Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Singh · 09 Nov 2005

I am very much missing Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji on this message board these days. Respected Pyarey Gyani Jeo, Pl let us know when you will be back as every thread is incomplete and waiting your input for last two weeks. Are you gone to a Bhora to do ikaantvas bhagti? Pl keep your invaluable presence as we always need elders like you (who have practiced Sikhi on their lives for more than a generation period) to share their wisdom with the growing current generation Sikh youth. [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Kulbir Singh · 09 Nov 2005

If I am not wrong, I think Gyani jee has gone to India. He did let the Sangat know, through one of his posts, that he would be gone for some time. I am sure, he will have many stories to share with us, when he comes back. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Gurcharan Singh · 09 Nov 2005

Giani Ji, Veer Jarnail Singh Ji, has gone to the USA and Canada, then he will be in India.If I rememeber his private post to me correctly, he will be away till December.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Singh · 09 Nov 2005

Jarnail said in one of hes post that he will never step into india until we get khalistan.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

SiNgH · 09 Nov 2005

Yeah, I miss Arshi Jee's posts too. [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LK · 10 Nov 2005

Author: Singh Date: 11-09-05 11:37 Jarnail said in one of hes post that he will never step into india until we get khalistan. ********************** Yes I remember that too, he mentioend how him and hsi father boycott India, and woulnd't step into India before SIkhs get justice- Perhaps koi Mazbori peh gi hovey?

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Gurcharan Singh · 10 Nov 2005

hey, I may be wrong and therefore please do not take that he is definitely going to India.I erased the mail, so have no way of checking, but thought India was included in his programme, if I re call correctly.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

manjh payara guru ko · 10 Nov 2005

me too [%sig%]

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Gurcharan Singh · 13 Nov 2005

Veer Arshi is in India for a PURPOSE.Please see below: Press Release Chandigarh, November 13, 2005 On the second day of the International Sikh Conclave being held at the Institute of Sikh Studies here for the Constitution of the proposed International Sikh Confederation, an apex body of the Sikhs, many other delegates from India and Foreign Countries offered their comments. The opening session started with the comments of Giani Jarnail Singh Arshi from Malaysia,who compared the state of Sikh affairs at the present time with the period of Sikh history just after Banda Singh Bahadur's downfall. He suggested that the constitution of ISC should be based on principle of "Collective leadership" a present version of old institutions of "Panj Piaras", "Sarbat Khalsa" and "Gurmatta". Sardar Avtar Singh Sidhu (Canada), insisted on the quality of management and integrity of the Management office bearers, because the earlier two World Sikh Organisations had failed because their management was weak and fell into the trap of subterfuge. He endorsed the forming of the ISC and its proposed consitution. Sardar Gursharan Singh from Malaysia endorsed the constitution of ISC but suggested certain amendments in the constitution of ISC and insisted that the framed draft constitution was too lengthy and repetitive. Only the basic essentials of the Constitution should be adopted in the initial document. Amendments and additions could be made later on as and when the need arises. ISC Should opearate through the latest means of information technology for the quick insemination of its programmes. Brig (retd.) Hardit Singh regarded the drafted constitution as the best possible one. He also suggested an alternative of dividing the whole globe into 22 Sikh zones and taking two delegates from each zone for including them into the governing body along with a few enlightened individuals. An immediate ad hoc committee of 50 persons was also suggested by him. Sardar Angrej Singh, a leading spokesman of the Union Territory villages, endorsed the formation of the ISC and suggested that there should be no election atleast for five years so that the first governing body could make this ISC fully functional and operative. Sardar Charan Kanwal Singh, Chief Secretary, Guru Gobind Singh Study Circle, Ludhiana brought a mandate from Giani Ram Singh, the chief of this Organisation, endorsing the formation of ISC. He cautioned the organisers that the ISC should not appear to be a brain child of the IOSS only, and make efforts to project it as a collective voice of the whole international community of the Sikh diaspora. He also cautioned that the Sikh organisations to be given representation in the ISC should be selected on the basis of their performance for the Sikh cause in any field, rather then their nomenclature. He expressed his views against the election system for the constitution of the ISC. Dr Birendra Kaur regarded the ISC as a kind of valuable garland made of all the representative Sikh Organisations. She advocated the participation of women in the ISC on the basis of their merit and contribution.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

. · 13 Nov 2005

please come back with loving and inspirational posts :)

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 24 Nov 2005

Guru Piyario Jio, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh. I am deeply touched by the sincere love and pyaar shown....and the fact that you have made me a part of your life. THANK YOU all for keeping me in mind when i was away.... With the Blessings of Dhan Dhan Guru Ramdass Ji Sodhi Sultan, I was given a clarion call to appear at His Royal Darbar...and a "bahana" in the form of an IOSS Confrence Special Invite to present a paper came along....and that was how i ended up in the Holy Land of my Gurus. I took this opportunity to have ishnaan at the Sarovar Darbar Sahib Harmandir Sahib Amritsar, Taran Taran Sahib, Baba Budha Singh Birr Sahib with its Parshaad of Missi Roti and Onion, Goindwaal Sahib Baoli, Fatehgarrh Sahib, and more than 45 Historic Gurdwaras in the Amrtisar/Kapurthala/Jullunder Districts...visited the House of Guru Nanak Ji ( and drank the water from the same well that Guru Ji used), House of Bibi nanaki Ji sister of Guru Nanak ji, Visited the small confined space that Guru ji was "confined" in while His "Tera Tera" complaint was dealt with by the nawab of Sultanpur, saw with my own eyes the Watteh weights used by guru Ji, visited the Janjh Ghar used by Guru Arjun Ji and His Baraat, visited the Birthplace of Guru hargobind Ji....visited the small kotthrree that Teeyai Taap was locked up in By Guru Amardass Ji, bathed at the baoli Sahib there as well, visited the Gurdwara Sahib of baba bir Singh Naurangabad...and many others....including the beautiful Khadoor Sahib..and Sannh Sahib with its "hole" in the wall that Guru ji gave this neech a chance to crawl through !! All in all a solid THREE WEEKS of Gurdwara darshans from 8 am in the morning to 10 pm at night daily..and an overnight stay lasting 30 hours for the 84 ishnaans at Goindwaal Sahib Baoli Sahib. I also "visited" the DERA of a famous Baba ( just opposite historic Fattehgarrh Sahib ) and saw with my own eyes how the Guru Granth Sahib was "parkash" in a tiny locked room with no lights..( we had to push open the closed doors and "on" the lights ourselves..while the Baba ji had a magnificent Hall with a huge gallery of his own photos..and all baba ji's huge photo garlanded hanging on the wall and a small photo of Guru NANAK Ji in the background...as if an afterthought !!!..and a huge luxury vehicle of the baba that the "shardhaloos" were mathateking to ( its WHEELS) while it was parked in the garage and a sewak was there to collect donations as well as see that the vehicle was not damaged !!! Suddenly a shout went up..Baba Ji aa gayeh...and we saw baba ji approaching in a white Toyota Lexus ...he swished past at full speed into a second garage that closed its doors in a flash... the shardhaloos then matha tekked to the dust that the toyota wheels just left in front of us.....second dera i visited was that of baba seechavaal in Sultanpur....this baba is doing a yeoman's job of cleaning up the Vein River, beautifying its banks and all....what the Govt should be doing !!! but is NOT doing. He has indeed cleaned up the dirty veinee River ( the river that Guru nanak Ji disappeared in for three days )..a beautiful Sant Ghaat Gurdwara stands on this site. I was also given a very special "invite" to visiit the Radhasoami Dera at Beas...a rented "private taxi" with driver was sent by someone whom i dont know.....and several phonecallas were made to remind me to come visit the dera and see for myself how things are run there but i declined... I have lots of "good experiences"...and "feel good" stories which i will relate later...after i unwind from the trip.. Thank You all once more for the immense pyaar.... Jarnail Singh.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Truth · 24 Nov 2005

It's amazing how well net-worked the Radhasoamis are. I'm sure they keep a watch on all these Sikh forums to see who's "hot" and who's "not"....haha. p.s. who's "Teeyai Taap"?

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Gurcharan Singh · 25 Nov 2005

Indeed they do.Some years back, I was on trip back from Malaysia, when incidently the plane stopped at Delhi.Some passengers got abroad. A "sikh" lady passenger sat next to me, and soon started a conversation with me, and somehowthe conversation got round to babas, and I made my displeasure known very well, esspecially about radhaswamis....she did not say much ..but at arival inLondon she asked if she could have my phone number, which I gave. About three weeks later , I had a phone call.from the same lady who apologised, and asked me to visit her at a centre that was of radhaswamis.I declined.then I got many number of calls that if I ever went to India, Iwould be welcommed and met at delhi and taekn by car to the dera at delhi from where I can be taekn by the baba ji to Dera beas. etc.I should come and vsist them. I declined .For months I had calls, I refused to respond they stopped.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

sikh · 25 Nov 2005

bhai sahib - why did you do 84 ishnaans at Goindwaal Sahib Baoli Sahib? can you please explain this. also i read somewhere about the gurdwara near amritsar where the sarovar is deep you have to walk down loads of steps to get to it - it said that if u take an ishnaan then do japji sahib on each step its supposed to be very benefiting? it this true which gurdwara is this? but does this not sound like a ritual?

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

NS · 25 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Bhai Sahib Jarnail Singh Jeeo, you meniton above the 30 hour stay at Goindwal Sahib for 84 ishnaans. I was just wondering did you carry out in practice the reading of Japji on every single step until 84 with ishnaan, if so did that take 30 hours to complete or less? I ask the question as I 've always had the urge to do this in life at some point.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Singh · 25 Nov 2005

Giani Jee which baba did you see near Fattehgarrh Sahib, also could you name the Baba at Sultanpur.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 25 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. Guru Piyario Jio, The 84 Japji Sahib paaths and Ishnaans were performed at the Baoli Sahib of Guur Amardass ji Sahib at Goindwaal. It is a continuous process...one ishnaan..followed by one Japji Sahib paath on one STEP....hence 84 steps, 84 ishnaans and 84 Japji Sahib Paaths. It can be called a "ritual"..if done as a ritual...or it can be spiritually uplifting "experience"...as I felt it to be..the water was ice cold ( being beginning of winter)..what actual benfit i will get i will only "know" as and when Guru Ji Wills it. Yes it took me the time period of about 30 hours in all....begin the paath/ishnaan from the highest steps in the beginning as soon you will get more and more tired...by the time i finished i should have been near collapsing..but amazingly i wasnt.. dont ask me why or how ?? I honestly cant answer it. The "traditional" theory behind this Baoli Sahib is thea 84 ishnnans and Japji Sahibs ensure one passes the 84 lakh joons at each step and gains muktee. To be fair I also read this same inscription on the Wall at Gurdwara Sannh Sahib, which said anyone who PASSES through this HOLE in the Wall be relived of all his 84 lakh Joons and gain Muktee. ( This hole in the Wall was made by Bhai buddha Ji/Bhai gurdass ji and other Prominent Sikhs to gain access to Guru JI. Guru Ji had gone into Ikaantwaas (Solititude), and written a strict injunction above the closed door that NO ONE SHOULD OPEN THIS DOOR....meanwhile the Sikhs who were getting restless without Guru Ji's Darshan, implored Baba Buddha Ji and other Prominenet Sikhs to find a solution. The "solution" was to OBEY GURU Ji and not use the Door to get in, but break open through a HOLE in the Back Wall of Guru Ji's House....hence SANNH ( hole in wall). This HOLE in the Gurdwara Sannh sahib opens at the back of the Takhat Sahib where Guru Granth Ji is parkash..and everybody CRAWLS THROUGH...and i did the same....again i dont know whether my 84 lakh joons slate is wiped clean or not ??? Guru Ji knows !! Again thius can be interpreted as ritual....even meaningless ritual....but then the same people take matha tekking to be ritual as well..and so is taking Parshaad - degh or partaking of guru ka langgar etc etc...But one thing i can say for SURE.... I AM NOT for a single moment taking it as assured my 84 lakh joons are over and so i can relax.... NO WAY...my Daily NITNEM and other Paaths rehit will continue as usual...but i sure have more INNER STRENGTH now to do even more of this. Thats all i can say on this matter for now. Same goes for all the Ishnaans at all the SAROVARS and other BAOLIS. The Baba Dera near Fatthegarrh Sahib is a few hundred yards away from the Main Gurdwara of Fattehgarrh Sahib....cross the road in front of the Gurdwara, walk through a huge walled car park/open ground and towards a RAILWAY LINE..... the small road LEADS DIRECTLY into that DERA. The name of the baba is i think Balkar singh or something similar. The Path into the Dera is Very LONG...at the side are huge sheds housing a few hundred Buffaloes cows etc donated by the sangats..and on one side are locked rooms. The baba at Sultanpur is baba SEECHEWAAL.... he has transformed the "Sewer" called VEINEE into the almost PRISTINE condition as at the time of GURU JI. The water is clean and clear flowing..huge parks at the sides of the banks and a beautiful Gurdwara Sant GHAAT ( exact spot where Guru Ji went into the Veeinee river to go to Sach Khand to get The Mool mantar. I also Visited the River called BLACK VEEINEE which flows through the Village of DURGAPUR/MARRYPUR where I stayed for a few days while visiting the Gurdwaras in Sultanpur/Kapurthala/Jullunder. Since i was visiting Punjab for the FIRST TIME in 55 years...I was very apprehensive....but i found the people very friendly/helpful...many going out of their way to help, the food was fantastic, Guru Ramdass Ji's Langgar tasted really beyond words....and i felt spiritually in tune with the Holy land of my Gurus and martyrs ( i felt foolish at first but am now thankful that i brought back a handful of soil from the major Gurdwaras as well..so as to "show" my family a nishanee from there..while in Harmandar Sahib performing the Parkarma..the beautiful words of Prof Pooran Singh rang true in my ears...O MY SON..step very very carefully in this Parkarma...because these are NOT ordinary Marble Tiles....BUT the HEADS of martyred Guru Ke Sikhs... Dhan GURU RAMDASS JI jin sirreah tinneh sawariah.....bestowed upon this neech an opportunity to visit His House. Jarnail Singh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

vaheguru · 26 Nov 2005

veerji, was there nothing you could do about teh beadbi done to Guru Maharaj in the first dera you talked about?

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 26 Nov 2005

Welcome back Gyani JI, nice to hear you had a nice time :) **************** took this opportunity to have ishnaan at the Sarovar Darbar Sahib Harmandir Sahib Amritsar, Taran Taran Sahib, Baba Budha Singh Birr Sahib with its Parshaad of Missi Roti and Onion, Goindwaal Sahib Baoli, Fatehgarrh Sahib, and more than 45 Historic Gurdwaras in the Amrtisar/Kapurthala/Jullunder Districts... **************** Is there any special significance of bathing at above mentioned sacred shrines?

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Kulbir Singh · 26 Nov 2005

Beautiful posts Arshee Gyani jeeo and welcome back. I commend you for being able to do 84 ishnaans and 84 paaths of Siri Jap jee Sahib. I look up to you. I myself could not gather courage to do this. And you are right. To some, it may be a ritual but if you don't do it as a ritual but do it with full shardha, then wiping out one cycle of 84 Lakh joon does not seem impossible to me. And how can it be a ritual when Gurbani paath is involved? Ritual is a supposedly religious act but without the essence but when Baani is recited, it cannot stay ritual any longer. You have rejuvenated my urge to do 84 paaths and 84 ishnaans. Some point in time, I intend to do this. May Guru Sahib do bakshish. About Darbar Sahib you hear so much and sometimes you think that the writers are exaggerating but when you actually arrive at Darbar Sahib, you begin to think that all writers who have written about greatness of Darbar Sahib have failed to do justice. Darbar Sahib's greatness cannot be written in words. Darshan Ishnaan of Darbar Sahib are sought for everyday in Ardaas. There is a good reason for this. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 26 Nov 2005

Why Kulbir SIngh Ji, is Darshan Ishaan of Darbar Sahib sought for? I Seek for Darshan Ishnan of the Shabad eachoing inside the complex, not the water filtered by ultra hydro filter system (just made that name up..) I mean what's the point :S

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Kulbir Singh · 26 Nov 2005

--------- Why Kulbir SIngh Ji, is Darshan Ishaan of Darbar Sahib sought for? --------- Because the ishnaan of Amritsar Sahib is spiritually uplifting. You have to experience to know. ---------- I Seek for Darshan Ishnan of the Shabad eachoing inside the complex, not the water filtered by ultra hydro filter system (just made that name up..) --------- Well, you can have darshan Ishnaan of shabad sitting at home; why bother going to Darbar Sahib then? Only the followers of Kala Afghana or some pseudo scholars who have no kamaayee of Gurbani and Naam reject Ishnaan of Sarovars build by Guru Sahib. Rest of the Sikh Awaam is willing to die for it. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 26 Nov 2005

Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 11-26-05 08:17 --------- Why Kulbir SIngh Ji, is Darshan Ishaan of Darbar Sahib sought for? --------- Because the ishnaan of Amritsar Sahib is spiritually uplifting. You have to experience to know. ---------- I Seek for Darshan Ishnan of the Shabad eachoing inside the complex, not the water filtered by ultra hydro filter system (just made that name up..) --------- Well, you can have darshan Ishnaan of shabad sitting at home; why bother going to Darbar Sahib then? Only the followers of Kala Afghana or some pseudo scholars who have no kamaayee of Gurbani and Naam reject Ishnaan of Sarovars build by Guru Sahib. Rest of the Sikh Awaam is willing to die for it. Kulbir Singh ************************* So you're saying that merely by Bathing in a sacred Shrine where the Guru's made the sarovar (presumably for HYGIENIC reaasons rather than spiritual) [gurbani]dIvwlI dI rwq dIvy bwlIAin] qwry jwq snwq AMbr BwlIAin] PulW dI bwgwq cux cux cwlIAin] qIriQ jwqI jwq nYx inhwlIAin] hir cMdurI Jwq vswie aucwlIAin] gurmuK suKPl dwq Sbd smHwlIAin ]ö][/gurbani] Lamps are lighted in the night of divali festival; Stars of different variety appear in the sky; In the gardens the flowers are there which are selectively plucked; The pilgrims going to pilgrimage centres are also seen. The imaginary habitats have been seen coming into being and vanishing. All these are momentary, but the gurmukhs with the help of the Word nourish the gift of the pleasure fruit. Dhanaasaree, First Mehl, Chhant: One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: Why should I bathe at sacred shrines of pilgrimage? The Naam, the Name of the Lord, is the sacred shrine of pilgrimage. My sacred shrine of pilgrimage is spiritual wisdom within, and contemplation on the Word of the Shabad. The spiritual wisdom given by the Guru is the True sacred shrine of pilgrimage, where the ten festivals are always observed I constantly beg for the Name of the Lord; grant it to me, O God, Sustainer of the world The world is sick, and the Naam is the medicine to cure it; without the True Lord, filth sticks to it. Ang 687 http://www.srigranth.org/servlet/gurbani.gurbani?Action=Page&Param=687&english=t&id=29780#l29780 [gurbani]mYN (BI) qIrQ auqy ieSnwn krn jWdw hW (pr myry vwsqy prmwqmw dw) nwm (hI) qIrQ hY [ gurU dy Sbd ƒ ivcwr-mMfl ivc itkwxw (myry vwsqy) qIrQ hY (ikauNik ies dI brkiq nwl) myry AMdr prmwqmw nwl fUMGI sWJ bxdI hY [ siqgurU dw b^iSAw ieh igAwn myry vwsqy sdw kwiem rihx vwlw qIrQ-AsQwn hY, myry vwsqy ds pivq® idhwVy hY, myry vwsqy gMgw dw jnm-idn hY [ mYN qW sdw pRBU dw nwm hI mMgdw hW qy (Ardws krdw hW—) hy DrqI dy Awsry pRBU ! (mYƒ Awpxw nwm) dyh [ jgq (ivkwrW ivc) rogI hoieAw ipAw hY, prmwqmw dw nwm (iehnW rogW dw) ielwj hY [ sdw-iQr pRBU dy nwm qoN ibnw (mn ƒ ivkwrW dI) mYl l`g jWdI hY [ gurU dw pivq® Sbd (mnu`K ƒ) sdw (Awqmk) cwnx (dyNdw hY, iehI) in`q sdw kwiem rihx vwlw qIrQ hY, iehI qIrQ-ieSnwn hY [1[[/gurbani] http://gurugranthdarpan.com/0687.html What is the difference between Sikhs and Hindus, if bathing at sacred places of pilgrimages now matter? Is there a doule standard somewhere? We say that bathing at the Ganges isn't going to give you any spiritual uplifting, then how will bathing at any of the historical Gurdwaras do that? ********* Well, you can have darshan Ishnaan of shabad sitting at home; why bother going to Darbar Sahib then? ********** Yeah, why bother going to the Gurdwara, when you can have Darshan of Guru Ji at home, and Darshan of His Bani at home.... SANGAT PANGAT. *********** Only the followers of Kala Afghana or some pseudo scholars who have no kamaayee of Gurbani and Naam reject Ishnaan of Sarovars build by Guru Sahib. Rest of the Sikh Awaam is willing to die for it. Kulbir Singh ************ Then so be it, if Following Gurbani and Akal Thakhat Maryada (showing no at all significance to bathing at sacred shrine, or nowhere in Maryada it says that - YOU HAVE TO( or shoudl for tha matter) BATH IN THE HISTORICAL GURDWARAS), and trying to udnerstand Gurbani and Guru Ji's HUkam makes you a Kala Afghana follower then so be it. If I agree with him on that single thing (and deny all of his rubish about no Amritvela Significance, no Dasam Bani etc) makes me a Kala Afghana follower, then I think quite a large amount of Sikhs would be Kala Afghana followers Regards I Hope I have not offended you as, I am but a student, of Guru Ji. Bhull Chukk maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Kulbir Singh · 26 Nov 2005

Lionking, Please read the following thread in response to your post above. This has been discussed many times before: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=53334&t=53010 Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Nov 2005

Piyarae veer Lionking Jio, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. As Gurbani also says....SEEING IS BELIEVING...( khaitoh kee sobha nahin deakha hee parvaan..). I agree with you that completely "ritualistic" ishnaan at the sarovars baolis is of absolutley NO USE. But then completley "ritualistic" listening/reading of gurbani will also amount to the same thing...its all "water off a duck's back..." There is no compulsion. BOTH command extra attention on our part for any benefits to accrue. I also used to hold views that are similar to yours.....i have "seen" through Guru Ji's Kirpa...and have "accepted" Parvaan. I firmly beleive that now my spiritual journey is on a firmer footing.... Jarnail Singh.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 27 Nov 2005

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh Gyani Jarnail Singh Arshi, and Veer Kulbir SIngh Ji, I have still to get response to the above shabads (surprisingly not even mentioned in the other thread thread) I tried responding to the other thread, however My response has not been allowed :S Again, you have stated that it will be benificial but not compulsory. We all know that Gurbani being the Diamond, Heera, Spirituality itself, has Gurbani FAILED TO MENTION that Sarovar Ishnan will benifit you spiritually? Gurbani is ALL ABOUT spirituality, eh kidha hogeya ke Guru Ji Sarovar no mention karna bhul gey????? Again If you go to the Ganges and ask a Hindu bathing there, I am 199.999% sure he will give you EXACTLY THE SAME response - you have to have faith, you have to believe, you have to experience to see ect ect, so what's your comment on that? Again unless you can provide anything from GURBANI, I will not accept it... I have yet to see ANY TRANSLATION /Explaination (whether English or Panjab) which says that going to pilgrimages or bathing in sarovars will help you spiritually. - Kulbir SIngh jee, you mention that you does not think that the Shabad in the other thread is saying that bathing in Sarovars - Are you trying to make your own interpretationg of Gurbani because it doesn't fit with what you believe? Also, you mention that the significance of the Sarovar is that Guru Ji made it (not the Bani, as you bluntly said that the Bani can be listened to at home to), did Guru Ji (Ik Baba Akal roop), Vaheguru, Gobind, Akaal, Kartar not create the Ganges or the nile for that matter, or did Advani or Vajpay create the Ganges or the Nile? Again, My Personal opinion on this at the moment is that it's for hygienic reasons and that it completly crushes the gender, caste, religion discrimination where one is superious to another... However, I refuse to believe that it washes our sins (or Apradh), unless you can provide a quote from ultimate and eternal Gurbani. This morning when Daas took Hukamnama, Guru Ji pretty much crushed my doubts - http://www.sikhitothemax.com/Page.asp?SourceID=G&PageNo=642&ShabadID=2415&Format=2 His mind's desires may lead him to go and dwell at sacred places of pilgrimage, and offer his head to be sawn off; but this will not cause the filth of his mind to depart, even though he may make thousands of efforts. ||3|| Singing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises in the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy, is the highest of all actions. Says Nanak, he alone obtains it, who is pre-destined to receive it. ||8|| Your slave is intoxicated with this Love of Yours. The Destroyer of the pains of the poor has become merciful to me, and this mind is imbued with the Praises of the Lord, Har, Har. ||Second Pause||1||3|| I don't really think Guru Ji can be more clear than the above two Shabads - where one says that the REAL TEERATH, is NAAM - he's said it word-to-word - the REAL TEEERATH IS NAAM, GURBANI - I don't understand Can Guru ji be ore clear than that? In the Hukamnama this Morning Guru Ji again evaporates the small doubts in my Mind. Again, I hope this post will be posted and not be declined like my other post seems to be. Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj =) Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Bhopinder singh · 27 Nov 2005

Lionking So we dont need sarovar and we may not even need Darbar sahib,we dont need amrit,we dont need any kesh lets term all of this as Bahaman vaad. What is the end result of all this. Hypothetically if i do this i am a Bahman as the singh will be removed from my name cause amrit is Bahamanvaad and i wii be Bhopinder kumar.Hence you and Kala Afghana have completed the mission of GOI. kALA AND others are targetting sikhs by attacking the sharda factor of Sikhs will fail as many like them have failed in the past.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

NS · 27 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh My question is to Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji, did you have 84 kacherras' and 84 lots of Gatras when doing ishnaan at Baoli Sahib? I know it's a stupid question but there are some that twist rehat to their own way of liking.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

... · 27 Nov 2005

NS, so you don't like changing your kacherra when you do ishnan? You like to strip down to your birthday suit to save the kacherra for another go, and keep wearing the same kacherra at least 3-4 days straight? Saves laundry time I suppose, but the kacherra by the end must by quite dirty eh? What a stupid question. You keep your kacherra on when you bathe and you change it afterwards. If you're doing ishnan repeated times, you would keep the same kacherra on and change it at the end. You wash and change your gatra so that it's clean every day. Or would you prefer to have it accumulate dirt and sweat and wash it every 7 days or so? Some people seem like they enjoy an argument for argument's sake even if they come off as idiots when doing it.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

... · 27 Nov 2005

LK, Why did Guru Sahib make 5 sarovars in Amritsar Sahib within close walking distance from each other? Why did he make Bibeksar Sahib and Ramsar Sahib right across the street from each other? There must have been a reason? So that everyone could have equal opportunity to bathe perhaps? When Guru Sahib talks about the glory of Ramdas Sarovar, was he mistaken? Even if there are some things we don't understand, its best to just take it at faith that Guru Sahib made it and it must have a purpose. Sikhs have been asking for Amritsar Sahib jee kay ishnan in ardaas for countless years. Singhs like Bhai Mehtab Singh used to go to Amritsar for ishnan even when it was at the risk of losing their lives. According to you they were very ignorant. Just ask yourselves: who is more believeable? Bhai Sukha Singh and Bhai Mehtab Singh and others along with hundreds of years of Sikh history or a Lion King, some guy posting on the internet, named after a cartoon.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

... · 27 Nov 2005

One more thing for LS you wrote: "if Following Gurbani and Akal Thakhat Maryada (showing no at all significance to bathing at sacred shrine" You must feel really funny and probably like a hypocrite when daily in your Akal Takhat Maryada Mandated ardaas you ask for ishnaan of Amritsar. Hundreds and thousands of Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, Baba Gurbachan Singh and others proclaim the glory and importance of Darbar Sahib and Amritsar Sarovar. But lion king and kala afghana (sexual molestor) say it's no big deal. Baba Deep Singh, Baba Gurbaksh Singh, Bhai Sukha Singh and Bhai Methab Singh put their lives on the line to protect Amrit Sarovar, but Lion King and Kala Afghana (traitor to the Panth), say "who needs it"? They probably would've suggested that it's only a building....let it go. I just wonder who you guys think you are when you preach stuff like this. Do you really think you know better than all the other Gursikhs who have died for this place?

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

NS · 27 Nov 2005

Dear ... Many Thanks for your comments I meant the question for Bhai Jarnail Singh Jee who did 84 ishnans at Baoli Sahib, now everyday basis. And for information I bath everyday and put a clean kacheera on smelling of comfort. So your telling me Jarnail Singh Jee changed his gatra 84 times and kacheera 84 times when he did Japji Sahib tapsayaa at Baoli Sahib? Don't even answer I rather wait for Bhai Jarnail Singh Ji to answer. If my question was idiotic for you then tell where is written in the Akal Takht maryada about your and Kubir Jee's version of ishnaan. AKJ is recognised by the Akal Takhat and vice versa should also respect what's written in the marayada, as the people who wrote it were not idiots it took them years they didn't dream of it just overnight like me and you posting on this forum. Bhul chuk maaf

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

singh · 27 Nov 2005

NS, it doesn't say in the Akal Takhat Maryada how to do parkash and sukhasan. We still do them. The maryada does say that the kakaars are to be with us at ALL times. This includes bath time. Look below at the article and see example from many different rehitnamas that specifically mention my and "Kubir Jee's version of ishnaan". Before making such bold statements, do some research otherwise, again, you end up looking foolish. >>>>>>>> A Singh/Kaur should be tyaar-bar-tyaar correct? That means Guru Sahib can call on us for our head or our seva at any given moment. Do you think you are tyaar bar tyaar standing naked in the shower with not even a kacherra to cover yourself up? Are you tyaar-bar-tyaar when your kakaars are off? Simple question. No. Akhand Kirtani Jatha, Damdami Taksal, All Nihang Dals and I know that at the Takhats (SGPC maryada) they tell you that you cannot be apart even during a shower. Which Jathas are there that allow you to separate from your kakaars? I think it boils down to an issue of love. These are gifts given to us by our Guru. Do you love that gift enough to keep it with you at all times and at all costs? Bhai Amarjeet Singh Babbar was stripped of his kakaars and after that point, despite the agonising torture he faced, he refused to even drink a drop of water until his kakaars were returned to him. He was martyred during the torture. Jathedar Gurdev Singh Kaunke when he was arrested, was ordered to take off his kakaars for interrogation. He refused. Swarn Ghotna, the interrogator dreaded across Punjab for being a butcher, put his hand on Jathedar jee's gatra to take it off. Jathedar Gurdev Singh grabbed him by the throat and said, "You dog of the Brahmins! You don't know the value of these to me!". It took 9 officers to remove Jathedar Sahib and he was then tortured to death. These Singhs gave their lives but wouldn't be separated from their kakaars by their own will. And here we are taking off our kakaars to go for a swim or take a shower. Who showed the love? Taking off our kakaars is a kurehit. It isn't a bujjer kurehit, but it is indeed a kurehit. Willingly taking them off requires that we present ourselves before the Punj Pyaaray for forgiveness. Countless Gursikhs have found a way to keep their kakaars at all times including work, sleep and bathing. Are you saying your situation is so unique that you can't manage? I have slept with my kirpan for 8 years. Haven't injured myself yet. You can follow the example of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, Baba Gurbachan Singh jee Khalsa, Jathedar Gurdev Singh Kaunke or Bhai Amarjeet Singh Babbar. When bathing, a Sikh will first wash his/her hair. The kirpan doesn't get wet and the keski is tied to the waist. After washing the kesh, the keski is tied back on and the kirpan is tied to the dastaar. Doesn't really cause any problem. Even old rehitnamas say that a Sikh should not remove the kacherra at once and should be changed one leg at a time. Washing with it on is a question that is so obviously answered, I'm not going to bother replying to it. These Singhs I mentioned would not give up their kakaars under any circumstances. They could have just said "oh well, I have no control on the situation, let it go" But they didn't they chose death over it. I really doubt "It is the same love in those instances as those who didn't make it through." if someone is taking off their kakaar to bathe. If your kirpan is on a gatra or if it's nearby when sleeping makes a BIG difference. I can easily walk up to you when you're asleep and take your kirpan away. A kirpan on a gatra cannot be taken away without disturbing the person wearing it. The person with his kakaar is "tyaar bar tyaar" for any call to battle but the person lying there without it is NOT. Question: when at darbar sahib, do you see people leaving their kirpans by the side of the sarovar? No. They wear them. Why? Because they know it is wrong and will look bad on them if they do that (even if they do it at home). Rehitnama References: Bhai Nand Lal Jee's Tankhanama states; [i]"He who abandons the Guru and follows another, who sleeps at night naked from the waist down, whoh engages in intercourse while naked, or who bathes while naked [let him be regarded as a grevious offender" verse 42.[/i] Rehitnama Bhai Desa Singh [i]"Sustain within your man, compassion, obedience to your dharam and tap. Never be separated from your kachh or your kirpan. In a fight never turn your back or flee from the field of battle" verse 15.[/i] Bhai Daya Singh Rehitnama: This is for after bathing, how to change the kacherra: [i]"For changing his kachhera, he should have alength of cloth measureing 2.5 gaz" [/i](what would be the need of this if he could just take it on or off. All Singhs who keep their kacherra at all times need this cloth to change their wet to dry) also [i]"If a Khalsa bathes without a kachh or with his kes uncovered instead of h aving a turban properly tied, he should incur a tankhah..." (verse 53)[/i] There is no doubt that Guru Sahib's precious kakaars cannot be removed willfully by a Sikh. If they are, he should appear before the Punj Pyaaray for a tankhah. Who would willfully want to be apart from Guru Sahib's gifts? or You can follow the advice of some guy posting on an internet forum. Your choice.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

NS · 28 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Veer singh Jeeo, I'm aware all the points you 've just mentioned, I can't understand where did you gather the notion that I said kakkars can be left alone by themselves and you can take ishnaan without them, where did I write that? Incidently I keep my kakkars with me at all times. My question relates to when you guys mention " left leg first in the kacheera, or right leg first in the kacheera" why does this matter?? kacheera must be white what about if it's black why is that a taboo? My other point is why would need to wash the gatra and kirpan everyday? Which marayda mentions this, I understand the cleaniness, I keep mine clean as possible. And singh try to read posts carefully instead of just jumping to conclusions and wasting your time and mine. My question still reamins unanswered for Bhai Jarnail Singh Jee? Also Lionking makes excellent points and that too reamins to be answered for the likes of Kulbir Jee or anyone else for that matter.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 28 Nov 2005

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh Firstly I'd like to thank Veer ji's for prompt responses and personal attacks :) ***************** Author: Bhopinder singh Date: 11-27-05 05:30 Lionking So we dont need sarovar and we may not even need Darbar sahib,we dont need amrit,we dont need any kesh lets term all of this as Bahaman vaad. ********************** When did I speak about Darbar Sahib, Amrit or Kes? ******* What is the end result of all this. Hypothetically if i do this i am a Bahman as the singh will be removed from my name cause amrit is Bahamanvaad and i wii be Bhopinder kumar.Hence you and Kala Afghana have completed the mission of GOI. ******** I never called Amrit, i.e Khande Battey di Pahul Bahmanvad - you seem to imply it is. As of mission of GOI, if quoting from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji makes me GOI, then so be it. I used to think that GOI agents have mission to mix Sikhs with Bhramans, and making them get into Bahmanvaad again - seems like opposing Bahamnvad makes me GOI, hahaha thanks for your dear accusation =) ****** kALA AND others are targetting sikhs by attacking the sharda factor of Sikhs will fail as many like them have failed in the past. ****** I don't know about you, but for me, My Guru, and his bani is the Sharda factor, hence why NIROL Gurbani is recited at Darbar Sahib =) ******** LK, Why did Guru Sahib make 5 sarovars in Amritsar Sahib within close walking distance from each other? Why did he make Bibeksar Sahib and Ramsar Sahib right across the street from each other? There must have been a reason? So that everyone could have equal opportunity to bathe perhaps? ******** Perhaps, Guru ji wasn't ignorant, he's Abhull, all knowin. Practicle issues- you don't need to walk from the sarovar to Darbar Shaib before your forhead is full of sweat. He wasn't ignorant that one day Darbar Sahib is going to be FULL of sangat wishing to meet Guru Ji (like on his Gurpurabh, when Guru Ji himself pulled the arm of over 2 million Sangta to come and have his Darshan) Be practicle can 2 million Sangta bathe in one sarovar? *** When Guru Sahib talks about the glory of Ramdas Sarovar, was he mistaken? *** No, you are mistaken in taking the litteral meaning of Ramdas Sarovar - Here's explaination by Prof Sahib Singh - [gurbani]hy BweI ! gurU ƒ iml ky mnu`K KotI miq dUr kr lYNdw hY [ ivkwrI mnu`K BI gurU ƒ iml ky pivq® jIvn vwly ho jWdy hn [[i] jyhVy BI mnu`K rwm dy dwsW dy srovr ivc (gurU dI sMgiq ivc Awqmk) ieSnwn krdy hn (mn ƒ Awqmk jIvn dyx vwly nwm-jl nwl ieSnwn krWdy hn) auhnW dy swry (ipCly) kmwey hoey pwp lih jWdy hn [2[[/i] hy BweI ! gurU dI sMgiq ivc iml ky prmwqmw dw nwm ismrnw cwhIdw hY, sdw pRBU dI is&iq-swlwh dy gIq gwxy cwhIdy hn [ jyhVw mnu`K pUry gurU ƒ Awpxy ihrdy ivc vsWdw hY, auh (pRBU-dr qoN) mn-mMgy Pl pRwpq kr lYNdw hY [3[ hy dws nwnk ! (AwK—) prmwqmw Awpxw mu`F-kdImW dw (ipAwr vwlw) suBwau kwiem r`Kdw hY [ auh prmwqmw sB qoN v`fw hY, isRStI dw pwlx vwlw hY, AwnMd-srUp hY [ jyhVw mnu`K aus dw nwm ismrdw hY, aus sB qoN au~cy AwnMd dy mwlk ƒ jp jp ky auh mnu`K Awqmk jIvn hwsl kr lYNdw hY [4[10[60[ [/gurbani] http://www.gurugranthdarpan.com/0624.html Also, you have not responded to the Shabad "Teerath Navan jao, Teerath NAAM HAI" REAL TEERATH is NAAM - in SIKHI thereis no such thing as bathing in sacred Shrines - there is Naam, and there's Shabad, let me know if you find any other way written in the Barah maha. ********** Even if there are some things we don't understand, its best to just take it at faith that Guru Sahib made it and it must have a purpose. Sikhs have been asking for Amritsar Sahib jee kay ishnan in ardaas for countless years. Singhs like Bhai Mehtab Singh used to go to Amritsar for ishnan even when it was at the risk of losing their lives. According to you they were very ignorant. Just ask yourselves: who is more believeable? Bhai Sukha Singh and Bhai Mehtab Singh and others along with hundreds of years of Sikh history or a Lion King, some guy posting on the internet, named after a cartoon. *********** Rather than trusting anyone I would put my trust in - [gurbani]gur ibnu Goru AMDwru gurU ibnu smJ n AwvY ] gur ibnu suriq n isiD gurU ibnu mukiq n pwvY ] guru kru scu bIcwru gurU kru ry mn myry ] guru kru sbd spuMn AGn ktih sB qyry ] guru nXix bXix guru guru krhu gurU siq kiv nl´ kih ] ijin gurU n dyiKAau nhu kIAau qy AkXQ sMswr mih ]4]8][/gurbani] Who is more believable Gurbani or anyone else? Without the Guru, there is utter darkness; without the Guru, understanding does not come. Without the Guru, there is no intuitive awareness or success; without the Guru, there is no liberation. So make Him your Guru, and contemplate the Truth; make Him your Guru, O my mind. Make Him your Guru, who is embellished and exalted in the Word of the Shabad; all your sins shall be washed away. So speaks NALL the poet: with your eyes, make Him your Guru; with the words you speak, make Him your Guru, your True Guru. Those who have not seen the Guru, who have not made Him their Guru, are useless in this world. ||4||8|| Gurbani is crystal clear on Teerath Ishaan. Unless you can provide me with anything from Gurbani about Teerath, please do not care to respond. Again if you've got a quote from Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj, the treasure of spritiuality and diamonds then please post... ARE YOU TRYING TO SAY THAT GURU JI FORGOT to talk about THE SPIRITUAL BENIFITS OF TEERATH ISHNAN? Is this the faith we put in our Guru? Guru Ji is CRYSTAL CLEAR on this issue yet we deny what he's saying!!! Unless you can provide a quote from Guru Ji there's no use of posting. [gurbani]gur ibnu Goru AMDwru gurU ibnu smJ n AwvY ][/gurbani] Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Kulbir Singh · 28 Nov 2005

Lionking, The shabad (Teerath Naavan jayo, Teerath Naam hai) that you have quoted pertains to Aanmatee (Hindu) teeraths and not Gurmat Teeraths. According to Gurbani, that place that Guru Sahib blesses becomes sacred. Please refer to the following Chhant of Siri Guru Raamdas jee Maharaaj: Jithay Jay Bahai mera Satguru, So thaan Suhaava Raam Rajay|| (That place where Guru stays becomes sacred) Gursikhee So thaan bhaaliya, lai dhoor much laava|| (Gursikhs find that place and place the dust of that place on their foreheads) Gursikhaa kee ghaal thaaye payee, jin Har naam dhiyaava (This hard work of finding Guru Sahib’s Gur-asthaan brings good results, provided they also japp Naam) The above pankiti clearly says that it is the duty of Gursikhs to find places where Guru Sahib stayed or built himself. Those places where Guru Sahib has sat on and did Kautak, are blessed places. You write that the purpose of sarovars was to clean the physical body but if you read instructions at Sarovars, they stop you from using soap to clean your body. It is recommended that you clean your body before going for Sarovar Ishnaan. What was the need for 5 sarovars in the vicinity of Amritsar Sahib? If you say that the only purpose of Sarovars is to clean the body of sangat coming from far off places, then how come Siri Guru jee did not build a sarovar at Anandpur Sahib, Keeratpur Sahib, Khadoor Sahib, Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib? Why only at Amritsar Sahib and why did he build not one but 5 Sarovars in Amritsar Sahib? If the purpose was to clean body, then what did the sangat in Anandpur Sahib, Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib do? What about sangat in Khadoor Sahib? How did they clean their body? Lionking, your argument that sarovars are only to clean body is a very shallow talk. The whole Sikh Panth including all Panthak organizations believe in the sacredness of doing ishnaan in Sarovars. Numerous Gursikhs have benefited their lives by curing themselves of diseases, just by doing ishnaan in Sarovars. You have to believe and then see the results of doing ishnaan in Sarovars. Why can’t the water of Sarovar be sacred? Guru Sahib blessed the sarovars with his Charan-chhoh and for so many hundred years there has been Gurbani kirtan going on in Darbar Sahib? You think Gurbani makes no affect on the surroundings? What is it that makes water amrit during Amrit Sinchaar? What else but paath of Gurbani? Water definitely has the ability to retain spiritual power of Gurbani and it is definitely beneficial to drink water at sarovars. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Nov 2005

Nearly everyone who is someone "advised" us not to drink "municipal water" ( that is water from the tap/unbottled water) under any circumstances....as that would be sure to make one sick.... Surprsingly NO ONE advised us NOT to take a CHULAAH from the SAROVARS...in fact we saw everyone taking chullahs from the sarovars..and some from the charan washing pools in front of every Gurdwara Entrance. As advised we didnt take a sip from any municipal tap or drink any unbottled drink.....but all those ( estimated about 250 ) Chullahs from the Sarovars and baolis didnt do us any harm..my long held "bharam" in this regard was broken through the Gurkirpa of Dhan Dhan Guru Ramdass Ji. What Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji says about the "bathing" aspect in the sarovars is also right. Not only is the use of soap "forbidden" i saw noticeboards advising against "rubbing your body hard" while bathing "...Sreer Mall mall ke nahauna manah hai !! so essentially its just a "dip" ( what they call mandi kerbau in Malaysian lingo) and NOT a "soaped/hard rub type of hygeinic bath process" which we normally engage in our home bathrooms/showers. To answer some one leses query...I took along only 5 kachheras for my entire trip but used only two during the entire 30 hour process. The gatra/Kirpan was wrapped around the dastaar/keski...three of the others were wearing theirs around the waist as normal !!There were four others who were doing this at the same time and i essentially followed what they were doing. This was...go down all the way to the Baoli..take a dip/chullah ( place for only TWO persons at the same time)....go up to the very FIRST Paurree, stand up with folded hands and complete one Japji Sahib paath...go down for another dip/chullah....go to SECOND PAURREE and complete another Japji Sahib paath ..and so on. The Four others who were there before me were at various stages and the paurrees are only wide enough for about three persons. The LADIES side was CLOSED with doors while the Mens side was open from all the way up. A very Similar Baoli Sahib was also seen at Gurdwara Pind Dalla Sahib in Kapurthala Dist ( Guru Hargobind Sahib Jees Gurdwara). At the right side of this Gurdawara is the Ancient House which was used as JANJH GHAR by Guur Arjun Ji Sahib during Guru hargobind Ji's wedding, and at the back of this Gurdwara is the Famous Hindu Shrine where SHARAAB is Parshaad. The mandir and Gurdawara used to share a common compound but since the SGPC took over, the mandir has been walled up and separated from the Gurdwara. Unlimited shraab..desi and walaitee is served as langgar....and an unending stream of alcoholics is ever present there....alcohics' heaven !!

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 29 Nov 2005

Lionking, The shabad (Teerath Naavan jayo, Teerath Naam hai) that you have quoted pertains to Aanmatee (Hindu) teeraths and not Gurmat Teeraths. ****************** Why did Guru ji use the word Teerath and not Hindu Teerath, or Aanmatee Teerath? Did he not knwo that this will bring confusion, if he wasn't including all sarovars in this?. Seriously we are now moulding our own explaination of Gurbani. All Guru Ji says is - JAO TEERATHA TE- Kere teerath te? NAAM DE TEERATH TE - *********** theerathh naavan jaao theerathh naam hai || Why should I bathe at sacred shrines of pilgrimage? The Naam, the Name of the Lord, is the sacred shrine of pilgrimage. ********* [gurbani]mYN (BI) qIrQ auqy ieSnwn krn jWdw hW (pr myry vwsqy prmwqmw dw) nwm (hI) qIrQ hY [ gurU dy Sbd ƒ ivcwr-mMfl ivc itkwxw (myry vwsqy) qIrQ hY (ikauNik ies dI brkiq nwl) myry AMdr prmwqmw nwl fUMGI sWJ bxdI hY [[/gurbani] Teerath Navan Jao, Teerath NAAM HAI. Can you please provide ANY translation/explaination of Gurbani that says that in this context Guru Ji is refering to Hindu Teeraths. And why only Hindu Teerath? is the Ganges less "holy"? Unltimatly, the Ganges, the Niles, Beas, Ravi allt hese were ultimatly created by - Akaal, Vaheguru, Kartaar, and not Vajpaay or Advani... Is something Kartar himself made less holy? Kes another thing, are not GIVEN by Guru ji, as obviously other religions kept Kes too before Sikhi, yes we show reverence to God's creation... Why do we have this double standard? Is there ANY WAY Guru Ji could have been clearer than this? [gurbani]pVy ry sgl byd nh cUkY mn Byd ieku iKnu n DIrih myry Gr ky pMcw ] koeI AYso ry Bgqu ju mwieAw qy rhqu ieku AMimRq nwmu myrY irdY isMcw ]3] jyqy ry qIrQ nwey AhMbuiD mYlu lwey Gr ko Twkuru ieku iqlu n mwnY ] kid pwvau swD sMgu hir hir sdw Awnµdu igAwn AMjin myrw mnu iesnwnY ]4] sgl AsRm kIny mnUAw nh pqIny ibbykhIn dyhI Doey ] koeI pweIAY ry purKu ibDwqw pwrbRhm kY rMig rwqw myry mn kI durmiq mlu Koey ]5] {pMnw 687}[/gurbani] [gurbani]hy BweI ! ijqny BI qIrQ hn jy auhnW auqy ieSnwn kIqw jwey; auh ieSnwn sgoN mn ƒ haumY dI mYl lw dyNdy hn, (iehnW qIrQ-ieSnwnW nwl) prmwqmw rqw Br BI pRsMn nhIN huMdw [ (myrI qW ieh qWG hY ik) mYN kdy swD sMgiq pRwpq kr skW, (swD sMgiq dI brkiq nwl mn ivc) sdw Awqmk AwnMd bixAw rhy, qy, myrw mn igAwn dy surmy nwl (Awpxy Awp ƒ) pivq® kr ley [4[[/gurbani] ********** According to Gurbani, that place that Guru Sahib blesses becomes sacred. Please refer to the following Chhant of Siri Guru Raamdas jee Maharaaj: Jithay Jay Bahai mera Satguru, So thaan Suhaava Raam Rajay|| (That place where Guru stays becomes sacred) Gursikhee So thaan bhaaliya, lai dhoor much laava|| (Gursikhs find that place and place the dust of that place on their foreheads) Gursikhaa kee ghaal thaaye payee, jin Har naam dhiyaava (This hard work of finding Guru Sahib’s Gur-asthaan brings good results, provided they also japp Naam) ************ Did Satguru Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji bathe in the sarovar of Amritsar? ***** The above pankiti clearly says that it is the duty of Gursikhs to find places where Guru Sahib stayed or built himself. Those places where Guru Sahib has sat on and did Kautak, are blessed places. ***** True, never said you shouldn't go and have a look and experience, but at the same time - it also implies that you don't have to, as the Gurus then, are exactly the same as the Guru Now, so to do to that "asthan" where Guru ji is sitting - you need to go no further than Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib! I agree that the palces the Guru's visited and the historical Gurdwaras are definetly rich of spirituality for having Gurbani Sung for soo long - no doubt - but there isn't any compulsion in it, and I have not denied the importanc

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 29 Nov 2005

Lionking, The shabad (Teerath Naavan jayo, Teerath Naam hai) that you have quoted pertains to Aanmatee (Hindu) teeraths and not Gurmat Teeraths. ****************** Why did Guru ji use the word Teerath and not Hindu Teerath, or Aanmatee Teerath? Did he not knwo that this will bring confusion, if he wasn't including all sarovars in this?. Seriously we are now moulding our own explaination of Gurbani. All Guru Ji says is - JAO TEERATHA TE- Kere teerath te? NAAM DE TEERATH TE - *********** theerathh naavan jaao theerathh naam hai || Why should I bathe at sacred shrines of pilgrimage? The Naam, the Name of the Lord, is the sacred shrine of pilgrimage. ********* [gurbani]mYN (BI) qIrQ auqy ieSnwn krn jWdw hW (pr myry vwsqy prmwqmw dw) nwm (hI) qIrQ hY [ gurU dy Sbd ƒ ivcwr-mMfl ivc itkwxw (myry vwsqy) qIrQ hY (ikauNik ies dI brkiq nwl) myry AMdr prmwqmw nwl fUMGI sWJ bxdI hY [[/gurbani] Teerath Navan Jao, Teerath NAAM HAI. Can you please provide ANY translation/explaination of Gurbani that says that in this context Guru Ji is refering to Hindu Teeraths. And why only Hindu Teerath? is the Ganges less "holy"? Unltimatly, the Ganges, the Niles, Beas, Ravi allt hese were ultimatly created by - Akaal, Vaheguru, Kartaar, and not Vajpaay or Advani... Is something Kartar himself made less holy? Kes another thing, are not GIVEN by Guru ji, as obviously other religions kept Kes too before Sikhi, yes we show reverence to God's creation... Why do we have this double standard? Is there ANY WAY Guru Ji could have been clearer than this? [gurbani]pVy ry sgl byd nh cUkY mn Byd ieku iKnu n DIrih myry Gr ky pMcw ] koeI AYso ry Bgqu ju mwieAw qy rhqu ieku AMimRq nwmu myrY irdY isMcw ]3] jyqy ry qIrQ nwey AhMbuiD mYlu lwey Gr ko Twkuru ieku iqlu n mwnY ] kid pwvau swD sMgu hir hir sdw Awnµdu igAwn AMjin myrw mnu iesnwnY ]4] sgl AsRm kIny mnUAw nh pqIny ibbykhIn dyhI Doey ] koeI pweIAY ry purKu ibDwqw pwrbRhm kY rMig rwqw myry mn kI durmiq mlu Koey ]5] {pMnw 687}[/gurbani] [gurbani]hy BweI ! ijqny BI qIrQ hn jy auhnW auqy ieSnwn kIqw jwey; auh ieSnwn sgoN mn ƒ haumY dI mYl lw dyNdy hn, (iehnW qIrQ-ieSnwnW nwl) prmwqmw rqw Br BI pRsMn nhIN huMdw [ (myrI qW ieh qWG hY ik) mYN kdy swD sMgiq pRwpq kr skW, (swD sMgiq dI brkiq nwl mn ivc) sdw Awqmk AwnMd bixAw rhy, qy, myrw mn igAwn dy surmy nwl (Awpxy Awp ƒ) pivq® kr ley [4[[/gurbani] ********** According to Gurbani, that place that Guru Sahib blesses becomes sacred. Please refer to the following Chhant of Siri Guru Raamdas jee Maharaaj: Jithay Jay Bahai mera Satguru, So thaan Suhaava Raam Rajay|| (That place where Guru stays becomes sacred) Gursikhee So thaan bhaaliya, lai dhoor much laava|| (Gursikhs find that place and place the dust of that place on their foreheads) Gursikhaa kee ghaal thaaye payee, jin Har naam dhiyaava (This hard work of finding Guru Sahib’s Gur-asthaan brings good results, provided they also japp Naam) ************ Did Satguru Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji bathe in the sarovar of Amritsar? ***** The above pankiti clearly says that it is the duty of Gursikhs to find places where Guru Sahib stayed or built himself. Those places where Guru Sahib has sat on and did Kautak, are blessed places. ***** True, never said you shouldn't go and have a look and experience, but at the same time - it also implies that you don't have to, as the Gurus then, are exactly the same as the Guru Now, so to do to that "asthan" where Guru ji is sitting - you need to go no further than Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib! I agree that the palces the Guru's visited and the historical Gurdwaras are definetly rich of spirituality for having Gurbani Sung for soo long - no doubt - but there isn't any compulsion in it, and I have not denied the importance of goign to historical Gurdwars, whether Anandpur Sahib or Hazoor Sahib, I am questioning the spiritual importance of bathing at sarovars. ********* You write that the purpose of sarovars was to clean the physical body but if you read instructions at Sarovars, they stop you from using soap to clean your body. It is recommended that you clean your body before going for Sarovar Ishnaan. What was the need for 5 sarovars in the vicinity of Amritsar Sahib? ********** I responded to this earlier on -------------- ******** LK, Why did Guru Sahib make 5 sarovars in Amritsar Sahib within close walking distance from each other? Why did he make Bibeksar Sahib and Ramsar Sahib right across the street from each other? There must have been a reason? So that everyone could have equal opportunity to bathe perhaps? ******** Perhaps, Guru ji wasn't ignorant, he's Abhull, all knowin. Practicle issues- you don't need to walk from the sarovar to Darbar Shaib before your forhead is full of sweat. He wasn't ignorant that one day Darbar Sahib is going to be FULL of sangat wishing to meet Guru Ji (like on his Gurpurabh, when Guru Ji himself pulled the arm of over 2 million Sangta to come and have his Darshan) Be practicle can 2 million Sangta bathe in one sarovar? ----------- ********************** Why can’t the water of Sarovar be sacred? Guru Sahib blessed the sarovars with his Charan-chhoh and for so many hundred years there has been Gurbani kirtan going on in Darbar Sahib? You think Gurbani makes no affect on the surroundings? What is it that makes water amrit during Amrit Sinchaar? What else but paath of Gurbani? Water definitely has the ability to retain spiritual power of Gurbani and it is definitely beneficial to drink water at sarovars. Kulbir Singh **************** Ofcourse Gurbani makes effect on surrounding - exactly why we shouldn't need to bathe - the AIR the Hava, the wholr atmosphere there is full of spirituality, so what makes it essential to do Sarovar Ishnan, if it effects the whole environment, or does this only refer to water? If water has the ability of retaining Spiritual power of Gubani, then doesn't the air have that? Some brothers have quoted the Ardas about Amritsar Ishnan - [gurbani]mÚ 4 ] gur siqgur kw jo isKu AKwey su Blky auiT hir nwmu iDAwvY ] audmu kry Blky prBwqI iesnwnu kry AMimRq sir nwvY ] aupdyis gurU hir hir jpu jwpY siB iklivK pwp doK lih jwvY ] iPir cVY idvsu gurbwxI gwvY bhidAw auTidAw hir nwmu iDAwvY ] jo swis igrwis iDAwey myrw hir hir so gurisKu gurU min BwvY ] ijs no dieAwlu hovY myrw suAwmI iqsu gurisK gurU aupdysu suxwvY ] jnu nwnku DUiV mMgY iqsu gurisK kI jo Awip jpY Avrh nwmu jpwvY ]2] [/gurbani] The place was not known as Amritsar back in Guru Ramdas Ji's time - what is Guru Ramdas ji then refering to here? Prof Saahib Singh - [gurbani]jo mnu`K siqgurU dw (s`cw) is`K AKvWdw hY (Bwv, ijs ƒ lok s`cw is`K AwKdy hn) auh roz svyry au~T ky hir-nwm dw ismrn krdw hY, hr roz svyry au~dm krdw hY, ieSnwn krdw hY (qy iPr nwm-rUp) AMimRq dy srovr ivc tu`BI lwauNdw hY, siqgurU dy aupdyS duAwrw pRBU dy nwm dw jwp jpdw hY qy (ies qrHW) aus dy swry pwp-ivkwr lih jWdy hn; iPr idn cVHy siqgurU dI bwxI dw kIrqn krdw hY qy (idhwVI) bihMidAW au~TidAW (Bwv, kwr-ikrq kridAW) pRBU dw nwm ismrdw hY [ siqgurU dy mn ivc auh is`K cMgw l`gdw hY jo ipAwry pRBU nMU hr dm Xwd krdw hY [[/gurbani] Let's stop interpreting Gurbani to what fits ourselves On a side note, Gyani Ji, did you go and visit "Guru Ki Kanshi" (as i believe it is called), at Mehta and see the place wher your father used to learn Santheya from? Hope you enjoyed your time in Panjabi Bhull Chukk Di Khima Bakhsni Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

A Kaur (London) · 29 Nov 2005

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear Gyani Ji.... Welcome back and your writings are so inspiring and detailed that I can imagine the surroundings too! Please can you post some pics too... Oh yes, and please tell more stories! Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Bhopinder Singh · 29 Nov 2005

LionKing I never called Amrit, i.e Khande Battey di Pahul Bahmanvad - you seem to imply it is. _________________________________________________________ what stops you from saying it so,ask yourself. why do all khalsa panth do ardas of darshan ishnan of A mritsar sahib? why did the mughals persecuting sikhs always surrounded sarover and still the sikhs risked their lives to take bath.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

...... · 29 Nov 2005

lionking is serving his masters well. rss and kala afgana must be very pleased with him.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 29 Nov 2005

Author: Bhopinder Singh Date: 11-29-05 04:43 LionKing I never called Amrit, i.e Khande Battey di Pahul Bahmanvad - you seem to imply it is. _________________________________________________________ what stops you from saying it so,ask yourself. why do all khalsa panth do ardas of darshan ishnan of A mritsar sahib? why did the mughals persecuting sikhs always surrounded sarover and still the sikhs risked their lives to take bath. *************************** Did you even read my last post about Amritsar Ishnan? Please reread it cause I posted an entire Shabad just on that theme Why do all Khalsa Panth do Ardas of Darshan Isnan of Amritsar Sahib - as showed in above Shabad "Amritsar nava" - Shabad by forth Guru - shows tha its' not the sarovar in Amritsar they are talking about - they are talking about a completly different Sarovar. Read my previous post pelase. Why Sikhs surrounded Sarovar and risked thie lives to bathe? to my humble understandng it's to get rid of the Mughal's thought that they had eliminated the Sikhs.... Time and Tiema gain the rulers thought - "hoon apa ehna nu Hara ditta- mar ditta Sikhsa nu - Mar gey sar" just to proe them wrong, you can read in Sakhis that Singhs woudl appear from nowhere, not just in Amritsar, but at other places to to show that they are very much alive, and will kick them back whenever circumstances allows them.... ******** Author: ...... Date: 11-29-05 13:49 lionking is serving his masters well. rss and kala afgana must be very pleased with him. ********* If my master is RSS nd Kala Afghana, then Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the biggest Kala Afghana and RSS agent, who himself wrote the above Shabads. Like prof Darshan Singh Ji once Said (I am nothing compared to him btw - I am not in any way comparing myself to him...) - if doing Katha & Kirtan makes him a terrorist (like GOI acused him of being, and eventually tortured him in jail) then Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is the biggest terrorist! I have simply quoted Shabads where Guru Ji Himself denies the importance of Teerath - if that makes me GOI then so be it. What a double standard we have - call ourself Guru Ke Sikh, Par apaa Gal ni Mani - "Mai Na Mano" - Guru ji explicitly says that real Teerath is naam - now discuss this with him. Mai Hor Thao Nahi jis Peh Karo Benanti Mera Dukh Sukh Tujh hi Paas. [gurbani]gur ibnu Goru AMDwru gurU ibnu smJ n AwvY ][/gurbani] Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki fateh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 29 Nov 2005

Also, you forgot to add that I'm a VHP agent ISI and RAW, Narkhdhari and Aushutosh's chela Need more suggestions? Let me know, I'll dig some more for you :)

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

NS · 30 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Bhai Jarnail Singh Jeeo, Many Thanks for answering my stupid question, apologies for asking it was to put at rest some of the people who post here saying you need to do this and that which is just not practical. However relating back to this post which is discussing wheter the Guru Teerths are the same as Hindu Teerths, LK makes excellent comments as well as Kulbir Jee and Bhai Jarnail Jee. I have to admit that regardless of the comments made by LK Jee, deep down there is a feeling that Guru Sahib Ji did indeed construct these Darbars for all of humanity. It's not uncommon who ever met Guru Ji, touched Guru Ji, looked into the eyes of Guru Ji ...was melted and was a different person afterwards. Guru Ji constructed these darbars with their own hands, and Sikhs in history when the Darbar Sahib was surrounded would gallop through the enemy and through the sarvor with the horse not caring for their lives , just for darshan ishnaaan of Amritsar. A lot of Sikhs were killed in this way.Why would we not be blessed by having Ishnaan at Darbar Sahib ? However if you look at the other side of the coin Guru Gobind Singh Jee never wanted a Gurudwara construced in his name and there is a mention of Guru Ji that who ever constructs it will not have naam or nishaan left of them on this earth. Maharaja Ranjit Singh laughed at this and on the contrary ensured construction of Hazoor Sahib which is present today.Where does it leave us.....confused only, well I am anyway. Giani Gurbachan Singh Ji Gulshan has done excellent vakyaia of Ardaas , I would urge people to listen to it, he makes excellent references to every single point in the ardaas as well as "Amritsar Ji ke Darsha Ishnaan". The scholars who constructed the Akal Takht rehat maryada and the ardaas didn't just dream of it overnight , it took years. Before we jump to any conclusions we need further deep thought process on this topic.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Niranjan Singh · 30 Nov 2005

LK, take some time and listen to Bhai Pinderpal Singh ji's katha on Ishnan at Amritsar Sahib. Ardas Vol. 65: Amritsar Ji Ke Ishnan 1 1h:32m:31s [url]http://media.waheguroo.com/Other/Katha/Bhai_Pinderpal_Singh_Jee/Ardas/Ardas%20-%20Bhai%20Pinderpal%20Singh%20-%20Vol%2065%20%28Amritsar%20Ji%20Ke%20Ishnan-1%29%20060804.mp3[/url] Ardas Vol. 66: Amritsar Ji Ke Ishnan 2 1h:27m:05s [url]http://media.waheguroo.com/Other/Katha/Bhai_Pinderpal_Singh_Jee/Ardas/Ardas%20-%20Bhai%20Pinderpal%20Singh%20-%20Vol%2066%20%28Amritsar%20Ji%20Ke%20Ishnan-2%29%20060904.mp3[/url] Courtesy: W!N

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 30 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. The "confusion" arises when we try to be "exclusive". What do I mean ? Simply that, GURBANI is ETERNAL and ABSOLUTE TRUTH....nothing but the TRUTH always. So when Gurbani says Teerath NAAM hai..it means EXACTLY what it says...without THE ALL IMPORTANT "NAAM" ingredient...any so called "gurdwara" "gur-teerath" etc would be woefully "INCOMPLETE". Its like baking a cake without flour...dont forget cake is cake and flour is flour..NAAM has its place and ishnaan at a Gur teerath has its own place..NAAM + Gur Teerath-Ishnaan makes for a most wonderful spiritual recipe imho, the one and only reason the "ritualistic" baths at the Hindu Teeraths are condemned in Gurbani is precisely because of the 100% EMPTY RITUALSTIC behaviour of the adherents...no Naam was japp, no attempt was made to have any religious effort, ..GURU JI went there and SAW with His own eyes the EMPTY RITUALS....not only Guur Ji, the BHAGAT SAHIBAANS also visited these teeraths and mandirs and saw the completley EMPTY rituals being performed there..and thus condemned them as USELESS. The Hindus had completely disregarded the NAAM ingredient...thats why GURU JI EMPHASISED the NAAM so much. I am the first one to agree that "ritualistic ishnaan" without any Naam/Gurbani/Rehit would do much for anyone's spiritual journey is doubtful. But then the difference with our Gur teeraths is that....The NAAM ingredient is being freely distributed at Harmandir Sahib and other Gur teeraths... so an "empty ritualistic" person going there would automatically get a dose of Naam/Gurbani whether he likes it or not...so even if one goes there "Empty inside"..it is more likely than not that one would come back a "better" person. This ASPECT is MISSING at the Hindu teeraths. I have met first hand several NON- SIKHS ( one was a group of five Chinese from my home country malaysia) who related to me the spiritual "SERENITY and PEACE" they somehow automatically got the moment they stepped into the Harmandir Sahib Grounds...none could put his or her finger on this precisely..it was just a "feeling". Like LK I too used to beleive that this is all "imagination"..but one journey and i am changed. I am sure this is the "feeling" the Sikhs of old died for....and asked for in the daily ardass....and to KILL this FEELING did the Durannis and others blow up Harmandir sahib/fill it up with salughtered cows etc..and in 1984 with the shaheed bodies of sikhs. Duranni was a supreme MILITARY GENIUS..the BEST in ASIA at his time....and only a genius can come to the conclusion that the "shaktee" of the Sikhs is emanating from the Harmandir Sahib and thats why he blew it up...and Indira came to the Very Same "conclusion" in 1984...that both failed in their mission is another story. Clearly Harmandir Sahib is something very very special...and there are ample proofs of this in our History and Ardass. The Millions of tourists and yatrees who visit there are certainly not doing it to admire the golden sheets..some maybe..but not the vast majority...but i firmly beleive each visitor is touched somehow by Guru ji's Kirpa...just as I was blessed. Thank You. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

banta · 01 Dec 2005

Rabindra Nath TAgore didnot know gurmukhi. But when he visited Harimandir Sahib he sat in trance for 7 hours continously. There is something there.

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing (LK) · 01 Dec 2005

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh Banta - I never said there wasn't anything there - the atmosphere is full of Spirituality - I'm questioning the importance of bathing in sarovar, case if Sarovar has Spiritual kamai - then so does the air. I'm fully convinced that there's something special at Darbar Sahib, no doubt about that, i'm questionign the spiritual benifits of bathing there, and it erasing your Aprad. Niranajan Singh, I have downloaded the kathas, and will be listening to them the coming few days, thank you =) ******************* So when Gurbani says Teerath NAAM hai..it means EXACTLY what it says...without THE ALL IMPORTANT "NAAM" ingredient...any so called "gurdwara" "gur-teerath" etc would be woefully "INCOMPLETE". ******************* No that is not what the Shabad says - the Shabad says go to the NAAM TEERATH. Guru Ji is saying tusi Naam de Teerath te jao. You are now making you own explaination of the Shabad. ************ Its like baking a cake without flour...dont forget cake is cake and flour is flour..NAAM has its place and ishnaan at a Gur teerath has its own place..NAAM + Gur Teerath-Ishnaan makes for a most wonderful spiritual recipe ************ So you're saying that Guru Granth Sahib Ji, Spiritual Khajana, treasure, forgot to mention the spiritual significance of Teerath? You are a typical case of humanity, contrdicting ourself... In some posts you say you keep only belief in Gurbani, and not Sakhis tha contradict Gurbani, then what makes you NOT ACCEPT WHAT GURBANI is saying - has GURBANi FORGOTTEN to mention something spiritual? If you want to learn about Spirituality it's all inside Guru Ji - unless you can say that Guru ji forgot to mention some stuff :) Don't just end it at that Gur Teerah has it's place- QUOTE FOR ME PLEASE! ******** imho, the one and only reason the "ritualistic" baths at the Hindu Teeraths are condemned in Gurbani is precisely because of the 100% EMPTY RITUALSTIC behaviour of the adherents...no Naam was japp, no attempt was made to have any religious effort, ..GURU JI went there and SAW with His own eyes the EMPTY RITUALS....not only Guur Ji, the BHAGAT SAHIBAANS also visited these teeraths and mandirs and saw the completley EMPTY rituals being performed there..and thus condemned them as USELESS. ********* Although I do agree with you in some thing, I' doing to be devils advocate and ask you- well surely if they go several hundred miles to bathe in the Ganges, they must have faith and love to do so, - JIn Prem Kiyo tin Hi Prabh Payo. If a Hindu ahs LOVE for God's creation (the Ganges, or Nile for tha matter) and bathes in the Ganges, will she/he benifit as much as a Guru.ka.Sikh bathing in Darbar Sahib Sarovar - as Kartar, Karta Purakh, Himself made the Ganges, so if they go with love, and devotion for the creation of God, and God himself - will that not benifit them? *********** am the first one to agree that "ritualistic ishnaan" without any Naam/Gurbani/Rehit would do much for anyone's spiritual journey is doubtful. But then the difference with our Gur teeraths is that....The NAAM ingredient is being freely distributed at Harmandir Sahib and other Gur teeraths... so an "empty ritualistic" person going there would automatically get a dose of Naam/Gurbani whether he likes it or not...so even if one goes there "Empty inside"..it is more likely than not that one would come back a "better" person. This ASPECT is MISSING at the Hindu teeraths. ************** Again, please quote Gurbani that Teeraths have significance, and do not misquote Gurbani to fit your own definition I will accept it, as soon as you provide me with a quote. Gur Bin Ghor Andhar Gur Bin Samaj Na Avai. Mino ni aundi Samaj hor kisi Gal di - Tusi Gurbani di Pavitar Pangti/Tukh deyo ji , te Daas man lave ga... *********************** I have met first hand several NON- SIKHS ( one was a group of five Chinese from my home country malaysia) who related to me the spiritual "SERENITY and PEACE" they somehow automatically got the moment they stepped into the Harmandir Sahib Grounds...none could put his or her finger on this precisely..it was just a "feeling". Like LK I too used to beleive that this is all "imagination"..but one journey and i am changed. I am sure this is the "feeling" the Sikhs of old died for....and asked for in the daily ardass....and to KILL this FEELING did the Durannis and others blow up Harmandir sahib/fill it up with salughtered cows etc..and in 1984 with the shaheed bodies of sikhs. Duranni was a supreme MILITARY GENIUS..the BEST in ASIA at his time....and only a genius can come to the conclusion that the "shaktee" of the Sikhs is emanating from the Harmandir Sahib and thats why he blew it up...and Indira came to the Very Same "conclusion" in 1984...that both failed in their mission is another story. Clearly Harmandir Sahib is something very very special...and there are ample proofs of this in our History and Ardass. The Millions of tourists and yatrees who visit there are certainly not doing it to admire the golden sheets..some maybe..but not the vast majority...but i firmly beleive each visitor is touched somehow by Guru ji's Kirpa...just as I was blessed. ************************* As I was saying Gyani Ji, I have no doubt whatsoever that the Gurbani recited in the complex has a spiritual effect - no doubt at all - You are right, there is an unqiue feeling/emotion that cannot be described in word, Mai tuhadey naal ethe saimat ha. BUT, I am still scepticle when it comes to Teerath ishnan, and how much of Gurmat that is. Again, Please provide me with one single holy verse from Guru Ji, without distorting the meaning, and after a thorogh reserach into the quote, if it appears that the holy quote is indeed saying that going to Gur Teeraths, will give you a spiritual benifit or erase your sins, then I have no choice but to change my opinion, but until you can provide me with a single quote, I see no reason to put sooo many quotes from Guru Ji descouraging Teeraths, aside. Niranjan Singh Ji, once again I'd liek to thank you for the links, and I will try to post my feedback to the kathas in a week or so... =) Bhull chukk maaf Karni Koi galti hogi hove ta chota bhra man ke maaf kar dena Je Gurbani di Pangti to kise no Thes Paunche, I definitly don't apologize Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Dec 2005

veer Lion King jio, Listen to Bhai Pinderpal Singh jis katha..i think he explains it all much better than me. Then we will discuss further. Thanks

Re: Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji

LionKing · 02 Dec 2005

Dear Gyani Ji, I will be copying the files to my protable player, and listening to it during the week (coming week), so it might take a little while. Please accept my apology that it will take so long, and please bear with me. BHai Pinderpal Singh ji, is a parcharac, I have yet to disagree with. I recommend eveyrone to download his "Guru Granth Sahib JI Boldey hun" from www.gurmatveechar.com Thanks for the links once agian, and pelase bear with me =) Bhull chukk Maaf Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh