Multi-Religion Experts on VIA & Kirpan Issue
News · 14 Nov 2005
SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 12, 2005 This week's question: How did you personally respond to news reports that a man was escorted off a VIA Rail train because he was wearing a kirpan, a ceremonial sword considered by Sikhs to be a requirement of religious faith? Kiran Kaur Bhinder's answer Kiran Kaur Bhinder Citizen Special Saturday, November 12, 200 I was dismayed and saddened. Sikhs have been living in Canada for over 100 years wearing the kirpan as one of Sikhism's five articles of faith. Ensuring safety in a transport environment does not preclude accommodating the individual needs of customers or employees, and Sikhs ask only for reasonable consideration that reflects the decades of contribution of Sikhs in Canada. One of my non-Sikh colleagues at work said the day after this story, "I can't believe we are still having to deal with the issue of not allowing kirpans in 2005." Sikhism is based on the fundamentals of seeking to preserve peace and prosperity of all citizens. Sikhs support security initiatives to preserve the peace and freedoms of our citizens, which can readily be accomplished without asking Sikhs to remove their religious identity in schools or while aboard Via Rail. Sikhs hope to put an end to misunderstandings of this uniquely distinctive and distinguished religious community. Reasonable accommodations for wearing the kirpan have been negotiated with the RCMP, Transport Canada, aboard airplanes, on motorcycles, and in public schools across Canada. Sikhs have maintained the five articles of faith (including the kirpan) while earning Victoria Crosses for serving the Commonwealth armies in the First and Second World Wars, to today serving in the Parliament of Canada. Committed to eduction, the Sikh community has worked with other faith groups to preserve safety, security and common freedoms. The right to wear a kirpan in Canada is a testament to the Charter of Rights. One of the fundamental rights that Canada stands for is the right to freedom of religion. The practice of Sikhism is not only consistent but also proactive in the belief and practice of security, peace, and prosperity for all of humanity. Sikhs support initiatives that enhance safety policies and that still support the spirit and intent of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Kiran Kaur Bhinder is an executive member of the World Sikh Organization. She is also a founding trustee of the Sikh National Archives. Reuven Bulka's answer Reuven Bulka Citizen Special Saturday, November 12, 2005 Frankly, I was torn between two clashing principles. On the one hand, I and hopefully all Canadians firmly believe that everyone is entitled to legitimate religious expression. Wearing a kirpan is one of the basic dress requirements for Sikhs. On the other hand, items even less potentially dangerous than knives are not allowed on public transport. Recently, I forgot to remove small nails from my travel bag, nails that were part of a package to affix a mezuzah (parchment containing excerpts from the Torah) on doorposts. Needless to say, I had to surrender them to the security officials, and was happy to do so. It is almost inevitable that these two vital principles -- religious freedom and public safety, collide on occasion. The kirpan issue is actually not new, in Canada and in other countries. In my life, I have had the opportunity to meet many Sikhs, and they are all very kind, peaceful, and most friendly. Personally, I would not be at all worried if I sat next to them on a plane, train, or bus. But the issue goes beyond personal feeling. My comfort level has little impact on public safety policy, nor should it. There is something about this that is not clear. I presume that this person was not the first Sikh to travel on public transport. Why have other Sikhs not been removed? Could it be that other Sikhs, realizing the manifest danger, have decided not to wear the kirpan for the duration of the journey? If, indeed, that is the case -- and I am not sure -- then this means that by Sikh rules, one need not wear the kirpan at all times, or that there are extenuating circumstances that allow for temporary relaxation of this requirement. For the future, I hope that some accommodation can be made that does not compromise public safety and operates within the acceptable boundaries of Sikh religious expression. Rabbi Reuven Bulka is head of Congregation Machzikei Hadas in Ottawa, a host of In Good Faith on the A Channel and host of Sunday Night with Rabbi Bulka on CFRA. Radhika Sekar's answer Radhika Sekar Citizen Special Saturday, November 12, 2005 Obviously, the free exercise of religion is guaranteed to every Canadian. The Sikh code dictates the wearing of the five Sikh articles of faith -- which includes the kirpan -- at all times. Some Sikhs are relaxed about this rule, but Khalsa Sikhs consider it mandatory to the practice of their sacred vows. And the personal level of observance of every individual needs to be respected. The five Ks visibly indicate a Sikh's personal commitment to his/her faith. The wearing of the kirpan arose out of a particular history, when no doubt it functioned as a weapon. But it has since evolved into a spiritual symbol of their sacred pledge. It is not, therefore, a mere religious adornment that can be removed at will and stored with the baggage! Furthermore no Sikh, lax or strict, would use it as a weapon, and it is offensive for law enforcement authorities to suggest this. On the other hand, in the wake of 9/11, both the public and security officers are justifiably more cautious on matters of security. While minorities are entitled to the unimpeded practice of their faith, the public, too, has a right to safety. In this instance, however, the issue seems to be one of ignorance and insensitivity. Moreover, the staff reacted to the kirpan only after receiving complaints from some passengers who felt "threatened" by the sight of a man in ethnic costume wielding a sword. (Would he have seemed less threatening in jeans and wielding a hockey stick?) The situation might have been avoided had the VIA officials received adequate training in cultural sensitivity. Apart from better training, to avoid such situations, clear and reasonable policies should be established in direct consultation with minority communities. Ideally, before such problems arise. Radhika Sekar has a PhD in Religious Studies and taught Hinduism at Carleton University for several years. She is a disciple of the Sri Ramakrishna Mission. Pat Powers' answer Pat Powers Citizen Special Saturday, November 12, 2005 Like all your readers, I was deeply saddened when I read these reports. I was reminded immediately of a passage from the Vatican II document Gaudium et spes, which underscores the equality of all peoples and rests upon their dignity as persons and the rights that flow from it: "Every form of social or cultural discrimination in fundamental personal rights on the grounds of sex, race, colour, social conditions, language or religion, must be curbed and eradicated as incompatible with God's design" (29:2). Still further reflection on this unfortunate event led me to realize that, although it was discriminatory, it was an act based more on ignorance of what the kirpan signified than its perceived threat to public security. As you know, every 10 years, people are asked about their religion in our annual census. In our archdiocese, we purchase statistics from Statistics Canada in that year, in order to learn more about who we are. In the last 20 years, the number of people who live on our territory, regardless of their religion, who speak neither English or French as a first language has risen to 9.9 per cent. I suspect it is similar throughout the country. Our society is changing. It now includes people from many cultural and religious backgrounds. In that sense, a great deal of education is needed everywhere so that such terrible errors can be prevented. An obvious effort is required, urgently, in all public service and safety areas, to assist officials to increase their knowledge of other traditions. But an even more fundamental educational effort must take place in our schools. As seen in our Catechism, we are called to share our faiths with all peoples, dialoguing with other religions, philosophies and sciences, as well (No. 39), thus producing graduates with far greater sensitivities, and hopefully eliminating the possibility of a recurrence. Msgr. Pat Powers is the rector of Notre-Dame Cathedral. John Gibaut's answer John Gibaut Citizen Special Saturday, November 12, 2005 I responded, initially, with sadness. Sadness for the Sikh law student who could not relinquish his kirpan because of his baptismal vows, and suffered humiliation as a consequence. Sadness as well for the employee who had the responsibility of enforcing VIA Rail's policy on that train. Then, I responded by learning something about the issue. I have come to appreciate the spiritual significance of the kirpan, representing the struggle of goodness against evil and injustice. As a sign of a Sikh's baptismal vows, the kirpan reminds me of some of the baptismal vows of my own tradition, which speak of perseverance in resisting evil, striving for justice and peace among all people, respecting the dignity of every human being. Recently, the Citizen that reported that Swiss army knife sales dropped 40 per cent after 9/11. My son would be suspended for bringing such a knife to school. I cannot board an aircraft with nail-clippers. When most people are so restricted in regards to knives, why should a religious tradition be exempt? Yet, human rights commissions have upheld the rights of Sikhs to wear the kirpan on the grounds of religious freedom, and I am sure they will again. Significantly, after a century of Sikh life in Canada, there is only one incident of a kirpan being used as a weapon, which occurred neither on a train, nor at school. Yet current fears and simple unfamiliarity about the kirpan -- and Sikhism -- reflect tensions between a changing society and an older faith tradition. Christian communities have long lived very painful and divisive struggles to live in modern Canadian society. I have learned that the Sikh community also faces such struggles and divisions, especially around the kirpan. I plan to keep on learning about this faith tradition, its beliefs, struggles, and symbols, including the kirpan. Rev. John Gibaut is canon theologian of the Anglican Diocese of Ottawa and a professor in the faculty of theology at Saint Paul University. http://www.canada.com/ottawa/ottawacitizen/specials/askthereligionexperts/index.html