Re: QUOTES ON WOMEN IN SIKHI
Balpreet Singh · 10 Nov 2003
The Chaupa Singh rehitnama is interesting on different levels. Chaupa Singh was a Chhiber Brahmin and sometimes he seems to let a bit of a Brahmin bias enter into his work. At other times he is completely egalitarian and condemns caste in all forms. "Naa daekhai Khatree, naa daekhai Shood ki Vaish hai. Sikh Guru kaa daekhai, jaat barn naa daekhai" meaning "One should not look at whether someone is Khatri or Shudra or Vaish. One should look whether someone is a Sikh, one should not look at caste or clan." (77) All my references on this rehitnama come from the Padam book.
The Chaupa Singh rehitnama also contains a number of internal contradictions which indicate that it has been tampered with. One very clear case is the situaton of "saluting the sun". "Guru kaa Sikh praatay outh kay sooraj noo(n) namastay aakh kay, Sikhaa(n) noo Vahiguru Jee kee Fateh bulai" (91) meaning, when a Sikh rises in the morning, he should say "namastay" to the Sun and then Fateh to the Singhs. That's problematic on a number of fronts, seeing as how Sikhs don't revere the sun and the sun hasn't risen when a Sikh gets up (last part of night ie. amrit vela). But the rehitnama later contradicts itself: "Jo sooraj dayvtay noo namaskaar karay, so Tankhaiyaa" (105), meaning, "One who salutes/does namaskaar to the sun is a Tankhaiyaa".
And so I come to the issue of women in the Chaupa Singh rehitnama. This again is a very confused issue. I havn't seen the manuscript you quote which says not to give Paahul to women, but the common Chaupa Singh rehitnama says the following: "Jo Sikh, SikhNee noo(n) khanday dee paahul naa dayvay, so Tankhaiyaa" (105) meaning, "that Sikh who does not give khanday kee paahul to a female-Sikh, is a Tankhaiyaa".
Even in regards to reading Sree Guru Granth Sahib, your references are correct, but the same rehitnama then goes on to say, "Guru kee SikhNee Granth Sahib pothee paRn sikhay..." (107) meaning a female-Sikh should learn how to read Sree Guru Granth Sahib.
Overall, we can learn interesting things from rehitnamas, but we can't consider them to be the authority on rehit. Rehit has been passed down amongst Gursikhs and it's hard to find but it still exists. Only that rehit is authentic which can pass the test of GurbaaNee.
Re: QUOTES ON WOMEN IN SIKHI
going nuts! · 10 Nov 2003
>>>>>>>>>>
Overall, we can learn interesting things from rehitnamas, but we can't consider them to be the authority on rehit. Rehit has been passed down amongst Gursikhs and it's hard to find but it still exists. Only that rehit is authentic which can pass the test of GurbaaNee.
>>>>>>>>>>
so does this rule out the kesgi being a kakkar? is dastar and keski interchangeable as a term. Bani mentions sabat soorat dastar.
bat vehis say keski is a kakkar
Re: QUOTES ON WOMEN IN SIKHI
Balpreet Singh · 11 Nov 2003
I think you've misunderstood. What I was trying to say was that if a rehitnama says something contrary to baaNee ie. women are polluted, then we can't accept that rehitnama over baaNee.
I'm not sure how keskee debate comes into this at all. Sree Guru Granth Sahib does not give instructions on what is a kakaar, etc. This information is given by the Punj Pyaaray ie. Guru Khalsa during amrit sinchaar. I find it really odd how regardless of the issue, the same topics of keskee, ragmala, etc. come into any discussion. Let's try to avoid this.
Re: QUOTES ON WOMEN IN SIKHI
Not much of a Gursikh · 11 Nov 2003
Thanks Balpreet Singh Ji for your posting. I had read some of the rehatnamay from Chaupa Singhs version and was quite shocked and upset. It comforting to hear someones researched opinion.
Re: QUOTES ON WOMEN IN SIKHI
going nuts! · 12 Nov 2003
does the mistakes in the rehitname invalidate Chaupa Singhs work? how do we know where he made mistakes and where he did not...yet alot of the jatha follow his work.
Re: QUOTES ON WOMEN IN SIKHI
Balpreet Singh · 15 Nov 2003
I wasn't actually shocked by the question, I just forgot about it. It's not shocking at all.
When it comes to rehitnamas and a lot of other older sources, the individual has to compare with other older sources and test what's said according to baaNee. Some things are clearly put in at a later date, while others aren't. All it means is that someone who's studying these has to thoughtfully analyse what's been written.