performing of kirtan
GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 12 Nov 2003
What is the sangats opinion on who can perform keertan?
i say
amritdharis/shasterdhari
sehajdhari (true ones)
and ppl of non-sikh families (hindus muslims .....)
but if one is a mona keshadhari from a sikhfamilly i don' think that person shoudl be able 2 hold the honour.
Re: performing of kirtan
Not much of a Gursikh · 12 Nov 2003
What exactly is a shasterdhari? First time I come accross that term.
Thanks
Re: performing of kirtan
somoene jus wondering · 12 Nov 2003
i think its when a person who keeps shastars, but hasnt taken amrit
Re: performing of kirtan
jus wondering · 12 Nov 2003
i think anyone should be able to do kirtan. kirtan is the singing of god's praises. anyone in the right state of mind, or anyone who has love for God should be able to do kirtan.
Re: performing of kirtan
Kulbir Singh · 12 Nov 2003
Sewa of Guru Sahib is a privilege and not a right. Doing kirtan is a great sewa. One doing kirtan not only purifies his or her own mind but also help purify the minds of sangat listening to kirtan. The reward of doing kirtan is unlimited.
At personal level, anyone is allowed to do kirtan but when other parties i.e. the sangat is involved, normally only amritdharis should be allowed to do kirtan. In certain cases, non-amritdharis can be allowed, provided they wear Gurmukhi baana e.g. kids who are not amritdharia should be allowed or sehajdharis i.e. otherwise keshadhari and preparing to take amrit but not yet amritdhari can be allowed to do kirtan provided they wear all 5 kakaars and Gurmukhi baana.
Some say that there should be no restriction on who does kirtan. This is a wrong notion. Before SGPC took control of Gurdwaras, Muslim Rababis used to be allowed to do kirtan at Darbar Sahib but thankfully SGPC banned them from doing kirtan. Those Tobacco chewing Muslim Rababis were given a choice to adopt Khalsa Faith or stop doing kirtan. Many became Sikhs but some did not.
One of the Rababis was seen spitting out and chewing Tobacco after doing kirtan at Darbar Sahib. He confessed that he does kirtan only to earn a living and felt disgusted singing baani of Kaafirs (infidels).
Daas,
Kulbir Singh