Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

NAAM DHRIRH???

NAAM DHRIRH???

singh · 19 Dec 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa!!! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! Saad Sangat Ji, 1. What exactly is naam dhridh? 2. When did it begin? 3. What is the history behind it? 4. Do all Panj Pyare teach it? 5. If you have not had "naam dhridh" do you have to take amrit again? Here are some things I have heard...to provide a basis of where I am with my understanding: I have never heard of "naam dhridh" outside of an AKJ circle - in fact most people are clueless as to what it is. I have heard that only the Panj Pyare can give "naam dhridh" and that if you don't have it you are not fully a Sikh. My benti to the reader is: if you are going to answer the above questions please STAY ON POINT and answer as completely as you can with as much support from Gurbani and historic writing (or references that I can follow up on) as possible. I really would like to learn about this. Bhul Chuk Maaf, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa!!! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Singh · 19 Dec 2005

"1. What exactly is naam dhridh?" Do a search on the forum it has been discussed many times. "2. When did it begin?" Do a search on the forum it has been discussed many times. "3. What is the history behind it?" Do a search on the forum it has been discussed many times. "4. Do all Panj Pyare teach it?" Yes. And do a search on the forum it has been discussed many times. "5. If you have not had "naam dhridh" do you have to take amrit again?" Purely your choice. But again, if you did a search on the forum, you would find it has been discussed many times before.

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Moorakh Singh · 20 Dec 2005

By having naam dhrih, it's a easier way to attain Vaaheguroo. A gursikh is expected to do simran with every breath!! man than saas giraas prabh eiko eik dhhiaae || In your mind and body, with each breath and morsel of food, meditate on the One and only Lord God. kaaeiaa garr sohiaa maerai prabh mohiaa kio saas giraas visaareeai || My body-fortress is so beautiful; I am fascinated by my God. How could I forget Him, for even a breath, or a morsel of food? Guroo jee tells us to do simran with every breath. Thats what naam dhrih is, doing simran with every breath. A gursikh can get to a stage where he is doing simran internally (aath pehur - 24 hours) when he is talking , sleeping, eating and so on. I personally think it's important for every amrithari gursikh to have naam dhrih. For the chardi kala gursikhs who did not have naam dhrih from the Punj Piare, such as Sant Jarnail Singh, Sant Attar Singh, Sant Kartar Singh and etc... Guru Jee must have blessed these souls with naam dhrih personally. This is how Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh was blessed with naam. I hope Guru Jee does kirpa on those who don't have naam dhrih. Phul Chuck Maaf PLease forgive this moorakh Vaheguroo jee kaa khalsa, Vaheguroo jee ke faateh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

a sikh · 22 Jan 2006

so basically is naam drirh being able to say waheguru at every breath silently . like rememebering got 24-7?????? im confused? waheguru ji ka kalsa waheguru ji ke fateh pull chuk maf

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Shaktishali Sha Soora · 22 Jan 2006

VahegurooJeKakhalsaVaheguroojekeFateh Great post Bhai Sahib 'Moorakh Singh' Jeeo. VahegurooJeKakhalsaVaheguroojekeFateh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

moorakh · 23 Jan 2006

"1. What exactly is naam dhridh?" Naam drirtaa is having naam abhyaas simran turned "on" from its dormant state in your soul. It is action of enabling you to do simran with each breath. "2. When did it begin?" It began as long as there has been Naam. "3. What is the history behind it?" History of Naam is an akathh kathhaa. It cannot be summarized. "4. Do all Panj Pyare teach it?" Yes, but methods differ, some of which give a better "jump start" for simran; but if the amritdhari doesn't do simran, any method won't help very much. "5. If you have not had "naam dhridh" do you have to take amrit again?" No. If you took amrit from rehitvaan, naam-abhyaasi, nitnemi, punj-kakari gurmukh tyaar-bar-tyaar punj pyare in the haazri of sri guru granth sahib ji, and you got khande-ke-pahul and gurmantar, that is the Sikh initiation ceremony and you are an amritdhari gursikh with all of the benefits and rules.

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 23 Jan 2006

Author: Moorakh Singh Date: 12-20-05 04:43 By having naam dhrih, it's a easier way to attain Vaaheguroo. A gursikh is expected to do simran with every breath!! ************* And he has to do that the AKJ-method. Are you sayign tha a Singh who's been blessed with Amrit from Akal Thakhat/Taksal/Whatever has a "harder time" to meet Vaheguru than a Singh who's been blessed in an "Akj-samagam" if they have equal amoutn of prem pyaar for Guru Ji and Gursikhs? ****** For the chardi kala gursikhs who did not have naam dhrih from the Punj Piare, such as Sant Jarnail Singh, Sant Attar Singh, Sant Kartar Singh and etc... Guru Jee must have blessed these souls with naam dhrih personally. This is how Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh was blessed with naam. ****** Or he blessed them with prem Pyaar. Most Taksalis I know don't do naam Drirh (or actually I don't know any Taksali who DOES do Naam-drirh) yet they were presumably blessed with Amrit at a Sanchar where one of the above Gurmukhs were part of the Panj.....? *** I hope Guru Jee does kirpa on those who don't have naam dhrih. *** Comments such as these makes people from other Jathey/samparda/dere annoyed as the Amrit they have been blessed with is previewed as "less blessed Amrit" and the Sancahr with naam Dridh is seen as a "more blessed Amrit" Something we need to look at. Bhull chukk maaf

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Swinder Singh · 23 Jan 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh Literal meaning of Dhrirh is to strenthen your belief in Shabad guru in a permanent way and to take it to of your sub-conscious mind so that you should not forget it even during asleep thus 24X7 simran. It is fundamental and foremost requirement while doing amrit sanchar, which is to be followed on by the blessed one later in his life. I donnt know the maryada of Akj otherwise there no need to retake amrit simply on this account. Gur Fateh ji

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jan 2006

It's my humble opinion that our debate should be about asools and not about organizations. Whether AKJ or Jatha Bhindran or some other Jatha, the amrit organized by them would be judged by maryada they keep and not by the organization that does it. Amrit is not amrit just because AKJ organizes it or Jatha Bhindran organizes it. Amrit is amrit if it is prepared with full maryada. If there is an amrit sinchaar organized by AKJ or Jatha Bhindran and they don't keep the most basic amrit maryada, then I don't think such amrit can be classified amrit. First of all there must be the true Saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Secondly, there must be Punj Pyaray who are tyaar bar Tyaar Gursikhs and the ones who strive to keep full rehit. Thirdly they should follow at least the basic maryada of amrit. Here are some points to ponder upon: 1) If the saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is not there, can amrit sinchaar be done? I don't think so. 2) If there are only 4 Gursikhs and not 5 Gursikhs to do sewa in Punj Pyaray can such amrit sinchaar be valid? I don't think so. 3) If Sarblohi Baata and Sarblohi Khanda is not there can such amrit sinchaar be valid? I don't think so? 4) Punj Pyaray ask for heads at the time of amrit sinchaar. Before the abhilaakhis can go inside to give head, they must wear full baana including all kakaars and dastaar. If they don't wear kakaars, can their head be accepted or will they even reach that point where their head will be asked? I don't think so. They must wear baana to enter amrit sinchaar mandal. If they don't wear dastaar, can their heads be accepted? No way. this daas is of the firm determination that Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj would never accept a head without the dastaar or without kakaars. It may be acceptable if the Gursikh wears the dastaar but does not consider it a kakaar but accepts it to part of mandatory baana like many Nihungs and Taksalis do but to offer your nanga head without a dastaar and just covered with a thin chunni, is not acceptable. 5) If Punj Pyaray just give you Naam but don't implant it inside you or don't teach you how to japp Naam, how would you japp it? Without method, how do you japp Naam? Where do you focus your dhyaan? So it's best if Punj Pyaray teach how to japp Naam. 6) Punj Pyaray should give amrit and not "Ikk Pyara". In all organizations I have heard of, Punj Pyaray prepare amrit but in most cases, one one pyara imparts amrit to seekers. This is not correct maryada. The whole purpose of receive amrit 5 times in your mouth, 5 times in your eyes and 5 times in your hair is to enable each one of the Punj Pyaray do so. I know in AKJ this maryada is still going on. Some other jathas may have it too and they are dhan if they are maintaining this maryada. But most of them have lost it. If there are small differences in maryada we should ignore them but if a person chhaks amrit with totally non-maryada (e.g. Nanaksari, pakhandi saadh amrit like Kashmira Singh etc) then I think its fair for a rehitvaan Singh to not do roti beti dee saanjh with such person, not out of hatred but out of respect and love for Gurmat Maryada. Such statements like "Amrit prepared by all organizations is same" are nonsense statements. How can amrit prepared by a pakhand like pehowa be amrit? How can amrit prepared by adulturous saadhs be amrit? How can amrit given to women wearing makeup and earrings be amrit? Statements like "the whole Panth does this and majority does that" are naive statements. Are we to keep maryada according to what the majority position is? Majority of the so called Sikh diaspora is patit i.e. they cut their hair. Are we to say that cutting hair is okay? As the matter of fact, it has already been accepted by most people now. How can langar prepared by or served by a patit (a monna, or an adulturous or a tobacco eater) be acceptable to Khalsa of Guru Sahib? Foolish and sometimes malicious are those people who blame Rehitvaan Singhs for refusing such food and for condemning such activities at Gurdwaras. To call such langar as "Guru ka Langar" is nothing short of blasphemy. Langar or degh prepared by adulturers, monnay, tobacco consumers and kutha eaters cannot be classified as "Guru ka Langar". Bhul Chuk dee maafi. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

singh · 23 Jan 2006

Mr lion King, I think you ask taksalis. I think you will surprised at the amount of taksalis who have come to jatha for Naam dhrirr. Some do it openly, others have done it secretly, but so many have come to AKJ for naam dhrirr

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

!!!!!! · 23 Jan 2006

WJKK WJKF nam dridh does not belong to any jatha or orginization in sikhi. nam dridh is the action of repeating waheguru with every breath. Sas sas simro govind. it is done by saying wahe while breathing in and saying guru while breathing out. when u take amrit the panj pyare do give nam dridh no matter what jatha they blong to. When u take amrit the panj pyare say bole Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. that is also a form of nam dridh. in the amrit sanchar u r suposed to do simran for an amount of time decided by the panj pyare some do longer than others. when the panj pyare do this they are giving u the key to obtain waheguru because they have given u nam all panj pyare do this by making u say fateh. its like planting a seed they plant it u take care of it. u have to water it give it light nurtue it untill it blossoms and then u have darshan. that is nam dridh pul chuk mar karna chardi kalan vich rana WJKK WJKF

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 24 Jan 2006

It's my humble opinion that our debate should be about asools and not about organizations. Whether AKJ or Jatha Bhindran or some other Jatha, the amrit organized by them would be judged by maryada they keep and not by the organization that does it. Amrit is not amrit just because AKJ organizes it or Jatha Bhindran organizes it. Amrit is amrit if it is prepared with full maryada. ************* Which Maryada? Veer Ji, you say Maryada, but is there ONE maryada in the panth. WHen you say Maryada you imply the Maryada AKJ follows - the one majority of Panth doesn't. You say it's naive to say that, but think about it, AKj is a relatively new "jatha" with relatively "different" maryada from rest of panth - is rest of panth joined? No because we don't stand together under the one Akal Thakat and show faithfulness to the one Panth, instead we decide to classify ourselves as Taksali, AKj-er, Whatever. Point is, unless we can sit together and decide - this is maryada - it's useless to use the word. Panth did that a 60-70 years ago, but today new sampardava, new samajs, new groups begin to rise and say "our maryada is right" Untill we stand together and make a panthic decition no1 can say "full marayada", because when you say "full maryada", its how YOU interpret it. Unless we throw away titles and labels, and call ourselvse ONLY "GurukeSIkh" We're not getting anywhere. WIll try to respond to toher points later. Ram Japo Ji Aiisey Aisey, Dhru Prehlad japeyo har jaisey Bhull chukkk maaf

'fullest' maryada...

Admin - Akaal Images · 24 Jan 2006

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, this thread has raised some interesting points, particularly regarding what 'full maryada' is. sometimes i look at issues of Rehit in the following way - if a person adheres to or does not adhere to a certain practice, what are the 'risks' they are taking. lets use an example... if a person eats 'dead animals' i.e.kutha, will they be denied Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa? well alot of GurSikhs believe they will. what about a vegetarian losing Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa by not eating kutha - even kutha-eaters cannot say that a vegetarian will be denied Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa. there is no evidence to suggest that Vegetarians are breaking any kind of Rehit. so my point is that if we are in doubt then we should use logic - the best thing is not to eat kutha in case you risk losing Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa. my point is that the GurSikh will decide that they do not wish to risk losing Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa by ignoring certain Asools, so they will adopt as much rehit as possible. this logic can be applied to the issue of Keski, keeping Kakaars on at all times, doing Punj Nitnaym Banis, Sarbloh Bibek, Naam Dhrir etc. after all, can it possibly hurt someone if they wear a Keski, read more Banis, keep Bibek, receive Naam Dhrir? but what if they do not do these things - i am of the opinion that they are, at the very least, taking a risk... the only issue this logic cannot address is Raagmala. one could argue that by reading it, GurSikhs will be covering all bases however, the anti-Raagmala GurSikhs will feel that by reading it they are blaspheming. therefore this issue is more complex and not as easily solved. bhul chuk maaf karna jio. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

singh · 24 Jan 2006

yes there must be 5 singhs who keep solid rehit in the panj pyareh.

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Harcharan Singh · 25 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru j iki Fateh, ONLY AKJ panj pyare give naam dhrih i.e. instructions as to how to breath/simmer the gurmanter. ALL OTHER Sikh Panj Pyare give Mool Manter and advise that it should be repeated with every breath i.e. constant naam japna. ONLY AKJ panj pyare insist that females wear Keski and that it is a kakaar. ALL OTHER Sikh Panj Pyare insist that females must keep their head covered and that Kesh is a kakaar. That is the difference between AKJ and the rest (large portion) of the Khalsa. Mahapurkh Sikhs like Baba Jarnail Singh, Baba Puran Singh, Baba Isher Singh (rarawale), Baba Isher Singh (Nanaksar), Baba Nand Singh, Baba Attar Singh, Baba Ram Singh....etc did not recieve AKJ Naam Dhrih nor did they invst it when they held amrit sanchaars. Only a foolish person would beleive that the Amrit Sanchaars these highly devoted servants of Akaal Purkh held were not Gurmat. In addition these Mahapurkh did not necessitate Keski and call Keski a Kakaar. It seems that only the young AKJ Sikhs I come accross have this "We are the chosen children of God" attitude. All the elder AKJ Sikhs I know do not even talk of AKJ, they are strict bibeki GurSikhs who welcome and treat all Sikhs aloke irrelevant of the "Jathaa" etc. They never rant or rave about Naam Dhrih or Keski. I would seriously advise the more responsible and mature AKJ Veers/Bhens to remove this increasingly fanatical element from amongst their youth, because if not, AKJ will simply isolate themselves by claiming in 100's of either clever/diplomatic/rude/ignorent ways that their amrit is the only correct amrit and their panj pyare are the only "proper" Panj Pyare. I other feable excuses like "other jathaas don't do amrit sanchaar in Guru Ji's hazoori or they don't use NITNEMi Sikhs or they don't use sarbloh bataa to prepare teh amrit", I have yet to come accross any of this rubbish. All the people I know who have received amrit from various parts of the panth, did so in the same way. This is not to say there aren't dodgy people out there, but they are not in the majority. Orgs like Guru Nanak Nishkaam Sevak Jathaa, Taksaal etc prepare and give the same amrit and use respected NITNEMi Gursikhs. Please open your eyes, AKJ does not hold the monopoly on Guru Gobind Singh, the Khalsa or Amrit. Guru Ji is not so restricted as to only bless a few Sikhs with their own understanding of Khande de Pahul. I am sure Guru Ji allows for differences that have always been created by man, and accepts all those who give their head to Guru Ji from their heart, in what they beleive is correct. Sat Sri Akaal Harcharan Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 25 Jan 2006

1) If the saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is not there, can amrit sinchaar be done? I don't think so. 2) If there are only 4 Gursikhs and not 5 Gursikhs to do sewa in Punj Pyaray can such amrit sinchaar be valid? I don't think so. 3) If Sarblohi Baata and Sarblohi Khanda is not there can such amrit sinchaar be valid? I don't think so? ************* These are the basics, that all Jathebandiya, including Akal Thkhat, AKJ and Taksal agree upon, so I don't see any reason to adress these. ******* 4) Punj Pyaray ask for heads at the time of amrit sinchaar. Before the abhilaakhis can go inside to give head, they must wear full baana including all kakaars and dastaar. If they don't wear kakaars, can their head be accepted or will they even reach that point where their head will be asked? I don't think so. They must wear baana to enter amrit sinchaar mandal. If they don't wear dastaar, can their heads be accepted? No way. this daas is of the firm determination that Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj would never accept a head without the dastaar or without kakaars. It may be acceptable if the Gursikh wears the dastaar but does not consider it a kakaar but accepts it to part of mandatory baana like many Nihungs and Taksalis do but to offer your nanga head without a dastaar and just covered with a thin chunni, is not acceptable. ****** Again, not saying I personally disagree with you, but a lot of people do. And they ahve got all reason to do so, when our rehit-records aren't the most reliable, which means that yes as Akal Images Admin said - WE need to blend, Gurbani, Rehtinamey with Logic. That's what the panth did 70 years ago, but with the uprise of new jathebandiya stating that "our rehit is RIGHT, our rehit and maryada is THE ONE - the BOMB" What can Panth do? Should it comprimise with every jathebandi coming to please them? ***** 5) If Punj Pyaray just give you Naam but don't implant it inside you or don't teach you how to japp Naam, how would you japp it? Without method, how do you japp Naam? Where do you focus your dhyaan? So it's best if Punj Pyaray teach how to japp Naam. **** [gurbani]gur ibnu Goru AMDwru gurU ibnu smJ n AwvY ][/gurbani] Without the Guru, there is utter darkness; without the Guru, understanding does not come. Therefore, I should instead of listening what some Sant Jee, Baba Ji, Bhai Sahib has to say about Simran, method of Simran, it's value, etc, I shoudl turn straight to my Guru who has answers to all questions. Guru Ji says - [gurbani]rwm jpau jIA AYsy AYsy ] DR¨ pRihlwd jipE hir jYsy ]1][/gurbani] Just as Dhroo and Prahlaad meditated on the Lord, so should you meditate on the Lord, O my soul. ||1|| [gurbani]hy ijMdy ! (ieauN Ardws kr, ik) hy pRBU ! mYN qYƒ aus pRym qy SrDw nwl ismrW ijs pRym qy SrDw nwl DR¨ qy pRihlwd Bgq ny, hy hrI ! qYƒ ismirAw sI [1[ hy dInW au~qy dieAw krn vwly pRBU ! qyrI imhr dI Aws qy mYN Awpxw swrw prvwr qyry (nwm dy) jhwz qy cVHw id`qw hY (mYN jIB, A`K, kMn Awidk sB igAwn-ieMid®AW ƒ qyrI is&iq-swlwh ivc joV id`qw hY) [1[rhwau[ [/gurbani] ਰੋਮੇ ਰੋਮਿ ਰੋਮਿ ਰੋਮੇ ਮੈ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਰਾਮੁ ਧਿਆਏ ਰਾਮ ॥ romay rom rom romay mai gurmukh raam Dhi-aa-ay raam. With each and every hair, with each and every hair, as Gurmukh, I meditate on the Lord. Gurbani mentions this kind of Simran - Swas Swas Simran - remembering Guru Ji was every Swaas but also says [gurbani]rwm jpau jIA AYsy AYsy ] DR¨ pRihlwd jipE hir jYsy ]1][/gurbani] Just as Dhroo and Prahlaad meditated on the Lord, so should you meditate on the Lord, O my soul. ||1|| Not mentioning any other method than PREM. L- O - V - E ******* 6) Punj Pyaray should give amrit and not "Ikk Pyara". In all organizations I have heard of, Punj Pyaray prepare amrit but in most cases, one one pyara imparts amrit to seekers. This is not correct maryada. The whole purpose of receive amrit 5 times in your mouth, 5 times in your eyes and 5 times in your hair is to enable each one of the Punj Pyaray do so. I know in AKJ this maryada is still going on. Some other jathas may have it too and they are dhan if they are maintaining this maryada. But most of them have lost it. ****** I am ignorant on this maryada, and as such I do not know much about this. Could you please clearify how this changed, from Panj Pyaarey giving to one giving. Also are you supposing all those in the Panth 60-70 years ago simply "forgot" this and were themselves doing Sanchar wrong? Again I do not know much about this, and woudl apprecaite if you could post historical evidence where all Panj are showed to give Amrit, rather than the wasy it's being done now. As I said , it's simple to use the word maryada, but we've all got a different notion of what it is... Bhull Chukk maaf

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 25 Jan 2006

Mr lion King, I think you ask taksalis. I think you will surprised at the amount of taksalis who have come to jatha for Naam dhrirr. Some do it openly, others have done it secretly, but so many have come to AKJ for naam dhrirr ********** May'be due to "my Amrit" is better than you, kind of thing going.... What's youe point? HAve they "cnverted" to AKJ-ism? Does it make you happy that they are "like you" now?, I'm sure it makes you as happy when a Mslim becomes a Sikhs as when a Taksali goes for Naam Drirh.. ******* How can langar prepared by or served by a patit (a monna, or an adulturous or a tobacco eater) be acceptable to Khalsa of Guru Sahib? ******* Because if one has prem for Guru Ji, then that's all. I'm nto saying a tobacco eat shoudl be allowed, but for example with Mone.. THey to are Guru ji's children - if they are not encouraged, and showed the signifiance of Seva, the phaal of Seva- how will they love Kartaar? ***** Foolish and sometimes malicious are those people who blame Rehitvaan Singhs for refusing such food and for condemning such activities at Gurdwaras. ***** How much humility these "Rehitvaan Sikhs" have, calling others with differing opinion foolish and malicious - that is how a Guru ka Sikh should be - right? Ehna pyaar, that you would blatently call other Sikhs who have different opinions foolish and malicious. That's how much prem Pavna, Mohabbat, Devotion a Guru ka Sikh should have right? ********* To call such langar as "Guru ka Langar" is nothing short of blasphemy. ********* I see nothign wrong in calling a langar prepared with love, devotion, pyaar prem Guru ka Langar. Where's the love? Where the humility? blatently throwing out comments, throwing down those less into Sikhi than urself? Is that the prem we've got? We're on the track Guru Nanak patsha put us on. We're definetly on Prem-da-Marag.

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

akky · 26 Jan 2006

"Where's the love?" You tell me...

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 26 Jan 2006

------------ Which Maryada? Veer Ji, you say Maryada, but is there ONE maryada in the panth. WHen you say Maryada you imply the Maryada AKJ follows - the one majority of Panth doesn't. You say it's naive to say that, but think about it, AKj is a relatively new "jatha" with relatively "different" maryada from rest of panth - is rest of panth joined? No because we don't stand together under the one Akal Thakat and show faithfulness to the one Panth, instead we decide to classify ourselves as Taksali, AKj-er, Whatever. Point is, unless we can sit together and decide - this is maryada - it's useless to use the word. Panth did that a 60-70 years ago, but today new sampardava, new samajs, new groups begin to rise and say "our maryada is right" Untill we stand together and make a panthic decition no1 can say "full marayada", because when you say "full maryada", its how YOU interpret it. Unless we throw away titles and labels, and call ourselvse ONLY "GurukeSIkh" We're not getting anywhere. ----------------- Thanks for your thoughtful comments. I agree that there are several maryadas in Panth today but when I was referring to maryada, I meant the basic maryada e.g. presence of Laridaar saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, presence of tyaar bar tyaar Punj Pyare and giving amrit to abhilaakhis only if they wear the baana. Okay fine, if non-akj do not want to call Keski a Kakaar but at least they should wear a keski. We talk about equality of gender in Khalsa Panth. Why is it that women are not required to wear a Dastaar when taking amrit? We know that historically, many jathas including Sant Attar Singh Mastuana jee’s jatha had Dastaar mandatory for women living in Jatha. Same way bibis of Majha Khalsa diwan and Panch Khalsa Diwan Bhasaur used to wear Dastaar. To give amrit without requiring both genders to wear a dastaar is wrong. Where in maryada does it say that women are not required to wear a dastaar and what hukam says that only men should wear dastaar? Small differences can be ignored but big differences like Dastaar etc. cannot be ignored. Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 26 Jan 2006

Veer Lionking jeeo, --------------- gur ibnu Goru AMDwru gurU ibnu smJ n AwvY ] Without the Guru, there is utter darkness; without the Guru, understanding does not come. Therefore, I should instead of listening what some Sant Jee, Baba Ji, Bhai Sahib has to say about Simran, method of Simran, it's value, etc, I shoudl turn straight to my Guru who has answers to all questions. -------------- Punj Pyaray in the hazuri of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee are the most qualified entities to impart Naam and Naam Vidhi to seekers. I don’t understand how a sensible person can disagree with a simple notion that when Naam is given by Punj Pyaray they should also teach how to Japp Naam. What is wrong with this notion? Doesn’t it make sense? ------------- Guru Ji says - [gurbani] rwm jpau jIA AYsy AYsy ] DR¨ pRihlwd jipE hir jYsy ]1][/gurbani] Just as Dhroo and Prahlaad meditated on the Lord, so should you meditate on the Lord, O my soul. ||1|| [gurbani] hy ijMdy ! (ieauN Ardws kr, ik) hy pRBU ! mYN qYƒ aus pRym qy SrDw nwl ismrW ijs pRym qy SrDw nwl DR¨ qy pRihlwd Bgq ny, hy hrI ! qYƒ ismirAw sI [1[[/gurbani] -------- [gurbani] vIr ipAwry, ieh nw Bulo ik DRU jI ny vI nwm audoN jipAw sI jdoN auhnW nUM nwm dI bKiSS guru swihb vloN hoeI sI[ AwpoN koeI vI nwm nhIN jp skdw[ jp skdw hY qW gurpRswid hI jp skdw hY[ ijs qrW DRU jI Aqy Bgq pRihlwd jI ny scy pwqSwh jI dw nwm jipAw sI AwpW nUM vI gurU swihb dy snmuK ho ky, Awpxw isr gurW nUM Arpx krky, nwm dI pRwpqI krnI cwhIdI hY[ nwm dI pRwpqI qoN bwAd Aiq ibhblqw, byqwbI Aqy muh`bq sihq gurW dy bKSy hoey nwm rwhIN vwihgurU dI ArwDxw krnI cwhIdI hY[ nwm dI ivDI nwm dw Aqut ih`sw hY[ nwm dy nwl hI nwm dI ivDI vI dsxI cwhIxI hY[ [/gurbani] ------------------ ਰੋਮੇ ਰੋਮਿ ਰੋਮਿ ਰੋਮੇ ਮੈ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਰਾਮੁ ਧਿਆਏ ਰਾਮ ॥ romay rom rom romay mai gurmukh raam Dhi-aa-ay raam. With each and every hair, with each and every hair, as Gurmukh, I meditate on the Lord. Gurbani mentions this kind of Simran - Swas Swas Simran - remembering Guru Ji was every Swaas but also says --------------- [gurbani] roim roim jpx dI AvsQw vI qW hI AwvygI jdoN AwpW pUrI ivDI muqwbk nwm jpWgy[ qusIN Kud hI soco, jy AwpW nUM nwm jpnw hI nhIN AwauNdw qW ikvyN g`l bxygI[ qusIN shI PurmwieAw hY ik pRym dI loV hY pr pRym nwm jpx ivc shweI hox vwly swDnW ivcoN iek swDn hY[ bwkI dy swDn ijvyN ik gurW ny sRI jpu jI swihb dI AT`qIvIN (38) pauVI ivc Purmwn kIqw hY, j`q, DIrj, gurmiq vwlI miq, gurbwxI rUpI vyd ArQwq q`q igAwn, Bau, qp krnw Bwv ik prISRm Bwv ik muSkq krnI Awid vI krny zrUrI hn[ ie`klw pRym kuJ nhIN kr skdw jy pUrI jugiq nw hovy Aqy bwkI dy swDn nw hox[ AnykW hI s`cy pRym vwly SKs jW lok, rwDw suAwmIAW Aqy hor AwnmqIAW dy fyirAW qy ruldy iPrdy hn ikauNik auh ivcwry gurmiq jugiq qoN ivhUxy hn[ auh vI kI krn, auhnW dy Bwg hI DuroN mMdy hn[ KYr, AwpW Awpxy ivSy qy vwps AweIey[ roim roim nwm qd hI jp hovygw jykr AwpW guru swihb dI g`l mMnWgy[ roim roim koeI AwpoN nhINN jp skdw[ ieh qW iek au~cI AvsQw hY jo ik gurU swihb dI pUrI imhr qoN bwAd hI muX`sr huMdI hY[ [/gurbani] ------------ rwm jpau jIA AYsy AYsy ] DR¨ pRihlwd jipE hir jYsy ]1] Just as Dhroo and Prahlaad meditated on the Lord, so should you meditate on the Lord, O my soul. ||1|| Not mentioning any other method than PREM. L- O - V - E ------------ Prem is only one ingredient of the Naam Vidhi. You cannot ignore the other ingredients as mentioned above my Punjabi response. --------------- I am ignorant on this maryada, and as such I do not know much about this. Could you please clearify how this changed, from Panj Pyaarey giving to one giving. Also are you supposing all those in the Panth 60-70 years ago simply "forgot" this and were themselves doing Sanchar wrong? Again I do not know much about this, and woudl apprecaite if you could post historical evidence where all Panj are showed to give Amrit, rather than the wasy it's being done now. ------------- I myself have not done historical research on this. I remember one hukamnama of Siri Dasmesh jee saying that “Tusa Amrit Punja tau laina” (You should take amrit from Punj). If only one of the Punj Pyara imparts amrit, then how can we say that we received amrit from Punj? Amrit from Punj will come only if all Punj give it to you. This is the whole purpose of giving amrit 5 times in your mouth, five times in your eyes and five times in your hair. Each one of the Punj Pyaray must give amrit. Then only you can call it amrit from Punj. Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 26 Jan 2006

Lion king jeeo, --------------------------- ******* How can langar prepared by or served by a patit (a monna, or an adulturous or a tobacco eater) be acceptable to Khalsa of Guru Sahib? ******* ------------ Because if one has prem for Guru Ji, then that's all. ------------------------------- IF this person has prem, why is this person not listening to Guru Sahib and keeping his or her hair? The paimaana of Prem is not that once a week this person works in langar and then expects everyone to eat from his or her hands. If this person truly wants Gursikhs to chhak from his or her hands, then it is imperative that this person give his or her head to Guru Sahib and take amrit. To force and coax Gursikhs to break their maryada and eat from them, without first reforming themselves is an irresponsible thing to do. The measure of Prem is obedience to Guru Sahib. If one does not obey even the most basic hukams of Guru Sahib, such person cannot be a premi of Guru Sahib. Yes there are some ignorant but innocent persons. Such persons should be told about Guru Sahib’s maryada but if even after finding out the maryada, they still insist on doing those 4 kurehits, then it is safe to assume that such persons have no prem at all. ------------- I'm nto saying a tobacco eat shoudl be allowed, but for example with Mone.. THey to are Guru ji's children - if they are not encouraged, and showed the signifiance of Seva, the phaal of Seva- how will they love Kartaar? ----------------- They can be Guru jee’s children only if they chhak amrit. Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee and Mata Sahib Kaur are parents to only those individuals who chhak amrit. --------------- ***** Foolish and sometimes malicious are those people who blame Rehitvaan Singhs for refusing such food and for condemning such activities at Gurdwaras. ***** How much humility these "Rehitvaan Sikhs" have, calling others with differing opinion foolish and malicious - that is how a Guru ka Sikh should be - right? Ehna pyaar, that you would blatently call other Sikhs who have different opinions foolish and malicious. That's how much prem Pavna, Mohabbat, Devotion a Guru ka Sikh should have right? ------------------ I have thought about it and still maintain my opinion. The only correction is that I add “ignorant” to the above list. ----------- ********* To call such langar as "Guru ka Langar" is nothing short of blasphemy. ********* I see nothign wrong in calling a langar prepared with love, devotion, pyaar prem Guru ka Langar. ------------ What is this “Fokka Pyaar” (Empty Pyaar)? What is pyaar? How can someone claim to be doing pyaar to Guru Sahib and not offer his or her head to Guru Sahib? Love and devotion to Guru Sahib are exclusive territories of Gursikhs. Baaki sabh chaurasi daa maal hai. ------ Where's the love? -------- Prem is in keeping rehit. Guru Sahib has made it clear that without rehit no one is a Sikh. Rehit pyari mujh ko, Sikh pyara naahi. Without rehit no one can claim to be doing prem. ---------- Where the humility? -------- True humility lies in obeying hukams and not in “Momo-Thagnee” kind nimrata of bowing your head for no reason. Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

nanosecond · 26 Jan 2006

wot if the panj aint tyaar-bar tyaar? can someone be forced to do sewa in the panj if they think they aint ready? my 2 cents worth.. peace [%sig%]

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 26 Jan 2006

Bhai Kulbir SIngh jeo, ******* Thanks for your thoughtful comments. I agree that there are several maryadas in Panth today but when I was referring to maryada, I meant the basic maryada e.g. presence of Laridaar saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, presence of tyaar bar tyaar Punj Pyare and giving amrit to abhilaakhis only if they wear the baana. Okay fine, if non-akj do not want to call Keski a Kakaar but at least they should wear a keski. We talk about equality of gender in Khalsa Panth. Why is it that women are not required to wear a Dastaar when taking amrit? We know that historically, many jathas including Sant Attar Singh Mastuana jee’s jatha had Dastaar mandatory for women living in Jatha. Same way bibis of Majha Khalsa diwan and Panch Khalsa Diwan Bhasaur used to wear Dastaar. To give amrit without requiring both genders to wear a dastaar is wrong. Where in maryada does it say that women are not required to wear a dastaar and what hukam says that only men should wear dastaar? Small differences can be ignored but big differences like Dastaar etc. cannot be ignored. Kulbir Singh ******************** This is the first time I'm hear Mastuaney valey used to have keski as mandatory. Also are you refering to the same Bhauriye who were later on excommunicated from panth (forgive my ignorance if I'm wrong) ? ******** Veer Lionking jeeo, --------------- gur ibnu Goru AMDwru gurU ibnu smJ n AwvY ] Without the Guru, there is utter darkness; without the Guru, understanding does not come. Therefore, I should instead of listening what some Sant Jee, Baba Ji, Bhai Sahib has to say about Simran, method of Simran, it's value, etc, I shoudl turn straight to my Guru who has answers to all questions. -------------- Punj Pyaray in the hazuri of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee are the most qualified entities to impart Naam and Naam Vidhi to seekers. I don’t understand how a sensible person can disagree with a simple notion that when Naam is given by Punj Pyaray they should also teach how to Japp Naam. What is wrong with this notion? Doesn’t it make sense? ********* Because the notion of giving Naam in the AKJ-method is alien to the rest of panth. IMHO, Naam is inside you. Naam is waiting to be taken. The Batta of Naam is within you and it's through innocent love that one obtains this naam. I have yet to read anywhere in Gurbani where the AKJ-method of is encouraged. [gurbani] vIr ipAwry, ieh nw Bulo ik DRU jI ny vI nwm audoN jipAw sI jdoN auhnW nUM nwm dI bKiSS guru swihb vloN hoeI sI[ AwpoN koeI vI nwm nhIN jp skdw[ jp skdw hY qW gurpRswid hI jp skdw hY[ ijs qrW DRU jI Aqy Bgq pRihlwd jI ny scy pwqSwh jI dw nwm jipAw sI AwpW nUM vI gurU swihb dy snmuK ho ky, Awpxw isr gurW nUM Arpx krky, nwm dI pRwpqI krnI cwhIdI hY[ nwm dI pRwpqI qoN bwAd Aiq ibhblqw, byqwbI Aqy muh`bq sihq gurW dy bKSy hoey nwm rwhIN vwihgurU dI ArwDxw krnI cwhIdI hY[ nwm dI ivDI nwm dw Aqut ih`sw hY[ nwm dy nwl hI nwm dI ivDI vI dsxI cwhIxI hY[ [/gurbani] Gurmukh Pyareyo, although I agree with msot of the above, I disagree with you that a "vidhi" or technique other than prem is required. For me, the most important thing is the Prem Guru Gobind SIngh ji stresses in his Swaiye Sahib.. [gurbani] roim roim jpx dI AvsQw vI qW hI AwvygI jdoN AwpW pUrI ivDI muqwbk nwm jpWgy[ qusIN Kud hI soco, jy AwpW nUM nwm jpnw hI nhIN AwauNdw qW ikvyN g`l bxygI[[/gurbani] You mentioned that Dhru jee did Bhagti through Gurparsad - I agree - but did anyone give him a "101 course in the Naam Bhagti Technique", or was is pyaar that was the fuel? [gurbani]qusIN shI PurmwieAw hY ik pRym dI loV hY pr pRym nwm jpx ivc shweI hox vwly swDnW ivcoN iek swDn hY[ bwkI dy swDn ijvyN ik gurW ny sRI jpu jI swihb dI AT`qIvIN (38) pauVI ivc Purmwn kIqw hY, j`q, DIrj, gurmiq vwlI miq, gurbwxI rUpI vyd ArQwq q`q igAwn, Bau, qp krnw Bwv ik prISRm Bwv ik muSkq krnI Awid vI krny zrUrI hn[ ie`klw pRym kuJ nhIN kr skdw jy pUrI jugiq nw hovy Aqy bwkI dy swDn nw hox[ AnykW hI s`cy pRym vwly SKs jW lok, rwDw suAwmIAW Aqy hor AwnmqIAW dy fyirAW qy ruldy iPrdy hn ikauNik auh ivcwry gurmiq jugiq qoN ivhUxy hn[ auh vI kI krn, auhnW dy Bwg hI DuroN mMdy hn[ KYr, AwpW Awpxy ivSy qy vwps AweIey[ roim roim nwm qd hI jp hovygw jykr AwpW guru swihb dI g`l mMnWgy[ roim roim koeI AwpoN nhINN jp skdw[ ieh qW iek au~cI AvsQw hY jo ik gurU swihb dI pUrI imhr qoN bwAd hI muX`sr huMdI hY[ ------------ [gurbani]rwm jpau jIA AYsy AYsy ] DR¨ pRihlwd jipE hir jYsy ]1][/gurbani] Just as Dhroo and Prahlaad meditated on the Lord, so should you meditate on the Lord, O my soul. ||1|| Not mentioning any other method than PREM. L- O - V - E ------------ Prem is only one ingredient of the Naam Vidhi. You cannot ignore the other ingredients as mentioned above my Punjabi response. [/gurbani] This is where our view conflict. Whereas Daas believes the Vidhi to be prem, you believe in a physical technique. Whereas I believe that when Gurdev Pita ji said Japo naam liek Dharu and Prehlad, I interpret it as jap naam with prem. It seems I'm not alone with this understanding - Prof Sahib SIngh - [gurbani]hy ijMdy ! (ieauN Ardws kr, ik) hy pRBU ! mYN qYƒ aus pRym qy SrDw nwl ismrW ijs pRym qy SrDw nwl DR¨ qy pRihlwd Bgq ny, hy hrI ! qYƒ ismirAw sI [1[[/gurbani] Freedkot Tika - ਭਾਈ ਰਾਮ ਕੋ (ਜੀਅ) ਰਿਦੇ ਮੈਂ ਐਸੇ ਐਸੇ ਪ੍ਰਕਾਰ ਜਪੋ ਜੈਸੇ ਹਰੀ ਕੋ ਧ੍ਰੂ ਅਰ ਪ੍ਰਹਿਲਾਦਿ ਨੇ ਜਪਿਆ ਹੈ ਭਾਵ ਯੇਹਿ ਕਿ ਪ੍ਰੀਤੀ ਪੂਰਬਕ ਜਪੇ॥ ਐਸੇ ਬੇਨਤੀ ਕਰੇ॥ http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=337&g=1&h=1&r=1&t=0&p=0&k=2 **** I myself have not done historical research on this. I remember one hukamnama of Siri Dasmesh jee saying that “Tusa Amrit Punja tau laina” (You should take amrit from Punj). **** Where can i find this hukamnama? Please do not say it's in the notorious G G Singhs, Bhangu's or Kavi Santokh Singh's work.. Please.. ** If only one of the Punj Pyara imparts amrit, then how can we say that we received amrit from Punj? Amrit from Punj will come only if all Punj give it to you. This is the whole purpose of giving amrit 5 times in your mouth, five times in your eyes and five times in your hair. Each one of the Punj Pyaray must give amrit. Then only you can call it amrit from Punj. ** Just because the postman is the one who gives you the letter doesn't mean you didn't recieve the letter from you chacha jee, or whoever sent it. The Amrit is prepared by Panj. That is all I know, and again I cannot comment before I read an actual historical account that this happened in the past. It seems to me, unlikely, that the whole panth would suddenly start changing the way or blessing the Sikh with Amrit.. and if so - how did this major change occur? I understand the people started not reading laridhar due to it being simler to read Padh ched (I do not agre with them), but i see no reason at all why this maryada woudl wanted to be changed if it ever historically existed. Let me ask you - would I be wrong to say that the only reason you encourage this maryada is because Bhai Randhir Singh encouraged it? Would that statement be false- you yourself said that you were not knowledgable about this issue (which is the exact same thing with me), so what makes you think that the whole apnth would suddenly change and only one man would be correct about this. Please tell me I'm wrong that your opinion is not based on merely Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's words.... Daas will try to respond to other post when he has more time... If I have offended you or anybody, please forgive me as I am your chota veer. Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Roopkaur · 26 Jan 2006

>It seems to me, unlikely, that the whole panth would suddenly start changing the way or blessing the Sikh with Amrit.. and if so - how did this major change occur?< I do not know how this major change occured, but your former comment seems very naive to me, since we all know how much the Sikhs in general have lost of their rehit due to the various attacks on our culture and history. Originally all five panj were required to together give amrit to the abhilakhee, that is why guru ji gave the five singhs as a whole the authority of guruship, not the individual. If the amrit should be prepared by all five, then why should it not be adminstered by all five as well. If the postman does not matter, than anyone from the sangat would have been able to give amrit, as long as it was prepared by the panj, but this is not the case. >>>would I be wrong to say that the only reason you encourage this maryada is because Bhai Randhir Singh encouraged it? Would that statement be false- you yourself said that you were not knowledgable about this issue (which is the exact same thing with me), so what makes you think that the whole apnth would suddenly change and only one man would be correct about this. Please tell me I'm wrong that your opinion is not based on merely Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's words....<<< Although Bhai Sahib was active in raising awareness of this dhill, it is ignorant to say he was the only individual who believed in this. Since when has it been the policy of the Sikh to blindly follow what the majority are following? Guru ji has instructed his Sikhs to do the exact opposite and do vichaar of what seems right. Guru ji created shers, not bakreeaa (sheep). I am sure the reason for holding this beleif is not because Bhai Sahib said it, but because when the information was read, it seemed right.

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 27 Jan 2006

******** >It seems to me, unlikely, that the whole panth would suddenly start changing the way or blessing the Sikh with Amrit.. and if so - how did this major change occur?< I do not know how this major change occured, but your former comment seems very naive to me, since we all know how much the Sikhs in general have lost of their rehit due to the various attacks on our culture and history. Originally all five panj were required to together give amrit to the abhilakhee, that is why guru ji gave the five singhs as a whole the authority of guruship, not the individual. If the amrit should be prepared by all five, then why should it not be adminstered by all five as well. If the postman does not matter, than anyone from the sangat would have been able to give amrit, as long as it was prepared by the panj, but this is not the case. ********** What where is the historical evidence that it has always been the way you're saying. I'm not saying I know it all, or that the way the rest of the Panth is doing logical - I'm asking for historical evidence that that's the way it was done - is there any that you can prove to me with that yes this is how it was done - look this Bhai Sahib's Rehitnama says this - so this is how it should be done or are you basing your argument solely on the founder of AKJ ? ****** >>>would I be wrong to say that the only reason you encourage this maryada is because Bhai Randhir Singh encouraged it? Would that statement be false- you yourself said that you were not knowledgable about this issue (which is the exact same thing with me), so what makes you think that the whole apnth would suddenly change and only one man would be correct about this. Please tell me I'm wrong that your opinion is not based on merely Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's words....<<< Although Bhai Sahib was active in raising awareness of this dhill, it is ignorant to say he was the only individual who believed in this. Since when has it been the policy of the Sikh to blindly follow what the majority are following? Guru ji has instructed his Sikhs to do the exact opposite and do vichaar of what seems right. Guru ji created shers, not bakreeaa (sheep). I am sure the reason for holding this beleif is not because Bhai Sahib said it, but because when the information was read, it seemed right. ******* Since when has it been the policy of the Sikh to blindly follow what one single Singh says? You mention he was not the only one - who more has done it.. Please mention other respected Gursikhs in history who have mentioned this "dhill". Also , please answer my question in a straight yes or no - would you personally encourage this rehit if Bhai Randhir Singh was AGAINST IT - and i.e Bhai Vir Singh, Giani Gurdit Singh and other panthic historical Sikhs had encouraged it (let's say the situation was opposite to how it is today -that is opposite that the Jatha encourages it, rest of panth do it in another way....) Let's say all other Sikhs said its THE WAY to give Amrit (i.e Panj giving it), but Bhai Randhir Singh said - no! historically one person gives it - who would you agree with the rest of panth or with Bhai Randhir Singh? I'm simply asking a yes or no. This itself will tell me a lot, of how much "logic" and "make sense" will have to do with your opinion. IF Bhai Randhir Singh said it was wrong for five to give it but one shoudl give it, and Panth said five shoudl give it not one - what would your opinion be??? This will tell me if you Tapoban Singhnees/Singhs are Guru Granth/Guru Panth de Sikh or not... I agree with what you're saying, that it seems logical that would be the way (five giving it), but unless you can prove any historical evidence except Bhai Sahib said so, there is no reason why I should believe that, the way as preached by Bhai Sahib is the way originally done. If there's any Rehitname or historical evidence then please provide it. Bhull chukk maaf

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 27 Jan 2006

Lionking jeeo, ------------ What where is the historical evidence that it has always been the way you're saying. I'm not saying I know it all, or that the way the rest of the Panth is doing logical - I'm asking for historical evidence that that's the way it was done - is there any that you can prove to me with that yes this is how it was done - look this Bhai Sahib's Rehitnama says this - so this is how it should be done or are you basing your argument solely on the founder of AKJ ? ------------- You seem to be very bitter towards Akhand Kirtani Jatha. “tussa Amrit panja tau laina” is written in one of the hukamnama’s of Guru Sahib. Otherwise too, if you use a little bit of common sense, you can easily come to the conclusion that since five prepared amrit, then five should impart it too. Why else is amrit administered five times to abhilaakhis? Use little bit of common sense here. As for historical proof, show me the historical proof that only one person should impart amrit to abhilaakhis. Don’t give me the argument that majority of Panth does it. Gurmat does not recognize the majority. If the whole world is saying one thing and if one Singh is saying the correct thing and the Singh’s saying happens to be correct, then Guru Sahib will be on that Singh’s side. ------------- Also , please answer my question in a straight yes or no - would you personally encourage this rehit if Bhai Randhir Singh was AGAINST IT ----------- We must follow Gurmat and not Manmatt. If there had been manmatt advocated by Bhai Sahib, we would not have listened to it. Bhai Sahib advocated Keski as kakaar but he could not have done it unilaterally. It was a joint decision of Singhs of that time. Bhai Sahib could have never acted alone like the pakhandi Saadhs do. Bhai Sahib always acted according to the Gurmatta of Khalsa. Following the tradition of Khalsa, Singhs in AKJ too make a decision in form of a Gurmatta i.e. all Gursikhs sit together and decide on an issue. Singhs from India and other countries are consulted while arriving at a decision. You are wrong in your allegation that AKJ follows Bhai Sahib blindly. Bhai Sahib never made a decision on his own. It was always a Gurmatta of Singhs. ------------- Let's say all other Sikhs said its THE WAY to give Amrit (i.e Panj giving it), but Bhai Randhir Singh said - no! historically one person gives it - who would you agree with the rest of panth or with Bhai Randhir Singh? I'm simply asking a yes or no. ------------ If it had been the other way, i.e. Bhai Sahib had advocated that only one person should give amrit and if all proofs pointed to the other way, we would have chosen the right way and not follow Bhai Sahib blindly. This is the stand of all AKJ Singhs. AKJ is not a naqli Sant organization that it would follow anyone blindly. Decisions in Jatha are taken in form of Gurmatta and one person’s dictatorship does not happen in Jatha. Having said that, it’s true that the opinion of Bhai Sahib and other Singhs of his time hold a very high value. Bhai Sahib’s jeevan is an inspiration to all of us. Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 27 Jan 2006

If that is truely how it is, then I was wrong. My theory was indeed that AKj follows Bhai Sahib blindly - if you say AKJ doesn't, then I was wrong and I apologize for assuming so. But on the other hand - does AKj have any stand which Bhai Sahib didn't make black/white. I.e. Bhai Sahib didn't say this is the Rehras I believe in, he didn't state any view about Dasam Granth - what is AKJ view on these subjects or does AKJ only have views on issues Bhai Sahib made clear? ********** ------------ What where is the historical evidence that it has always been the way you're saying. I'm not saying I know it all, or that the way the rest of the Panth is doing logical - I'm asking for historical evidence that that's the way it was done - is there any that you can prove to me with that yes this is how it was done - look this Bhai Sahib's Rehitnama says this - so this is how it should be done or are you basing your argument solely on the founder of AKJ ? ------------- You seem to be very bitter towards Akhand Kirtani Jatha. “tussa Amrit panja tau laina” is written in one of the hukamnama’s of Guru Sahib. Otherwise too, if you use a little bit of common sense, you can easily come to the conclusion that since five prepared amrit, then five should impart it too. Why else is amrit administered five times to abhilaakhis? Use little bit of common sense here. ********* I am not bitter of any Jatha, samparda, or dera. I do oppose anything that might seem suspicious to me, whether that's narials with read clothes (which some jathebandis do acknowledge) or whether it's having fires - i oppose everything that seems to be manmat. If it makes any difference i used to go to AKJ smagams, when i lived at a plcae where these used to occur regularily. ***** As for historical proof, show me the historical proof that only one person should impart amrit to abhilaakhis. Don’t give me the argument that majority of Panth does it. Gurmat does not recognize the majority. If the whole world is saying one thing and if one Singh is saying the correct thing and the Singh’s saying happens to be correct, then Guru Sahib will be on that Singh’s side. ***** If Gurmat does not recognize majority how dow Sarbat khalsa work? As for proof, that I cannot give you but what I can give you is a common trend. A common trend seen in most old jathebandi's is that it is done in the way Akal Thakhat deos it. That itself is enough evidence to INDICATE (not prove) that, that is the way they used to do it. AKJ happily relates it's rehit's to Niahngs, Taksals etc whenever it fits them best, but when it's own arguments do nto agree with the other they don't care to mention these jathebandis (either they are authorities that can be related to- or they're not, not half half).. why does AKJ not look at what most puratan jathebandis do in this case? AKJ justified a lot of rehits such as Sarbloh Bibek with Nihangs, - so how do Nihangs give Amrit (if I'm not mistaken) they too give it the way Akal Thakhat does. Bhull chukk maaf

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Harcharan Singh · 27 Jan 2006

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh, Veer Kulbir Ji, You have mentioned common sense many times in this discussion. The following could also be construed as common sense: Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj 1st gave amrit to Bhai Daya Ram, Guru Ji would have administered the amrit 5 times and Bhai Daya Ram would have therefore recieved amrit 5 times, with Guru Kirpa becoming Bhai Daya Singh. This means that a Sikh receives amrit 5 times, agreed? Therefore, if the Panj Pyare are the embodiment of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, then when administering amrit, they as a collective, should only give amrit 5 times, yes? But, if each pyara is giving amrit 5 times, the person being initiated receives amrit 25 times, not 5 times as Bhai Daya Singh Ji received it. To me the following quoted line could mean 2 things aside from how you have interpreted it: “tussa Amrit panja tau laina” 1 - Amrit needs to be prepared by 5 pyare 2 - Amrit needs to be given by panj pyare Either way, in staying consistent With Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj, the recipient should only receive amrit 5 times. A way to ensure this could be for each pyara to give amrit once, hence in total 5 administrations. By each pyara giving amrit 5 times, they are as individuals representing Guru Gobind Singh Ji, by each Pyara giving amrit once, they would as a collective be representing Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Just my thoughts, bhullan chukaan maaf karnian. Sat Sri Akaal Harcharan Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 27 Jan 2006

Lionking jeeo, -------- If that is truely how it is, then I was wrong. My theory was indeed that AKj follows Bhai Sahib blindly - if you say AKJ doesn't, then I was wrong and I apologize for assuming so. ---------- Yes, ask Jatha Singhs around the world and you will realize that the decisions in Jatha are not taken by a dictator. Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara has done translations of many baanis and at several instances his translations are quite different from Bhai Sahib’s. There has been no hue and cry over this. Imagine, a prominent derawaadi Singh overturning the translations of their sant jee maharaja. -------------- But on the other hand - does AKj have any stand which Bhai Sahib didn't make black/white. I.e. Bhai Sahib didn't say this is the Rehras I believe in, he didn't state any view about Dasam Granth - what is AKJ view on these subjects or does AKJ only have views on issues Bhai Sahib made clear? ----------- I personally recite the Rehraas prescribed by SGPC. As for Dasam Granth, I have seen both extremes in Jatha. Some singhs reject many baanis of Dasam Granth and others accept all of them. This is an individual decision. I personally believe that there are two kind of compositions in Dasam Granth – Guru Sahib’s own Ilaahi Baani and translations of various books of that time e.g. Chandi kee Vaar seems to be a translation of Markanday Puraan, Chaubees Avtaar seems to be a translation of Siri Madd Bhagwat Puraan. Perhaps this was done to make Sikhs cognisant of other religions. In any case, it’s not a good idea to discuss Dasam Granth. -------- If Gurmat does not recognize majority how dow Sarbat khalsa work? ----------- Sarbat Khalsa has not happened for more than 200 years and I am not sure, how it can be done now. Last time it happened, before the Raj of Raja Ranjit Singh, all Singhs had pretty much the same maryada. Today there are many differences between different jathebandis. I don’t know how Sarbat Khalsa can occur today. --------------- That itself is enough evidence to INDICATE (not prove) that, that is the way they used to do it. AKJ happily relates it's rehit's to Niahngs, Taksals etc whenever it fits them best, but when it's own arguments do nto agree with the other they don't care to mention these jathebandis (either they are authorities that can be related to- or they're not, not half half).. why does AKJ not look at what most puratan jathebandis do in this case? AKJ justified a lot of rehits such as Sarbloh Bibek with Nihangs, - so how do Nihangs give Amrit (if I'm not mistaken) they too give it the way Akal Thakhat does. ---------------- These are futile arguments. AKJ is lot closer to SGPC maryada than most other organizations are. Those organizations can’t even agree on the most basic concepts like Mool Mantr and Rehraas Sahib paath. You are making vain efforts to alienate Jatha. The main difference lies in Keski rehit and Kutha rehit. Sarbloh and Bibek rehits are only on top of the existing SGPC maryada. Even if we assume for a moment that Sarbloh is not a rehit, the presence of few Sarblohis in Panth are not going to do any damage to it. The damage is going to come from Sant Deras and other dhillee (weak in rehit) organizations. History stands witness to the fact that the Jatha has never shied away from pouring blood in the foundations of Panth to make it stronger. Worry about the Sant Deras who are good for nothing. Get off the back of Jatha. Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

G Singh · 27 Jan 2006

Kulbir Singh Jee, in response to your argument that that how will a sikh know how to jap naam if he is not told to jap naam by panj pyarey, can you please respond to the tuk with space left around it [GURBANI] soriT mhlw 5 ] koit bRhmMf ko Twkuru suAwmI srb jIAw kw dwqw ry ] pRiqpwlY inq swir smwlY ieku gunu nhI mUriK jwqw ry ]1] hir AwrwiD n jwnw ry ] hir hir guru guru krqw ry ] hir jIau nwmu pirE rwmdwsu ] rhwau ] dIn dieAwl ik®pwl suK swgr srb Gtw BrpUrI ry ] pyKq sunq sdw hY sMgy mY mUrK jwinAw dUrI ry ]2] hir ibAMqu hau imiq kir vrnau ikAw jwnw hoie kYso ry ] krau bynqI siqgur Apuny mY mUrK dyhu aupdyso ry ]3] mY mUrK kI kyqk bwq hY koit prwDI qirAw ry ] guru nwnku ijn suixAw pyiKAw sy iPir grBwis n pirAw ry ]4]2]13] [/GURBANI]

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

G Singh · 27 Jan 2006

sorry, i forgot to leave the space between the tuk [gurbani] soriT mhlw 5 ] koit bRhmMf ko Twkuru suAwmI srb jIAw kw dwqw ry ] pRiqpwlY inq swir smwlY ieku gunu nhI mUriK jwqw ry ]1] hir AwrwiD n jwnw ry ] hir hir guru guru krqw ry ] hir jIau nwmu pirE rwmdwsu ] rhwau ] dIn dieAwl ik®pwl suK swgr srb Gtw BrpUrI ry ] pyKq sunq sdw hY sMgy mY mUrK jwinAw dUrI ry ]2] hir ibAMqu hau imiq kir vrnau ikAw jwnw hoie kYso ry ] krau bynqI siqgur Apuny mY mUrK dyhu aupdyso ry ]3] mY mUrK kI kyqk bwq hY koit prwDI qirAw ry ] guru nwnku ijn suixAw pyiKAw sy iPir grBwis n pirAw ry ]4]2]13] [\gurbani]

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

singh · 27 Jan 2006

ha ha ha ha! bhai kulbir singh ji...just an observation, but the last thing you said sounded pretty defensive...and sounded like you didnt want to answer the question. from what i have observed, there is so much ambiguity in the "jatha" it is of no consiquence what you (as an individual) say the jatha's views are (except keski-that is pretty universal, but the meat thing...i have seen otherwise). no individual can represent a group and express the views of the whole organization - at least i have not seen it happen in my lifetime good try though...the thing about bhai randhir singh not being the end-all be-all authority is good too (comparing gurbani translations with talwara ji's). but you missed one thing: every time a jatha singh/singhni wants to prove a point they invoke bhai sahibs name...as if he were (dare i say it) a "sant." i mean look at this very forum...just do a simple search on his name and you will probably find that it is being invoked to prove a point (a lot of times). anyhow...may guru sahib give the khalsa panth nimrata and ekta so we can get over ourselves and focus on HIM. waheguru ji ka khalsa!!!!! waheguru ji ki fateh!!!!!

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006

-------- If that is truely how it is, then I was wrong. My theory was indeed that AKj follows Bhai Sahib blindly - if you say AKJ doesn't, then I was wrong and I apologize for assuming so. ---------- Yes, ask Jatha Singhs around the world and you will realize that the decisions in Jatha are not taken by a dictator. Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara has done translations of many baanis and at several instances his translations are quite different from Bhai Sahib’s. There has been no hue and cry over this. Imagine, a prominent derawaadi Singh overturning the translations of their sant jee maharaja. *********** I've personally seen a few Taksalis - hard-core taksalis say they disagree with certain parts of the Taksali Rehit. They believe that 99% of the Taksali Rehit is right, but ther is stilla percentage that is wrong, and they are able to acknowledge this. I have yet to see any Jatha Singh disagree with anything Bhai Randhir Singh said (i.e thing's he's made black and white) ***** But on the other hand - does AKj have any stand which Bhai Sahib didn't make black/white. I.e. Bhai Sahib didn't say this is the Rehras I believe in, he didn't state any view about Dasam Granth - what is AKJ view on these subjects or does AKJ only have views on issues Bhai Sahib made clear? ****** I personally recite the Rehraas prescribed by SGPC. As for Dasam Granth, I have seen both extremes in Jatha. Some singhs reject many baanis of Dasam Granth and others accept all of them. This is an individual decision. I personally believe that there are two kind of compositions in Dasam Granth – Guru Sahib’s own Ilaahi Baani and translations of various books of that time e.g. Chandi kee Vaar seems to be a translation of Markanday Puraan, Chaubees Avtaar seems to be a translation of Siri Madd Bhagwat Puraan. Perhaps this was done to make Sikhs cognisant of other religions. In any case, it’s not a good idea to discuss Dasam Granth. ******* I assume you meant prescribed by Akal Thakhat... The fact that you have seen both extremes in the Jatha about Dasam Granth is exactly what I men. AKJ does NOT have an official stance on points Bhai Randhir Singh didn't make clear. THat is why I in my other post said that I do not se anything with calling it Randhir Singh da Jatha (where my post wasn't allowed through) simply because AKJ's official stance is whatever Randhir Singh made black and white. Randhir Singh made following things clear - Raagmala kakkar kurehit (all of these are clear AKJ stances) He did not mention Rehras Sahib (what version) Dasam Granth (how much of it is Bani) Sarbloh Granth (is it bani of fiction of a Sukha Singh) I'm not here to discuss whether Dasam Granth is Bani, all I'm trying to say is that all points Randhir Singh had a view on, AKJ has as an official stance. All things he did not make clear there are still conflicting views about those in the Jatha, and therefore in my opinion AKJ follows everything Randhir Singh made black and white... ******* -------- If Gurmat does not recognize majority how dow Sarbat khalsa work? ----------- Sarbat Khalsa has not happened for more than 200 years and I am not sure, how it can be done now. Last time it happened, before the Raj of Raja Ranjit Singh, all Singhs had pretty much the same maryada. Today there are many differences between different jathebandis. I don’t know how Sarbat Khalsa can occur today. ******** 1986 there was a Sarbat Khalsa about Khalistan, I doubt it would be decleared if 90% of Panth was against it and 10% was for it... [to be honest I'm not sure how it works, but i believe that too works on majority] ********** --------------- That itself is enough evidence to INDICATE (not prove) that, that is the way they used to do it. AKJ happily relates it's rehit's to Niahngs, Taksals etc whenever it fits them best, but when it's own arguments do nto agree with the other they don't care to mention these jathebandis (either they are authorities that can be related to- or they're not, not half half).. why does AKJ not look at what most puratan jathebandis do in this case? AKJ justified a lot of rehits such as Sarbloh Bibek with Nihangs, - so how do Nihangs give Amrit (if I'm not mistaken) they too give it the way Akal Thakhat does. ---------------- These are futile arguments. AKJ is lot closer to SGPC maryada than most other organizations are. Those organizations can’t even agree on the most basic concepts like Mool Mantr and Rehraas Sahib paath. You are making vain efforts to alienate Jatha. The main difference lies in Keski rehit and Kutha rehit. Sarbloh and Bibek rehits are only on top of the existing SGPC maryada. Even if we assume for a moment that Sarbloh is not a rehit, the presence of few Sarblohis in Panth are not going to do any damage to it. The damage is going to come from Sant Deras and other dhillee (weak in rehit) organizations. History stands witness to the fact that the Jatha has never shied away from pouring blood in the foundations of Panth to make it stronger. Worry about the Sant Deras who are good for nothing. Get off the back of Jatha. *************** Veer JI, I do acknowledge a lot of things the jtha does [although it might not seem so in my posts].. For example, I'm really happy AKJ emhisizes - - Pure Kirtan without dharna (but unfportunatly AKJ has lost the puratan way of doing Kirtan - in raag, and has instead started doing Vaheguru in between, which Akal Thakhat says is to allowed) - Pyaar amongst AKJ Gurmukhs (although they've left out mone, but the pyar amongst Gurmukhs is minfblowing - but unfortunatly the pyaare for those who are not that forunate that they havn't been able to get into Sikhi properly - Larridhar saroop (I would not even know it used to be that way if I hadn't visisted AKJ forums) - Bana But I will resist anything that too me sounds manmat whether that makes someone feel nervous and insecure about themselves, whether that's part of AKJ or taksal, I do not care. I feel that some have coconuts and red clothes - I will talk against if. If I see that someones following someone to the max, yet calling others blind folowers, I will take resistance, but I do acknowledge their good things as well. Unfortunatly Jatha Singhs at the same time try to say they are closer to Akal Thakhat Rehit, yet they cannt accept thta someone might disagree with them. They cannot accept that hey - if someon believes meat is okay then so be it - no! Jatha SInghs will start saying they are not Sikhs, they will say that Amrit SAnchars where kuttha is condemned is not a real Amrit Sancahr (whicch means Amrit at Akal Thakhat, or anywhere for that matter where kuttha is condemned - is not valid - how much pyaar is that).. Unfortunatly we have gotten into labeling ourselves, and unless we stop grouping ourselves we're not going to get Ekta. I do acknowledge that AKJ has spilled blood for Panth, I do have massive respect for Gurmukhs such as Bhai Fauja Singh Ji, Bhai Sukhdev SIngh Babbar, Bhai Anokh SIngh Babbar, Bhai Lashman Singh Babbar BHai Kulwant SIngh (aka Mengha Singh) babbar etc. but where i see something is wrong I will take resistance Perhaps we should get back to the thread topic?? bhull chukk maaf

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

BirRaas Singh · 28 Jan 2006

History stands witness to the fact that the Jatha has never shied away from pouring blood in the foundations of Panth to make it stronger. ******************************************************* VAH JI VAH!!! The eternal Panth of Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj needs BLOOD to be revived, what kind of sick thinking is this? Is the power of Naam not enough? Nor the Ardas of a Rehitvaan Sikh? Nor the Paat of Guru Granth Sahib? If the Jatha has never shied away from making the panth stronger by spilling blood, why does everyone always say "Sikhi is under attack, Sikhi is dying?" Have these lives been lost in vain?? How much blood to you intend to spill before there is a utopian Sikh society?

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Singh · 28 Jan 2006

Lionking I wouldn't say Bhai Randhir Singh made Raagmala that clear as only in one book he mentions the Bhog of Akhand Paath at Mundavani. Furthermore he has quoted extensively from Dasam Granth (even 404 Chariters so I have heard) yet many people still do not believe Dasam Granth in AKJ. In addition to this the vast majority of people in AKJ do not follow Sarbloh Bibek. And there are a portion who do not at all agree with it.

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jan 2006

G. Singh jeeo, ----------- Kulbir Singh Jee, in response to your argument that that how will a sikh know how to jap naam if he is not told to jap naam by panj pyarey, can you please respond to the tuk with space left around it ------------- Aradhana means to worship. Aanmatees (followers of other religions) have many complex ways of doing Aradhana of whom they worship. Siri Guru jee in these two pankitis declare that he does not know the complex ways of doing Aradhana. All he knows is to do “Har Har Gur Gur”. This pankiti does not mean that you just do “Har Har Gur Gur” without the proper vidhi. Guru Sahib is clearly saying the he does not know Aradhana. All he knows is to Japp Naam. Siri Guru jee is not saying that he does not know how to japp Naam nor is he saying that Swaas Swaas Naam should not be done. Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee himself has written in the first stanza of the 24th Ashtpadi of Siri Sukhmani Sahib that by doing Swaas Swaas simran, all worries go away. Nice try! Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jan 2006

Lion King jeeo, ------------ I've personally seen a few Taksalis - hard-core taksalis say they disagree with certain parts of the Taksali Rehit. They believe that 99% of the Taksali Rehit is right, but ther is still a percentage that is wrong, and they are able to acknowledge this. I have yet to see any Jatha Singh disagree with anything Bhai Randhir Singh said (i.e thing's he's made black and white) ------------ I have given you the name of a prominent Jatha Singh – Bhai Joginder Singh jee Talwara who did numerous translations different from Bhai Sahib. Can you give me one instance of a topnotch leader of other organizations who went against their Sant and was not disgraced for doing so? ----------- I assume you meant prescribed by Akal Thakhat... ----------- I meant SGPC. ----------- The fact that you have seen both extremes in the Jatha about Dasam Granth is exactly what I men. AKJ does NOT have an official stance on points Bhai Randhir Singh didn't make clear. THat is why I in my other post said that I do not se anything with calling it Randhir Singh da Jatha (where my post wasn't allowed through) simply because AKJ's official stance is whatever Randhir Singh made black and white. ----------- As far as I know, Bhai Sahib has never uttered a word against Dasam Granth and quoted extensively from all major baanis of Dasam Granth. Still, you have many Jatha Singhs who don’t consider baanis like Bachitter Natak as baani. This proof should be good enough. Same way, you will find many Jatha Singhs reading Ragmala. ----------- Randhir Singh made following things clear - Raagmala kakkar kurehit (all of these are clear AKJ stances) -------------- There have been Gurmattas about these rehits in Jatha. As I stated before, Jatha does not follow anyone, including Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, blindly. Jatha believes in only one authority and that is Guru Sahib. As I wrote before, it’s true that Bhai Sahib’s opinion holds a great value in Jatha but Bhai Sahib is considered to be a Gursikh and not some Sant as in the case of naqli sant deras. Bhai Sahib himself lived as a Sikh all his life. Guru Sahib blessed Bhai Sahib with a wonderful spiritual jeevan and I find nothing wrong in taking lead from Bhai Sahib but no one thinks of Bhai Sahib as perfect. By the same token, I don’t think holding high value for Bhai Sahib’s opinion goes against Gurmat. Don't we hold high regard for Bhai Gurdas jee, Bhai Mani Singh, Bhai Nandlal jee's opinions? You can try as much as you want but you will never be able to prove that Jatha believes in santvaad. Jatha believes in the supremacy of Khalsa and not of one person. -------- I'm not here to discuss whether Dasam Granth is Bani, all I'm trying to say is that all points Randhir Singh had a view on, AKJ has as an official stance. All things he did not make clear there are still conflicting views about those in the Jatha, and therefore in my opinion AKJ follows everything Randhir Singh made black and white... ----------- You are not an insider of Jatha and this is why you are talking like this. Didn’t Bhai Sahib make it clear that Sarbloh is an important rehit? How many Jatha Singhs follow this rehit? Same thing for Bibek. I like to narrate an incident from the time of Bhai Sahib. As long as Bhai Sahib did sewa in Punj Pyaray Sarbloh was a mandatory rehit prescribed by Punj Pyaray. In the 40s or late 30s, a group of prominent Singhs from jatha came to Bhai Sahib with a request. They came and said to Bhai Sahib that they are going to make a request. Bhai Sahib said that he too would like to make a request and that his request be accepted. The Singhs gave their bachan. The singhs went ahead first. They said that the condition of Sarbloh Bibek be taken off when doing amrit sinchaar. Bhai Sahib knew that this is what they were going to say. He said that he is not going to argue with them and that he be given chhuttee (leave) from doing sewa in Punj Pyaray from that time on. Both requests were granted. From that day amrit was not given on the condition of Sarbloh and only Bibek and other rehits were kept in main samagams of Jatha. Bhai Sahib too did not do sewa in Punj after that. This incident proves that Bhai Sahib did not have the last word in jatha. He was a Singh, a respected Singh, but not an absolute dictator like sants. ------- 1986 there was a Sarbat Khalsa about Khalistan, I doubt it would be decleared if 90% of Panth was against it and 10% was for it... [to be honest I'm not sure how it works, but i believe that too works on majority] --------- I personally don’t believe this to be a Sarbat Khalsa. Akhand Kirtani Jatha, Babbar Khalsa, SGPC and a whole lot of Sikh organizations were not present there. Some of the decisions made in this samagam are outrageous e.g. dissolving the SGPC. Lionking jeeo, I think you are wasting your energy by trying to discredit Jatha, one of the most precious organizations of Panth today. Your energies and your knowledge could be better utilized if you spend it on exposing the anti-Sikh organizations. Why don’t you spend some time on exposing the Kukas and Radhasoamis? You have a sharp brain and you possess good knowledge. Use it for the Chardi Kala of our Panth. Jathay noo baksh lai yaar. Koi kamm dee gal kar. Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

singh · 28 Jan 2006

sarbloh bibek is an importnat rehat to keep but i dont believe that story about bhai randhir singh is true. gyani amolak singh ji took amrit and bhai randhir singh ji was in his panj i believe. the panj did not say anything about sarbloh bibek. could you please reference your story and give examples of those who took amrit in bhai sahibs time and were given sarbloh bibek as a hukam by the panj (i am not doubting the importance of sarbloh but i dont think all these gurmukhs from bhai sahibs time decided to go against the panj and give this rehat up).

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jan 2006

Singh, Ask any puratan Singh e.g. Bhai Harbhajan Singh jee Shatrana (currently living in Anandpur Sahib) and Bhai Mahinder Singh jee Kala Sangha who does sewa in Punj Pyaray at Bibeksar. They will vouch for this story. Many other puratan Singhs know of this incident. Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006

Bhai Kulbir Singh ji, as you have probably seen I do not save any time when it comes to exposing anti-sikh organisations such as mentioned by you, and will not stop doing so. However wherever I find manmat practises amongst Sikhs I will question those to whether they are practised by AKJ or Taksal or Nihangs. ** Why don’t you spend some time on exposing the Kukas and Radhasoamis? ** I do! Please read the naamdhari's thread! *** Use it for the Chardi Kala of our Panth. Jathay noo baksh lai yaar. Koi kamm dee gal kar. *** I believe Chardikala of Panth can only come by Naam, and by questioning. Questioning will make people think about things they blindly accept. Unless we get bahman things out of Panthwe're not getting anywhere, whether they're practised by Taksal or Jatha. Also I've got (I think) one last question =P Why was (is ? ) Bhai Randhir SIngh refered to as "Bapu Ji" by some Jatha Singhs back in the day? Why did Bhai Randhir Singh not object to this? And If I'm not mistaken (which I could be - but I doubt it) there is a Sakhi posted about Bhai Randhir Singh being called "Bapu Ji" by Panj Pyaiarey!!! I Find this very offensive, and nothing less than what Dhadria is doing today. Could you please justify why Randhir SIngh allowed others to call him "Bapu Ji" (please do not give me the same arguement that Dhadria gives - Sangat kehndi e apa ki kariye?) Again I'm sure I've seen it several times in AKJ circles. bhull chukk maaf

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jan 2006

-------- Why was (is ? ) Bhai Randhir SIngh refered to as "Bapu Ji" by some Jatha Singhs back in the day? Why did Bhai Randhir Singh not object to this? And If I'm not mistaken (which I could be - but I doubt it) there is a Sakhi posted about Bhai Randhir Singh being called "Bapu Ji" by Panj Pyaiarey!!! I Find this very offensive, and nothing less than what Dhadria is doing today. Could you please justify why Randhir SIngh allowed others to call him "Bapu Ji" (please do not give me the same arguement that Dhadria gives - Sangat kehndi e apa ki kariye?) ---------- What's wrong in calling bazurg Singhs Bapu jee? When Bhai Sahib was young i.e. before he went to jail, Singhs used to call him "Baayee jee". Bhai Sahib was from Malwa region of Punjab and there they call elder brother "Baayee jee". When Bhai Sahib grew old, young Singhs used to call him "Bapu jee" just like they would call any other bazurg person. I personally was taught by my parents to call Sikh Bazurgs "Bapu jee" and "Bibi jee" to Bazurg females. I have taught my children to call elder Sikh bazurgs "Bapu jee". Is there something wrong with this? This is the firt time I am hearing this. It's our culture to call elders by names like "Bapu jee", "Bayee jee", "Bhaayoo jee", "Bhaayeeaa", "Bibi", "Beejee". Why would Bhai Sahib stop young gursikhs from calling him "Bapu jee"? This allegation is totally insane and proves that you were not born and raised in our Maatar-bhoomi Punjab. Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006

Although I am indeed not born and raised in Punjab, I have been taught that only Guru Gobind Singh ji is the true Bapu Ji and not anyone else. IF you go to Punjab today, you will rarely see anyone calling elderly "Bapu Ji", atleast where I live lol. Again I find it offensive that PANJ PEYARREY call someone Bapu ji, because Panj are the ultimate Bapu Ji, Guru Gobind SIngh ji himself - so how could anyone be called the Bapu of Guru Gobind Singh Ji (except Kartar himself, or Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib) So I personally find it offensive that when someone is representing Guru Gobind Singh JI , they call another human being (although Gurmukh) for "Bapu Ji", as Guru ji himself is the ultimate Bapu Ji, so who could be his Bapu Ji?

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jan 2006

--------- Although I am indeed not born and raised in Punjab, I have been taught that only Guru Gobind Singh ji is the true Bapu Ji and not anyone else. --------- Many children I know, call their worldly fathers "Bapu jee". As the matter of fact, talk to any bazurg from Malwa region and he will vouch that they used to call their father "Bapu jee" or they will confirm that this is an acceptable term to address our Bazurgs. Indian culture does not allow us to call our elderly persons by their names. I always call elderly males "Bapu jee" and elderly females "Beejee" or "Bibi jee" or "Mata jee". It's true that Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj is our Pita jee but this does not mean that we should stop addressing our worldly father as "Pita jee" or "Bapu jee". --------- IF you go to Punjab today, you will rarely see anyone calling elderly "Bapu Ji", atleast where I live lol. ------------- Where I come from, I hear Bapu jee all the time. As the matter of fact, whether you go to Majha, Malwa or Doaba, "Bapu jee" is a commonly used name to address our elders. ------------ Again I find it offensive that PANJ PEYARREY call someone Bapu ji, because Panj are the ultimate Bapu Ji, Guru Gobind SIngh ji himself - so how could anyone be called the Bapu of Guru Gobind Singh Ji (except Kartar himself, or Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib) So I personally find it offensive that when someone is representing Guru Gobind Singh JI , they call another human being (although Gurmukh) for "Bapu Ji", as Guru ji himself is the ultimate Bapu Ji, so who could be his Bapu Ji? ----------- I personally find nothing wrong in Punj Pyaray addressing our elders with respect. What do you think Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee or Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee Maharaaj call Baba Budda jee? "Oye Budda"? You are mistaken if you think that Guru Sahib did not used to respect elderly Gursikhs. I personally believe that they called Baba Budda jee "Baba jee". Same way, if a bazurg walks in to the Darbar of Punj Pyaray, there is nothing wrong if they call that Bazurg male "Bapu jee" and the Bazurg female "Mata jee". Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 28 Jan 2006

******* I personally find nothing wrong in Punj Pyaray addressing our elders with respect. What do you think Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee or Siri Guru Hargobind Sahib jee Maharaaj call Baba Budda jee? "Oye Budda"? You are mistaken if you think that Guru Sahib did not used to respect elderly Gursikhs. I personally believe that they called Baba Budda jee "Baba jee". Same way, if a bazurg walks in to the Darbar of Punj Pyaray, there is nothing wrong if they call that Bazurg male "Bapu jee" and the Bazurg female "Mata jee". ******* I personall have a hard time believing Guru Gobind Singh Ji calling i.e. Bhai Desa Singh or Bhai Chaupa Singh ( I know they were younger, but lets for a moment imagen they were 20 years older) Guru Ji would call them "Bapu Ji" as he himself is the Bapu of the Bapus. Yes he might have called them "Baba Jee", just like Guru Nanak Patshah Called Baba Buddha Ji, Baba jee, and not Bapu jee. There is definetly a twist in here, and I disagree that everyong, including Guru Sahib should call a man for Bapu jee, because although the Guru shows respect, he IS the Bapu of the Bapus (not as in grand dad, but you know what I mean). I have never heard any other Gurmukh such as Bhai Amolak Singh Ji, Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji, Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara being called Bapu Ji - are these Gurmukhs not old enough to be called Bapu Ji? I have yet to hear them being called Bapu ji by ANYONE let alone Panj. There is definetly a diference between "Bapu Ji",and "Bhay jee" or or Baba ji. Orelse Gandhi woudl have been called "bhay, or baba ji of the nation" but Mohandas is refered as the "bapu" of the Indian nation... I feel that Randhir Singh was being refered to the Bapu in a similar sense and not in a bazurg sense, because otherwise the other bazurg Gurmukhs would also be called Bapu ji, which I have yet to hear from ANY AKJ-er Bhull chukk maaf

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Kulbir Singh · 28 Jan 2006

Lionking jeeo, "Pokhar neer viroliye, Maakhan nahi reesay". You can continue to churn water but you will not get butter out of it. If you are not aware of the culture in Punjab just give it up. It's not fair for you to judge the use of word "Bapu jee" according to your standards. Your futile attempts to paint Jatha as santdumm are not going to bring any fruit. Jatha is the champion of holding the notion of supremacy of Guru Granth (Sahib) and Guru Panth. -------------- I have never heard any other Gurmukh such as Bhai Amolak Singh Ji, Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji, Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara being called Bapu Ji - are these Gurmukhs not old enough to be called Bapu Ji? I have yet to hear them being called Bapu ji by ANYONE let alone Panj. ----------- I personally just spoke to Giani Harbhajan Singh jee of Anandpur Sahib yesterday and called him Bapu jee. My children call at least couple of Singhs I know "Bapu jee". I always refer to him as Bapu jee. Is there is problem with that? Not if you are from Punjab. I have heard so many gursikhs call Bhai Jeevan Singh jee Bapu jee, especially young children. -------------- There is definetly a diference between "Bapu Ji",and "Bhay jee" or or Baba ji. Orelse Gandhi woudl have been called "bhay, or baba ji of the nation" but Mohandas is refered as the "bapu" of the Indian nation... I feel that Randhir Singh was being refered to the Bapu in a similar sense and not in a bazurg sense, because otherwise the other bazurg Gurmukhs would also be called Bapu ji, which I have yet to hear from ANY AKJ-er ------------ Come on, Lionking, you are showing the bankruptcy of your limited knowledge of our culture now. Stop applying the your handicap Western notions on Sikh culture. Shame on you for speculating that Bhai Sahib was called "Bapu jee" in the same sense as Mahatma Gandhi is called "Bapu" of the nation. Our father is only Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee. No Jatha Singh ever called Bhai Sahib "Bapu jee" in that sense. Jatha is not a Sant dum. Jatha believes in the supremacy of Khalsa Panth. It would never accept any one person as "Bapu" in the Mahatma Gandhi sense. You should apologise for your stupid and perhaps malicious speculations. Kulbir Singh

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

G. Singh · 28 Jan 2006

Kulbir Singh jee, by your comment "nice try" it seems as if you believe i was trying to outsmarten. I am very sorry if it seemed like this, but i truely had a genuine question, i was not trying to poke fun or twist gurbani in any way. Nor was I trying to prove you wrong, i was curious to your veechars on the topic. Bhai sahib jee, i have one more query, please give your veechars on this as well. If one does says vahiguroo as they breath in and once again when they breath out. Or even just vahiguroo when they breaht in and say nothing when they breath out. Would this also not be considered swaas swaas? Is simran not still going with each breath?

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Punjabi · 31 Jan 2006

Lionking Jee, I understand you are a western born a bred Sikh. You shouldn't argue over things you don’t understand. You are using your western technicalities to judge who we can call Bapu Jee, Mata Jee, or Baba Jee. These are our traditional title we use to respect our elders in Punjab. I like many from Punjab are taught by our parents to refer to any elder who is of my grandparents age as Bapu Jee or Baba Jee. Similarly, any elder who is of the age of my parents I refer to them as Uncle Jee or Aunty Jee. This is simply a result of good parenting. BTW, I am interested in knowing what do you call Bujurgs of your grandperents age group? do you use their name when calling them? [%sig%]

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

Roopkaur · 31 Jan 2006

I agree with 'Punjabi'. This objection to the use of Bapu ji is a non issue, and I do not understand why it is being blown so out of proportion. We say guru ji is our pita ji too, so that means we can no longer call our Dads pita ji/paapaa ji/ or whatever else we call them because Guru ji is our pita ji, according to your logic.

Re: NAAM DHRIRH???

LionKing (LK) · 31 Jan 2006

It was a genuine question, a doubt in my mind. I was honestly not aware that they call older peopel Bapu ji, but wasmore familier with the bhayee, and thought the use of bapu ji was in the context of M. K gandhi, and not just as any bazurg. Stop being so defensive. It was a genuine question and we have not understood the reason - a twist of misunderstanding. Stop being so defensive. I did make a misatke and i apologize for doing it. let's stop blowing up stuff to amke it seem tht he's making him seem liek santvadh -yes I did think so but I was wrong. Have i ever hesitated in apologizing when I was mistaken? I this very thread I have apologized 1-2 times - wso whats the issue? you guys shoudl seriously consider becoming less defensive. God......