Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 03 Nov 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Today, in the news it was stated that the trainstations which have Heathrow Express Trains will have X-ray machines and hand-search checking at the barriers (before entering train platform). Though it will only be introduced to Paddington Station and another one in January 2006, it may introduced other places if the pilot scheme is successful. In the UK the Sikhs are safeguarded to wear the Kirpan under the 1988 Criminal Justice Act. However, I was thinking to myself, today Amritdharis remove their Kirpans before boarding aeroplanes. Generally, Sikhs have made an exception for wearing the Kirpan at all times for when we are travelling by air. However, if someone tomorrow asks us to make another exception for the trains. Then what? They could state "will you take it off for air-travel and you just do Ardaas when putting it back on. So whats the problem? Its for your and the public's security." What would happen? Even though the new X-ray machines in theory should not effect Sikhs because the Law permits us to wear the Kirpan (any size), many security staff are 1) ignorant of the law, 2) ignorant of who Sikhs are, 3) ignorant of what the Kirpan is. I thought i would share my vichaar. Bhul chuk maaf.

Re: Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

A Singh · 03 Nov 2005

I sometime ago had to meet with a client at Gary Rhode's 24 Restaurant with a number of Accountants and Bankers. I didn't realise, but they too had metal detectors at the entry point. The situation was however easy to deal with, I explained before going under the detector that I was an Amritdhari Sikh and have a Kirpan. The guards were fine with this and let me through without any scan. Of course, it caught everyone's attention and the discussion for somewhile remained on Sikhi and allowed for an effective means to creating awareness. From other such experiencing I think, things which help is advance warning - either call before hand or explain fully. Try to avoid using the term "symbolic", instead I find "ceremonial" works just fine (since ceremonial does not imply 'needs to be blunt' or 'rubber' and other such nonsense). Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

Zorawar Singh · 03 Nov 2005

I do think western sikh youth need to create a think tank to deal with the kirpan issue specifically. Unless we get it reversed on planes, it will always be a problem.

Re: Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

31 · 03 Nov 2005

lets just take it off where we have to and cause no problems. we create problems for ourseleves and make ourselves look bad in the media. if you take your kirpan, god knows that you have to, and that your not doing it on purpose. a prime example where we showed ourselves up is when that behtzi play happend, we made a massive fuss and campaigned like plonkers, and looke bad on the news and in the media. A few top singhs could have approached her and told her not to do the show. We, Sikhs were the biggest plonkers of that issue.

Re: Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

... · 03 Nov 2005

31, The kirpan CANNOT come off. Guru Sahib can "understand" a lot of things according to your logic, including cutting hair to save your life (Bhai Taru Singh should've just made a compromise and grew it later right?) The fact that some of us have made a compromise on planes or other places is going to be used against us forever. If we took it off there, why not in some other situation? I would prefer that these issues get resolved without bad publicity and uproar, but if the price of keeping rehit is looking like "plonkers" then so be it. It matters what Guru Gobind Singh thinks of us and what the Khalsa thinks of us. What the rest of society feels and thinks doesn't matter all that much.

Re: Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

TRUE facts @ q(3` · 03 Nov 2005

I think the problem arises when sikhs do NOT explain properly and start an argument.If I may suggest both the terms ceremonial and symbolic are often used wrongly by Sikhs and the media. The proper wording should be.." it is an article of my faith, and as a Amritdhari Sikh I am required to keep it on my boy and not part with it at all times." Show them before they see it.I have travelled with kirpan on the planes , apart from the fact that I do hold a very senior post in the same department that monitors the security of the nation- I ussually show it as I go through security detectors, and ocassionly , I am asked to explain, and I explain, and .."it is okay, Sir, Thank you,for explaining, I apologise having to stop inconvenienced you.."I ussually hold back my ID if there is a problem, but I am yet to produce my ID..I have seen a fellow Sikh passenger stopped once because he tried to walk through the security arch very quickly.he did NOT tell them he had a kirpanon him.he could not sopeak good enough english.And I saw an argument developing. I walked up to the front and spoke to one of the officers, and at once the tome chnaged when I explained and the man was allowed through. However he never once came said gurfateh to me though.Never mind.PLEASEdeclare it before they see it.As soon as one nears the secuurity arch expose it gently and discreetly to the officers so they can see.I think this very much depends on how one conducts themselves , and not walk around with a chip onthe shoulder attitude.A simple polite ettiquette helps.

Re: Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

Jagjit Singh · 03 Nov 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare 31 jio, if Sikhs in our history just accepted what you say because of perceptions, then we would have no history. Gurmat has a distinct path. It is the ideal lifestyle choice of the 21st century, in which who have a healthy, stress-free lifestyle away from the ills of today. Rights have to be won, very few are given automatically. History of every nation proves this. We as Sikhs have to engage in debate to show our distinctness and our morals. Where we fail is we debate kakaars with media, but we do not mention the mindset that our Guru ji blesses us to maintain them kakkars. The only problem is Sikhs have is not become as media wise as the could, and as a result they are getting some bad press. But the behzti issue was such a strong issue, that even some bad press was worth it. The stupidity of one punjabi girl was the cause. Where we failed is by stating to the media, who made the issue of freedom of expression and speech. We should have pointed out that it was not about freedom of speech, but if someone has the freedom to offend. It was our fault for not being media savvy, and using 40 years old men doing our talking, when instead we need young Singhs, and in particular young bibian speaking for us. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

A Singh · 04 Nov 2005

I don't believe the word ceremonial is incorrect, symbolic yes. Ceremonial does not mean blunt, rubber etc is acceptable (as is the case under symbolic). In fact a full 3ft kirpan is acceptable as "Ceremonial" for even the Queen uses a full sized sharp saber in her ceremonial customs. What we need to do is reconsider the way we explain the Kakkars as "Symbols". Most laws on this front refer to religious, cultural and ceremonial purposes - in the case of Sikhs, the Kirpan qualifies for all three purposes. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 04 Nov 2005

TRUE facts @ q(3` Bhaji, do you live in the UK? I never knew that the security on aiports let people through with the Kirpan. Is this certain airlines? Someone I know said that he always wears a small gatra Kirpan and shows it to the security and they let him through. COuld someone clarify this. Thanks

Re: Today Aeroplanes, Tomorrow Trains - Kirpan in UK

rsingh · 04 Nov 2005

gosh i got stopped and made to wait at enterance by security yesterday yet my kirpan is small. I'm currently looking for 10 inch plus but I was wearing a small 4-6inch small one. one or two sikhs who went in to the court earlyer for public hearing had 10 inch kirpans and they where cleared eventually. it seems that Judge Motta singh has said 4 inch blade. Im lkike first I herd. number 1 I thought it was ment to be 6inch min. number two. who is motta singh to put restrictions on kirpan in court!