Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh hash smugglers

Sikh hash smugglers

Singh · 22 Nov 2005

Canadian Sikhs need to stop their press using the word Sikh to describe Punjabis or Indo canadians. TV movie explores our sordid side Fantasy trip from Da Vinci's Inquest creator has look of reality Ian Mulgrew Vancouver Sun Sikh hash smugglers, the assassination of a Punjabi cabinet minister, Chinese heroin dealers, marijuana-growing operations, organized crime, murder, police politics, sexual intrigue, national security bungles . . . Chris Haddock, the local television wunderkind with the bad hair and worse sense of fashion, has once again taken today's headlines and produced another piece of startling cinema verite. Best known for creating Da Vinci's Inquest and Da Vinci's City Hall, Haddock unveils a new two-hour, made-for-TV movie called Intelligence, Monday, Nov. 28, at 8 p.m. on CBC. It will give B.C. media junkies a curious sense of deja vu -- the rest of the country will see another dark, thinly disguised tableaux of the underbelly of the Left Coast. Haddock specializes in fictionalizing real life and in this movie, he follows the third generation in a Vancouver smuggling family, the RCMP organized crime unit, Vancouver police and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service. Wearing a producer and writer's hat on the show directed by Stephen Surjik, Haddock aimed to mirror current criminal and domestic security realities. He succeeded, although it is a particularly pessimistic perspective. As he weaves his subplots, Haddock also plays with the concept of "intelligence," its many connotations and applications depending on context, be it affairs of state or affairs of the bedroom. "I wanted to broaden the concept of intelligence as it's usually understood and discussed in film terms," Haddock says in his publicity package. "Intelligence is what leverage you've got, how prepared you are.... You've got to know what other people are doing before they do it to you. I thought it was really unexplored, how much intelligence is really in our daily lives -- we all do intelligence-gathering amongst our friends.... Every police force has an intelligence unit and it's really about information gathering and swapping and that kind of scouting to leverage and defend or go on the offensive." He does a good job exploring that idea, too, I think. His research into Canadian security issues, Haddock says, revealed "a series of bungles that I could weave into a really exciting story." "I personally feel that Canada's intelligence services are greatly lacking and not really developed to our own advantage, use and defence." Haddock always has displayed a layered and sophisticated understanding of the underground, its inherent violence and intimate betrayals, and the symbiotic relationships among cops, criminal and spooks. That strength is also evident in this production. The star of Intelligence is multiple-Gemini-winner Ian Tracey, one of Haddock's longtime favourite actors, who plays the chief crook and double-dealer. The female lead is Klea Scott, whom many will recognize from her Hollywood work, who serves as his would-be handler on the Organized Crime Unit. The plot ostensibly revolves around a stolen briefcase that contains confidential law enforcement files on the top informants. Their lives are suddenly at risk and the moral quandaries that arise as a result are milked for all they're worth. It is a big-budget effort with a large cast -- 66 actors -- and a slick noir look. Still, be warned. Haddock's is a cynical take on the world, a melodramatist's view that the worst lurks behind every headline. His is a world where the police perform summary executions, where deals with the devil are just doing business and where the only rule is there are no rules. If you're a fan of the inky detective novels by writers such as the late, great Jim Thompson, you'll be a fan of Haddock. Otherwise you'll have to keep reminding yourself that in spite of the many news stories to which Intelligence alludes, in spite of its gritty realism, this is television -- not reality. [address removed]

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

singh · 22 Nov 2005

You can't disown the bad apples from your community just by stating they are not Sikhs, when they don't serve your purpose. Remember that their have and are today many smugglers in Canada who maintain Sikhi Saroop.

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

kaur · 22 Nov 2005

I agree with Singh. It is time we stopped letting people treat Sikhi like a ethnic group. It is a religion, a way of life, not an ethnic group. You cannot be born a Sikh, You become one.

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

Truth · 22 Nov 2005

There are also many religious catholic hispanics in the drug trade, yet the media down in the states never brings up the person's religion...why?....becasue it's irrelevent!!! doesn't matter if the person is a shaven or kesadhari sikh, there's no reason to identify the person's religion, becasue it doesn't relate to the crime in any way. this is either another case of yellow journalism, or just plain stupidity..!!

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

singh · 22 Nov 2005

You can't have your cake and eat it too. In Britain Sikhs are treated as an ethnicity under law in order to keep religious freedoms. In this article they make mention of Sikh hash smugglers, probably because they are Sikh. Once the program airs, if its seen that they are not Sikh and could be described as Punjabi, then you might have a valid argument. Otherwise you don't because describing them as Sikh is most accurate if that is what they are.

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

Truth · 22 Nov 2005

>>You can't have your cake and eat it too. In Britain Sikhs are treated as an ethnicity under law in order to keep religious freedoms. In this article they make mention of Sikh hash smugglers, probably because they are Sikh. Once the program airs, if its seen that they are not Sikh and could be described as Punjabi, then you might have a valid argument. Otherwise you don't because describing them as Sikh is most accurate if that is what they are.<< well, this isn't Britian first of all. there is no need for describing a criminal's religion unless it's related to the crime (like someone stabbing a fellow over religious doctrine or something). a hash smuggler is a hash smuggler, unless he's smuggling cause it relates somehow to his religion..lol at most, a person's race should be disclosed if it serves some purpose, but a person's religion? makes no sense.

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

singh · 22 Nov 2005

The descriptions in the article are describing characters in a tv movie. Mentioning that the smugglers are Sikh is a much better description of the character than mentioning their race or gender or anything else. I'm pretty sure the religion will be part of those character's dynamic just as the race of other characters will play a part in theirs. "Canadian Sikhs need to stop their press using the word Sikh to describe Punjabis or Indo canadians." If the above statement is meant by Singh, then it should also apply to media stories where Sikhs are doing charitable work as well. We can't pick and choose and hope that the media obliges. If we don't like the negative attention its up to us as a community to rid ourselves of the apathy that allows members of our faith to partake in criminal and immoral activity.

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

Truth · 22 Nov 2005

but it's really double standards....if the media can do this kind of branding for each and every faith, then i wouldn't likely argue...."the christian bank manager"...."the buddhist massage therapist".. if the hash smugglers are Sikh, then what religion was the "Punjabi minister" or the "Chinese heroin dealers"? >>Mentioning that the smugglers are Sikh is a much better description of the character than mentioning their race or gender or anything else.<< you've got to be kidding!

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

singh · 22 Nov 2005

Read my next sentence... "I'm pretty sure the religion will be part of those character's dynamic just as the race of other characters will play a part in theirs." If thats not the case, then you do have a valid point and it is wrong. I have a suspicion that religion will play a part for those particular characters and thats why its mentioned for them and not for the Punjabi minister and Chinese heroin dealers. [%sig%]

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

Jagjit Singh · 23 Nov 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, rather than just discussing this between ourselves. It would be more constructive to create an information leaflet about this subject, which can be posted to all newspaper and TV reporters. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Sikh hash smugglers

surrey jack · 27 Nov 2005

Dude i saw the comercial went to the website didn't see anything about sikh's being in the movie if so it's probably for 30 seconds it's not focused on sikh's the movie is based around a white third generation crime family who gets all of csis information probably go through it and see something about sikhs not big deal.