Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Kirpan and Police.

Kirpan and Police.

Singh · 29 Oct 2005

Is there any Sikh organization around that is educating the police about the kirpan by going to their police stations? If the police have some knowledge of our kirpans, that can make a huge difference and create alot of tolerance. Maybe a Sikh body or group can be created whose task should be to go to every police station in the GTA area giving them a brief 10 minute power point presentation about the Sikh faith and in particular the Kirpan. What do you all think... [%sig%]

Re: Kirpan and Police.

javaan mard · 30 Oct 2005

a singh and i are going to a police recruiting center and doing presentations there. we are gonna hvae our first presentation on sikhi during november. nihang niddar singh in uk also works with the police educating them on sikhi and kirpan etc.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

Jagjit Singh · 30 Oct 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh Pyare jio, I know the Slough Sikh Youth have an excellent presentation for the ethnic awareness training of the Sikh community to the Police. They are officially recognised by the Metropolitan Police. All new officers have to attend their sessions. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji kefateh

Re: Kirpan and Police.

Singh · 30 Oct 2005

Javaan, where does Niddar teach the police? I think he is a bad representation of sikhi.......

Re: Kirpan and Police.

Gurpartap Singh · 31 Oct 2005

why bad????

Re: Kirpan and Police.

Confused Khalsa · 31 Oct 2005

Because he advocates the use of Ganja and Meat, which is against the basic teachings of Sikhism.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

VSK · 31 Oct 2005

http://media.waheguroo.com/KhalsaTV/The_Sikhs_By_San_Jose_Police_Department/The_Sikhs_By_San_Jose_Police_Department.wmv

Re: Kirpan and Police.

jss · 31 Oct 2005

wait... we can't be mad at him cuz he eats meat...according to akal takt maryada...meat is allowed as long as it's not halal.. i personally only follow the vegetarian rehit...but we have to understand there are people who will follow the sgpc version and they are still considred amritdharis in the eyes of akal takt

Re: Kirpan and Police.

RoopKaur · 31 Oct 2005

JSS, this discussion has occured many times before, please do a search to find the facts that say meat is actually a bajjar kurehit. You can start with the gurmat section of this website.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

LionKing · 01 Nov 2005

100% agree with JSS. You can blame him for encouraging Bhang, and all other crap he says (which you can read on his websites) but, personally being against meat i think you shoudl acknowledge that Akal Takhat says you can eat it - until that is changed you have no right to call pople who have been blessed with Amrit there for non-sikhs Regards

Re: Kirpan and Police.

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 02 Nov 2005

Author: jss Date: 10-31-05 17:58 wait... we can't be mad at him cuz he eats meat...according to akal takt maryada...meat is allowed as long as it's not halal.. i personally only follow the vegetarian rehit...but we have to understand there are people who will follow the sgpc version and they are still considred amritdharis in the eyes of akal takt Bhai sahib, I have not met this Niddar Nihang therefore I cannot comment upon him.But bhang should not be encouraged and it is NOT part of Sikhi either. There is NO such thing as vegetarian rahit.There is ONLY ONR recognised Maryada-the Shiromani Rehat Maryada authorised by the SUPREME BODY OF SIKHS-the SGPC. That is the oNLY recognised maryada.Any others claiming their own are just as good as Indira gandhi or Massa ranggher since they are not prepared to come under the compliance of the majority agreed maryada. This wher ethe problems of the Sikhs start.It took the SGPC over 25 years to consult the SRM maryada, before it was finally authorised in 1945 I think off my head. The maryada of the Sikh is not for free taking or nagotiations.Neither it is a free fall for one to choose. THERE IS NO SUCH thing as VEGETARIAN maryada! To be a vegetarian or not has nothing to do with Sikh maryada.It is a practice that has come down from masands and dera saadhs in the 18th and 19th and 20th centuries,who lived more under the influences of the sanskritic mentality, and decided along with hindu matt saadhs to adopt vegetarian diets, and some how like divali and many other practise associated it to with amritpaan. Like wise the langger is also liked in from the eating culture of the old, and to accomodate both hindus and muslims in sikh sangats.A non vegetarian meal served the purposes of both hindus and Sikhs.So langger came to be vegetarian oriented. People trying to convince another that once one has taken amritpaan, one must be a vegetarian really are doing it on their own personal choice not because of any rehat.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

akj4eva&everamen · 02 Nov 2005

Gurcharan Singh Kulim if u eat meat youre not a sikh. full stop

Re: Kirpan and Police.

Single Singh · 02 Nov 2005

How is SGPC Supreme body of the Sikhs when it does not include countries outside of India? What about Delhi then is the DSGPC Supreme for them and then if they step into Punjab it is SGPC. ****admin cut**** SGPC IS NOT THE SUPREME BODY OF THE SIKHS!!!!WAKE UP AND SMELL THE COFFEE!!!!! Heck they do not even have an office in Canada or the States. And if they do they have done a terrible job (as usual) of letting people know. If they are the supreme authority, why are they elected by only India members only, who as we all know have free flowing alcohol at election time? If they are so supreme why do they not have offices in each of the big cities outside of India where local Sikh problems can be handled rather than running to local courts? Heck they can't even control and guide the sangat in India, They can't even implement this maryada they have in the gurdwara run by there own members. SGPC is a good idea but they are crooks hungry for power. The only organization that is needed is the Akal Takht, who should then have everything under its wing, not the other way around.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

moorakh · 02 Nov 2005

SGPC IS DEFINATELY NOT THE SUPREME BODY OF THE SIKHS !!!!! They are not supreme body of any thing. Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee is our jathedar Khalsa panth decides these things

Re: Kirpan and Police.

Gurcharan Singh · 02 Nov 2005

LoL.am I suprised at the mentality expressed.I am not. One says if ..I " eat meat I am not a Sikh"..I say to him ....if that is all you know about Sikhi, you are a not even a sikh!You must be a hindu radaswami or arya smajist.full stop. Those who say SGPC is NOT the SUPREME body, I am sure you can carry on saying that,as many times as you like, just becuse you do not agree out of the 30 million Sikhs , it is not going to make any iota of difference. SGPC is the recognised body , as much as I dislike it for its effectiveness, for the forseeable future that is WHAT IT IS>FULL STOP>THE SUPREME BODY OF THE SIKHS> Now , it needs to change, it needs to increase its role and widen representations is a altogther a different story. Bhai sahib, why are Canada ,M alaysia etc NOT represented in SGPC ....it is NOT so because the SGPC is registered in India and only Indian citizens can hold any office .Foreign based Sikhs may be given an honorary observer representation,but that has to be agreed as yet. The consultations about the SRM took place involving ALL Major Sikh organisation world wide at that time, starting from 1925 to 1940, 478 organisations and societies and gurduaras responded to the SRM consultations.That was WORLD wide SIKHS then. The fact SGPC has today become ineffective, corrupted, unsikh and unethical is a different issue altogether.This needs to be addressed. Unless, and until another world wide organisation becomes acceptable to the world sikhs, the SGPC STAYS as the SUPREME BODY of the SIKHS. I know many ill informed little developed individuals think if they say it is NOT then it does not become, and if they twist something because they do not like, then that is the way it ..goes...chldren ..before you let your emtions tale over and speak ...leaving the intelligence behind ...the SGPC is the supreme body of the SIKHS.It is as simple as that. For your information, even the present set up of the SGPC cannot chnage unless the indian parliament agree, neither can the indian parliament is essence can chnage the SGPC unless the Sikhs agree to the change. Before flaring up wide gapped in here please go and read the rule and the law about the SGPC.The SGPC contrl, eventhe throne of the GURU- the AKAL TAKHAT.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

TRUE Facts · 02 Nov 2005

Veer Gurcharan SIngh Ji, these are yesterdays kids who think they know it all.They do not understand the set up. The khalsa Panth decided on the SGPC in 1925.The khalsa panth in 1925 decided that the SGPC be the supreme body of the Sikhs. MOORAAKH Which khalsa Panth are you talking about??After all being a moorakh it is probably hard to undertsand. All these things about no offices etc and not being effective are all different issues like Veer Gurcharan singh ji says.Sgpc cannot set up sgpc offices outside India because they do not have that authority to do so.In fact we cannot see a world wide Sikh organisation that canhave universal authority from one country. a new organiation needs to be set up that operates in this age , but no body has guts to say that to the SGPC>until that is done SGPC is the supreme body, sadly.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

RoopKaur · 02 Nov 2005

This issue has been discussed many times before. The SGPC Rehit maryada says kuttha meat is not allowed. Look up the word kuttha in the Mahan Kosh and see what it really means. As for following the rehit maryada, A Sikh's first duty is to follow Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, which states that meat should not be eaten. All rehit of a gursikh should be measured against what guru ji says, and in this case it is clear that mass is unacceptable. Not only does Gurbani say it is unacceptable, but the Hukamnamaas found written by Sri Guru Harkrishan Sahib Ji all state to stay away from mass and machhi. But if one is willing to overlook Gurbani just to feed the taste of their tongue, than any excuse can be found to eat meat.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

A Singh · 03 Nov 2005

Roop Kaur, Please quit with your vegetarian propaganda, I'm a very strict vegetarian myself, but the Panth's words are clear on this, not only in the existing Rehit Maryada, but also in numerous other older sources. This one point is perhaps the biggest thing that splits the Panth for really no good reason, if you and your friends who like to cook up unecessary controversy over minor points such as this, then by all means set up your own little sect (in the event you don't already belong to one), the Khalsa Panth is clear on this subject along with every other. People like to talk a lot about ekta - shame that they are themselves often responsible for its nonexistence. Veer Javaan Mard, its now November 2005 - when will you be meeting with the Police, keep us all informed of this important issue. Gur Fateh! A Singh.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

Gurcharan Singh · 03 Nov 2005

Roop kaur Ji , I think, You need more than a dictionary to understand the reallity and Gurbani.Please do NOT distort Gurbani.Like Veer A singh ji has said, the PNATH is very clear on this .You are confused , and sunken in your own version of distorted version og the pnaths maryada , and Gurbani. Bhen ji it really looks like you do not even read properly.Kuttha means totured, killed according to the mohammdan law. So what is your point ??The rehat Maryada of the PANTH say Sikhs will NOT consume kuttha meat, BUT meat prepared in Jhatka.Sikhs can consume Jhatka meat. It is such a pity some deviant sect follower like yourself tries to misrepresent the KHALSA EDDICTS > SGPC IS THE SUPREME BODY OF THE SIKHS. AMRTDHARI SIKHS IF THEY SO WISH MAY AND CAN EAT JHATKA MEAT.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

Singh · 03 Nov 2005

Hey people, why did the topic I started have to get ruined? I'm the guy who started this topic! and it is about finding solutions for our CURRENT problem i.e. the kirpan issue. The meat issue can be discussed in another thread or just look at the Gurmat section of this website for some good articles on the meat issue. Our first concearn should be the kirpan issue, because that is what matters right now. We need to come up with some solutions fast, or else Canada will end up like France.

Re: Kirpan and Police.

A Singh · 04 Nov 2005

Singh, I agree and I wish to know more from Javaan Mard when he and the other Singh will be meeting with the police, since this is a critical issue and one we need to be proactive about. The deviation occurred solely on the basis that people reacted to the notion that Nihang Niddar Singh has met with the police as well on this topic.