Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Harpartap Singh · 15 Nov 2005
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
The committee of Leamington Spa Gurdwara have called a general meeting this Sunday at which they will propose (and almost certainly pass) a resolution to call a room in the Gurdwara Sahib a 'social club'. This will mean that any body will be allowed to eat meat, drink alcohol on the Gurdwara premises.
PS the next party has already been scheduled for 26 November. For all of us who talk about serving our Panth and paying tribute to our Shaheeds like Bhai Fauja Singh ji - maybe we should be asking ourselves, when it came to the crunch what did we do stop disrespect to Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji?????????
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Kuldeep Kaur · 15 Nov 2005
..and to those who talk about serving our Panth and paying tribute to our Shahids like Sant Gyani Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwaleh and all those other countless Shahids..
VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh!
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Gurcharan Singh · 15 Nov 2005
"and to those who talk about serving our Panth and paying tribute to our Shahids like Sant Gyani Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwaleh and all those other countless Shahids.."
Please refrain from adding titles like Giani for Shahid Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawala.I would simply say , please go and understand the title first and how and when it really should be used.
Giani is an academic title gained via study through to university level.
NOW THE REST:-
Thank you sir, The trouble with Sikh community is we now have a youth that thinks the SGPC led maryada is rubbish.They know better, although they have nothing better to offer as a solution.Quite the contrary, in their zest to get things done right, it looks like the early muslims they are embarking upon the wrong direction themselves.They do not see using large numbers of intimidating people turning up as a precipitating factor to set off flashes or violence.
We also have an old guard group that is refusing to let go off gurduaras, and has allowed some influences into the gurduara that should not be there, nor carried within the premises.
It does not matter what religion a person professes but when terror is carried out in the name of God, then all of us need to speak up against such senseless actions. There should not be any empathy, even in the slightest form for people who indulge and participate and instigate terror.
It can be interesting and informative to know why people, who spend all their time reading religious books which emphasise love, peace and forgiveness, could end up becoming evil people who use violence in the name of faith.
I see today, no matter what ever they say to justify, a new brand of Sikhs arising who are taking the road to extremism that muslims took when they started to burn the salman rushdie book years back, and earned great notoriety
These people who run the gurduaras and those who have gone to defend the sanctity of the Gurduara are supposed to be do-gooders who know their religious book better than many of us and live a morally upright way of life but yet they end up as devils, and the cause of fights and violence.We already have a number of examples of this charade.
It is very sad, that people who do not subscribe to "their" interpretations of the religion are either kesadhari hindus,sadly (PM Manmohan Singh falls into this category according to them) or sinners. In their eyes, their faith is being threatened and their actions are justified to purify the world of these corrupting influences in Sikhi.Some who speak of the reallity of far away dream of Khalistan also sometimes get called names,thrown into the garbage, even though throwers may be the bottom end of that garbage!
Intimidation and pressure in the name of Sikh religion used by these zealots to exert their influence is not acceptable nor sikhi. Not many of us are prepared to face their threats, let alone speak up against them.
But if we pause for a moment and think,it is even more difficult when their voices are not heard or, worse, denied in the light what goes on in our gurduaras at these moment and times.Gurduaras have become ritualistic tools for ritualistic practices.Their potential is untapped, under used and MISUSED.The people responsible are the management's who now see gurduaras as their own properties and their right to do anything with.
In the recent days I have heard a gurduara official referring to a very active Sikh like Harmander Singh ji, a not full Sikh and who is he to speak for the Sikhs, yet the same person in the gurduara have totally clean shaven parbandaks and presidents! His mona vice president on a gurduara trip got drunk and verbally insulted two amritdhari ladies for no reason, and later apologised!
Had I heard that comment directly, I would have asked him about his participation in covering up this issue, and his cajoling with his clean shaven gurduara parbandaks!
This is the state of affairs the Sikh community has been reduced to.Sikh religion is such a potent force that many prefer to conform and, in a democracy, few politicians dare to take up those in religious clothing for fear that they would lose votes. While some prefer to keep silent, some try to outdo their opponents religiously, which is even worse.This is EXACTLY what has happened and is bound to happen until we get up off our laurels and get to a platform and talk this out honestly within the confines of the SRAM and Gurbani.
This cannot be sorted through force or intimadation by anyone.
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Jagjit Singh · 16 Nov 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, the pictures are very conclusive. Thier arguments demonstrate a clear lack of sharda and fear of Guru ji.
They can pass what you want in meetings. But the supreme authority is the Siri Akal Thakht. I would urge the youth to create a dossier of names, addresses, then compile witness statements and pictures, videos , etc. Then send a Gursikh to submit this to Siri Akal Thakht.
They may wriggle their way out of the meat thing, but the booze is indefensible.
They have to be ex-communicated. Then legally then will have no right to hold positions in the Gurdwara.
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
sewadar ;-) · 16 Nov 2005
yes, One singh has been arrested since then,not out yet.
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Harpartap Singh · 16 Nov 2005
You can see the photo's of the alcohol and meat below:
http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=15030
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
sewadar ;-) · 16 Nov 2005
jis singh ne eh masa ranger's khilaf awaj uthai hai,oh ik sikh koum da ik anmol heera hai,te menu maan hai us te!
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Gurcharan Singh · 16 Nov 2005
MS as YOU put it, NOT me, "Secondly, the 'book' as you put it,There are amny bvooks apart from Gurbani read by everypone ,including the youth,You are now reading here on the net"
Can a sensible discussion of looking at all angles be not carried out without inferring and attacking an individual view.I see thgis always happens on this net.No wonder people are so confused out there.
Please refrain again from misconstruing.I live in the UK , I know, and I understand, but at the same VIOLENCE IN ANY FORM Vcannot be justified.
In fact my letter to the MP is far stronger than any one of you have written or put out here.I have explined to him the tenets of theSIKH religion VERY clearly and suggested to him VERY strongly to come out and apologise to the wider Sikh community and condemn the individuals who brought alcohol on to the premises, if that indeed happend.I have also aske him to own up, to the words he is said to have uttered, if indeed he did so.That he will earn mre respect and understanding if he spsoke the TRUTH.
I have given a view, accept it or reject it, it makes no difference to me, except that unless Sikihs, take the righteous path and ensure violence is not the theme.If it is , you are equally responsible as the bekoof dharra in the gurduara who are running the committees breaking every rule in the book.
It does not matter what your convictiopns in Sikhi are ..you break the law, be ready to stand for it.And if you break the law and also belittle the community t you ar eguilty of breaking the law and being an irresponsible sikh towards the community, like the parbandaaks who are carrying out the same in the name of being parbandaks.
The reallity is the youth have no solution to the maryada.One says it is damdami taklsaal maryada , others claim some sant and yet others claim another....the solution we have one panthic maryada is being rubbished by many.As amny youth are , just as many ,maryadas there are .THIS IS A FACT.No community can unite with so many offers.Why dont you READ and provide me with the oNRE MARYADA yiou believ is acceptbale to all here .let us se you make that first.
The reallity is the youth have no say in the gurduaras either.If they do, these unlearned parbandaks will not be s doing what they are doing.This is happening all over the country , it hapens in india in another form.
HEY you say again " supose Bhai Fauja Singh who killed a rapist cop was one of these exteemists, maybe he should have just stood by and watched hey? Punjaibs would have probably liked that hey?"2
HEY was that part of this discussion?Did I say that ,not at all.MY writing bothers you as I have analysed both sides, violence is unacceptable from any one.AS simple as that.
The parbandaks are wrong to be carrying out unsikhi activities, terribly wrong.there qiught to be a channel through which they should be punished through the law.
But then turning up, and precipitating violence even inadvertently is also WRONG, no matter what the povocation was, esspcially so when Sikhs are involved.
I can understand, how terribly provoking they have been, but your share in the goonda gardi no matter how insignificant makes you a goond as well, and defeats your purpose.Do you want to gain that image?
If indeed , why not sit out peacefully in front of the gurduara , even if it means day in and day out , until these parbandaks give up or the sangats presureises them ....but in this age violence will not gain you anything ,instead you are leading with all justifications down the path of the muslim extremeist community.PERIOD.
If indeed it means anything to any of you extremist hot heads,instead of calling Bhai fauja Singh etc , to who you cannot be copmared to ,neither are capable of being, take the challenge of these corruppted parbandaks and sit out a maran warat..hunger strike in front of the gurduaram a peaceful hunger strike ..you will get noticed and thesangta will see your resolve and good intetions..instead carrying out arguments with any one that gives you another view, and coooming up with YOUR unsubstantiated and misleadingly contrued allegations.
Bahi sahib THAT would be the HEROISM of you , following your true Guru Arjan Dev ji and Guru Tegh bahadur.That is Sikhi.
The rest of it causing violence on streets, unless to defend your individual or a needy person , is simple gooda gardi and violence.two wrongs do not justify anything.
This habit of being confrontationist keyboard heros against anyone that does not repseresent your view..will not achive much exccept air your ego.
At least I do not write under pen names.I know the intetions are well meant for people turning, but the lagacy you people leave in violence washes of every bit of your claim to defend sikhi into the same corner like the culprits who drink alcohol and abuse the Sikh gurduaras.I see no difference in you both.
Instead zeroing on individuals . seek out their view, and see how you can tap on exp[ertise and knowledge to deafeat these bent gurduara officials.
I am not much older than the oldest youth at 30, but I feel sorry the route you are taking to carry out this reform.It is a difficult task, but with some common sesne why dont you defat these bent officals and at the same time preserve your own Sikh dignity.
I see the same akali mantality of karo ja maro in you, and like the akali mentality I see you pople will rise to cause enough damage to stand on the same podiam like the bent officals , and leave a legacy of shame to even the like of Bhai Fauja Singh ..who idolise more than the teachintgs of your Gurus!
be like Guru Arjan and Gur Gobins singh and launch something like a hunger strike and stand to sjow for your priciples, you will also have the chance of being a shaid like Darshan singh Pherumaan, and NO ONE CAN ACCUSE THE LIKES OF YOU CREATING VIOLENCE!
That would be your true Sikhi.The rest of is all talk of the youth with hot heat !!
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Harpartap Singh · 16 Nov 2005
Everybody should do their bit:
Call the Gurdwara on 01926-424297 and voice your concerns.
Surely this is the least all of us can do....
PS the general secretary is Ranjit Hayer and teh President is Sanghera Sahota
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 16 Nov 2005
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
What the hell has happened to the world, its completely corrupt.
The two sins that are causing destruction to religion; meat and alcohol shouldn't be aloud nowhere near a Gurdwara.
niddariaa ddar jaaneeai baajh guroo gubaar ||3||
One who does not fear God shall live in fear; without the Guru, there is only pitch darkness. ||3||
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Gurcharan Singh · 16 Nov 2005
MS
if indeed you the perfect Sikh that you say join me in hunger strike against these ...strat a hunger strike ...
MS Bhai sahib Let this be an open challenge to any of my bent critics...start a Hunger strike in front of any gurduara run by bent offcials, if you have the mouth where you talk from , strat a hunger strike and you will have the nation moving behind you and the government will get the message.....thgese bent officals will get the message....just drink water,reciting the name of the Guru , start a hunger strike with a jaap nam peacefully in front of the gurduara, thousands will gather, the press will gather, the snagtas will come, you will be truly walking the esps of the gur ji, and indeed have the right to compare your sikhi to the deeds, others wise sitting here and asking questions and comparing to Guru Gobind Singh this or that is a whole load of rubbish , you do it orally while the gurduara patbandaks are doing it through their actions.
Any one of you, here star t a relay of individuals going on hunder strike , Bhai sahib I take the challenge that I will go for that for five days with you, and we can increase the momentum ,se how these besharam parbandaks run ...how they will run from the sangat ...
apart from that sittingf here ...and waffling left right and centre is a load of rubbish.I have a view, you have a view, instead of monitoring every body's view I see some are getting into an argument and trying to shoot each other ..as one disagrees...I can see the immaturity of these pople ...bhai Sahib, I offer my body to join in hunger strike with you...if you are indeed are the real sikh, let us make it for five days, and start a relay ....the attention will there, we can always dstart getting serious later and extend it ...that is Sikhi.
I can see a lot of talk ..here...and shooting people who even see how you will damage the image of the community in this age with violence...the pen is mightier than your kirpan ..behzhti was enough ..learn to beat them ...HUNGER STRIKE ?any one of these that compare and remind us of Guru Gobind Singh and bhai Fauja singh ji ?
let us get serious.
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Harpartap Singh · 16 Nov 2005
Sangat ji,
Instead of writing on the forums, please can we can do some practical ACTION. Please ask your local Gurdwara Sahib to write to the committee at
Leamington Spa Gurdwara
Tachbrook Park Drive,
Leamington Spa
Warwickshire
CV31 3LZ
The future of our Gurdwara Sahib's is in your hands - if we do not take a stand now, within 5 years virtually all Gurdwara's will have so called social clubs with drinking etc.
A benti to Tapoban Gurdwara sevadars, your open support would also be very valuable - please write to the committee.
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 16 Nov 2005
VahegurooJeKaKhalsavahegurooJeKeFateh
Bhai Sahib Gurcharan Singh Jee,
Oh shut up about the pen is mightier than the Kirpan, Kirpan is one of the Kakaars that goes along with you to the hereafter, not a materialistic worldly object. Kirpan is one of the powerful kakaars that lights up the Gursikh; Guru Gobind Singh Jee praises weapons greatly in Dasam Granth as well as by giving us this Kirpan as a Kakaar, it shows how much value the Kirpan has had in the past and the present and always forever in the future. So never ever give disrespect to the Kirpan.
For goodness sake it’s a Gurdwara you don't need to go on hunger strike to get your view from a Holy place where Guru Jee lives in and only Sikhs go to.
Furthermore, try and convince these worldly beings by doing whatever you want, but nothing is going to happen. I'm sorry but I really don't think a hunger strike will change anything. You’re going to have to do something more effective than go on hunger strike, which is getting a group of Sikhs to argue with these people, the committee of the Gurdwara will have to listen to what Sikhs have to say about their decision and also give strong reasons why this social club room for meat and alcohol shouldn't be built.
Vaheguru Jee has control of everything, and by doing an enormous amount of Naam Bhagti your word can become much more effective.
VahegurooJeKaKhalsavahegurooJeKeFateh
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Khalsa_Force · 16 Nov 2005
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Gurcharan Singh · 16 Nov 2005
Shaktishali," shut up"you say, shows how much mentality and ego you have ...".dont need to go on hunger strike" you say. But you are quick to instigate others ....and call people like Bhai Fauja singh singh's name to instigate further....the Sikhs lied down on railways lines to liberate their Gurduaras, and you tell me to shut up ..I suppose it is the chiken in you that spoke...Like I said, this is turning into frenzy now, Harpartap singh ji has said it .stop talking and do something.....BUT for those heros like you Put your mouth where your words are ..in other simple words ...walk the BIG egoed talk ...that you give ...I really think you need to grow up //
Shakatishali in words only, I can see that..it can be seen as I have said, it does not take two wrongs to make one right,BUt loud mouths like you just know how to instigate sangats on and on ...while you sit in your armchairs..
You are shalktishali ..as you say ...get on the road in front of the Gurduara and start the hunger strike..I will JOIN YOU, I will come up from London ...if you are finding excuses ,than I suggest you practice a little oof what you offered me...less of verbal diarrehoea from you would help a lot.
Shaktishali, I have seen the likes opf you taking Kiropanbs off at the airports, and you cant even win that fight ...Bhai sahib, the kirpan of Guru Gobind Singh ji is no more in you today ..as you meekly instigate others.I am proud to say that I still never have taken mine off for a plane neither has anyone challenged me to.
You are truly the Sikh of Guru Gobind Singh ji if you take the challenge to launch a hunger fight against these masands.The Sikhs have lied to die on railway tracks, and a someone said Sikhs have refused to eat in jails etc ...so dont please talk through your airy mouth !
Use brains to beat these chaps,use the press to see your values and principles and beat them , get the press on your side ...see how they run ..hunger strike peacefully will get that for you ...so please do us a favour ...get that air out of your mouth if you have to ...but ...see the flavour does not kill you!
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 16 Nov 2005
VahegurooJeKaKhalsavahegurooJeKeFateh
Did you even read the whole of my post or just the shut up bit, and turned red in the face. I had told you to shut up (sorry for that) because you disrespected the Kirtan by comparing it to a pen. Don't even use what Guru Jee's given to us to favor your view in a disrespectful way.
As I've already mentioned a hunger strike won't solve anything, if its a Gurdwara, discuss the matter with the Gurdwara committee as they're going to have to listen since Sikhs are the only people that go to the Gurdwara and if that doesn't work then go on hunger strike. But when the matter is being discussed, make sure you bring a whole group of Gursikhs so that the committee can tell that more then one Sikh are against their decision. Also, at least more than one person should have a say with a strong and effective reason for the matter.
In addition, if the discussion within the meeting isn't successful then as I've already said, go on hunger strike.
VahegurooJeKaKhalsavahegurooJeKeFateh
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Gurcharan Singh · 16 Nov 2005
""Did you even read the whole of my post or just the shut up bit, and turned red in the face. I had told you to shut up (sorry for that) because you disrespected the Kirtan by comparing it to a pen. Don't even use what Guru Jee's given to us to favor your view in a disrespectful way"" Now he asks me ....I wonder if he ever read my whole write up or just what he one eyedly saw!
Bhai sahib, the reallity is the likes of you are the ones who have disrespected the KIRPAN when you take it off at airports.I never do.
The pen is mightier than the KIRPAN in this age, does not belittle the KIRPAN in any way, where the KIRPANS use is good, there it still reigns.Understand that.
You have displayed a mentality that prevails among Sikhs ....JUMP before you use brains to think.
So you telling me the HEROS of Jaito were who laid down on the rail road were foolisg to do that .Did they wonder if it will work or not?Bhai sahib ...as long as people with your thinking to JUMP into the fire exist, sikhs willbe where we are ...I can assure you of that.
I can assure you, you will achieve a lot and mUCH d-faster, and you will reknew the spirit of Shaidi in Sikhi by maran warat.
the b ritish government will not want any of its MPs being involved in this saga, and the world press will move to zero on the issue..and you are telling it will not work.May be you should have told that to fauja Singh Darshan Singh Pheruman and those in jaito morcha.
bale bale, I knew it all mouth and no walk!!
I still challenge any one of these loud mouths here, I will walk with you , as soon as you take the stand.. instead of shooting us, and calling yourself the whiter than white Sikhs.
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
sikhsangat.com · 17 Nov 2005
Posting from SS:
I am ashamed to have to admit this, but having read so much and understood both sides I have to tell you all the situation i was faced with.
My dad was one of the men who were at the party. He came home covered in meat and sharab. It was not a nice sight, we asked him what had happend and he explained to us.
He told us he had made a mistake and drunk in the Gurdwara. He admitted it was a proper party and it wasn't the first time they had this. He said these youth came in and wrecked the place. They beat people up and smashed the place to bits. He was really scared and has refused to give a police statement. We have told him not to as it was his fault and he is a shame on us all. The matter should now be closed.
He was guilty and he admitted it. I have to rate my dad for that but at same time i feel he deserved what he got. My mum agrees, she is a amritdhari and spent all her life doing paath and working hard. She was appalled at my dad. They haven't spoken for 2 days now.
This should be a lesson to all the others at the party, they should apologise. I am trying to get my dad to go infront of panj-pyare again, or if not the whole sangat and apologise and ask for forgiveness.
He has gone up in my eyes in a weird way.
Gurdeep Singh.
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Harpartap Singh · 17 Nov 2005
Sangat jio,
Please can everybody confirm whether their local gurdwara's have tried to make contact with the Committee? And if so, what response they have received?
Re: Social Club Room in Gurdwara to be used for meat & alcohol
Rashpal Singh · 17 Nov 2005
I agree with everything written by UK Singh
[%sig%]