Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Kulwinder Singh · 20 Nov 2005

What does Teear Bar Teear ( Ready) mean ? Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ? If that is the case how it differ from the Udashis of Guru Nanak Dev ji time or Brahmins who just follow their Karm Kand 100%. What is the point of being a Sikh of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. [%sig%]

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

... · 20 Nov 2005

tyaar bar tyaar means: 1) has avoided the 4 kurehits 2) keeps 5 kakaars 3) does daily nitnem of 7 banis 4) Gives dasvandh 5) keeps bibek And yes, this person should be in Bana. I don't understand what you mean by "What is the point of being a Sikh of Guru Granth Sahib Ji"?

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Kulwinder Singh · 20 Nov 2005

Dear… You have written 5 things + Bana. Out of these six things only one “Dasvandh” have something to do for others and all others have only to do with one’s own self. My Question include: “ If that is the case how it differ from the Udashis of Guru Nanak Dev ji time or Brahmins who just follow their Karm Kand 100%.” In brief: The Point I am raising is that the Only thing to go drumming about being in dress code which actually if not done to reflect the inside of human being state work as a decoy for and can be very misleading. Without the state inside being higher or equal to outside become Dikhawa ( Pretending) and that to my knowledge is far from be a desirable position. And about the rehit is YES for sure it is important but it is important to make you focus on the real issues so you behave in same way as required, to be helpful, Kind, being brave and fighting evils within your self and in society, standing up for the weaker. I think Guru Ji want a Sikh to focus on others welfare as well rather then just on oneself.

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

... · 20 Nov 2005

I think Kulwinder, that if you want to help the world, you have to begin with yourself first. Someone that reads bani, does simran and is committed to Sikhi puts him/herself in a position to help others. Someone that doesn't have a spiritual base cannot be of help to others because they dont' have any guidance. We can't do true "par-upkar" without guidance from the Guru and Sikhi. Otherwise people get stuck in ego and make their seva about making themselves feel good. I think being a spiritually strong and grounded person is a prerequisite before we can begin to try to help others.

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Kulwinder Singh · 21 Nov 2005

Dear.. you have written “I think Kulwinder, that if you want to help the world, you have to begin with yourself first. “ I agree with you 100%. You also have said: “Someone that reads bani, does simran and is committed to Sikhi puts him/herself in a position to help others.” My Question: is this true for all the current leadership of Sikhs regardless of their Jaths or party. You have written further: Someone that doesn't have a spiritual base cannot be of help to others because they don’t' have any guidance. I think that is very ignorant comment “many people who have no faith and actually are atheist go to many lengths even better then so called religious people to help the needy, if you need example I can give you many. But I would think you actually know that. You write further: “we can't do true "par-upkar" without guidance from the Guru and Sikhi. Otherwise people get stuck in ego and make their seva about making themselves feel good.” I think you are labelling non Sikhs’s good work as some kind of untrue Par-upkar. That is very disappointing to have comment that narrow minded. Please Check your comment is very hurtful to come from a Guru Sikh. specifically when Guru Sahib Says: Ek Bujeh ta hovea pak bin bujeh tu sada na pak. You last lines say: ” I think being a spiritually strong and grounded person is a prerequisite before we can begin to try to help others.” Guru Sahib Says: and I agree 100% Having Kindness is the prerequisite. “ Tol Tarm Dya Ka pute “ Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

!! · 22 Nov 2005

3) does daily nitnem of 7 banis 5) keeps bibek where in the rehatnama 7 banis are mentioned. When AkalTakhat do Amrit parchar only 5 banis are told as nitnem. It is good to do more but this is not in rehatmatyaada. Again AkalTakhat does not ask for bibek. Why make ur own rules and regulations? Is AKJ jatha above AkalTakhat? Please Give full respect and regards to AkalTakhat.

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

?? · 22 Nov 2005

Someone that doesn't have a spiritual base cannot be of help to others because they dont' have any guidance. We can't do true "par-upkar" without guidance from the Guru and Sikhi. Otherwise people get stuck in ego and make their seva about making themselves feel good. Not true. White people do more sewa than so called true sikhs. Gorey help mire people in the world when there are natural disasters in the world. what do they sikhs do. they even steal from gurdwara funds. Gorey help people of other faiths and countries. Not their own people. Sikhs don't even help sikhs. Please don't say sikhs are helping people of kashmir that is nothing compaire to what other people do.

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

:-D · 22 Nov 2005

2 many fakes around just cuz 1 wears a banaa dnt make him any more of a sikh that doesnt hw r u going 2 get a job wid a banna on? sum ppl r starting 2 sound like pandits etc..

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Kulwinder Singh · 25 Nov 2005

It make perfect sense for many people to just dress up and claim that they follow rehit and then be arrogant and ignorant to defy everybody else. To defy others as sub standard and less then equal suit their ego and aims very well.

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

bana singh · 25 Nov 2005

If someone wears pants and shirts, does it make them more of a Sikh? If someone wears the bana of Guru Gobind Singh, does it make them less a Sikh? Is this bana necessary? Well would you imagine the punj pyaaray in pants? Why not? Because Sikh dress is bana. If you want to say people who wear bana are egotistical, then I suppose you could extend that and say people get ego from keeping kesh or wearing a dastaar. Should they stop that as well? Talk some sense for god's sake. If people want to wear bana, what mirch is being applied to you to make you so agitated?

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Kulwinder Singh · 26 Nov 2005

Dear Bana Singh Ji, Very oddly you are saying to me. “ If someone wears pants and shirts, does it make them more of a Sikh? “ And I do agree with you, absolutely not Again “ If someone wears the bana of Guru Gobind Singh, does it make them less a Sikh? “ I do agree with you, absolutely not, ” Is this bana necessary? “ it is a personal choice, I know for sure, I Guru is not narrow minded or shallow who would judge somebody on if they wear bana or not. Although it does look very nice. “ Well would you imagine the punj pyaaray in pants? Why not? Because Sikh dress is bana. “ Can I imagine Punj Pyaaray in Pants? If you mean the first Punj Pyaary then obliviously not, if you talking some Gurusikhs I know who are good and can do seva as Punj for Amrit Sanchar yes I can imagine them in pants and some of them do wear pants. ” If you want to say people who wear bana are egotistical,” When did I say that, I have said some of them, you only have to read the messages on this form to see how these people perceive others, I give you first very bad and extreme example that a some “less rehitwan or non amritdhari” Sikh touched the degh’s utensil from outside and some other “VERY ULTRA GOOD SIKHS” have to prepare the degh again as that was spoiled by the touch of this substandard sikh. You tell me, is that some thing Guru ji would be proud. Second example: some people want only babies to do kirtan who have keski. Third Example: some people want people with Banan to do kirtan. I can give you many more..if that is what you want. “ then I suppose you could extend that and say people get ego from keeping kesh or wearing a dastaar. Should they stop that as well? “ Dear Bana Singh ji your mind is controlled by your self if that is what you can come up with then that is you. I do not have to say a word in this two lines above to make any difference. ”Talk some sense for god's sake. If people want to wear bana, what mirch is being applied to you to make you so agitated? “ Believe me Vir Bana Singh ji , If you or anybody want to wear bana, promote bana, I have no disagreement with them, but when they want to show other down with their version of Sikhi, which indeed hurt the Good reputation of my Guru then it does have mirch effect on me. Do you suggest I should just keep quite and let these people say my Guru is narrow minded and shallow who do endorse these views ? Let me know if the above kind of mud application on our Guru’s Glory do have mirch effect on you too or not ? Thanks for your contribution to the debate in most genuine manner. [%sig%]

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

RoopKaur · 26 Nov 2005

To Kulwinder Singh, You say that white people do more charity work than some Singhs. And then you go on to make a mockery of Sikh rehits. Although there are many flaws in your reasoning. THe problem is that your foundational argument itself is quite flawed. Alright, if we accept that more white people donate money to charities or help the homeless. I agree, this helps the person in need IN THIS WORLD. He or she will receive momentary confort in this life and this is great. BUT what about the next world. What about that person's next life? Will giving them a blanket help them svaar their jeevan so they will get out of the 4.4 million lives? Will it help them when they go to Dharm Raj's court and are jugded? The truth is, only GUru ji, through his beloved Gursikhs, is able to really HELP a person. This true help will not only be temporary pleasure or relief from discomfort in this world, but will also aid them in teh next world. As for your mockery on rehit. You say guru ji is not narrow minded that he will accept food from anyone. Well,was Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji being narrow minded when he refused Malik Bhago's food? I think not. The truth is, the path of Sikh is 'khaneo tikhi, valo niki', which means you have to make some sacrifices. It is reasoning like yours that does not want to make these sacrifices that cry out in protest when someone is promoting rehit. This discussion on degh maryada has been discussed before, so I will not go into details, just do a search and see how important maryada is. As for your second example, when Sikhs themselves are against keski, why do we even bother to fight against France and others? I have seen at Tapoban Sahib that no child has a problem with the keski issue, why would they? it is easier for them to understand the value of a dastaar, yet it is so hard for older people to understand this. As for your third example, you fail to say what is wrong with that? Keertan is a supreme seva of Guru ji, and requires a set uniform for it, which includes dastaar and appropriate bana. By lowering the standards that have traditionally been followed, you are essentially sending a message that you are also lowering the value of this mahaan seva. By mocking Khalsa rehit and those that follow it, you are mocking the panth of Guru ji, Yet ironically, you claim that this what you are fighting against. All rehit that you mentioned has historical evidence, as well as reference in Bani (for Bibek for example). Please do a search on this site for references. Yet this new apologetic, politically correct "lets show the world some love and to Hell with Sikhi asools" version of Sikhi that you promote has so far been just your own input, and has no proof what so ever. I suggest you look at historical Sikh documents, read Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji;s books, and actually read bani thoroughly and not just the english translations, instead of following the new, "lets accept everything that comes our way,as long as society thinks we are okay" version of Sikhi.

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

LionKing (LK) · 27 Nov 2005

As for your third example, you fail to say what is wrong with that? Keertan is a supreme seva of Guru ji, and requires a set uniform for it, which includes dastaar and appropriate bana. By lowering the standards that have traditionally been followed, you are essentially sending a message that you are also lowering the value of this mahaan seva. *********************** Please provide reference that only Keski Dhari bibiya have done Kirtan in the past. ***** All rehit that you mentioned has historical evidence, as well as reference in Bani (for Bibek for example). ***** PLease provide.. ***** I suggest you look at historical Sikh documents, read Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji;s books, and actually read bani thoroughly and not just the english translations, ******* You're saying that Randhir Singh's books are equivilent to historical Sikh documents? 60 odd years before us our of some 500 years makes him puratan?

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 27 Nov 2005

The OLDEN DAY Sikhs like Baba Budha Ji, Bhai mani Singh Ji Baba banda Singh Ji bahadur Ji and many many more were SO STRONG INTERNALLY thta their outer Rehit came almost naturally....the INSIDE SHONE THROUGH effortlessly....Precisely becasue his inside was so strong did Bhai mani Singh INSIST that the Jalaad follow his master's orders to cut him JOINT by JOINT and not take a short cut approach.. We however are WEAK.... we have to BEGIN with OUTER REHIT ( which is way easier to follow).....and build up on our INSIDE REHIT.. EXAMPLE: Doctors often tell us that we are WHAT WE EAT....IF our diet is healthy we will NEVER have pimples/acne/skin problems etc The Olden day Sikhs had a very healthy diet of GURBANI/Food for the Mann....Right from Day ONE... We already have skin problems...and we take the other way out by First TEMPORARILY applying Creams/lotions/acne medicines on the SKIN to make it go "clear" while simultaneously Going on a HEALTHY DIET. To accuse a modern sikh of "putting cream" on his skin as arrogance/deciet/is wrong...he is just using his best method..he cant be letting his skin go to "hell" while he improves his DIET..when he can do BOTH ??? I have outer rehit as well as some Inside rehit...but i can tell you right away that should i be faced with a situation like Bhai mani Singh Ji .....I will scream bloody murder at the mere sight of a knife...much less cut my joints ?? SO what can I say about the posters who ask..How to get a job with Banna ?? To this poster BANNA means NO JOB !!!...even though if he wants to he can actually find out many thousands of bann wearing sikhs with good JOBS... I can point to him many THOUSANDS of MONNAY "sikhs" in MALAYSIA who have NO JOBS.... they came from Punjab and work at MENIAL LABOUR !!!! while the banna wearers get JOBS and keep their banna !!

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Kulwinder Singh · 27 Nov 2005

Many Thanks Roop Kaur ji for your criticism. That is the way forward to analysis and learn to make better of your life. I hope you are going to reply to my this post as well. You very strangely saying: “ The truth is, only Guru ji, through his beloved Gursikhs, is able to really HELP a person.” Guru Ji has shown us direct way to GOD not via any middle man, where does this through beloved Gursikhs comes from, How one is going to be sure which Gurusikhs is the one to follow, or are you saying let’s look for some Baba ji of some sort ? Very odd. Guru Sahib shown us the straight path in Simple Gurumukhi, rather then taking that path and guide, you are saying listen to some other individuals, Why ? Or this is an attempt to claim that people should listen to certain individuals who you think are passport officers for Guru Sahib. And you have also written: “As for your mockery on rehit” can you point out where I have mad mockery of rehit, Asking question is Mockery, I am saying at least Sikhs should not treat others as some substandard human beings. Dear Roop Kaur ji if you are using the example of “Malik Bhago's”( who was exploiter, deceiver, and fake of the time) to describe any other person then you are proving my point. That these people treat others as some substandard human being. You seems to like have two kind of humans in your categories your own type and Evil like Malik Bhago. Never mind Great Guru Nanak Dev ji even a simple human like me would not like to associate with exploiters. You are saying “'khaneo tikhi, valo niki'” yes true but true because Anjan mehi Naranjan Rehia. -------is very difficult, any body can stay protected in a shell created around them, but Sikh should be right in the society [( where many social evil still exist)( not controlled society as some want)] helping others from all angels and still maintain his or her integrity. You have said, it is easier for children to understand the value of a dastaar, yet it is so hard for older people to understand this.” Well I genuinely congratulate you on doing this fantastic seva for the penth, and may God guide older people in the Sikhi too, But where you teaching children about dastar you should also tell them that it is fantastic to have dastar they must also demonstrate it in their behaviour to be extra kind in their life to treat all humanity as one as that is the core of Sikhi. Your comment “As for your third example, you fail to say what is wrong with that? Keertan is a supreme seva of Guru ji, and requires a set uniform for it, which includes dastaar and appropriate bana. By lowering the standards that have traditionally been followed, you are essentially sending a message that you are also lowering the value of this mahaan seva.” Dear Roop Kaur Ji, By restricting anybody who declare themselves as lover of Gurubani to do Kirtan, you are doing harm to the Glory of Sikh Philosophy, Guru Ganth Sahib which have hymns from all kind of Bhagats, you want to restrict people doing kirtan because in your eyes they are not up to the standard. But then again Some of these Sikhs will claim that all the Bhagats were Gurusikhs and claim that no non Gurusikh’s Hymns are included in the Guru Granth sahib ji, Which I find very disturbing and bad taste humour. Your have written “Yet this new apologetic, politically correct "lets show the world some love and to Hell with Sikhi asools" version of Sikhi that you promote has so far been just your own input, and has no proof what so ever.” Dear Roop Kaur ji could you point me out where is my apologetic response ? And which bit of my writing is based on Just political correctness. Your Comments “"lets show the world some love and to Hell with Sikhi asools"” ----------- Dear Roop kaur ji Jin Prem keio Tin hi prab pyeio --- Guru Gobind Singh is saying this not me. Dear Roop Kaur Ji I think if anybody move away from love for the world then they are definitely on some other path rather then Sikhi. Dear Roop Karu Ji why do you find it a need to look into history and Jiven of others Sikhs when Guru Granth Sahib ji is so close to you, Why not ask the Guru at first hand why take second hand information ? although you can ask Gursikhs but when they contradict Guru Granth Sahib’s Philosophy then you should listen to Guru Sahib Ji rather then them. You have said” actually read bani thoroughly and not just the english translations “ Dear Roop Kaur ji thanks for the comments, I am not going to say what and how much Gurubani I read or not, actually so far I have not found a single translation of Guru Granth Sahib which I believe is any where near to be said as 10% correct version of Guru Granth Sahib, But I do have lot of respect for those who have attempted to do so in order to help the world to be a better place. Dear Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji, I have no issue with the anybody, how they are attempting to make their life better quite the opposite of it, What I am saying is, do not treat others as some kind of sub standard human beings, my point is have Kindness as starting point and what ever you do don’t let that go, build on Kindness and Aim to be one with One and consult Guru Granth Sahib Ji rather then some Sikhs on most issues, of course some things are worth discussing and learning from other Sikhs, but not by ignoring the philosophy of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

RoopKaur · 28 Nov 2005

>Guru Ji has shown us direct way to GOD not via any middle man, where does this through beloved Gursikhs comes from, How one is going to be sure which Gurusikhs is the one to follow, or are you saying let’s look for some Baba ji of some sort ? Very odd.< Guru Sahib shown us the straight path in Simple Gurumukhi, rather then taking that path and guide, you are saying listen to some other individuals, Why ?< Gurbani says the exact opposite. It is through Guru ji that Vaheguru can be obtained, there is no direct route to Vaheguru, except through the middleman e.i. Satguru Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. As for following Gursikhs, there are numerous pankitis in Bani praising Gursikhs, and also numerous pankitis which tell us that sangat is essential in following the Sikh Marg. I have not mentioned anywhere that a Baba is needed, unless you mean Sri GUru Nanak Dev Ji. >any body can stay protected in a shell created around them, but Sikh should be right in the society [( where many social evil still exist)( not controlled society as some want)] helping others from all angels and still maintain his or her integrity.< I agree with you, but first a person must svaar themselves before they svaar others. If a person is weak themselves, how can they hope to better another person? Would you want a ill doctor try to make you feel better? A lover of doing Gurbani Keertan will also be a lover of guru ji. Then they will happily adopt the uniform of guru ji to sing praises of Guru ji/Akaal Purkh. Then what is the issue? >Dear Roop Karu Ji why do you find it a need to look into history and Jiven of others Sikhs when Guru Granth Sahib ji is so close to you, Why not ask the Guru at first hand why take second hand information ? although you can ask Gursikhs but when they contradict Guru Granth Sahib’s Philosophy then you should listen to Guru Sahib Ji rather then them.< The Khalsa REhit maryada cannot be found in detail in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. This is a seena baseena rehit passed down from the Panj Pyarey to abhilakhee, how then can I find out that I must wear the puunj kakaars, that I must wear white kacheraa etc, when these rehits are within the Panth? You do not realise the immense value of Gursikhs when on the path of Sikhi. it is only through sangat that one realises the rehits one must keep in order to remain in chardi kalaa. For one who has not experienced this kind of sangat, it is hard to understand, but for those who have experienced it will know what I am talking about. >But then again Some of these Sikhs will claim that all the Bhagats were Gurusikhs and claim that no non Gurusikh’s Hymns are included in the Guru Granth sahib ji, Which I find very disturbing and bad taste humour.< It is sad you find the truth in bad taste. I suggest you read Bhai Gurdit Ji's book on the subject as he has done extensive research on the topic, instead of following the approximate dates that most historians have accepted from McCaulliffe, without researching them. Guru ji does say, Bin Satgur Kinae Na Paaeo, Bin Satgur Kinai Na Paeaa. If your idea of love for the world is based on eating from their hands, that seems like a pretty shallow love. Why ignore such pankitis such as Vadeenai Kee dosti, Vadeenai Ka Khaan|| Sifti Saar Na Jaanani Sadaa Vasai Shaitaan|| and also:Santan Ka danaa rukhaa so sarab nidhaan|| Grehi Saakat Chhati parkar tai bikhoo samaan|| To show love for humanity is part of Sikhi, but how can one expect to help them when one cannot help themselves. One must svaar themselves through Guru Gobind Singh Ji's rehit and then think of svaaring others. You also say consult Guru Ji instead of some Sikhs. But it is impossible for a person on their own to understand Guru ji, it is only through vichaar of bani in the sangat of Gursikhs that one comes to realise an inkling of what Guru ji is saying. How then do you suggest to surpass this sangat? Sikhi is not an individual religion, but a congregational one. It depends on sangat. When one stays away from sangat for long, they will ultimately feel its affects. As for Bhai Sahibs books, although they are not puraatan texts, all that Bhai Sahib has written is just elaboration of Bani and Puraatan rehit maryada, except it is written for the common person so they too can benefit from the amazing avastha of Bhai Sahib. It is rarely that a person that themselves have had expereinces write about it and guide others to do so. THis is the true help for humanity. THis is kindness. This is love. As for Guru Gobind SIngh Ji, he also said, Rehit Pyaaree Mujh Ko, SIkh Pyaare Nahe|| It is the rehit of a Sikh that he loves, not the individual. I do not understand what 'philosophy of Guru Granth Sahib Ji' you are talking about, when you dismiss many central themes such as sangat, the mehma of Gursikhs, the importance for Sikhs to listen to guru ji, and the fact that there is only one true path to Akaal Purkh, through Satguru. Instead you promote an accept all approach, and I am not sure where you find this philosophy where it says this. Kindness and daya is essential, but they are essential for bhagti, and bhagti e.i. Naam Japnaa and Bani parnee is thge important keys, from which one can svaar oneself.

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

uk singh · 28 Nov 2005

Kuliwinder Singh Ji, You stated ''I think Guru Ji want a Sikh to focus on others welfare as well rather then just on oneself.'' Why can a Sikh not do both concurrently? ================ ''The Point I am raising is that the Only thing to go drumming about being in dress code which actually if not done to reflect the inside of human being state work as a decoy for and can be very misleading. Without the state inside being higher or equal to outside become Dikhawa ( Pretending) and that to my knowledge is far from be a desirable position.'' No one is perfect - even people who wear bana have to deal with being robbed by the 5 chors daily. Dikhawa is an intentional desire to deceive the masses. I too feel that this maybe the case in the younger generation - especially within the Nihang fold. As we do not know the spiritual status of their minds, we should not be questioning how they dress. Inner rehit is just as important as outer. ================ ''Guru Ji has shown us direct way to GOD not via any middle man, where does this through beloved Gursikhs comes from, How one is going to be sure which Gurusikhs is the one to follow, or are you saying let’s look for some Baba ji of some sort ? Very odd. Guru Sahib shown us the straight path in Simple Gurumukhi, rather then taking that path and guide, you are saying listen to some other individuals, Why ? Or this is an attempt to claim that people should listen to certain individuals who you think are passport officers for Guru Sahib. '' If someone is more spiritually advanced than yourself, there is no reason why one cannot goto them for advice/guidance. There is no denying that there are some rare souls that can point us in the right direction. ==== Points I agree with: I do not believe in Brahmanvad for a second and do not understand why some Singhs become fanatical over issues surrounding langar and do not see why amrtidharis without keski cannot perform kirtan??

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

amarjeet singh · 28 Nov 2005

keski is the fifth kakaar , u shud be tyaar bar tyaar when doing kirtan which means u shud be wearing all 5 kakaars. if you dont think keski is 5th kakaar oh well, ur loss [%sig%]

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Kulwinder Singh · 30 Nov 2005

Dear Roop Kaur Ji, Thanks again for your contribution. Now my reply is : Guru Show us the way but going on this it is a matter of individual’s own decision on the top of that the milap with GOD is an act of Kindness from Guru and GOD, Guru Nanak Dev ji is not a middle man like worldly middle man who take away something, Sikh Guru only give and give he never take away anything, He is middle man of PEROPKARI who help to reach GOD rather then hinder for his own interests. SO do not think him as a middle man of worldly understanding. >>As for following Gursikhs, there are numerous pankitis in Bani praising Gursikhs, and also numerous pankitis which tell us that sangat is essential in following the Sikh Marg. I have not mentioned anywhere that a Baba is needed, unless you mean Sri GUru Nanak Dev Ji.<< I have not even once said that doing Sangat is bad ? So I do not know what you are complain for ? >>I agree with you, but first a person must svaar themselves before they svaar others. If a person is weak themselves, how can they hope to better another person? Would you want a ill doctor try to make you feel better?<< I agree with you that you need to be good your self to do good for others. >>>A lover of doing Gurbani Keertan will also be a lover of guru ji. Then they will happily adopt the uniform of guru ji to sing praises of Guru ji/Akaal Purkh. Then what is the issue?<<< Have you seen one uniform worn by all the good Sikhs of current time and old times ? be constructive, you accuse me of being objection ate but look who is the making the biggest objection . You will always have debates on Rehit maryada never mind me saying or not, First we have Akal Takhat which most of use agree to be supreme but are selective of their orders, So I am saying you question Akal Takat, you question Gursikhs, you can Question Jathas and Jathebanies, You have full access to Guru Granth Sahib, if in doubt check with the Guru Sahib’s philosophy if you it does contradict Guru Sahib then is it not worth questioning it ? or are you suggesting that we should ignore Guru Granth Sahib Ji ? >>>>You do not realise the immense value of Gursikhs when on the path of Sikhi. it is only through sangat that one realizes the rehits one must keep in order to remain in chardi kalaa. For one who has not experienced this kind of sangat, it is hard to understand, but for those who have experienced it will know what I am talking about.<<< You are spot on this point. I Agree with you the value of Sangat. But don’t say that some Guru Sikhs have passport to GOD, like you suggested in the previous message. >>>But then again Some of these Sikhs will claim that all the Bhagats were Gurusikhs and claim that no non Gurusikh’s Hymns are included in the Guru Granth sahib ji, Which I find very disturbing and bad taste humor.< It is sad you find the truth in bad taste. I suggest you read Bhai Gurdit Ji's book on the subject as he has done extensive research on the topic, instead of following the approximate dates that most historians have accepted from McCaulliffe, without researching them. Guru ji does say, Bin Satgur Kinae Na Paaeo, Bin Satgur Kinai Na Paeaa.<<<< I hope you know that the word Satgur is used for GOD in this pankti. So I do not see any reason to debate these lines. >>>If your idea of love for the world is based on eating from their hands, that seems like a pretty shallow love. Why ignore such pankitis such as Vadeenai Kee dosti, Vadeenai Ka Khaan|| Sifti Saar Na Jaanani Sadaa Vasai Shaitaan|| and also:Santan Ka danaa rukhaa so sarab nidhaan|| Grehi Saakat Chhati parkar tai bikhoo samaan||<<<< I can point you many pankties too for the defending my argument. Let me know if you want me to print them for you. >>>To show love for humanity is part of Sikhi, but how can one expect to help them when one cannot help themselves. One must svaar themselves through Guru Gobind Singh Ji's rehit and then think of svaaring others.<<< I guess you are not aware of any good work done for humanity by any non rehti Sikhs or non Sikhs ? This does sound really odd. Gurbani have power to enlighten anybody if they start reading it and make effort to do vichar of it, it is not like Sanskrit which is difficult and written for Acdemic elite, it is simple and comprehensive, of course help from others Gurusikhs and Scholars does make it easy. And yes Sangat is very important. >>>As for Bhai Sahibs books, although they are not puraatan texts, all that Bhai Sahib has written is just elaboration of Bani and Puraatan rehit maryada, except it is written for the common person so they too can benefit from the amazing avastha of Bhai Sahib. It is rarely that a person that themselves have had experiences write about it and guide others to do so. This is the true help for humanity. This is kindness. This is love. <<< I think Bahi Sahibs contribution is extremely admirable, Please also do not forget that Guru Sahib themselves have written Gurubani which is the real Guru for us now. And don’t forget that that is THE BEST GUIDE and THE BEST FRIEND you have who is more close to you then any other thing in the world. That is the most kindest thing ever and that is the real true love of Sikh Gurus in the form of SHRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI. …As for Guru Gobind Singh Ji, he also said, Rehit Pyaaree Mujh Ko, SIkh Pyaare Nahe|| It is the rehit of a Sikh that he loves, not the individual<< Yes of course discipline is very dear to Guru Sahib and I have on issue with that. >>>I do not understand what 'philosophy of Guru Granth Sahib Ji' you are talking about, when you dismiss many central themes such as sangat, the mehma of Gursikhs, the importance for Sikhs to listen to guru ji, and the fact that there is only one true path to Akaal Purkh, through Satguru. Instead you promote an accept all approach, and I am not sure where you find this philosophy where it says this. Kindness and daya is essential, but they are essential for bhagti, and bhagti e.i. Naam Japnaa and Bani parnee is the important keys, from which one can svaar oneself.<<< Where I have dismissed Sangat ? Where I have said mehma of Gurusikhs is bad? Which approach you are saying please point out from my writing. Kindness is the fundamental of any principle, if you lose kindness then what ever is left could not possibly be religion. Of course Naam Japna is crucial where did I say you can ignore Naam Japna Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Kulwinder Singh · 30 Nov 2005

Dear UK Singh ji, ======================================================================== You stated ''I think Guru Ji want a Sikh to focus on others welfare as well rather then just on oneself.'' Why can a Sikh not do both concurrently? ============================================================================ ANS: Dear UK singh ji pleas read carefully you will see my line have “Rather then just” which is exactly what you are saying as well. ========================================================================== ''The Point I am raising is that the Only thing to go drumming about being in dress code which actually if not done to reflect the inside of human being state work as a decoy for and can be very misleading. Without the state inside being higher or equal to outside become Dikhawa ( Pretending) and that to my knowledge is far from be a desirable position.'' No one is perfect - even people who wear bana have to deal with being robbed by the 5 chors daily. Dikhawa is an intentional desire to deceive the masses. I too feel that this maybe the case in the younger generation - especially within the Nihang fold. As we do not know the spiritual status of their minds, we should not be questioning how they dress. Inner rehit is just as important as outer. ========================================================================== ANS: My vir I agree with you 100%, I am not saying don’t wear Bana, I am saying don’t say to other that they are some kind of sub standard human or Sikhs. ============================================================================ ''Guru Ji has shown us direct way to GOD not via any middle man, where does this through beloved Gursikhs comes from, How one is going to be sure which Gurusikhs is the one to follow, or are you saying let’s look for some Baba ji of some sort ? Very odd. Guru Sahib shown us the straight path in Simple Gurumukhi, rather then taking that path and guide, you are saying listen to some other individuals, Why ? Or this is an attempt to claim that people should listen to certain individuals who you think are passport officers for Guru Sahib. '' If someone is more spiritually advanced than yourself, there is no reason why one cannot goto them for advice/guidance. There is no denying that there are some rare souls that can point us in the right direction. ============================================================================ ANS: Well if you have seen some of these Singh then you are very lucky and I bet you any thing in the world, that they will say to you that pray to GOD and Listen to Guru to progress rather then listen to me or my way. ============================================================================ Points I agree with: I do not believe in Brahmanvad for a second and do not understand why some Singhs become fanatical over issues surrounding langar and do not see why amrtidharis without keski cannot perform kirtan?? ANS:I am glad you agree with the Guru Sahib. ============================================================================ [%sig%]

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

RoopKaur · 03 Dec 2005

You say bani is easy to understand, please do viakha of the seheskriti saloks for me, and without looking at the english translations. Or even Majh ki vaar. THe truth is, without the knowledge of the Viakran of Gurbani and without the joint effort of sangat to figure out the meanings of Gurbani, it is impossible to understand it. Take your reading of the pankitit, Bin Satgur Kinai Na Paeoo, Bin Satgur Kinai Na Paeaa. YOu say satgur is for akaal purkh, but in fact satgur is Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. There is no doubt about this, as Bhai Gurdas Ji says, Satgur Nanak pargatiaa mitee dhund jag chaanan hoaa. and Satgur Nanak Deo Guraa(n) Gur Hoeaa. Even the next pankiti of the former pankiti, Satguru vich aap rakheon kar pargat aakh sunaaeaa, proves that Satgur and Akaal Purkh are two different entities. Your statement does not hold here. And you still did not ackowledge that the dates of bhagats you beleive in are not based on research and fact, but on guesses of an outsider historian. Perhaps you should look at the hard evidence. As for sub standard treatment. This is just haumai, to bring down someones rehit because whoever they do not eat from or whoever is not allowd to do keertan feels slighted. But answer this, if we do not let non amritdharees be panj pyarey, is this treating them as sub standar humans? There are certain requirements that certain sevas have, and to change this rehit or tradition of the Khalsa just so we can fit our religion into the dominant discourse of "we are all equal" is not acceptable. We all know that the dastaar is part of the Sikh rehit and uniform, so what is the big deal if a bibi wears it? Why do you discourage bibiaa from wearing keski? Do you think this is a right for only males? You also mention there are non rehit people who help people. But how are they helping them? They might give them temporary relief in this world, but what about the next world? What is the point of doing these good deeds if they do not take care of their dharm? What help CAN someone give without Guru Ji, and what is the point of giving our head to guru ji if we cannot even listen to what they say? THe point of becoming a Sikh is to meet Akaal Purkh, and this is through Naam, Bani and Rehit. If these things are neglected, and a person does not svaar themselves, how can they think of svaaring others? Please, give gurbani quotes that you claim go against bibek. I welcome this, as there are non. Also, you keep mentioning that LOVE is needed, but is not love needed for guru ji? How can a Sikh love others if they cannot love guru ji? And if a Sikh does love guru ji, how can they NOT follow rehit, if they know how important it was to guru ji. This does not make sense.

Re: Does the dress code and declaration of I follow rehit is sufficient ?

Kulwinder Singh · 04 Dec 2005

Dear Roop Kaur Ji, Thanks for coming back, (text between ---- is your writing in this reply) You have said: ------“you say bani is easy to understand, please do viakha of the seheskriti saloks for me, and without looking at the english translations. Or even Majh ki vaar. THe truth is, without the knowledge of the Viakran of Gurbani and without the joint effort of sangat to figure out the meanings of Gurbani, it is impossible to understand it.”-------- First thing first Seheskriti Salokes are in deed the most difficult bani to pronounce, and vichar of that without the knowledge of history and Language it is mega hard, But not to say that rest of the Bani is very simple written and to pick a small amount of Seheskriti Salokes ( which use to be used as test for the Granthi’s in Darbar Sahib Amritsar) and some how take them to characterized the Guru Granth Sahib as whole is very very odd coming from Some Gurusikh who I am sure well aware of the simplicity of Guru Granth Sahib, The point made was that it is not just for the elite like Hindu Scriptures. And I did say “it is simple and comprehensive, of course help from others Gurusikhs and Scholars does make it easy. And yes Sangat is very important.” With the Grace of my Guru Sahib anyway if you want I can attempt to do Viakha for anything you select. ------“Take your reading of the pankitit, Bin Satgur Kinai Na Paeoo, Bin Satgur Kinai Na Paeaa. YOu say satgur is for akaal purkh, but in fact satgur is Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. There is no doubt about this, as Bhai Gurdas Ji says, Satgur Nanak pargatiaa mitee dhund jag chaanan hoaa. and Satgur Nanak Deo Guraa(n) Gur Hoeaa. Even the next pankiti of the former pankiti, Satguru vich aap rakheon kar pargat aakh sunaaeaa, proves that Satgur and Akaal Purkh are two different entities. Your statement does not hold here.”---------- Roop Kaur Ji you should have read the last tow pankitis too……. Which are. outham eaehu beechaar hai jin sachae sio chith laaeiaa || jagajeevan dhaathaa paaeiaa ||6|| -You are also saying “ ----- “ And you still did not acknowledge that the dates of bhagats you believe in are not based on research and fact, but on guesses of an outsider historian. Perhaps you should look at the hard evidence.”-------- Hypothetically Let’s take your view as truth on this. If all the Bhagats were Sikhs then, Why did Kabir never said he is Sikh of Guru Nank, Why Nam Dev never mentioned that Just explain this to me and I think that would be big help to me to see some light in your argument. ਮਹਲਾ ੫ ॥ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਗੋਬਿੰਦ ਸੰਗਿ ਨਾਮਦੇਉ ਮਨੁ ਲੀਣਾ ॥ ਆਢ ਦਾਮ ਕੋ ਛੀਪਰੋ ਹੋਇਓ ਲਾਖੀਣਾ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਬੁਨਨਾ ਤਨਨਾ ਤਿਆਗਿ ਕੈ ਪ੍ਰੀਤਿ ਚਰਨ ਕਬੀਰਾ ॥ ਨੀਚ ਕੁਲਾ ਜੋਲਾਹਰਾ ਭਇਓ ਗੁਨੀਯ ਗਹੀਰਾ ॥੧॥ ਰਵਿਦਾਸੁ ਢੁਵੰਤਾ ਢੋਰ ਨੀਤਿ ਤਿਨਿ ਤਿਆਗੀ ਮਾਇਆ ॥ ਪਰਗਟੁ ਹੋਆ ਸਾਧਸੰਗਿ ਹਰਿ ਦਰਸਨੁ ਪਾਇਆ ॥੨॥ ਸੈਨੁ ਨਾਈ ਬੁਤਕਾਰੀਆ ਓਹੁ ਘਰਿ ਘਰਿ ਸੁਨਿਆ ॥ ਹਿਰਦੇ ਵਸਿਆ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਭਗਤਾ ਮਹਿ ਗਨਿਆ ॥੩॥ ਇਹ ਬਿਧਿ ਸੁਨਿ ਕੈ ਜਾਟਰੋ ਉਠਿ ਭਗਤੀ ਲਾਗਾ ॥ ਮਿਲੇ ਪ੍ਰਤਖਿ ਗੁਸਾਈਆ ਧੰਨਾ ਵਡਭਾਗਾ ॥੪॥੨॥ Where it is saying that Dhana met Guru Nanak Dev Ji and then went to achieve GOD ? you are then saying “ -----As for sub standard treatment. This is just haumai, to bring down someones rehit because whoever they do not eat from or whoever is not allowd to do keertan feels slighted. But answer this, if we do not let non amritdharees be panj pyarey, is this treating them as sub standar humans? There are certain requirements that certain sevas have, and to change this rehit or tradition of the Khalsa just so we can fit our religion into the dominant discourse of "we are all equal" is not acceptable.” --------- You really make me laugh when you give example of the above of Punj Pyarey Seva to establish the Equality concept in general. Dear Kaur Ji , Learn something form the outer world too, Take an example of UNO, the organization which represent the whole human society, Even on the platform for that is only open to some selective people, who are authorized by their role and duties, What Punj Pyara do is a special ceremony it is restricted to those who themselves have Amrit Shakea to administer the Amrit, Even Guru Gobind Singh Ji asked for Amrit from Punj Pyarae, on the contrai the Gift of Kirtan was given to Sangat ( not some exclusive club) by Guru Arjan Dev Ji. IF what you are saying is right about only high “standard Sikhs” can do the kirtan how it is different from Kicking Bhagat Nam Dev Ji Out , Just because somebody get kicked out because of caste or “A standard” does not make slightest difference to the person who is getting kicked for being different. So it is ok for Pir budhu Shah’s sons to die for Guru Sahib but not to do kirtan ? Dear Roop karu ji you do not have case, as Kirtan is just singing the praise of GOD and GURU and everybody have right to do that. -----Strangely you are saying. “We all know that the dastaar is part of the Sikh rehit and uniform, so what is the big deal if a bibi wears it? Why do you discourage bibiaa from wearing keski? Do you think this is a right for only males? “------------- Where have I said bibia should not wear Keski ? you are making this up as most likely that is what you want me to say, Please let me know where have I said what you are making is a serious accusation? You have also said---------“You also mention there are non rehit people who help people. But how are they helping them? They might give them temporary relief in this world, but what about the next world? -----------“ I think when Guru Nanak Dev Ji met hungry Sadhus, The first thing he thought was to supply them with the Langar to make them healthy, rather then he though ok, I know you are hungry but let’s get your after life sorted first ! Now roop kaur ji make your own mind on the issue, Guru Sahib started Langar to help anybody who was hungry, Even Akbar came and had langar he did not converted to be a Sikh for sure, Guru Sahib said first Pangat phir Sangat. Now are you going to say Akbar never came to Guru Sahib or he never had langar ? ------ “What is the point of doing these good deeds if they do not take care of their dharm? “------------------ I think Dharm mean principle and I am sure those who work to help other do have some very valuable, admirable and strong principles. ------------------What help CAN someone give without Guru Ji,and what is the point of giving our head to guru ji if we cannot even listen to what they say? THe point of becoming a Sikh is to meet Akaal Purkh, and this is through Naam, Bani and Rehit. ----------------- I got your point now , Kindness, Love and Service are completely ignored by you which are MUST even before you start doing NAM, BANI and Rehit The Three things you have mentioned are important and must to progress but to get to the starting point the three I have mentioned are must. You can not ignore them and jump on the one three you have mentioned. -------------If these things are neglected, and a person does not svaar themselves, how can they think of svaaring others?---------------- I think that question can be answered by Pir Budhu Saha Ji …… Try asking Him. I am more then certain he will give you more then satisfying answer. -------------Please, give gurbani quotes that you claim go against bibek. I welcome this, as there are non.-------------------- Please give me my written text copy where I have said go against bibek to start with then we can progress on your claim. -------------Also, you keep mentioning that LOVE is needed, but is not love needed for guru ji? How can a Sikh love others if they cannot love guru ji? And if a Sikh does love guru ji, how can they NOT follow rehit, if they know how important it was to guru ji. This does not make sense.------------------ LOVE is need for everything never mind Guru Sahib, Where I have said rehit is not important, again you are saying things which you want me to say but I have not said that. So get your facts right, and please provide reply. Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]