Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

Gora · 03 Nov 2005

waheguru ji kha khalsa, Waheguru ji khi fateh what are the sikh views on bioethics, i realise this is an ambiguous question, so i will give an example question; is it ok to use animals for vital medical research? (i've been thinking about this, i thought, well, most antibiotics are tested on animals before put on the drug markets (pharmacys). please reply asap, this is part of an university assignment, and i dont want to put an answer that conflicts with sikhi morals. thank you waheguru ji kha khalsa, Waheguru ji khi fateh

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

khalistani · 03 Nov 2005

i dunnt think its wrong to use animals to advance medical sceince as bhai gurdas jes vaar says, when a human dies its of no use, but an animals body is used in so many ways even live ones i cud understand some animals may die but the discovery cud save millions of human lives :) i think its sall gud to progress medical sceince bhula chuka maf

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

???? · 04 Nov 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji Reading 'khalistani ji's' post i agree half and half. If the animal is dead then one is not possesing any harm to the specie, however if it is alive and it has the chances of dying due to your experiment then isn't that 'jeev hatheya' as well. Except the difference will be that you may not be sheding it's blood. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

Zorawar Singh · 04 Nov 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I think the problem is that most animals are alive when they used for testing. Often the stuff done to them if very inhumane. I think it is anti-Gurmat. The dilemma is if you do not use animals, then you have to use humans. That would be equally inhumane. So how do you test medicines for side effects? Sahib Siri Guru Har Krishan Ji, Sahib Siri Guru Ram Das ji, Sahib Siri Guru Har Rai Ji all gave medicines. But the medicines they gave were no chemicals but herbal and natural medicines. I think the world is now opening its eyes to alternative, herbal and natural medicines. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

Jas · 04 Nov 2005

Gora, This is a good question. Animals should not be used. It's not a part of Sikhi. Moreover, medicine is just a conspiracy.

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

Jasmin · 04 Nov 2005

Iam frankly opposed to all exploitation of animals, or animal bodies, ideally, and I don't want to exploit humans either, in fact even less so. I resently read Mohandas Gandhi felt the same, but he was a liberal (anti caste) Hindu. Gur Fateh

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

Singh · 04 Nov 2005

gandhi was the most caste ridden person. read history thoroughly!!!!!

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

Gora · 04 Nov 2005

waheguru ji kha khalsa, waheguru ji khi fateh! thank you for the reply's, there seem to be conflicting views, maybe il have to make a personal choice, a singh told me (simmal tree): gurbani says to have mercy for all creatures and never abuse your powers gurbani also says to do actions for the greater good Again, these are conflicting arguments, is there gurbani directly to tell us our view? thank you again waheguru ji kha khalsa, waheguru ji khi fateh! bhula chuka maf

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

Jasmin · 04 Nov 2005

O.k.---------- but not that relevent to topic.

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

... · 04 Nov 2005

no. sikhs believe that animals can be used for material things but not for food or medicine.

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

khalistani · 04 Nov 2005

i thinnk to say no wud actually be agaisnt sikhi and be folwing a marag of thejains instead of the khalsa if u are soo compasinate, then stop breathing dont walk dont eat plants, they have athmas too to survive and to live we can use other animals for our uses singhs used leather singhs used animal skin for tablai they used leather for sheaths, when they cud hae used wood medicince advancment is good, if animals are tested then it is ok obvously we dont want to hurt animals but human joonis a billion times more impirtant than other joona this is the only joon where people can dobhagthee and become mukhth even in nature animals kill each other to survive are humans not allowed to do that to survive? wud it be better that milliions of people die instead of a few animals? which is better? maybe im wrongi dunt kno but i think it is ok bhula chuka maf

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

singh · 04 Nov 2005

i agree with khalistani, animals were used in the Guru's times to help to survive. And to say an animal life is just as imporant as a human life, i do not think this is correct. If you are using it for survival such as medical advances to cure diseases it is ok. But being cruel and torturing animals has to be considered wrong.

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

?? · 05 Nov 2005

Those who are against animal testing have used any medicine. Don't be hypocrites. U are willing to use the end product but how it is produced u r against it.

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

vichar · 05 Nov 2005

gurbani says those who live without repeating the lords name may aswell be dead. what makes you think the lives of manmukhs are more important then that of animals? researchers do the most disgusting things to animals like inject them with diseases to see if antibiotics work they mess with there genes in developement producing deformed animals pain and suffering caused to these animals will come back on those who give the pain. whether using medicine developed using animal testing is hypocritical or not is a separate issue, you maybe be right it may be hypocritical, but that doesnt justify giving pain to animals.

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

khalistani · 05 Nov 2005

then dont breathe, dont eat plants, then dont walk it is not possible for the human race to survive without giving some pain to some animals or beings is it better for a few animals to die or for MILLIONS of humans to die? een in nature animals do what th must to survive humans have been given the same right to develp medicine that can save millions is ok we shdunt develp the same attitude the jains have, which guru je critises because it is hypoctical ?? made a good point too bhula chuka maf

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

vichar · 06 Nov 2005

"then dont breathe, dont eat plants, then dont walk it is not possible for the human race to survive without giving some pain to some animals " breathing and eating doesnt give pain to animals bacteria and plants do not have a nervous system, they dont feel pain lol dnt walk? thats a bit like me saying to you, dont comb youre hair incase you might break one, except accidently breaking a hair is worse then accidently killing an insect anyway insects are primitive, they dont have a complex nervous system which enables pain reception " is it better for a few animals to die or for MILLIONS of humans to die?" answer - millions of humans to die who are you to play god? animals are innocent they know no better, not like humans who have consciounce, yet still commit sin after sin after sin. why is it so important to keep 'humans alive'? gurbani says those who dont repeat gods name may aswell be dead. and youre willing to give gods animals huge amounts of pain to keep people alive, and what for - so they can have good time drinking, smoking, clubbing, adultery, cutting hair. animals dont do these filthy acts, and yet you decide to take an animals life jus so manmukhs can enjoy wine of the world?

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

vichar · 06 Nov 2005

actually youre going off point a bit discussion is not about killing living things, its about torturing living things and giving them pain and suffering. obviously killing living things is unavoidable, actually killing an insect by accidentally stepping on them does them a favour as youre speeding its progress through the cylcle of joons. or consuming bacteria in food which is destroyed in stomach acid, this is different from torturing animals, like scientists do. for example injecting rabbits with a deadly disease, implanting a tumour into the spinal cord etc etc this causes horrible suffering, where animal dies of slow painful death. which is very different from killing a micro-organism which cannot sense pain.

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

khalistani · 06 Nov 2005

all plantshave souls, just because they dont have a nervous system doesnt mean they dont have s oul ure nervous system is not ure soul read gur nanak dev jes shabd, where the gardner is told that each leave has life in it everyhting has life its a joon and walking doesnt give animals pain??? nect time u walk jus watch wa u walk on and look at the insect once u kil an insect it wriggles aroun in pain an it sitl has an athma y shud we treat animals better than humans? first ensure the survaval OF OUR species, then worry boutt he animals wat the hell is the point of saving 100 animals if medical testing cud have saved millions of humans? in nature its a low, survival of the fittest we shud be kind to animals, but for our own survival guru je tells us to do what is nessecary i think pepl e r forgetting our gurus KILELD SHEEP and used there skin for lather, tabla, etc animals were killed in our past for there skin, etc. for human use, we can use animals i agree that itd sad tht we have to do things such as inflict pain unto animaals but dont u think the ggoats felt pain when the singhs chatka them for there skin? animals will feel pain thas SAD and horrible but first worry bout HUMANS then worry bout animals the price of a few animals is nothing to pay, foor example, if we discover a cure for cancer our gurus have used animals for human use mankind as been doing it since we been here vaheguru has not said this is wrong to survive it is not wrong to do somethings bhula chuka maf

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

vichar · 07 Nov 2005

"all plantshave souls, just because they dont have a nervous system doesnt mean they dont have s oul ure nervous system is not ure soul" i didnt say plants dont have a soul, i sed they cant feel pain. same with bacteria. whether you think insects feel pain or not is going off point, theres a difference between un-intentionally stepping on a insect and caging up a rabbit so that you can surgically implant a tumour into it. animals werent killed for skin, skin was taken from dead animals. "first ensure the survaval OF OUR species, then worry boutt he animals wat the hell is the point of saving 100 animals if medical testing cud have saved millions of humans? in nature its a low, survival of the fittest" disease in humans are being artificially treated, going against natural selection thats why the human population is growing ever faster and faster if there was no medical treatment, humans wouldnt become extinct, they would jus grow at a normal rate like other species.

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

uksingh · 07 Nov 2005

khalistani - read pg120 se kineya by baba harnam singh babaji is upset with farmer for overworking his animals, as a consequence the farmer has no yield of crops.

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

vichar · 07 Nov 2005

jeea badhhahu s dhharam kar thhaapahu adhharam kehahu kath bhaaee || You kill living beings, and call it a righteous action. Tell me, brother, what would you call an unrighteous action?

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

vichar · 07 Nov 2005

kabeer jeea j maarehi jor kar kehathae hehi j halaal || Kabeer, they oppress living beings and kill them, and call it proper. dhafathar dhee jab kaadt hai hoeigaa koun havaal ||199|| When the Lord calls for their account, what will their condition be?

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

khalistani · 07 Nov 2005

hmmm i resepct baba je a lot i wil read tha and then post bak :) bhula chuka maf

Re: What are the Sikh Views on Bioethics?

bruce · 07 Nov 2005

my belief is that if you object to something and want to be vocal about it then it is your obligation to provide an alternative solution.