Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

News · 25 Oct 2005

Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train Canadian-born U of O student says he was humiliated, treated like al-Qaeda terrorist BY MOHAMMED ADAM A University of Ottawa law student is accusing VIA Rail of treating him like a terrorist and smearing Canadian Sikhs after he was ordered from a train twice in one month for wearing a sheathed ceremonial sword known as a kirpan. Balpreet Singh, 24, said yesterday he felt angry, humiliated and very much like a secondclass citizen after the latest incident Friday afternoon when VIA officials escorted him off a Toronto-bound train because he was wearing a kirpan. VIA officials took the action after someone complained. Mr. Singh claimed his explanation — that the kirpan is not a weapon, but a religious artifact worn as part of his faith — was ignored. The officials said weapons are banned from the trains, and no exceptions are made for religious symbols. Mr. Singh, who is in his first year at the university, said he has taken the bus, travelled on Toronto’s subway and the GO Train with hundreds of other Sikhs, and there has never been a problem until the incident with VIA. He said what irked him even more was that after they took him off the train, officials made no alternative travel arrangements for him, and he had to abandon a trip to Brampton where he was heading for a congregational service and teaching assignment. Mr. Singh said the incident follows a similar one last month in Toronto. He said that after the first incident, he’d been assured steps would be taken to ensure it never happened again. Now, he said, he is considering a complaint to the Ontario Human Rights Commission. “I was born and raised in Canada, but I don’t feel that I am treated like a Canadian. It was absolutely humiliating, what happened to me. They led me off the train as if they captured some big al-Qaeda terrorist. Because I don’t look like everybody else, they treat me differently. “What happened doesn’t do much for my image, and it reflects horribly on my community. Twice a Sikh is led off the train and the impression people get is these people are dangerous.” VIA spokeswoman Catherine Kaloutsky said yesterday officials were acting in the larger interest of public safety and security when they took Mr. Singh off the train. VIA’s baggage policy bans weapons, which are defined as including “collectibles, antiques and those of a ceremonial nature,” she said. No exception could be made for Mr. Singh, because he was carrying a weapon that fell into one of the categories. “Any passenger who is in possession of this type of weapon — collectible items, antique items and knives, such as in this instance, that are recognized as of a ceremonial nature — will be denied boarding,” Ms. Kaloutsky said. “We acknowledge, we respect an individual’s culture and religion, but our priority has to be safety and security of all those who travel with us. It is not targeting any individual.” Transport Canada spokeswoman Vanessa Vermette said after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks in the United States, the federal government banned the carrying of knives and “knife-like objects,” which includes kirpans, from airplanes. But there is no policy on trains, and each company is left to make its own decision. There are about 300,000 Sikhs in Canada, about 15 per cent of whom wear kirpans. VIA’s policy suggests, in effect, that the 45,000 orthodox Sikhs who wear daggers as an article of faith cannot travel on the national rail carrier. The incident involving Mr. Singh is likely to resurrect the debate on individual rights and the balance between religious freedom and public safety. Orthodox Sikhs have worn sheathed kirpans strapped to their chests since the 17th century as a symbol of strength and willingness to defend the weak and fight for justice. The daggers are one of the five articles of faith of the religion and range in length between 15 and 30 centimetres. However, their use in countries like Canada and the United States has been marked by controversy, because some people consider them weapons. While Ontario, British Columbia and Alberta permit them in schools, Quebec prohibits them. In April, the Supreme Court reserved judgment in the case of Gurbaj Singh in which the Quebec Court of Appeal overturned a lower court decision and banned the wearing of kirpans in provincial schools. Acknowledging that the ban on the kirpans was indeed a limit on freedom of religion, the Appeal Court nevertheless said it was a reasonable limit in light of public safety concerns. Manjit Singh, a spokesman for the Canadian Sikh Council, called VIA’s action “deplorable,” saying there is no excuse for it. “I don’t want to accuse people of being racist or xenophobic, because name-calling like this doesn’t help. Sikhs have been in this country for over 100 years and as a Crown corporation, VIA should know better,” he said. Meanwhile, Mr. Singh said he can understand why someone unfamiliar with Sikhism would be concerned about the kirpan, and he would have been happy to explain what it is. But he said nothing justifies the behaviour of VIA Rail officials in Ottawa, especially after his first encounter with the company in Toronto last month. On Sept. 18, he was in his seat on the train when an official took him aside and said someone had complained about the kirpan and felt intimidated by his presence. After he was taken off the train, Claire La France, VIA station manager in Toronto, apologized for the incident, called her head office and was advised to let Mr. Singh continue with his journey on the next train. She assured him that the issue would be resolved once and for all. Three days later, Ms. La France told Mr. Singh in an e-mail that she had referred the matter to senior VIA officials. “I know that our Chief Operating Officer has been made aware of the circumstances. I expect it will be a topic of discussion at the meeting of the upper level executives this week. There has been much interest in your specific case by many parties,” she wrote. Mr. Singh said he was shocked and distressed Friday when he was again taken off the train, in full view of other passengers. He said a VIA official who, he said, would only give his name as Yves, and his employee number 300015, was rude and offensive. He considers the official’s behaviour as blatant discrimination, and said he doesn’t understand how a Crown corporation can allow it. “I’ve taken public transit in Toronto and Ottawa dressed like the way I was on the train, and there’s never been a problem. Navdeep Singh Bains, the prime minister’s parliamentary secretary, is a Sikh and he wears a kirpan into the House of Commons and there is no issue. So why is VIA doing this,” he said. “If I can’t wear the kirpan on the train, next they will say ‘you can’t wear it on the bus, you can’t wear it in the mall.’ Where is it going to stop? What they are really saying is, you can’t follow your religion and live here in Canada.”

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Balpreet Singh · 25 Oct 2005

To be clear, I spoke with the writer for about 1.5 hours and the "Al Qaeda" remark was just in passing, but I suppose they need to find the quotes that are most bold and striking for their story. At any rate, I'm glad the issue of kirpan has come up. Maybe this will be a good opportunity to secure our rights not just on trains but in courts, planes and other places. I know that's a very optimistic outlook, but who knows?

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

? · 25 Oct 2005

So what happens from here?

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Iron Man · 25 Oct 2005

http://cbc.ca/ottawa/media/video/canadanow/canadanow.ram

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Iron Man · 25 Oct 2005

Tapobaners making the news!! You guys should all put your support behind him, get some lawyers and SUE! take it all the way to the canadian supreme court... it would be awesome!

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Jagjit Singh · 26 Oct 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, many sikhs face these situations day in, day out. Balpreet Singh did well to take it with calmness and dignity. It is important that we refelct the vitues required to justify a kirpan, which are clamness, patience, and do not become angry. Often these things are blessings because they create oppotunities for debate and education. I would recommend Balpreet Singh write an open letter to the Board of directors of that crown Corporation asking them politely to be allowed to attend their meeting and present his case to be allow to practice your religion, and show that the kirpan of the Khalsa is not something that they need to fear. This letter should also be CC`ed to the press who have covered this case. I am happy to help draft any letters if you choose to take this action. This matter needs to be taken further but in a constructive matter. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

... · 26 Oct 2005

now that the story has come into the media, what is the next stage in the fight? the international sikh community is behind you balpreet singh !!!

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Singh · 26 Oct 2005

Shabaash Babbar Sher! Chakk de phattay!!

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

GarjKaur · 26 Oct 2005

http://cbc.ca/ottawa/media/video/canadanow/canadanow.ram

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Harjinder Singh · 26 Oct 2005

All Sikh recourses must stand in full action behind Balpreet Singh who has taken up the stand by raising his voice very boldly and patiently to seek this right for all of us. A strong peaceful struggle (Morcha) is the call of the time now and we all must do all we can to win this battle of our rights to practice our faith by wearing five K's anywhere anytime. We should prepare ourselves to make what ever sacrifice it requires to get the needful and I strongly believe that together we can definitely do it. Let us do what ever effort needed and Ardas with true heart that [gurbani]jhW jhW Kwlsw jI swihb, qhW qhW riCAw irAwieq, dyg qyg Pqh, ibrd kI pYj, pMQ kI jIq, sRI swihb jI shwie, Kwlsy jI ky bol bol bwly[/gurbani] Jahaa(n) Jahaa(n) Khalsa Ji Sahib, Tahaa(n) Tahaa(n) Rushciya Riyat, Degh Tegh Fateh, Birud Ki Paij, Panth Ki Jeet, Sri Sahib Ji Sahai, Khalsai Ji Kai Bol Baley Wherever respected Khalsa is present, Give Your protection and grace, May the free kitchen and sword never fail, Maintain the honour of your devotees, Confer victory upon the Guru Khalsa Panth, May the respected sword always come to our assistance, May the Khalsa always get honours [%sig%]

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Single Singh · 26 Oct 2005

Just a question. Why would you wear such a big size on a public train? I think 9 inches is a good size. You have to realize the public gets scared. We know that we will not pull it out and use it, but the public does not know this.

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Balpreet Singh · 26 Oct 2005

Single Singh, I consider it a mistake on my part to not have thought hard about the photo the paper would take. The first time I was taken off the train, I was wearin a 9" sri sahib. They asked to see it and it didn't really matter. The second time, they didn't ask to see my sri sahib at all and just asked if I had one and that was enough to remove me. Size wasn't an issue in this matter. Just the fact that I had a kirpan was the deciding factor. In retrospect, I can see how the picture with the larger sri sahib is pretty damaging. But like they say, hind sight is 20/20. I usually wear the larger one and for the photo I didn't choose to change that. But like I said, it probably would have been better to go with the smaller size.

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

MOW · 26 Oct 2005

why should you have to change your kakkar just for the sake of goreh on the train?

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Gandalf · 26 Oct 2005

Liberal MP calls VIA's banning of ceremonial sword 'unacceptable' PM's parliamentary secretary to take up issue with transport minister Mohammed Adam The Ottawa Citizen Wednesday, October 26, 2005 Prime Minister Paul Martin's parliamentary secretary has condemned VIA Rail for ordering a Sikh student off a train for wearing a ceremonial sword, or kirpan, saying he intends to take the matter up with Transport Minister Jean Lapierre. Navdeep Bains, an Ontario Sikh and MP for Mississauga-Brampton South, said yesterday he also plans to raise the incident with VIA Rail executives and the board of directors. Mr. Bains noted that he wears the kirpan in the House of Commons without any problem and is disappointed that a Crown corporation, such as VIA, would order a man out of a train for wearing an article of religious significance. "It is unfortunate and it is unacceptable. It is disappointing to see an institution like VIA Rail taking a position like this, because you expect better from them," Mr. Bains said. "I want to make sure that the appropriate authorities that I am aware of -- ultimately the transport minister -- are brought up to speed on this. The management of VIA Rail and the board of directors have accountability on this particular issue and I'll probably communicate in an appropriate fashion with them." Controversy over kirpans, long a subject of debate and litigation in the courts, erupted once again after University of Ottawa law student Balpreet Singh was taken off a train twice in a month after someone complained that he had a weapon. His explanation that the kirpan is a religious symbol worn by baptized Sikhs wasn't acceptable to VIA officials, who took him off a train once in Toronto and last Friday in Ottawa. A VIA spokeswoman said the company prohibits all kinds of weapons from its trains and the kirpan falls under a ban on weapons that includes "collectibles, antiques and those of a ceremonial nature." VIA said the ban is in the larger interest of public safety and security. Mr. Bains acknowledged that public safety is of paramount importance to Canadians, but said people ought to know the difference between a weapon and the Sikh religious artifact. In a democracy, every effort should be made to strike a balance between public safety and religious freedom to make sure people's rights under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms are respected. After more than 100 years in Canada, Mr. Bains said the incident shows that Sikhs still have a major task of educating Canadians and the likes of VIA Rail about their religion. "Public safety is always an important part of sound public policy, but I think it has been demonstrated, through various cases, that there should be a balance with respect to articles of faith," he said. "At the end of the day, the issue is very clear -- Balpreet poses no threat. He is simply practising his beliefs and it is important for VIA Rail to understand that, and enforce a policy that is mindful of that." About 15 per cent of Canada's estimated 300,000 Sikhs wear a sheathed kirpan strapped to their chests as a sign of their readiness to defend the weak and fight for justice. While Sikhs say the daggers have never been used in violence or cited in any such action in North America, they have been the subject of furious debate and controversy in Canada. The blades are allowed in most Canadian schools, but in the wake of the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks in the U.S., Transport Canada banned the carrying of knives and "knife-like objects," which includes kirpans, from airplanes. Sikh leaders say the 2001 attacks were such a searing event that "there was no way anyone could have made a stand or fuss" about the prohibition, said Manjit Singh, a spokesman for the Canadian Sikh Council. The community had to strike a balance between its religious beliefs and public security, and accepted the ban. "That was an exceptional circumstance," Mr. Singh said. Even then, Sikhs had to make an atonement for not wearing the dagger, he said. At the end of their journey, they had to say a special prayer of atonement and perform other rites and then don the kirpan. VIA Rail's action, however, is viewed as a form of harassment that threatens the religion. "You've got to look at the next step. Can people carry kirpans anywhere?" Mr. Singh said. What They Said The Citizen's Vito Pilieci spoke to several shoppers last night and asked them: 'Would you object to having a person wear a kirpan on public transit and what are your thoughts with regard to Mr. Singh's ordeal?' Here is what they said. Sanjein Lee, 28 It is part of their religion, so they should allow it. But, for safety reasons, maybe then there should be some kind of limitations. Pierre St. Cyr, 39 I think it's a good thing not to allow him on the train with that. They wouldn't allow me to come on with a knife, even if it was for my religion. Matt Martin, 21 I know it's ceremonious for them to wear it (the kirpan). Personally, I don't feel uncomfortable with it. But there are a lot of people who would feel uncomfortable with it and so I would say, don't allow them on the train. Roberta Dupont, 70 We have had so many problems. This fellow may be fine. But if you are going to have a rule and break it, where does it end? I find it a difficult thing, because we have had so many problems with high school kids carrying blades. Rules have to apply to everyone. Richard Whitelock, 48 This is a free society. We are very open. If he is boarding the train, then he should not be hassled. The way he was dressed ... he might be going somewhere. If he wanted to do anything (terrorist related), it would not have been possible. He is not a terrorist. They should have asked him where he was going, dressed like that. They may have learned something.

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Kaur · 26 Oct 2005

>>>>>why should you have to change your kakkar just for the sake of goreh on the train?<<<<< I agree...why would you want to wear a smaller kirpan in public just because of ignorant people's ridiculous reactions to the bigger one? I find there's no need to back down and hide one's kirpan in such a case. Who cares if people are afraid and intimidated? If someone doesn't like the way some Sikhs dress at school (ie. in bana) would that make one change his/her mind and start wearing pants and shirts again? I sure hope not. We have a right to practice our religion freely in Canda. I'm glad something like this has come up. It's definately time people start to understand and acknowledge the significance of our panj kakaars without us having to hide and wear smaller kakaars in public just because of them.

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

5abi · 26 Oct 2005

Balle bhi Jattaaa! ChaKde Fatthaaay!

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Single Singh · 27 Oct 2005

Kirpan issue double-edged The Ottawa Citizen October 27, 2005 VIA Rail was correct to remove a Sikh passenger for wearing a ceremonial dagger. But it would be better if VIA could find a way to allow kirpans on trains without putting public safety at risk. Balpreet Singh, a University of Ottawa law student, says he felt singled out and humiliated by the policy. The kirpan is one of five items observant Sikhs wear. It is a spiritual symbol. But reasonable, tolerant people can question whether kirpans are appropriate in all situations. Trains and airplanes are enclosed areas, travelling at speed. They are their own societies, removed from most emergency services and law enforcement. It is not unreasonable, therefore, for rail companies and airlines to implement rules about what items they allow. And it is not bigotry for them to apply the rules to all passengers, regardless of religion. That is not to say that universal rules cannot be discriminatory. Were VIA to institute a rule against head coverings, that would be an unjustified discrimination against people whose faiths require such items. But a policy against weapons, even ceremonial ones, is justified, even if its effect is to discriminate against observant Sikhs. Arguably, a weapon is defined by the intentions of its holder. A sharpened spoon -- or, notoriously, a box-cutter -- can be a weapon in the wrong hands. But while almost everything can be used as a weapon, it does not follow that everything is a weapon, or that nothing is. Some things are much more likely to be used as weapons than others. It would be ridiculous to keep spoons away from schoolchildren because they could be used to cause pain. It would be equally ridiculous to distribute swords at recess. The kirpan falls somewhere in between. It is neither a spoon nor a sword. But it is more like a sword than it is like a spoon. It could very easily be used to hurt somebody. In the wrong hands, a kirpan could be an instant and efficient weapon. This is not to imply that Mr. Singh or any other wearer of a kirpan intends any harm. But Mr. Singh's seatmates should not be forced to take his word for that. Beside, his intentions might not be relevant. On a train or a plane, Mr. Singh would be introducing the kirpan into an enclosed environment, where someone else could seize it and use it to do harm. Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees freedom of religion, but it also allows for reasonable limits. Religious freedom does not trump every law and every other right. If Sikhs can alter the kirpan's form without undermining its significance, perhaps there are compromises they can reach with VIA and other companies. Perhaps VIA could allow kirpans that are very small and very blunt, or with the blade fixed inside the scabbard in a definite and visible way. VIA should accommodate people of all faiths as much as possible, but it must put the safety of its passengers first

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

... · 27 Oct 2005

I encourage people to write in to the Ottawa Citizen. The Kirpan got massacred today in their editorials and letters page. Not one positive point was allowed. [url]http://www.canada.com/ottawa/ottawacitizen/news/editorials/story.html?id=59fa9091-8dd3-4b95-8521-b35a9a21aa50[/url] The editorial comparison of trains and planes isn't correct. If the visible kirpan should not be allowed because it is a danger on the train, then there should also be precautions for the invisible danger that could be in baggage or hidden on the person. That would require baggage checks and metal detectors. Precautions on a plane are only justified by the use of metal detectors and baggage checks to find ANY potential danger, not just focussing on the Kirpan. The threat posed by the kirpan is insubstantial compared to the threat posed by giving passengers knives and forks with their meals. Or the threat posed by those who might bring real weapons with them in their baggage. Those threats aren't addressed by VIA policy, but a Sikh wearing his kirpan over his clothes is a focus?

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

akj4evaandevaamen · 30 Oct 2005

u shud move to uk, more sangat and no1 eva tells u to lob ur kirpan off, the police sed that wearing a kirpan is perfectly fine

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Jagjit Singh · 30 Oct 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, why are sikhs telling them to move to UK? No Sikh should ever refuse a challenge, especially when the challenge is just to educate. All this means is Canada youth, with the help of us, need to be more vocal and articulate. waheguru ji kekhalsa waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

.. · 30 Oct 2005

I think in general their is not many problems with wearing kirpan in public in Canada, not saying its perfect though. But if we lived in a place were we had absolutely nothing to worry about in regards to wearing a kirpan, well only place i can think of khalistan. You cannot blame goreh for being a bit frieghtened seeing one wearing a kirpan when majority of them have no knowledge of the religion.

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

ken hunter · 31 Oct 2005

posted on Ottawa Citizen I was reading all the comments by readers. If one was to just see that as a reflection of Canada by someone like me who has moved from UK, one would think this is not a modern, open minded country. Instead this is a right wing Christian dominated country which speak down in a patronising manner to its ethnic minorities. I know that Sikhs of UK, are very widely respected. Even the National Audit Office in UK recognises them as the most succesful ethnic minority group in UK,even more than the Jewish. Similarly I see Sikh have been very successful in Canada over the last 30 years. Sikhs have faced a crisis in mistaken identity since 9/11, due to their appearance. However more disturbing is how other Canadians have made this situation into an "us and them". Are the Sikhs in Canada not fellow Canadians? Especially this young man who is born and bred in Canada. Who are we to lecture them about customs and culture, when they too are Canadians? Are we bigots or hypocrites?

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

Ottawa citizen · 31 Oct 2005

This has been blown out of proportion. Sikhs have worn kirpans without incident for years. Why the sudden "threat to public safety"? If this was the case then it should have been done years ago. Are we a society that is fuelled by fear? or do we need to be more rational. I think you will find passive smoking and GM foods are more a threat to health on trains? If you are going to ban kirpans, then you will be a hyprocrite if you do not also ban all guns, knifes for use, sport and sale in Canada!

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

decent canadian · 31 Oct 2005

good post by a decent canadian Name: S.Smith Email: [address removed] Occupation: Location: West Island Despite this articles very well made points on defining weapons, I still see this whole issue as one of paranoid racism. If a Christian was to attack someone, I somehow doubt that he or she might use the crucifix around their neck to do it with. Even if they did would you ban the wearing of crucifixes also? The daggers in question are so small you could inflict more damage with a Bic pen. But the danger that the weapon poses isn't really the question is it. It's who is carrying the weapon, the faith of said person and what is the likelihood of that person using it. If you do have the misfortune of coming face to face with an extremist, who wants your infidel self dead. I can pretty much guaranty you that he's not going to use his Kirpan. If colour of skin is how you decide if someone is dangerous or not, be on the lookout for white people, because killing is what we do best. Living in fear is fascism's best friend.

Re: Sikh’s sword not welcome on VIA train

kaur · 07 Nov 2005

well i think if the public is afraid and it is difficult to make them understand, then perhaps we should work close with them and tell them that we are like the army of GOD. If there is injustice happen to any civilians...perhaps we can save them...let us be the army or GOD and protect innocent people. But then anybody could just carry the kirpan. Well...the requirement for a person to hold a kirpan is that he must be with long kesh..mean with dhara and dastar, wears a kechera , kanga and kara. So the identity of a true warrior could be pictured clearly...so that the public would not be afraid anymore...instead respect the sikhs. Just an idea...which i think is a great idea. Khalsa mero roop hay khas