Sanatani Sikhi - analysis and critique
Singh · 15 Nov 2005
Gur Fateh! It seems at last we have a potentially academic analysis and critique of the Sanatan Sikhi websites without the need for dressed up dolls and other such petty childish behaviour. This looks to be promising – let’s keep an eye on the developments. Jaikara Gajave, Nihal ho Jaave, Shaheeda Singha Singhnia man du pave, SAT SRI AKAL! Taken from: http://www.amritworld.com/sanatani/aim.pdf Aim of This Section (Amrit Pal Singh 'Amrit') Self-proclaimed Sanatan Sikhs of UK are running their websites, in which they have made several comments on Sikh tradition and history. Their comments seem to be very strange for mainstream Sikhs. On one of their websites, Sanatanis have written: - All concepts and information revealed on this website with regards to Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya are fully backed-up with transcripts of interviews from present masters of this art, and a great variety of Sikh and non- Sikh historical literature. They say: - This website out of fear of controversy does not shy away from discussing the misconceptions that are so prevalent now with regards to Sikh martial arts, its true practitioners, and those subjects that it feels are undermining Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya today. It is not only what they call Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya, but they have raised other points as well on their websites. These points are controversial. Obviously, many other Sikhs are not agreed to many of their points. On this, one of Sanatani websites says: - Due to the nature of the website, and its willingness to be open with the truth with respect to Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya, it is inevitable that reputations and egos of certain individuals and groups with vested interests in promulgating the lies that are being exposed by the site will be bruised. Such individuals have resorted to death threats, slander, emotional blackmail, and even labeling Sanatan Sikh Shastar Vidiya practitioners as "anti-Sikh" to prevent the truth from being known. They further say: - www.amritworld.com II As Sanatan Sikhs, what we seek is the truth, and if the truth damages the foundations of institutions, then that is inevitable. If the truth really damages the foundations of institutions, we are more eager to know it. We would like to know which institutions it would damage. Then, they have said: - To such groups, we ask them to refute if they can what has been revealed here with clear objective scriptural, historical, rational or logical evidence. If we are wrong or mistaken in ANY of the facts presented here, then we will revaluate our stance and make changes accordingly. After all, as Sikhs, we are but seeking the truth. In other words, Sanatan Sikhs of UK have invited certain individuals and groups for discussions. They are ready to revaluate their stance and make changes accordingly, if prove wrong or mistaken in ANY of the facts presented on their website. I had a few discussions with the Webmaster of Sanatan Sikh websites, on online Sikh forum www.SikhAwareness.com. During one of such discussions, Sanatan Sikh Webmaster said (wrote) that he would be coming to my house, when he comes to India. I happily agreed to him. After all, it was a good opportunity to have discussions with Sanatan Sikh scholar. When I heard that the Webmaster of Sanatan Sikh websites, along with others, was coming to India to participate in Hola Mahalla festival in Sri Anandpur Sahib Ji, in the year of 2005, I invited him through www.SikhAwareness.com to have a face-to-face discussion, which was to be recorded for online sangat. The Sanatan Sikh Webmaster replied that he would be busy, so not sure if he meets me or not. I thought that he surely would take part in Mahalla procession, which was on March 26, 2005; and I could get a chance to learn from him. Therefore, I reached Sri Anandpur Sahib Ji with some of my students. We arranged video cameras to shoot the discussions. Unfortunately, I could not find him in Budhha Dal camp. I tried my best to meet him during the Mahalla procession, but I came to know later that he did not take part in the procession. I contacted some Sikhs from UK, who showed ignorance about whereabouts of Sanatan Sikh scholar. Despite my efforts, I could not have his Darshan (glimpse). Though, I could not have discussions with the Webmaster, I instead studied his Sanatan Sikh websites. I read that they have invited certain individuals and groups, to refute what has been revealed on Sanatan Sikh websites with clear objective scriptural, historical, www.amritworld.com III rational or logical evidence. They have promised that they will revaluate their stance and make changes accordingly if they are wrong or mistaken in ANY of the facts presented on their websites. When I read these comments, I thought I should analyze what has been revealed on these websites. The aim of this section on www.AmritWorld.com is to understand views given by Sanatan Sikh websites. While trying to understand their views, I have made a few comments also and tried to support them with clear objective scriptural, historical, rational or logical evidence. After all, as Sikhs, we are but seeking the truth.