Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Singh · 15 Nov 2005

Gur Fateh! It seems at last we have a potentially academic analysis and critique of the Sanatan Sikhi websites without the need for dressed up dolls and other such petty childish behaviour. This looks to be promising – let’s keep an eye on the developments. Jaikara Gajave, Nihal ho Jaave, Shaheeda Singha Singhnia man du pave, SAT SRI AKAL! Taken from: http://www.amritworld.com/sanatani/aim.pdf Aim of This Section (Amrit Pal Singh 'Amrit') Self-proclaimed Sanatan Sikhs of UK are running their websites, in which they have made several comments on Sikh tradition and history. Their comments seem to be very strange for mainstream Sikhs. On one of their websites, Sanatanis have written: - All concepts and information revealed on this website with regards to Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya are fully backed-up with transcripts of interviews from present masters of this art, and a great variety of Sikh and non- Sikh historical literature. They say: - This website out of fear of controversy does not shy away from discussing the misconceptions that are so prevalent now with regards to Sikh martial arts, its true practitioners, and those subjects that it feels are undermining Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya today. It is not only what they call Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya, but they have raised other points as well on their websites. These points are controversial. Obviously, many other Sikhs are not agreed to many of their points. On this, one of Sanatani websites says: - Due to the nature of the website, and its willingness to be open with the truth with respect to Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya, it is inevitable that reputations and egos of certain individuals and groups with vested interests in promulgating the lies that are being exposed by the site will be bruised. Such individuals have resorted to death threats, slander, emotional blackmail, and even labeling Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya practitioners as "anti-Sikh" to prevent the truth from being known. They further say: - www.amritworld.com II As Sanatan Sikhs, what we seek is the truth, and if the truth damages the foundations of institutions, then that is inevitable. If the truth really damages the foundations of institutions, we are more eager to know it. We would like to know which institutions it would damage. Then, they have said: - To such groups, we ask them to refute if they can what has been revealed here with clear objective scriptural, historical, rational or logical evidence. If we are wrong or mistaken in ANY of the facts presented here, then we will revaluate our stance and make changes accordingly. After all, as Sikhs, we are but seeking the truth. In other words, Sanatan Sikhs of UK have invited certain individuals and groups for discussions. They are ready to revaluate their stance and make changes accordingly, if prove wrong or mistaken in ANY of the facts presented on their website. I had a few discussions with the Webmaster of Sanatan Sikh websites, on online Sikh forum www.SikhAwareness.com. During one of such discussions, Sanatan Sikh Webmaster said (wrote) that he would be coming to my house, when he comes to India. I happily agreed to him. After all, it was a good opportunity to have discussions with Sanatan Sikh scholar. When I heard that the Webmaster of Sanatan Sikh websites, along with others, was coming to India to participate in Hola Mahalla festival in Sri Anandpur Sahib Ji, in the year of 2005, I invited him through www.SikhAwareness.com to have a face-to-face discussion, which was to be recorded for online sangat. The Sanatan Sikh Webmaster replied that he would be busy, so not sure if he meets me or not. I thought that he surely would take part in Mahalla procession, which was on March 26, 2005; and I could get a chance to learn from him. Therefore, I reached Sri Anandpur Sahib Ji with some of my students. We arranged video cameras to shoot the discussions. Unfortunately, I could not find him in Budhha Dal camp. I tried my best to meet him during the Mahalla procession, but I came to know later that he did not take part in the procession. I contacted some Sikhs from UK, who showed ignorance about whereabouts of Sanatan Sikh scholar. Despite my efforts, I could not have his Darshan (glimpse). Though, I could not have discussions with the Webmaster, I instead studied his Sanatan Sikh websites. I read that they have invited certain individuals and groups, to refute what has been revealed on Sanatan Sikh websites with clear objective scriptural, historical, www.amritworld.com III rational or logical evidence. They have promised that they will revaluate their stance and make changes accordingly if they are wrong or mistaken in ANY of the facts presented on their websites. When I read these comments, I thought I should analyze what has been revealed on these websites. The aim of this section on www.AmritWorld.com is to understand views given by Sanatan Sikh websites. While trying to understand their views, I have made a few comments also and tried to support them with clear objective scriptural, historical, rational or logical evidence. After all, as Sikhs, we are but seeking the truth.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Singh · 15 Nov 2005

Jagdeep hounslow, who is the Snaatan Sikh webmaster has been shown up so many times. He cannot debate because he has no knowledge himself, and is just a blind worshipper of Niddar and Parmjit. Jagdeep acts like a hero on the internet. If you listed all his aliases in sikhsangat & sikhawareness, you will probably get a whole dictionary. He knows he propogates lies, but he just has such a callous and mischievious personality. Anyone who debates with him knows that. He talks about this and that, but if you go up to him to challenge his views, then he usually legs it scared. He is nothing but a chamcha.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

.. · 15 Nov 2005

I found the following on the shastar viadya website - is this true tat you are m,eant to challenge God ??? Sastar Vaidaya 'Within Dasam Guru Durbar, it is written that even if you meet God, considering He is the greatest warrior, a Khalsa warrior should challenge and engage the Master of the universe and thus die at the hands of the greatest warrior and attain eternal salvation. Akali Nihang Guru Gobind Singh writes: ‘He who’s name the four Yugas [i.e., all time] contemplates, with Him let us duel and thus die and attain salvation.’ (Akali Nihang Guru Gobind Singh, Kharag Singh Yudh Kathan, Krishna Avatar, Dasam Guru Durbar) '

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Singh · 16 Nov 2005

this quote was discussed before on tapoban.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

A Singh · 16 Nov 2005

This quote has been discussed before, I feel for a productive discussion, we first present the original lines from the Dasam Granth Sahib and conduct any veechar from thereon. The matters of what Jagdeep Singh Sohi/Bhamra/Khatri/Nihang/’ex-driver of Bhai Rama Singh Ji’/nang/afrikoo/blah blah blah has to say or not is largely irrelevant. He is just one person for whom many people have personal disdain and this has largely been, alongside similar sentiments that have been drummed up for Nidar Singh Nihang, that many people the world over have fallen for at the expense of addressing the real issue. The real issue is that of the assertions and challenges that have been presented on the Sanatan Sikh websites. Even mighty internet warriors well known by all and who even style themselves as Nihangs have either chosen to attack the personalities (with the above mentioned dressed-up dolls website), further fuelling the actual assertions made on the Sanatani websites (since clearly no one could actually address the points), these same internet warriors have then admitted that they “have given up” and “can’t be bothered” and issue a whole host of excuses like “they won’t admit to their errors” – which frankly is nothing short of naïve and childish expectations. At best we have seen some attempts at presenting some analytical papers however these are always based largely on 20th century texts and hearsay (aka “seena-baseena”) contain more errors than they solve or are simply a means for the author to try and seek some one-up-manship for their particulary Jatha or institution alongside which they make some more errors. In short no-one has done much to really address the ACTUAL questions raised on the Sanatani sites or even re-assess their quotes – perhaps one reason is that many of today’s Sikhs who are anti-Santani/anti-Niddar Singh, actually fancy themselves as Nihangs and are afraid that concluding against the Nihang ideology may well destroy some of their own pre-conceived ideas on Sikh customs – one good example of this was the thread in which I was accused of being a paid RSS agent for making a few comments on the attire of puratan Sikhs with regard to the Kachera and Chola. This is not a situation unique to this Sanatan Sikhi in the UK, which is arguably quite small and in its infancy of development. The RSS that everyone dreads so much these days are succeeding for much the same reason in Punjab - despite the presence of the SGPC, AKJ, Taksal, Sant Samaj –ALL undertaking active parchar throughout Punjab, yet the rate of apostasy in Punjab is far greater than that witnessed amongst the Delhi, Kashmiri and Pakistani Sikhs.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Singh · 16 Nov 2005

bhai rama singh never had a driver. notsure why his name is mentioned above. he has nothing to do with this lot.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Confused Khalsa · 16 Nov 2005

The saddest thing is these people break every kurehit, apart from maybe the smoking ciggaretes part and still call them selves Khalsa. They eat meat, drink and even remove hair. it's clear that theres something not right here, and then theres the hindu influence. Their websites are full of udasi/nirmalla babas yet when it comes to bhai sahib randhir singh ji, and sant jarnail singh ji they insult them and call them cowards. these practices are TOTALLY the opposite of sikhism, and yet people still run to join them to learn "the art Guru Ji taught". Whats the point being a really good fighter, if you have no knowledge of WHEN to fight and without Guru ji on your side? the people usually pulled towards Niddars teachings are those with little or no knowledge of sikhi, and with the minimal lack of "rules" their version of Sikhi preaches it is so much more appealing. another sad thing is how Gurbani is used on their site, minimal quotes are used and those that are used are out of context. The rest are from random sources and "undercover" litreature that only they have access to. I just hope that people open their eyes to what is going on.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Manmeet Singh · 17 Nov 2005

Amrit Pal's article is more to do with the webmaster of the snatani websites than snatani sikhism itself. An old saying which myself and my family try to live by is "If you cant see God in other's you cannot see God at all". Whether a person drinks, smokes or takes drugs has no bearing on whether they have the potential to do good or not. If we all began using diet to determine who does good and not (or who has the potential to do good or not), than the Allies in World War 2 would all be considered evil. Within their ranks were people who smoked tobacco, utilised opium and morphine (recreation and medicinal), drank alcohol, ate meat (of various kinds), and generally followed a diet that today's 'Panthic Gursikhs' would find disgusting. For people calling themselves "Singh" it is surprising that they resort to attacking individual personalities rather than keeping to the topic at hand, ie, snatani sikhs and the websites created therein. What is against Sikhism is resorting to mindless petty insults, judging others based on personal differences and spreading trash in order to create hatred and distain. Manmeet Singh (UK)

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

singh99 · 18 Nov 2005

>>Amrit Pal's article is more to do with the webmaster of the snatani websites than snatani sikhism itself<< That's a strange comment! Jagdeep's website IS snatan sikhism. Snatan Sikhism is still being created, it's just a lets make it up as well go along Sikhi and lets call anyone who doesn't agree with us as a fanatic. And there you have it, a good a definition as you will ever get of this thing called snatan sikhism. Hopefully with Amritpal Singh's well researched articles, we will see the end of snatanism in the UK at least. No doubt a few of the die hards will remain and they might even successfully convert themselves into another dambhi gurudom like the sant nirankaris or radhaswamis but the majority will abandon it. I can already see it happening. Niddar the uber nang and his chela jagdeep have no answers to Amritpal Singh and I wouldn't be surprised if they don't start to call him a fanatic and extremist.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Singh · 18 Nov 2005

Sorry Manmeet, but if the slag of Guru Hargobind ji by saying he was a druggie, then what more can you say? Snaatan sikhi is UK is clearly based around 3 individuals who are working everyday to promote it. They are Niddar, Jagdeep and Paramjit. You can be as politically correct as possible, but you cannot say that is not the truth.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Manmeet Singh · 18 Nov 2005

Lets be rational. If someone choses to insult others - be it the Gurus, why should we dirty our own souls by insulting and manufacturing hate towards them in return? Or are we so full of anger that we cannot settle our differences in a calm manner? From my own reading of the websites in question, there is nothing but praise for Goorbani and Sikhism, be it of a personal nature. They have chosen to portray the Gurus as consumers of cannabis but I personally believe that the Gurus were intelligent enough to be aware of the fine line between use and abuse. If my Guru wishes to consume cannabis for a purpose, then I would question it, but would not dismiss it souly based on my personal opinion about cannabis (for example). I hope my parents brought me up with enough sense not to dismiss anything, and not to accept anything blindly. Sikhism is about questioning and discovering - not about accepting the status quo simply because it upsets the applecart. In the modern age of general aneasthetics and painkillers, steroids, etc. would the Gurus not make use of these in order to increase the advantage over the opposition? The same analogy would be that it is against logic to face a man with a gun armed only with a knife as chivalry and rules, will not win battles in this day and age. Even Lucozade, Red Bull and other such energy drinks would be considered "drugs" as they alter the state of the mind. Hence their use in relieving fatigue or enhancing performance. Are we that petty that we cannot rise above these low level squabbles? There is much to be said about maintaining dignity in a discussion - and it appears many have lost it. As a side note, does anyone know whether the book being written by Niddar Singh is available? I came across a thread a while back where someone spoke of a book being released about nihungs.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

Singh · 18 Nov 2005

Manmeet - no one spreading hate for them. They did a good enough job of creating hatred against themselves. People have made thier own conclusions. People have debated with them for years, and shown them up. I wish you would stop writing such patronizing mails.

Re: Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique

A Singh · 18 Nov 2005

<> Veer Manmeet Singh, I beckon you to read the updates on Amritpal's website, you'll find clearly that they analyse and address the items on Sanatan Sikh websites and do so without any ridicule, that we have seen to date against the Sanatanis and BY the Sanatanis. The references to the website owner are only in the introduction - let's read fully - and in any respect, Amritpal has been very respectful throughout which needless to say is a lot more than the webmaster of sarabloh has ever done to anything/person he has analysed let alone criticised. Gur Fateh! A Singh