Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Mangalacharan

Mangalacharan

yo · 10 Nov 2005

What is mangal charan? Some raagi singhs do this?

Re: Mangalacharan

Kulbir Singh · 10 Nov 2005

Manglacharan is the verse or set of verses read or written before starting a composition or lecture. Traditionally all Indian writers start their work by writing Manglacharan and Guru Sahib too wrote all their baani starting with a manglacharan. Mool Mantr is the Manglacharan used before starting Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Many Gursikhs write manglacharan before writing anything. Hindus always start their compositions or works by writing about Ganesh whereas Sikhs always write Manglacharan about Akal Purakh. Sooraj Parkash Granth contains some of the most beautiful Mangals with respect to 10 Guru Sahibaan. Muslims write Mangals about Allah and then about Mohammad (see Heer Waris Shah or Heer Damodar for details). This is why the manglacharan should always be read first and not after the Mahala. The following is contained in most Gutkas and is totally wrong: Gauri Mahala 5 Salok IkOankaarSatGurParsaad|| The correct way is: IkOankaarSatGurParsaad|| Gauri Mahala 5 Salok How can you say Mangal after "Salok" when we clearly know that the salok is "Aad Guraye Namah"? Also, the manglacharan coming after the Mahala would indicate that it is the composition of that Mahala and this poses even bigger problem in case the baani is of Bhagats. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Mangalacharan

yo · 10 Nov 2005

thanks:)

Re: Mangalacharan

Taksali · 11 Nov 2005

hold up hold up hold up hold up -Kulbir Singh- did i get this right u said ------------------------------------ The following is contained in most Gutkas and is totally wrong: Gauri Mahala 5 Salok IkOankaarSatGurParsaad|| The correct way is: IkOankaarSatGurParsaad|| Gauri Mahala 5 Salok --------------------------------------------------- I dont know if u meant it vice versa but the top one is correct not the bottom one which u wrote Gauri Sukhmani Muhula 5 Salok Ik OankaarSatGurParsad is the correct way ur version is the version where the people who think they know wat they are talking about believe during sant gurbachan singh bhindranwales time the singhs almost beat up the prabhandak comittee of the time because they were sayin these type of things but sant ji stopped the singhs. then later the singhs went to sant ji and did benti that "mangala di sudaee karnee chaydee" otherwise they will change how sri guru granth sahib ji was originally composed and everywhere there is a mangal they will put ikoankaarSatGurparsad above everything even tho it comes after in this example of Sukhmani Sahib. So when the singhs did benti to sant ji he said that it is a good idea and was extremely happy. so 5 singhs went to amritsar do this seva. Sant Kartar Singh Bhindranwale, Premi Kartar Singh, Jathedar Ram Singh, Bhagat Ji, and another 5th which is off my mind right now. but they did the whole mangla di sudaee and had they not done that ppl would be lost today and ikOankaarSatGurparsad would be at the beginning of everybani instead of how guru ji wrote it like in Sukhmani Sahib after the Salok. If u do not believe wat i say u can ask any prana singh mainly bhagat ji who is not far from tapoban. there was a big rola about this during sant jis time and had the 5 singhs not done the sudaee you would see all maharaj saroops today printed the way u state. i was actually shocked that u said that.

Re: Mangalacharan

**- · 11 Nov 2005

_____ Hindus always start their compositions or works by writing about Ganesh _____ Kulbir Singh, This is not true. Why do you always try and make out yourself to be an authority of Hinduism? You always like to make such silly generalisations in order to belittle Hinduism and maginify Sikhi - you make me sick

Re: Mangalacharan

Singh · 11 Nov 2005

here we go again, fairytale sikhi?? Mr taksali, if we believe everything you say, including the taksal belief that Moolmantar is up to Nanak hose bhi sach. Then manglacharan would be Ik Onkaar Nanak Hosi Bhi sach. It is a good job that we are not that gulliable!

Re: Mangalacharan

... · 11 Nov 2005

Taksali, the big problem here is when people follow what others have told them blindly. Have you seen any puratan birs and know where the mangals went? They went at the far right of the shabad quite often. When they were typesetting the bir, they saw the mangals at the far right and depending on whether they thought it was above the shabad heading or below, they changed it. There are many puratan birs (that were in the reference library and now with G. Gurdit Singh and others) that have all the mangals clearly above each shabad heading.

Re: Mangalacharan

Taksali · 14 Nov 2005

Clarification to above post: The fifth singhs name was Sant Jarnail SIngh Bhdinranwale