Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Balpreet Singh · 18 Nov 2005

Blue *IS* A Khalsa Colour I applaud Bhai Amritpal Singh Amrit for his analysis of Snatani practices. But as they say, we shouldn’t, "throw the baby out with the bath-water". I was concerned to see him try to dismiss Blue as a Khalsa colour. Blue has traditionally been worn by the Khalsa along with orange and white. Black is also acceptable but became popular later on. I will try to give a preliminary reply to his article here Muslims & Blue I and some other Singhs were discussing Bhai Amrit’s article on blue clothes and one Singh asked why “neel bastar” were described as being Muslim colours and why the Khalsa now wears neela. Muslims are not discerned by blue clothes now. In the past Muslim dress has always thought to have been green (haideri) and Muslim Ghazis are known to wear Green clothing. Why does Gurbani say neela? A Singh from Kashmir (Poonch) was sitting with us and he said that where he is from, the locals call green “neela”. They call green chilis not “haree mirch” but “neelee mirch” they call green grass “neela ghaa”. This explains it. For people of that area (mainly Muslims), neela meant not blue, but green. What Did Guru Gobind Singh Wear? There has been an attempt to say that Guru Gobind Singh jee only wore blue when leaving the forest in Macchiwara. The oldest account of Guru Gobind Singh jee and the formation of the Khalsa is the Bhatt Vehis. What do the Bhatt Vehis say about what Guru Sahib wore when the Khalsa was created? The Bhatt Vehi "Multani Sindhi Pargana Thanaysar" is described by Piara Singh Padam as the oldest account of this event : >>>>>>>>>>> "Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji, tenth Guru, son of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, in the year 1752 on Tuesday-the Vaisakhi day-gave Khande ki pahul to five Sikhs and surnamed them as Singhs. First Daya Ram Sopti, Khatri resident of Lahore stood up. Then Mohkam Chand Calico printer of Dawarka; Sahib Chand barber of Zafrabad city; Dharam Chand Jawanda Jat of Hastinapur; Himmat Chand water carrier of Jagannath stop up one after the other. All were dressed in blue and he himself also dressed the same way. Hookah, halaal, hajaamat, haraam, tikka, janeu, dhoti were prohibited. Socialisation with the descendants of Prithi Chand, followers of Dhirmal and Ram Rai, clean shaven people and Masands was prohibited. All were given Kangha, Karad, Kesgee, Karhaa, and Kacheraa. All were made Keshdhaaree. Everyone’s place of birth was told to be Patna, of residence as Anandpur. Rest, Guru’s deeds are known only to the Guru. Repeat Guru Guru, the Guru will help everywhere >>>>>>>>>> So blue was the colour the Khalsa was first given according to the oldest source. Bhai Amritpal Singh has said: >>>>>>>> Furthermore, when Guru Gobind Singh Ji left for his heavenly abode, he was also in saffron ('Kesree') attire. 'Gur Bilaas Paatshaahee 10' written by Bhai Kuyer Singh clearly mentions the colour of Guru Ji's clothing, when he left for the 'Sachkhand': - Aap Snaan Karyo Sah Kesan, Kesree Khyom Patam Pahraaye. From the foregoing analysis of various texts, we can conclude that Guru Gobind Singh Ji wore clothing of various colours and that to assert that he wore only blue attire after the inauguration of the Khalsa in 1699 is wholly incorrect. >>>>>>>>>>>>>> No one denies that kesri is an acceptable colour. Punj Pyaaray today generally are all dressed in kesri robes. Kesri is considered a royal colour. The fact that Guru Gobind Singh jee was wearing kesri only says that kesri is an acceptable colour for the Sikhs as well, not that blue is not special or unacceptable (as the article seems to suggest). What would surprise me would be if Bhai Amritpal Singh could show me any reference to Dashmesh Pita jee wearing something besides Blue, White, Kesri or Black. That would be a find. Clearly, Blue was a special and acceptable colour of the Khalsa. Guru Gobind Singh jee being royalty, wore kesri as well (as our royal Punj Pyaaray still do today). This is not a surprise, but to be expected. Puraatan Sikhs and Colours Amritpal Singh has provided the quotation about the dress of the sahibzadas: >>>>>>> the Sahibzadas were in fact in saffron (Kesaree) clothing: - Kesaree Ang Paushaak Mahaabar, Moorat Pekh Kahai Eh Baanee. >>>>>>> As I said before, Kesree is the royal colour for the Sikhs. It is no shock that the princely Sahibzadas would have worn this colour. What I do take issue with is Bhai Amrit’s next statement: >>>>>>>>>> Bhai Sukha Singh speaks of Sahibzada Ajit Singh Ji, the eldest son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji being called into the holy court of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. He comes to Guru Ji and Bhai Sukha Singh describes his attire as consisting of red ('Arun') shoes which were shining on Sahibzada Ajit Singh Ji's feet, a red shawl, a red shirt and a red turban which graceful upon his head. The original lines read as follows: - >>>>>>>>> The colour red has been forbidden amongst the Sikhs since the start. It is not an acceptable colour for Sikhs to wear. Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama tells us that those “who use colour prepared from red ochre or the kusumbha flower” are tankhaiyas. It says plainly, “Bastr kusunbhay na pehray” or “Do not wear clothing which is coloured red. ”(verse 23). Bhai Prehlad Singh rehitnama also tells us, “soohay anbar pehn kar jo naasay nasvar…” “He who wears red clothing, or inhales nasavar up his nose will be beaten about the head and thrown into hell” (verse 12). So how is it that this description of Baba Ajeet Singh jee came about? It must be asked, Who was Sukha Singh? The fact is that he NEVER SAW Sahibzada Baba Ajeet Singh jee. On what basis is he giving such a detailed description besides his own imagination? Sukha Singh was born in 1768 and wrote this in 1797. After a hundred years, how would he know what Baba jee was wearing? This is clearly his own literary imagination at work, not a statement of fact. Bhai Amrit has also given a description of Baba Gurbaksh Singh and the Singhs with him who became Shaheeds. He quotes Pracheen Panth Prakash as following: >>>>>>>>> Giani Gian Singh writes in 'Panth Prakash' that Bhai Gurbaksh Singh wore saffron clothing, when he went to fight: - Tan Dhare Bastar Kesree, Dastaar Ooch Sajaaye. (He wore saffron robes and tied a high turban). In 'Pracheen Panth Parkash', Ratan Singh Bhangu speaks of the colours worn by other Sikh companions of Bhai Gurbaksh Singh Ji: Kisai Pushaak Thee Neelee Sajaayee. Kinai Set, Kisai Kesaree Rangvaayee. >>>>>>>>> This is no big finding. It goes with what has always been known. White, Orange and Blue are all Khalsa colours. The story of Baba Gurbaksh Singh in Panth Parkash (Bhangu) actually begins with a saying "neel bastar rakh, reh rehit changee" meaning Baba jee wore blue clothes and kept good rehit. It doesn’t say here that they wore green or red. Only Orange, Blue and White. This is in complete accordance with Khalsa Tradition. What I do find interesting that Bhai Amrit has not taken note of is that Baba Gurbaksh Singh jee is said to have an "ooch" dastaar. Perhaps in those days these type of dastaars weren't called dumallas, but by any name, it is the same thing. Baba jee's dumalla had different chakars and a kirpan in it(according to Panth Parkash). Clearly, even if it wasn't called a dumalla, it was indeed a dumalla. This is in contrast to Bhai Amrit's assertion that dumalla did not exist in those days. I’m not much moved by the descriptions of Singhs in only kacherras and blankets. Singhs in those times had very little. Depending on the condition of the weather and their own economic condition, it is possible they wore very little. But that does not go to say that Sikh dress is no dress at all. Clearly this dress was functional for the circumstances. Even today some bana-wearing Singhs will wear only a fatoohee (short kurta) when they are training for gatka or some other circumstance, but that doesn’t mean this alone in isolation is the dress. Clearly when the went to Guru Sahib's darbar they were not dressed in just a kacherra. Proof of Special Nature of Blue Dress Blue dress is not something recently invented for the Khalsa. As mentioned before, Bhatt VEhis tell us that Guru Sahib himself dressed the Khalsa in Blue. Furthermore, the old vaar“Vah Vah Gobind Singh Aapay Gur Chela” we all sing, by Bhai Gurdas II, tells us about the creation of the Khalsa as well. [gurbani] inj pMQ clwieE Kwlsw Dir qyj krwrw] isr kys Dwir gih KVg ko sB dust pCwrw] sIl jq kI kC phir pkVo hiQAwrw] sc Pqy bulweI gurU kI jIiqE rx Bwrw] sB dYq Airin ko Gyr kir kIcY pRhwrw] qb sihjy pRgitE jgq mY guru jwp Apwrw] ieauN aupjy isMG BujMgIey nIl AMbr Dwrw][/gurbani] See the last line. It says that “thus the Bhujangi Singhs were created, dressed in blue”. The puritan Rehitnamas also tell us that Blue is a Khalsa colour. Bhai Daya Singh’s rehtinama tells us that a Khalsa colour is “surmaiee” or dark blue (verse 23). He goes on further to say , “So Akali rooop hai neel bastar dherai” or “An Akali is known by the blue garments he wears”. Clearly blue clothing was a special Khalsa colour! Rattan Singh Bhangu in Pracheen Panth Parkash writes about the differences that lead to the split between Baba Banda Singh and the Tat-Khalsa. In regards to the clothing issue, he writes that Baba Banda Singh wanted his soldiers to wear red, which was unacceptable to the traditionally blue wearing Khalsa: [gurbani]“nIl pihrn qy dUr krwXo] smrw sUhw sIs bMDwXo][/gurbani] meaning, “he tried to wean them away from blue. He made them tie red on their heads” The Khalsa would not give up blue and could not wear red, so a split occurred. This also flies against Bhai Amrit's assertion that the Tat-Khalsa only took on blue after the split. They clearly were wearing blue before. Thus you can see that the Khalsa did indeed wear blue clothing and considered it their “special” colour, not just one colour amongst many others. Blue is a traditional Khalsa colour and we should feel proud to wear it. Blue isn't the only acceptable colour. Orange, White and Black are fine as well. But I do think that Blue was perhaps the one most Khalsa preferred. Just because some Nihang Singhs do corrupt practices like Bhang does not mean we should dismiss everything about them. They do have many traditions preserved like bana, sarbloh, gatka, etc. These should be appreciated. I have not written this to be a comprehensive article in support of blue. That would require a lot more research and that is something I don’t have much time for at the moment, but I did want to give an answer to the article on blue clothing. [%sig%]

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

singh. · 18 Nov 2005

I think amrit pal singh is on sikhawareness if i m not mistaken. you better be off putting it on there so he can reply to your post.

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Gurpreet Singh · 18 Nov 2005

yeah, good points, actually, great points. but you should consider raising them somewhere he can reply back

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Seva · 19 Nov 2005

Great post Veer Ji. Very well written and enlightening. It is pretty much clear that blue is indeed the preferred color of Khalsa, along with orange, white and black. One point, in the Bhatt Vehi account you quote, it says: "Hookah, halaal, hajaamat, haraam, tikka, janeu, dhoti were prohibited." A thought that sprung to mind here is that in those days the vast majority of meat eaters were Muslims and they most like referred to meat as halaal, so when Bhatt Vehi mentions Halaal (note these are Bhatt Vehi's words, not Guru shaib's) he is actually referring to all meat. My understanding is the the words "haraam" also refers to meat. Is that true? What does "hajaamat" mean?

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

uksingh · 19 Nov 2005

black blue orange = gurmat colours neele bastar - group of muslims, the pathans used to wear blue also but this doesnt make blue any less of a khalsa colour

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

singh · 19 Nov 2005

hajaamat is shave and halaal doesnot ALL meat. and muslims were not majority on what basis do u say so? I still await answers from balpreet singh and '/ ' on bhai randhir singh ji wearing dumala

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Balpreet Singh · 19 Nov 2005

singh, I've answered the dumalla question before, but for your sake I'll answer it again here. Giani Harbhajan Singh jee told me personally that Bhai Sahib used to wear a Dumalla in the early days of the Jatha. He also showed me a painting that he has in his home of Bhai Sahib dressed in a dumalla and chola. Also, in "Lagaa(n) Matraa(n) Dee Vilakhanta" , in the introduction, Bhai Sahib tells the story of how he was in a divan and the Granthi was corrected by a Gyani sitting in the sangat, but corrected incorrectly. Bhai Sahib said that the Granthi was correct and he says the Gyani spoke rudely thinking Bhai Sahib was just some Nihang Singh. The question is, why would the Gyani mistake Bhai Sahib for a Nihang? He obviously had to have been dressed like one for that to have happened ie. chola, dumalla. As for "halal" in this quotation: Bhai Manmohan Singh LA says that the reference to both Halal and Haraam make both types of meat forbidden. I personally think that the poet was taking poetic license of making the four kurehits all start with "H" ie. "hajamat, halal, hookah, haram". The other account based on the Bhatt Vehis (there are more than one) by Sarup Singh Kaushish says the following: >>>>>>>>>>> Thereafter, Guru ji pronounced, ‘on your rebirth in the Khalsa Panth, your previous lineage, caste, creed, calling, customs, beliefs and superstitions, etc. stand annulled from now onwards. Transforming you into the Order of Khalsa, I have endowed you with the apparel of the Almighty God, you shall have to keep its honour. Before administering this nectar of steel, I also bestowed you with five kakaars (Ks, i.e. defining emblems). You have never to keep them away from your body even by mistake. I gave you, at the start, a blue keski, kangha, kirpan, sarbloh ka kara and white kachhehra. In the event of the loss or misplacement of any of these, get its infringement pardoned in the Sangat by going to Gurdwara without any delay. "Now listen to the following four bajjar kurehats (negative injunctions or transgressions) by the commission of any of them a Sikh becomes an apostate and cannot intermingle with the Sikh sangat. The first is the dishonouring of one’s rom (hair) from top to be. The next are eating of kutha, using of tobacco and cohabiting with a Muslim woman. In the event of the infringement of any one of these, you must get yourself pardoned by having yourself re-baptized with the nectar of the broadsword. Do not cherish any relation or communication with the five antagonists of the Panth, that is, the descendants and followers of Prithi Chand, Dhir Mal, Ram Rai, masands and the shaven. Whosoever from any of them shall come to the Sangat and shall present himself for forgiveness for his omissions or commissions, he should be forgiven without any suspicion or hesitation. You shall not fix your faith, even by mistake, in any monastery, crematory, tomb or grave, excepting in God, the only One Timeless Being. I have blended you with gold’ - So do not harbour delusions and suspicions, differentiation’s and discriminations among yourselves". >>>>>>>>> So here, the word used is "kutha". As I've said before, kutha comes from the source "kuthaar" which means axe. Kutha refers to all butchered meat. It did not mean halal alone, just meat. Afterall, an axe is not the tool used for halal. "Cohabiting with Muslim women" is a very strict translation of "Muslee-yudh" which means in general adultery but translated literally it means Muslim-Women, when we clearly known from other sources it was women in general. At any rate, there are many sources that say meat is not allowed in Gurmat.

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Suraj Singh · 19 Nov 2005

Khalsa Ji, Good points and Amritpal Singh "Amrit" has been notified. He has read all of your points and will respond as soon as he gets time. He is busy as he is updating his website. He will respond on Sikhawareness.com under "Nihang dress" thread and it will be posted here for cyber Sikhs knowledge.

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

a.s.b · 21 Nov 2005

blue is the color of politics, orange is the color of 1984 white is the true khalsa color, and the maryada of dasam pitha.

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

singh · 21 Nov 2005

Thanks Balpreet for repeating what you had repeated earlier. My questions are repeated here again. My Questions... Who is this Giani Harbhajan Singh Ji and how old is he? When did Giani Harbhajan Singh Ji come into first contact with Bhai Randhir Singh Ji? Do you have any photographs of the painting being discussed here? What was the age of Bhai Randhir Singh Ji when he took Amrit?

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Balpreet Singh · 21 Nov 2005

At the risk of taking this thread off topic, Gyani Harbhajan Singh jee is a very old Singh. I don't know when he was born and I'm not sure when he met Bhai Sahib exactly. Bhai Sahib received amrit at the age of 25 in 1903. The painting is below:

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

singh · 21 Nov 2005

balpreet why not have it in a new thread rather than risking goin off topic we can discuss it there. What do you say?

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

uksingh · 21 Nov 2005

that looks like a gurmukhs dastar to me, with chakkar in like he usually wears

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

uksingh · 21 Nov 2005

*gurmukhi dastar*

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

.. · 21 Nov 2005

the theory about neele meaning green is weak i agree blue is a khalsa colour however, whether pathans wore blue or not dont matter.

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

singh · 21 Nov 2005

balpreet there is something written in punjabi on the pic and i cannot read because of resolution. will you kindly reproduce that punjabi?

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Balpreet Singh · 21 Nov 2005

Gurmukh piaray, naam baNee de raseeay, anthuk Akhand Kirtaniay, sidki sengramiay, kala premi, Bhai Sahib Sant Randhir Singh jee dee Janam Shatabadi dee pavitar yaad no sharda bhent. Eh chitar Sant jee nay apay tyar-bar-tyar ho kay, daas day sahmnay khalokay 1944 vich tyaar karvaiaaya. Valo, Trilok Singh chritrikaar. Guru Arjan Nagar, Patiala. (Please dont' stary brining up the "Sant" point. This was written and published by the artist. Neither Bhai Sahib nor the Singhs in the Jatha used the term "Sant" with his name)

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

A Singh · 21 Nov 2005

My reading of Amritpal Singh’s articles do not indicate any where for him to have stated that Blue is forbidden for the Khalsa – in fact he has shown that Blue is amongst the many colours including Saffron, Yellow, White, and even the dreaded Red that Singhs of old have worn. His point on Blue seems to be more akin to addressing the claim made by certain groups that BLUE is the ONLY colour of the Khalsa or even the ORIGINAL colour of the Khalsa which clearly has been shown to be incorrect. This is a point, that I have personally mentioned before on this site (of course at the ever increasing reassurance from some members that I am some sort of paid RSS agent!). The point being that all the stories concerning Neela Bana and its various meanings and uses from being a supposedly distinguishing Sikh colour, to be effective camouflage, particularly for night time attack through to the favourites of the UK Nihangs concerning the understandable psychological advantage Blue presents in Battle (blood appears as sweat) through to the weird and wonderful claim of it signifying SHIV SAROOP (correct me if I’m wrong, but doesn’t Shiv Jee wear little more than a Lion Cloth? Even accounting for the possibility that the reference to Neela is to his skin tone, SHIV SAROOP in both respects is probably more akin to Udasis than Nihangs, more so given the former even acknowledge this much in their matras – but anyway this is a separate discussion) are all items and tales that came into vogue post the creation of the Khalsa in 1699, i.e. they were not ideals set up by Guru Sahib. This does not in all cases, negate their value – but they certainly indicate that the notion of Blue being THE Khalsa colour per se is incorrect. Why harp on about this, why not ask our Blue dressing brothers, why they harp on about other colours like white in particular, as being inappropriate for the Khalsa – amongst these would include Baba Nihal Singh Hariawale, who in his speech on Fort Panth Khalsa suggests that one cannot fight wearing white, only blue is a warriors clothing – presumably then, the likes of Baba Sham Singh Atariawala and Baba Ram Singh Namdhari, both who were valiant warriors and dressed in white, would not qualify as such according to this Nihang Baba and another learned Veer and Gursikh is none other than our respected Bhai Kulbir Singh, who in an article in which he sought to address trends persistent in today’s Diaspora took particular issue with the East African dastaars and the wearing of WHITE clothes as something that would NOT please Guru Sahib, the latter on the basis that Blue is the colour that Guru Sahib desires for his Khalsa. In short, perhaps we can reconsider this item more carefully without needing to jump to conclusions, as not everyone presenting something slightly different to the notions we have all be fed from young is necessarily pursuing a sinister hidden agenda. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

A Singh · 21 Nov 2005

Veer Balpreet Singh, That’s an awesome picture – please could you tell us some more about when Bhai Sahib Jee first begun adopt the Bana of a Nihang (his autobiography doesn’t really point to this ever occurring and presumably given his family background he would not have been raised wearing a Dumala or Chola) and also why following his release and tremendous efforts to revive much of the Tat Gurmat Maryada, he didn’t revert back to wearing this Bana? Thanks and Gur Fateh! A Singh. p.s. On a personal note, glad to hear about your resilience on the Kirpan issue, keep up the great work and Chardi Kala!

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Balpreet Singh · 21 Nov 2005

I don't know when Bhai Sahib began to wear this type of baNa. After Gyani jee told me, I noticed the reference in Lagaa(n) Matraa(n) Dee Vilakhanta and it seemed to make sense to me that if he was mistaken for a Nihang, he probably was wearing a chola/dumalla. I also found the reference to Mata Kartar Kaur dressed like an "Akali of old" "On one side of the hall, the daughters of Mata Sahib Kaur were appearing. At this, our royal meeting, the Singhnis present appeared to the Panth in the image of Mai Bhago. From amongst them, Bibi Kartar Kaur jee (wife of Bhai Randhir Singh ji) was in the uniform of an Akali of old. It was said that she was in truth the picture of a female Singh of ancient times" [Akali Newspaper, October 23, 1920, page 2] So if Mata jee was dressing like this in 1920, I can only assume Bhai Sahib used to dress like this as well before he went to jail. All this put together leads me to believe Bhai Sahib did indeed wear this baNa. But I wasn't there so I could very well be wrong.

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Balpreet Singh · 21 Nov 2005

I think that in my research, I have shown that Blue was a special colour for the Khalsa and not just one colour amongst many (as I believe the article on amritworld was trying to say). I don't think anyone would suggest saffron/orange, white and black are unacceptable, but I do think Blue was the most common and probably was "special".

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

#* · 21 Nov 2005

i know very little about the Bhatt Vehis rehitnama, was it written at the time of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, if not then when? Did the author ever have any interactions with Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself? Finally someone stated that the Bhatt Vehis are not Sikh, is this true?

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Kulbir Singh · 21 Nov 2005

Some asked for more information on Bhai Sahib Giani Harbhajan Singh jee. Bhai Sahib is the brother-in-law of Bhai Atma Singh jee Panjokhra Sahib walay. Bhai Harbhajan Singh jee is from village Shatrana of Patiala district and is one of the most respected Jatha Singhs alive today. Whole of his family follows the strict Bibek rehit of Khalsa and Giani jee himself is an embodiment of Gurmat. Talking to him and just by being in his sangat one gets the Chardi Kala feeling of Khalsa. During the times of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee, he used to do sewa in the langar area. He does wonderful kirtan. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

singh · 22 Nov 2005

so this picture you got is printed in 1978 Do you have the original print of the painting?

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Suraj Singh · 25 Dec 2005

Amritworld.com has updated the section in which refutal has been provided by Amardeep Singh. http://www.amritworld.com/nihangs/comments_by_amardeepsingh.html Also, check new section introduced on the same website at http://www.amritworld.com/gallery/book_release.html [%sig%]

Re: Blue *IS* a Khalsa Colour

Balpreet Singh · 26 Dec 2005

In the article I’ve argued not that blue is “an acceptable colour”, I’ve argued it is more than just acceptable, it was the special Khalsa colour. My comment on the Singh from Poonch, according to Amardeep Singh “should in fact indicate that the Khalsa’s primary colour is Green, not blue – why does Balpreet Singh suddenly forget this new found fact? “ Unless one has serious intellectual impairment, I think it was clear that I have argued that for Muslims in the Kashmir area, neela means green. This is not the case for Sikh writers. “Bhai Sukha Singh, it appears is someone that Balpreet Singh is not too familiar with. Bhai Sukha Singh, if we deviate for a moment, was the Granthi at Sri Keshgarh Sahib and also a valiant warrior who also participated in battle” A cursory look at any article on Sukha Singh will tell you that he was the author of a number of spurious works he tried to pass off as the writings of Guru Gobind Singh. He is not exactly a respectable figure in Sikh literature. The fact you see it fit to valorise him says a lot for your ideology. Amardeep Singh finishes off, “Bhai Balpreet Singh Jee is entitled to his belief that Blue received special preference, however he has shown no primary evidence to support this case, so as such it remains an opinion, to which of course we are all entitled. “ Nice. First Amardeep Singh said I was trying to show that blue was “acceptable” now he himself admits I was trying to show it was special. Whether I made a convincing case or not is of course up to individual readers, but I feel there is little doubt it was. I find "critiques" like this somewhat funny because they try to pass off a more or less empty argument as intelligent commentary. My point was clear but perhaps the reader's processing was a bit muddled? At any rate, it's a good try at a rebuttal, but I don't think it was all that successful. My point was that blue is the special Khalsa colour. I think any reader can see the evidence supports this assertion.