Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Wrong to eat kill an animal and eat it? How about mutton? lol..jus read it

Wrong to eat kill an animal and eat it? How about mutton? lol..jus read it

SenghSational · 21 Oct 2005

VJKK VJKF Firstly...I believe eating meat is COMPLETELY WRONG due to a number of reasons and implications in the Sikh Religion. For example; eating Fish fills the mind with lustful thoughts, and even in the Guru Granth Sahib Ji, negative reference is made to meat. THE THING IS; In my mind I like to picture possible arguments that an anti-Sikh/ or a random person may bring forward against my religion; and try and crush their argument. Not only is this wierd to some people; lol...but it brings me closer to my Sikhi. Here are a question I believe I would not be able to answer convincingly... and would appreciate it if some learned Sikh would shed some light. 1) (This is what one English guy asked me) If killing an animal for its meat is wrong...how about if the animal died from natural causes such as mutton? OR even still...why wouldn't you eat a lizzard's tail which has fallen off??? If you do eat it; your not hurting anyone; the tail isn't part of the lizard any more; and he won't feel no pain. lol...I kinda laughed. But I couldn't fully answer the question. I'll post more questions later. VJKK VJKF (sorry if i offended any one... but just imagine if a 6 year old kid asked you this. please simplify your answers as those are the ones which have most assar on lowww people like me) Jay phul chuk hogi, maaf karna!

Re: Wrong to eat kill an animal and eat it? How about mutton? lol..jus read it

..... · 21 Oct 2005

As an Amritdhari it is WRONG to eat the jooth of others... the lizard too eats food & therefore eating them would also mean your eating jooth.

Re: Wrong to eat kill an animal and eat it? How about mutton? lol..jus read it

Jasmin · 21 Oct 2005

It may seem O.K. to eat meat from animals that are already dead. After all you did not kill the animal. However you have benefited from it's death. You've used it, and in so doing it is likely you will develop a taste for meat. How many dead sheep are you going to find? Will you stop their? If we say eating meat is evil, when we eat a dead animal we admit our indifference to evil. Indifference to evil is evil, because we allow evil to grow when we are indifferent. WjkkWjkf

Re: Wrong to eat kill an animal and eat it? How about mutton? lol..jus read it

khalistani · 21 Oct 2005

man we dunt eat meat because of a couple of things it is bad for ure BHAGTHEE no matte rhow the animal was killed, meat is just a type of food that maks ure mind concentrate less on akaal eating simple foods, like daal rotee, are good for bhagthee keeps mind simple even eating really hardcore rich foods arnt good for ure bhagthee but meat is REALLY BAD, like bhagthee pooision now alothough halal is kureight, there is noe need to kill somethings mother or father for meat so if it dies by itself its still bad for urebhagthee now if ure in the jungles, and have nothing to eat, as long as its not halal, u can eat it but i dunt think many people r gonna get into a situation like tha these days, i mean subways everywhere go and grab a sub lol bhula chuka maf

Re: Wrong to eat kill an animal and eat it? How about mutton? lol..jus read it

RoopKaur · 21 Oct 2005

You are what you eat. Whatever that animal was feeling is what you will develop inside you. But the most important reason is that Gurbani tells us again and again that maas is wrong, as well as other historical references such as Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Jis hukamnamey, whatever Guru ji has stopped us against doing, there is always a good reason behind it whether we know it or not. For example, guru ji forbade us from smoking, and this was when no one knew the consequences of smoking, and now centuries later we are still learning the extent of damage that this digusting habit does. Likewise, science is also discovering that the human digestive system is not built for meat consumption, but for a vegetarian diet. Many health problems arise because we go against the laws of nature. There are probably many other reasons, and we must wait for science to attempt to catch up to what our guru jis have already protected us against.

Re: Wrong to eat kill an animal and eat it? How about mutton? lol..jus read it

Iron Man · 21 Oct 2005

dhuna(n)aeeaa muradhaar khuradhanee gaafal havaae || rehaao || The world eats dead carcasses, living by neglect and greed. ||Pause|| gaibaan haivaan haraam kusathanee muradhaar bakhoraae || Like a goblin, or a beast, they kill and eat the forbidden carcasses of meat. dhil kabaj kabajaa kaadharo dhojak sajaae ||2|| So control your urges, or else you will be seized by the Lord, and thrown into the tortures of hell. ||2|| [%sig%]