Re: When one died, two were dead
chalte chalte · 16 Nov 2005
Author: guessing
Date: 11-16-05 07:40
The two women were pregnant, and expecting boys
.....
Oh thats a clever answer! This Salok has had me thinking for a long time and that seems like a logical answer!
[%sig%]
Re: When one died, two were dead
panjabi translation · 16 Nov 2005
professor sahib singh is unsure what the 6 refers to but he uses other salokhs and baani to come to the conclusion of this:
[gurbani]ArQ:— hy kbIr ! (pRBU dy gux gWivAW guxW dw AMq qW nhIN pY skdw, pr ies is&iq-swlwh dI brkiq nwl ‘mn’ mr jWdw hY ‘mn’ ivkwrW vloN ht jWdw hY) ies ie`k mn dy mrn nwl iek hor BI mirAw jwiq-AiBmwn, qy kul do mr gey—mn Aqy jwiq-AiBmwn [ iPr do hor mry—dyh-A`ØiDAws Aqy iq®Snw; ku`l cwr ho gey [ do hor mry—kusMg Aqy inMdw; qy ieh swry Cy ho gey, cwr puilMg (‘purK’) Aqy do iesq®I-ilMg (‘nwir’) [91[[/gurbani]
Re: When one died, two were dead
Kulbir Singh · 17 Nov 2005
This salok is unsolved. Different scholars have interpreted it in their own ways. Bhagat jee has not mentioned what has died. He just says that when one died, one more died, totally total 2 dead. When the two died, two more died adding up to a total of 4 dead.
When 4 died, 2 more died and now there were 6 dead. Out of these total 6 dead, 4 were men and 2 were women.
So let’s see now, when one died, someone else died too making the total number at 2. When these two died, two more died, making the total Four dead.
Before we go further, we need to figure out the following:
1) Who dies first?
2) When this first thing dies, who dies along with it?
3) When total two are dead, which other two die along with them?
4) Finally when the last two things (or people) die, what two more things die?
5) The total number of dead now sit at 6.
6) Out of the six, four are men and two are women.
Let’s all think about this and come up with an answer. Bhagat jee has written a riddle that we all should solve.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: When one died, two were dead
Kulbir Singh · 17 Nov 2005
Professor Sahib Singh jee has written that after mann dies, the next one that dies is Jaat-abhimaan (pride of one’s high class) but I don’t agree with this. Jaat Abhimaan is such a little thing as compared to other evils. Jaat Abhimaan dies even before one's mann dies. So it's got to be something else.
What is the first thing that dies after mann dies (or is controlled)? What is the first thing that dies? Haume or Mann? Perhaps the first thing that dies is Haume and not mann. Or is it the other way roung.
Lets list the things that should die before we achieve Vaheguru:
Haume
Bharam
Trishna
Dubidha
Mann (or Manmat)
What else?
Lets all think about this and reach a conclusion. I am still thinking.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: When one died, two were dead
Gurpreet Singh · 17 Nov 2005
What i thought it meant when originally reading it was that when 1 dies (kills his maan, surrenders to akaal purakh) he takes others along with him (another one dies) when this one dies as well, he also influences others (2 more die)
what i didnt get was 4 men and 2 women...................
Re: When one died, two were dead
Inderjit Singh Dhillon · 17 Nov 2005
Please forgive any error this is my lame attempt at answering the riddle.
The one human exists of 3 entities: body, mind and soul, when the human dies, the body and mind both cease to exist (die), the soul continues in the here after which is feminine in character and is referred to has the bride-soul so is in a sense female. The body and mind are bondage for the soul so are therefore masculine. So when the 4 died that is 2 bodies and 2 minds, these are 4 males and forms of bondage, the 2 females are the souls they are referred to as dead and as such the whole theme of the entire shabad is about liberating your soul whilst alive.
This is in no way the truth!
Inderjit Singh Dhillon
Re: When one died, two were dead
Tarsem Singh · 18 Nov 2005
According to Guru Tegh Bahadur Jee, the following should be dead before God can be met:
pain/pleasure (reaction to dukh/sukh)
fear
distinction between valuables and non valuables (gold and dust)
slandering/praise (doing and reacting to)
5 chor
sadness/happiness (reacting to situations in harkh sog)
pride
hope and desire (aasa mansa)
Re: When one died, two were dead
Harinder Singh · 05 Sep 2006
I feel that the thing that shud die is hope.That is there shud be only one hope (that of marrying Waheguru) and all other hopes shud die. Once this happens haume, 5 demons, trishna, bharam, rog will automatically extinguish.
These hopes can only die when one starts to get Anand from Naam and Bani.When the mind starts to get substantial rass, it will automatically stop going after wordly entities and hence hopes will die.
Re: When one died, two were dead
santbirsingh · 07 Sep 2006
Professor Sahib Singh's explanation needs to be better explained. He demonstrates that all of the things that are talked about in the Slokhs refer back to earlier slokhs (at least 14 slokhs back from what i recall). his argument is fairly convincing and seems to me to be best explanation. the other eplanation traditionaly given of a hunter killing a deer and so forth does not seem to serve any real purpose for sikhyia.
intrestingly, in bhagat kabir's writings not collected in guru granth sahib jee he has many more riddles, many of them also still unsolved.
fateh!
Re: When one died, two were dead
Harinder Singh · 07 Sep 2006
<< What is the first thing that dies? Haume or Mann?>>
I feel that the first thing that shud die is hope. Without hope dying, mann can never die. When hope dies,kaam which is also hope of someones body also dies and the second thing that dies is trishna or hunger for wordly entities. After this the other demons will die but i am not sure of the order in which the demons die. According to me mann shud die in the last just after haumme has died.
If we assume that mann/haumme dies in the beginning,then everything else will die immediately after and hence this 2.4.6 thing wont be achieved.
bhul chukk maaf
RAJ KAREGA KHALSA
Re: When one died, two were dead
Balbir Singh · 08 Sep 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all!
The word 'ayk' occurs often in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. First one should experience the death of 'ayk'. What is this 'ayk'? 'Ayk' is Param-aatmaa and His Truth too. I feel Kabir Ji is not referring God here.
God does not die. Nor His Truth dies. Still, all what we know is dying every moment. From this whole word what is 'ayk', Kabir Ji is saying? Let us experience this to solve the riddle.
My humble suggestion is this. These are the results of true Simran. We should be curious to know Simran to solve the spiritual riddles. A borrowed explanation may only satisfy the intellectual greed.
Explanations of this Shabad available surprise me. I have come across.
Balbir Singh
Re: When one died, two were dead
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 09 Sep 2006
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!
daas has a question - could you please kindly list all of the "male" attribute entities of human life, and all of the "female" entities?
for example maya is a female entity, and so is the human soul. whereas akaal purakh is a male entity, and so is (i think) the mind.
could you please list all of them?
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!
Re: When one died, two were dead
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 09 Sep 2006
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!
could you also please list if any entity is the "son" or "daughter" of another entity?
for example some shabads say the body is the house, the mind is the father, and the five evils are the five spoiled sons.
could you please list like this?
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh !!!!
[%sig%]
Re: When one died, two were dead
Balbir Singh · 10 Sep 2006
Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal!
Dear all!
Please click the following to read my views on this riddle.
http://www.saysatsriakal.com/riddle_of_kabir_ji3.htm
Balbir Singh
Re: When one died, two were dead
Harjas Kaur · 15 Sep 2006
I have totally given up on the understanding of the shabad. My little brain is too tiny, lol. Everytime I read it, it's confusing me, heh.
All I know is Guruji has some profound truth in it beyond my brain. Waheguru.
[%sig%]
Re: When one died, two were dead
Kulwant Singh · 07 Oct 2006
WJKK, WJKF
The following shabad by Bhagat Kabeer Jeo (same author) might answer the question...
[gurbani]rwgu gauVI cyqI ]
dyKO BweI g´wn kI AweI AWDI ]
sBY aufwnI BRm kI twtI rhY n mwieAw bWDI ]1] rhwau ]
duicqy kI duie QUin igrwnI moh blyfw tUtw ]
iqsnw Cwin prI Dr aUpir durmiq BWfw PUtw ]1]
AWDI pwCy jo jlu brKY iqih qyrw jnu BInW ]
kih kbIr min BieAw pRgwsw audY Bwnu jb cInw ]2]43][/gurbani]
In the third line, the words "Bharam" and "Maya" appear.
In the fourth line, the words "Duchitay" and "Moh" appear.
In the fifth line, the words "Trishna" and "Durmat" appear.
If we consider the words "maya" and "trishna" feminine and the rest as masculine words, it would explain the original salok, since all 6 of these die together.
This sabad was suggested by a good friend of mine.
WJKK, WJKF
Kulwant Singh
[%sig%]