URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
Tarrandeep Kaur · 13 Nov 2005
im goin to india tomorrow, and i have to remove my kirpan on the aeroplanbe :-( the panj piyare told me that on the aeroplane we can remove our kirpans and as soon as we get to india we should immediatly put our kirpan bak on and do ardas. howver they didnt say anything about eating while ur kakar is removed. so...........wen im on the aeoplane am i allowed to eat anything or not? please reply to the post.
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
Tarrandeep Kaur · 13 Nov 2005
can you give me a reason as to why we should not eat wen seperated with kakar?
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
Gurcharan Singh · 14 Nov 2005
In which part of the Rahitnamamis this recorded or is this the brain child of any individual?
bhai sahib, once the Kirpan is off the rehat is broken , refraining from eating is no excuse.
Sikhs should protest at taking the kirpan, and do an ardas for being in such a situation after that.
This is NOT an acceptable situation but until we stand up and count, we have no choice but to put up with such situations.
This suggestion fro not eating is NOT part of Sikhi but somewhere along the line brought up by some over zealous self motivated individual.
I am sorry, I do not buy this; this how unauthorised versions and practices creep in.
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
akj_4eva_and_eva_amen · 14 Nov 2005
bhai kulbir singh?
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
innocent bystander · 14 Nov 2005
oh my life
you guys are so ritualistic. like Hindus man
dont be so silly
take it off eat on the plane put it back on when you get there, no big deal man.
you guys are turning the kirpan into a "janeyoo"
if it comes off your body so what its a kirpan a a weapon, in the old days the kirpan was 3 ft not a little small one at side
and anyone who has held a 3 ft kirpan knows YOU cant have it with you 24 hours a day. esp when you have a bath as it would damage the sword be beyadbee.
u need to look at the facts and not just hold onto ritualistic behaviour or habits, when gurujee dressed as uch da peer he took his kirpan off and let his hair down for disguise.
when countless singhs were jailed in early 1900's by British then they never had kirpans but that didnt mean they were any less singhs.
and finally look at the other gurus not all of them wore a kirpan if you got darshan of guru angad dev ji and he isnt wearing a kirpan are you not guna accept him because he aint wearing one
cumon man and fasting is not a sikh principle ok... so fasting because you dont have your article of faith, i think consists of ritualistic behaviour.
the kakaars are our uniform and symbols of our faith they are NOT the be all and end all of OUR FAITH, if your kirpan comes off does not break your connection with the Guru, that is stupid.
the real connection is in the heart. the real kirpan is the courage in the heart, the outside one is just for self defence.
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
Gurcharan Singh · 14 Nov 2005
My apologies, There is one point I had failed to mention.
the law of the land requires us to take the kirpan off, it is not something we do willingly.
Like ....assin aap nahi kirpan launde, eh sadde kolon lahi gayi hai airport te, therfore the Sikh is absolved off of any deliberate act to break the rehat.
But however, in law, the rehat has been broken whther deliberately or whther due to circumstances out of your own control like the airports or an accident, and treatment.
Therefore a simple ardas asking forgiveness is sufficient and enough, as the Guru sahibs understands.
But asking people to refrain from eating etc is effecting a ritual that unfounded.This is Not in the maryada-the maryada I soeak of is the SRM Panthic maryada not some sideline maryada.Sikhism was FREED from ritualism.
please do not drown it back into some ritualism again.
I have always explained to the authorties before I cross under the security arch, about my Kirpan, and ussually I hold it in my hand as I cross over.I use a three inch, and have NOT had any reason to take it off.But then I also have the advantage of the Home Ministry ID on me, should anyone attempt to harrass me further.But so far I have had none.
Please keep sikhism simple and not confused poepl with rituals and esspecially those taht have no place and value in Sikhi.It is a simple religion.
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
Gurcharan Singh · 14 Nov 2005
"Gurcharan Singh, I sympathise with your stand that the SRM is important. But it was made by humans. It was made by a council, of which not all even approved it. You still couldn't provide any answer to the meat question and here again, you think you can limit Sikhi to the SRM".
Author, The administration of this site ,of which you must be one is not allowing my answer to you on the site.
i think it is you who is spreading malicious lies about meat and the so called hukamnama of which there is no substantiation.
Guru Gobind Singh ji gave the Panj Piare and the Panth to make decisions, and the one such deciosn was amde over meat and reahat maryada, you cannot explinthat and respond within panthic contents and here you are again, shouting one man band ideas, like a BAGGI from the Panth.
One can say, your version of made up Hukamnamas is not recognised, you are only one man band spreading lies.
I have checked with the learned of the panth, three Gursikhs one with an MA in Sikhi and founders of the missionary society,and no such hukamanam from Guru hargobind sahib exosts, it is easy for you to hide under some pen name bleat continually.
Guru Sahib gave the Pnath the authority to decide, not behave like the rigid Koran.So you think your say is above the Panth?Bhai sahib do not spread malicious lies.
You cannot take your issue openly , here you are agin with your self egoed brand , I can sympathise with your mentality of ..main naa manoo....sad chap.
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
Gurcharan Singh · 14 Nov 2005
Thank you bhen roop kaur ji you have said it for me ...indeed author Penname...
"Who granted these scholars their MA? Probably some worldly authority. What is to be done with this kind of MA? Sikhi and Rehit is not learned by doing MA's, but by practicing the religion"what exmpts ganda Singh from the above raises his status to claim that Guru Hargobind Sahib issued such a hukamnama, when the entire Pantrh has screened all gurbani for years.Are you suiggesting they deliberately ignored this hukamnama .The question is WHY ARE YOU HIDING BEHIND A PEN NAME.I think you are entitled to a sensible discussion ONLY if We KNOW YOUR NAME and identity, other wise I beleive you are NOTHING more than a dera saadh chela hood winking Sikhs here.
I thank Bhen Roop kaur ji for answering part of your questions-to why should we give any credance to Ganda singh's book, if we cannot give any credance to another GURSIKH with some learned knowledge and understanding and a Gursikhi life!
Author Pen name, you have not either answered my question as well to why WAS THIS HUKAMNAMA NOT CONSIDERED DURING THE CONSULTATION BY THE GURU PANTH IN THE SRM FORMATION?
Bhai Author Ji pen name, and Roop kaur ji, what makes you think you have greater life of a Sikh to comment upon an issue of the Panth ?These people do live a life of a gursikh unlike those who today refuse to understand the definition and position of Guru Panth.Even Guru Gobind Singh ji took the hukam of Guru Panth and evacuated Anandpur sahib.Who do you two think you are and what makes you above the panth and allow some deviant ideology to preside in your minds?
1) What basis is there for you or your "scholars" to claim that the hukumnamas are false? Since the book was published, all scholars have referred to it and accepted it. Some hukumnamas not included like the Kabul one are shown to be fake because no nishaan and other signs. What makes you say these are false?
Well as said Roop Kaur has answered the above what makes Ganda singh a scholar ?And the Guru Panth subsevient to Ganda Singh ?
For your information, Ganda singh's First book on Hukamname was published in 1967 by Punjabi university, not in 1999 as you have claimed.The second Nisan te Hukamname was by Bhai shamsher Singh Ashok also in 1967.They both used the same material for their reaserch.Any Hukamname before 1691 bore no dates.You have yet to answer WHY WAS THIS so called HUKAMNAMA IGNORED BY THE PANTH?
The reality is the Guru Granth sahib however neither condemns nor prohibits the eating of flesh.Although there are clear prohibitions to eat Kuttha meat.
Guru Hragobind only issued TWO HUKAMNAMAS.Ganda singh has given a total of 89 Hukamname and nisan.Apart from the above, there are also two Nisan's of Guru Hargobind sahib.
The Hukamnamas of the past related to issues before the formation of Khalsa was finalised.
If we are to beleive your claim, then we will find a contradiction in Guru Gobind Singh ji's adesh.Why would he say do not to consume Kuttha, if this meat eating habit had been decided already and has been settled so clearly by Guru Hargobind sahib long before the formation of khalsa in 1699?Can you answer that logically Bhai sahib before censoring my mail ?
Two issues arise here
One-why was there a need For Guru Gobind Singh ji to speak on Kuttha meat if Sikhs were NOT already eating meat as per instructions of Guru Hargobind sahib?
Two-why Guru Gobind Singh mentions only Kuttha meat and not all meat ?
Guru Gobind Singh gave the powers to the Guru panth.These two words go togther.They together reflect a great unparalled institution of Sikhi , what makes you think and roop kaur and you are above that parampara to belive in the rehat maryada that was set out by the guru Panth ?
In gurbani Vichar dhara the two words go together.taking that Hukam from the panth even Guru Gobind Singh evacuated the fort of anandpur sahib...why should you not accept the guru Panth. Are you suggesting Guru Gobind Singh was a lesser Sikh as he had taekn a hukam f rom five individual sikhs?Your rationale is a sign of baggipoona , nothing else.
A true Sikh believs in the parampara set out by the Gurus, and Five Gursikhs have the authority within the sphere of Gurbani to make the adjustment provided it all falls within the precedent and rahitname , history and gurbani.
Bhai sahib earlier you claimed new Gurbani came to light, now it has turned to be this Hukamnamas.There ar e many books published by individuals , that does not necessarily mean they all follow withinthe confines of the Guru panth maryada.The Mukh sewadar of Akal Tkahat too wrote a book, Gurbilas Paatshai 6 vi, which was banned subsequently.
The Panth was given the panch pardhani parampara.The Guru Granth sahib was made the custodian of the Guru Shabad.When this was done by Guru Gobind Singh sahib, the panth was also given to make decison within the relms of the Gurbani.So for you to even suggest it,that will sikhs follow to discard the turbans and beards shows exactly how much understanding you have about the Vishalta of the panthic values and ability to discuss within the concept of Gurbani.
Until I get to know the hidden ghost behind a pen name, for allI know you are a dera saddh floower undermining and confusing Sikhs...and for roop kaur ji I now recall you being accused as a vege brigade leader.
It is not true either the majority of Sikhs are veges, as I know majority of sikhs are not.yes, I do eat BUT jhatka, and until the Rehat maryada says so i will, and i will.
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
the same Hypocrisy over n over · 14 Nov 2005
who has stated this???????? and who has that authority to do so???? And how are we are forced to take it off?????? Were we not forced to convert to Islam????but did we????? I do not want to debate if it is wrong or not, because as along as you do not disrespect GGSJ or i am in no power to say what is wrong. It if you take it off, its up to u. But who are u to make these new rules???or to enforce them???? I believe in sarblo bibek, and a lot of other things, which a lot of other people dont follow but i dont force it on people nor do i say they do not follow rehit. However, i always see in many of your posts that you acuse people of not following rehit. In your post above you say that
"they can study Sikhi all they want, but until they actually start following rehit, they will never know what Sikhi is about"
It is basic rehit to keep on thr 5Ks at all time and to be tyaar bar tyaar. Thus, from your own posts, you wont understand sikhi cause you dont follow rehit
Now with that said, i am not saying it wrong or right to take off the kirpan, because you should know you self. HOWEVER, to all you people, who always preach to everyone about how bebik is part of rehit, and how this is gurmat and this isnt, first start following basics and stop being hypocrites.
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
Balpreet Singh aka. .,. · 14 Nov 2005
1) I never claimed anywhere it was published in 1999. Even if I did, the point would be irrelevant in this discussion. Perhaps some other poster did, but I did not. The reason why this Hukumnama wasn’t considered during the formation of the SRM, can be surmised to be the fact that it wasn’t known in the Panth at that time. Dr. Ganda Singh went and did the research to collect these hukumnamas. They weren’t well known before that time. How could they consider something they didn’t know about?
You still haven’t told me what leads you to believe that these hukumnamas are not authentic. What factual basis is there for such a claim?
Where have you seen Guru Gobind Singh refer to Kutha? Even if he did, where is kutha defined as halal? Muslims don’t define it as such. Muslims don’t have that term.
Kutha in fact means to kill. Not through halal or anything else, but just to kill/butcher.
On kutha: kutha comes from the word Kuthaar which means an axe.
[gurbani]kwiF kuTwru ipq bwq hMqw AauKDu hir ko nwau ]1] rhwau ][/gurbani]
kaaD kuthaar pit baat huntaa aoukhudh har ko naao
The Name of the Lord is the medicine; it is like an axe, which destroys the diseases caused by anger and egotism. ||1||Pause||
Now, tell me, can you do halal with an axe? No. You can only do halal with a blade or a knife. So the root of the word itself shows it cannot be associated with halal-slaughter.
Then, when kutha is used in Gurbani, it is clear that it cannot mean halal. "Azraaeel faRay faR kuthay. " Do you think the angel of death performs the halal-slaughter on the soul?
When in Asa dee Vaar we say the word “kutha” it comes, “abhaakhiyaa ka kuthaa bakra khaaNaa” . Now tell me, why say “abhakhya” to clarify it is the kuthaa done with Kalma, if kutha itself is halal? Why clarify what kind of kutha it is, if kutha is halal?
Next you talk about Guru Panth. Guru Panth is certainly an important concept. But the Panth cannot contradict something in bani or the Guru’s words. There can be logistical decisions taken ie. To start a morcha or something. Or in the case of Guru Gobind Singh, to evacuate a fort. But it is UNHEARD OF to say the Panth can contradict Guru’s principles. It would not be acceptable if some Sikhs got together and decided kesh are no longer necessary. It is not something the Panth has any jurisdiction over.
You said, “Bhai Sahib, earlier you claimed new gurbani came to light…” When did I say this? I’ll tell you what, since this is causing you so much vexation, I’ll start using my name in this debate. I am Balpreet Singh. I never said “new gurbani” came to light. It’s not possible to have new bani come to light.
You still haven’t answered questions 2-4. I repeat:
2) What makes you say there is no substantiation? What more do you want besides pictures of them?
3) Why do you call them "translations"? What part seems translated to you?
4) The hukumnamas all have the same injunction. You want context and the context is clear that the hukumnamas start with general instructions like "guru guru japna" and not to eat meat. Then the specific insturctions are given. What troubles you with the context?
Tell me, when you eat “jhatka”, do you kill it yourself? Do you know it was done with one blow? Is it done by a Sikh? All these are necessary conditions for “jhatka”.
Re: URGENT HELP!!!!-kirpan on aeroplane
the same Hypocrisy over n over · 14 Nov 2005
Roopkaur,
I understand its not from your own matt, but its it ok if rehitvaan singhs it is ok?? If we are trying to keep the same rehit as in Gurus time than why are we making an exception for this??? When we take amrit our only obligation is to Guru Sahib. Singhs during Gurus time gave up their lives because they forced with convert, but did they convert??? wasnt Baba Banda Singh obligated to save his son??? but did he??? If we do nothing about this problem, and continue to remove our kirpan while boarding the plane, than we will never have the right. Plus, why would Guru sahib do kirpan on us if we dont follow his hukam. Also because of this till, we get kicked off the train and out of school and other places. They say that if we can take it off while boarding a plane than we should have no problems taking it off on their property. Personally, to tell you the truth, i dont find ANYTHING wrong with that. If we can make an exception for some situations than why cant we make some exceptions for other situations? I personally, would never board a plane unless i have my kirpan. However, being a GurukaSikh, i knw that somehow or someway Guru sahib is going to do kirpan and allow me to have darshan of Siri Harminder Sahib.
Oh yeah about darshan of Siri Harminder Sahib. Bhai Sahib went to jail, and was given many options to get released, however, he decided to stay firm in his belief. When he made that decision, he was fully aware that he might never have darshan again of Siri Harminder Sahib. HOwever, because he had to SOO much sardar, Guru Sahib did kirpa.
I have one question for everyone. When get a feeling that something is wrong, we usually knw that is it wrong. So, when the question is, do feel right being at the airplane without your kirpan???