Birth Control
umm · 17 Oct 2005
i duno how to ask this, but i am just recently getting married and wondering if birth control is umm ok? like i duno is right for a gursikh to like go out and buy stuff at the store?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
umm · 17 Oct 2005
i duno how to ask this, but i am just recently getting married and wondering if birth control is umm ok? like i duno is right for a gursikh to like go out and buy stuff at the store?* · 17 Oct 2005
Use of birth control as a contraceptive is not in accordance with Gurmat. You'll have children if and when you're meant to. Birth isn't something that we as humans control anyway. It's all in Guru Sahib's hands. Count your blessings if you're fortunate and worthy enough to have children.bush · 17 Oct 2005
birth control is strictly for lust. it allows you to engage in kaami acts without allowing the female to be impregnated. im not buying all the westernized bs that pro birth control advocates are thowing back as excusesdsingh · 17 Oct 2005
I don't want this thread getting to graphic or anything, but it is not wrong to show affection for your wife./\ · 17 Oct 2005
Relations between a husband and wife are acceptable and allowed in Sikhi. Birth Control tries to take away all responsibility and committment from the act and reduces it to sheer recreation. Having a child is one of the responsiblities attached to this and if you aren't willing to bear that responsibility (to the other partner and the child) you should abstain. This is why premartial sex is so common: recreation with no responsiblities or committment. Birth Control is not acceptable according to Gurmat.sea · 19 Oct 2005
Many Gursikhs give in to fear, because they see Muslims in the UK having 6, 8, 10, 14 children. These Gursikhs indulge there fear by pressureizing other Gursikhs in to having as many children as possible. The real answer comes from Naam Simran. Not having a child right a way can be a way that you take responsibility for your relationship and your life together, and can be one of Waheguru's factors in how you have the number of children that Waheguru ji intends. But is that the right way for you? Only HE can tell you. We cannot, we are only his slaves. Naam Simran is better this silly fear. Find your answer there. Let HIM be your guideunreal · 19 Oct 2005
I'm not sure I buy that - A Sikh ideal is to be above kaam; however, kaam has a place in life. The same can be said for anger as well, although it is one of the "chors". Anger can be very useful in battle. Likewise, kaam is allowable in the confines of the grist-jeevan. I'm not promoting all-consuming, it's all you ever think about kaam but the exact limits depend on the husband and wife - Guru ji is silent on the question of such limits. Marriage is an institution promoted by our Gurus. Among other things, it protects against lust outside of the marital union. The ultimate goal of sexual relations is to produce children but I think it is a stretch to say that must be the goal at all times, everytime between husband and wife. What happens in the bedroom between husband and wife is strictly their business. I don't think any of our comments on limitations are appropriate or based on anything more than our own opinions. Leave it to the couple to decide what is best for them - intimacy between the two is not some evil, ugly thing - we're not Victorian.Kulbir Singh · 19 Oct 2005
The use of contraceptives is not in accordance to Gurmat. The problem today is that a vast majority of Sikhs make use of birth control measures. We forget that jeevan-maut is in hands of Vaheguru. How can one have more children than what Vaheguru wills? Kulbir Singhunreal · 19 Oct 2005
But Veer-ji, if you say (and I agree with you) that jeevan-maut is in the hands of Waheguru and that one will have as many children as Waheguru wills, then why does it matter if contraceptives are used? For example, maut is in the hands of Waheguru, but there is nothing wrong with wearing seatbelts when we drive. If our death is written, no seatbelt in the world is going to save us but it doesn't hurt to wear it. Kulbir Singh wrote: > The use of contraceptives is not in accordance to Gurmat. The > problem today is that a vast majority of Sikhs make use of > birth control measures. We forget that jeevan-maut is in hands > of Vaheguru. How can one have more children than what Vaheguru > wills? > > Kulbir Singh<cut: unacceptable name> · 19 Oct 2005
unreal wrote: "but there is nothing wrong with wearing seatbelts when we drive." That seatbelt is amrit, the driver is Vaheguru and Guru Granth Sahib is our manual book. have faith in that and nothing will go wrong. I think the problem with our society is that people try to mix in western culture with Sikhi. Nowadays, i see young Singhs and their Singhies hugging and touching etc, and carrying on like normal western couples in public. When i look at it, they are just like western couple except that they wear the punj kakars. This is not according to gurmat. I dont think you would see Sant Jarnail Singh or Bhai sahib with their arms around their Singhinee and being all lovie dovie or saying, "yeah bhai sahib, this is my boo". I mean, if you look at the new amritdhari couples, they cant seem to get enough of each other in the public. Now, i did not say that showing your emotion in public is wrong. However, it is wrong for singhs and singhinees. If you want to show ur affections in public, enjoy a good'ole westerns couples day or whatever....than you should have asked yourself whether the sikhi path is for you.SK · 19 Oct 2005
The use of certain contraceptives causes changes to harmones in the body (ie; the pill changes estrogen and testoserone levels) which is not natural.vivek · 19 Oct 2005
"A Sikh ideal is to be above kaam; however, kaam has a place in life. The same can be said for anger as well, although it is one of the "chors". Anger can be very useful in battle. Likewise, kaam is allowable in the confines of the grist-jeevan" kaam krodh have no place in the the minds of gurmukhs gurmukhs fight in battle with love (bir ras), when dasm patsah struck his enemies , they got nam ras, and became mukt. gurmukhs have no kaam, its not kaam which drives them reproduce, its gurus hukam, to live in a family and practise celibacy. gurmukhs at highest level can have children without lust, who says you need to be filled with libido to have children?singh · 19 Oct 2005
I think the real question boils down to if it is ok to have relations with ur wife if you do not intend to have children, Its a question I have never really thought about but would like to know the answer.~ · 19 Oct 2005
I think it goes beyond a question of 'life and death are in god's hands' . They are of course, using that argument leads to questions already asked like why seatbelts? Why look both ways before crossing the road? Why anything? I think a better explanation is the one already discussed that having these relations is fine but having them only in a situation where you are willing to accept the results that can follow meaning children. If you aren't , then don't do the act.sea · 19 Oct 2005
Kulbir Singh says "We forget that jeevan-maut is in hands of Vaheguru. How can one have more children than what Vaheguru wills?" And one cannot have less children than what Waheguru wills, for all moves that we make - including contraception - are only done if HE sees fit.unreal · 19 Oct 2005
I think there is a difference between having no anger and being the master of your anger. The same way there is a difference in having no kaam as opposed to being the master of your kaam. Kaam in the marital union, given that sexual interaction takes place, exists. You have said libido does not fill the Sikh but nevertheless, libido is necessary in order to engage in the act - if there is no libido, the act is impossible. The question is whether you are the master or your libido is the master. As long as you maintain control, libido is a natural, healthy part of life. Regarding anger, I don't know many Gursikhs who were filled with pyar for Indira Gandhi when she ordered Operation Bluestar and am not sure if there were many Gursikhs who were filled with pyar for the perpetrators of gross abuse on helpless Sikh children and women in Delhi. Anger, focused anger is a part of battle; the key again, is to be in control of it and the ability to channel it when and how you wish and not let it control you.vivek · 20 Oct 2005
Regarding anger, I don't know many Gursikhs who were filled with pyar for Indira Gandhi when she ordered Operation Bluestar and am not sure if there were many Gursikhs who were filled with pyar for the perpetrators of gross abuse on helpless Sikh children and women in Delhi. Anger, focused anger is a part of battle; the key again, is to be in control of it and the ability to channel it when and how you wish and not let it control you. gurmukhs are filled with pyar for god, they see god in there enemies, they have no hatred or anger like when dasm patsah fought in battle, the enemies he struck doen got mukhti, and received nam ras. bir ras is very different from anger, anger implies they are upset with gods hukam/written will. singhs fighting with bir ras, have no anger, they are in bliss while fighting, so it appears they are angry because of their ferocity, its not anger. when gurmukhs merge with god, the panj chor flee, its therefore impossible for a gurmukh to practise kaam, krodh, lobh, moh, onkar.g · 20 Oct 2005
1. Relations with your wife is not kaam, its simply a way of showing love and affection 2. It's not gonna last very long anyways get it out of your system and go on with your everyday life 3. why is it anybody elses buisness what you do with your wife/husband... they have no right to tell you what you can do or cant do. I cant even believe people bring this up =P 4. Its your choice if you want to you use Birth control, Some people arent ready for kids they might still be in school or cannot afford to have kids yet if you chose not to have relations thats your choice but there is nothing wrong with it... its between you and your spouse no where in Gurbani does it say anything on this subject this is all personal opinions. I'm sorry if all you have experinced with your spouse is kaam, Ive experinced kaam... and its alot diffrent that The love and affection I give to my spouse Huge diffrence, I am sorry if you are uncapeable of experinceing this but dont try to bring others down to your level because all you are capable of is kaam.unreal · 20 Oct 2005
We're getting into semantics now. Bir-ras and focused, controlled anger carry the same meaning for me - a difference in terms only. However that doesn't address the fact that libido is a necessary element in engaging in marital relations. I reiterate, it is not the absence of libido which is key but the absolute control of it.... · 20 Oct 2005
what about birth control that isnt medicine, u know the other kind of birth control that gore keep in their wallets, is that ok?g · 20 Oct 2005
what about birth control that isnt medicine, u know the other kind of birth control that gore keep in their wallets, is that ok? In my personal opinion its fine... also I think you guys should stop refering to people as gore, these gore do that these gore do this... there's white sikhs too... seems kinda racistomg · 21 Oct 2005
waheguru...i can't believe this topic.....first off.... CONTRACEPTION IS NOT ALLOWED ....simple as that and as for people who think they can get pregnant straight away...well sometimes it's not possible.... this is where living in bhana and hukum comes into play.. think about it....singh · 21 Oct 2005
*********** Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 10-19-05 09:49 The use of contraceptives is not in accordance to Gurmat. The problem today is that a vast majority of Sikhs make use of birth control measures. We forget that jeevan-maut is in hands of Vaheguru. How can one have more children than what Vaheguru wills? Kulbir Singh ********* Jeevan Maut is in hands of akalpurakh........very true Why do Sikhs go to hospitals/doctors taking treatment? Are they not sikh.(though i know some who dont and never) Why do sikhs take medicines? Does you profess that no medicines should be taken because pain is also bhana and one should bear it without trying to reduce it? Need some answers hereKulbir Singh · 21 Oct 2005
---------- Jeevan Maut is in hands of akalpurakh........very true Why do Sikhs go to hospitals/doctors taking treatment? Are they not sikh.(though i know some who dont and never) Why do sikhs take medicines? -------- Taking medicine for disease cannot be equated to using contraceptives. Having a child is not a disease and hence there is no need to use birth control. From what I have learned from sangat and senior Singhs, birth control is grossly anti-Gurmat. There was even an hukamnama from Siri Akal Takhat Sahib in the late eighties, when Professor Darshan Singh was the jathedar, prohibiting Sikhs from using contraceptives As a poster posted in this thread, use of contraceptives will reduce the love between husband and wife to mere recreational activity. -------- Does you profess that no medicines should be taken because pain is also bhana and one should bear it without trying to reduce it? -------- I don’t’ profess that medicine should not be taken. Vaheguru’s bhaana is never to hurt us or bring pain to us. Behind every hardship we endure, the motive is to motivate us to japp Naam and apply the daaroo (medicine) of Naam. Kulbir Singhunreal · 21 Oct 2005
We are dealing with opinions only. Whether contraceptives are allowed or not, is a matter of opinion so, no offense meant, an opinion is not the same as Guru ji's hukum or official edict. This is my opinion: whatever intimacy a husband and wife have between them is their business only - no one has any authority to tell them what is allowable or not. As to the purpose or goal of their intimacy, again, that is their business and no one else's. I do not see intimacy with one's spouse as some evil or ugly thing. To reiterate, that is only my opinion. I, like other posters, have little in the way of Gurbani backing me up on my point. omg wrote: > waheguru...i can't believe this topic.....first off.... > CONTRACEPTION IS NOT ALLOWED ....simple as that > and as for people who think they can get pregnant straight > away...well sometimes it's not possible.... > this is where living in bhana and hukum comes into play.. > think about it..... · 21 Oct 2005
I think if akal takht sahib said its not allowed, its not allowed. Were they specific? like no pills or did they say nothing is allowed? I am surprised akal takht sahib issued a hukam on this.tableji · 23 Oct 2005
jabay ban lageo, tabai ros jageo guruji was struck by an arrow, and had ros? what does that mean??I Kaur · 23 Oct 2005
I think it’s up to each individual couple to decide and nobody else’s business. With regard to the ‘Chors’ I prefer to consider them as dutiful, respected, servants. For example when anger comes, I listen to what it has to say and then decide what I need to do in response to the value or boundary that I or another has violated. My journey of self mastery and spiritual growth starts with the consciousness that I am a ‘soul’; this is my true identity, who 'I' really am. I am not my mind. Suddenly all the servants flee to their corners, the Masters home. [%sig%]Doctor · 23 Oct 2005
In this debate, we should consider the consequences of the contraceptives. For example, the birth control pill prevents the FERTILISED OVUM from adjoining onto the placenta in the uterus. Hence the unborn child - a potential Soul - is flushed away. We should really think about that. Consider the amount of paap one could commit through the use of these contraceptives. In addition many of these drugs have many many side effects. Why throw hormones into a healthy system - it's beyond me.unreal · 24 Oct 2005
I would defer to your expertise as a doctor with regards to the effect of birth control pills on the human body; however, your comments regarding "potential soul" are a little shaky. All potential for the placement of souls is in the hands of God - and if we want to argue about when a person is a person, or a baby is a baby, or a soul becomes part of that baby, then there are plenty of Pro-life and Pro-choice debates to be found online which touch on these arguments. (note: I am not advocating abortion! Simply stating that discussions of soul, and "humanness" on this topic are found aplenty). Consider prophylactics, which essentially prevent the ovum from becoming fertilized in the first place......but this could also be seen as destroying the possibility of a potential soul..........it's a slippery slope this argument. For that matter, abstaining from sex when one could engage in it, could also be seen as destroying the possibility of a potential soul..........and the slope gets even more slippery... Doctor wrote: > In this debate, we should consider the consequences of the > contraceptives. For example, the birth control pill prevents > the FERTILISED OVUM from adjoining onto the placenta in the > uterus. Hence the unborn child - a potential Soul - is flushed > away. We should really think about that. Consider the amount > of paap one could commit through the use of these > contraceptives. > > In addition many of these drugs have many many side effects. > Why throw hormones into a healthy system - it's beyond me.Seaside Kaur · 24 Oct 2005
And the slope could get more slippery still... Families do not have to grow through sex. Families can also grow when the parents quiet their ego enough to open their hearts to a child that has no parents of his own/her own. However, by keeping the conversation just on sex and pregnancy, this keeps a Sikh from thinking about seva - the very worthy seva of adoption.unreal · 24 Oct 2005
Well said. It is such a noble, and very "Sikh" thing to do but we tend not to see adoption unless the couple are physically unable to have children. Is adoption the better route to take? Should it be the preferrable route for Gursikhs? I don't know but your post has made me think. Seaside Kaur wrote: > And the slope could get more slippery still... > > Families do not have to grow through sex. Families can also > grow when the parents quiet their ego enough to open their > hearts to a child that has no parents of his own/her own. > > However, by keeping the conversation just on sex and pregnancy, > this keeps a Sikh from thinking about seva - the very worthy > seva of adoption.Iron Man · 24 Oct 2005
from http://blog.mkhalsa.com/2005/06/adoption.html Adoption Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh! This is something that has been on my mind in the past few months, and really in the back of my mind for years: Adoption. I am nowhere ready for it now, as I am realizing, but sometime, hopefully in the near future, I want to adopt kids (hopefully I will be married as well before I do that!). I have said this to many people who know me and some have said that it is a great idea. Others have said, "WHY?! Whats wrong with having your own kids?" Nothing is wrong with having your own kids--I want to have "my own" kids eventually as well. But I want to adopt kids first and foremost. What makes them not my kids? Just because their genes are different? Skin color? Eye color? If I adopt them, they are my kids and will be forever. Here's the way I see it. First, as Sikhs we have a DUTY to adopt kids. Yes, a DUTY. Guru Gobind Singh Jee set the example by adopting four sahibzadas. He had four of "his own" and four he adopted. Do we as Sikhs not have a duty to do seva? Think about the incredible seva it would be to change even one person's life, and even more importantly, bring that person into Sikhi, ensure that person grows up to be a moral and just human being. Tell me, is this not a great seva (service to mankind)? I mean, who are we to bring more kids into this world when so many are suffering? So many have no parents. So many turn to drugs, gangs and even prostitution. Many grow up to eventually abuse or neglect their children. I am not saying all, but some. So stopping this from happening to one child, is this not a great seva? And not to mention the generations to come from that child you adopted. Think about it.. If every gursikh family in North America were to even adopt one child, think about how strong Sikhi would be here. Think about how much fewer children would suffer here. These are just some of the reasons I have. Not to mention the fact that it would be pretty cool when I have a little fauj of black, white, asian children running around at samagams! errr *cough cough* sitting down and listening to keertan.... Just some thoughts. I hope some of my older brothers and sisters who are in a position of stability and can do this seva now, I hope you consider my words and think about this seriously. I know I have and as soon as it becomes possible for me to do so, I intend to adopt as well. So hear my benti veer jees/bhen jees I know this is a very important, life altering decision, but think of all the good you will do. _____________________________________________ anyway no1 has really answered the original posters question.. I dont think he/she was asking about birth control pills...!! · 25 Oct 2005
""Jeevan Maut is in hands of akalpurakh........very true""" In punjab sikhs including amritdhari sikhs are aborting female fetus. where is their sikhi? This is all yap yap yap. [%sig%]* · 25 Oct 2005
The question has already been answered. If you think about it from a Gurmat perspective, there's no way birth control is acceptable as a contraceptive. From a non-Gurmat perspective, we can say "it's no one else's business, it's up to the couple", etc etc etc, but there's a term for that -- it's called Manmat.sandeep · 25 Oct 2005
I think our guru always want us to be on the top of the world. I beleive if you do something , with a trust in your guru, nothing is wrong. we should go beyond these futile discussions and have faith in our guru. mere sikh path is jag toon niaaraa hai...unreal · 26 Oct 2005
With respect, you are incorrect. You are simply passing off your opinion (manmat) as Gurmat. Outside of your own opinion (manmat), you have provided nothing with respect to Gurbani or Guru ji's edicts on this issue. As far as I am aware, Sikhi is silent on this issue. * wrote: > The question has already been answered. If you think about it > from a Gurmat perspective, there's no way birth control is > acceptable as a contraceptive. From a non-Gurmat perspective, > we can say "it's no one else's business, it's up to the > couple", etc etc etc, but there's a term for that -- it's > called Manmat.Harjinder Singh · 26 Oct 2005
In my humble opinion, I think birth control and especially facial hair are the issues that affects primarily only Singhnees. So Only Singhs who can practically contribute to help the singhnees in this situation should actually give their judgment on this issue. Personally I feel it very hard to say anything negative about any singhnee who find herself very week to handle these two things as per Gurmat. Regarding facial hair issue, I personally blame primarily the Singhs (and also the singhnees who do not have this God-given so called abnormality) for the challenge that Singhnees have. I have personally seen many divorces or situations leading to divorces on the issue of facial hair in many Sikh families and unfortunately most of them in AKJ. We who do not have these issues in our lives need to do practical efforts to give higher respect to the sisters/mothers who show extra-ordinary courage to overcome these challenges to live on Gurmat path WITH PROUD. So we should not make such a singhnee feel like a victim but we should treat her like a hero in practical. Unfortunately, it is very rare to find such singhs who do not care for physical so called outer beauty in practical when the time comes to test them. If a singh and the surrounding sangat have top priority for such a singhnee, I do not find any reason that such a singhnee will not feel proud for the gift (so called abnormality) of Waheguru they have in special. Regarding birth control, only all singhnees have common challenge. So only singhnees should be given authority to resolve it and decide the solution and singhs must follow the singhnee and make any kind of sacrifice on this issue subject to no violation of Gurmat . [%sig%]?? · 26 Oct 2005
we must understand the root cause of birth control. 1.Majority of sikh families want baby boy and no one look forward for the birth of a baby girl. 2.Every family demands a well educated daughter in law. 3. Every family expect daughter in law to bring a large dowery. To meet these demands people need family planning. As some body already mentioned about female fetus. A get good education you need a lot of money. And I have no words to explain the demand of dowery. In punjab how many young women die within a year after the wedding. The greed has crossed all limits. Every body is runing after maya. NOT the NAAM. [%sig%]kaur · 26 Oct 2005
birth control is not always effective and not in accordance with Gurmat. it's all Vaheguroo's bhana how many kids you have. my mom told me that she was on the pill when she became pregnant with me. [%sig%]hmm · 26 Oct 2005
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>In my humble opinion, I think birth control and especially facial hair are the issues that affects primarily only Singhnees. So Only Singhs who can practically contribute to help the singhnees in this situation<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< ummm, i dont think the birth control teh topic start is talking about is for singhnees, but the one for guys.. not the pill... thats the impression i got.. and I think its ok for guys to use that, i mean then theres no disease or whatever else? right?gloves! · 27 Oct 2005
I think they are talking about protection..g · 27 Oct 2005
Author: * Date: 10-25-05 18:52 The question has already been answered. If you think about it from a Gurmat perspective, there's no way birth control is acceptable as a contraceptive. From a non-Gurmat perspective, we can say "it's no one else's business, it's up to the couple", etc etc etc, but there's a term for that -- it's called Manmat. ------------- How is that a non-Gurmat perspective? it is no one buisness what I do with my wife why would it be somone elses buisness ?!? do you want to know what I do behind closed doors with my wife? what you Said makes no sense The Term is not called Manmat its called privacy, Please when you have some Gurbani to back up what you are saying then you can speak and call it manmat... But all you are doing is passing your personal Opinion as Gurmat and that is manmat.* · 27 Oct 2005
g Jee, Do you have Gurbani to back up YOUR point? I don't have Gurbani to back mine up either, but as stated earlier, there was a Hukamnaama passed by Sri Akal Takhat Sahib in the eighties prohibiting the use of contraceptives. So adhering to your right to "privacy" over a Hukamnaama can surely not be called Gurmat.singh · 27 Oct 2005
birth control is manmat, but not kurehit bleaching/ plucking facial hair is a kurehit you cannot compare.Princess · 27 Oct 2005
//////// 3. why is it anybody elses buisness what you do with your wife/husband... they have no right to tell you what you can do or cant do. I cant even believe people bring this up =P ////// G jee, Can one beat up his wife and say it's not anyone's business? Don't try to look at things in western way. Gursikhs lead their lives according to Gurmat and if someone is doing manmat, other gursikhs have full right to correct that person. ///// 4. Its your choice if you want to you use Birth control, Some people arent ready for kids they might still be in school or cannot afford to have kids yet if you chose not to have relations thats your choice but there is nothing wrong with it... its between you and your spouse no where in Gurbani does it say anything on this subject this is all personal opinions. ///// If someone is not ready for children then wait for marriage till they are ready. If we believe in your statement then it means one gets maaried just to satisfy his/her kaam but marriage means something else not just kaam. Gursikhs are suppose to follow Gurmat not their own choices. If We have offered our heads to take Amrit and Naam to Guru Sahib jee then there can't be anything like 'our own choices'. By using Birth control we interfere in Waheguru's law-of-nature but by wearing seat builts it is not so. That's the difference between these two issues which are not even comparable. [gurbani]slwmu jbwbu dovY kry muMFhu GuQw jwie ][/gurbani] salaam jabaab dhovai karae mu(n)dtahu ghuthhaa jaae || One who offers both respectful greetings and rude refusal to his master, has gone wrong from the very beginning. [gurbani]nwnk dovY kUVIAw Qwie n kweI pwie ]2][/gurbani] naanak dhovai koorreeaa thhaae n kaaee paae ||2|| O Nanak, both of his actions are false; he obtains no place in the Court of the Lord. ||2|| [gurbani] sqgur kw Bwxw mMin leI ivchu Awpu gvwie ][/gurbani] sathagur kaa bhaanaa ma(n)n lee vichahu aap gavaae || I will accept the Will of the True Guru, and eradicate selfishness from within. [gurbani] eyhw syvw cwkrI nwmu vsY min Awie ][/gurbani] eaehaa saevaa chaakaree naam vasai man aae || By this work and service, the Naam shall come to dwell within my mind. [gurbani]jo hir pRB Bwxw so QIAw Duir iliKAw n mytY koie ]3][/gurbani] jo har prabh bhaanaa so thheeaa dhhur likhiaa n maettai koe ||3|| All things happen according to the Will of the Lord God. No one can erase the pre-ordained Writ of Destiny. ||3|| [gurbani]hir kw Bwxw BgqI mMinAw sy Bgq pey dir Qwie ]3][/gurbani] har kaa bhaanaa bhagathee ma(n)niaa sae bhagath peae dhar thhaae ||3|| The Lord's devotees surrender to His Will; those devotees are accepted at His Door. ||3|| [gurbani]siqgur kw Bwxw kmwvdy ibKu haumY qij ivkwru ]5][/gurbani] sathigur kaa bhaanaa kamaavadhae bikh houmai thaj vikaar ||5|| They act in harmony with the Will of the True Guru; they shed the poison of ego and corruption. ||5|| [gurbani]jo ikCu vrqY sB qyrw Bwxw ][/gurbani] jo kishh varathai sabh thaeraa bhaanaa || Whatever happens, is all according to Your Will. [gurbani]ijin jin mwinAw pRB kw Bwxw ]2][/gurbani] jin jan maaniaa prabh kaa bhaanaa ||2|| who surrender to the Will of God. ||2|| [gurbani]jg mih AwieAw so prvwxu ][/gurbani] jag mehi aaeiaa so paravaan || Blessed is their coming into this world [gurbani]so isKu sKw bMDpu hY BweI ij gur ky Bwxy ivic AwvY ][/gurbani] so sikh sakhaa ba(n)dhhap hai bhaaee j gur kae bhaanae vich aavai || He alone is a Sikh, a friend, a relative and a sibling, who walks in the Way of the Guru's Will. [gurbani]AwpxY BwxY jo clY BweI ivCuiV cotw KwvY ][/gurbani] aapanai bhaanai jo chalai bhaaee vishhurr chottaa khaavai || One who walks according to his own will, O Siblings of Destiny, suffers separation from the Lord, and shall be punished. [%sig%]g · 28 Oct 2005
Author: * Date: 10-27-05 12:36 g Jee, Do you have Gurbani to back up YOUR point? I don't have Gurbani to back mine up either, but as stated earlier, there was a Hukamnaama passed by Sri Akal Takhat Sahib in the eighties prohibiting the use of contraceptives. So adhering to your right to "privacy" over a Hukamnaama can surely not be called Gurmat. ------- No I dont have Gurbani to back up my Point and I never claimed to =P but I am not going around saying this is Gurmat and his is manmat as you are with your personal opinion. Princess.... In no way can you compare beating your wife with having relations with your wife beating your wife is wrong having relations with your wife is not. And you keep refering to birthcontrol as manmut but can provide no Gurbani to back up your opinion and somones Interpretation of a hukam they took is not good enough. And I NEVER said marriage was about kaam quiet the opposite I dont believe anything you do with your spouse is kaam, I believe you can have relations with your spouse as a way of showing love and affection towards them I do not know why this concept is so foriegn to you people do you not feel love towards your spouses? I do not get it Somone can get married because they want companionship to love somone to share life with... Somone to help them grow in sikhi give them extra strength in sikhi... anyone who thinks about kaam when they think of marriage is a pig, and thier are alot out there. I do not believe it is interfering with any laws of Guru ji if Guru ji wants you to have a baby he will make you want one and not use birth control, it is all his will is it not? And like I said somones Interpretation of a Hukamnama is not good enough backup I dont care who they are, I probally interpret Hukamnam's way diffrent than anyone else but I do not advise anyone to follow my Interpretation's when you show me a line in Gurbani where it speaks against Birth Control then I will believe you Gurbani has all the answers right? And if you really believe that it is kaam then why not just avoid relations there are ways to have baby's without relations why not just do that? It is not kaam with your spouse* · 28 Oct 2005
g Jee, "And like I said somones Interpretation of a Hukamnama is not good enough backup..." You've misunderstood. I'm not talking about a Hukamnaama from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee that any random person can read and interpret. I'm talking about a Hukamnaama issued by the Jathedar of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib, ie. a direct order, like how recently a Hukamnaama was issued for Sikhs to oppose gay marriage. In the 80's, the Jathedaar of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib, Professor Darshan Singh, issued a Hukamnaama prohibiting Sikhs from using contraceptives. It's an order that the Panth must accept and abide by.Princess · 28 Oct 2005
//// And you keep refering to birthcontrol as manmut but can provide no Gurbani to back up your opinion and somones Interpretation of a hukam they took is not good enough //// g jee, anything that breaks law of nature(Waheguru) is manmat. All above Gurbani punkities I have quoted are proof of what Guru Sahib jee wants us to do. If you can't understand or you don't want to understand the message then no one can help you. ///// I do not believe it is interfering with any laws of Guru ji if Guru ji wants you to have a baby he will make you want one and not use birth control, it is all his will is it not? ///// If Guru jee wanted you to have babies HE made you to get married to opposite sex why use your own mat to avoid HIS bhaana(will)? If HE does not want you to have babies HE won't even if you are not using birth control. What is according to HIS will using it or accepting HIS will without using it?Singh · 28 Oct 2005
I think Sikhs should have as many kids as possible.g · 28 Oct 2005
"You've misunderstood. I'm not talking about a Hukamnaama from Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee that any random person can read and interpret. I'm talking about a Hukamnaama issued by the Jathedar of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib," Thats why I said I dont care who read it =P they are people they are not God's it is not in Guru Granth sahib I do not care for what they say. Princess According to you it breaks the law of nature, ok using your same rule then we should not drive cars it is not natural we should not use computers not natural we should not use ovens microwaves anything! they all break the rule's of nature... these are all tools to live life same with birth control if you dont want to have kids wich is somones choice they can either not have relations or they can use birth control one is not worse than the other you say it's kaam, I say it is not kaam with your spouse. do you know what love and affection is? it's going to be the same thing if you use birth control or not your going ot do it for the same reason if your not ready to have kids yet then use it... that would be Guru ji's will if you do use it he created all he gave us the tools... you have your belief thats fine It's wrong for you to use birthcontrol but dont tell me or anyone else it is wrong for us when you have no Gurbani to back up your claims... you say there was a hukamnama? but these people are not my Guru's they are not Guru's at all They are people.... Sorry but in no way is that good enough, stick to the basic's we know whats wrong and right in sikhi Gurbani tells us that much... Do you think Waheguru is going to punish you for using birthcontrol? you must think Waheguru is a evil god... I feel sorry that you feel this way about Waheguru, I think there are much bigger issues in our community that we need to be addressing... I have seen so much Greed backstabbing come out of our community from people who are supposed to be "high up there" Gursikh's respected and all the ninday people do... and here we are discussing birthcontrol something that should only be discussed between husband and wife and whats right for them.Singh · 29 Oct 2005
When was the below provided "there was a Hukamnaama passed by Sri Akal Takhat Sahib in the eighties prohibiting the use of contraceptives." I have never heard or seen of it, please can it be posted on this site, as I don't think it exists.