Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

what would you do?

what would you do?

anon · 21 Nov 2005

If you were raised in a gursikh environment and married someone you thought was a gursikh but turned out not to be? what if after you were married you found out he watched pornographic movies? what if one night he went out drinking and came back having lost his wedding ring? what if he swore it wouldn't happen again and you gave him the benefit of the doubt because you felt you had made a comitment to him in front of god. and what if you thought things were starting to change but then three years later found that actually they hadn't? what if you felt that divorce wasn't an option because your own parents were already divorced because your father was too weak to keep his commitment. knowing this you know that after divorce you would have no life but knowing that you have no life now. what would you do...

Re: what would you do?

... · 21 Nov 2005

I would definitely go to the punj pyare at the next amrit sinchar and tell them about my situation and get their advice.

Re: what would you do?

Kulbir Singh · 21 Nov 2005

I would suggest that you consult the Siyaanay Gursikhs of your area and see what they have to say. You can also tell Punj Pyaray your situation. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: what would you do?

anon · 21 Nov 2005

today's panj pyare are human! in the same way that sant , bhagat and all other statutes of authority are human! Except Guru Granth Sahib ji. I have taken hukamnaama many times. Guru ji's hukam has been to recite naam... have tried in this darknes to recite naam. sometimes I succeed sometimes I faill. I even try to bring my partner into Sikhi. I bring inspirational kirtan cd's home. I bring home videos of people from other backgrounds who have converted to Sikhi in order from him to understand the beauty of sikhi and the reason and logic behind a gursikh lifestyle... I am not perfect. I am not amritdhari but I try to lead righteous way of life. He tells me he has changed but he has lied to me so many times. I have found this out when I confronted him on several different occcasions. It feels as if he's just got better and better at lying and covering things up until today when I found a movie in his bag. He said he was just hanging on to the movie to pass it on from one collegue to the next. What am I supposed to think? Should I beleive him? Even so why should I accept that it's ok for him to pass these things on to others? I really care for him and I don't want to lose my husband but at the moment I am losing my mind. I always thought I am never going to be one of those poor women who suffer in silence and then breakdown. I've always been strong, I've worked hard and acheived academic success but I've been reduced to being a poor broken down woman through my love for the one who is supposed to be my soulmate.

Re: what would you do?

... · 21 Nov 2005

I'm always afraid of giving advice because I'm afraid of insulting the intelligence of the person I'm advising or coming off as condescending. But I'll give it a try here. I think maybe you should sit down with him and tell him that you know he's got this problem and how its effecting you. Get beyond his denials, and just start the discussion with an acceptance that there is a problem. Why is he watching these videos? I can tell you that it's possible he's addicted to them. It may be hard to understand, but pornography can be addictive for men. Even if someone with this problem wants to stop, they can't. But he's married and the question arises, why is this happening? You need to have a frank talk about it. If you have children, you need to focus on what effect it is having on them. If not, then you need to confront the fact that you may have children and what kind of a father figure can he be when living like this? Talk to him about how you are feeling. Express to him your humiliation and your pain. Maybe he just doens't understand it or never took the time to notice it. What is this doing to you? Tell him how you feel about him and what you want out of this marriage. It's very likely you've done all this already, but discussing all these issues in one sitting again may be helpful. Failing this, I really would consider going to elder Gursikhs that you can trust. They may be human but when 5 or more Gursikhs gather, Guru Sahib speaks through them. You are talking to us through this anonymous forum, so clearly you need to talk and need to be heard. Find some Gursikhs you trust and confide in them. They will be able to know your situation much better when they can meet and see you in person, or know about you already. I also want to stress the power of bani and ardaas. Let that be a source of power for you. I don't know what more I can add. I hope the very best for you.

Re: what would you do?

Kulwinder Singh · 21 Nov 2005

He may be lying because he wants to avoid the subject of discussion which obliviously bothers you and even he finds it embarrassing. Do not forget you are as partner their to help him to concur his demons, you lashing out because he is weak in dealing with these unpleasant things will only generate aggravation which is exactly the opposite of what you want to achieve. Gurubani says three virtues are the key to a successful bride. Humbleness Forgiveness Sweet talk Use these three to achieve your desires (if you think he is worth it, only you know that for sure). I would be more offended by the lying then anything else, of course others are bad too but lying take the trust out and without trust it get very difficult, But you need to make sure you give others room to state the truth without the fear of unpleasant reaction. Friends accept friends short comings and help them to overcome. The biggest weapon you have to deal with is the above mentioned three virtues and Ardas, don’t argue about it accept it and then encourage him to give up those things, and include him in person to do Ardas at home, for God to help him. All the above is only valid if he has not done some thing which is far more damaging then above mentioned things, It actually bothered me that you have said “reduced to being a poor broken down woman “ , I have given my advise but I am also scared that I do not put you on undesirable grief and pain, so please be sensible and use advise if it suit you otherwise ignore it. Stay in Chardi kala, Look at the sikh history how bad the odds been for Sikhs, but we have always done much better then our opponents so stay high spirited , low and high are the seasons of the life so don’t get dishearten. Feel free to discuss this further or email me, My question to you is : your partner apart from the mentioned things do you have anything else to complain and do you have at least 10 things nice to say about him ? Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: what would you do?

anon · 23 Nov 2005

Thank you all for all the advice. Well this is what I did. I stayed up most of the night crying. Which wasn't very clever but I had to do something to relieve the pain. Then I wrote some messages to my husband and some to the colleague who had asked him to pass this thing on to someone. I told my husband that women are not pieces of meat and I told him to at least be honest about who he is and what he believes in. On the DVD which had an image of a naked woman on it, I wrote "to all men, when you next view this, picture this body with your mother's head on it. She is a woman too!" My partner later convinced me that he was indeed only passing it on to someone and I do believe him now for various reasons, from his reaction to his words and to his later action. He passed the dvd back to his colleague and told him he wanted nothing to do with it. His colleague broke the CD into pieces and threw it away saying it haunted him. I thank Waheguru for being with me in this battle. I apologise to my husband for not believing in him and I hope the colleague has come to his senses. I thank the sangat for their effort in writing and for the support they gave. Many thanks. Keep up the good work.

Re: what would you do?

singh · 23 Nov 2005

to anon the pnaj pyare are not human, the panj pyareh represent the guru as only the guru can give amrit

Re: what would you do?

agyani · 23 Nov 2005

ur a nindak of sant and i dont believe the day has come where i would have to say your a nindak of the 5Panj..lol...yet u want sukh?...hmm think again

Re: what would you do?

anon · 23 Nov 2005

I'm sorry for my first two posts. I wrote them in haste, with tears streaming down my face. I didn't mean to sound offensive. Apologies for any offence caused to anyone.

Re: what would you do?

anon · 24 Nov 2005

Dear “Agyani” I am not a nindak of the panj pyare. I wrote something that I did not mean, in haste and in anger. I apologised for this and I apologise again. When I said they’re human I meant something else. The thing about approaching someone face to face is that you lose your anonymity this can sometimes hinder the resolution of a problem, in that I’m sure if my partner knew that people he knows knew about this issue he would probably become defensive and continue. I am not a nindak of sant. I have been on this forum many times discussing this topic and I have always stated that nindiya of anyone let alone sant mahapurakh is wrong. By nindiya I mean slander. I believe we have a lot to learn from spiritual figureheads. (Now we're probably going to get into the sant reverence issue… lol) I have not asked for sukh. I have asked for righteousness. If society and religion requests that I live by certain morals and I do. Then is it not fair for me to ask that my partner does the same? I care about what happens in the world and if I can prevent immoral actions by one person and instil consciousness in them then I think I should at least try. Kulbinder Singh ji, thank you for your practical and constructive comments. I had tried a lot of those things in the past and they had not always worked in one attempt but I do agree with the methods you suggested for long term success. Yes it was the previous lying that hurt me. As you say honesty is paramount in establishing trust and building friendships. The thing about trying to think of 10 nice things is a good one to remember. Kulbir singh ji, you are always an inspiration. Thank you. I’m sorry for the way my reply came across. I also wanted to thank Veerji / Bhenji who entitled themselves "..." you did not insult my intelligence. I have none. You were very kind in taking time out to write to someone who had lost direction. I thank you sincerely. I had done the sit down frank discussions and I thought that they’d had no effect in breaking an addiction which had occurred prior to marriage, but from what I believe to be true now, I guess over time they have had effect. Thanks again to everyone. I’m really sorry if I hurt or offended anyone.

Re: what would you do?

Suvinder Singh · 24 Nov 2005

gurfateh.. i think i agree with veerji kulbir....u should go n take advice from any other elder and siyanaa person... GuRfAtEh !