Forum
How did "1984" begin?
How did "1984" begin?
Useless · 21 Oct 2005
WJKK WJKF!
I know im gonna sound soooo stupid, but can you please tell how and why the events at Harmandir Sahib on 1984 took place. How did everything begin, for what reason?
What did Indira Ghandi do that lead Bhindranwale to respond the way he did?
WJKK WJKF!
Re: How did "1984" begin?
The TRUE FACTS · 22 Oct 2005
Bhai sahib, there are many sikhs today who very racist and behave like as there is only ONE side to a story.Any body that does not agree with them is quickly called a kesadhari hindu...so before they call me that ..I will call them ungian te ulu de patthe so called sikhs.
the story really started long before Bhindrawala cameon the scene.The indian government was being pro hindu and side tracking sikhs on some few BUT VERY important issues.but the Sikh leadership was stupidly also VRERY confrontative as well.Instad of seeking court verdicts and taking the legal line to pursue issues, it thought it can ride shotgun over todays india ...bhindrawala was brought by indira to split the sikh politicians, but he turned against indira.Killings started, he retreated into the harmanadr sahib which was TOTALLY wrong ..the sikh ledership is equally to be blamed as much as indira..she was a novice at sword fighting ...and misplayed and hence was cut down herself in the process and came heavy when it was too late and in the process many innocent Sikhs were killed ...and that started all off ...there are always two sides to a story ..then what happend was all wrong ..sikhs were kille dthe day she died...the sikh leadership meanwhile remained in effective in all these and still remains like that ...
WJKKWJKF
Re: How did "1984" begin?
singh · 22 Oct 2005
ppl need to look at this in an unbiased way, bhindrenwala was in harmandir sahin a long time before 1984 attacks.
with all theories, stories, versions of how events happened, its difficult to say whether bhindrenwla provoked the attack.
was the government plannig an attack before bhindrenwala took up residence inside the complex? i dont know the answer to this,
im not afraid however to admitt bhindrenwala made a mistake, im only afraid of speaking something which is false.
most ppl are afraid of putting any blame what soever on bhindrenwala, i think ppl should look only at the facts, and not falsify any, which i have seen done before, by people who look only for bised evidence.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
MB Singh · 22 Oct 2005
There are always two sides to a story. May be it is so. One kills other is killed. One is tyrant other is tortured. But we have to decide; with whom we stand for.
Bhindrewale represented feelings of the sikh masses at his time. He talked about Sikh demands in a forceful and logical manner. He talked about bravery and truthfulness.
One can prove, if he wishes so, that Bhindewale was "planted" by Indra; in sikh strugle. But who is not planted. I am planted here by Microsoft. P M Manmohan Singh is planted in India by USA. Every sikh on foriegn lands is planted by their countries; because they serve their interests.
Bhindeawale was great.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
P.S.Sandhu · 22 Oct 2005
Just read the book., " India Commit Suicide" By : Gurdarshan S Dhillion ( a punjab university history professor). ur all queries will be answered. book is available with "singh brothers amritsar".
fateh.
Parminder S Sandhu
Re: How did "1984" begin?
DDT · 22 Oct 2005
y was reatreating to darbar sahib totally wrong. Watever Sant ji did was completly correct. He started a morcha and was jathedar he could go to harimander sahib. GOI captured him and let him go and then blamed the attack on capturing him again.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
gabroo · 22 Oct 2005
"you MAY call me a something so let me cuss you first..."
that mentality bhai sahib, IS the fuel for the current state of this panth.
unbelievable.
may Waheguru have kirpa on us and those who have this mentality
Re: How did "1984" begin?
kirtan singh · 22 Oct 2005
I am personally beign hurt by this violence. My grand parents are hindu. my mom is hindu. My grandpa and his friends were killed by his neighbour who was sikh. it was during 1984. My grandpa was very vocal about killings insted of going peaceful route. because my mom married a sikhi he was proud of my dad. My dad was killedin air india bombing. You can gain freedom if you you pursue freedom with dialogue. But now my sikh friends want nothing to do with khalistan.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Prabhjoyt singh · 22 Oct 2005
"true facts" Please Explain how Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale were brought on the scene by indira?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
LionKing · 22 Oct 2005
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Bhaji "the True Facts"
I would not be surprised If you hadn't read a Single book about Panjab by an independent Journalist
Just having read the book BY A.R Darshi (Punjabi Hindu) you will learn a lot. I suggest you read it.
As for "useless bhaji"
I will try to narrate how the tension came about. This will be a pretty long post and you are recommended to read the mentioned links in the text -
* 1947 Pak/Indian Independence.
Sikhs offered own country during partition.
- Sikh leads made a lot of promises by Brahman- India, that if Sikh join India they will be entitled to a lot, such as having the right to split into a independent country if they so-wish and are not happy being with India.
All laws and rules will be done with the agreement of Sikhs. Indian Consitition will be pbulished with agreement of Sikhs etc etc
The main man would be Jawaharlal Nehru and M.K Gandhi.
Master Tara Singh & Baldev Singh the main Sikh leaders fell for it
Later when Indian constitution came, it included Paragraph 25(2) which is basically saying that Sikhism comes under the branch of Hinduism. (read Explaination II of 25(b) www.constitution.org/cons/india/p03025.html)
**********
(b) providing for social welfare and reform or the throwing open of Hindu reli- gious institutions of a public character to all classes and sections of Hindus.
Explanation I: The wearing and carrying of kirpans shall be deemed to be included in the profession of the Sikh religion.
Explanation II: In sub-Clause (b) of clause (2), the reference to Hindus shall be construed as including a reference to persons professing the Sikh, Jaina or Buddhist religion, and the reference to Hindu religious institutions shall be construed accordingly.
**********
Also the Anand Marraige Act (Form Sikhs had to fill during British rule) had been eliminated and replaced by "Hindu Marriage Act", and even today Sikhs have to fill that in for a court Marriage.(luckily most Sikhs don't do that)
Sikh leaders refused to sign it, but still it was put into action, and Sikhs understood they had been betrayed.
Nehru when Sikhs asked him about promises -"Circumstances have now Changed"
see Sikhundeground.com "hindu leaders section"
1966 - Punjabi Suba movement -
http://www.allaboutsikhs.com/events/punjsuba.htm
* 1973 - Sikhs Draft the "Anandpur Sahib Resolution", a draft prepared by the Akalis with the demands of the Sikhs.
http://www.sikhcoalition.org/Sikhism21.asp
http://www.sikhpoint.com/religion/sikhhistory/MainEvents/anandpursahibresolution.htm
Whilst the media say that Bhindrawaley demanded Khalistan, from his speaches you will understand that it is not true. He openly said that he was neither for it nor against it. The Gov decides whether it wants to keep Sikhs in India or not. Sikhs have a demand, if India wants Sikhs to stay with India those (the resolution) were the demands. If the Gov decides to give Khalistan, we will not make the same mistake as in 1947, but it is NOT A DEMAND - the DEMAND is the resolution. The resolution basically said that Panjab should get more rights, like in the US the states have more autonomy, with some local laws and some national laws. Please read the Basic Demands of the Sikhs
1978 - Nirankari Morcha. - http://www.allaboutsikhs.com/events/akj.htm
Nirankari "Gurbachan Singh" (called "bachna" By Sikhs) a governmetn agents begins his propaganda of being a living guru. Begin disrespecting Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Guru Gobind Singh Ji.
Said that if Guru Gobind Singh Ji made Panj Pyaare (five beloved ones) he would make Sat Sitarey (seven stars) - a straight Challenge to Dasmesh Pita, Kaligiya Valey, Shaheshan Sha Patsha.
Sikhs find out that 13th April, in other words- Vaisakhi 1978 Bachna is going to disrespect Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Singhs led by Bhai Fauja Singh Ji, go and peacefully protest. Singhs are welcomed by rain of bullets and 13 Singhs are Shaheed and more than 70 are wounded, but they do not allow the disrespect of Guru Sahib - so much was the respect for Guru Sahib by the Singhs. Today unfortunately we Sikhs don't even care about Guru Sahib and call Guru Sahib
"THE Guru Granth Sahib" referring to Guru Granth Sahib Ji as an object rather than a LIVING GURU!
You might also want to read this about the Nirankaris -
http://www.allaboutsikhs.com/events/kanpur.htm
* Tension between Sikhs and Gov increases. Sikhs hold peaceful protests, just as the blocking trains and traffic in the streets, for a day or two, by the Akalis.
Both A.R Darshi (Author The Gallant Defender) and the Investigation team of : Amiya Rao, Aurbindo Ghose, Sunil Bhattacharya, Tejinder Ahuja and N.D.Pancholi (Authr of report - Oppression in Punjab - Part of it can be read on http://www.allaboutsikhs.com/bluestar/ob08.htm)
Write that if the government wanted and were serious about it, they could have solved the Panjab problem a lot earlier but decided no to, and allowed the tension to grow...
The gov was responsible for creating drifts between Sikh-Hindu unity to isolate Sikhs.
As to why Bhindranwale chose to live in the complex is irrelevant as Mark Tully writes that the gov had made a replica of the Darbar Sahib complex in mountain areas in order to train the army to be able to kill as many people in as little time as possible. this was built and trained on 18 months before the attack. The Singhs moved into the complex 11 months before the attack.
If getting the Singhs was the point, then why didn't they do it when they were outside?
Bhindranwale and the Singhs were outside and did Parchaar a lot of their time, and weren't inside the complex 24/7 - they could have arrested them any time they wanted..
Ram Narayan Kumar writes on http://www.allaboutsikhs.com/bluestar/ob21.htm -
Sikhs kept asking for their rights and Anandpur Sahib Resolution. Government to oppress Sikhs and to teach them a lesson tried to attack the Darbar Sahib complex.
Until June 1 1984, Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale held his regular public meetings on the roof of the community kitchen inside the Golden Temple complex. The meetings were open to all, and it should have been possible for a group of commandos to nab him there by using minimal force. This was not done. It should also have been easy for specially trained sharp-shooters, who had positioned themselves on the buildings around the temple, to target Bhindranwale and his armed followers, and to "neutralize" them. On June 1 afternoon, mixed groups of various security agencies that had occupied the multi-storied buildings in the circumference did open fire against the temple complex when Bhindranwale was holding his audience on the roof of the kitchen building. Instead of targeting Bhindranwale, the sharp shooters aimed at various buildings, including the main shrine of Harmandir Sahib which received 34 bullet marks.
The white paper (gov report) says that Singhs started shooting unprovoked - ALL eyewitness reports say the opposite, the Gov shot at the Darbar Sahib unprovoked, and the Singhs did not shoot back due to strict orders not to shoot until the army enters parkarma. With the genious general Bhai Subegh (Some write Shabagh) Singh, Singhs were able to hold the army men out for 5 days. They weren't allowed to come even a few feet into the parkarma before they were shot at. Great was the planning of Bhindranwale and General Sugbegh Singh Sahib Ji.
The generals promised Gandhi that they will be able to take control over the complex after 2 hours.
For 5 five whole days they tried to come in, but failed miserably with the Singhs resisting. After five whole days of them not even being able to come close to the parkarma, the army had to use helicopters and tanks.
Why did the army cut all the connections to the complex?
Why was food supply shut to the complex?
Why were innocent people killed?
Why was the Red-Cross not allowed to come close to the complex, and weren't allowed to come closer than to the "Jallianwalla Bagh" approx 1 km away from the complex?
Surely they had something to hide from the rest of the world...
I recommend you order " A.R Darshi's - The Gallant Defender "
Punjabi - http://singhbrothers.com/private/db/auresult.asp?auth=A.R.%20DARSHI
English - http://boss-uk.org/stall/books/
http://www.biblio.com/books/8925010.html
He goes much into detail about the politics of the time.
You can read a few chapters on
www.shaheedkhalsa.com in the bottom of the library section
hope this helps
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa
Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: How did "1984" begin?
WTF!!!!!!! The real true facts · 22 Oct 2005
firstly i gotta say true facts is talkin a load of rubbish. i'm not sayin he/she a kesadhari hindu but only that he/she has been mislead or misinformed.
no1 can say Sant Bhindrenwala was wrong - he was more learned and pious than anyone contributing to this forum.
On 13th April 1977, head of Naqli Nirankaris named Gurbachan led a procession in Amritsar. Earlier he had declared that "If Guru Gobind Singh can make five beloved one's., he will make seven stars" . Naqli Nirankaris are strongly associated with Arya Samajis and other such organization which came out of need to reform Hinduism, from its age old superstitions and rituals., but these movements instead of targeting common Hindu individuals spearheaded their movement against Sikhism. Arya Samajis and Naqli Nirankaris wanted Sikhs to start shaving and to drop their individuality and assimilate into Hinduism (or their form of Hinduism with rituals like "Havan"). So on this occasion of Vasakhi, Gurbachan Nirankari led a procession in Amritsar. Bhindrenwale at this time was a small time preacher, who would visit villages and preach to youngsters to adopt Sikh practices. Akhand Kirtani Jatha with its leaders set out from Akal Takht to stop Gurbachan Nirankari for his act of "Creating five stars". Gurbachan and his armed accomplice fired at these Akalis and one by 13 Akalis were killed
After this incident, Bhindrenwale's reputation as a fierce emerging Sikh leader rose tremendously in Sikh political circles. From 1977 until 1983, Bhindrenwale led his agitation against Arya Samajis and other fanatic Hindu organizations who were working against Sikh and ncept of Punjabiat as well as many Sikhs who opposed him for his fanatical views. Many of his followers were young rural Sikhs, who had been disappointed with state and central government due to unemployment, poverty and other problems. After 3-4 years of trial, Gurbachan of Nirankari sect was acquitted by Indian court, even though more then 10 person testified against him in court, it was clearly evident that there were political heavy weights behind him as well as behind Bhindrenwale
Till 1983 about 500-1000 persons were killed all over Punjab by armed brigades of young motor cycle driving terrorists who would suddenly appear and with one burst of machine gun kill 10-15 people. Prominent Arya samaji leaders and news paper publishers of Hind Samachar group like Lala Jagat Narain was killed by unidentified persons and Government of India implicated Bhindrenwale and arrested him at Chowk Mehta in 1982, but he was released in two days. Then, in later half of 1982 he moved to Golden temple complex where he setup his headquarters in Guru Ram Das Sarai. In 1984 he moved to Akal Takht. Indira Gandhi and government of India declared president rule in Punjab and deployed 4 division of Army through out Punjab, in a desperate attempt to flush out Bhindrenwale and his accomplice from Golden Temple complex. Then it all started, I quote from much accomplished book called "Amritsar Mrs. Gandhi's Last battle", by Mark Tully and Satish Jacob "At Seven o'Clock on the evening of 5th June, tanks of the 16th Cavalry Regiment of the Indian army started moving up to the Golden Temple complex. They passed Jalianwala Bagh, the enclosed garden where General Dyer massacred nearly 400 people. That massacre dealt a mortal blow to Britain's hopes of continuing to rule India and was one of the most inspirations of the freedom movement. When Mrs. Gandhi was told that Operation Blue Star had started,she must have wondered whether it would provide the decisive inspiration for the Sikh independence movement, a movement whch at that time had very little support outside Bhindrenwale's entourage and small groups of Sikhs living in Britain, Canada and the United States. Major-General Brar was leading a mixed bag of troops, representative of the widespread recruiting pattern of the modern Indian army, which has broken with British tradition of limiting recruitment to certain 'martial castes'. There were Dogras and Kumaonis from the foothills of the Himalayas, India's northern border. There were Rajputs, the desert warriors from Rajasthan. There were Madrasis from Tamil Nadu, one of the most southern states. There were Biharis from the tribes of central India, and there were some Sikhs. Major Brar had joined Maratha Light infantry 30 years ago in 1954 as a lieutenant. He had fought in Bangladesh under Lieutenant-General Jagjit Singh Aurora, the Sikh general who was most outspoken critic of the Operation Blue Star."
Bhindrenwale and his group had moved to Akal Takht, the highest seat of Sikh authority few weeks before Army attack. He had been criticized for this act as he became the only person after Guru Hargobind to live in Akal Takht. He was obviously spearheading the last showdown with Indian army and had knowledge that sooner or later Army would attack and he himself wanted to go down in Sikh history as a martyr and not deserter or negotiator as other Akalis political leaders. He had support of Major General Shabeg Singh, unofficial hero of Bangladesh war., as well as thousands of rural Sikh youth.
Brar's superior officer was Lt-General Krishnaswamy Sunderji, who asked his chief staff Officer, Lt-General Ranjit Singh Dayal, to draw up the plans for Operation Blue Star. Dayal, like Brar was a Sikh, but he had not shaved his beard or cut his hair, and still wore a turban. Dayal was also an infantry soldier, having served in the Ist Battalion, the Parachute Regiment, which was to spearhead the attack on the Golden Temple Complex. During the 1965 war with Pakistan, Dayal became legend by capturing a pass which had previously been thought to be impregnable, and blocking off one of the most important routes from Pakistan-Controlled Kashmir into Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir. A frontal assault was impossible and so Lt-General Dayal climbed up the mountains towering over Haji Pir pass and came down on top of the Pakistanis.
Dayal, Sundarji and Brar drew up at twofold plan. The essence of this plan was to separate the hostel complex from the Temple complex so that the hostels could be evacuated without becoming involved in the main battle. To achieve the prime objective to get Bhindrenwale out of the temple complex they had planned a commando operations. Commandos were to be supported by infantry, Tanks were only to be used as platforms for machine guns to neutralize fire on troops approaching the Golden Temple complex, and to cover the Temple exits in case anyone tried to escape. Armored personnel carriers were to be positioned on the road separating the hostels from the Temple complex to keep the two potential battle fields apart.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
A Few True Facts About 1984 · 22 Oct 2005
The attack took place on the day of Guru Arjan Dev Patshah's Shahadat Gurpurab observations.
why on such a day when the Indian Govt. new there would be many innocent people visiting Amritsar(women, children, elderly)
The Golden Temple Complex was attacked by the Indian Armed Forces using tanks, helicopters, and other heavy artillery. Sri Akal Takhat was desecrated during this attack. Sri Darbar Sahib sustained at least 300 bullet holes. Thousands of innocent people were murdered in cold blood.
They were attending the Martyrdom day of Guru Arjan Dev Ji. The brave GurSikh soldiers in the Akal Takhat, numbering about 250, gave extremely tough resistance to the Indian army. However, their resistance was no match to the large number of tanks, helicopters, bombs, and other heavy artillery that destroyed the Akal Takhat
The destruction of the Sikh Reference Library is a loss that can never be fulfilled. No wealth in the world can ever restore what was destroyed during the Operation Blue Star by the Hindu government.
The Sikh Reference Library was fine until the evening of June 6, 1984. This has been verified by the in charge of the Library S. Devender Singh Duggal. The library was set ablaze on June 7, 84 in the early hours of the morning.
why was this destroyed?
THE INDIAN GOVT. DID NOT ONLY ATTACK AMRITSAR ON THIS DAY. MANY OTHER GURUDWARA'S ACROSS PANJAB WERE ATTACKED ALSO. SO OBVIOUSLY THIS ATTACK WAS AGAINST SIKHISM AND NOT SANT BHINDRENWALA.
In the temple the army came in with shoes, which you are not supposed to do, and attacked innocent people. They took the turbans off the worshipers there and tied their hands behind their back. They then shot them at point-blank range, execution style.
In all the army killed innocent pilgrims and destroyed half of Akal Takth [The 'Whitehouse' of the Sikhs]. It did not end there. Witnesses of the attack, even a four-year-old child, were put in jail.
India being a democracy gives the right to free speech and this is what happens when you exercise that right.
Sikh pilgrims who were held up by Army in buildings in and around Guru Ram Das Sarai, Teja Singh Samundri Hall, etc. These innocent bystanders were not given any food or water for 4 days. Army soldiers asked them to drink water mixed with urine from small puddles on ground. One army soldier went berserk and fired on these innocent pilgrims killing 70. About 40 or so bodies of Sikh men with their hand tied up behind in execution style, were found in several rooms. A Journalist saw a whole truck filled with bodies of women and children. There is more then enough evidence that Army Soldiers were served alcohol as well as cigarettes inside Golden Temple complex.
Learning of the operation Bluestar, hundreds of thousands GurSikhs from rural Punjab march to defend Sri Darbar Sahib despite the heavy presence of armed forces. They wanted to stop the sacrilege of Sri Darbar Sahib. Sikhs came from RajaSansi-Ajnala, Taran-Taran, Nawa Kott roads. They were fired upon with helicopers and thousands of Sikh marchers were shot dead. Several thousand Sikhs, including women and small children were arrested.
The above are all true facts! Now how can ANYONE say the Sikhs were wrong. Did Bhindrenwala take his troops and attack Ghandi or did Ghandi's troops attack the most holiest Sikh temple on a day when thousands visited it to pay respect?
We have a right to protect our people and places of worship and Bhindranwala took up this right. Thank Waheguruji that he did or we would still be undergoing the evils of the Indian govt.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
to kirtan singh · 22 Oct 2005
I'm sorry your granpa was killed.
But how many Sikhs were slaughtered after Ghandi's assasination.
there were huge riots after this in which Hindus burned down Sikh houses, killed every Sikh male within sight - set them alight and danced as they burned.
Sikh women would watch helplessly as Hindus murdered innocent Sikh males of their family.
you may have lost your grandfather but some Sikhs lost their Grandfather, father, brothers, husbands, sons, nephews
I think the figure was something like 20000 Sikh males being killed in Delhi alone while the police did nothing to stop this.
All this after Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji gave his life so Hindus could keep their religion.
WAHEGURUJI KA KHALSA WAHEGURUJI KI FATEH
Re: How did "1984" begin?
TRUE FACTS · 23 Oct 2005
People can speculate and call their littkle lies the true facts ...that happens all the time.The facts remain with such mentality Sikhs will never get far collectively.they have never got far.
The truth is Sikhs for whatever and probably the same mentality sealed their faith with a hindu dominated India, with out any constitutional gurantees.from 1947, they volunteerarily became part of India.PUNJAB and SIKHS WERE NOW PART OF INDIA LEGALLY.The fact later two Sikhs MPs walked out made no difference ...amny MPS walk out in a democracy ...akll the time ...this what sikhs fail to understand and keep up their age old rethoric ..about the verbal promise and news anouncements that nehru made ..that are always made to drive the point home to get the numbers to support ..by any politicians.
Why does no country support the Sikhs on issue of Khalistan ..because they know legally Sikhs are part of an independent country ..apart from human rights issues no one country will support ..I spoke in detail about this with three PMs of three countries during my visit to UN as part of a delegation of another country where I live , and where I was born ...but I am a Sikh.
After independance Nehru obviosly changed and the country changed.But theSikhs waoke up to a stark shcok...suddenly they found they had jumped from the frying pan into the fire.
Long unplanned and aimless in the main morchas started...it was one after another ....the Sikh leadershiop went with the attitude ...je lena taan sara lena, nahi taan kujh nahi lena ...when dealing with governments ..any one adopting such tactis is really tigthening the noose around their own neck ...had the Sikhs adopted the soflty approach of saying okay ...give us what you can NOW, we can review the situation later ...and either take the reamining demands to the courts, or put a few in a few years later ...and adopted the same attitude ..give us what you can now ....over the years we may had achived about 80 % of the needs, rthaer than the "demands"..but NO, the Sikhs kept clashing with the government ..
I have stayed many long months in 1983/84 with sikh politicians of very high standing and observed their mentality ....I wonder how did God created a kaum of Lions to be looked after by the ignorant and blind opportunists caretakers....
Long story short such confrontational attitudes by the AKALI DAL led tio the government becomming hard as well....and at the end of the day how could 1.5% sikhs dictate to a government run by 98% non sikhs?
Bhai sahib all these name callers..."waheguru" now they say ...(but not when they call names...) forget how even today SIKH LEADERS are driving the Sikhs astray with their OWN agendas rather than a Kaumi agenda...look at the golden palki nonsense, look at the horse that is dressed as Guru Gobind singh s horse and paraded every years ..look at the christian missionaries that are abundent in punjab and these leaders are all silent ...look at the jathedar pf Akal Takhat who himslef wrote a balsphemous book called gurbilaas paatshsi 6vin, but conveneiently jumped upon GS kala afghana to mislalign him ...look at Prof.manjit singh who being the head of a takhat is involved in real estate scandals...how can such leaders claim to speak the TRUTH and lead sikhs ..look at badal the tycoon who did NOTHING for the victims of 1984 during his rule ...BUT shouts the loudest now ..they are all the same ...people are NOt interested about the real Sikhsi but only in making the wealth when the opportunity arises ...it is only the Sikhs outside who are running around and shouting the loudes...ask any Sikh in India ...they say they are happy and very respected by the ordinary man in the street ...
But that does not hide the fact that Sikhs got short changed -they way to do the right is FOR SIKHS to UNITE. develop skills and networks where in todays world we can set up our own powerful business and systems and offer the jobs to our own first and anyon willing to adopt Sikhi ...we can soon control the financial economy of india...and othe rmajor cities like NY, London, Singpore..etc ...then issues will fall at Sikh feet ..but sadly our people dont understand this ..long term strategy ..instad they happy continually shouting on the streets and getting Sikhs the image of terrorists ..the jews did it why cant we ..we compare other things the jews have done ...but on this we go quiet ...
You know why we cant, because we have no sense to be united ..unity does not run in our Sikh veins ..where there is one gurduara , we fight to create another and split the community ...
I can gurantee you if Khalistan is created today sikhs will kill each other on the basis of jat, tarkhaan,. and shinbe or malwaii , majhel or doabia...
We should get our priorities right ...create sikhi that gives us unity ,create panthic economical power, that if goes on strike for one day can cause India to loose billions ..that they cant afford to loose...you will soon nanavati will be put opne and all c riminals arrested and treid ...other wise use the Panths collective financila power and litigate cases against these individuals ...and expose to the world press ...you will see how they cower down ..but no ..sikhs rather killeact other and fight over gurduaras..the reallity is people in India know what happend in 1984 was wrong and many are repentent ..I was in the south during Tsunami..people.. were hugging ..many were crying openly that despite the bad times in 1984, sikhs have come to rescue us today ..Sikhs have not been beaten but have risen successfully ..
look at today 's pakistan ....after the horendous killings of 1947, the muslims are welcomming Sikhs and hugging them on the streets for the Sikh help...while some nut head Sikhs are sitting behind the computers and continuing to call the hindus ..Racists NAMES ...WHAT MAKES THEM BETTER SIKHS?Is this not tit for tat ?Is this the Sikhi that Gurus gave us?In their blind hatred they twist reallity about the Bhindrawala era ..thefacts are bindrawala was equally to be blamed as the Indian government as well as the Sikh leadership..non of them thought of the poor Sikhs in the streets.
the issues that in 1978 this happend , in 1963 that happend are just minor events that took place along the journey to the destruction of 1984 ..many more happend that no body even remembers today ..
Someone asked how was Bhindrawal to be used by Indira.?She gave him the prominence, she did arrest him when earlier he paraded the streets of delhi with about 800 of his fiollows on trucks...he thought she could split the Akali party by pushing him forward..as a leader of sikhs..but for the treatment meted to sikhs during the ASIAN GAMES,HE TURNED AGAINST HER, and of course that meant agionst the congress government of Beant singh in Punjab.beant then ordered the racsacking of Mehta Chowk ////to please his own boss Indira Gandhi ..TIT FOR TAT started ..the Sikh leadership was sidelined ...they cowered in fear of retaliation from Bhindrawala ..bhindrawala was a good preacher ..he was not a politician ..he meant well for Sikhi ..but in the wrong way ..in this age ...forcefully .., he DID NOT ASK for khalistan....but did say that should SIKHs be offered it now ...Sikhs will NOT refuse...he started counting the numbers of hindus that come in ratio to one Sikhs to eliminate ...now talk like that is dangerous ...that starte dalarm bells ringing in the Hinndu community in punjab ..who strated to look towards the centre to help them ..beant saw this as an opportunity to please his bosess ..and started some heavy tactics ..in retaliation Bhindrawala followers are alleged to have started killings..tit for tat started!!Some of the police sided with Bhindrwala and closed their eyes to weapons being smuggled in ..others allege the police was supplying and planting weapons ...whatever weapons inside the HARIMANDER could only be used to fight someone outside...that someone inside was bhindrawala....outside was the police owing allegiance to the government ..
Why did he go into the HS?If the cause of Khalistan meant so much //surely it was common sense that the leaders must be alive at all times...look at bin laden ..whether he is dead or alive we do not know ...his campaign is very much alive ...surely he could have fought and killed himself ...like bhindrawala....
it was ill advised for him to hole up in the HS as that was a place of prayer ..he could have become greater had he walked out and surrendered to the police and let the law take its cause ...many things could have come to light ...he did not want to be arrested ...he could have invited the journalist from world over when he walked out ..he could have vanished off to another country and kept the movement alive and much more effective ..
on the other hand the indian govt did not need to attack on the shahidi day ,. killing thouands of innocent shardhaloos..they could have encircled the harimander and cut off the water supply and electriccity, they could have invited UN staff to oversea and offered bhindrawala a way out to go off to another country from where he could have strengthend his campaign ..In all these the sikh leadership ...kept silent and in fact many began to work with delhi or bhindrawala others kept mumm.
The whole issue got so complicated that no way out was left for nayone.Bhindrawala as is typical of any Sikh ..got himself onto a corner by issueing hardline statements that he will fight to death should the army enter to arrest him ...until he found he could not get out of what he said ...he was a brave man ...but sometime to die needlessly for a braveman is stupidity ...the indian government became harder ...beant singh playing his own game to avenge his own scores .....bhindrawala became harder ..
the facts remain both sides made a mess....bhidrwala was no politician, indira was no sword figther , beant singh was no angel of a person ...the Sikhs were in ytight conrer , the hindus were fed up with all the ninsense to break uop the coiuntry ..the pakistani ISI was deep into all sorts of nonsense egging the sikhs against india ..the foreign based sikhs were giving false hopes to the bhindrawala camp ...with their silly immature statements ...indira was trying to please the majority of population about the perceived threat to break up india into khalsitan and a feeling of wanting to teach the irking Sikhs was in the air ......the sikhs were shouting discrimantion and continually going over silly press statements prior to 1947..which really mean nothing as these were not part of any constitutional agreement signed between sikhs and Indian leaders..... eventually in these choas and tit for tat killings... HELL BROKE LOOSE!The indian army many of them sikhs attacked the harimander sahib ...which bhindrwala responded with..with force that surprised the army ..that called in more reinforcements ..and more damage and killings ......I wonder whose relatives were the Sikh soldiers. who participated in the attack ...funnily no body admits to that ...not even the so called computer based khalistanis ....the issue became more complicated..sikhs overseas wanted to beleive one side of the propoganda, other s another side ..next indira was assasinsted ...killings of Sikhs started all over north india ...innocent Sikhs were murdered brutally ...the sikh leadership was lost ...and justice to this day was not done ....aprt from shouting on the streets Sikhs themselves have not done much to better the community ... and make it powerful ....instead the same old sikh menatlity and politics continue for the worst.meanwhile it looks like india has matured and sikhs are looked upon more respectfully ..and in the process a sikh becomes PM...he increased the turban profil on the world stage ...but many Sikhs still will not hesitate to call him a kesadhari hindu ..in their continued hatred and blind faith ...well such sikhs will never make khalistan ..in the next thousand years ...the only way i see is to be come a good Sikh and strong sikhs and build the community upon love for one another ....make it powerful....generate the expertise needed in todays world ...soon ..we can have better than khalsiatn ...but as long as these different rehat maryadas, sampardais, and dals and accusations and counter accusations continue among sikhs we will never advance one inch into the direction of khaistan.
Of course many will find this irking as it exposes the true picture that Sikhs themselves are equally to be blamed for the destruction they have brought upon themsleves...
when we have learnd to administer ourselves properly then and only then can we thionk of something as responsible as a nation like khalistan -- unitil then all thse pro khailstanis we see on the nets are just ...phonies and out dated opportunitists living in a make beleive world ..we have not eradicated thes e sect and jaarwaad based gurduaras among ourselves ......khalistan is indeed a FAR thing and beyond our ability to run or even own !
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Zorawar Singh · 23 Oct 2005
read the Sikhs in History by Sangat Singh. An excellent book!
Re: How did "1984" begin?
khalistani · 23 Oct 2005
peope think this started with sant jarnail singh je
indra has been pissed with taksal ever seince sant kartaar singh je at dehli said indra is nothin, and if it wasnt for guur je all hindus wud be muslims
sant kartaar singh je fought agaisnt nakli nirankaris, and the panth contunied tha fight after there akaal chalanaa
the issues were many
nirankaris
radhaswamis
rss
gov wa changing the history books to go agasint sikhi
many issues
led to 84
sikhi is still in the same condition
the same issues still happenin
under a "sikh" pm
just look at the facts
sant jarnail singh je after being made head of taksal, raised his voice agaisnt the attocities commited agasint sikhs in punjaab
sant je just asked for basic demands
if u listen to there speeches no where does he ask for khalistan
he does say if gov gives it to him, they will take it
but sant j didnt ask for it
so was wit the gov sayin he was a khalstanin activist workin to divide the sikhs and hindoos
this is a lie
saant je helped many hindus who had there shops burned down by india, and then were told to say sant je did it, but some refused sayin we cannotlie
sant je gave money to people like them
an dhelped anyone who came to him
sant je didnt ride around in bmw's
he didnt use the sangats money for stupid uses
he didnt go into this for his own gain
as for sant je being indras puppet
this is a theory that is baseless
sant je was never indras puppet
sant je always told indra to meet him in person, there were no background meetings
refer to sant jes letters
many terriorsts were gov men sent to infritlate the sikh regiments
and there were some who were truly idiots
and did stupid things
those are not khalstanees
a khalstanee will not hurt an inncoent
gov was also a partof the iinnocent killings
and some peole did it for ther own intrests, liek someone near m pind robbed a bank pretninding to be a khalstani fighter, but after robbin the bank cut his hair
sant je did parrchaar
to make his parachaar more heard, he went to darbar sahib, his fathers house
sant je had also heard rumours of attacks being planned on darbar sahib, thus he warned india before the attacks not to attak it, sant je defended it
any son is welcome to defend his fathers house
sant je cud have went even if he didnt have his reason, this is the first time ive heard sikhs cant stay at the gurughar
was san tje not a sikh aswell
and y cudnt sant je keep weapons in the guurghar
shud amridahree now check in there kirpana at the entrenace to the gurghar
shud guur je have checked in his guns?
didnt guur je keep guns?
sant je did wat guru je ordered us to do
he kept weapns
if dehli sikhs had done as sant je asked, and told them that if there is a fire in punjaab the heat will come to dehli, and he told them to keep guns, if they had there never wud have been so much massacre of sikhs
they wud have been able to defend themselves
sant je was right
because they ddint keep shastar, they were massacred
sant je had all right to go and stay at akal takht, and he had all right to keep weapons to defend sikhi, and harminder sahib
if people wnna look at facts, even an idiot cud see tha india picked the worst day for the attack
it was a attck done to kill as many sikhs as possible
guru je knows wa happened
and they know who was right
we may hide from the truth in this world
but in the next we wil not be able to face dharm rai
bhula chuka maf
Re: How did "1984" begin?
facts · 25 Oct 2005
Guru Ji also knows everything else.If there was no history there would be no tomorrow.Buy history is not today.
Guru Ji knowing all is not is not suffiecient.Individuals are also expected to do something ..something sensible.
NOT crying over spilt milk and putting a full stop at that point.
it takes two cause a bang.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
khalistani · 25 Oct 2005
guru je knows eerything
its obvious to see wat happened
i dunt knoo wat kind of slow person combinded witht he date of the attack, the number of soldiers sent in, the fact sant je wasnt even pro khalstanee, the fact tha gov admits to sendin in black cats or somethinlike tha to infletrate singh groups, the fact tha at same time of darbar sahib attack more gurghars were being attacked at the same time, guess sant je was some how in all of them
guess tha they say they wented to kil a man who had before come out willingly wen charges pressses agsint them, but had to let san tje go BECUASE NO PROOOF
this list can go on forever
even after 84 how human rights says punjaab is hroibble with human rights
pictures f little kids killed by india
singhs torurted
inncoent people killed for being strong in sikhi
just hate
pure hate
guru je knows
no one wl be able to lie to or decive dharm rai
bhula chuka maf
Re: How did "1984" begin?
s s · 25 Oct 2005
I fully agree with my khalistani brother. I was in patiala on june 1984 and indian army break the wall and enter in complex of gurudawara dukh niwan sahib ji with a rain of bullets killing many innocent people.
this act of shame can not be justified in any way. Hope and pray this neve happen again.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
FACTS · 26 Oct 2005
It is amusing is it not ???The subject goes all over the place.We were trying to understand WHY and how 1984 too place and came about.
Here we are repeating every time what is true and what damage was caused ...we all know that ...no body is arguing that is how it did not happen , please addres s the issue rather than patting each other on the back and saying this is true and that is true and this damage was caused and that damage was ..caused....
THis how sikh jump off the trail and go on random elsewhere off....and never solve the problems...instead carry on bleating at one full stop!
Re: How did "1984" begin?
GHANDI WAS A MURDERER · 26 Oct 2005
WWW.SIKHGENOCIDE.ORG
Re: How did "1984" begin?
DDT · 26 Oct 2005
dont worry... when sant ji returns u can ask him ureself
Re: How did "1984" begin?
????? · 26 Oct 2005
all it was was we the Sikhs wanted a seperate country.
politics and power got in the way of minds and thats how it all got out of hands.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
DDT · 27 Oct 2005
we didnt want a seperate country we wanted equal rights and if we needed to have a seperate nation to get those rights then so be it.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
singhni wannabe. · 27 Oct 2005
Everyone is showing different views on what happened in 1984 but who really knows the true story on what happened? every where there are stories about what happened but which story is correct?
wahey ji ka khalsa wahey ji ke fateh.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
DDT · 27 Oct 2005
i'm telling u just wait for sant ji to return and ask him ure selves.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Gurcharan Singh · 27 Oct 2005
Sant ji will tell you that he did not want khalistan ..but if they offered he will not refuse this time.
India will tell you punjab is leagally part and parcel of india ....and if punjab goes,,,the whole of india will break up!!
Why could we have not settled this with a good debate instead of killing people tit for tat ?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Are you serious? · 27 Oct 2005
Are you serious "DDT"?
"wait for sant ji to return"
Come on, the Panth has acknowledged that Bhai Sahib is Shaheed. Even his family has acknowleded this by accepting a Saroopa from Akal Takht Sahib. How can you say he's still alive?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
khalistani · 27 Oct 2005
veer je are u serious
and ddt
i do benti to bothmof u not to get into this debate
ddt please stop sayin wait for sant je
y dont u wait for sant je and jus wait
dont bother thinkin bout it
do wat u can for the panth in the meantime
do ure bhagthee
just because sant je is gone doesnt mean we stop everything
and for are u serious veer je
many peopple stil belive sant je is alive
everyone will see if sant je is alive or not
time wlays realeals the truth
:)
so no need to fight on this
:)
we already have to many ocntreversies, just if u belive wait, if u dont, fine ok sall gud jus chill and everyone jus keep there belif to themselves and jus wait it out
if they come they will come, if they wont they wont
lol gurcharan singh je
hahahahaha
a good debate
u must really kno a lot of how to get freedom
guru jes own words
no one gives raj in this world
one must take it
india isnt gonna GIVE punjaab to u because u beat them in a debatge
they aaint gonna GIVE u ure rights and freedoms
its up to us with guru jes kirpa to take it
sikhs have tried asking
wat r u going to do when asking doesnt work
just take it
the person that takes it is not a sikh of guru gobind singh je
a sikh of guru gobind singh je is a saint soldier
SOLDIER
saintly soldiers who fight for truth, rights, freedom
any tru khalstanee wud not have killed innocents
ive already addressed tha in one of my earlier posts
the reason for attacking darbar sahib is simple
hatered for sikhs
y was it attacked by musalmans in our purataan history
was sant je there too
naw
the muslamaans then did it out of hatred of sikhs
india has done the same
and just as the muslim empire crumbled in india
the corrupt british raaj in india crubled
the corrupt hindu gov of india will also crumble
bhula chuka maf
Re: How did "1984" begin?
TRUTH & Facts · 28 Oct 2005
Bhai sahib .history has come and gone.They are now histroical heros..but they will not now fight for your khalistan ....use intelligence and make the WHOLE of india Khalistan ...not a littlke tukkrri ....it is nice to remeber these heros of old,but it is never easy to walk their deed...so be realistic....use intelligence ..increase numbers of Siikh converts and beat them at their own game ...
Re: How did "1984" begin?
DDT · 28 Oct 2005
wat i meant was that if u really want to no wat happened in 84 and if u really want to know how it happened u should wait for sant ji i didnt say that we should not do anything for the panth until they return. i was simply stating that the best way to find out about 84 is to talk to someone who was deeply involved and someone that was there when it all happened.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Gurcharan Singh · 02 Nov 2005
Vengeance
In the aftermath of Mrs Gandhi's assassination there was mayhem; Sikh
homes were systematically singled out for brutal destruction. Sikhs
were hounded, tyres were put around their neck, petrol doused on
their faces and set ablaze.
More than 3,000 were either burnt or butchered in Delhi itself. Two
hundred gurudwaras (Sikh places of worship) were burnt in Delhi,
hundreds of shops looted. A baffled, helpless community was
embittered: "And this is the nation we made so many sacrifices for! Why?"
The situation worsened when Rajiv Gandhi was quoted as saying, "When
a big tree falls, the ground beneath is sure to rumble." This gave
those who were wreaking havoc a boost. For Sikhs the trauma of 1947
was being replayed.
The Partition of India had robbed them of everything. They had worked
tirelessly to rebuild their lives and an amalgamation of karam (hard
work) and nadar (blessings) had helped the community to jump back
economically. The community had displayed strength and resilience.
Subsequent events proved Sikhs to be loyal, compassionate and
courageous. They did not carry a grudge too far. Hindus and Sikhs had
been like a nail to a finger. Language, customs, eating habits were
similar. They had coexisted peacefully. Suddenly Sikhs felt they had
become strangers in their own land. The entire community, with its
traditions of honour and chivalry, paid the price for the actions of
a few on its extreme fringes.
Mrs Gandhi's assailants were avenging Operation Bluestar. In June
1984 Mrs Gandhi wanted to flush out terrorists, led by Jarnail Singh
Bhindranwale, who were seeking refuge in the precincts of the Golden Temple.
Operation Bluestar, 20 years on
For most Sikhs the assault on the Golden Temple was unacceptable.
After all, they reasoned, wasn't the military required to combat
foreign attacks? Paramilitary forces were sufficient to guard
internal security. They were not appeased by the words of General K S
Brar, who led the Operation at 4 am on 4 June 1984: "We went to the
holy precincts with prayers on our lips."
Sikhs were observing the martyrdom of their fifth Guru Arjun Dev
(1563-1606), the builder of the Golden Temple, who fought against the
tyranny of the Mughals. Historically Sikh gurus had sacrificed their
lives for the country. The founder of Sikhism, Guru Nanak, had raised
his voice to protest against Babar's atrocities against the Hindus in
the 16th century. Guru Tegh Bahadur sacrificed his life for Kashmiri
Pandits (members of the Brahmin caste of Hindus who were/are learned
in the religious scriptures).
In proportion to their numbers, a mere 50 million in India and
abroad, Sikhs have made huge sacrifices for India and have firm roots
here. Operation Bluestar went against all they had stood for. The
Golden Temple was their most sacred shrine. Says Saran Singh, a
retired bureaucrat and a distinguished member of the community, "It
was sacrilege to send troops inside, open fire and in the process
kill innocent devotees gathered to observe the martyrdom."
The community felt that a political issue needed a political
solution, not military action. Sikh youths taunted the elders: "What
an award for all your sacrifices!" The Government of India had its
own justification.
In its White paper it stated:
The essence of the problem in Punjab was not the demands put forward
by the Alkali Dal but the maturing of a secessionist and
anti-national movement. The Akali Dal [a predominantly Sikh regional
political party] leadership allowed the initiative and control over
the agitation to pass out of their hands to the secessionists and terrorists.
The terrorists escalated their violence. With each passing day the
situation worsened. The subversive activists of groups inside the
Golden Temple had assumed menacing proportions in the context of
India's security. The influence of external forces, with deep rooted
interest in the disintegration of India was becoming evident. The
government was convinced that this challenge to the security, unity
and integrity of the country could not be met by the normal law and
order agencies at the disposal of the state. It was in these
circumstances that the army was called in.
From June to September 1984 most members of the Sikh community
nursed a festering wound. It was this wound that affected the young
men who were Mrs Gandhi 's security guards and who murdered her.
Khalistan
It was against this background that some political elements raised
their hopes of Khalistan or Sikhistan -- a cry for a separate
country, spearheaded by self-proclaimed leaders of the community. An
attempt was being made to create a sense of alienation.
For a decade after Mrs Gandhi's assassination Sikh youths were killed
in Punjab and Rajasthan on charges of terrorism. The demand for a
Sikhistan or Khalistan was not new. From the late 19th century large
settlements of Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs were established in West
Punjab. These had tremendous social impact.
The Arya Samaj was among the first of the reform movements within
Hinduism to seek to woo back Sikhs to its fold. This led to a
reaction from the Sikhs, and the Singh Sabha Movement (1880s), which
wanted an independent Sikh identity to be preserved, was launched.
Strangely the Sikh gurudwaras were managed by Hindu priests -- an
Akali movement was initiated to take back control and the Singh
Sabha's project in a manner of speaking merged into the Akali effort.
Finally in 1925 the Gurudwara Act was passed, recognising the
Shiromani Gurudwara Prabandhak Committee (SGPC) as the legal
authority to manage and control Sikh gurudwaras and the Akali Dal as
the political wing of the SGPC.
Religion and Politics
According to a senior journalist, B S Saral, where the Sikh community
is concerned religion and politics go together.
In fact Guru Gobind, the tenth guru, felt that it was not possible to
protect the faith without control of the political process. The basic
idea is that an individual who is truly religious, who is dedicated
to the Almighty, who does fear God, will always be conscious of his
actions and the result of those actions. Such a person will not do
anything wrong. If such a person comes to power, he will not do any
injustice to his subordinates or his people. If politics is checked
by religion, then politics will move in a better way to serve humanity.
The demand for Sikhistan was raised in 1944 during the Gandhi-Jinnah
talks. On August 20, 1944, at a meeting in Amritsar, it was Master
Tara Singh, the most powerful Akali politician during the Partition
period, who asked for an independent country for Sikhs.
The Akali Dal favoured an undivided India with constitutional
guarantees and electoral weightage for the Sikhs, but if Pakistan was
conceded then it demanded an independent Sikh state.
However, the arguments for Sikhistan were undermined by the absence
of any contiguous area where the Sikhs formed a distinct majority. In
1947 Sikhs comprised 1 per cent of the population of India and 14 per
cent of undivided Punjab. There was no Sikh majority area in Punjab.
Partition changed Punjab's ethnic mix, with Muslims now comprising
just 2 per cent of the population in Indian Punjab, whereas the Sikhs
now comprised 35 per cent -- up from 15 per cent.
In 1951 the first Hindu-Sikh riots occurred in Punjab over a census
study on whether an individual's mother tongue was Hindi or Punjabi.
A separate Punjabi Subba (State) was sought.
It was only on March 10, 1966 that Mrs Gandhi granted the Akalis a
state with Punjabi as the state language, after they had proved their
loyalty during the 1965 war with Pakistan.
Punjab 's social structure has always been unconducive to terrorism.
Sikhs have always been spread all over the country, even in the far
flung northeastern states. Well established and enterprising, they
have pursued their businesses with zeal. Sikhs and Hindus have been
close. The Sikh was the militant, protective arm of the Hindus.
Traditionally, each Hindu family in Punjab would make one of their sons a Sikh.
It is felt by some that the Khalistan issue was raised by Akalis when
they were not in power in a bid to secure a mass base. When they
became a ruling party, better sense prevailed. The majority of the
Sikh community finds little logic in the demand for Khalistan, seeing
it as instigated by interested political groups and neighbouring countries.
The origins of the movement in recent times came with the passing of
the Anandpur Sahib Resolution by the Akalis on October 16, 1973. The
major demands were seemingly innocuous:
1. Limit the power of the central/federal government to defence,
foreign affairs, currency and communications;
2. Integrate Punjabi speaking areas into Punjab;
3. Provide central assistance for power generation projects;
4. Institute agricultural reform, particularly in financing of farmers;
5. Provide a solution to water sharing with neighbouring states.
Over a period of time the non-fulfillment of these demands became the
cornerstone on which the secessionists attempted to capture popular sentiment.
Tomorrow: Present-day divided politics
Payal Singh Mohanka
Re: How did "1984" begin?
surrey jack · 29 Nov 2005
i don't want to live in a country with coward hindu's india has the biggest cowards in the world hindu's
[%sig%]
Re: How did "1984" begin?
asb · 29 Nov 2005
if jarnail bhindrawale did not come on the scene, it would'nt have happend.
this group wanted thei own country e.g. khalistan (which will never ever hapen) and when they were refused, they started saying bad thing about the indian government, which caused problems, and this then caused 1984
bhul chuk marf.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
_ · 30 Nov 2005
<<
i don't want to live in a country with coward hindu's india has the biggest cowards in the world hindu's
>>
Guru Granth Sahib does not teach discrimination based on religion.
Sant Jarnail Singh used to say for sikh to be true sikh, hindu to be true hindu, muslim to be true muslim. Even Guru Tegh Bahadur gave their head to save the hindu religion from extermination. Therefore imho sikh are to be like their guru and be paroupkari.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Prabhjoyt Singh · 30 Nov 2005
"if jarnail bhindrawale did not come on the scene, it would'nt have happend.
this group wanted thei own country e.g. khalistan (which will never ever hapen) and when they were refused, they started saying bad thing about the indian government, which caused problems, and this then caused "
Oh shut the hell up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You just a typical hinduwashed gulam Sikh (thats if are even a Sikh )
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Shaktishali Sha Soora · 30 Nov 2005
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
asb, what you said is completely rubbish, and watch and see Khalsa Raj will occur in india there's no doubt about that, there' s a secret about Khalsa Raj no one knows and it shall be revealed in the future to a special Panj Pyaria but not to panj pyara in india but in a different country, as the Sikhs in india have gone weak in sikhi-wise.
What Sant Jarnail Singh Jee did was great and i'm proud of him for what he did, and whoever disagrees with what he did can go to hell.
What he did was completely right.
VahegurooJeKaKhalsaVahegurooJeKeFateh
Re: How did "1984" begin?
tiger force · 30 Nov 2005
ha ha u lot tooo funny bhindrawale a sikh hero indra an indian hero they didnt get along so u no what happened bhindrawale never ever asked 4 khalistan
an interview was done with ks brar 1 of the genrals at the attack and they asked him why attack harminder sahib n why attack bhindrawale his excuse was bhindrawale was gonna declare khalistan soon due to their intlegance
wow wat a nice excuses
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Sehajvir Singh · 30 Nov 2005
HAHAHAHA
"if jarnail bhindrawale did not come on the scene, it would'nt have happend.
this group wanted thei own country e.g. khalistan (which will never ever hapen) and when they were refused, they started saying bad thing about the indian government, which caused problems, and this then caused 1984
bhul chuk marf."
Wow thats funny. The funniest comment i have read in a while. Thank you asb for ur informative reply. This comment is beyond ignorant its funny.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
gurdeep · 28 Feb 2006
yes
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Guru Da Banda · 23 Apr 2006
WGKK WGKF
Lots of mistakes were made intentionally or unintentionally by a lot of people (government and locals - Hindus and Sikhs) in Punjab during the 1984 crisis. I just wrote about 2000 words essay on it and deleted it, no use writing about it. All I say to all you guys is that we all were victimised by circumstances and politics.
Who benefited? Pakistan for sure.
Did Sikhs mean bad for Hindus? No.
Did Hindus mean bad for Sikhs? No, they were scared **** by the government to join the congress or else be done away by the Sikhs.
Childish politicians? Yes, they are should be held accountable for the lives lost.
Attack Justified on Golden Temple? No. Should have done it peacefully and without entering the Golden Temple.
Army to blame? No, just following orders.
Stories about Army attrocities? Maybe 10% true. Army did a lot good in villages and protected people from bad cops.
This is in short. Lets look forward to repairs in the future and punishing the guilty of '1984'.
Suggestions for us Sikhs and Sikhism in India and abroad? Need to glamorize 'Guru Roop' ie being a 'Khalsa' in real life and living proudly as Sikhs with turban, long hair and beard. We are well admired by the whole world. I love to see a 'Khalsa' when I see one! Our Guru's were great they faught for all the down trodden, remember we fought the Mughals and saved the Kashmiri brahmins from their tyranny.
Advise to Hindus? Please respect your Sikh brothers and the great Guru's for their sacrifices for you. Sikhs will always mean well to and for you. Sikhs should not be termed as 'Hindus' but 'Sikhs' as an entity if they feel so, by the virtue that they feel so.
I want to see that you all see the light as Hindus and Sikhs and move on in one spirit, and don't let your religious sentiments be ruined or motivated by petty politics.
Consider me to be a - Sikh/Hindu/Muslim/Christian/well wisher etc etc as God is One!
Be far sighted like our great Guru's.
Sat Siri Akal.
WGKK WGKF
[%sig%]
Re: How did "1984" begin?
PTE SINGH · 24 Apr 2006
Its easy sitting around in the US, Canada and the UK and talking about Khalistan etc, if you want it so bad go there, even the fundamental Muslims have the bottle to go and fight in their Muslim arenas. Claiming that all those who are, were against Bhindrawala as being anti Sikh is absolute rubbish.
The claim that Bhindrawalla spoke for the Sikh masses is absolute fiction. In a hundred years from now and a hundred years before 1984 no one would care about Bhindrawalla, he is already irrelevant, what has he achieved or effected that is good?
What our Sikh ancestors and children will ask is how could we have allowed the destruction of our sacred sites just to protect a group of renegades.
The operation on the Harminder Sahib was disgraceful in its proposal, planning and execution and all the terrible acts committed and the revenge for it was directly because of that attack.
For being so bloody-minded the blame goes to the government and the army, but the biggest fault lays with Bhindrawalla and us the Sikh community for allowing him to become from a political figure to a Sant who was allowed to occupy our most sacred shrine.
[%sig%]
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Hardeep Singh · 24 Apr 2006
If you guys are saying it was Sant Jarnail Singh Jee's fault that Sri Akal TakhAT got attack, NO your WRONG!! Indra Gandhri wanted to weaken the sikh panth and this will never happen. It soo obvious that Indra gave fuinds to nirankaris to weaken tjhe panth. It soo obvious and there's even a picture with indra and gurbachana. Come on!! we need to wake!!! Jaap naam and become sikhs of the guroo!!
Re: How did "1984" begin?
question mark · 24 Apr 2006
for the sake of the logic ok 200 militants needed to be flushed out in 1984.
the question is why were mock rehersals of op bluestar carried out in 1982 in the ussr?
why were 39 other sikh gurdwaras attacked in june 84?
and where were those and thei rgroups now critisising shaheeds yesterday in june 84?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Dogra · 24 Apr 2006
This has been interesting reading, Thanks to all.
Indira Ghandhi played dirty communal politics.
Bhindrawale occupied the Golden Temple.
The attack on the Golden Temple was an outrage when, as has been mentioned, cutting of the utilities supply and closed the temple untril the guns and killers came out.
As a govtn, it has to behave in a manner for the people. Guru Arjan Devji matrydom day was on that fateful day in 1984, surely Indira knew this, but still she chose to attack , says a lot about her, and her congress workers who, stirred up the attacks on innocent Sikhs in Delhi.
Also we had the killings in Punjab by terrorists, and the heavyhanded approach by KPS Gill, which stopped when the terrorists stopped.
Bhindrawale and Indira are no more.
The comment on granting Punjab more autonomy to make it more prosperous are reasonable should have been addressed. Punjabi is the language of Punjab.
Sikhism is clearly different from Hinduism.
In the words of Shaheed Udham Singhji "MY NAME IS RAM MOHAMMED SINGH AZAD"
Re: How did "1984" begin?
PTE SINGH · 25 Apr 2006
Operation Blue star was a shambles, an outrage and should have been avoided, however in response to QUESTION MARK.
The armed forces of all nations carry out exercises for all sorts of eventualities. There is no point in preparing after the event.
In the UK, plans for dealing with attacks on the London underground have existed for decades yet that does not mean the British government instigated the June 05 attacks.
Besides, Bhindrawalla had occupied the Harmandir Shaib complex by the early 80’s so security forces always knew that this was a possibility.
By Bhindrawalla’s actions, the armed forces were given an excuse to clamp down on other Gurudwaras.
I was 6 years old in 1984 old boy, but as an adult I will never allow any heavily armed militants to ever take refuge and control of our Harmandir Shaib
Re: How did "1984" begin?
. · 25 Apr 2006
Shaktishali Sha Soora wrote:
"What Sant Jarnail Singh Jee did was great and i'm proud of him for what he did, and whoever disagrees with what he did can go to hell."
So the most of the Babbars can go to hell as many did not agree? Are you aware that many of the Singhs in the movement did not agree?
Please think before you write. Once we have said something the damage is done and it is difficult to take back.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
more questions than answers · 26 Apr 2006
so if the army wanted bhai jarnail singh and his armed friends why did they kill 5000 sikh women and children out of 365 days a year one special day called gurpurb upon where thousands of householders would congregate to celebrate and converge on the temple?
compare 5000 civilians to 200 armed militants.
bhai jarnail singh bhindrawala held public speeches at various places from mumbai, delhi to punjab mehta chowk all the way upto june 1984.
i think the word "blunder" seems to cloud over the obvious facts we have a gov and a military here which deliberatly planned to attack a sacred shrine 2 years in advance ? rather than choosing to avert destruction of a sacred shrine knowing full well the implications would lead to further unrest. This is common sense.
If one were to apply logic without bias, let us for a second say jarnail singh was this villager all brauns for it. On the other side we have a govment with 40 years of experience of running a country, its military wing fresh from combat zones in bangladesh and pakistan fully aware of the line between militancy and civilians.
what options had congress I and the military exhausted before it went in fully armed with tanks to destroy the golden temple and 5000 civilians?
why did the government of india sanction destruction at 38 historic gurdwaras at the same time? what proof has india or the military shown any militants were killed or captured at these 38 sacred sikh shrines in punjab?
The most important question at the time why did rajiv ghandi call bhai jarnail singh bhindrawala one week before op bluestar "saint holy man" on his public visit to amritsar and how did this saint holy man tranform into the most wanted terrorist within a week?
why was the sikh library housing rare sikh documents blown up? why were the remaining important sikh contents handed over to raw? what use would raw the gov of india or the military have for scripts of any religion?
this does not seem like a military or modern government blunder to me, but a strategically planned programme for genocide to follow.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Sardar · 26 Apr 2006
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Bluestar
Please, this is my request. Take your time and read this whole piece of BS. The governement gave out the world wrong information about 1984, claming that militant Sikh group run by Sant Bhindrawale was full terrorists. It also says that militant Sikhs were against the government, which isn't true. The government was against the whole Sikh community, and it still is. Just read it. This is my request to the Sangat. I know it's long, but read the whole page, every single word. It's going to make soooooo furious!!!!!
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 27 Apr 2006
if the indian government was going to attack the golden temple whether bhinranwale was in it or not he should of stayed out of it and let the indian government do it then how would the indian government defended itself for attacking the golden temple for not reasion, the world would of seen the government as the true terrorists and supported the sikhs.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
PTE SINGH · 27 Apr 2006
This number of 5000 civilians killed- are you implying that 5000 civilians were killed within the Harminder shaib complex on that day?
There is no evidence at all to support that even a fraction of that number of civilians were killed.
For The indian Government to carry out this 'genocide' it would have needed
about 10 years of planning, much like the third reich in Germany and would it would only have been possible if there was a lack of democratic transparency, and a severe hatred for the minority in question from the public and the goverment as a whole.
Please explain and give evidence of what the democratic Indian government, the Armed forces and the indian public had against the sikh population ?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Sardar · 27 Apr 2006
"if the indian government was going to attack the golden temple whether bhinranwale was in it or not he should of stayed out of it and let the indian government do it then how would the indian government defended itself for attacking the golden temple for not reasion, the world would of seen the government as the true terrorists and supported the sikhs."
What do you mean he should've let them attack????huh????? you don't find it a big deal that the indian government attacked the "Komi Sikh House" Guru Gobind Singh JI didn't create a Khalsa who would step out when there is a problem in the Panth. Bhindrawale and jis Jatha fought and they achieved Shaheedi. Maybe that's what you would do when you see indian government with tanks inside the parkarma of Shri Akal Takht and Harminder Sahib. Maybe that's what you would do when you see indian government going around killing Sikhs and you're standing there in some hiding place saying to your self"maybe it's better if i step away....at least i won't lose my life" even if Bhindrawale had done this, still there would've been other attacks on Sikhs. Why do you think the two Sikh body guards shot indira gandhi?? first, she attacked Harminder Sahib and Akal Takht along with the indian government. and she had other plans to kill Sikhs that her two Sikh guards knew about.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
...... · 27 Apr 2006
well to be honest i think she only attacked harminder sahib because jarnail singh bhindrawale was in there...
and if he wasnt present in the harminder sahib then all of this might not have hapenned and this is not stating whether he was in the right or not but if he wasnt present in the harminder sahib then it wouldnt have got attacked...however still do believe whatever happened was wrong!
...yh and i know half of the sangats gunna be going crazy after reading but at the end of the day im only asking because things dont make sence to me.......
and pleaseee dnt cum up with sayin that she was going to attack harminder sahib anyways because i really dnt think she would have.....
..also, i really dnt understand what jarnail singh bhindrawale was doing in the harmider sahib? i mean for what reason...( its not a rheotorical question by the way)
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 27 Apr 2006
"sardar" i didn't mean that you should run away when you see the indian government attacking the harmandar sahib what i meant was that jarnail singh bhindrawle should of never bin in the harmandor sahib he gave the indian government a reasion to attack the harmandor sahib damage it and kill inocent people, it should of bin common since then to know that if he stayed in the in the harmandar sahib it would be attacked and common sence for everyone that the indian government wouldn't attack the harmandar sahib with out a reasion it would be the dumbest move by the indian government, I also have had many family members fight for the cause and die fighting for the cause unlike cowards like you "sardar" and the other 70% of the so called sikh militants who would runn of to england america canada and try fighting from their and ive had a relative murdered in operation blue star because of the indian government and jarnail singh bhindrawale who should of surrendered right away to protect the inocent lives that would be killed in the cross fire, he should never entered the harmandar sahib and turn a place of peace and love and worship into a military camp. No jarnail singh bhindrawala didn't protect the harmondar sahib and die fighting to protect it he was the reasion it was attacked. Jarnail bhindrawale knew the government would attack and he knew if he stayed and tried fighting the indian government from the harmandar sahib it would put fire in every sikh's heart watching and hearing about the government attack the harmandar sahib and jarnail bhindrwala knew he would go down as a hero who fought to protect the harmandar sahib but in reality jarnail bhindrawala was the reason the harmandar sahib was attacked and both the indian government and bhindrawala and his militants deserve to rot in hell for operation bluestar. Now for other khalistan militants who deserve to rot are the people involved in the air india bombing who let the indian government send in double agents to manipulate them to kill inocent people like cowards and destroy the sikh identity while the indian government celebrated for successfully taking control of the sikh militant organisations and using it to destroy the reputation of the sikh community.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Prabhjoyt Singh · 28 Apr 2006
Was Sant Ji in the other 39 Gurudwaras????????? NO so shut up
It would have been cowardly to surender thats what torha longowall badal ect. did. I think nindaks like ,if, pte and dorga realy need to know the truth and stop with this slave attitude if you are Sikhs and if your on of these chapli de congerssi or badalie sikhs take your propagand elswhere or if you think your bad enuff come out and say these things in public the hyde park rally that would be a good idea dont you think???????? and as for "Why was Sant Jarnail Singh in Harmandir Sahib? " the answer is he lived there and NO ONE not even the badals or the SGPC objected so if some one came to attack your house would you protect it or surrender like a coward your house may be different but what about your Guru's house? what a true Sikh would DIE defending his Guru and his/her Guru ji's house so stop being cowards "if" "pte" and "dogari" and if u wanna say something say it in public instead of hiding behind your computers and talking trash!
and i request Admin Ji not to allow such posts that do nindia of our great Gursikhs and Shaheeds.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
sharma ji · 28 Apr 2006
the white paper version of india via media has had almost complete success in its version totally contradicting the sikh side entirely in brainwashing the indians to believe operation bluestar was the right move.
how many indians or people outside believe sikhs were massacred? how many believe operation bluestar was right? see this is the power of the white paper, whatever is constantly drummed out 1000 times will become truth however cold evil or callous it is.
Even if bhindrawala had been ten steps outside, they would still have blown it up and wrote officially he was inside as they had blamed him for almost every crime in india.
If they wanted him dead why could they not do it anywhere other than the golden temple? why was the destruction of a sacred shrine vital to the completion of this operation?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 28 Apr 2006
listen him being in the harmandar sahib gave the government permision to attack.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
KS · 28 Apr 2006
Sikhs are always armed, during the time of maharaja Ranjit Singh paintings of the time show Sikhs armed with guns and cannons at the Akal Takht. The Indians spent years planning this attack, Indira saw the Sikhs as a threat to her rule. The June massacre and the Nov 84 massacres were all pre planned by the Indians.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Dogra · 29 Apr 2006
Prabhjoyt, what are you talking about talking trash, and why do you want these comments banned?
I am no nindak or whatever, stop making baseless assumptions. I am just a person who is not that religious and wants to know more about all that happened in 1984.
If it was a case of defence then why were innocent people killed in Punjab by the supporters of Bhindrawale????
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Prabhjoyt singh · 29 Apr 2006
sif they were sfter Sant ji thay had already arrested him in the lala case before why didnt the sentance him then? coz your chachay werent after Sant Ji they wanted to "teach Sikhs a lesson" i bet your jus some who talks trash all the time because even if you didnt agree with SanT Ji, and were an Amritdhari Sikh u would neve say things like "Jarnail Singh Bhindrawala should rot in hell" so you must be one of those who do nindia of eveyone if your not im sorry but thats just a fact a Gursikh never does nindia of another Gursikh!
Re: How did "1984" begin?
lakshman chander · 29 Apr 2006
why was operation bluestar launched? to dent sikh confidence in its glorious traditions of miri piri through destroying darbar sahib and akhal takht the parliament of the sikhs. The conflict between the sikh nation and ghandis personal empire was a power struggle.
in order to remain the rani of india indra introduced tight legislation in 9n the late 1970s that meant power would remain in her hands, and opposition would go to jails. The opposition were hindu politicians. At the same time sikhs were agitating peacefully for rights covering religion, lingual and restoring cultural freedom. The peaceful movement was called darm yudh morcha. During this period sikhs demonstrated for both punjab, sikhs and hindu opposition politicians. This caused the opinion polls around different indian states into a u turn against indra , she was no longer regarded as a leader. Dharm yudh morcha was launched from the golden temple and akhal takhat each time with the sacred institute of miri piri enshrined.
Therefore the sikh religion itself was a thorn in the side of ghandi, as it unlike others had a dual role on earth. Indra becoming unpopular led to a grduge between her and the sikh nation.
She needed to swing opinion her way and stop the dharm yud morchas. Therefore she and raw would blame sikh militants for rises in crime levels, causing divide, and demaidning seperation. When in fact various sikh groups were reviving gurmat, amrit sinchar, and trying to stand up in the face of strangling communal policies of congress i. The media of india at the time had taken efforts to daily report sikhs were trying to carve a seperate country with the help of pakistan. Then indra would send in her own bomb squads and blame sikhs. At this time various sikh groups were barely trying to restore the rights of sikhs and punjabis by going to jail and demonstrating many of whom are still rotting in jails as we speak. In a period of time indra and raw managed to manipulate coimmunal politics and turn hindus against the sikhs. The final countdown left would be operation bluestar to avenge her insult. To get to this level she had demonised bhindrawala as the frankenstein ready to eat up india with a pakistani army waiting to help him. Therefore further drumming support in favour for action against him with the pretence of flushing out militants holed up inside golden temple. Through op blue tara she managed to gain revenge and tried to dent the sikh psyche.
A time came when sikhs demanded justice from torture rapes through police, courts, appeals all of no response. When the law , the courts who are supposed to administer justice do not, the police who are supposed to protect the rights of a citizen instead of raping and torturing its subjects. It was this time when sikhs were told to bear weopons to defend their lives, as nobody else would defend them. we can walk out in canada america and england without being harrassed or tortured by the police, but it was not like that for sikhs in punjab at that time.
This is how 1984 came about. on the topic of babbars not for defending darbar sahib i have no idea about akj bk or taksali all i know is shaheed bhai mengha singh babbar took the first bullet in 1984 defending darbar sahib. If this posture was wrong i am sure babbar singhs would not have been shaheed. From what i have heard shahheed sukhdev singh babbar had wanted to defend darbar sahib but had been told to lead the movement outside.
There is no straight forward black and white picture like some are trying to create here. indra did not just have a grudge with bhindrawala, she had it in for the akali movement who when it came down to june were not around . the same akali movement which had fought for dharm yud morcha. The sikh shahid parivars, jajaru jathebandis have experienced a completely twisted official account which is a deep lieing insult to the truth. Even if bhindrawala was not born, as long as sikhs protested in the form of miri piri from their sikh parliament she would have found an excuse. This is the black politics of the day. There are no straight forward facts as if bhindrawala was not there it would not happen. another 1984 can be launched any time again, we do not have a bhindrawala, as soon as amrit sinchar resounds into a growing success in punjab will mean sikhs will begin to recognise their rights as individual. it is this the bjp rss shiv senas would not be happy to see. But raj karega khalsa in the end.
the khalsa will flourish no matter how many setbacks it will face. The instituition of miri piri has been established by Guru sahib.
so who gave permission to india to attack 39 other sikh gurdwaras in june02 1984?
who gave india permission to invade and launch operation black thunder in 1986?
who gave india permission to massacre 250 000 sikh children, fathers, mothers, sisters and brothers?
or permission to;
-torture sikhs in guru gobind singh jis roop and amrittharis?
- run circulars in the army stating amritthari sikhs are a threat to india.
- strip punjab of its territorial rights hariana, uttranchal,
- strip punjab of its cultural rights punjabi language which required sacrifices to restore it. and what did nehru promise when punjab was deciding its future in 1947?
-strip sikhs from freedom with the black tada law?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
t dot jatt · 29 Apr 2006
so why arn't we blowing up india any more it pissed me off sitting back while you have to see in indian media how they make fun of sardars and all any of the sikhs can do is insult one.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 29 Apr 2006
ps i wish this website would let me post my comments because most of them arn't making it onto this site, what ever happened to freedom of speech why our so many of my responses not making it to the website and being cencored.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
PTE SINGH · 30 Apr 2006
Prabjoyt Singh,
When you come down to insulting people just because they hold a different view point, thats when you have lost the argument. Please base your points on facts not insults.
You have no idea about the peronal history's of myself or the other people on this forum, so you are in no position to question our Sikhi.
In the words of our tenth Guru " the person who speaks the truth is always at ease" You my friend seem uneasy.
The Harminder Shaib is the home of every person in the world, hence the name Har-mandir. Bhindrawala had no right in inviting his personal problems and fight to the home of the 50 million Sikhs that have EVER existed in the last 500 hundred odd years.
In the same way that you think that i should stop hiding behind my computer screen and come out in the open. Bhindrawalla should have come out from hiding in the Akal Takht and come to face the Indian Army out in the open.
Please remember that this was not the first time that an army had come to attack the Harminder Shaib. (read your history rather than insult those that have) But previously the brave sikhs came out-side to defend the shrine so as not to have it damaged, were they cowards??
If the Harminder was always gonna be attacked regardless, then why out of the 20 million Sikhs around the world was Bhindrawalla the only one that knew of this imminent attack? Or was he the only Sikh of out 20 million that cared?
The Harmindar Shaib was not Bhindrawalla personal fort but a shrine belonging to the past present and future of Sikhism and should have been treated as such by both sides.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
RS · 30 Apr 2006
PTE Singh,
The vast majority of sikhs at the time supported Sant Jee and his stance. There were only a few who were against him.
If the majority of sikhs weren't with Sant jee on this, there was no way he could have stayed at Akal Takht Saahib. Maybe you weren't around then and don't know.
In history, when sikhs defended outside of darbar sahib (during guru Hargobind Sahib Jee's time), they defended at the point where there control began. Basically at the point where the enemy entered there land, they defended. This was at some distance from Darbar Saahib. There is nothing in there to suggest that Guru Saahib wouldn't have fought at Darbar Saahib if needed. Remember, it was Guru Hargobind Saahib Jee who build Akal Takht Sahib next to Darbar Saahib. Akal Takht Sahib was a direct challenge to the Dehli Takht, a symbol of sovereingty and the military headquarters of the panth. This is where money and weapons were brought. As such, it represented a target for the moghuls. If Guru Saahib thought like you, they would have built it somewhere else. They wouldn't have built it next to the spiritual center of the Sikhs. However, they did.
Guru Gobind Singh Jee defended at Anandpur Sahib. This town was as important to the sikhs as Amritsar Saahib. But the sikhs did not leave without a very long and tough fight.
Our Gurdvaras are not just symbolic pooja centers. They fly the nishan sahib and represent the freedom of the Khalsa. If Sikhs can't take in weapons to Akal Takht Saahib (a tradition started by our guru's) and can't stay there due to government pressure, then they are no longer our gurdvaras. The takht of Delhi can never be higher than the Akal Takht Saahib. It can never tell us what to do. It is better to fight for that principle than to act like the French in WWII and leave our shrines to look beautiful.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 30 Apr 2006
only offensive thing i said on my last post was if Prabjoyt Singh were to call me a coward or not a true sikh to my face i would beat and i don't know anything else offensive i said and that ive had family that made termendance sacifice while his family sat in america or were ever crying about whats happining in india while i had family fighting for the cause rather then sitting on the other side of the world like little cowards while supporting the cause, if your gonna support the cause then go fight for it when the war was on and i wish you guy's would edit the good things out of my last post and post it down.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 30 Apr 2006
i have come up in the open and insulted sant jarnail singh Prabjoyt Singh Bhindrawalla and no one has said anything to me that includes the hardcore bhindrawalla supporters usually they understand my point of view now if i were to say this stuff to your face lol i doubt you would have the guts to raise your voice at me, unlike your family i come from a family of true fearless lions unlike your family who probably sat on the other side of the world in america or canada trying to act all brave but are to scared to fight anyone or anything let alone try taking on the indian government, now how do you call sant jarnail singh bhindrawale a gursikh, he probably was a gursikh till he entered the harmandar sahib and turned it into a military base at that moment he was no longer a gursikh, he didn't protect the harmandar sahib he was the excuse indira gandhi needed to attack and i bet she was so happy to hear that bhindrawale was in the harmandar sahib because thats the break she needed to hurt the sikh community and she did, and i know the indian government wanted to pull a genocide on the sikh's like hitler did on the jews thats why so many from my family laid down their lives for the cause. Now that gursikh's our on the decline in india especially in the punjab more people are doing drugs cutting their hair and becoming acholics sikhism is on the decline and barely surviving, now were is bhindrawale now to protect sikhism, their's more damage done to our community after he died then their was while he was alive. The reasion the government didn't charge bhindrawele when they arrested him but attacked him was when he was in the harmandar sahib is because they had no evidence against him but when he was in the harmandar sahib the indian government was able to come up with a story to tell the world they had to flush out the militants and now were allowed to attack the harmandar sahib.
And im my opinion you are no longer a gursikh once you turn the harmandar sahib into a place of politics and a military base, i agree with the post that lakshman chander made about indira gandhi wanting to attack the harmandar sahib but she needed a reasion and the day the militants turned the harmandar sahib into their home she must of bin jumping up and down because sant jarnail singh Bhindrawale just had given her a reasion to attack and hurt the sikh community while having the support from the people of india and she was also able to use the excuse that if sant jarnail singh bhindrawele would hide in the harmandar sahib for sure their must be more of his supporters in the other gudwara's, i agree the government wanted to do to the sikh's what adolf hitler wanted to do to the jews but when it comes to fighting a war lets not fight a war without remembering how a true gursikh behaves and fight's if we had done this in the first place india and everyone involved in hurting the sikh community would of bin punished including kps gill and rest of the congress party. Ive lost many family members in this cause and i hate having to go against my fellow sikh's and getting angry but while so many sikh's have suffered and no justice has bin done for them most of the sikh community terified out of their minds stand behind and support these so called gursikh's while they rob our gudwara's while they took donations to help the cause for khalistan but just stole that money honestly out of all that money that was donated for the cause and to help our sikh brothers and sisters in india were the hell did most that money go because the sikh community won't stand up to these morans sikhism is almost dead in india their are not many true sikhs left their all going extinct and the indian government is winning look at the condition the sikh's in the punjab our in, majority of them are acholics cut their hair like honestly and yet we havn't bin able to fix the problem yet because in order to win this war we need to clean up our own community of all these evil . I need some proof that the gudwara's a place of worship and peace can be turned into a military base and become a house of politics while their our inocent people inside.
ps: PTE SINGH thank you for understanding the point of view im trying to make and to the website i hope this passes the cencors.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Dogra · 01 May 2006
Shaheeds Bhagat Singhji and Udham Singhji never killed innocent people.
Some Khalistanis did, this plain and simple fact and should not be swept under the carpet.
Also why is Guru Nanaksji's birthplace not in the Khalistan map?? Is this because the Pakistani ISI would not be happy?
Also some Khalistanis have shown hatred towards those of the Hindu faith, this is not what Maharaja Ranjit Singhji did, his was a secular land, without dirty communal politics, like we had with Indira Ghandhi and the Khalistanis.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
use your brains · 02 May 2006
darbar sahib is the mecca or vatican for sikhism.
if 200 christian militants were in the vatican would the EU army blow up the vatican?
if 200 muslim militants were in mecca would the saudi fawj blow up mecca?
reality and history of the world has shown us examples of shrines and attacks by state and terrorists on shrines such as darbar sahib abdali, and the recent attack by sunni militants on one of the most holiest shia mosques in iraq.
any attack on a shrine is wrought with havoc and destruction.
India also allowed the destruction of babri masjid and desecrated hazratbal mosque.
here we have a proffsional army and its government not freshly won in a by election with no experience, but with 40 years experience of running a nation. Bombarding mock complexes of darbar sahib 2 years earlier while bhindrawala would be moving from place to place in india preaching.
If one recieves news darbar sahib will be desecrated with a modern army equipped with state of the art machinery, planes, copters the lot, how would you have defended a shrine that large? bhindrawala may be cussed down for that. But he was not holed up or turned it into a military camp, the bunga towers, kirpans in a gurdwara, nishan sahib, all present a warriors dharm. In sikhism we do not have templs seperated from state, the sikh nation is an inseperabl part of the sikh faith. The sikh nation has to defend its right when under attack.
Bhindrawala was not alone, never in history had so many sikh groups united to face oppression. Most sikh groups had supported the defence of darbar sahib if not actively engaging. personally i am not a supporter of bhindrawalas group and find some things questionable, but like most sikhs am fed up of hearing stuff like sikhs were to blame for 1984, this is plain lie.
Indra wanted darbar sahib destroyed to avenge her political dishonour, sikhs were blamed for everything wrong in india. Therefore op bluestar would have happened anyway as long as the ramification of sikh politics crated waves and challanged the misdeeds of imperialist ghandi.
so get it through your head 1984 was inevtibale, bhindrawala or no bhindrawala as long as there were huge demonstrations of sikhs using politicis the right way and challanging indian so called democracy, any government on earth would find a pretence to launch an attack just as bush did on iraq for oil.
governments do not care for people bottom line.
understand bhindrawala was just a soul in a body he was not the start or end of 1984 .
india found it easier to buy the akali leaders out to control sikh politics from top layer and sgpc controlling shrines after 1984.
so use your brain bit of rational thats all it takes.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Prabhjoyt singh · 02 May 2006
Ok "iffY" you say your family made major sacrifices i can easily sit here and write all the torture my father had to through for supporting and fighting for the movement but thats just ego. and plus when the Harmandir Sahib was attaked i was
-5.5 years in age. so your family made alot of sacrifices? thats great! but why are you going against a cause that so many people sacrificed their lives? and did your family members sacrifice themselves for the Sikh cause so why are you going against them? sorry if sounded harsh in my previous posts but i just hate it when someone insults the Shaheeds of the KHalsa Panth
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 03 May 2006
Prabhjoyt singh im not against the cause im all for it but we need to learn from all the mistakes we have made in order to win this war, as far as im concerned the war is not over and this is the time to learn from our mistakes so we don't make them again for example the men who were supporters of khalistan yet murdered other people of other faith's to creat a talibon style sikh country is wrong and i know their were many of them but i also know that the indian government sent many men who claimed to be khalistan supporters and murdered inocent but i know sikh's who were hardcore khalistan fanatics murdered inocent and that is not what any of the guru's would of supported and in the end hurt us bad for example with the air india bombing i believe the indian government was behind it all but used the babbar khalsa to do their dirty work. Also we need to stop fighting within the community and have all the people who will fight for the cause to come to an agreement on same terms rather then have 5 different groups with 5 different ideology's fighting a war we need all of us to stick together with one goal in mind that is freedom and justice. We need to expose the corrupt sikh's in the gudwara's who steal money who fight in the gudwara's over table and chairs like common this is exactly what the indian government wants us doing, we need to stop attacking people who don't support the cause but our main goal has to be to destroy the indian government and any politicions with nazi style mentalitys and bring justice for all those who had lost loved once in the 80's and 90's and work together not against eachother gettin jeolous of others success does not help and we need to help the sikh youth of punjab because every year that i visit i see more and more cutting their hair doing drugs getting drunk and turning into criminals and this is exactly the indian government game plan to destroy sikhism in india with out using much force.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Prabhjoyt Singh · 04 May 2006
yes anyone can admit there were kharkoos who killed innocents BUT Sant Jarnail Singh Ji didnt and Babbar Khalsa Didnt blow up AI! and as for your veiws about Sant Ji comming out of Harmandir Sahib and fighting, that would be just like surrender, it doesnt matter whether he fought from inside or outside the Harmandir Sahib would have been destroyed no matter what! and as for politics and military base in Harmandir sahib the 2 nishaan Sahibs represent Miri and Piri, Sanit and Soldiers so whats the problem? and as for "harmandir Sahib was never fortified etc" the Akaal Bungay were built to be fortified and protect the Harmandir sahib against attacks
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 04 May 2006
but what would india tell the world as their reasion attacking the harmandar sahib and the people of india, killing inocent people inside the harmandar sahib and i believe if bhinranwale stayed out india would less likely to attack, i know india wanted to attack the harmandar sahib but indira gandhi was a smart politicion and wouldn't of attacked without a reasion that is why she is one of the biggest names in indian history unfortunatly, and i don't think india would of attacked the harmandar sahib without a excuse to tell the world they were alot smarter then that but if they would attack the harmandar sahib for no reasion no excuse and the militants knew this the first thing the militants inside should thought about if inocent people would be killed in the cross fire and how to keep them out of the way and to not live inside but to protect it from the outside like their had to be a million other strategy's they could of used and the number 1 thing i think about is the inocent people killed in the harmandar sahib and i still find both sides accountable but believe india is more accountable because they were waiting for so long to attack.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 05 May 2006
the harmandar sahib is not to be used as a military base when their our inocent worshippers inside.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
but what if? · 05 May 2006
akhal takhats purpose is an integral part of sikh religion. This is what india wanted to destroy.
india has murdered hundreds of thousands of sikhs in punjab.
what did it tell the world about that "if "? it was hunting terrorists.
innocent amritdharis young old men women mothers sisters grandmothers daughters babies thrown onto blocks of ice, scalps ripped apart, bones rolled into powder and blood with belneh. India told the world it was facing terrorism, the reality was amritdharis were being exterminated.
The world did not really blink an eyelid to the sikh holocausts in that timeframe.
India does not need reasons, it makes them up, it is in charge of land.
Your belief that harmander sahib would be less likely attacked is not factful considering the preceding sikh holocaust, and operation black thunder during which there was no bhindrawala nor inside 40 other sikh gurdwaras homes of guru granth sahib which were attacked mercilessly by indian soljers.
any plonk that knows how politicians work would know they can work their out of anything. 1984 was the biggest lie.
please tell us the million strategies that should have been adopted if someone comes to destroy your home?
you seem like a confused fellow i think instead of reading official accounts maybe you might need to study the sikh side of events.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Prabhjoyt Singh · 05 May 2006
Talking about these situations and being in them is VERY VERY different, but i still do not understand why you would say "jarnail Singh Bhindrawale shound rot in hell" what did he do wrong? What did Sant Ji do wrong? if you could turn back the clock wat would you do? or how about tanks pull up outside your house and start firing wat would you do then? go outside and surrender? or fortify your house and fight from inside?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
proffessor krishan lal · 07 May 2006
Former Vice Chief of Army Staff recalls "Bluestar" (attack on Harimandir Sahib in 1984)
While fighting against the army during June 5 - 7 1984, Sikhs inside the Golden Temple Complex at Amritsar were "exercising their legitimate right of self-defense." This is the unequivocal statement made by Lieutenant General S.K. Sinha (Retd.), former Vice Chief of the Army Staff and presently Governor of Assam.
"The Army action was not the last resort as Prime Minister Indira Gandhi would have us believe, decided upon toward May-end (1984). It has been in her mind for more than 18 months".
Said the General, highly respected and regarded for this sagacity and professional skills, that "when he was GOC-in-C of Western Command, he got a call around 10 p.m. fro 'some in Delhi' that a decision has been taken at the highest level that the army should undertake the arrest of Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale. Nothing was heard after the General told the caller in matters like this he would like to hear from either the Chief of Army Staff or the Defense Minister."
This was towards 1981-end when Darbara Singh was Chief minister or nearly 30 months before the Army actually struck at Amritsar.
"Again, when Sant Bhindrawale went into Mehta Chowk," adds General Sinha, "there was a request to the Army to supply Armoured Personal Carries (APC) to the police to facilitate his arrest.
This was long before the Akalis launched their morcha in August 1982 Shortly after the morcha, the Army began rehearsals of a commando raid near Chakrata cantonment in the maintains over the Doon Valley where a replica of the Golden Temple complex had been built.
"Another operation involving the Aviation Research Centre with Special F.F commandos, was given in the Sarsawa area and Yamuna river bed in helicopters converted into gunships. This plan, earmarked for implementation in August 198 and then in April 1984, was given up as it had leaked out to the Sikh 'militants'.
In view of these military preparations, if Sant Bhindrawale and his men decided to defend the Golden Temple with all their might and means, no one can, and should, blame them.
"You are duty-bound to do your all when you know someone is going to raid your house. In this case, the house of the holiest Sikh shrine in the world.
"Mrs. Gandhi contends that arms were being collected by Sant Bhindrawale for the last on year. But this was much after she herself had drawn up plans for Army action against the Golden Temple and other gurdwaras.
"In December, 1983 two trenches were dug by the Sant's men in front of Teja Singh Samundari Hall within the holy complex but he was persuaded to fill them up.
"This proves that till then no responsible Akali leaders was prepared for an armed showdown with the Government."
Fortification of the complex, according to SGPC Secretary Bhan Singh, started from February 17, 1984. And that also after CRPF and BSF units had resorted to unprovoked firing and had begun converting the buildings on the periphery of the temple into bunkers and fortresses. This action by Sikhs was a response to the provocation provided by Government's para military forces.
Again, toward May-end 1984, CRPF and BSF units deliberately fired some 10,000 bullets every day on the temple areas for more than a week in order to find out from the return firing, as was officially admitted later, where the terrorist fortifications were located and what kind of equipment they had. This was given a deliberate design to escalate the conflict.
"No Sikh worth his salt could allow easy entry into the Golden Temple area to any armed force. It is his sacred duty to smash the enemy's teeth and sacrifice his life while fighting."
"This is what Sant Bhindrawale and his men did. In the best tradition of Sikh warriors, they fought to the last bullet and their last breath."
"for the same reason, hundreds of men, women and children, who has come to he Golden Temple as pilgrims, laid down their lives when were caught in the crossfire of the army invading the holy area."
"before this open clash if arm, there were only hardly five per cent Sikhs who supported Sant Bhindrawale's actions or utterances. But then the Government made him a hero in all Sikh eyes. Now everyone, including hid previous detractors, hail him as a martyr of the same genre as Baba Deep Singh who had fought against Ahmad Shah Abdali's marauders."
Lieut. General(Retd.) S.K. Sinha
Former Vice Chief of Army Staff, Indian Army
This account of the runup to Indian Army's attack on Harimandir Sahib appeared in the second issue of Nishan in 2001 and was first published in the Spokesman Weekly, New Delhi, July 16, 1984.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Rsingh · 08 May 2006
"if", there is something that you don't seem to understand. Sri Akal Takht Saahib IS a military center for sikhs. It always has been. It is the sikh seat of power and has been a military center ever since it was constructed. You need to study the whole miri piri concept and then re-examine your stance on this issue.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
jeetee rowad dhabba · 08 May 2006
did you ever hear the official countdown on radio to the op tara attack? as the countdown began, jakarey were raised from the complex which thundered through the radio which was doing a live audio recording, after which blasts were heard. those electrifieing jakarey were beyond what you would normally hear during ardas. the thunder of jakarey resonated far more spirit than any tank or indian fire that would be heard.
If defending their home was for personal name, fame or to create a cause then
how comes so little sikhs more like 70 were able to take on countless thousands of a modern army? where has thet happened in history?
why were so many women and children willing to die in honour for their home?
what use would bhindrawala have being dead as a martyr for a name?
what use would a wrong cause be if he is not there?
you may not forgive him, its not in your position to judge or forgive but in Gods hands.
i think the complex is the size of a football pitch, so how would you have defended something that size?
sanatans, modern thinkers, india waley you have lost the logic of your argument. You came here believing it would be easy to convince young sikhs that 1984 could have been avoided. The truth is inside every truthful persons heart. I fail to understand how you think we could be fooled like blind sheep? I have read official accounts and any sikh who has studied sikhism would compare the white paper with sikh rehat maryatha and study bhindrawalas speeches and see the faults lieing therein in the official version.
we should have more debate and questions about who started 1984 so the truth may come out. This truth should then be demonstrated to sikhs in every school college university and gurdwara. The same should be explained to local hindus, and muslims to encourage understanding.
We should refrain from bitterness and overly emotive feelings for hindus and be rational, as to not give ghandi any credit amunitition. Finally we should make efforts to get in touch with sikhs in the media and help them understand both sides of the account so we do not have official one sided picture.
1) those on here stating sikhs should have used different tactics to defend the golden temple, kindly xplain those tactics? and secondly why did you or those brainwashing you not act upon these other tactics to defend the golden temple dear to every sikhs heart?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
? · 13 May 2006
why did the army check points deliberatly allow weopons to ba taken into golden temple?
the sikh nation was threatened for many years by indra that it will face the consequences if it did not stop the dharm yud episode ( democractic demonstration against state repression).
singhs in 1984 were told golden temple will be destroyed therefore duty bound to defend it.
what use were these checkpoints? why were they there what was their objective? and under whos order did they act?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
some12 · 14 May 2006
dogra, that name represents u perfectly.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Singh · 14 May 2006
would the indian govt have attacked Harmandir Sahib if bindrawale hadnt hadn't taken it over and stashed it with weapons, grenades, missiles etc. ??
also, can some one answer is it true that he said any sikh who drinks alcohol should be boiled alive?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
richna duaahb · 19 May 2006
would defences have been laid along the golden temple if it was not threatened under attack? If you
1) threaten year after year to destroy some 1s home
2) take steps to destroy that home in mock practice
3) lay down cordons around some 1s home
4) take up positions,
came to attack an area the size of 3 football pitches. Then would it not be just to defend that position through whatever means?
looking at what general sinha stated, the most senior army man of the time it is obvious sikhs had every right to defend the house of spirituality and political guidelines which should ideally safegaurd the rights of the sikh antion in gurmat leadership. There is no personal opinion on it, the facts were clear.
a sikh drink alcohol is patit and is no longr sikh must retake amrit. Guru Gobind singh had masands dealt with severly. I myself do not know if bhindrawala demanded sikhs drinking be boild alive, if he did then i do not agree to that unless it was a so call giani amritdhari 5 kakari who has a responsible position in the sikh nation towards anandpur sahib, only if repeatedly the giani has been first asked to mend ways then refuses to, and finally refuses to stand down as a respobnsibl preacher while drinking.
But i have not heard of any case where sikhs were boiled alive by bhindrawala but we hear many thousands of cases where sikhs wereburned alive on diwali 1984 delhi riots by the delhi and hareyaneh hindu jaat goons and nam bani reheti amritdari sikhs burned alive on couldrons salt poured on wounds after with nam still being recited, all at the behest of
india
worlds largest democracy
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Mr. Singh · 19 May 2006
"would the indian govt have attacked Harmandir Sahib if bindrawale hadnt hadn't taken it over and stashed it with weapons, grenades, missiles etc. ??"
how many times must we go over this before it sinks in?? what weapons were stored at all the other gurudwaray? the several dozen others that were attacked? Was bhindrawale there too?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
t dot jatt · 19 May 2006
after everything the indian government did to the sikh's we still havn't gotton any revenge we pretty much got back handed by hindustan and it pisses me off.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
%.)"^&! · 20 May 2006
bhindrawala is not reported to have stated a sikh should be boiled alive for drinking alcohol. So please state your sources before you lie to the sangat.
The debate is about 1984 and why the indian army launched an attack to start with.
It is not appropriate to accuse bhindrawala of things he did not state.
In any case bhindrawalas speeches under scrutiny should be started on another thread so the issue of who started 1984 is not to be confused with bhindrawalas speeches. This thread is only about how 1984 began.
In any perspective if any reasonable excuse can be found to have launched an attack please provide the evidence first. There was no excuse to massacre men and women.
so far it appears as one delves into why 1984 began there was no reason to hurt demolish or massacre a people and their holiest place of reverence.
Weopons were not stashed into harmandar saahb. preperations for defence were barely put days before a full scale national army assault which was fully equipped with state sources to the brim. Any sikh on entire earth can stay in their holiest home, it is no crime. If indira deemed it a crime, she could have ordered another arrest warrant on bhindrawala.
Why did indra not do this? because bibi was intent on the destruction of the heart of sikhism.
Are there any more excuses one can fabricate before we arise to a conclusion that 1984 was all about the foundation stone of destructing of sikhisms role created to protect itself and others.. The foundation stone of the forces of kaal was to cement a black house of fake fantasy democracy by massacring sikhs devoted to amrit in future. This destructive house of dark force has a short period in which it will thrive and then it will face its own demise.
This black house of destruction sits many feet below the foundationstone of another home which has its foundations created on sacrifices, truth, spirit, nam resounding through each atom, . The walls to this house are yet to take form.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
t dot jatt · 27 May 2006
why is congress ruling punjab
and check out the other threads we got rss hindus on this website in threads like "are sikhs hindus" and "hindu panth"
but yea looks like we got hindu rss fundamentalist on this site trying to convince us we are hindus.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
001 · 28 May 2006
ok i would like to ask something straight and simple..
.....how do we know that india government would've attacked harminder sahib if bhindrenwale wasnt in there?...
...its a risk of sayin e.g.......that person walking behind me carries hatred...therefore he will atack me.....(not a gd example though)
however what im trying to get across is that... to ME..it couldve been that they wouldnt have attacked harminder sahib if bhindrenwale wasnt in their as the government aint thick....they new they would dig a whole for themsleves if they did attack harminder sahib with no excuse...?
....however this post is not to bew seen as if im saying what the india government did was right....they were wrong for attacking our holy shrine?
but what im saying is that if he knew that the government is after him....and he KNEW that the place will be blown up cuz of that cause.....then why didnt he leave the place, which would've been for the best?? ..............it wouldve saved soo many innocent lives??....
e.g.......if i was in a gurdwara...and i knew that i will be killed by an outsiders.......then i would rather leave the gurdwara as i wouldnt want to cause soo many other deaths with me??
Re: How did "1984" begin?
massra di dal · 01 Jun 2006
kiddah 001 putri aahkthi ne
".....how do we know that india government would've attacked harminder sahib if bhindrenwale wasnt in there?..."
doh!! indias operation khala bathal 1986 on the holy land of harmandar sahib kohi sant jarnail singh bhindrawala nei si he died 2 years before
india did invade harmandar sahib and attack it again even when bhindrawala was not there so what now?
there was no arrest warant on jarnail singhs name in 1984 but news hit punjab that the government was looking to do a hamla on darbar sahib.
yes it really would have saved thousands of innocent lives considering gurpurb was picked as the day of the assault by indra the gidda queen herself????? dweh
and no the government was not thick it managed to wipe out a whole generation of baptised amritdari, hoodwink the world , promote itself as the democracy of the world, and made sikh holocaust victims look as if they were terrorist murderers.
next debate?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
pindustan · 01 Jun 2006
cprf came in trucks and laid sandbags out on their first phase, and then began firing small rounds as a warning shot just days before bluestar.
at this point golden temple was forced into a situation where it had to defend itself and media blacked out.
meaning the gov of india had launched an attack on the golden temple with no provocation with no weopons inside and gave no warning shot. To cover itself it blanked media out and lied to the world claiming militants had taken seige.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
khalistan · 01 Jun 2006
“Hindu Militants Murdered 38 Sikhs in Cold Blood”
Clinton: India Responsible for Chithisinghpora Massacre
WASHINGTON, D.C., May 30, 2006 – In the introduction to former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright’s new book, The Mighty and the Almighty, former U.S. President Bill Clinton writes that “Hindu militants” are responsible for the massacre of 38 Sikhs at Chithisinghpora in March 2000. This reflects previous findings by the Punjab Human Rights Organization, the International Human Rights Organization, the Movement Against State Repression, and New York Times reporter Barry Bearak.
President Clinton writes, “During my visit to India in 2000, some Hindu militants decided to vent their outrage by murdering 38 Sikhs in cold blood. If I hadn’t made the trip, the victims would probably still be alive. If I hadn’t made the trip because I feared what militants might do, I couldn’t have done my job as president of the United States.”
According to Amnesty International, “the attackers wore uniforms of the armed forces and were led by a tall man whom they addressed as Commanding Officer (CO). All Sikh men were rounded up, ostensibly to check their identities, and made to sit on the ground in two groups against the walls of the gurdwaras [Sikh temples] a few hundred metres from each other; they were shot at point blank range. As the attackers withdrew, they reportedly shouted Hindu slogans.” On August 2, 2002, the Washington Times reported that the Indian government admitted that its forces were responsible for the massacre. India finally admitted that the evidence it used to implicate alleged Kashmiri “militants” in the murders was faked.
At the time of the Chithisinghpora massacre, Dr. Gurmit Singh Aulakh, President of the Council of Khalistan, strongly condemned the murders. “What motive would Kashmiri freedom fighters have to kill Sikhs? This would be especially stupid when President Clinton is visiting. The freedom movements in Kashmir, Khalistan, Nagaland, and throughout India need the support of the United States,” he said. Khalistan is the Sikh homeland declared independent on October 7, 1987.
The massacres continued a pattern of repression and terrorism against minorities by the Indian government, which it attempts to blame on other minorities to divide and rule the minority peoples within its artificial borders. The Indian newspaper Hitavada reported that the Indian government paid the late governor of Punjab, Surendra Nath, $1.5 billion to organize and support covert terrorist activity in Punjab, Khalistan, and in neighboring Kashmir.
A report issued by the Movement Against State Repression (MASR) shows that India admitted that it held 52,268 political prisoners under the repressive “Terrorist and Disruptive Activities Act” (TADA) even though it expired in 1995. Many have been in illegal custody since 1984. There has been no list published of those who were acquitted under TADA and those who are still rotting in Indian jails. Additionally, according to Amnesty International, there are tens of thousands of other minorities being held as political prisoners. MASR report quotes the Punjab Civil Magistracy as writing “if we add up the figures of the last few years the number of innocent persons killed would run into lakhs [hundreds of thousands.]”
The Indian government has murdered over 250,000 Sikhs since 1984, more than 300,000 Christians in Nagaland, over 90,000 Muslims in Kashmir, tens of thousands of Christians and Muslims throughout the country, and tens of thousands of Tamils, Assamese, Manipuris, , and others. The Indian Supreme Court called the Indian government's murders of Sikhs "worse than a genocide.”
The book Soft Target by Canadian journalists Zuhair Kashmeri and Brian McAndrew , shows that the Indian government blew up its own airliner in 1985 to blame Sikhs and justify further repression. It quotes an agent of the Canadian Security Investigation Service (CSIS) as saying, “If you really want to clear up the incidents quickly, take vans down to the Indian High Commission and the consulates in Toronto and Vancouver. We know it and they know it that they are involved.” On January 2, 2002, the Washington Times reported that India sponsors cross-border terrorism in the Pakistani province of Sindh.
“Only in a free Khalistan will the Sikh Nation prosper and get justice,” said Dr. Aulakh. “When Khalistan is free, we will have our own Ambassadors, our own representation in the UN and other international bodies, and our own leaders to keep this sort of thing from happening. We won’t be at the mercy of the brutal Indian regime and its Hindu militant allies,” he said. “Democracies don’t commit genocide. India should act like a democracy and allow a plebiscite on independence for Khalistan and all the nations of South Asia,” Dr. Aulakh said. “We must free Khalistan now.”
Re: How did "1984" begin?
khalistan · 06 Jun 2006
whats with all the hindus and rss supporters doing on this site trying to convince sikh's that they are hindus.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Jalawatan · 08 Jun 2006
O my Lord!!
Gur Fateh to all posties....!! So people are debating the cause of Operation Bluestar!! This is a sad day for the Sikh Nation as a whole and the Diaspora in particular. I will not go into the details but I will add my few comments for those who are unaware of those historic moments that have shaped the SIkh Nation's Liberation Struggle.
For those of you who question a Sikh being armed...please read Sikh history and its philosphy in its totality. Read the Sikh Political thought processes from the times of Guru Nanak Dev ji. Wasnt he a political person and dared to call the Indian Moghul Emperor Babur....as Jabar (tyrant) to Babur's face?? Guru Nanak Dev ji's and the Sikh Political philosphy had been diluted by the so-called Sadhs who want us, to just do what a parrot does (tota ratan). Guru Nanak Dev ji challenged the norms of the day and called the Indian EMPEROR a tyrant in his court? How do you feel about that? Wasnt this a bold political statement and directly proportional to the Sikh Philosphy of Nirbhau and Nirvair? Sikh Political Idealogy is based on these two pillars. Living what the bani says everyday in and out and standing up to the challenges is what Guruji asked and expect us to do. Remember religion is a tool to make you a better human being. It is not an end in itself....it is a tool towards an end!
Apply the rich heritage, to which you belong, to your current live and try to seek the relevance of what you do in daily activities. If you are being a ritualist please dont call yourself a Sikh. Sikh is a student and always prepared to learn and always seeking the truth and company of the learned.
As far as suffering in the Nationalist movement goes...every Sikh did that and if you are in pain and anguish, may I suggest you to channel that pain and angusih towards research and seeking more knowledge about the Sikh philosphy and it heritage before you do any kind of research on the failed Sikh Nationalist Movemnt of 80's and 90's. You need to understand the SIkh Political Thought (according to the lives of the Sikh founders...Guru's lives) before you start talking about the Kharkoo's.
The Sikh Nationalist Movement is not over. It failed due to multiple reasons and unless you know the reasons/causes of failure(which are many and interlinked and INTRAlinked) there is no need to revive the Movement and get humiliated. Dig deep in Sikh philosphy and get away from Sadhs who tell you to do just certain paths (bani) and all will be okay. You have every right to question EVERY sadh that you come across and he or she must address your concerns. Ask them why do they not talk about Asa Di War and stress so much on Sukhmani Sahib. They dont want sangat doing Asa Di war because it tells you what it is....whilst Sukhmani Sahib is full of praises of those who repeat naam and Sant. So in a subtle way they preach that they are Sant and people should not question them thus! What a divine solution!!!
Akal Sahai!!
Re: How did "1984" begin?
kaur · 12 Jun 2006
Note: just b4 the attack occurred, a Sant sent a message to Sant Jarnail Singh Jee saying, “you know there is going to be an attack on the Sikh panth, why don't you leave Harmandir Sahib, so it’s protected".
Sant Jarnail Singh Jee’s reply was, "this attack is in Guru Gobind Singh Jees Bachan, I can't make guru Jee’s bachan incorrect.
After hearing this, the Sant apologized for tell him to leave.
vjkk vjkk
[%sig%]
Re: How did "1984" begin?
why khalistan failed · 12 Jun 2006
1984 the harmandar sahib is attacked in june in october the sikhs take their revenge by murdering indira gandhi Nov 1st the hindus take their revenge by murdering sikhs in mass riots in delhi the sikhs take their revenge by murdering inocent hindus and sinking down to the level of the hindus responsible for mass murder in delhi and started killing inocent people, the gurus said that a sikhs job is to protect inocent life not take it that is probably the number 1 reasion we failed and for all of you who say the khalistani's didn't kill hindus in the punjab and didn't want to kill any inocent life well what about babbar khalsa in canada who preached they would not rest till they killed 50 000 hindus and many others who turned it into an issue of sikh vs hindus, but not all khalistani's killed inocent life about 80% of them did fight the government and justice to the sikh people but many times when their family's would be murdered they would let their emotions control them and turned them from freedom fighters to murderers were they started killing inocent lives as well but you can't blame them for that because the indian government was using the dirtiest tricks in the books by killing inocent family members so many khalistani's had to put their family first and the cause second so you can't blame them for that either and plus many khalistani's were fighting within themselves over ideology each group carried their own idealogy like babbar khalsa who wanted khalistan to be like afganistan under talibon control and then you had other groups who wanted revenge who didn't want khalistan who did want khalistan but not under sikh rule and so on and so on, we couldn't come together, if all the khalistani's had joined together and created one big militant groups with one ideology for everyone to shar and fought in the way's the guru's would of approved and not let any inocent life come to harm we can have khalistan.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
savran · 12 Jun 2006
wah gwaan to da sher de put nation producing 1 man against 125 000 big up!
india is weird never understood it. It wanted to clear out officially stated "flush out" terrorists from desecrating a holy place of worship the golden temple as these militants were supposedly armed.
if india had the best interests of everyone into account, and it indeed waas worried about the holy place of worship golden temple being taken over by terrorists.
case 1 terrorists armed inside temple
case 2 india bombs the hell out of it anyway, walks in with shoes rampling bodies, kills 10 000 innocent bystanders congregated on the birthday of their guru, rapes women on the site itself, hits rifle butts on the turbans of children aged 10, troops smoking on the temple grounds, bombs both the temple the library and the akal takhat. your telling me all that just to stop terrorists taking over the temple?
no it does not make sense.
thats a blatent massacre a genocide tell me otherwise?
i do not care what sant jarnail singh said or did hes just a man like me and you. the point is that much damage for one man? bullbags thats crap. ind
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Dogra · 12 Jun 2006
The path of the Gurus is very clear, when were innocent people killed?
Guru Gobind Singhji did not go around saying to kill innocent muslims unlike Bhindrawale did about Hindus.
The Ghandhi govtn attack on that day was an outrage but she is no more the Indian Govtn is not the same as at that time.
Hate begets hate, never ending circle. We are all individuals, and to group wholesale human beings according to religion and so they must all be evil or they must all be good is crap. The dark side is an easy path to go down it helps to stop asking questions and just follow the inner demons.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
king inder ageya · 13 Jun 2006
i had no idea bhindrawala said anything of the kind dogra can you please provide references?
why would sant jarnail singh say that when his gurmat parchars (preaching of sikh faith) often involved hindu terminology, devi devte, katha on pandus sons ( gurmat prachar ninth edition)?
and sant jarnail singh having saved the daughters of hindu families in amritsar from their in laws wrongful doings, providing sustenance to hindu familiees affeecteed by rasta rokho agitation dharm yud morcha, the police or indra did not help the hindu families sant jarnail singh did and providing money to help rebuild a hindu temple in amritsar?
if he hated hindus why did he do all that?
provide some references first otherwise you are going around in circles.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
kaur · 13 Jun 2006
The 1980s in Punjab witnessed a decade-long insurgency, fueled by failed attempts at procuring greater autonomy, water rights, local control over agricultural production and prices, and redress for human rights abuses. The Sikh community’s grievances with the Indian state related to: issues fundamental to their identity, such as Article 25 of the Indian Constitution, which defines Sikhs as Hindus and thus denies the distinct existence of the Sikh religion; complaints of territorial loss, specifically the government’s transfer of Punjab’s capital Chandigarh to the Union and of Punjabi-speak-ing lands to Haryana; and economic deprivation. Throughout the 1970s, government canals diverted seventy-five percent of Punjab’s river waters to Rajasthan and Haryana, in violation of the international law of riparian rights. The diversions forced small farmers to use expensive and erratic tube well irrigation.[2] Since the 1950s, thousands of Sikhs had engaged in civil disobedience and risked arrest in protest over these issues.[3]
In the 1980s, the economic burdens on Punjabis increased. The army imposed a cap on the percentage of Sikhs in the army, which caused a dramatic rise in the educated unemployed in Punjab. The rise in educated unemployed denied many small farmers their only source of capital investment in the form of wages from family members employed in the army.[4] Central government investment in Punjab fell from 2% to 0.8%, placing further economic burdens on the state.[5] On May 24, 1984, the Akali Dal, the Sikh
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*** Top of Page 271 ***
political party, channeled discontent into an agitation that blocked transport of Punjabi wheat and withheld taxes from the Indian government.[6] The government responded by deploying 100,000 army troops in Punjab, setting the stage for the violent attacks of June 1984.[7]
B. Decade of Disappearances
1984 exploded in Punjab, beginning the government’s active armed oppression of Sikhs and a violent police crackdown of the Sikh insurgency. On June 3, 1984, the martyrdom anniversary of the fifth Sikh Guru, the Indian army launched Operation Bluestar. The army invaded the Golden Temple complex, the center of Sikh religious and political life, and forty-one other major Sikh gurudwaras[8] with tanks, 70,000 troops, and CS gas,[9] and imposed a statewide curfew. The government forbade news coverage of the army attacks, expelled foreign journalists, and cut phone lines across Punjab.[10] Eyewitnesses reported that over 10,000 pilgrims and 1300 workers had gathered inside the complex and could not leave before the attack for fear of arrest.[11] The police detained Red Cross volunteers at Jallianwala Bagh, near the Golden Temple complex, preventing them from accessing the pilgrims and workers.[12]
Re: How did "1984" begin?
ashamed · 14 Jun 2006
india wanted one geezer out of the temple and it had to blow it up, raze it down, kill innocent devotees gathered to celebrate the christmas day of their guru we are talking about women grannies and children here, rape them, rope tie old aged pensioners till their hands were broken, police smoke tobbacco on the site that forbids narcotics, completely wipe out the reference library that housed priceless manuscripts that will never be returned, all that
common dogra common hindu bhaiys
all that much damage more like deliberate carnage, pre planned genocide
its impossible to do that much just for one man?
someone somewhere was responsible with orders there had to be a line which would not be crossed.
orders came from somwhere to do that damage.
how many hindus were actually killed before 1984 by these so called militants ?
therefore what can justify the attack in the first place?
now abu hamza and bin laden called for the murder of non muslims. this does not mean america is going to blow up mecca and medina. No country in the world would do that.
so why did it happen to sikhs?
i am ashamed that sikhs actually think and feel the buck should be passed to what is dramatised out to be a weak irresponsible sikh leadership in 1984.
have you ever had to fight for the right to water? the right to speak your own language? the right to walk without being raped and tortured? the right to freely practice what you are?
nihungs leaders , and other sanatan bhais what beauty of sanatnism has been achieved in india after 1984? what did ram raj achieve when bjp came? where is the panjhva takhat to todays declining situation?
therefore bhais whether you are sikh nihung or even hindus you have to admit you are ghulam slaves in a country run by family tier situation class structures. Poverty does not just come, it has been given to you and you have accepted it through slavery. You are not free your mind is not free you think and feel as puppets do on a string. Let your heart roll a bit be honst with yourself read unbiased accounts of history.
[%sig%]
Re: How did "1984" begin?
ghaggar · 14 Jun 2006
khalsa raj will incarnate over entire india
khalsas have a duty
india will not exist forever
corruption and untruth will depart truth will reign victorious
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Harjas Kaur · 14 Jun 2006
[quote]if jarnail bhindrawale did not come on the scene, it would'nt have happend.
this group wanted thei own country e.g. khalistan (which will never ever hapen) and when they were refused, they started saying bad thing about the indian government, which caused problems, and this then caused 1984[/quote]
You are a fool to believe this.
Sant Ji with injured Bhai Amolak Singh after the 1978 Amritsar massacre by Hindutva government sponsored Nirankari's.
read http://allaboutsikhs.com/events/akj.htm
Shaheed Singhs of Amritsar massacre 1978.
Indian government was doing corrupt and immoral things. Congress wanted to politicize the Punjab by corrupting Sikhi to radical Hindutva interests and subvert the Punjab resources to "greater India." The police defended and assisted Nirankari's in killing peaceful Gursikh protesters, in the heart of Amritsar, after rally where they shouted abuse and invective against the Guru to provoke confrontation. There was no way to get justice or fair trial, because the Indian government had a campaign to subvert and weaken Sikhi. Congress government began to call staged encounters with police and retaliation self-defense the acts of "terrorists." In Punjab, Sikhs were treated like second class citizens, being demonized and portrayed as criminals or idiots in Bollywood productions. This is evidence of a deep and troubling propaganda attack to break down Sikh identity. Without fighting back it would have amounted to extermination of Sikhi. Indian Congress intended to replace Gursikh's with Hindutva elements in Sikh garb like Nirankari's, Radha Soamis, union of Akali Dal with BJP, PM Manmohan Singh to undermine Sikh independance. This went so far as to identify Sikhism a subservient form of Hindu religion in public law.
This is what Sant Ji absolutely preached against. This is what made talk of an independent Khalistan where Singhs would be safe to practice Gursikhi. He spoke the truth. He didn't intend to start a new government. Sant Ji knew that he would die. But he would fight and die defending Sikhi until time of Khalistan will come. Was it any different for Saheed Baba Banda Bahadur?
Sangat Ji please forgive my mistakes.
India's war against Sikh religion.
PM Manmohan Singh standing with Tytler
RAJ KAREGA KHALSA
KHALISTAN ZINDABAD
[%sig%]
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Dogra · 15 Jun 2006
"On August 17, 1983, Bhindranwale asked Sikh youth to buy a motorcycle and a revolver and threatened to kill 5,000 Hindus in an hour if the police delayed the minibus he had sent to fetch Amrik Singh who had just been released from police custody.59 "
http://sikhtimes.com/bios_060604a.html
The Indira Govtn was corrupt and was guilty of spreading communal hatred and the attack on the Golden Temple was an outrage,as it was also Guru Arjan Devjis Matrydom day, but the dark side was with Bhindrawale as well.
Indira Ghandhi govtn was finished.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
dr sharma · 16 Jun 2006
did 5000 hindus get killed by bhindrawala at any point?
and where can the revolver and motorbyke speeches be referenced to?
Re: How did "1984" begin?
qweryopi · 16 Jun 2006
these hindus always make excuses to call sikhs terrorists and would like to know were sant jarnail bhinranwale asks for hindus to be massacored, it's a myth created by the hindu government to help destory sikhism, are goals need to be turn bjp against congress and bring the hindus into a civil war and help fund and supply islamic terrorists and watch them bomb the daylights out of hindustan.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Harjas Kaur · 17 Jun 2006
Corrupt governments spread disinformation and propaganda to manipulate the public to support their evil aims. Everyone with a brain can see the end result of that evil government....slaughter and repression of Sikh's. This is the main reason people should not believe the distortions against Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale. They didn't just kill one man, or even arrest and put him on trial for alleged charges. How can the dead defend themselves? With what voice do they speak? Instead the evil government used propaganda to justify the wholesale murder of a generation of amritdharis. Their own deeds speak louder than anything they ever claim Sant Ji said or did.
The end result betrays the true guilt. Take the blinders off!
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Bhupinder Singh "daas" · 17 Jun 2006
Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee FAteh!!
The religion hinduism was saved because of a Sikh, Guru tegh bahadur jee. So, in return the hindus wish to destroy our religion - how does that work?
They all end up turning their back on us, and for what reason? Have we given them pain, agony or anguish? No, they just hate our religion. Their ego wants to turn the whole of India into a Hindu only state where no one else lives their except for hindus just like iran or any other muslim state. It's their pride, ego and hate that is forcing them to make this move. Our religion is too pure to live in a world of evil where hatred prevails, though within this evil resides vaheguru jee's light so all a Sikh has to do is turn from a sikh into a Khalsa by reaching Saachkhand, and this will release the goodness from within evil to shine and conquer. The good is there but only one who, from millions, moves above this world and reaches saachkhand can guide the world to truth. Naam is the guide for a Sikh, so we should use it to become a khalsa and thereon good shall follow that walking light.
All the world needs is a Khalsa. Thousands of them. Japping Naam can turn a human into a Khalsa.
Vaheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa Vaheguru Jee Kee FAteh!!
Re: How did "1984" begin?
jason · 17 Jun 2006
Dear DOGRA can you please tell me were you got this information from.
On August 17, 1983, Bhindranwale asked Sikh youth to buy a motorcycle and a revolver and threatened to kill 5,000 Hindus in an hour if the police delayed the minibus he had sent to fetch Amrik Singh who had just been released from police custody.59 "
Re: How did "1984" begin?
sarbloh · 17 Jun 2006
After 84 coward slaughtering of sikhs,Rajiv Gandhi led congress swept the election polls in a manner never done before.Indian majority stood after Gandhis.Indira was made Durga.What a shame!
Guru ji has requested again and again for people to give up useless rituals and idol worship etc because Gurus knew in times to come such humans would get soo degenerated that they will become burden on earth,will suffer a lot and make others suffer too.
1984 was the worst possible attack on a community and so far justice has not been served by Waheguru Ji.One thing is for sure that justice will come and it will be really horrible to see the punishment given by Waheguru ji.I feel like the TSUNAMI is coming.
Individually,I feel that without the ability to get justice qualities like forgiveness etc are just weakness.Khalsa will seek justice for 84 in the same manner Banda Singh Bahadur sought justice in Sirhind.
Bhul Chukk Maaf
RAAJ KAREGA KHALSA
Wahegurujikaakhalsa Wahegurujikeefateh
Re: How did "1984" begin?
jj · 19 Jun 2006
the only problem i have with this thread is that we seem to either blame sant jarnail singh for an insurgency or hindus appearing kind of favourable to sikg genocides.
there are hindus who generally sympathise with sikhs once you actually demonstrate and explain the sikh perspective. there are likewise sikhs who ae chappali sikhs.
I think the louder the sarkar gets the louder the sikhs should get and ensure they get heard through the media.
do not sit down on this for one moment, express it in such a way where there are no comebacks.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Dogra · 19 Jun 2006
Dear Jason,
the quote is taken from the website from Sikh Times as i posted that as well.-http://sikhtimes.com/bios_060604a.html
As has been mentioned Indira govtns was finished she is no more.
India is a land for all, always has been.
The potty holing of people into various faiths does not always work for those who goto any place of worship, and so these people are of no faith as such but just believe in God.
Along the road to Chandigargh from Delhi there is a place of worship that has the Guru Granth Sahib, Gita and Koran all in one room.
People are individuals who cannot be subjected to wholesale prejudices, racists and bigots show themselves in all colours and faiths
As Shaheed Udham Singhji said:
"'I never afraid of dying so soon I will be getting married with execution. I am not sorry as I am a soldier of my country it is since 10 years when my friend has left me behind and I am sure after my death I will see him as he is waiting for me it was 23rd and I hope they will hang me on the same date as he was.'"
He also said my name is RAM MOHAMMED SINGH AZAD!
http://www.punjabilok.com/misc/freedom/udham_last_word2.htm
Re: How did "1984" begin?
nikki · 20 Jun 2006
vjkk vjkf
some of you people really need to get a life, i mean, sikhi's basic teachings are to not talk bad of anyone, n her all you guys are ...............
if this topic really means alot to you and you honestly feel hurt by the events thats occured, then do something productive about it. if you not gonna do anything then you've got no right to comment about it.
it doesn't matter if you blieve in sant jarnail singh jee khalsa or not, its about getting on with the present and making a difference.
[%sig%]
Re: How did "1984" begin?
anjaan · 20 Jun 2006
vjkk vkjf
we had a youth program at our local gurudwara a few days ago, and giani thakur singh (kathaa vajik from dam dami taksaal) was doing kathaa on stage.
he talked about 84 and the attack. he said that there was a sant that knew about the attack BEFORE it was going to actually happen and he sent a message to warn SANT JARNAIL SINGH JI KHALSA BHINDRANWALE, and asked him to leave the complex for this reason.
Sant jarnail singh ji said that he also knew that the government would attack, but he would not leave.
He said that it is in guru sahibs hukam that the attack will take place, and he did not want to make a bachan of guru mahraj false. therefore he stayed at sri harmandir sahib.
Alot of thing are MEANT to happen, rather than debating on whose right or wrong we should just take as bhana. 'thera keeya meetha laagai'
bhul chuk maaf,
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: How did "1984" begin?
respect your dad · 21 Jun 2006
did Jarnail Singh acheive his aims that he was fighting for ???
NOOO !!!
if he was so chardi kala why did he not acheive the aims??
Re: How did "1984" begin?
singh · 21 Jun 2006
wjkk wjkf
it all started when indra came to harimandar sahib and every body stood up and sant jarnail singh said she is not more important than guru granth sahib ji
wjkkwjkf
Re: How did "1984" begin?
if · 22 Jun 2006
I agree what did sant jarnail singh bhinranwale do for the sikhs anyways, what benifit was he all i know is he could be compared to osama bin laden for wanting a sikh talibon style country.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
GuptSoulja · 22 Jun 2006
Sant Jarnail Singh Bhinderwala Jee did the right thing and I'm proud of him and everything that he did and stood for!! He made the right choice.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
A singh · 22 Jun 2006
true - all the things that he was fighting for like Punjabs water etc. - none of it was acheived by Bhindranwalay.
Infact ever since he kicked off sikhi has gone down in Punjab like crazy.
- look how many guys chopped their hair off, and now its like people are embarrassed to be into sikhi in Punjab.
Sikhi was much better off in Punjab before he came on the scene
Re: How did "1984" begin?
anjaan · 23 Jun 2006
sant jarnail singh is one of few chardi kala gursikhs out there.
he awakened a sleeping nation!!!! he always abided by the law, nothing he did was against sikhi!!!
alot of people misjudge sant jarnail singh ji, they dont know the truth about him, they go by rumors started by those that hate him or are against what he stood for (justice and freedom)
>>>I agree what did sant jarnail singh bhinranwale do for the sikhs anyways, what benifit was he all i know is he could be compared to osama bin laden for wanting a sikh talibon style country.
that is the kind of statement i would expect from a person that know absolutly nothing about sant jarnail singh ji!!!
veer ji, i suggest you do your research before you do your nindia.
bhul chuk maaf
vjkk vjkf
Re: How did "1984" begin?
nikki · 23 Jun 2006
vjkk vjkf
so you think you know whats best for the sikh paanth do you!!!!!
so what about vaheguru jees hukum...................... everything happens in his pa-naa.
but nooooooooooooooooooooo you don't like think that, u have to take it that extra step.
p.s - nobody on this site has got the right to judge sant jee's kamai. NOBODY. these's one person who is aloud to do that n thats the creator.
any kamai you gain as an individaul is being lost by making such comments, i think we need to look at ourself before we even start to look at the jeeevan of others.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
sarbloh · 23 Jun 2006
Around 1730,sikhs were openly hunted and had to go through extremely tough times for a period of about 50 years.Many people were afraid to be called sikhs and the true khalsa was surviving in the jungles.After all this struggle we got a rule in which khalsa had the authority.In the same way,its only 22 years.Have patience.This play of god is beyond us.Sant Jarnail Singh khalsa's efforts had laid the foundation stone of khalsa raaj in punjab.
The battle that he fought is one the greatest ever.Handful of armed singhs against a nations army,holding army for about a week and killing thousands of enemy soldiers.He further glorified our history.Blaming him for the present state of youth is totally wrong.Just wait and see for urself in the future.We will rise and we will rule and we will teach our enemies a lesson that the world will remember.
RAAJ KAREGA KHALSA
Wahegurujeekakhalsa Wahegurujeekeefateh
Re: How did "1984" begin?
servant of khalsas · 24 Jun 2006
At the end of it all, two questions are asked by the Sikhs of Punjab. Was the Army action necessary and unavoidable? Secondly, if unavoidable, could it not have taken a different form, avoiding all the destruction and the blood shed and the brutalities ? Kirpal Singh, President of Khalsa Dewan, Amritsar, told us - "If the government had been sincere in its efforts in solving the Punjab problem, it would have solved it long ago even before the Blue Star Operation, and there would have been no cause for the Akalis and others to orgainise Morchas of the thousands of the peopl, from time to time, and the extremists would have been isolated and it would have become known as to who were the extremists, what kind of men they were, and what they had been doing. The Government could have negotiated with them. If the Government could talk with Laldenga of Mizos and extremists of the Nagaland, who had been fighting with our military for the last 31 years, then what was the difficulty in talking to the extemi sts of Punjab and asking them what they wanted, what they were fighting and why they were collecting arms?" Similarly, S.S. Bhagowalia who is the Vice-President of the Association fro Protection of Democratic Rights (Punjab) was extememly forthright, "when the government in 1948 could control and capture Hyderbad from the Nizam who wanted to secede from independent India without any violence and killing of the common people, why this Government could not capture Bhindranwale with tact, without any damage to the Golden Temple?
This has created tension and anger amongst the minds fo the people". Surinder Singh Ragi gave another example -
"The Indian Army had captued 93,000 soldiers of Pakistan army in Bangladesh in 1971 without bloodshed. Was bloodshed the absolutely necessary at the Golden Temple to flush out a hundred or so terrorists?"
Hazara Singh Vadale, and employee of the SGPC, echoed a common sentiment. "The way the government of Independent country attacked the Golden Temple reminded us of the medieval time when our religion was attacked and we are persecuted. Thousands of women, children, pilgrims, had gathered here on June 3 for Gurupurab. They had no connection with politics, why they shot down?"
Kirpal Singh elaborating on the excesses committed said: "At the time of Blue Star Act, it could be known how many died of those who were fighting with the military but the fact is that due to Guru Purb Day hundereds of pilgrims had come and were staying in the premises of the Darbar Sahib. There were children and women among them.
These pilgrims were unarmed and the military attacked them and killed them. Thereafter the military did not allow their dead bodies to be cremated by the relative nor h anded over the same to them. Their dead bodies were insulted. No effort was made to record their names and addresses. Now it has created a lot of problem. For example, if any deceased has any insurance or bank balance or any land dispute, his heirs require death certificate but in absence of any record of it, they did not get any compensation. Even in the history of military wars, the people are allowed to take the dead bodies from each others territories by showing white flags. When General Dyer killed people in Jallianwall Bagh, he also allowed the dead bodies to be taken by the relatives."
Shiv Singh Khushpuri, 65 years, a member of the S.G.P.C. from Gurdaspur district, said, "It was the duty of the State to identify the bodies of those who died in Operation Blue Star. Afer the Jallinwala Bagh massacre, the British Government identi fied those killed, handed over their bodies to the next kin and paid Rs. 2000 as compensation for every person killed in the incident. Whereas in Blue Star Operation, the present governemnt of an apparently independent country have not only not identified those killed or missing, rather they are harassing and persecuting the families and friends of those who are reportedly missing." S.S. Bhagowailia throws light on the efforts of the Government to suppress information. "The doctors who conducted the post-mortem of the victims of the army action at Golden Temple were simply terrorised. If there were 20 bullets in a body, they were forced to record only two bullet wounds, under the threat of being shot." This only indicates the extent of massacre that took place and the ferocity with which the Army undertook the operation. The common feeling in Punjab is that it was indeed not an Operation against Bhindranwale and other so called terrorists according to the Government, it was an attack on the Sikhs "to teach them a lesson" so that they would never again raise their head or voice of protest.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
Santa Singh · 24 Jun 2006
"We will rise and we will rule and we will teach our enemies a lesson that the world will remember."
1-sikhs dont crave to rule
2-who are we to teach lessons- the Guru is the teacher when he gives his kirpa
3- na ko vairee na ko vegaana - sikhs dont have enemies
Re: How did "1984" begin?
kaur · 27 Jun 2006
1984 was not a beggining. the sikh leadership lost its kingdom, got betrayed by nhru slowly they took away sikhi from sikhs and punjab.
Then sikhs decided to become proper sikhs, this was too much for the hindu leadership. the hindu leaders began murdering baptised sikhs long before 1984.
bhindrawala never killed 5000 hindus but the hindu government of india killed 5000 sikhs in operation bluestar alone.
So the tussle is between india a newly formed country administered and formed for the purpose of british interests which will never allow any form of politics with true religion and the sikh religion striving and struggling to find a place to live in india.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
jason · 01 Jul 2006
when will the sikhs around the world wake up and give rebirth to the movement for a sikh homeland.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
chingahri · 04 Jul 2006
why do sikhs not grow their beards, give up meat eating drinking smoking caste tribalisms grow their hair take amrit and make a change in their own libves and do selfless seva?
even amritdari sikhs i talk to are changing their ideas and views in life. There are very few sikhs left now who believe in gurmat.
Re: How did "1984" begin?
A Singh · 14 Jul 2006
I fully agree with the analysis of TRUE FACTS Date: 10-23-05 03:25