Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Why the bare legs?

Why the bare legs?

Manj · 16 Nov 2005

A question from a different forum - but something I've woundered about as well. http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=12163 Dearest Guru Ki Sangat, Recently I came across a few Sikhs males who were wearing long kurtha chollas (normal members of the sangat) along with the 5 Ks yet they only appeared to be wearing their Khecharas with their legs left bare. This post is not a criticism but a simple query to ask the reasoning behind this? Would we consider it appropriate if a lady were to dress the same?

Re: Why the bare legs?

ASingh Boongawala · 16 Nov 2005

Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa Vahiguru ji ki fateh This topic has been discussed before. But the answer is that men are different to women. You can't prove that both are alike because its not true, men will always be different to women. In the times of Guru Gobind Singh Singhs use wear a kachera with no chola and just chawl on top to cover their bodies. In Suraj Prakhash it says: "Khat Ras Ka Wah Swaad Na Jaanai. Kaprha Aur Na Tan Par Thhaanai. Kamar Jaangheeya, Ik Sir Patka. Bhoore Giltee Baana Jatka." Meaning: (They [Singhs] do not know taste of six flavors. They do not wear any other clothes. There is underwear around their waists and a turban on their heads. They wear blankets, a Jatt dress). That is what Singhs use to wear now the question is would that be acceptable for women? No it wouldn't. That reason Singhs leave thier legs bare is because they do seva of Guru maharaj which requires a person to change or not to wear a pajama. When doing langar dee seva you either wear a new pajama or no pajama at all. But in the case for Singhnis they keep theirs on as it is immodest for them to take it off. [%sig%]

Re: Why the bare legs?

' · 16 Nov 2005

What about babies in the sangat that are only in diapers?

Re: Why the bare legs?

ekta · 17 Nov 2005

what the hell.... i just dont' understand a kaur is a khalsa a singh is a khalsa? why different rules for the same khalsa?

Re: Why the bare legs?

stranger · 17 Nov 2005

A Singh Boongawala Your explain is not very convincing. Are you saying bear legs are cleaner then a jurtha pyjama during seva or are you saying that Guru Ji will be most unhappy if you do seva with a pyjama on - total confusing. ............... elaborate please

Re: Why the bare legs?

LK · 17 Nov 2005

AS Boongwala- Are you saying rehit for men is different than for women? whats the difference between SIkhi and Islam then? it isn't inmodest for a man to have bear legs? Don't women "check out" men's legs? Have a look on the thread and a poster posts of how he knows people who Check out SInghs legs.. It works both sides my friend. if Singhs check out womens legs, then women check out mens legs. the same with Hija, if men don't go kaam-crazy looking at the hijab - why are women aloud to go kaam-crazy at men? That is a very illogical explaination. Especially for those who claim that rehit is same for Men and Women and thus Keski is a must for women.. then why double standard her in this case?

Re: Why the bare legs?

ASingh · 17 Nov 2005

Vahiguroo ji ka Khalsa Vahiguroo ji ki fateh Guru piyare. Like I said before men ARE DIFFERENT to women. In the times of Guru Har Gobind Sahib Jeeo, Guru Sahib use to tell Singhs to do wrestling, singhs use to do wrestling half naked - as that was the tradtion (I think still is). In the times of Guru Gobind Singh, Singhs use to wear barely nothing but a kachera, shastars, distaars and a shawl to cover their bodies. Wouldn't women be "checking mens legs out" those days? >>Are you saying bear legs are cleaner then a jurtha pyjama during seva or are you saying that Guru Ji will be most unhappy if you do seva with a pyjama on - total confusing.<< Stranger jeeo, when wearing bana with pajama and traveling one wears shoes. Shoes are dirty and make your clean pajamas dirty also. So if your clothes dirty then how can you be clean enough to do seva? How can you sit in Guru Sahibs tabhiya and do chaur sahib seva or read Gurbani? The fact is you can't. Wouldn't it save much more time to not wear pajama at all and just have a long chola and long kachera? The fact is that when wearing no pajama with bana, ones bana must be long. In Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singhs time, whenever he saw a Singh with a short chola and no pajama, he would tell them off. This is what I have heard from older Singhs. When making degh one can't wear dirty pajamas or even cholas, they have to wear clean clothes and either take their pajamas off or wear new ones (that applies for men only, women can only change pajamas). >>AS Boongwala- Are you saying rehit for men is different than for women?<< No rehit is the same for both men and women. But don't go over the board by this fact, everything has a limit. >>it isn't inmodest for a man to have bear legs? Don't women "check out" men's legs?<< Like I said before in Guru Sahibs time Singhs use to walk around with hardly anything on, the same cant apply for women can it? Let me ask you, can a woman walk around half naked? the answer is no because it is immodest for woman to do so. Are trying to say that Singhs in Guru Gobind Singh's time were immodest? Maybe learnt Gursikhs on this forum can explain futher. Tapoban vale Singhs what your views on this? Vahiguroo ji ka Khalsa Vahiguroo ji ki fateh

Re: Why the bare legs?

cyber singh · 17 Nov 2005

i heard that a mahapursh got darshan of many shaheed singhs entering a Gurdwara and taking matha. there were Singhnis with them aswell and every one in that shaheed jatha dressed the same: dastaar, neela chola, and no pajama. no adays its cultural that women aren't allowed to wear just a kashera.

Re: Why the bare legs?

rajj · 17 Nov 2005

wahguru ji ka khalsa,wahguru ji ki fateh, as we read Jappji sahib every day,Sochai soch na hova-ee jay sochee lakh vaar. That means we can never keep such,if we try to wash our body hundreds of times.it only can retain if we keep our minds clean. if our minds are dirty ,,our cloths are clean. give me your thoughts please.

Re: Why the bare legs?

Manjot Kaur · 17 Nov 2005

Don't mind me but... I tend to use the pyjami to distinguish the difference between males and females. Males tend to wear longer chholay and when doing gatka, it's more of a hassle to reach down and fix your pyjami so it stops falling off your ankles. Males usually do a little bit more gatka than females because they are thought to be stronger so that might be part of the reason. Bhul Chook Maff

Re: Why the bare legs?

Gerk · 17 Nov 2005

If you want to say women should wear a distaar (rehit is the same for both genders right?) then men should either cover their legs or let women walk around with their legs uncovered. Or if you are more resonable (this is a good thing) you can accept that men and women are different, but with that you must accept the fact that their women don't have to wear a distaar and their is nothing wrong with that. I'm personally part of the latter camp rather than the former.

Re: Why the bare legs?

Liongking · 18 Nov 2005

So what culture sees as inmodest is allowed to take voer the clothing of bibis?

Re: Why the bare legs?

A Singh · 18 Nov 2005

LionKing, The same people who promote Bibis with no pyjamas on the believe that culture is irrelevant are the same to speak ill of skirts - not short skirts, but JUST skirts, which can be very modest depending on which culture you're from...obviously in ours not so much!

Re: Why the bare legs?

simple singhani · 19 Nov 2005

lol...this is an intresting topic..i think 'ASINGH boongawala' is totally right! u guys are jus lookin at it frm a one sided point of view..but i can gurantee if u saw a singhani with a chola and no pjama u wud think..'omg what iss she doing' u would! cus any one would! its not right.. its immodest!.. everyone knows mens bodies are different to women.. ''women can have babies..why can men.. '' its like saying that! men and women werent made TOTALLY equal..if they were ther wouldn't b such thing as men and women. A Kaur of guru gobind singh jee is meant to be BEAUTIFUL..how can she b BEAUTIFUL IF SHES SHOWING HALF HER BODY OFF TO EVERYONE. she cant! anyway.. 'ASINGH boongawala' has sed everything i wanted to say.. stay chardikala bhajee bhull chuk maaf wjkk wjkf

Re: Why the bare legs?

LionKing (LK) · 19 Nov 2005

Personal opinion - if you're going to say that rehit is same for all - then It's same for all, irrespect in what it is, whether that's keski , keeping legs bare, or whatever.... Whether I believe keski is kakkar or not is completly irrelevant, but I think that it would be double standard, if those who think that keski i mandatory for bibis as well as men, and still claim that one can have bare legs and one not.... Culture might see having bare legs as immodest for women, but if it's okay for men then which Gurmukh on this planet cares about Panjabi Culture?

Re: Why the bare legs?

ManjitSingh · 20 Nov 2005

You must differenciate between Rehit and Tradition. As everyone knows Rehit is must to keep and if you don't you cease to be a Sikh until pardoned by Panj. On the other hand traditions are good to have but if you don't keep you don't cease to be a Sikh. There are some traditions that should never be changed as it could severely affect the trust and sharda of sikh masses. Just for an example a round traditional Baata is used to prepare Amrit by Panj, if some Panj start to use a square Baata instead it may hurt the feelings of Sikhs so this tradition should never be changed. Rehit is same for all men and women but traditions may be different for men and women. Now it is upto some one's own interest and shardha how to inerpret the traditions set by Guru Sahib Jio and then by Singhs in olden times. Now come to the bare legs. It is the tradition since Guru Sahib Jio's time that Singhnees usually wear pyjamee and Singh may or may not. This tradition was never challenged until recently as done by some people whose mind/brain is polluted by western culture. Is there any good reason why this traditions should be changed now? There could be some traditions that may be changed with time but there should be some very valid reason to change a tradition.

Re: Why the bare legs?

Singh · 21 Nov 2005

Lionking stated: "but I think that it would be double standard, if those who think that keski i mandatory for bibis as well as men, and still claim that one can have bare legs and one not...." Going by your ridiculous logic, is it a double standard for women to be allowed to take Amrit just like men and one have bare legs and the other not? Just because women keep their legs covered doesn't make the Keski any less valid in the same way none of the other Kakkars, such as Kachera, Kirpan, which are considered more masculine by society, are any less valid.

Re: Why the bare legs?

singh · 21 Nov 2005

Why is there even an argument, women in bare legs?? use common sense, have some sharam. Women and men are equal but mannn ther not the same.

Re: Why the bare legs?

NO one · 22 Nov 2005

Back to the original point at hand. The reason many males do not wear a pajama with a long chola is that its easier not to. Pajama's get dirty very easily, touching your shoes, rubbing the ground and also when u go to the toilet u can get splashback on your pajama, nasty i know... but very true. Especially if u consider how people use to go back in the day, im sure there would have been alot more splashback. hence the reason for no pajama. Its alot easier for a singh to simply do panj ishnaan including washing legs before doing maharaj di seva than having to find a new pajama and then doing seva. For bibia, once again this issue isn't about rehit. Bibia dont really have the same problem as men, as guys tend to standup when they go to the toilet. Also singhs traditionally have done maharaj di seva (obviously not all the time, but generally you see men doing these types of seva) and therefore its more relevant for men. Also on a personal basis i would get kinda weirded out if i saw a bibi's legs, probably not get kaam, but i think "freaked out" would be more accurate. We must accept the society we live in. Saying that, a singh couldn't exactly walk into a gurdwara with only his panj kakaar and nuffin else without causing a few stares, but if you saw a singh doing ishnaan at darbar sahib without a shirt it would be perfectly fine. This is how society has programed us to be and its not a bad thing. Use common sense people. Fateh