Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 14 Nov 2005
Can somebody please explain to me why lassan (garlic) and massara(n) di daal (lentils) are not used in Guru-ka-langar? (in most Gurdwaras around the world)
I have heard that massar are included in langar at Anandpur Sahib but I am not sure if this is true- I can't recall eating massar when I have ate langar there.
Somebody once said that apparently (according to legend) massar/lentils came from cows so that's why they are not prepared at Guru-ghar. Surely, if this is the only reason, then Sikhs do not believe in such nonsense? I know most Sikhs eat massara(n) di daal at home, so why isn't it used in langar?
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
innocent bystander · 14 Nov 2005
daal wihtout lassan ....... you gotta be kidding
what is the world coming too....
next they will be saying you can't make chips in langar
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
Gurcharan Singh · 14 Nov 2005
The question is not what the world is comming ot, it is whatvis what are the SIKHS comming to with their own versions of Sikhi snd sikh practices..some sikh do not even beleive in the panch pardhan and panch parawan ...
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
Kulbir Singh · 14 Nov 2005
Brahmins don't eat onions or garlic. Looks like some Sikhs are copying Brahmins and avoiding the use of garlic and onions. In Gurmat, there is no prohibtion over the use of garlic or massara di daal.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 15 Nov 2005
Thanks for the replies- I have read various versions of Sikh rehit maryada (Taksal, SGPC etc) and never seen anything against garlic or lentils either.
So, are these ingredients used at Tapoban sahib?
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
BirRaas Singh · 15 Nov 2005
The same hukamnama attritubed to Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji in regards to "maas machi deh nehreh nahi jaana", also prohibits the use of onions in the next line.
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
Kulbir Singh · 15 Nov 2005
---------
Thanks for the replies- I have read various versions of Sikh rehit maryada (Taksal, SGPC etc) and never seen anything against garlic or lentils either.
So, are these ingredients used at Tapoban sahib?
-------
There is no prohibtion on the use of these ingredients at Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib.
----------
Muslims brought garlic to india, hindus treated muslims as malesh or impure did not use whatever they used in their daily life.
-----------
I don't think Muslims brought garlic to India. There is mention of Garlic in Vedas and other religious books of Hindus.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
Balpreet Singh · 15 Nov 2005
Bir Ras Singh,
You are wrong. I hope it is an innocent mistake and not more Sanatani propoganda.
The Hukumnama by Guru Hargobind Sahib contains NO MENTION of garlic or onions.
Yes, the hukumnamas by Banda Singh Bahadur do contain these in addition to meat and fish.
If you can find it, tell me where it is below:
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
manjh payara guru ko · 17 Nov 2005
brahmin can eat meat but.....without lassan(garlic)
[%sig%]
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
*saintsoldier* · 17 Nov 2005
many brahmgiani mahapurakhs prohibted lasan and laal mirch because it is not good for bhagti as it disturbs immune system and mental state.
baba hor khana kusi kuar jit kade tan pirea man mei chale bikar
[%sig%]
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
keepin it real · 19 Nov 2005
i've been told, its an aphrodisiac and therefore not used.
Re: Lassan / Massara(n) Di Daal
Kulbir Singh · 21 Nov 2005
As written before, Garlic is not prohibited in Gurmat. Some people do believe that it induces Kaam but Singhs who do abhyaas at amritvela need to eat "garam" things e.g. badaam (almonds), Badaam Rogan (almond oil) etc. Same way, even if Garlic is garam, it gets digested by Singhs who do abhyaas in the morning.
Kulbir Singh