Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

God & Guru

God & Guru

- · 05 Nov 2003

I'm confused about whether the Guru IS God or not - in Gurbani ive read that it says to see God and the Guru as ONE - but at the same time, Guru Gobind Singh said that anyone who calls him God will be punished horribly! Gurbani also says that the brahm giani is God him/herself - so why wouldn't the Guru be God? ("brahm giani aap nirankaar") I don't understand this When I'm having problems doing simran because I can't concentrate or think clearly, I think of Guru Nanak or Guru Gobind Singh, and the ways that they helped people, the bravery they encompassed, the love that they had for God and even for their Sikhs. This really inspires me, and I just keep thinking "Dhan Guru Nanak" or "Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Sahib" (and all the Gurus in between) -- because they were amazing.. It seems easier to think of them when I'm down, and when I think of Guru Ji I just go into a weird state of bairaag ... but someone told me its wrong to do this, that we should worship God, not the Gurus.. I thought it was the same thing... It's just that, sometimes its easier to imagine the Gurus, as compared to Vaheguru who is limitless.. can someone please explain a bit about this topic? it's really confusing me.

Re: God & Guru

&1 · 05 Nov 2003

When Guru Gobind Singh said not to call them God it was because of the humbleness they had. Gur Parmeshar Eko Jaan Gur Parmeshar Bhed Naa Bhai Guru Nanak Dev Ji is the avtaar of God. And it was the same jot that was in all the Gurus. Whomever considers a difference between the Gurus cannot call themself a Sikh. Guru Nanak is Guru Gobind Singh is GOd.

Re: God & Guru

Kulbir Singh · 05 Nov 2003

>>>>>>> When I'm having problems doing simran because I can't concentrate or think clearly, I think of Guru Nanak or Guru Gobind Singh, and the ways that they helped people, the bravery they encompassed, the love that they had for God and even for their Sikhs. This really inspires me, and I just keep thinking "Dhan Guru Nanak" or "Dhan Guru Gobind Singh Sahib" (and all the Gurus in between) -- because they were amazing.. It seems easier to think of them when I'm down, and when I think of Guru Ji I just go into a weird state of bairaag ... but someone told me its wrong to do this, that we should worship God, not the Gurus.. I thought it was the same thing... It's just that, sometimes its easier to imagine the Gurus, as compared to Vaheguru who is limitless.. >>>>>>>> We should do what our Guru Sahibaan have taught us to do. Our Guru Sahibaan have asked us to worship Akal Purakh or Satguru, THROUGH NAAM. That is what we should do. Doing Naam abhyaas is saying dhan dhan to Guru and Vaheguru. To do Guru Guru or Vaah Vaah we should do Naam abhyaas. There is no other way. Along with Naam we should sing praises of Vaheguru, THROUGH Gurbani. In Sikhi Naam is the centre of worship. Through Naam and Gurbani we worship Guru/Vaheguru. No other way. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: God & Guru

- · 05 Nov 2003

But then is there anything wrong in singing 'dhan guru nanak dev sahib ji', 'dhan guru angad dev sahib ji', etc..? If at times it's hard to do simran sometimes it makes it easier (for me) to think of guru jee directly first and that helps me to concentrate on simran because you realize the jot of god that was in all of the gurus.. and this makes me think of Waheguru, who is everywhere in everything, in all beings always... I can't explain it, it just helps me.. But it's just that, someone told me - what if I'm singing praises of guru gobind singh or any of the gurus and that turns out to be my last moment -- if i pass away while singing the gurus praises, this person said that ant kaal vich, you should be singing praises of only waheguru... but praising guru and waheguru is the same isn't it? Because it's not like you're praising the physical guru - your praising the WAHEGURU within the guru -- the jot of god is what makes the guru so amazing. You're praising that right I am sorry if I'm confusing you :-(

Re: God & Guru

Mkhalsa · 05 Nov 2003

what if u died while watching tv.. i saying dhan guru nanak dev jee is a lot better than that!

Re: God & Guru

princess of power · 06 Nov 2003

i had the same question...funn thing is no one seems to be answering it....they telling you to do simran which you are doing....but is it alright to think of Guru Ji as God?

Re: God & Guru

&1 · 06 Nov 2003

Gurbani tells us whoever says Dhan to Guru Jee, a jamdoot doesn't come close to that person.

Re: God & Guru

answer · 06 Nov 2003

The reason why Guru Gobind Singh ji didn't want anyone to call him "parmeshwar" was because he didn't want people to put up his pictures or make an idol of him and start worshiping. He always quoted "gyan guru atam updayso naam biboot lagao" The guru is Gyan and have the naam close to you. He never wanted his Sikhs to worship his body as God, like the hindus do. He always taught the Sikhs to focus on Akaal. There is no doubt that a Brahmgyani and the Brahm are one "ram kabeera ek bay hai koi na sakay pachanee" but taking that into perspective, if you focus on the body or idol of Guru Nanak and not the Shabad that was inside him, then we're still in kindergarten like the state of India during the time Before Guru Sahib whereas the focus on shabad is more of an academic level Hope that helps

Re: God & Guru

Jinder · 06 Nov 2003

Man, I think you are failing the point. Guru Gobind Singh Ji came to this world to tell eveyrone about Waehguru, to believe in Rabh. Guru Gobind Singh Ji in Sri Bachitar Natak Granth explicitly states that those who will worship him, will go to hell. Guru Ji states this, becuase previously all the Rishis and Bhagats started making people worship them. Guru Ji said that he would never want his disciples to worship him, rather than Akal Purakh. I

Re: God & Guru

Singh · 06 Nov 2003

Guru Sahib is God. That is clear from gurbani. The quote from Guru Sahib has been translated wrongly - it actually means that anyone who calls themselves God will burn in hell. Guru And God are the one and the same.

Re: God & Guru

- - - - · 06 Nov 2003

there isnt any difference between GURU AND WAHEGURU...

Re: God & Guru

- · 06 Nov 2003

"Guru Gobind Singh Ji in Sri Bachitar Natak Granth explicitly states that those who will worship him, will go to hell." Well, what do you mean by 'worship' - that could mean anyone who worships his physical image or body, right? I think when people praise Guru Gobind Singh they praise how he sacrificed his whole family for Sikhi, how he was not only brave and fearless but a perfect saint soldier, he was the GURU, man... He was sweet and humble but also a brilliant warrior..It's just because he was the Guru, he was jeevan mukht..He was the embodiment of God, i think in one of BHai Nand Lal Jees writings it says "Guru Gobind Har Ka Roop Na" -- he was the roop of God.. Its not like you're worshipping him because of his body or anything, you're worshipping him because he practically was like God, you're worshipping him for the God that u see in him.. I dont know Jinder, what do you think Most other people are saying Guru and God are the same

Re: God & Guru

s!nghn! · 06 Nov 2003

(Siree Raag M: 4, Ang 77) gur sathigur suaamee bhaedh n jaanahu jith mil har bhagath sukhaa(n)dhee || Know that there is no difference between the Guru, the True Guru, and your Lord and Master. Meeting with Him, take pleasure in the Lord's devotional service. _ _ _ _ _ _ (Asaa M:4, Ang 442) gur govi(n)dh guovi(n)dh guroo hai naanak bhaedh n bhaaee ||4||1||8|| The Guru is God, and God is the Guru, O Nanak; there is no difference between the two, O Siblings of Destiny. ||4||1||8|| _ _ _ _ _ _ (Gujri M:1, Ang 504) baddae bhaag gur saevehi apunaa bhaedh naahee guradhaev muraar || The most fortunate ones serve their Guru; there is no difference between the Divine Guru and the Lord. _ _ _ _ _ _ (Bhairon M:5, Ang 1142) paarabreham gur naahee bhaedh ||4||11||24|| There is no difference between the Supreme Lord God and the Guru. ||4||11||24|| _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (Bhatt Mathuraa, Svaiyay Mehl 5, Ang 1409) eih padhhath thae math chookehi rae man bhaedh bibhaedh n jaan beeao || O mortal being, do not leave this path; do not think that there is any difference between God and Guru. _ _ _ _ _ _ (Bhatt Mathuraa, Svaiyay Mehl 5, Ang 1409) bhan mathhuraa kashh bhaedh nehee gur arajun parathakhy har ||7||19|| So speaks Mat'huraa: there is no difference between God and Guru; Guru Arjun is the Personification of the Lord Himself. ||7||19||

Re: God & Guru

- · 07 Nov 2003

But then, why would Guru Gobind Singh say that

Re: God & Guru

Singhani · 07 Nov 2003

Har Ka Sewak Har Hee Jeha... Gur Parmesar Eko Jaan... I think the above illustrates the Guru and God are one and the same. Gurfateh