Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhagat

Bhagat

Kulbir Singh · 17 Apr 2003

One day Guru Sahib - Guru Gobind Singh jee asked sangat who the king was during the time of Bhagat Kabir jee. One Sikh said that the king was Humayun. Another Sikh got up and said that the king was in fact Babur. Another Sikh suggested that the king during the time of Bhagat Kabir jee was Sikandar Lodhi. Many other guesses were made. All this time Guru Sahib kept smiling and did not approve of any name. In the end, Guru Sahib said that the purpose of his question was to tell that the bhagat (devotee of Vaheguru) is greater than any other person in the world. He said that this is a perfect example that all of the sangat knows about Bhagat Kabir jee but no one remembers who the king was during the time of Bhagat jee. This proves that bhagats are remembered positively for ages in this world and the next world while the kings are often not remembered positively and mostly they are lost in the pages of history. For this reason, O mere manaa (mind, dil), Naam japp lai. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhagat

Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 22 Jun 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. IMHO Veer Ji Kulbir Singh Ji is 100% correct. An interesting side line to the above. We normally hear people telling us that Bhagat Dhanna Ji was a Jatt and being uneducated "peasant" jatt he was given a stone by a Brahmin to worship......and due to his intense bhagtee of the stone Bhagat ji GOT WAHEGURU TO APPEAR. This is a very interesting story.....BUT PURE UNADULTERATED FICTION . Read Guru Arjun Sahib Jee's Shabad......Dhanna Wadbhaga Pg 488 GURU JI gives Personal Evidence on HOW ALL the Bhagats...Poor Jolaha kabir, Peniless Chamar Ravidass, Ignorant jatt Dhanna, Butcher Sain etc etc ALL RECEIVED WAHEGURU and Became FAMOUS the World OVER by BHAGTEE.........when Dhanna HEARD of all these peniless men becoming World Class Bhagats through BHAGTEE....... then Dhanna the wothless jatt also GOT down to doing BHAGTEE and GOT WAHEGURU......... Guru JI LISTS ALL the Bhagats before Dhanna and then goes on to say dhanna followed suit..... So the Story of dhanna Ji getting God out os a Stone is FALSE This is also clear as Guru Ji in GURBANI openly CONDEMNS idols and idol worshippers..... so how could Dhanna Ji get God through a stone and then FIND a place in Gurbani. This is proof that in Guru Ji's time this False story was already making its rounds and GURU Ji had to Write this SHABAD to CLEAR any DOUBTS.

Re: Bhagat

((((:-) · 23 Jun 2003

Vaahegurroo Jee Kaa Khaalsaa Vaahegurroo Jee Kee Fatehh!! on the topic of Bhagat Dhanna Jee, theres a really awesome keertan tape of Mohinder Singh (SDO) in which he starts out with the shabad: "Gobind Gobind Gobind Sang Naam Deyo Man Leenaa" and then he stops and explains the whole story and clarifies it all up that Bhagat Dhanna Jee did NOT recieve muktee by doing pooja to a rock. he explains it REALLLLY well. its really amazing when u listen to it. he also used one of Bhai Gurdaas Jee's Vaars (cant remember which at the moment) to help clarify it up. its good stuff. Vaahegurroo Jee Kaa Khaalsaa Vaahegurroo Jee Kee Fatehh!!

Re: Bhagat

Tarsem Singh · 23 Jun 2003

Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa! Vaheguru Jee Kee Fatheh!! Please view Pauree from Vaar 10 of Bhai Gurdaas Jees Vaars at http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=5771 Bhagat Dhanaa Jee did get Darshan through his Pyaar for Vaheguru even if on the surface it appeared as though he was worshipping a stone. His innoncence (bholaa) was pure and was in no way a violation of Gurmat. Mohinder Singh SDO says a lot of things - he will also have said that the Vaars are not the key to Gurbani - which proves you can ignore the majority of what he says anyway.... baamhun poojai dhaevuthae dhhu(n)naa goo churaavun aavai|| dhhu(n)nai ddit(h)aa chalith eaeh pushhai baamhun aakh sunaavai|| t(h)aakur dhee saevaa kurae jo eishhae soee ful paavai|| dhhu(n)naa kurudhaa jodhurree mai bh dhaeh eik jo thudhh bhaavai|| puuthhur eik lupaett kur dhae dhhu(n)nae no gail shhuddaavai|| t(h)aakur no nhaavaalukae shhaahi rottee lai bhog churrhaavai|| huthh jorr mi(n)nuth kurae pairee pai pai buhuth munaavai|| ho bee moo(n)h n jut(h)aalusaa(n) thoo(n) rut(h)aa mai kihu n sukhaavai|| gosee puruthuukh hoe rottee khaae shhaahi muhi laavai|| bholaa bhaao govi(n)dh milaavai ||uu|| A brahman would worship gods (in the form of stone idols) where Dhanna used to graze his cow. On seeing his worship, Dhanna asked the brahman what he was doing. “Service to the Thakur (God) gives the desired fruit,” replied the brahman. Dhanna requested, “O brahman, if you agree kindly give one to me.” The brahman rolled a stone, gave it to Dhanna and thus got rid of him. Dhanna bathed the Thakur and offered him bread and buttermilk. With folded hands and falling at the feet of the stone he begged for his service to be accepted. Dhanna said, “I will also not eat because how can I be happy if you are annoyed.” (Seeing his true and loving devotion) God was forced to appear and eat his bread and buttermilk. In fact, innocence like that of Dhanna makes the sight of the Lord available. Fatheh jee

Re: Bhagat

r2d2 · 23 Jun 2003

"Mohinder Singh SDO says a lot of things - he will also have said that the Vaars are not the key to Gurbani - which proves you can ignore the majority of what he says anyway...." Mohinder Singh SDO used to be a respected member of Jatha at one point and did his fair share of seva around this globe. It is true that for a long time he was preaching his own manmatt but he has gone back to Akaal Takhat and has asked and recieved forgiveness. If you do not like the messenger that should not mean that you should ignore the message. I still listen to old tapes of SDO and they are (IMHO) still amazing. Perhaps we should worry about our own faults and mistakes rather than boost our ego by pointing out others' faults and mistakes. Fateh.

Re: Bhagat

Kulbir Singh · 23 Jun 2003

>>>> If you do not like the messenger that should not mean that you should ignore the message. I still listen to old tapes of SDO and they are (IMHO) still amazing. Perhaps we should worry about our own faults and mistakes rather than boost our ego by pointing out others' faults and mistakes. >>>>> Dear rdd2, it is true that we should worry about our own faults and mistakes but when we know that a person has harmed the whole of panth, then someone has to take up the cause. SDO’s credibility is very badly damaged. Anything from him does not seem good. If anything panthik does come from him, that too is to lure more innocents to his cult. I hear that his site that preaches his damaging propaganda is still running. Please confirm. How about all those cassettes that he recorded? They are going to stay in circulation forever and will do dirty parchaar forever. As for old tapes of SDO, there are some good ones but most of them are bhangra type tunes that he introduced in akj. To this date those bhangra type and dhaadee type tunes that he introduced, are being sung by our akj kirtaniye. He has permanently damaged akj and he is one of the main persons who has introduced dhuni in kirtan. Before his kirtan became popular, dhuni was not that popular in jatha. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bhagat

Mkhalsa · 24 Jun 2003

>>>>>>I hear that his site that preaches his damaging propaganda is still running. Please confirm.<<<<<<<< Yes it is still up.

Re: Bhagat

Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 24 Jun 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa waheguru Ji Ki fateh. When it comes to GURU ji's WORD against anyone else...no matter who..even Bhai Gurdass ( His Varaan could be adulterated too !) then MY Dhara is with GURU JI. GURU ARJUN DEV JI SAHIB very clearly says that Dhanna Ji, the ignorant Jatt BEGAN to DO BHAGTEE and FOLLOW the path of GOD when HE HEARD HOW the other Bhagats got where they were........ No mention of any stones, not eating etc etc...... IDOL worship ?? If we even begin to believ that Dhanna "got " something out of an idol.....then how are we going to reconsile with Gurbani where it says.....One stone is Worshipped...another similar stone is FOOT STOOL.. Secondly if a "mandir" going so called sikh then tells you if Dhanna ( ji) can get God out of a stone, why cant he go to the mandir. We have plenty of these type of sikhs in Malaysia who visit hindu mandirs......and if Dhanna Ji can get what he wanted from a brahmin given stone then surely these sikhs can get what they want in the mandir too ?? NO NO NO. Gurbani is clear, unequivocal and TRUTH... 100% TRUTH. GOD can ONLY be won over by LOVE and Bhagtee, Naam and Simran.....not by sitting in front of a stone ( innocen tor not) . If that had been the case GURU JI would vertainly have reciorded it in Guru Granth Sahib Jee....BUT there is NOT a single such record anywhere., in the 1430 pages.

Re: Bhagat

Tarsem Singh · 25 Jun 2003

Pyario Veer Jee, What do you make of the following from Dhan Dhan Sree Guru Granth Sahib Jee nimuth naamudhaeo dhoodhh peeaaeiaa || Because of Naam Dayv's devotion, the Lord drank the milk he offered. Bhagat Ravi Daas Ji Raag Aasaa Pannaa 487 And the following from Bhagat Naamdev Jee Himself This Shabad is by Bhagat Naam Dev Ji in Raag Bhairao on Pannaa 1163 dhoodhh kuttorai gudduvai paanee || kupul gaae naamai dhuhi aanee ||1|| dhoodhh peeo gobi(n)dhae raae || dhoodhh peeo maero mun putheeaae || naahee th ghur ko baap risaae ||1|| rehaao || suoein kuttoree a(n)mrith bhuree || lai naamai har aagai dhhuree ||2|| eaek bhuguth maerae hirudhae busai || naamae dhaekh nuraaein husai ||3|| dhoodhh peeaae bhuguth ghar gaeiaa || naamae har kaa dhurusun bhaeiaa ||4||3|| Naam Dayv milked the brown cow, and brought a cup of milk and a jug of water to his family god. ||1|| "Please drink this milk, O my Sovereign Lord God. Drink this milk and my mind will be happy. Otherwise, my father will be angry with me.""||1||Pause|| Taking the golden cup, Naam Dayv filled it with the ambrosial milk, and placed it before the Lord. ||2|| The Lord looked upon Naam Dayv and smiled. ""This one devotee abides within my heart.""||3|| The Lord drank the milk, and the devotee returned home. Thus did Naam Dayv come to receive the Blessed Vision of the Lord's Darshan. ||4||3|| This can only be regarded as idol worship too then. OF COURSE IT IS NOT. It is innocence and devotional love. Bhai Gurdaas Jee has given an accurate account of this too Bhai Gurdaas in Vaar 10 kaum kithae pio chaliaa naamudhaev no aakh sidhhaayaa|| t(h)aakur dhee saevaa kuree dhudhh peeaavun kehi sumujhaayaa|| naamudhaeo eishunaan kur kupul gaae dhuhikai lai aayaa|| t(h)aakur no nhaavaalukai churunodhuk lai thiluk churrhaayaa|| huthh jorr binuthee kurae dhudhh peeahu jee gobi(n)dh raayaa|| nihucho kur aaraadhhiaa hoe dhuyaal dhurus dhikhulaayaa|| bhuree kuttoree naamudhaev lai t(h)aakur no dhudhh peeaayaa|| gaae muee jeevaaleeoun naamudhaeo dhaa shhupur shhaayaa|| faer dhaehuraa ruakhioun chaar vurun lai pairee paayaa|| bhuguth junaa(n) dhaa kurai kuraayaa ||uu|| Namdev's father was called to do some work so he called Naamdev. He told Namdev to serve Thakur, the Lord, with milk. After taking bath Namdev brought the milk of black-teat cow. Having bathed the Thakur, he put the water used to wash the Thakur, on his own head. Now with folded hands he requested the Lord to have milk. Becoming steadfast in his thoughts when he prayed, the Lord appeared before him in person. Namdev made Lord drink the full bowl of milk. On another occasion God brought a dead cow to life and also thatched the hut of Namdev. On yet another occasion, God rotated the temple (after Naamdev was not allowed entrance) and made all the four castes (varnas) bow at the feet of Namdev. The Lord accomplishes whatever is done and desired by saints. Bhagat Dhannaa Jee and Bhagat Naamdev Jee were identical in terms of the way they applied their innocence and love. By seeing what the Bhagats did I feel ashamed (thinking I have Sikhi) and have learned something from this debate. Bhai Gurdaas Jee was a Pooran Brahmgianee and his Vaars are the key to understanding Gurmat. Anyone who states any different is a Panth daa dhokhee and should be shunned for trying to bring shankaa into the Panth. The only Pauree I thought there was skankaa about was the one about the 4 Jughs and Vaheguru Manthar. As for Mohinder Singh SDO's keertan was never amazing. Daas would class him as a competent Keertanee (in my humble opinion!!) because he could put relevant parmaans to give understanding etc (with all due respect). His tunes were majority Kan Rass ones. But Keertanees like Chattar Singh, Zakhmee Brothers etc have been doing that for a long time so it is nothing new. Amazing Keertan can be learned about by reading books like Ranglay Sajjan where Jaagdhee Joths can awaken even the most stubborn. Fatheh jee Sorry if I have offended any premees of SDO

Re: Bhagat

r2d2 · 26 Jun 2003

"Weekly keertan programs were being held under the organization of Prof. Beant Singh jee and I encouraged Bhai Raghbeer Singh to attend these smaagams. I had with me a tape player and every day for a month, we would listen to tapes of Bhai Mohinder Singh SDO, Bhai Joginder Singh Talvara and some other Bibis. Some other Singhs would also come to listen, because Poona has many good Singhs. Bhai Raghbeer Singh was struck by the sweet arrows of baanee and keertan, and as a result, he memorised his nitnem banees and began keeping the five kakaars. One day he made a request before me: "The Singhs who's voices you play on the tape player everyday, please let me meet them in person and please have the punj pyaaray bless me with the gift of amrit-naam." From the Tapoban Site.. Apparently SDO's kirtan had an effect on a Shaheed of the Panth. Does this mean Tapoban administrators plan to take down that passage or are they willing to admit that SDO's kirtan was more than just "bhangra tunes" that damaged AKJ kirtan? Or perhaps we can simply admit that SDO KNEW how to evoke a response during his kirtan back in the day. And for clarification, I'm not a "premee" of SDO. I simply can admit that, although I do not approve of his current actions, that he was at one point an excellent Sikh and Kirtanee who's seva probably inflluence alot of people... ...I have a feeling that if SDO was still part of Jatha at this stage that we would STILL be applauding him and wouldn't be criticizing his "bhangra" tunes. Just MY humble opinion.. :)

Re: Bhagat

Sukhdev Singh · 26 Jun 2003

VahegurooJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurooJeeKeeFateh r2d2 wrote >> Apparently SDO's kirtan had an effect on a Shaheed of the Panth. I think this conclusion is incorrect as first of all you are relying on 3rd party source, who could be open to different interpretation of what actually occurred. Secondly I think the source is mentioning names not Bhai Sahib (Even then I think he was only trying to generalise that Bhai Sahib liked Jatha Keertan of which there were many Keertanees some of which the source does not mention). Thirdly even if Bhai Sahib listened to a tape of SDO it might be the odd one in the period of the 60’s, which might not contain these Bhangra tunes. So therefore it would be wrong to conclude that Bhai Sahib was influenced by a SDO Bhangra tune tape. However I think r2d2 has done this innocently. Bhula Chucka Dee Maaf VahegurooJeeKaaKhalsa VahegurooJeeKeeFateh