Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh pupils being served halal meat

Sikh pupils being served halal meat

uk singh · 04 Nov 2005

Sikh pupils being served halal meat 03 November 2005 HALAL meat is being fed to schoolchildren, even though many are forbidden from eating it. Initial Catering Services, the borough's largest contractor, has not told schools that new menus use halal meat, causing alarm for Sikh families whose religion forbids them from eating it. Schools in south Ilford with a high concentration of Muslim pupils request certified halal products, but it has emerged that the same meat is being served to schools across the borough. Harmander Singh, of Wellesley Road, Ilford, and who is chairman of Sikhs in England, said: "Sikhs are forbidden to eat halal and kosher, not because they are against those religions' ways of preparing food but they are only allowed to eat meat from animals that have not suffered." FOR FULL STORY SEE THIS WEEK'S RECORDER http://www.ilfordrecorder.co.uk/content/redbridge/recorder/news/story.aspx?brand=RECOnline&category=newsIlford&tBrand=northlondon24&tCategory=newsilford&itemid=WeED03%20Nov%202005%2009%3A54%3A43%3A733

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

khalistani · 04 Nov 2005

halaal is a bujjar kureight a sikh can NEEVER eat that skols shud chnge this straight away bhula chuka maf

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

Singh · 04 Nov 2005

How about not eating meat at ALL!

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

..... · 04 Nov 2005

so what's happening now?

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

... · 05 Nov 2005

Yeah if they had no meat at all, the confusion wouldnt arise!

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

TRUE facts -q(3` · 05 Nov 2005

A few more mails have come through from a friend of mine ...who lives within this area .. I concur with ASKhalsa ji.I have a few horendous stories about these pardhaans and other members.Recently, after I made some complaints about the Punjabi teaching standard, I found out that there was no body who oversaw the claess apart from the teachers.For the number of years these classes have been running NOT A SINGLE ocassion can be recorded where the children hav ebeen encouraaged to prepare an exhibition of the theme ..eg Gurpurab etc.NOT A SINGLE. It was suggested to me,that I take over as the present committee member with responsibilty runs a shop and has never been around to check the quality of teaching and the teachers participation in the classes. I said I will --on one conndition, THAT NO BODY else will interfere and I will expect accountabilty from teachers and also reserve the right to seek the sacking off anyone of the three teachers should they be found not to be adherring to a recognise standard-standards that I will seek to set from more efficiently run Punjabi schools. The pardhan looked at me and went silent.The secretary said we will do that ...and THAT IS THE LAST I have heard from them.I have now found out as well that some of the teachers are appointed NOT because of their ability to teach ...but because they are related to the pardhan or some other committee member!!!!! Some of the other issues , I have discussed with you personally Harmander Singh Ji the other day on the phone...- issues that affect the Gurduaras and the attitude of the pardhaans to these issues and the need for them to understand them ! I would not be surprised the exitement of the member to be able to walk into a police station !!!! IT IS NIL> In a message dated 11/4/2005 4:46:49 PM GMT Standard Time, [address removed] writes: Dear Harmander Singh,Ji, We need to discard the reliance on the major Gurduaras within this borough to advocate, represent, support and voice any Sikh issue which go wider than the Gurduara walls, and the gurduara electionsk, except for the inaptly named Guru Arjan Dev Shaidi tournament. Apart, from the issue of the school meals prepared against the Sikh teachings, there is another issue of meals provided in the hospitals and The Wheels on meal service, for the aged.Again there is provision for Kosher and halal meals, both of which are against the Sikh ethical code of preparing a meat meal. In 1997,a halal meal was offered to my father in law, and told that is all there was.He was on a visit from Malaysia and taken ill very suddenly.Fortunately, I arrived at that moment, and at once took to task the ward manager, the Senior Manager of Nursing and the catering manager.Within 45 minutes, not only he was offered an alternative meal, but arrangments made to ensure halal meal was never offered to him again ever. However, one of the defensive reactions and an example quoted to me by the catering manager was ,there were two other Sikh patients on the ward, who often happily accept a halal meat.Fortunately, I was able to cut that argument down because they were both MONE, and hence had already compromised their own principles, and were NOT practising Sikh like my father in law.With my eperience and knowledge of the NHS If enough pressure and presence is asserted I can assure you the NHS will move to provide meals that do not compromise Sikh code. Diversity play a major role in the NHS provison now. Initial Catering has a major contract with the NHS, and have to adhere to many many policies and it would make no difference if they have to adhere to another one, to cater for sikh needs.The patients needs come first.But sikhs need to assert their presence and needs. There is another issue that I beleive needs addressing within the borough,Again I can only speak from one experience of my own daughter.Last year she was asked to remove her kara during PE lessons.She took the issue up with her teacher, but the teacher tried to shot ride over, using her position,then I took the issue up with the head mistress at once, and after initial excuse of H&S the school agreed that she will NOT be asked to take it off, as long as she covered it with a hand band for the duration of any physical excercise, which was my suggestion.I accepted. But lately my daughter has been telling me that she has noticed some other Sikh children often quite willingly take the karas off.My daughter is quite upset with that , she made an issue in the hope other Sikh children will follow , but feels let down. I also understand from my 10 year son, the same applied in his school.But he took himself to explain to the PE teacher , and they both agreed he will use a hand band to cover and support his wrist and the kara during the PE lesson.This has not been an issue since.I am proud that for a ten year old he successfully resolved his own issue. He has also never been asked to take it off during football matches as he is on the school football team for juniors in Redbridge. I beleive the Sikh community needs very badly to come together breaking down the barriers of all local sikh political divide and address these issues for once and all within all Redbridge schools. I will be more than willing to support the lead in this issue.I think the days are past, when Sikhs address individual cases and settle, to fnd the same arises elswhere yet again. Sikhs in Redbbridge form at the minimum at least 4-5 % of the population,I beleive,if not more; we must address this issues collectivly. Gurcharan Singh Kulim Redbridge Borough

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

?? · 05 Nov 2005

Author: Singh Date: 11-04-05 14:09 How about not eating meat at ALL! Singh ji this is not the answer. If u don't eat meat it doesn't mean that every sikh don't eat meat. We must raise our concern with the relevant authorties. Be realistc 50% sikh eat meat. I don't want to get into this debate. We must do something. [%sig%]

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

Gurcharan Singh · 05 Nov 2005

Author: Singh Date: 11-04-05 14:09 How about not eating meat at ALL! Singh ji this is not the answer. If u don't eat meat it doesn't mean that every sikh don't eat meat. We must raise our concern with the relevant authorties. Be realistc 50% sikh eat meat. I don't want to get into this debate. We must do something. -------------------------------------------------------------------- Sir, what exactly is the answer?i dont see any thing wrong put up by the two psost from true facts ..taht should be an issue, except that the writer has opened it up wider a little to say how the Sikhs are being left OUT of their say, and all youare trying to say just dont eat meat!!!That is NOT the answer either sir, that is apersonal opinion. It is not an issue of eating meat or not, it is an issue that concerns Sikhs and their rights.We are not speaking for the rights of meat eating of grass eating Sikhs .We are speaking of terights of Sikhs NOT to eat halal food.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

/\ · 05 Nov 2005

Not eating meat at all is indeed the answer. Non-halal meat isn't "jhatka" either. Not that "jhatka" would be acceptable either. At any rate, meat is not acceptable food for a Sikh.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

erm · 05 Nov 2005

halal is an excuse for sikhs to eat meat ive read many rehit name which say - dont sleep with a MUSLIM WOMAN. sleeping with a muslim is bujjar kurehit in reality sleeping with anyone other then your sikh husband/wife is a bujjar kurehit certain groups of sikhs like these rehit name cause it means they can sleep with all women except muslims. same with meat, eating meat is bujjar krehit regardless of how its killed. but rehit name say dont eat meat killed in MUSLIM MANNER, this allows people to eat meat which isnt halal. these false rehit name are all false, corrupted documents which people have made to support/justify their false actions. what makes halal worse then chatka? ive seen conditions animals are left in prior to chopping their heads in one blow (chatka) and their suffering is worse then some animals who are killed in muslim fashion. there are videos of nhangs chopping off bukra's head, they tie the legs, rope round neck and back legs, you should see the stress and emotion on the poor goats face. and only after 3 attempts did the head come off, first 2 brutally injured animal but didnt kill. i would say both methods of killing are equally bad, both situations animal goes into shock and actually doesnt feel much pain, it is the mental stress of the animal which is upsetting.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

JB · 05 Nov 2005

"/ ": thas ur opinion. if an animal is killed free of pain, with one single blow, its chatka... to the author of the thread: cant the kids survive one meal time without meat?? take a packed lunch if they cant... lol.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

shaddy · 05 Nov 2005

my dog woudnt eat halal meat.i take him to rockys. an there feeding sikh kids it at school how discusting

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

umm · 05 Nov 2005

it not just east london. most london schools serve it but dinner ladies dont know.. or they just dont telll u

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

shaddy · 05 Nov 2005

the only schools that serve this rubbish are the ones with a high concentration of pakistani kids in it. other wise normal english schools just serve proper meat weather the muslims like it or not this is london england not halalistan if the pakistanis dont like to live an eat like the rest they should go back home.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

** · 06 Nov 2005

sikhs cant eat meat full stop so whats the problem shouldnt be eating it whether it halal or not?

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

ksingh · 06 Nov 2005

wjkk wjkf akal takhat has the final authority over controversial issues and it had already issued hukamnama that sikhs can eat meat if it is not halaal meat. if you don't have any respect for akal takhat then go ahead and propagate your type of sikhi

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

Singh · 06 Nov 2005

Is there a Hukamnama from the Gurus that says we have to follow everything the Akal Takht say? Who started the practise of having a "Jathedar" of the Akal Takht? Which historical documents point towards this? I am not question the Akal Takht I am just curious as to why people always fall back on the "you can't go against the Akal Takht" rule when the Jathedar and ruling body of Sikhs are clearly corrupt or at best not Gurmat orientated.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

/\ · 06 Nov 2005

Akal Takhat Jathedar in 1982 issued a hukumnama saying Sikhs who eat meat can't aren't to be excommunicated. Guru Hargobind Sahib, the founder of Akal Takhat Sahib, issued 3 or 4 hukumnamas saying "Maas machee day naray nahee jaanaa" ie. not to even go near meat or fish. Which hukumnama do you figure Sikhs should follow?

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

ksingh · 06 Nov 2005

wjkk wjkf is the hukamnama from guru hargobind ji proven genuine.if it is proven genuine then why akal takhat issued a hukamnama that sikhs can eat meat. the sikh scholars at akal takhat must had checked all the historical material. we are not sikh scholars.akal takhat has the final authority over controvercial issues.if you don't want to beleive in the decision of akal takhat then sikhi is very much divided now

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

Gurcharan Singh · 06 Nov 2005

Author: ** Date: 11-06-05 10:21 sikhs cant eat meat full stop so whats the problem shouldnt be eating it whether it halal or not? Sikhs can eat meat prepared as Jhatka .FULL stop. I think this Forum is biased and does not allow post they feelthretens their view.Some of my post exposing writers like above has been banned. THe PROBLEM IS people like you are MISREPRESENTING the Sikh way of Life and GURBANI. vegetarian is a hindu ritual.These are hindus misqouting Gurbani to prove their hindu points. There is NO such thing as three or four Hukamnamas issued by Guru Hargobind Ji...that say such.This person is misusing the actual qoutes from GURBANI. ONLY TWO HUKAMNAMAS were issued by Gur Hragobind sahib ji not "three or or four"as alleged by this deviant writer.NONE of this relates to eating meat.In fact Guru Hargobind sahib used to go hunting!However Bhai ashok in his book claims there were three Nisaans from Guru Hargobind and three Hukamanas.The confusion may be due to the fact there is NO written record of this hukamama, there is reference .. "Haarr Pirtham ekam Thith mahi'n Har gobind gur Paag bandahi Hukam nave din dutia'n lakhai Sri Gur desan des pathai..." Guru Harkrishan JI issued one. Guru Teg Bahadur JI issued 22. Guru Gobind Singh ji issued 34. Guru Hragobind Ji issued the first Hukamnama when Guru Arjan Dev ji was martyred, and Guru Hargobind sahib took to Gurgaddi.It also called sikhs to come armed with good horses and arams when visiting gur Hargobind Sahib ji. There is no such thing that GurU Hargobind sahib issued a Hukamnama against eating meat or said anything about machee or meat ..or whatever...the whole shabad means something else.I suggest this errant individual submit the wheol shabad !It is very mischeivious people trying to impose their own eating habits upon the panth and mislead the Panth.I think the administrators should look into such mischeiveious claims and stop such mail.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

/\ · 06 Nov 2005

Gurcharan Singh, Take a look at this one hukumnama (there are others in the book) in the book Hukumnamay by Dr. Ganda Singh. The line about meat is underlined in grey on the original. Meat is against Gurmat. Period. Here's the easy to read version provided as well in the book:

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

Gurcharan Singh · 06 Nov 2005

It is also a lie that a Hukamnama was issued i 1982 against meat eating ! Thre were ONLY two Hukamnamas issued in 1982.Bth were against an individual called Siv Singh Bela, a member of the SGPC executive commitee for attending a Nirankari....wedding!he was reported by sant Ajit singh !! Bhai sahib please dont lie with cooked up hukamnamas

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

/\ · 06 Nov 2005

You got me Gurcharan Singh. First you claimed the hukumnama by Guru Hargobind Sahib was fake (see above) now you say the Akal Takhat hukumnama also is a fake. But you're right. It wasn't issued in 1982, it was 1980. The Hukamnama issued by Akal Takht Jathedar Sandhu Singh Bhaura dated February 15th 1980 that Amritdhari Sikhs can eat meat as long as it is jhatka meat and that eating meat does not go against the code of conduct, Kurehit, of the Sikhs. Thus a Sikh cannot be excommunicated for eating meat. Even by that hukumnama though, the meat you get in supermarkets isn't acceptable because it's not jhatka. But as I said, I think Guru Hargobind Sahib's word is a bit more influential than Sadhu Singh Bhaura's.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

Gurcharan Singh · 06 Nov 2005

AUTHOR/ \ By your own admission you accept that you have made mistake by alluring to 1982 Hukamnama. There was NO such jathdear as sandhu singh Bhaura, BUT Sadhu singh Bhaura.He issued the last Hukamnama on 16th of Novemeber 1979 against Jagdev Singh talwandi becuse of talwandi's refusal to accept a 7 member SAD committee for choosing of election nominees. The next Hukamnama then come out in 1981 on the 23 of august. It was agains realting to some misrepresentaions made by Jathedar santokh singh nd his subsequuent failure to attend the Akal takhat over same issue.The next after this came out on 10/09/1981, again relating to Jathedaar santokh Singh.THis is signed by all the takahats and granthis of Darbar sahib,.The takhats hazoor Sahib and Patna sahibs are missing. Now for you information.I can gurantee that NO Hukamnama was isssued in 1980 either, that related to what you claim.He may have given an opinion of his own. First this so called translation is very interesting.As there are many such translations.This translations have been written by many over the same so called jouneys- and interpretedly differently by different writers.However, I would like to explore more on this issue.The transaltions are NOT all correct, but assumptions. Even for argument sake if we accept that is the correct translation, two things come to mind...first Guru Gobind Singh finalised the formation of Sikhs, therefore any previous issues may be superceded.Secondly,there was NO such Hukamnama ..a letter may have gone to the sikhs, thirldy there was no such formation of a rehat for a Sikh during that time.Until I see the book myslef I cannot comment upon it.However, I say this is NOT part of a hukamnama but a letter probably sent. However genuine this may be ..the rehat was formed over 25 years, and looked into everything before it was finalised.The SRM reigned over the code of conduct for the khalsa. Now Guru Ji also said never cut the hair , bhai sahib there are thousands who do ...... The 10th master also gave the Khalsa control to take decisons, therefore to argue that the hukam of the Guru (which has not really been proven regards its authencity) is greater than that of the khalsa is irrelevant. The panth is divide enough , let us stick to accepted norms instead of reinventing different meanings to suit own individual likes and dislikes.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

/\ · 06 Nov 2005

Gurcharan Singh, If there isn't a ruling by Akal Takhat about meat, that frankly is to my favour. My quote above about the ruling was taken from the article at http://www.sikhs.org/meat.htm. Now about Guru Hargobind Sahib's hukumnama. There is no "translation". It is the original version and then copied out into text. There is no interpretation or anything else taking place here. I've underlined the original version's injunction against meat and the text version's. There is NO TRANSLATION. You said, "However, I say this is NOT part of a hukamnama but a letter probably sent." On whAt basis are you saying this? The book is by Dr. Ganda Singh and is accepted as authentic by all scholars. Dr. Ganda Singh is one of the most respected Sikh scholars. What are you basing your argument on besides, "Mai naa manoo(n)"? The hukumnama has Nishaan of Guru Hargobind Sahib and there is another hukumnama with the same hukam of not going near meat or fish. You claim there was no rehit before Guru Gobind Singh. WRONG. Guru Ram Das has clearly told the rehit in "Guru Satgur ka jo Sikh akhai.." the rehit of charan paahul and keeping kesh all are accepted as early rehits. The rehit of doing nitnem of Japji Sahib, Rehras Sahib, Sohila Sahib are all proven rehits. Not eating meat was another rehit like this. You then bring up the ludicrous point about the Khalsa being able to rule Guru Sahib. Come on. If the "Khalsa" decides tomorrow that cut hair is ok and no need for kakaars, will that overrule Guru Sahib too? Khalsa cannot violate any of the principles. No Guru issued a a hukam about a [i]principle[/i] that went against some earlier principle. The Gurus' hukams were all complimentary, not at all contradictory as you are trying to suggest. The Sikh Rehit Maryada is a good document and a good idea. But it is NOT perfect. It was written not by Guru Sahib but by scholars. Not all those scholars even accepted the final draft. The writers were just humans and they did indeed make mistakes. That draft written by a few people cannot be thrust upon the entire Panth where it contravenes a Gurmat principle like eating meat. But even the SRM says not to eat "Kuthaa" . The footnote defining kuthaa as halal was not in the approved draft. It was added afterwards. Kuthaa just means meat.

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

omg make jatka of jatka eaters · 07 Nov 2005

im vegie ut I would lik to state all new zeland meat iss halal as 80 % goes to arab countires so they do all in same way

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

Jagjit Singh · 07 Nov 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, one veer has stated "vegetarian is a hindu ritual.These are hindus misqouting Gurbani to prove their hindu points." Although I have not reponded to the subject. I just thought Sikh children should always take the vegetarian option or just take packed lunches. Anyway, the above comment. Yes, Brahmins believe in vegetarianism. That is to their credit. I think anyone from any religion who sincerely chooses to be a religious person which deep spiritual purpose and compassiona nd justice in their hearts. That person can never eat meat. Being vegetarian is not being a Hindu. The defination of a hindu is a theif or dog by some accounts. Being a vegetarian is compassionate living. This is definately something that Sikhs do not need to be embarrassed about. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Sikh pupils being served halal meat

LionKing (LK) · 08 Nov 2005

"/" I agree with most of what you said, except - *************** But even the SRM says not to eat "Kuthaa" . The footnote defining kuthaa as halal was not in the approved draft. It was added afterwards. Kuthaa just means meat. *************** Bhai Vir Singh Ji in his Guru Granth Sahib Kosh defines Kuthas as meat slaughtered in muslim way. Agree with you about the Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji Hukamnama which is accepted by most. Perhaps someone should show this to AKal Thakat Jathedar so that they reconsider the SIkh view on Meat.... If this Hukamnama did not exist I would be sceptical, but this HUkamnama, if authentic overules over HUkamnamas :)