Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

shaster vidya rong or right

shaster vidya rong or right

.......... · 22 Nov 2005

is it ok to learn shaster vidyaa even tho the ustaad has different beliefs etc... ?

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Reality Check!! · 22 Nov 2005

Would you learn Paath from a Nirankaari? It the same for Shastar Vidya & Raag Kirtan. Those teaching will teach your their own manmat, learn from those who have pyar for Guruji...you will learn more from them than those who use a skill to manipulate.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

pappi · 22 Nov 2005

wat about if u learn karate or sumink they dnt no nothing about guru ji is it ok 2 learn from them isnt it ok just 2 learn the combat not wat they believe in i just wna go a cupla lesson n c wat it like init if i dnt like it i'll stop

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Singhani · 22 Nov 2005

ooh yeah guru gobind singh jee was wrong to send 5 singhs to learn knowledge of the scriptures in kashi too then.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Wanna learn · 22 Nov 2005

I agree with above. Shouldn't learn from someone who has beliefs that are totally opposite to what you believe. But then who should we learn from. I'm sick of people telling me just learn gatka. No offence to anyone but even a novice martial artist knows that gatka is not the real fighting system that was used puratan singhs. It doesn't have any real foot work. No hand to hand combat. The actualy weapons that are used are light so they can be swung around faster to look better. It takes years to learn an art well. Gatka takes maybe weeks. And after you have mastered it, those skills really don't help u if u are being attacked. No one teaches u where are the kill spots, how to bring someone down, how to defend with bare hands. HOW TO DEFEND WITH SHASTERS, how to use each shaster and i've heard we as sikhs have a load of shasters that were used. How to use each shaster to inflict optimal damage. I have just been taught to swing a sword and a few sticks about so i "look" fierce. I have even been told before performing when me and other singhs were supposed to attack our "teacher" I was told by the teacher not to really attack to just wave the stick so it looks like i'm attacking and then wait for him to hit my stick. WOW I hope my oponents are that understanding. This was so shocking to me, it is so egotistical for someone to wanna look good infront of people. It showed me that these people have no real skill they just want people to think they do. Where as a real warrior has true skill but he wants people to think he doesn't. Once i was talking to a nihung who was teaching gatka. I had respect for him cause i thought he being a nihang would know shaster vidiya. I asked him how do i use my kirpan the best way. I wanna learn teach me, i will learn from you however long it takes. He told me to just attack the guy blindly. This is very poor advice. If someone who has extensive knowledge of martial arts attacks me and i pull out my kirpan it could be easily taken away from me and used against me. My point is even before I came across these NANGS i BELIEVED Something was wrong with gatka. We need to get back to learning the pure form. So that every sikh is a true sant sapai. after reading the ideology of the nangs I personally believe niddar is or has an RSS agenda. I don't have any respect for them from personal experiences. I hung out with one, when i first got into sikhi a few years back. All he did was swear and talk about what girls he had relations with before he took amrit. I know people who are pushing this pro snatanism are gonna say i'm lying. BUT I KNOW THE TRUTH. I try not partake in chugli nindiiya. I know how bad it is for a persons spiritual path. I only say things that i have personally seen. So believe me U DO NOT WANT TO LEARN FROM THESE PPL. However I wish there was a chardi kalla gursikh we could learn from.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Wanna Learn · 22 Nov 2005

Wanna Learn jee, I agree with you. But I think you have misunderstood what is original gatka. Nang teachings aside, true shastar vidya from puratan times includes many different aspects of warfare, hand-to-hand combat, wrestling, weaponry, strategic planning, teamwork, leadership, obstacle training, and much more. today's version of gatka is much different from original version.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Vastoo · 22 Nov 2005

Young Sikhs get so taken along with this new fad of "Shaster Vidiya". What use is any knowledge if you do not use it? We are meant to be Saint-Soldiers, yet before we even take one step towards becoming Saints, we want to know how to kill someone. Even when we know that, we use it only for our personal ego-inflation amongst friends and associates. Never does it cross our mind to do what the Singhs of the past did, because we are sheep with swords who have no heart or desire to use them to the use they are meant to be put to - to combat injustice.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

A Singh · 22 Nov 2005

Yeah, again please tell me when you've made that cave for all the CK SInghs to live in, so we can also learn Math, Science, PE, Geography etc from Singhs in Bana and not from 'flithy' goras (as someone once saw fit to refer to an entire race) and other 'narakdharis' (as the common phrase goes)... what are we - nomads or the Amish???

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

thug life · 22 Nov 2005

"A Singh" great postttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

SOORMAA · 22 Nov 2005

JUST LEARN IT GOSH LIKE A SINGH SAID WE SHUDNT LEARN FROM GORA TEACHERZ OR NETHING EITHA THEN SHUD WE WE ARE BEING SO NARROW MINDED ABOUT THINGS WE ARE NOT MENT 2 JUDGE PPL ON THEIR BELIEFS GOSH DOES IT MATTER IF HE PRAISES HINDUISM OR WAT HVE U LEARN IT IF U DNT LIKE IT QUIT IF HE CHATS HIS CRAP QUIT SIMPLE

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

.. · 22 Nov 2005

It's one thing to learn from a gora or a kala or a hindu. It's quite another to learn from soeone anti-Panthic. Guru Sahib might have sent his singhs to kanshi but he didn't send them to the rami raiyas or the dhirmaliyas. Learn vidya but dont associate with those out to distort sikhi.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

singhaa · 22 Nov 2005

every1 in this world is almost anti panthic if they dnt agree with the religion our teachers , managers etc.... they dnt care about ur religion long as u do ur work wid shaster just learn n do ur job n allow his bull crap yeh y isnt they no decent comabt teachers that aint anti panthic ?????

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

thug life · 22 Nov 2005

"y isnt they no decent comabt teachers that aint anti panthic ?????" maybe you should redefine who you think is "anti panthic"

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

ravinder singh · 24 Nov 2005

Learn how to punch and kick effectively (thai-boxing) Learn how to grapple standing and on the ground (wrestling, judo or jujitsu will also do) Learn how to use your kirpan (gatka) Learn the basics of the above and practice. Forget shastar-vidiya, it doesn't exist anymore. Niddar vidiya is not shastar-vidiya, its his own BS teachings and hidden agenda's. Your first shastar is your own body. Learn to use your own body-weapons. Your secondary shastars are your kirpan, kara and a gun if you have one.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

ytytryt · 24 Nov 2005

gatka teaches u to hit the hit the shield gatka is a joke its just a few spin- aroos to impress the goreh if u can learn thai boxing judo karate etcc why not shaster vidyaaa? long as u dnt listen 2 his views on stuff den wats rong?

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

H · 24 Nov 2005

Jus learn it. I have seen him in action and as long as you go to him in the frame of mind thinking 'i'm gonna take away with me what i need from you' you'll be fine. he's very good at what he does and i dont see anything wrong with learning off someone who has different belief's to myself. for example, the Namdhari sikhs are absolutely amazing at raag and traditional kirtan. u want to learn raag, go to them, but take with you what you need. you control the way you think, people shouldnt be able to manipulate. people who are against such actions are weak themselves and scared of movin from the norm. niddar singh teaches savvya ruksha classes, have been to one myslef and it is amazing, depending on whtat type of art u like. this is a very brut, get-the-job-done-quickly-and-walk-away art and that is what i like about it. absolutely amazing

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Confused Khalsa · 24 Nov 2005

the difference is white people dont distort our religion. is it ok to allow meat in sikhi? is it ok to find singhs following this sanatan sikhi drunk? i've been told by my friend he saw another singh pulling hairs out of his arm to prove he hadn't broken his amrit... where do the kurehits stop? is there anything that this version of sikhi says that you cannot do? is that why it is so appealing? its fine to learn from people, but if they are going to distory Guru Sahib's Hukaams with their 'hidden resources' then they should not be associated with at all. especially if your not sure about sikhi in the first place, like alot of the youth who learn from him now.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

tete · 25 Nov 2005

is there any good martial arts apart from shaster vidya den? n dont say gatkaa

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

x · 25 Nov 2005

what you think is anti-panthic might not be so to Guru Jee, so keep your mouth shut.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

H · 26 Nov 2005

try aikido tete. or brazilian jiu jitsu, both amazin, aikido more traditional japanese, jiu jitsu is grapplin art, wot you will see in Ultimate Fighting Championship (check it on bravo at night time - brilliant program)

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Wanna learn · 26 Nov 2005

Still no one has answered the question. Where do we learn it. I don't wanna learn foriegn martial arts. I WANNA LEARN SHASTER VIDIYA. The art that guru ji taught us. But i wanna learn from Gursikhs who practice the SANT sapai part to the fullest. BUT WHO DO I LEARN FROM. It is a sad set of affairs when we cannot find one Gursikh who can teach us our original form of martial arts. Gatka really isn't it anybody who thinks that has never set foot or learned a martial art. I am saddened by how egotistical it really is. Anyways Does anyone know who can teach us the real art?

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Don't want to learn · 26 Nov 2005

What makes you think Shaster Vidiya is the original Sikh martial art? Because Niddar says so? There are Singhs who have been to the Akhara with an impartial mind and come back unimpressed. Whatever Sikhs previously practised, has been lost, just as many other important elements of our history have been.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Sehajvir Singh · 27 Nov 2005

Don't wanna learn. I'm not saying it is our true martial art. All i'm saying is I wanna learn the true martial art. If it is lost that is really sad. If its not we should perserve it. cause it should be part of a gursikhs life. Staying tyar bityaar

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Singh Man · 27 Nov 2005

We have our own art why, go else were?

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

singha · 27 Nov 2005

muay thai + brazilian jiu jitsu, with muay thai ur limbs become ur weapons, in modern world we may not b able 2 carry and use kirpan so learn to use the body Maharaaj gave 2 us.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

ravinder singh · 28 Nov 2005

I believe that Naam is the biggest shastar that we can ever have. It is naam that will give you the fearlessness and strength of spirit that you will need to beat an opponent, regardless of his strength or skill. Knowing the use of weapons (especially your limbs) and being physically fit will help you in a fight, but being a spiritual warrior is something else. Without strong rehat and naam kamai, we r no better than a street thug or a nightclub bouncer, always looking to prove his toughness to people.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Someone · 07 Jul 2006

Shaster Vidiya is the best marital art ive came across, Ive been learning Karate before and in the Shaster Vidiya less I saw a black belt in karate go down. Shaster Vidiya is the complete fighting system both unarmed and armed, forget gatkha. I wanted to do gatkha before, thought it was tthe system to learn cos I thought it looked good. But then after my mate told me about Shaster Vidiya, ive noticed that all that the gakta people do the same moves, which would get more and moreeee predictible! And predictibilty isnt good in fighting. People say it takes about a month or more to learn Gatkha and be as good as the teacher by the end of it. But in shaster Vidiya it takes years to become a master and it and is even more effective than gatkha in the long run. There are people that used to go gatkha and now they come to Shaster Vidiya, they all say, they didnt teach us that in gatkha!!?? For instance, in gatkha they dont teach you how to unarm the oppent. They dont teach you how to use your kirpan in gatkha. They dont tell you how to use your Kara in Gatkha. They dont teach you how to fight unarmed in gatkha. Once a saw a Gatkha video and one singh, dropped his strick and ran away from the other singh, if this happends in real life, wouldnt it be silly?

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

gatka singh · 07 Jul 2006

WJKK WJKF i heard of this one place in toronto that is teaching gatka its yudh gatka akhara or sumin. the ustaads name is sarbjit singh and they do half an hour of workout before they do techniqe work and they dont learn soti or kipan they spend 2 years just learning pantra and hand to hand and wrestiling they do it all its preatty cool im gonna check it out soon and i ll tell u how it is . the ustaads number is 905 459 7000 he bought his own place and he charges money so ya if u wanna call him go ahead im gonna go to his class and check it out. i think this is real gatka.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Harjas Kaur · 07 Jul 2006

In my youth, the greatest martial arts master was Bruce Lee. He was a master because he incorporated American boxing styles, Korean Tae Kwon Do and Hapkido styles, Japanese Jiu Jitsu styles, Okinawan Karate styles. Bruce Lee was a master because he never had any hesitation to use what worked. The greatest militaries in the world don't rely on techniques of the past, but constantly innovate the best techniques to fit the present. Khalsa should never hesitate to use what works, or to learn it from any source necessary. To be rigid is to be predictable. To be predictable is to be defeated. [quote]Jeet Kune Do is not a new style of kung-fu or karate. Bruce Lee did not invent a new art composite style, nor did he modify a style to set it apart from any existing method. His concept was to free his followers from clinging to any style, pattern, or mold. The total picture Lee wanted to present to his pupils was that above everything else, the puplils must find their own way to truth. He never hesitated to say, 'Your truth is not my truth; my truth is not yours'. Bruce did not leave a blueprint, but rather a series of guidelines to lead one to proficiency. In using training equipment, there was a systematic approach in which one could develop speed, distance, power, time, coordination, endurance and footwork. But Jeet Kune Do was not an end in itself for Bruce--Nor was it a mere by-product of his martial studies; it was a means to self discovery. JKD was a prescription for personal growth; it was an investigation of freedom--freedom not only to act naturally and effectively in combat, but in life. In life, we absorb what is useful and reject what is useless, and add to experience what is specifically our own. No art is superior to any other. That is the object lesson of Jeet Kune Do, to be unbound, to be free: in combat to use no style as style, to use no way as the way, to have no limitation as the only limitation. Neither be for or against a particular style. In other words, Jeet Kune Do 'just is'. http://jeetkunedo.gungfu.com/[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Trigger · 08 Jul 2006

Yes, i kinda agree with Harjas Kaur- I feel sikhs are preventing evolution in many aspects of their faith and culture, in order to keep things 'puratan'. Evolution is natural and can be beneficial. As far as martial arts are concerned, I don't see why 1 has to be right and the other wrong, or why 1 is the best - surely different people depending on their body shape, size, strength etc might be better of doing different martial arts. Do which ever martial art is most effective for you.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Harjas Kaur · 08 Jul 2006

[quote] Yes, i kinda agree with Harjas Kaur- I feel sikhs are preventing evolution in many aspects of their faith and culture, in order to keep things 'puratan'.[/quote] I did not say anything aboout evolution of faith and culture. Some things are not evolving, they are set in stone. One can't change Gurbani. One can't change the kakkars. Otherwise, you lose the Guru and eradicate the Khalsa. But militarily, spending years studing swordfighting techniques is a bit of a waste except as an art form. One has to be practical. Our enemies won't be coming with swords anymore. One has to effectively defend oneself in the present. I don't think it matters how the original Singhs used shastars, since effective shastars have changed. Otherwise Guruji would have preserved these combat forms intact. It's foolish for someone to be deprived of learning the effective techniques that his enemies are able to learn because he is studying something like Gatka. Does it make sense that paramilitary groups are hard training with proven martial arts, sniper rifles and M-16's and explosives while Singhs are twirling swords? Shastar vidya and Gatka will not train a guerilla fighter for any kind of military usefulness or survival. They do not train a modern day soldier. [%sig%]

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

Harjas Kaur · 08 Jul 2006

Polish Cavalry in suicidal defense against German aircraft and tank divisions, 1939. They proved utterly incapable of halting the German invasion. [%sig%]

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

5vikaari,no-amritvela manmukh · 09 Jul 2006

Martial arts teaches discipline, and is a good way to stay fit, one must have a strong mind and some discipline, it will build your moral and do wonders for your body/mind/soul.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

some1 · 09 Jul 2006

agreed with Harjas Kaur, sikhs need to learn guns.

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

gatka singh · 10 Jul 2006

wjkk wjkf i checked out the yudh place and it is awsome. they do every kind of shaster and they do it to a practical way like some of the older singhs were doing soti and they were telling them about exactly were to hit for the most efficiency and they were talking about balance and speed and control. they dont teach u how to swing around a kirpan and make it look cool they teach u how to hurt the other person and how to protect ur self in a fight using a veriety of shaster aster and hand to hand combat. i urge everyone to try it out or at least to call the instructer for more info. 905 459 7000

Re: shaster vidya rong or right

google · 10 Jul 2006

shaster vidya looks rite to me but when maharaj ji sed sant sipahi sant came first then the sipahi bit so we need to clok the simran first b 4 we even touch shastervidya