Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Kulbir Singh · 19 Dec 2005

A collegue of mine is a Maratha. We were talking and it was brought up that if the Sikhs had helped the Marathas in the third battle of Panipat, the foreign rule from India would have been eliminated in the mid 1700s. I know that Sikhs did not help the Maratha and I also know that Bhau Sahib who was leading the Maratha forces lost his life even though he fought very bravely. Something terribly went wrong because the Maratha forces were in a better position going in the battle. Before going to the battle Bhau Sahib instructed his personal guard to slay his wife in case he does not come back. He did not want his wife to be caught by Afghans and sold as slave in the Middle East. Eventually, Abdali took 10,000 Maratha women as slaves. The Sikhs under the leadership of Sardar Jassa Singh Ahluwalia liberated 2200 of these women by attacking the forces of Abdali as they were going back to Kabul after winning the crown of Delhi. Does any keen student of history know why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Ahmed Shah Abdali the tyrant who massacred Sikhs many times and even destroyed Siri Harmandir Sahib? Seems like it would have been the logical thing to do. If the Sikhs had joined this war, they would have destroyed Ahmad Shah Abdali and his forces. Perhaps, as I mentioned in a post written by Bhai Udoke that Sikhs normally go their way alone and do not seek help from anyone but in this case it was helping Marathas to and not getting help from them. I personally don't question the decision of Singhs of that time but I just want to know if Sikh history makes any mention of why Sikhs did not participate in this war. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

S Singh · 19 Dec 2005

Bhau was a very weak leader and that is why they lost the battle. Even Raja Suraj Mall of Bharatpur left him because he was so poor when it came to negoitations with others. The only good thing to come out the Maratha loss was that Mahadji Scindhia learnt how to raise a proper army.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Dec 2005

IF the Marathas had "won" at the Fileds of Panipat...then Punjab would have come under them....just an exchange of "rulers". It is a fact that the Marathas wanted to rule the entire Mughal Empire..and Sikhs already had a taste of the Paharree Rajah rulers who fought battles with Guru Gobind Singh ji...... as it is Abdali, who is well known as the supreme military genius of ths time, destroyed the Maratha power..and this led to his own destruction at the hands of the Sikhs in Punjab through guerilla tactics and NOT straight out face to face battle as at Panipat. SIKHS wanted a truly INDEPENDENT PUNJAB..not an Abdali one and also not a Maratha ruled one. This was a time of really fluid borders and many other factors came into play rather than just straight out who is who..Sikhs were a minute MINORITY and finding their feet..while the Marathas already had states and royal families and such

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 19 Dec 2005

I have the same question for sikh's and why they were so loyal to the british during the war of 1857 the first war for independence and why they were so loyal to the british during world war 1 even though the british treated them like second class citizens and so many sikh's gave up their lives so the british could keep their empire and keep their rule over india and the sikh's and why the sikh's didn't rebell against the british after the massacore that took place in 1919 when the british shot all those inocent people why didn't the sikh's drop out of the military and police and try fighting against the british and why they helped the british fight the indian national army rather then join it and free india, all I hear about is how sikh's contributed so much to the freedom movement then the next thing i hear is how the sikh's were so loyal to the british why couldnt they make up their minds and if they all had chosen to rebell then sikh's could of taken out the british and maybe even ruled india politically. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

....... · 20 Dec 2005

1708 - 45 -> Thousands of Shaheedis by Gursikhs 1746 - Chotta Holocaust 1757 - Attack on Darbar Sahib and Baba Deep Singh Ji became Shaheed Where were the Marathas when Sikhs were dying in large numbers? Battle of panipat took place in 1761 but until then Sikhs had suffered great losses and no marathas came forward to help. Sikhs were fighting for the entire country and fighting every foreign invader. Sikhs suffered great holocaust in 1762 in which more than 50% of our population was killed. Just after 3 years Sikhs took over Punjab. This shows bravery and courage. Marathas come nowhere closer to Sikhs. Marathas did not start fighting until invaders came close to their own kingdoms. When they came to Punjab they tried to take over and turned against Sikhs. Why did they not join Sikhs? Marathas fought one battle and their back was broken forever. They fought to save their kingdoms. They had their kingdoms, palaces, money, treasure and well paid army. Sikhs had to live in jungles, had no mountains or palaces to hide behind and certainly no army that fought for money. Even then Sikhs sacrificed lot more than marathas. Every time hindus pick a battle and blame Sikhs for their defeat. They never even fought for freedom or wished to unify the country. It is a well known fact that both sides were getting tired of the war but at the end Abdali encouraged his forces and marathas lost their self confidence. If hindus really wanted to free their country then they shouldn't have joined the british in Anglo-Sikh wars. They helped british to take over Punjab, fought against Sikhs and raped our women. after doing all of this did they really expect Sikhs to help them just after eight years in 1857 which was nothing more than bunch of senseless people running around killing people wanting to establish their own kingdoms. Hindus use battle of panipat (1761) and 1857 movement. In 1000 years of their slavery do they have anything else? Any sacrifices? Any wars fought for freedom? think about it. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

KS · 20 Dec 2005

Most of the sepoys who rebelled in 1857 had fought against the Sikhs with the British in the Anglo Sikh Wars of 1845-1849. These sepoys carried out attrocities in the Punjab and carried out looting, so in 1857 there was no support for them. The Hindus wanted there Hindu rulers back in power and the Muslims there own rulers , this did not appeal to the Sikhs. At the time of 1857 the British said the Sikhs could have their rule on Punjab back, rather like Nehru and Gandhi said in 1947, but it did not happen. As for the Indian National Army 70 % were Sikh and the senior leaders were Sikhs. The Congress Party and Gandhi supported the British during the war, and oppossed the INA as they new they would be popular with the masses and they would lose support. The Marathas wanted to rule Punjab in 1806 the Maratha leader Holkar invaded the Punjab, Maharaja Ranjit Singh then expelled them. It must be understood that the concept of India did not exist until the British created it. There several hundred countries and principalities on the Indian Subcontinent each with its own interests.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

S Singh · 20 Dec 2005

>>I have the same question for sikh's and why they were so loyal to the british during the war of 1857 the first war for independence Where were the Hindus during the 2 Anglo Sikh wars ? Why were the Hindu sappers so loyal to the British during these wars ? It was never a war of independence. The Rani of Jhansi fought becasue she was stopped from appointing a successor.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Bhopinder Singh · 20 Dec 2005

Why didn't Hindus fight british in totality, because forget fight they never fought anything . I will answer you same thing in my next post. Sikhs are not even fighting Hindus now.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Kulbir Singh · 20 Dec 2005

Excellent posts by Arshi Gyani jee, Vijaydeep Singh jee, "..........." and KS. Marathas were very proud of themselves and they treated non-Marathas very poorly. They treated the Rajputs of Rajasthan (especially Mewar) very poorly and also ill-treated the Jaats of Bharatpur. They isolated themselves from all indigenious people of Indian subcontinent and God knows why they supported the Mughal regime in Delhi and why they appointed Adina Begh the governor in Punjab. The Peshwas of Marathas did some good in the beginning but later they emboilled in worldly pleasures. Shivaji Maratha was a very religious person who led his life in the fear of God but his successors were all debauchees. A person who gets embroilled in Kaam can never be a succesful person. The Maratha history is very interesting and of special interest is the battle of Panipat. One hears such conflicting accounts of this battle that one does not know what to make out of it. Many historians say that Marathas lost because they were overconfident and because they failed to make use of the French cannons they had bought recently and instead of waiting for Abdali to attack them, they moved forward and attacked Abdali. But they had no choice because their supply lines were cut by Abdali and BhauSahib lost his patience with Abdali. As Veer Vijaydeep Singh explained, it now makes sense why Dal Khalsa did not help Marathas. For Khalsa, the victory of Marathas would have been just change of a ruler and perhaps if the Marathas had won the battle, Maharaja Ranjit Singh may not have been able to establish his rule. Regarding Sikhs helping Britishers in the 1857 Mutiny, as other contributors have already written, Sikhs were still upset with Poorbis (Biharis and UP residents) who had helped British against Sikhs in the Anglo-Sikh wars. How could have Sikhs helped them? But one thing really bothers me. How did the Sikhs join the armies of British who had annexed their kingdom merely 8 years ago and how did they stay so faithful to the British? I wish the Sikhs had remained as opposed to foreign rule as Afghans have been. I guess all Sikh leadership got eliminated and Baba Maharaj Singh too got arrested. Otherwise, it makes no sense joining the British who annexed their kingdom. Kulbir Singh

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Kulbir Singh · 20 Dec 2005

-------- Till 1857 they were not allowed to wear truban but wore hats.In East UP when Britishers were in trouble then they allowed Turban and British officer also dwaned the same. ---------- Could you please backup this claim that the Sikhs in British army before 1857 did not wear turbans? I highly doubt the veracity of this statement. Kulbir Singh

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 21 Dec 2005

I know the hindu's never did anything against the british but why didn't all the sikh's I know their were sikh's who rebelled against england but why didn't every sikh rebell against england why were they laying down their lives for an empire that considered them equal to dogs. Why is it we talk about how their were so many sikh's that died fighting the british rule yet then we brag about how loyal we were to the british so didn't we basically cancel eachother out for every sikh freedom fighter it sounds like their were two sikh's that were loyal to the british why did they go help the british during world war 1 would they join the military and go into the trenches and die for an empire that considered them equal to dogs why not during world war 1 rather then join the army why couldn't they rebell against the british I agree sikh's made the greatest amount of sacirfice for india but at the same time even more sikh's made sacirfices for the british empire why during world war 2 were we helping england and not rebelling and don't say we joined england in the war to fight the germans that the british were the less of two evils because most of the world didn't know about the concentration camps till the end of the war and the british were no different from the nazi's they both treated the colored ppl like crap. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Dec 2005

Dear "Same thing" Jio, You are confusing "individuals" with "Kaum". A Individual...and the KAUM are two different things. An "individual" soldier in the BRITISH ARMY is duty bound to be LOYAL to his employer..in order to be NOT referred to as LOON HARAMEE. So all those "individual SIKHS" who were in the BRITISH ARMY fought for their EMPLOYER..who paid their WAGES faithfully every month. EXACTLY the "same thing" with all those "SIKH" Generals and Tank Drivers, and Cannon Gunners of the INDIAN ARMY that SHOT the Akal Takhat to Bits in 1984 and slaughtered thousands of other "SIKHS". These "individuals" were being LOYAL to their employer..the Indian Armed Forces. ALL thsoe SIKHS who couldnt stomach thsi "rebelled" and are today termed "Dharmee Faujis" and are languishing in Indian Jails...but to their Former EMPLOYER they committed TREASON are not dharmee at all but traitors. There is a news about a SIKH who has becoem the First SIKH in the Pakistani Army. Since he is employed by the Pakistani Army and he is pakistani Citizen....when and IF Pakistan Attacks India..he will of course not become a traitor or loon harami and refuse to shoot at the Indians ?? Why should he ?? Havent the "Same thing" Indian SIKHS shot the Akal takhat and their own brothers in cold blood ?? IF and when the Indian Army invades "malaysia" we SIKHS in the Malaysian (Muslim nation" army will shoot the B***S off the indians..why shouldnt we ?? we owe our livelihood to the Malaysian Army !!! Why should we Malaysian sikhs become AKIRTGHAANS and LOON HARAMEES ?? There was a time when there were SIKHS even in the Moghul Admin..that is where the word "TANKHAIYAH" and "TANKHAH" comes from. The Sikhs in the Moghul Govt received a "tankhah" (salary) for their monthly expenses..and THAT itself was a "bad word" to the other SIKHS...whose heads were put on PRIZE MONEY LISTS. So whenever such a SIKH repented and joined the other SIKHS..he was given a "TANKHAH" just as the Jathedars today give to repentant Sikhs..and thsi "Tankhah" was to "CUT" the influence of the regular tankhakh thy had beenreceiiving from the moghuls. We all have a CONSCIENCE..some have more than others...but its the "same thing" but not for all. Kartar Singh Sarabha, Bhagat Singh, Udham Singh gave their lives fighting AGAINST the British..many others gave their lives fighting FOR the British...an INDIVIDUAL CHOICE...not to be questioned by ANYONE...but the same individual himself...

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 21 Dec 2005

Yea but the sikh's who attacked the golden temple's were traiters to their own faith they put the government in front of their religion which is a terrible sin that's like saying if you part of the german army in world war 2 you have to support hitler or you are a traiter and are doing wrong when they killed inocent people and the sikh's loyal to the british pretty much sold their souls just like the sikh's that attacked the Akal Takhat during 1984 by helping an empire that treated their own people less then human and why are their so many sikh's who brag about the sacirfices they made for freedom when their were more sikh's that made sacirfices for the british empire to keep their own ppl under rule by an empire that considered them dogs all for a stupid wage I don't think your soul or dignity has a price. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Bhoinder Singh · 22 Dec 2005

Mr. same thing ji There was no such thing as India before 1947 .Brits brought together for exploitation all the different regions and construed a entity as such.Had their been no brits you would have had 22 different states with different languages ,cultures and religions although i think it would have been more. So as you can see their was no such thing and the reason to fight for something that never was would be foolish.For sikhs freedom and soveriginity ended with the fall of sikh kingdom all events after that could be termed with respect to solidery as slavery,let be british,indian or any at the same time no body in india fought for India but their own kingdoms selfish it seems but that was their india as no such thing ever existed.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

fly fast · 22 Dec 2005

"Yea but the sikh's who attacked the golden temple's were traiters to their own faith " According to many eye witness acounts, the majority of sikh soldiers who attacked mutinied and became shaheds for the panth. even dusht brar admited that sikh soldiers did mutiny but many whitnessed the majority turn their guns against hindustan when intentions of the attack became clear to the soldiers. Parnaam shaheeda nu

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 22 Dec 2005

then why was it majority of sikh's who took out the freedom fighters for khalistan and why were they sikh police officers and soldiers who turned on their own people I never heard about any of these sikh's rebelling I just heard a few did but majority stayed loyal to hindustan and why did so many sikh's attack the golden temple in the military. But my question on why sikh's were so loyal to the british when the british treated them like dogs why did we suck up to the british. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

khalistani · 22 Dec 2005

we dddint suk up to the british read all the sikh movements agasint the british man wa u talkin bout bhula chuka maf

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Mehtab Singh · 22 Dec 2005

Have you heard of the Anglo-Sikh wars? Sikhs lost the second Anglo-Sikh war because of the Dogras who became traitors. As long as Maharaja Ranjit Singh was alive, the British didn't dare set an eye on Punjab.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 23 Dec 2005

I know their were many sikh's that rebelled against british rule but their were twice as many sikh's that gave their lives up to protect the british empire why were their so many loyal sikh's did the feel like the british were more superior then sikhs. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 24 Dec 2005

I don't think anyone can answer my question [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Akaali · 24 Dec 2005

Akalis didn't have enough force to help the marathas. Marathas had over 1 lakh and abdali had only 40 thousand so marathas should have had no probs. Also there were no phones or emails to tell, "Hello, I a being attacked, help me." Marathas never helped the Khalsa either. Also the 1857 mutiny was not for independence. It was a bunch of hindus fighting for stoppage of using cow products. http://www.sikhmarg.com/sikh-1857.html

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

fly fast · 26 Dec 2005

"khalistan and why were they sikh police officers and soldiers who turned on their own people " i was refring to the soldiers who wrre ivolved in ayyacking darbar sahib. ther was sympathy for freedom fighters among the punjab police ranks cuz the khlistanis told all fighters not to attack police officers, the government then created the "black cats" as we all know , who went around killing innocents Including families of police officers, hence thikin it was done by khalistanis they also went against us. on top of that you know how the "media mafia" used to portray sikhs as terorist on top of variouse acts of terorism i.e bomb blasts carriedd ouyt by RAW in india and includin air india - Read the book "Soft target" but if you live in india you wont able to read it cuz its been BANNED in hindustan.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

simply the best · 27 Dec 2005

Regarding the Mahratas a few years before the third battle of Panipat, the Mahratas, Sikhs and Adina Beg Khan had conquered the Punjab from the Mughals. After Adina Beg was made the governor of Punjab he re-started the same persecution as Meer Mannu had done. Sikhs were hunted down and their heads brought to Lahore. The Mahratas did not object to this policy as long as Adina paid the revenue to them. The Mahratas although they are portrayed by Hindu historians as Hindu nationalists, they were never interested in anything more than stripping the rest of India of gold and silver and taking it to their own country Maharashtra. So it isn't surprising that the Sikhs did not help their Mahratas at Panipat. If anything the Sikhs leaders displayed a great understanding of realpolitik by standing aside and recruiting to their depleated ranks whilst a major and a minor enemy tore themselves apart. The battle of Panipat destroyed Mahratas power in north India and after that their power declined and they split into different kingdoms. This left only two claimants to Punjab Afghans and Sikhs. The Sikhs then spent the next decade destroying the Afghans in Punjab. As for the 1857 mutiny. The other posters are correct that Sikhs did not help the British because of the Poorabiyas who had only 8 years previously helped the British annex the Sikh kingdom. If anything it was a good opportunity for the Sikhs extract revenge from the Poorabiyas. This the Siks did in Delhi and other places. Imagine if in 1984 Pakistan had invaded India, would the Sikhs have joined the Pakistani in order to extract revenge from the Indians for the descration of Harmandir Sahib? The poster who seems to think that Sikhs were treated worse than dogs under the British needs to read up on his history. The British were unlike any of the other invaders of India. They wanted to rule through opening up markets for trade and as long as no one was against their rule they left the Sikhs, Hindus and Muslims alone. None of this was the case during the Mughals, Afghans and now the present Hindu rulers of India. The Sikhs actually enjoyed a better relationship with the British than the other Indians because the British respected the Khalsa traditions and although they used this in order to have the Sikhs fight in their wars but how exactly is this different from the Sikhs today fighting in Indian, British, US armies today?

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 27 Dec 2005

the british were racist they thought we were inferior to them and tell people we need the british. They would treat us like dogs by putting up signs like no dogs and indian's allowed killed many inocent people like the 1919 incident when so many inocent people lost their lives and the guy's shooting were indians in the british army shooting at their own people the same army many sikh's served in. After all the misery the british caused the people of punjab even during seperation by ripping land away from the sikh's, sikh's wanna still take pride in what they did for the british while we were wippping their feet and running around like their little slaves they still pretty much slapped us across are faces. 1984 many sikh's and militant group's got their aid from pakistan many wanted sikh militants would hide in pakistan and get their support from pakistan but the 1984 incident would of never happened and we wouldn't be ruled by hindus if the sikh's used their heads and came together at once and drove the british out rather then have many sikh's like bhagat singh and yet have twice as many sikh's who were loyal to the british and would hand over guy's like bhagat singh to the british to be hanged. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 27 Dec 2005

simply the best yep I have read up on some of the history and like you said in your post "They wanted to rule through opening up markets for trade and as long as no one was against their rule they left the Sikhs, Hindus and Muslims alone." Read the article below. In his book Late Victorian Holocausts, published in 2001, Mike Davis tells the story of famines that killed between 12 and 29 million Indians. These people were, he demonstrates, murdered by British state policy. When an El Niño drought destituted the farmers of the Deccan plateau in 1876 there was a net surplus of rice and wheat in India. But the viceroy, Lord Lytton, insisted that nothing should prevent its export to England. In 1877 and 1878, at the height of the famine, grain merchants exported a record 6.4m hundredweight of wheat. As the peasants began to starve, officials were ordered "to discourage relief works in every possible way". The Anti-Charitable Contributions Act of 1877 prohibited "at the pain of imprisonment private relief donations that potentially interfered with the market fixing of grain prices". The only relief permitted in most districts was hard labour, from which anyone in an advanced state of starvation was turned away. In the labour camps, the workers were given less food than inmates of Buchenwald. In 1877, monthly mortality in the camps equated to an annual death rate of 94%. As millions died, the imperial government launched "a militarised campaign to collect the tax arrears accumulated during the drought". The money, which ruined those who might otherwise have survived the famine, was used by Lytton to fund his war in Afghanistan. Even in places that had produced a crop surplus, the government's export policies, like Stalin's in Ukraine, manufactured hunger. In the north-western provinces, Oud and the Punjab, which had brought in record harvests in the preceeding three years, at least 1.25m died. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

gareeb_SIKH · 28 Dec 2005

<> This is a foolish question. Why so many indians kept on killing indians for a small number of britishers for 100 years. Why so many kashmiris have killed their own brothers.Farook Abdulla is the parkash badal of punjab. Recently Babbar Khalsa employed many hindus(according to the police). Human mind is FICKLE and full of greed.Many fall to greed easily,many fall with little difficulty,many fall with quite a bit of difficulity and only few dont fall at all and the examples of those few can be Sukhdev Singh babbar ji,Bhindrawale ji, etc. The brahminical GOI fell to a level beyond imagination,they fell to a level that is a disgrace to human race.Its tough to fight an enemy like this. The brahminical GOI killed also,dint admitt also and what more,put blame on the poor people who were killed. wahegurroooooooo,they have truly forgotten death. KHALISTAN ZINDABAD

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Singh · 28 Dec 2005

Why did 80% of the Indian subcontinent Hindu population stay loyal to firstly Moguls, Afghans and then British? Surely the millons of Hindus could have thrown them out rather than wait 1000 years for a small number of Sikhs to do it. Many of the Moghuls used Hindus to carry out oppression of Sikhs e.g. the Hindu Hill Rajas attacked Guru Gobind Singh ji before the Mughals did.They did not care that Guru Tegh Bahadhur ji had laid down his life for Hindus. Nehru and Gandhi stayed loyal to the British calling Sikhs like Bhagat Singh a terrorist and calling Guru Gobind Singh ji 'misguided'.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 30 Dec 2005

Oh everyone knows the hindu's will get on their knees for anyone are easy to rule over but why did the sikh's let the british walk all over them after fighting off the afgans and moghuls for so long. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

khalistani · 31 Dec 2005

how did sikhs get walked over??? it sikhs who gave ovwer 90 percent shaheedi it was sikhs who used methods which ghandi COPIED later on i dunt understand how we let them walk over many sikhs went to jail , and became shaheed who said that they were walked over:S? and some hindoos gave shaheedi as well, so its not fair to say that they jus fall on there knees bhula chuka maf

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

singh · 31 Dec 2005

<> Dear Veer, Though I dont know much about the history of that time,but I do feel that sikhs and sikhism are 2 different things.Sikhs have faltered on the path of sikhi many times and currenty too they are on a low.So,I feel lot depends on the type of sikhs that were there at the time britishers took over. just for a thought,if today some foreign rule attack Punjab,the sikh population might perform better than hindus but there wont be too much of a difference. If we go back to the period of 1983-1987,the foreign ruler who would attack sikhs of that time will be in trouble. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

LS · 31 Dec 2005

In the Anglo Sikh Wars, 1845-49 Maharaja Ranjit Singh's Dogra and Brahmin officers and Ministers came to an agreement with the Britsih that they would bretray the Sikh state for personal rewards. All battles plans were given to the British, ammunition witheld or tamperred with, troops were deployed in the wrong areas. After the war the Dogras were given Kashmir as a prize. All Sikh leadership was killed or sent into exile. Some of the big chiefs were bought by the British also.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 31 Dec 2005

Author: same thing Date: 12-30-05 03:12 Oh everyone knows the hindu's will get on their knees for anyone are easy to rule over but why did the sikh's let the british walk all over them after fighting off the afgans and moghuls for so long. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Not quite the "same thing" mate. Punjab fell to the British the LAST....and was the LEAST time under British Control..about 90 years compared to 10-200 years for other parts of India. NOT a Single SIKH was in the British Army attacking other Indian States...but there were many THOUSANDS of "Indians" in the British Army attacking PUNJAB. The British LOST the Two Anglo-Sikh Wars....the MOST BRUTAL they ever fought and with the MOST loss of British Lives....But the HINDU DOGRA TRAITORS in charge of the Sikh Armies...made VICTORY in the battlefield to DEFEAT in the Political Arena.. So Punjab and the rest of India cannot be "same thing" even 1%.. And the Punjab was the First to Get up and fight back. just 10 yeras fater losing the war.....revolts by the Kookas of Baba ram Singh,( exiled for life to Andamans) bhai Maharaj Singh.( Exiled for life to Singapore)..Kartar singh sarabha at age of 16...Ghadar/Freedom fighters/Gurdwara Lehr/Morchas/komagatamaru etc etc...while the rest of India was peacefully letting the Brits walk all over them just as the moghuls did for 1000 Years..

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Dogra · 01 Jan 2006

'Hindus' 'Hindus' , why does this characterisation assume that those of the Hindu faith all think the same? The Hill rajas were traitors, this does not mean other people of the hindu faith were like that. Also Ghandhi's and Nehrus assessment of Bhagat singh and Guru GobindSinghji and Shuvaji of the Marathas was their view, not shared by other people. Also did not in Punjab, the first son followed the Sikh faith, even if the family followed Hinduism? The Marathas under Shivaji followed a path of respectability towards othewr religions, they did not destroy any Mosques, just like the path followed by Guru Gobind Singhji

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

khalistani · 02 Jan 2006

i cant belive this SIKHS GAVE 90 PERCENT OF SHAHEEDIS TO FIGHT BRITISH and read jarnail singh gianis post, craz and dogras post bhula chuka maf

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

nei yar · 02 Jan 2006

i only speak on this becausei disagree with some statements if i am wrong brothers and sisters do correct me. bhai jarnail singh ji said " NOT a Single SIKH was in the British Army attacking other Indian States...but there were many THOUSANDS of "Indians" in the British Army attacking PUNJAB." sikhs attacked each other. The mini sikh kingdoms on the other side joined with the british to attack maharaja ranjit singhs punjab. which was not a sikh state but a democratic entity representing all faiths while the khalsa remained the backbone of shere punjab. therefore the sikhs who attacked shere punjab were as wrong as the thousands of indians who had done the same. bhai jarnail singh ji "the MOST BRUTAL they ever fought and with the MOST loss of British Lives....But the HINDU DOGRA TRAITORS in charge of the Sikh Armies...made VICTORY in the battlefield to DEFEAT in the Political Arena.." the khalsa gave shahadata for a sacred cause. The political spiritual matters should have been placed with the with panj piare and sarbat khalsa. By creating a monarchy ranjit singhs empire would have been doomed, absence of sikhi, asools, timeless values gone. If we had sarbat khalsa at the start instead of monarchies sikhs would not have been divided into shere punjab , nabha jind etc. Ranjit singh in order to expand territory sought allies and the like, this is why power was distributed more outwards than within. Many sikh traitors existed within sandhawalia brothers to start with, his own maternal sidhu nankey on the other side joined the english. Certain rajputs were in fact shaheed to expand ranjit singhs punjab into kashmir, while the dogar brothers won kashmir for helping england, what happened to every other dogar? so we must not become partial in rational thinking. Ranjit singhs suicidal movs were much before appointing dogars hindus and the like. He fought like a lion and risked his life to fight for punjabis as did his fathr and grandfather however leaving the khalsa in favour of monarchy he made mistake. such a raj could never have lasted. punnjab and india are not the same correct. everything else bhai sahib said is correct. siklhs were the real movement and first to fight british back after.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

A Singh · 04 Jan 2006

Dear Same thing, There were 12000 Sikh soilders out 20000 who supported Netaji Subhash Bose in Singapore to form the Azad Hind Fauj. These Sikhs were POW held by Japan. As you may be aware Netaji was sidelined by Gandhi & Nehru. Last year I saw a Bolloywood movie "Forgotten Hero - Netaji". It was a very controvertial film. Considering the numbers of Sikhs who served the "Azad Hind Fauj", there were hardly a few or negligiable number of Sikh soilders shown in the film. What are your comments on that. Regards, A Singh. same thing wrote: > I know their were many sikh's that rebelled against british > rule but their were twice as many sikh's that gave their lives > up to protect the british empire why were their so many loyal > sikh's did the feel like the british were more superior then > sikhs. >

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

indy · 04 Jan 2006

marathas - who are they?

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Kulbir Singh · 04 Jan 2006

The residents of Maharashtra are called Marathas. Shivaji Maratha who built the Maratha empire lived at the time of Aurangzeb. Marathas don’t have a history of martial spirit but they rose to fame under the leadership of Shivaji. The Marathas would have ruled whole of India and would stopped the British Raj if they had treated others with respect. They made all Rajputs their enemy by constantly raiding Mewar and other adjoining kingdoms in Rajasthan. They enraged the Jaats of Bharatput by ill-treating them. They even managed to upset Sikhs by their upper-handedness and by appointing Adina Beg (a Muslim) as the governor of Punjab instead of extending hand of friendship towards the Sikhs. This stupid move by Marathas cost them the slaughtering of 100,000 Maratha warriors in the hands of Abdali in the 3rd battle of Panipat because Rajputs, Jaats and Sikhs did not help them. Marathas were left to themselves to fight Abdali. If they had won, the history of India would have been different. Perhaps, the history of Punjab would have been different too. The British probably would have been left in Bengal only. The tragedy is that even the defeat of Panipat did not open their eyes and they continued to trouble Rajputs and Jaats. Rajputs joined hands with the British and after 3 battles with British, Marathas lost their kingdom in the early 1800s. Maharaja Ranjit Singh tried his best to save and help the Marathas but they lacked men of vision. Maharaja Ranjit Singh mediated between the Marathas and the British at the time of treaty of Amritsar in the 1820s. Marathas are respectable people and are only few of the people who stood against foreign rule in India. Had they worked prudently, they would have become a very great and lasting power in India. Bhagat Naamdev was a Maratha. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 05 Jan 2006

I know about all the traiters to the sikh empire and I know the two strong war's they put up and how ranjit singh's son became a christian and like i said their were sikh freedom fighters and I do believe more per capita then hindu's but why were their twice as many loyal to the sikh's why did they make up majority of the indian british military in world war 1 and 2 and why were so many of them in the army and police force when they british ruled over punjab and india if you check the facts their were many more sikh's that fought for the british then their were sikh's that fought for freedom why is that why do we take so much pride in being so loyal to the british in world war 1 and 2 and in 1897 in the battle were sikh's fought to the last against the pathons to protect a british fort when they should of bin helping the pathons take the british out of punjab and india. Why were the afgans able to keep the british out but the sikh's instead comming together and rebelling support the british if the sikh's of gotton together and rebelled against the british we would of never lost so much of the punjab to pakistan and we would be able to rule both india and pakistan rather then have the british treat us like dogs then get treated like dogs by the indian government after england left. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 05 Jan 2006

I know about all the traiters to the sikh empire and I know the two strong war's they put up and how ranjit singh's son became a christian and like i said their were sikh freedom fighters and I do believe more per capita then hindu's but why were their twice as many loyal to the sikh's why did they make up majority of the indian british military in world war 1 and 2 and why were so many of them in the army and police force when they british ruled over punjab and india if you check the facts their were many more sikh's that fought for the british then their were sikh's that fought for freedom why is that why do we take so much pride in being so loyal to the british in world war 1 and 2 and in 1897 in the battle were sikh's fought to the last against the pathons to protect a british fort when they should of bin helping the pathons take the british out of punjab and india. Why were the afgans able to keep the british out but the sikh's instead comming together and rebelling support the british if the sikh's of gotton together and rebelled against the british we would of never lost so much of the punjab to pakistan and we would be able to rule both india and pakistan rather then have the british treat us like dogs then get treated like dogs by the indian government after england left. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Kulbir Singh · 05 Jan 2006

"Same thing", In every quom there are good and bad people and Sikh quom is not exception to this rule. The rebellious nature of Sikhs kind of got mitigated during the Raj of Maharaja Ranjit Singh when Sikhs gave up important rehits and started mingling with Hindus and Muslims. They allowed their women to dress up like "Pattolay" and look like "pattaolay" as well. They themselves took up liquor drinking and other such evils. They gave up Sarbloh Bibek rehit that was the base of keeping Khalsa unique. Without Sarbloh Bibek, Khalsa can never stay niyara (distinct) and will surely get influenced by neighbouring quoms. This is what happened with Sikhs. Lack of leadership placed Sikhs under the authority of the British. Baba Maharaj Singh jee fought for sometime against the British but after he was caught, the Sikh resistance came to an end. You are right in pointing out that Sikhs should have never accepted the authority of British and Sikhs should have never accepted the authority of Hindus after 1947. It was the ghulam-zehneeyat (slave thinking) of Sikhs that they accepted authorities of other quoms and are still doing the same thing. Why should the Sikhs be ruled by anyone else? They forgot the Bachan of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj that Khalsa must stay distinct and should never go the way of other people. Sarbloh Bibek is the base of keeping Sikhs distinct. A Sikh who does not keep Sarbloh Bibek can never be classified as "Niyaara". Such Sikh is basically a Dhilla Sikh or Milgobha Sikh. Kulbir Singh

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

singh · 08 Jan 2006

sikhs should take responsibility for their own mess ups. every man today like yesterday is out there for himself whatever religion he is. a king thinks like aking, politiician like a politician, a saintly person like a saintly person.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 08 Jan 2006

so sikh's even though made greater crontribution then anyone else in the freedom movement at the same time had more sikh's who helped keep british rule in india. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

screwed to the maximum · 09 Jan 2006

the sikh maharaja of patiala or nabha dont know which one also helped abdali to kill sikhs in one of the galukaras. was this at the time of sikhs mixing with hindus and muslims causing a relapse in rehat? the patiala sikhs were with the hindu bhaiyeh and british all up to invade punjab. where did the royal sikhs outside punjab get their bad influence from when they governed sikh majority states more so than punjab itself which had a greater number of muslims and hindus and was the last to fall to british?

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Dogra · 09 Jan 2006

Marathas loss at Panipat was a turning point. The wisdom of Shivaji was not with them. Kulbir Singh u say, that Sikhs should not have accepted the authority of Hindus, in what way? The partition was the devils child. The majority people of the sub continent did not vote for it. People regardless of faith were living together side by side, for the most part peacefully. The hate filled muslim league spread the poisonous venom under the pork eating Jinnah. Jinnah himself would not have gone after Pkaistan had he been given the Prime ministers post. Sivakar was Hindutva, similar to Jinnah. Nehru was again another self serving politician , and did not keep his word to the people of Indian subcontinent. Subhas Chandra Bose, uinfortunately was killed and could not come to India in time to face Jinnah and vanquish him and the hate filled bigots for good. Ghandhi was blinded by his nonviolence, but deserves credit in trying to remove the hate.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Dogra · 09 Jan 2006

Also there is no Hindustan. Indias boundaries are clear, the Himalyan, Hindu kush mountain ranges and the Deserts in balouchistan. Other side of the Himalaya is China. Kingdoms were always there throughout each nations history. In India there have been to many self serving kingdom chiefs, worried about their own position and not of the greater good. Guru Gobind Singhji and Shivaji were individuals who thought of the greater good. Baba Banda Singh Bahadhur, a dogra rajput , did his valiant best, but a number innocent people were killed in his campaigns. But his valour and sheer courage will never be forgotten, in carrying on the work of Guru Gobindji.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Punjab E Lionz · 10 Jan 2006

jarnail singh say " NOT a Single SIKH was in the British Army attacking other Indian States...but there were many THOUSANDS of "Indians" in the British Army attacking PUNJAB." Punjabi Hindus and, with greater reason, the Sikhs refused to listen to the belated appeal to save Hindu Dharma from beefeating foreigners who used cow fat to grease their cartridges. However, there were stray cases of Sikhs joining the mutineers. It was reported that a large number of Sikhs gathered at Ropar and declared the Khalsa Raj for which the leader of the band was immediately put to death. A Sikh Chief, Raja Nahar Singh, was executed for supporting the cause of the rebels. After annexation Bhai Maharaj Singh had moved from village to village in Majha region and incited the people to rebel. The Cis-Satluj chiefs of Patiala, Malerkotla, Kalsia, Nabha, Faridkot and Jind, along with their mercenary forces, rendered full help to the British in suppressing the rebellion. These chiefs owed their existence to the British and were always outside the main Punjab, being hostile to Ranjit Singh. They still remembered with gratitude the support extended to them hy the British against Maharaja Ranjit Singh. But for the British protection, Ranjit Singh would have overpowered them long ago. This mutiny led British to recruit for their armed forces heavily among the communities which had been neutral to this rebellion. Especially, Gurkhas, Rajputs of Rajasthan, Punjabi Muslims and Sikhs. Sikhs started enlisting with British forces and were thus back to the profession of their liking, the military services. Ninety Years later when India became independent Indian leaders decided to call the Mutiny of 1857 as "The first war of Independence", which in reality was the last war of Mughals. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- BIBLIOGRAPHY Copyright © Daljeet Singh Kharak Singh "Sikhism, its Philosophy and History" Copyright © Daljeet Singh "The Radical Bhagats" http://www.sikh-history.com/sikhhist/events/mutiny1857.html

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Punjab E Lionz · 10 Jan 2006

a question needs to be asked why did sikh majority countries of the sis cutlej align with the british to attack the more multi ethnic multi religious punjab? they were afraid of punjab, they souht power and used bigger powers to break their enemy. If the sikh run cis sutlej countries from day one merged every missal into one khalsa confederacy, the buffer would have been strong enough to fight the british beat them, defeat afghans for good and even kick the british out . But the sikhs of the cic sutlej became very vocal in sikh revolutions against foreign rule, the same regions have seen very strong uprisings time and aain right upto 1990s. Therefore we need to scrutinise actual facts in history, so we do not make the same mistake again. The khalsa need to be tyar pur tyar! united as one ! not seeking power for one state or royal monarchies , but for the khalsa nation as one, increase ties cross states and recognise actual facts to learn from our history. Scapegoating dogars and bhaiyeh asthe only enemies rsponsibl for th decline of punjab will never bring us raj, we should all pull togethr for a united front (sikhs), in reality this is very not so th case. we stop short of our own goals which is to bring back our lost country. if we fail to look at reasons, then how will we every correct the posture to awork towards khalsa raj?

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Dogra · 10 Jan 2006

Vijay deepji, just a note the Aryan invasion is disputed, as there was already a large number of North Indians before any Aryans crossed the Hindu Kush, which was not easy in those times, and as it was frozen for nine months. Evidence suggests the Aryans played a minimal role in the Indian subcontinent. http://www.geocities.com/neovedanta/acxxvi.html

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

shampal · 11 Jan 2006

I dont mean to be rude buit who exactly are aryans in india? i thouiht aryans were europeans. indians do not look european, ke nehi?

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

same thing · 26 Jan 2006

why were so many sikh's laying down their lives for the british against their own brothers who were fighting for india's independence and how did we contribute to the indian freedom movement when their were so many sikh's who worked for the british raj and i know we made up majority of the freedom fighters but we pretty much cancelled eachother out. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 30 Jan 2006

vijaydeep singh ji is right. The Communal FRENZY was only whipped up sky high in PUNJAB..and Begal by the likes of the ARYA SAMAJISTS who are still around in Jan Sangh and now turned into BJP. Their Mahasha Press was Pure Poison. The Muslim League sprang up and fed on this Blood as well..the results are in front of everyone..Punjab and Bengal saw the worst in humanity. Punjab and Bengal were the ONLY two States that stood out...Bengal for language, subhash chander bose and independence fighters. just like Punjab. Is it any wonder that the Jan Sanghis with not a single sacrifice for Independence..Now have over HALF the seats and control Power in many states and even ruled the Centre...this is the result of their Communalism. The Congress is now FORCED to pander to the Hindus and show they are "more Hindu" than the BJP in order to win votes..this Caused the GUJRAT HOLOCAUST...a Must See Documentary on this is The FINAL SOLUTION...the entire story of how the muslims are slated for Hitler's Final Solution ( Sikhs are no matter also slated but later..as are the christians and other minorities. Pakistan achieved this "ZERO minority" rule 50 years ago !! BJP wants India to achieve it in the next few years)

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Balwant Rao · 06 Feb 2006

Back to the subject please note that most Marathas beleive that some Sikhs like Ala Singh Jat of Patiala played a traitorous part against the Marathas On many occassion they offered alliances and treaties with the Marathas only to break them when they got the chance When the Marathas invaded Punjab in 1757 they marched up to the Attock When they fought Abdali in 1761 many Sikh chiefs sttod aside and even took titles from Abdali (even though he attacked the Golden Temple) When the marathas conquered Delhi again in the 1780's the Marathas signed treaties with the cis Sutlej Sikhs chiefs - These chiefs broke their word again and again - They then supported the Brits in the Anglo Maratha war of 1803

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Balwant Rao · 06 Feb 2006

Vijaydeep Singh You whole history is on a false basis The peshwas were brahmin, so war Raghunath Rao and Sadashiv Rao - what is your point ? The alliance with the Sikhs was made by Sindhia (not by Sindhia Holkar and th Peshwa) The Sikh stronghold of Thaneswar was part of the Maratha dominion and not linked with the cis Sutlej states to my knowledge the combined forces of Holkar and Sindhia never attacked the Sikhs The whole Indian world was aware that the Mughal empire was controlled by the Marathas who governed in their name just as the British did later on. The Marathas hammered and humiliated the Mughals and the only time the cis Sutlej Sikhs fought in Delhi was in Support of the Rohilla Pathans Ghulam Qadir and Ismail Beg of the Mughals before they were smashed by Mahadji Sindhi You speak of the Pepsu states - would not have history and dharma said that they shoudl have joined the empire of Ranjit Singh Finally you story of the lady defeating some Maratha force is a footnote of history - there were inumerabel skirmishes between Marathas of Sindhia and the cis Sutlej Sikhs - every time the Marathas reduced troops in the regiion the cis Sutlej Sikhs woudl begin to raid and fight them

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Balwant Rao · 07 Feb 2006

I have not said that the Sikhs were a homogenous group. Indeed many fought with great valour and bravery whilst others acted in a despicable manner (like all other groups) I have never heard that Raghunath Rao had a different ideology from the Peshwas- indeed he was a Peshwa himself for a broef period. He was the son of Baji Rao and the brother of Balaji Baji Rao the conquerers of India. The balance of your history seems to be confused as per the internal politics of the Maratha Empire – which always ruled in the name of Shahu and his family Also Mahadji Sindhia was not poisoned but died in Pune in 1795 After the time of Balaji Baji Rao the Sindhias and Holkars were almost permananetly at loggerheads You say ‘and then when you talk of Marathas controling Moghuls by proxy is it not shamefull that they still let Mallechhas to rule Delhi just to appease Muslim Masses(Still this Happens in India),why did not they remove Halali Parcham and replaced it with Jarri Patka of Marathas in Delhi.’ Empires are not removed and resuracted overnight. The Marathas were in an almost continous mode of warfare and never had periods of peace to consolidate the gains made on the battlefield. Even the British maintained the fiction of the Mughal Empire for another 50 years ! You say that the Sikhs made thocratice states – Yest this dod not stop them fighting each other almost endlessly until the rise of Ranjit Singh so what is your point ? You say’Then coming to Ghualm Qadir Rohila,Well his grand father Najjeb Khan who descreeted Haridwar so mnay times and Datta Ji wanted to cut his head yet Malhar Rao deemed him as his son.but nenver did Hindu tried to convert him. Jassa Singh Ramgarhia when in charge of trans Yamuna region did convert Jaffeta Khan as Piara Singh and Ghulam Qadir Rohila as Bhola Singh.’ Yet Zabita Khan and his son Ghulam Qadir reconverted to Islam – why do you not mention this ? Some Sikh chiefs supported his and Ismail Begs attempts to resuracte the Mughal control over the empire – they were smashed by Madhaji Sindhia and his new model army in alliance with the Jaats of Bharatpur Your entire reading of history is faulty The Marathas had the closet ideology to nationalism – Hindu Pad Padshahi which they attempted to foist over all India You say ‘ Yet it took great mnay years for Sikhs to break Rohilas in Hariyana and West UP and once Sikhs overcome that area and gained domination then why should Marathas come in thier Areas.In fact Marathas can not convert a non Maratha as Maratha but Sikhs did carried out local conversion in Hariyana and West UP.So it was anyway right of Marathas to get area but Sikhs had right to defend.’ Reply: The Marathas claimed right over all India and the right was pressed at the point of a sword – just as it was by the Sikhs in their areas – not by gentle persuasion – have you ever heard of the shuddi ceremony introduced by the Marathas to bring and return people to Hinduism ? You say’ Marathas reduced troops to check Britishers and Sikhs amde use of it to regain thier Area but it was Shamefull that Marthas did let Muslim nawabs be restored like in Karnal or Jhajjar after removing Sikhs(Jaats also did not like it).It was only in 1857 that Brithers removed many Muslim nawabs as they deemed them to be reason of rebellion and let Sikhs Rajas take over.’ Reply: What are you talking about ? there were many Muslim generals and nawabs in the Sikh controlled areas – what is your point ? And that book link you have given is of a totally worthless and anti Hindu polemic which is sadly all too typical of many anti Hindu groups regardless of the Brahmin name etc You say : Das repeat that Marthas like Srimant Raghunath Rao(he was from Brahmin Family),Malhar Rao Holkar,Mahadji Sindhia were in line with Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj ie to let ideology be out of politics as that ideology is doubtful.They were more successful then those Marathas who were more after Brahmincal ideolgy which itslef is falsehood(it is anti Sanatan Dharmi scripture themselve which are also anti racial,ritauls and Regeoanlism. Das is only trying to prove this Reply: Trying to prove what ? That the evil Brahmins caused the downfall of the Maratha Empire? People like Malhar Rao played and Raghunath Rao were hardly ideology drive men – they were practical hard headed men – your reasoning is faulty and based on fake history

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Bhagat · 07 Feb 2006

------------------------ The Marathas had the closet ideology to nationalism – Hindu Pad Padshahi which they attempted to foist over all India ------------------------ Balwant Roa, the closest ideology to Bharati nationalism was with the Bengalis during the British Raaj. The Bengali nationalists are the ones who came up with the whole Desh Bhagti, Vandhe-Mataram, Bharat Mata etc concepts. Before them the only other community of people who envisioned a Muslim free India were the Rajput alliance under Rana Sangha which unfortunately lost during the first battle of Panipat, otherwise India would have been free of foreign rule back then. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Balwant Rao · 08 Feb 2006

Bhagat ji I note your comments in respect of the Bengal revolutionaries - even they drew their inspirations from somewhere but please note that we must look at inherent defects in society and the art of war The Rajputs were very brave but had not concept of the Art of warfare which had diminshed from the ancient times, The Marathas reinvigorated this art by creating a system which covered the whole of India and provided (howver imperfectly) the nearest thing to a unifiying ideology which was squandered by the pride and arrogance of their later leaders

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Bhagat · 08 Feb 2006

Balwant Rao Jee, why didnt the Jats of Bharatpur help the Marathas?

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Jaggi · 08 Feb 2006

Balwant Jee why did the Marathas take Gwalior and Gohad away from the Jats of Gohad who were in control of it? Could it not be possible that because of the Marathas conquering territory of fellow native uprisings against Islamic rule, the Jats (Bharatpur, Gohad) and Sikhs did not help the Marathas during the battle of Panipat? On the other hand, when the Marathas would conquer Islamic lands ruled by Nawabs Mughals, they would leave their Islamic rulers intact, in fact they would even become the new protectors of dependent states ruled by Muslims.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Balwant Rao · 08 Feb 2006

Bhagatji, The Jats of Bharatpur had an on off relationship with the Marathas - The warrior Peshwa Baji Rao made alliances with Rajputs , Bundelas and Jats whoch his more proud followers did not follow up un full. The Holkar section of the Marathas oftern pushed for hostility with the Jats whilst the Sindhia section pursued the policy of alliance with the Jats. After the Battle of Panipat Suraj Mal of the Jats offered succour to the Marathas. Later Mahadji Sindhia made an alliance with Ranjit Singh of Bharatpur to fight the Pathan Mughal effort by Ghulam Qadir and Ismail Beg to regain control of the empire 1789-90. In the second Anglo Maratha war the British made a disastarous attack on Bharatpur lossing thousand of soldiers I do agree however that a consisent policy was not followed by the Marathas vis a vis the Jats

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Balwant Rao · 08 Feb 2006

Jaggi ji, THe Marathas due to the nature of theeir polity sometimes operated at loggerheads with each other. Thus when Bengal and Bihar was being yearly raided for the chauth by the Marathas of Nagpur the Nawab of Bengal had to pay the Marathas of Pune to restrain the Raghuji Bhonsle of Nagpur. You must note that Haider Ali and Tipu Sultan paid the chauth to the Marathas, as did Nizam of Hyderbad and the Nawab of Bengal By 1752 the wazir of the Mughals, Safdar Jung offered the tribute of Punjab and Sindh to the Marathas. this right was exercied in the invasions of 1757. Sarhind and Lahore were conquered with the help of Sikh chiefs and Adina Beg. An invasion by Timur Shah Abdali was beaten back by Sabaji Sindhia It was the ruthlessness of the Maratha soldiers that exaparated the fellow Hindu populations of India. The restraint exercised by Shivaji and Baji Rao went out of the window The Muslim chiefs of India with the excpetion of Tipu Sultan were either destroyed or ran to the British for protection Even Ahmed Shah Abdali after his victory at Panipat wrote to Balaji Baji Rao then advancing to north India with a further army that they shoudl demarcate their respective borders at the River Sutlaj. Note the British conquest of India included (1) Three wars with the Marathas , 1775-82, 1803-05 and 1818-1819 It also includes (to my knowledge) the only surrender of British land forces in Indian history at the Battle of Wadgaon in 1779 Maharashtra. which the Brits later repudiated My point is that hisory is not black and white and although being proud of Maratha history of warrior and saints I am open to the faults in my society and how these led to the final defeat of the Maratha Empire before the British. Hisotry does not rest on a few individuals but on strong and effective systems being in place If I read Sikh history correctly this is amply proved by the fate of the Sikh kingdom following the death of Ranjit Singh - the system was simply not cohesive enough to sustain without the unifying factor of the kings personality and strengh of will

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Jaggi · 08 Feb 2006

thank you Balwant jee for answering.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

teek ke nehi? · 09 Feb 2006

without the name of god and truth on their lips they Marathas jaats rajputs scindias holkars including many of our own so called sikhs, their kingdoms, will loose their shine on earth in a temporary fashion.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Balwant Rao · 10 Feb 2006

Vijaydeep You say’ He was elder brother (about Raghnath Rao) and was never allowed to succeed for his libral and anti Brahminacla Ideas. Kautilaya,Pushymitra Shunaga,Gorakh Nath(he acted in ploticis to unite all Sanatan Dharmis under Bapa Rawal to defeat Arabs) among others insptire of being born in Brahimn family did opt for Kshatriyochit or warrier worthy idelogy.and Srimant ,who never becaem Peshwa was one of them. Let live and live,Rely on others are many such instances of Brahmnaicalism while Kshatryas do thing on thier own let other relies on them. Like we have Bhai Alam Singh ,Baba Gurbabk Singh Nihung,thier Pagan forefathers were Brahimins but they acted like Kshtriya.’ I am not sure what you are talking about ? The Chitpavan Brahmins of Maharashtra have a long history of martial endeavour. Baji Rao, Madhaw Rao, The Patwardhan chiefs, even Sadashiv Bhau all were fighting men and leaders from this clan. There is no tradition or evidence that Raghunath Rao was against their belief and family systems. Indeed his long expedition to North India almost bankrupted the Maratha state. Many other Brahmins like the bhumiars of north India. And the mohyal bramhins have long histories of fighting like the kingdoms which fought in Sindh, West Punjab etc I am also not sure what you mean by pagan – this was an insulting term given to non believers by Christians in the early era and involved the disgusting murders and genocides of millions of innocent peoples – a bit like the term kaffir given to non Muslims You say’ Also Mahadji Sindhia was not poisoned but died in Pune in 1795 ----- Pandit Bala Ji Janaradan @ Nana Pahdnavees Called him for treat and let him eat poision.He was from Gwalior but died in Pune seat of Peshwa when came to negotiate. If you want you can contact Grandson of Rajmat Jotirditya Sindhiy who is MP and yuo could see the records of Gawlior. Reply: You history is utter conjecture and not backed by tradition or history. Even the worst detractors of Nana fadnavis do not claim he killed Mahadji Sindhia, Jyoti Sindhia is a 235 year old youg man – Why would I ask him about history and events from m 300 years ago ? You say’ Caste of Holker was low and Sindhia supported them sometime till Tukoji took over.’ Reply: Sindhia and Holkar were of the same caste – their struggle was for control over the northern Maratha empire You say’Jaats made the offer when they won Delhi to remove Muslims just before Third War of Panipat.Raja Surajmal wanted Jaats to have Delhi. Sadashiv Rao prefered Moghal over hindu Jaats and Jaats who were so far allies of Marthas against Abdali left Martha camp. das gives you the Name of Sardar Bhan Singh Jaat and Antu Raam Aheer who reprsented Jaats. As true Brahmincal tendency to show idealism which was shown by Daheer(Sindh),Anandpal(Brahimin Shahi of Punjab),Jawahar Lal Nehru and AB Vajpayee was shown by Bhau and supported by Peshwa. commitment to moghuls. Peshwa means prime minster and was hardly commited to own Bhonsle king but yet showed mental slavery to Moghuls. At the time of Wiining Attaock they were form Attock to Cuttock and even one kingdon as south as thanjuor(Gurumurti of Swadeshi Jagran Manch is Martha Brahimn from there only). If Marthas were fighting among themselve then how can they go in to unite Hindus either? But at that time till Thierd war of Panipat all were under Peshwa but peshwa was bit soft himself and defensive. Had he wanted he could have used his power with support of Marathas to remove Moghuls then just over take Delhi.It was lack of political will and want to let old traditon remain and let moghul king keep on giving them praise to be genous and at the cost of humilation to Hindus. And Jaats were prevented to remmove Moghual King Reply: All I can say Vijaydeep is please read some history – The History of the Jats by Wendel and another book by Natwar Singh say that Suraj Mal was infuriated by the Marathas taking the gold from the Mughal palaces and alienating the Mughal remnants and by his talk of converting the Taj mhal into a temple. No Mughal fought with the Marathas at Panipat You comments about brahmincal tendency to compare Anandapal who died fighting Mahmud Ghazni in West Punjab [three generations of these brahmhins died fighting the invaders of Punjab !], Dahir who was martryed fighting the Arabs in Sindh to worthless politicians like Nehru and Vajpayee is staggering ! You say that the Peshwa should have removed the Mughal king yet you fail to realize that the era of Maratha supremacy had hardly a year of peace in which to consolidate their gains – Even the Brits kept the fiction of the Mughals for decades until 1857 - And to say that the Jats were prevented to remove the Mughal King – I have never heard this, please clarify Furthermore I understand what you say about the head of the Nihung Misls and I honour their commitment and bravery Vijaydeep says’ There were at least some attempts to convert by Sikhs. But say if your Peshwa or say king of Jhansi even married the Muslim Lady thier sons were still a Muslims. Even in Bhagalpur or Gujrat Hindus never tried to convert before killing. In Gomantak Veer Savarkar only imagined but never did Muslim was converted back(Reconversion and conversion are two differant things). They you still are harping on the wrong thing. Jaffeta Khan tried to humliate the Moghul familiesand blineded the Shah Alam ,then just for the sake of Commitment to moghuls as thier servent Marathas came to help Moghuls. GHULAM QADIR WAS KILLED BY DEBINE(FRENCH) AND RANA KHAN,AFTERR CAPTURE FROM MEERNAPUR AREA OF MEERUT BY AFTER MARTHAS RESTORTED MOGHUL RULE.THE TWO PEOPLE FRENCH AND MUSLIM WERE PART OF MARTHA ARMY.EVEN THEN MAHADJI WOULD HAVE KILLED SHAH ALAM AND OVERTOOK DELHI.IF JAATS WERE WITH HIM THEN WHAT PREVENTED HIM TO DO SO?MARTHA(KSHTRIYA ALSO BECAME LIKE BRAHMIN IN IDELAOGY OF HINDUS).IT IS LIKE NINAMI BABA OF GOMANATAK BY VEER SAVARKAR. Perhaps bro yuo want to make a new history.Check the sources of Sikhs,Non Peshwa Marthas,non Martha Hindus and Muslims.anyway writers of that time were also biased. As per Bhangu's book during Afghan attackes only Koel forst was remaned as Aligarh from Ramgarh when Jaats were removed from there. Marthas did not let jaats make it ramgarh again.Jaats were not allowed to retake it by Marthas and you talk of thier allinace. Reply: in respect of conversions there are clans in Maharashtra today who were previousl Muslim and became Hindu from this time. Your other points refers to modern day riots and I don’t think I even have to answer such an absurdity Many Muslims were followers of groups such as the Sikhs, Satnamis, Kabirpanthis, even the Thugees were composed of many Muslims Furthermore you talk of history let me repeat it was the Marathas who defeated Ghulam Qadir not a French/Muslim combine as you have tried to mishevioulsy contend. That is like saying Ranjit Singhs army was French because of a few dozen French commanders ! They were two generals in any army which also included Rayaji Patil, Ambaji Inlge, Lakhwa Dada etc etc. Mahadji Sindhi before battle used to pray before his family diety with Rana Khan Bhai. You must release hatred from your heart Vijaydeep if you are to read history correctly and paint black and white pictures In the attacks by Abdali on India the Sikhs used to rise on all sides against him, Sixty Thousand Marathas died at Panipat to defend the land, thousands of Jaats perished fighting before Mathura in 1757 and then Suraj Mal stood in this forts to face the Afghans in 1761 with determination, thousands of Naga Sadhus defended the Gokul from the attacks of Abdalis general Sardar Jahan Khan You say’Under the Muslim Moghul rulers. Even the last Peshwa and his son in Bithur in 1857 beheld Moghul Bahadurshah the 2nd as emeror of India. So reason of their unsuccefullness was to sometime put Muslims over hindus’ Reply: I wonder if you would interpret history differently if the Peshwas were not Brahmins ? I am beginning to see a connection. I am a Jadhav Maratha and even in Marathi itihas there is rivalry between the castes but I do not let this cloud my judgments Nana Saheb in 1857 proclaimed himself the Peshwa first – he was attempting to take over the edifice that the British took from the Marathas in 1818 You say’ Shudhi can be done to Rangherh or Meo(Rajputs) back to Hindus but Sayyads or Pathans/turk from Arebia or Afgnaishtan/Turkistan needed the conversion.It is only in writing of Veer Savarker. Reply: What nonsense and incorrect conjecture ! After a millennia of attacks on our nation it takes time to recover. Read the Ali Ahmeds book’ Religion and Politics in the Mughal Empire’; to understand the numerous attempts by the later Mughals from Aurangzeb to prevent Muslims becoming Hindus or marrying Hindu men Much of Savarkars historical writings writeen in the time of the freedom struggle have been proved to be wrong You say; It is not anti hindu(a race) but good for them but anti to hinduism(as an idelogy) which has been shrinking from Afghansitan to Indonashia into present sate where Kashmeer is in danger. Till in the name of self respect wrong doings in past are not recified and thier false justification is not ended hindus will keep on getting reduced and getting defeated. Wrong of past are still not rectified. hindus are still exploited by Hindus,and non Hindus being put front over hindu welfare like hindus themselfve making Mrs Sonia Ghandhi or Mr Rajeev Khan S/O Feroz Khand as leader. Advani singing jai jinnah.Bala Saheb Thakre abusing Biharis and Purbias out of Maharsthra(old tendency of hindu Pad Pad ShahI).So still do not understand that as per Vedas and Vedanta there is not race called Hindu leave aside race called Marathas,Rajputs or Jaats.All worship Sanatan God Purush or Prabrahma and all of civlised Race called Araya. That God is god of Sikhs Called Akal. Reply; I repeat that the book is a worthless load of nonsense despite the Hindu sounding name- I wonder why a Sikh internet site finds it important to place that on their recommended book list ? Why Vijaydeep ? The Hindus today are one sixth of humanity – Hindu ideas are gaining greater acceptance around the world and people and rediscovering their roots and ideals prior to the fascist monotheist takeover of the world- I Don’t however believe in slaughtering modern day Muslims to prove that I am rectifying the inequities of the past You talk of Bala Thackery abusing outsiders to Maharashtra – and I agree – he is wrong and should be condemned as such – Will you also condemn the condemning of outsiders in Punjab as Bhaiyas and the rest You say’ Brahims are not evil but Brahmnical ways or Viprwad is Bad.Samrath Ramdas Ji fought with it(He was an allie of our Sixth Guru),when Brahimns hated Chhartapati Shiva Ji terming him as Sudra.Sanskritsation was done by terming Bhonsale as sisodiya of Mewars.It was just and eqavtion being made.Esle No sisodiya recoganise Bhonase as sisodia. Last thing which you said practical men thats what das wanted to prove. History can be faked but then it makes future and present unfit to live. so again it is up to you.’ REPLY: The whole word brahminsm is a misnomer- in many cases so called brahminism is actually referring to caste domination of one over the other and not literally the domination of Brahmins over other castes – like Rajputs and Yadavs in UP, Bhumhiars and Yadavs in Bihar and Jats in Punjab and Harayana. The term ‘brahminism’ has given other caste groups who have exercised domination over their respective areas for hundreds of years a convenient scapegoat to blame others for their own sins of omission and commission You are living in a fake world full of fake history and convenient scapegoats to blame for all evil What other lies you are pedalling !; some Brahmins did not co- operate with Shivaji whilst others aided in his coronation, many others like Moro Pant loyally served him – many Marathas and Kunbis also opposed him like the Ghorpares and Mores You say: Past is gone but present and futrue is in your Hand.Das was a supporter of Bala Saheb Thakery till he staerted to remove Biharis from Maharsthra and such things still are there. He can not make them Marathi.But Sikhs have made mnay biharis as Sikhs in bihar and in Punajb also.Das could be one of them. REPLY: I have never been a supporter of Bal Thackery and his brand of Shiva Sena. Tens and Thousands of Christians and Muslims have become Hindu in India in recent years – read about Duleep Singh Judeo in Chatisgarh, the programes in Orrisa, Jharkhand, and western India Majority of even Marathi people are not supporters of Shiva Sena Also poor immigrants often take the manners and habits of the land to which they immigrate – do not Sikhs abroad do the same thing – is this because Sikhism is deficient – I think not ! You say’ Das wanted to prove the varous points. 1. unlike other sections Sikhs were more nearer to Islam as they do not recoganise the regianl and racial boundaries and do carry out conversion. 2. there was nothing to do with Hinduism or Indianness with Sikhs as like sematic faith Sikhism does not recoganise bounbdaries of nations or Race. Like Marathas of Maharashtra or Hindus or Hindustan. 3. Till Hindu do not incorporate such a mentilty(as Swami Vevekananda said that thier body must be like that of Islam) thier coming generation may have names like john or Mohumud.only way out is to have surname Singh so only your childrem may mnaitain names like Ram or Shyam. 4. due to idelogy like that Sikhs were hardly any good allies for Marthas but alliance and wars were made on lotical bases and gain to be made. 5. Lastly after wining Punjab twice there is no mark of Marathas left there yet in Mahrastra,without ever having any victory march there,in Marthwada Region and the area near Nagpur we will get Sikhs whose moterh tongue is Marathi(Das is not taling about Punjabi immigernts,Deccanis or Hajuris) but those Sikhs who are from lowr caste or tribe. REPLY: by point (1) I do not agree – virtually every Sikh I have met identifies totally with Punjab as if Sikhism and Punjabi are one and the same thing – Also did not the Sikh political party, Akali Dal in its resolutions repeat that the Sikhs are a race – many Sikh publications also stress this point – Also are not the similarities with Islam superficial – to my understanding the spiritual background of Sikh religion is eastern based – You are wrong again by ignoring Hindu groups like Arya Samaj and Pranamathis which are functionally much closer to Islam that Sikhism (2) You say Sikhs have nothing to do with Hindusim – fine, good luck I am not bothered to dispute that point. As for Hindus we are one sixth of humanity with increasing populations in Bali, Indonesia, South East Asia and Europe, true Hinduism is slowly spreading its wings – we are not a semitic faith and proud of it – semitic faiths have spread murder, genocide and terror for two thousand years so good luck with being semitic ! (3) You third point is utter rubbish – we of Maharashtra don’t need anybody to defend us, Aurangzeb dug his grave in our land and our warriors and saints travessed from the deep south of India to the border with Afghanistan, fought the British, led the freedom movement – The surname Rao is enough for us ! we remember the martyrdoms of Baji Rao Prabhu, Tanaji Malusare, Shambaji son of Shivaji and Pandit Kavi Kalash wsho were hacked to death limb by limb (4) I have already provided you with an answer to this point – your ideological pontifications are rubbish and based on conjecture (5) Once again your point is nonsensical prejudice, there are many Marathi Pathaks, Raos and others all over North India. We are not a prejudiced people and honour the Sikhs who live amongst us – it is a sign of strength and not weakness You say; In fact had we not had some pagans in the guise of Sikhs who themselves were racial,we would have had Baba Saheb Ambedkar as Sikh(one of his Brother did becaome on of us). 6. Lastly it is a bit absurd to compare Sikhs and Marthas why? Say Mongols(a race) can not be compared to Islam a Faith.There are some who are mongols only,some are Muslim mongols and some non mongol Muslims. REPLY: What the hell is Pagans to do with Hindus – yet again you reflect a prejudiced mindset. Ambedkar rejected Sikhism because he found it more caste ridden than Hinduism . Pagans have been slaughtered in the tens of millions from North America to Europe and Asia for thousands of years in the name of your liberating semitic ideologies that you are praising and trying so hard to be a part of - Is this where you wish to see Sikhism headed ? You say; We need to read the accunt of last Anglo Maratha war by Veer Swarkar where he does not dessit from self critism.That can only be done by Kshatriya Guna which Rama had,Ravan maintained the Brahaminical guna to listen all good things and let Vibhishan run away.such things are good for prist,docter or Teacher but in plotics might matters.and critical annalysis matters. defeat of Sikhs was due to pagan influnce of race or regeonalism and Sikhs are working hard to remove it.But by praising Maratha or say Jaats or Rajputs etc. Hindus are still on the tract downfall,why do not wake up. REPLY: Your jaundiced mindset is unbelievable – If I read Sikh history correctly they were locked in intercine and bitter struggle with each other for decades before the rise of Ranjit Singh. Even then five of the twelve misl chiefs preferred to remain first under Maratha and then British influence ( are they also part of the Pagan mindset ?!) Then after the death of the great Ranjit Singh the contradictions in his empire came to the surface and the empire collapased due to these contradictions – your pontificating is not much different to an Evangeical Christian or an Al Qaeda Muslim – where no fault can ever be theirs but all evils come from the ‘Other’ You need to liberate your mind and instead of trying to find scapegoats for the downfalls of history try and clear your mind I am proud of Marathi history and achievements but am open to our mistakes and failures I honour the many acheivments of the Sikh people but that does not preclude me from making a critical analysis of their mistakes and failure rather than put it down to a few evil Brahmins or evil pagans that is the only true road to success You solution that we should reject Marathi, Rajput and other Hindu historical inspirations is utterly absurd – another example of a disgusting racism and prejudice to your fellow man – you are saying that ONLY Sikhism can save us if we reject our disgusting pagan polytheist Hindu beliefs – I reject this utterly as representative of a fascist and racist mindset – I respect, honour and ACCEPT all Dharma’s It is good to be proud of who you are (although at one time you say you have Brahmin relatives and then Teli – but never mind) but if that pride means despising your fellow man then what have you learnt from Dharma ? I will be happy remaining a dark skinned Maratha pagan any day of the week Are you a Das of God or of Untruth ? You need to ask yourself Asato maa sad Gamaya Tamaso Maa Jyotir Gamaye Mritorma Amritam Ganaya Lead from darkness to light Lead me from untruth to truth Lead me from Death to Immortality

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

K Singh · 10 Feb 2006

I personally think that the Marathas like the Jats of Bharatpur were an honourable people who courageously defeated the Muslims many times. Although I do think that the Marathas made a few political mistakes because of which the Jats and Sikhs did not ally themselves with them during the 3rd battle of panipat, but because of this lack of unity during the battle, the British found their chance in enslaving India. The 3rd battle of Panipat was to the Marathas as Waterloo was to Napolean or as Sabroan was for the Sikhs. Rajputs in that century had lost their boldness that they were once known for and even went further to write letters to Abdali to invade India and restore the Mughal Empire. Had these three (Marathas, Sikhs, Jats) powers united, the British would have never taken India.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Bhagat · 10 Feb 2006

I don’t think that we should be comparing Sikhs and Marathas or Marathas and Jats, or Jats with Rajputs. All did their part to free India of the Sharia law. All three of the major powers i.e. Marathas, Jats, and Sikhs made some political Mistakes during those times. Sikhs history is litered with political mistakes (just read 'Sikhs in history' by Dr. Sangat Singh). As for Sindh that first fell to the Arabs. The reason for that was because the Jats of Sindh turned on the side of the arabs and helped them. They did this because the Jats who were the former rulers of Sindh were displaced by the new Brahman elite that ruled Sindh with an Iron fist. They treated the Jats very badly as Shudras. So when the Arabs invaded Sindh, the Jats saw their opportunity to take revenge and joined the invading Arab armies in conquering Sindh. The Sindhi army fought very bravely but ultimately were defeated by the Arabs. The Jats of Sindh who helped the Arabs then migrated to modern day Iraq and settled their amongst the Arabs. But not all the Jats helped the invading Muslims. The Jats in the form of Kharals, Ghakkars fought against Mahmud Gaznavi, Tamar Lane, Babbar and the ones in Bharatpur gave resistance to the Mughals and Abdali’s Afghans. As for the Hindu Shahi kingdom of Gandhara (Afghanistan) ruled by Anandpal. I have to agree with Balwant Rao Jee on this one. The Hindu Shahi kings should be praised as they died fighting for generations against the invading Muslims. It is only until the Hindu Shahi kingdom was destroyed that the Islamic terror was unleashed into all of India. If it were not for the Hindu Shahi Kings resistance, this would have happened atleast a hundred years earlier. Sikhs are not a race but a faith based group. A Sikh can be anyone whether he is Punjabi, Maratha, Jats, Bihari, Tamil, Gora, Kala etc. Once a person becomes a Sikh, one relinquishes the birth caste and becomes Khalsa. You become the same substance as your Guru (Khalsa mero roop hai khaas). Even a Muslims can become a Sikh as many Muslims became Sikhs when Banda Singh Bahadur ruled. One of his most trusted officers was Ali Singh who was formerly a Muslim and even became a Shaheed along with other Singhs. Sikhi is the faith that can unite the Hindus and Muslims as brethren, because a Muslim will never become a Hindu and a Hindu will not want to become a Muslim. Khalsa Dharm is such that it is acceptable to all and any. Even if we read Sikh history we read how the Gurus had even Muslim followers and premees. [%sig%]

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Balwant Rao · 13 Feb 2006

Vijaydeep It is said that a little bit of knowledge in the hands of the semi literate can prove dangerous You have once again proved this matter. I did not think that it was possible for one man to provide so much incorret information and malicious twist to historical and religious events Without bothering to launch into a lon boring polemic like yours I can only summarise some of your errors (1) Your rantings about Brahmin and Kshatariya gunas are of course nonsense. The only guna required for power has been strength and the ability to weild it (2) You take about Hindus as Pagans, a racist and milcicous term given by Christians to ‘unbeleivers’ This is clearly represtatative of a fascist mindset. It does not matter if a few Hindus and Europeans have taken this name. After two millennia of genocide and attack it is gpoing to leave some people confused. If you see Sikh people on the Semitic side of world religion then good luck to you ! You leave the freedom and acceptance of Eastern Dharma for the rage and hatred of the Semitric faiths ! (3) You try and prove that Mahadji Sindhia was poisoned based on a bollywood drama [Need I say any more ?] (4) You first say that Sindhia and Holkar hated each other because they were form different castes and then because they worhsipped different devtas – You need to admit when you have been proved wrong and stop trying to make nonsense (1) Your talks about Jaats and Marathas are the biggest nonsense. You are basing your history on a bollywood serial ! How Pathetic ! to clarify it was Bhau who wanted to convert the Taj Mahal into a temple not the other way around (2) Imad ul Mulk was nothing but a tool of the Mughals (3) The war with the Afghans was fought for control of the Mughal Empire NOT for the Mughal Empire ! This is proved in a thousand documents and histories ! (4) You lies about the Nagas are continued. The Nagas fought a grim hand to hand battle with the Afgahns to defend Goukul which is testified in the corespondece between Abdali and Sardar Khan You are confusing the story with the bishnois of Rajastahn who hugged the trees to protect them Another example of a semi literate trying to put down Hindu peoples and their achievements Your history of the Hindu Shahi kings is all wrong – you cannot blame the recruitment of a few Muslims as being the downfall of a kingdom Finally the Hindus have been converting people for thousands of years We have not sprung from thin air or from a single race ! Historians like KS Lal have shown that during the middles ages whilst the North and west of India was under attack and the Buddhists massacared and converted to Islam an equal if not more tribes were brought to Hinduism in the north and south and beyond This has been happening from time immemorial And a counter point A hundred years ago the Sikh Dharma had adherents from Punjab to Sind and beyond The rigid semitising of the faith and ( like you trying to tell me that the Sikh God is different from the Hindu God(s) ) began not long after with the search for purity and the ridding of Hindu influences And therefore from potentially having seventy to eighty milliond adheresnt today are limited to twenty million Makes me think that some people are so far behind in the race they actually think that they are winning God bless you

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

... · 13 Feb 2006

Balwant, When you dillute something enough, you lose the original essence. I would much rather have a dharam of 20 million adherents who recognise the original message than 800 million adherents who have created something totally new with the same name.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Bhagat · 13 Feb 2006

Sikhi is an eastern religion which believes in Karma, reincarnation, meditation etc. It is not a Semitic faith which is about violence, intolerance, Jaziya towards the 'unbelievers’ and getting multiple amount of hoors in heaven for sex. Read the Bhagwat Gita and compare it with our philosophy and you will see the similarities, on the other hand read the Koran and compare it with our philosophy and you will barely see any philosophical similarity.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

samething · 18 Feb 2006

why were so many sikh's laying down their lives for the british against their own brothers who were fighting for india's independence and how did we contribute to the indian freedom movement when their were so many sikh's who worked for the british raj and i know we made up majority of the freedom fighters but we pretty much cancelled eachother out. And don't write a book were you guy's copy and paste something from a website that is like 12 pages long put it in simple forms i don't have that much time to read all of this stuff.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Bhagat · 18 Feb 2006

Samething Jee, Sikhs did not crush Sikh freedom movements or other Indian nationalist movements. Sikhs were mainly in the Indian armies. Like the Gurkhas and other martial races, Sikhs dominated the army. It was the Police of India was carried out the dirty work of crushing Indian and Sikh freedom movements. Most Sikh freedom fighters were themselves formerly soldiers in the Indian army. In Punjab and other areas of Northern India, the police was dominated by Punjabi and Pathan Muslims. That was one of the main reasons why the Indian police did very little in helping Sikhs and Hindus during the 47 riots, rather they would help the Muslim rioters by supplying them weapons. The only freedom movement Sikhs helped the British crush was the sepoy mutiny. Sikhs had reasons for doing this. Firstly, the sepoys who mutinied were the same sepoys who had helped the British during the Anglo-Sikh wars few years earlier. Sikhs saw this as an opportunity to exact revenge against those very same sepoys. Secondly, the Sepoys were fighting under the banner of restoring the Mughal Emperor, and this again gave Sikh soldiers a reason to fight.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

samething · 08 Mar 2006

if the sikh's in the army were freedom fighters wouldn't india had their freedom right away considering their would be no army left if the army wants to rebell.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

samething · 26 Mar 2006

At the end of the day the sikh's cancelled themselves out even though they provided the most freedom fighters they also produced the most soilders loyal to the british army and i read these articles of how proud sikh's were to serve in the british army during world war 2 well no one really knows we served in world war 2 and seems like rest of the world doesn't care because they see us as puppets who had to help the british in world war 2.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

JS · 26 Mar 2006

Apart from the Sikhs, Dogras, Gurkhas, The Bombay and Madras contingents of the British East India army, and many provinces and princely states stayed loyal to the British. The Sikhs had a valid reason as the same sepoys had carried out attrociticies in the Punjab during and after the Sikh Wars, but why did all these others stay loyal to Britain?

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

PTE SINGH · 27 Mar 2006

The Hindu bashing in these messages is disgraceful and unbecoming of any real Sikh. Please remember that It was the Punjabis of all religions Sikh, Hindu and Muslims that formed Ranjit Singhs army not just Sikhs. Also Ranjit Singhs Punjab was Sutlej upwards, all the Punjabis including the Sikhs which are from Malwa had sided with British long before the anglo Sikh wars. The Sikh Hindu and Muslim Punjabis of Doaba and Maja fought gallantly against the British and there native allies, and were not going to mutiny with them a mere 8 years latter to reinstall a mogul emperor as was the intension of those sepoys in 1857. 1857 was a mutiny, the last true battle for india's freedom was in Punjab in 1849 unfortunatly bar the true Punjabis the rest of india was on the other side.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

samething · 27 Mar 2006

everyone in india stayed loyal to the british but so did the sikh's why did they, they ended up getting used and were robbed by the british while sikh's helped them do it and died for the british army fighting their wars rather then fighting our own to get our freedom and if we all got together and drove the british out then the sikh's could of ruled all of south asia pakistan bangledish india would all be under sikh rule.

Re: Why the Sikhs did not help Marathas against Abdali?

Balwant Rao · 16 May 2006

I dont understand why the Sikhs would seek to take revenge on the sepoys on 1857 but not on the British rulers. That make no sense at all And also why not seek revenge against the Patiala, Nabha, Jind Sikh Rajahs who fought on the side of the British in the Sikh Wars ?