knows that a Sikh should show daya/compassion. And this means not only to each other but also our surroundings. As a person becomes a better Sikh, this compassion naturally grows. When it comes to supper time, do you think that person will feel better eating a seemingly 'lifeless' plant, or an animal that he/she can better relate to (ie. in motility, anatomy, size, social structure, communication, etc.) Just about any random person will agree that its worse to kill a rabbit over a carrot, and worse still to kill an elephant. Now the meat eater's next arguement would be that since all of these creatures (carrot included) have the same light within them, killing one is no different that killing the other. However, a vegetarian taking a compassionate viewpoint could just as easily, and correctly, argue that killing the 'greater' being (ie the animal) has a more adverse affect on the environment. But then the meat eater could counter and say that this is the way the world was created, and it is just the natural order or things. The arguement can bounce back and forth indefinately. In my eyes (and I'm sure a lot of people will surely disagree with me), both sides are equally correct. So, according to everything I have said, I'm naturally inclined to view the choice as personal preference. The vegetarian feels he/she should show compassion towards other beings and reduce his/her footprint on nature. wicked. The meat eater sees everything the same and happening according to the laws of nature. Also wicked. Why can't we just leave it at that? Let's not try and convert people. Let's not judge others based on these trivial decisions. Let's not call one person is a 'lesser' sikh based on his/her decision (or even think for that matter -- and I know most people do think lesser of other Sikhs based on these types of decisions. I struggle with it every day). We should be fighting for Unity instead of with each other over trivial matters such as this. Acceptance is key. wjkk wjkf **Stop the bickering Sikhs. Pass this on. (Creating Unity and Protecting the panth from divides based on insignificant issues campaign)** ....hehehe :)

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

. · 01 Jan 2006

science has also proved that we evolved into clever humans becauss we started eating meat, causing our brains to grow.

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

look · 01 Jan 2006

you aint gonna stop us eating meat, so give up preaching instead

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

indy · 01 Jan 2006

dont eat meat it is filth stick 2 vegetables----healthy, cheap, tasty and my grandad grows half the stuff bak at home in jallandhar go 2 your local supermarkets groceries and buy the vegtables now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

Regarding Sadhna · 01 Jan 2006

Vah-e-guroo Je Ka Khalsa Vah-e-Guru je Ke Fateh Veerji, yeah yeah, abit of research into bhai Gurdasji's vaar (the key to the Sikh Philosophy and ideology) will give you the answer regarding Bhagat Sadhna. If you are unable to get hold of a copy or are unable obtain a translation, here it is dhan dhan Bhai Gurdasji: In Vaar 31, titled Pootnaa meaning Beware of exceptions, states: Je kasaaee udhriaa, jeeaa ghaai na khaaeeai bhangaa Though the butcher (Sadhna) got salvation, the killing of any being or causing them injury is a vicious deed. Bhai Gurdasji clearly is emphasising that to continue indulging in a vice(s) i.e. lust, in the belief that many sinners have been liberated and saved by late penitence or through vaheguroooji's kirpa is very unwise and foolish. Therefore STOP IT! Regarding lust, Bhai Gurdasji in the same vaar brings forth the example of Gankaa (the prostitute) as follows: Gankaa udhri aashiai, par ghar jaai na laeeai pangaa Similarly, if Gankaa obtained salvation, this does not make prostitution free from taint. [%sig%]

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

SST · 01 Jan 2006

How were the Panj Piare chosen? I think it involved killing an animal. Do you really think the Gurus as well as the Sikh army did not eat meat? It is not possible to have that much streangth to fight a war without the nutrients from meat. "Only the foolish quarrel over the desirability of eating flesh. They are oblivious of true knowledge and meditation. What is really flesh? What is really vegetable-food? Which one of is sin-infested? They do not differentiate between good food and that which leads to sin.... Men are born of a mother's and father's blood yet they do not eat fish or meat ... Meat is mentioned in the Puranas and the Katebas: It has been used in Yajnas on marriages and festive occasions". (p.1290 of SGGS).

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

khalistani · 02 Jan 2006

aii thas a bunch of crap, the nutrient meat part many veggies can beat the crap out of meat eaters jus come to ma skool and meet some singhs, ull find out wa im talkin bout milk has protien to get certain vitamins ure body can produce, and beans, etc. etc/ all good source of nutrients it is historically proven that when panj pyarai were choosen guru je did not cut of 5 goat heads, but INFRONT of the sangat guru je cut the panj pyarais heads off this is recorded by someone who was there, a muslim gov spy, who then took amrit after seein this, abdul trani as for the shabad posted read the history and watch the films on gursikhijeevan.com on taksal and meat The only hymn in the whole of Sri Guru Granth Sahib that is specifically cited in support of eating meat is the hymn of Sahib Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji in the Var of Raag Malhar on pages 1289-90 beginning with the couplet: Maas Maas Kar Moorakh Jhaghrrey. Gian dhian Nahin Jaaney. Kaun Maas Kaun Saag Kahaavey Kis Mah Paap Samaaney. (pg. 1289-1290) Only the fool quarrels over the question of eating or not eating of the meat. He does not have the True Wisdom. Without True Wisdom or Meditation, he harps on which is flesh and which is not flesh and which food is sinful and which is not. A deeper study of the whole hymn brings out: Herein, Guru Sahib is addressing a Vaishnav Pandit who believes that he can achieve his spiritual goal only by avoiding meat as food and not trying to obtain the true wisdom through meditation. Guru Ji has stressed that only avoiding meat will not lead one to the achievement of Spiritual Bliss if one does not do Naam-Simran. This equally applies to all, including non-meat-eating Sikhs. It relates to the flesh or meat in general and not to any particular type of flesh - whether prepared by Halaal or Jhatka method. The Sikh supporters of flesh eating do not accept at all the intake of all types of meat, but according to them, only Jhatka meat is permissible and Halaal is totally prohibited. In other words, what does the term "Kuthha" denote? The flesh of the mother's womb wherein the human body is born, the flesh of the mother's breasts which feed the infant, the flesh of the tongue, ears, mouth, etc., used for perception of various senses of the body, the flesh in the form of wife and off-springs referred to in the Shabad, is flesh no doubt and one cannot escape it, but is it the flesh to be eaten as food by the humans? Does the love for this type of flesh involve any cruelty or slaughter of living bodies? Obviously, the Shabad has a deeper meaning telling Vaishnav pandits that merely escaping from the flesh does not take one anywhere. Nor can anyone get rid of the flesh (i.e., attainment of salvation from the cycle of birth and death) by his own futile efforts without the Grace of the True Guru i seriously suggest u watch the videos on gursikhijeevan.com for this topic bhula chuka maf

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

abc123 · 02 Jan 2006

i would very much like it if bhai kulbir singh could enlighten this mainly carnivorous sangat who have deluged this post with their limited knowledge and ego.... its not a complicated argument, its jus complicated when its mixed with a manmukhs ego.... wjkk wjkf

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

To SST · 02 Jan 2006

Do a little bit of research it goes along way! These questions keep coming up again and again we get fed up of answering 'em again and again and again... its becoming tedious to say the least. Look for the two Hukhumnama by Sri Satguru Hargobind Sahibji! Hukamnama by Shaheed Banda Singh Bahadur dated 17 December 1710. The ang 1290, has been repetitively brought forward by individuals who indulge in the Unadulterated taste of a dead corpse. maasahu ni(n)mae maasahu ja(n)mae ham maasai kae bhaa(n)ddae || In the flesh we are conceived, and in the flesh we are born; we are VESSELS of flesh. giaan dhhiaan kashh soojhai naahee chathur kehaavai paa(n)ddae || You know NOTHING of spiritual wisdom and meditation, even though you call yourself clever, O religious scholar. The above is from ang (limb) 1290 not P. (page) 1290 (Guru Sahib is not a book!), the above quote speaks for itself ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Now to ang 1289 not page. Lets have a look at each line with concentration and focus.... maas maas kar moorakh jhagarrae giaan dhhiaan nehee jaanai || The fools argue about flesh and meat, but they know nothing about meditation and spiritual wisdom. Okay what is guru sahib saying? The fools argue about the consumption flesh and meat... like people argue over the consumption of larger and spirits. Then guru sahibs says (this is the important bit are you ready)? but they know NOTHING about Meditation (Naam Simran) and Spiritual Wisdom... So, these people are devoid of any spiritual gain, enlightenment or liberation. Then the following verse states: koun maas koun saag kehaavai kis mehi paap samaanae || What is called meat, and what is called green vegetables? What leads to sin? So these people who may dress themselves as saints and act like saints are unable to differentiate what is good and bad and are unable to distinguish what acts lead to sin ... without focusing their minds on naam. So without naam does it make any difference to what you consume? >> How were the Panj Piare chosen? I think it involved killing an animal. You are going in the lines that goats gave their heads in 1699 and NOT Bhai Daya Singh, Bhai Dharam Singh, Bhai Himmat Singh, Bhai Mukham Singh and Bhai Sahib Singh ... if the goats had given their heads they would be the panj pyare... END OF. [%sig%]

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

ss · 02 Jan 2006

People, Thanks for correcting me, I wrote on Bhagat Sadna on hearsay and without looking at his saaki, Thanks for your knowledge and wisdom. I 'm not for meat eating anyway and never have been.

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

H · 02 Jan 2006

so you are actually denying that guruji took the talwar to each of the panj pyare's necks and instead killed a goat!??!! well done

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

LionKing · 02 Jan 2006

.(Sikhs r punishers and may punish an evil person to death , but that is destroying not killing) -------------------------------------------- Nowhere has Guru JI given every Sikh to go and punish every other person who does anything wrong.

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

Harcharan Singh · 02 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, To all the budding scientists, give it a rest. Science thought smoking was good for you up until around 50 years ago. That meat has contributed to brain growth is a "THEORY" and not a fact as some posters have said, the creation of the universe through the "Big Bang" is a theory, and not a fact, please think before you speak. Gorillas and Orangutans are amongst the 2 most intelligent animal species on earth, yet they live on a 99% vegan diet? Why is it that animals species like the Crocodile which have been around for a 100 million years eating 100% meat have not developed intelligence to surpass ours! THINK. It is through Gods grace that we achieve the human form, the most highly developed on earth, that which allows us to find God. It is through environmental and survival necessity that one animal develops more intelligence than others. As for FACTS, it is a proven statistical fact that the single most devasting reason for cutting the rain forests is to create grazing land for sheep and cattle to feed the glutonous, selfish and increasing demand for meat as a daily diet. It is also a proven fact the we could feed the whole world over twice with only 50% of the grazing land used to supply the west with meat (North America being the greediest culprits). There is only around 30% of the worlds rainforest left compared to 100 years ago, hmmm, thats not going to help our other big problem is it "GLOBAL WARMING" which incidentally is no longer a theory. The question here is not a fight about whether eating meat is right or wrong. In line with history (which proves that SOME Sikhs did kill and consume meat in hard times when necessary during the late MISL period - read Sieks, tigers and thieves), our maryada does state that only kutha meat (not specifically halaal) is banned. That means meat killed in a ritualistic/inhumane manner, which no one out there can claim does not apply to modern day abotiores, all animals are killed inhumanely, do some research if you don't agree, this is not a debate. In line with Sikhi we should only take what we need, we do not need animal flesh to survive. I have spoken to many old people and I know for a fact that many a brave and strong Gursikh were fighting fit up to a very old age and strictly did not ever consume meat (includingmy own great great grandad who fought in WW1 Basra at the age of 85 with his son). I refuse to accept that our Guru's did either, it wouldn't make sense. The Guru's kitchen was always Guru the Langar, meat has never ever been served in the Darbari langer (not even by Nihangs), so what are some of you implying that Guru ji sneaked away to have a meat snack? Have some shame. I am not saying that meat is wrong in all circumstances, to all the brahman minded brothers, what are Eskimos and Aborigines supposed to eat - SNOW AND SAND? God has made a sustainable environment for all his children, we are lucky, in ours fruit and vegetables are always available. Meat is and has always been either a luxury or a survival necessity, for Sikhs, in line with bani and Sikhi it should only ever be a survival necessity IF NECESSARY (killing the animal with zero pain - Jatka), that is not to say that those Sikhs who would rather die than kill an animal are wrong, that is their perogative and we are none to judge. Jist of it, Sikhi believes in a simple lifestyle, minimal damage to the earth and minimal harm to Gods creatures, roti and daal have been proven to produce armies of brave and strong men, don't stick your noses up at it. Banda Singh Bahadur raised a Sikh army from the lowest castes in the land who destroyed the Mughal foundation and inflicted many a courageous defeat o nteh Mughals armies, they did this on a Veg diet (maybe stemming from Banda Singhs Yogi background), when suffering hard times, particularly in Loh Garh they were known to have eaten the bark off trees as a last resort. If you still wish to eat meat, understand it should be a last resort, and if you profess to be a Sikh and still want to meat, then kill the animal yourself exercising Jatka, the only way to be sure that no pain has come to the animal. This should ensure that 99% of the thoughtless consumers will turn vegetarian, nearly all the Punjabis I know are happy to consume meat but wouldn't have the guts/heart to kill the animal and prepare the meat themselves, i.e. skin it, gut it etc. To me, this cries of hypocrisy, they are happy to knowingly ignorently consume meat, irrelevant of the fact that the animal has been born into horrific farming conditions, been fed rubbish (steroids etc), may have a number of diseases (cancer being common amongst farm animals), and will have been killed in a sadistic manner. Most importantly, think about compassion to animals and the environment, the meat trade has devasted both. Satnaam Harcharan Singh

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

ns · 03 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Most excellent post by Harcharn Singh with Guru Ji at heart all the time.

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

Be practical · 03 Jan 2006

Dear Sabji Ram, Which research are you referring to exactly. Exact medical journals with dates and references would be appreciated. In the past its true that the incidences of certain cancers are more prevalent in meat eaters but its also true that certain cancers have a higher prevalence in vegatarians. The only guidelines to reducing risk from cancers is a well balanced diet. Only last week a report was released about the cancer protective properties of Vitamin D. Its been suggested in many research journals that as much as 50mcg of Vitamin D should be ingested to fully realise the benefit of this vitamin. Current RDA is 5mcg. One of the best dietary sources of Vitamin D is fish. Health experts recommend three servings of fish a week in addition to a high strength daily multi-vitamin. That should give you an average of 30mcg a day. So in summary it could be suggested dear sabji ram ji that eating fish reduces the risk of breast, ovarian, colon and prostate cancer. There is far more evidence suggestive that meat/fish products are beneficial than not in the right amounts as part of a well balanced diet. So i would suggest that you stick with the spiritual argument to support your case for vegatarianism. At least on that platform you can argue that it may be considered inhumane to kill animals. Once again its difficult to take su[pport from history and quotes from the guru granth sahib ji because you will be bombarded with countless pieces of evidence suggesting that Sikhs have always been meat eaters and have been observed to have no dietary limitations unlike the hindus and muslims. Surely the world should focus on the message "stop the massacre of innocent people in the world" than having to worry about gary the goat. I think a little perspective is lacking. No offence intended Be practical PS references Do vegetarian diets reduce cancer risk? "Vegetarian diets include many health-promoting features; they tend to be low in saturated fats and high in fiber, vitamins, and phytochemicals (e.g., flavonoids). It is not possible to conclude at this time, however, that a vegetarian diet has any special benefits for the prevention of cancer. Vegetarian diets differ in composition, although all avoid red meat. A vegetarian diet can be quite healthful if it is carefully planned and provides adequate calories. Diets including lean meats in small to moderate amounts can be just as healthful. The greater the restriction of food groups in a particular diet, the more possibility there is of dietary deficiencies. Strict vegetarian diets that avoid all animal products, including milk and eggs, should be supplemented with vitamin B, zinc, and iron (especially for children and premenopausal women)." American Cancer society" http://www.cancer.org/docroot/PED/content/PED_3_2X_Common_Questions_About_Diet_and_Cancer.asp Other references suggesting benefits from Vit D http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=12465754&dopt=Abstract http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=10332920&dopt=Abstract http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=9426741&dopt=Abstract http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=12899532&dopt=Abstract

Re: Stop being one sided and biased

singh · 03 Jan 2006

maybe if more of you eat meat there would be less people suffering from depression here. Meats contain seratonin, the transimiter in the brain which causes us to experience pleasure, did you not check that in any medical journals

Re: Stop the Meat ASAP

Chi Chi · 03 Jan 2006

excellent post Jay the papi i agree totally!!