Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

seek · 17 Oct 2005

are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's? is it true they have been ex-communicated from the panth?

Re: are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

""""" · 18 Oct 2005

But AKJ are Naamdharis

Re: are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

Hello · 18 Oct 2005

naamdharis?

Re: are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

??????????? · 19 Oct 2005

wot r naamdharis? [%sig%]

Re: are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

ekta · 19 Oct 2005

i don't think naamdharis have been excommunicated?

Re: are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

LiongKing · 20 Oct 2005

I'm nto sure fi they come into the 5 people not to associate with. I want to larn Raag Kirtan with trad instruments, and for that I would need to learn from naamdharis - can anyoen answer which ones are excommunicated. As far as I can remember it's the - * Masands * Dhirmaliye * Ram Raiye * Kuri mar * Minas (found from rehitnamey) * Not sure if Narakdhari's were added after 1978.. Can Kulbir SIngh or some other knowledgebale person tell us about this?

Re: are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

Vahegurooooo · 21 Oct 2005

nirankaris/narkdharis have been since around 1978 by the akaal takht

Re: are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

khalistan zindabad · 21 Oct 2005

Naamdhaaris believe in 10 gurus BUT BUT they dint stop over there and continued to have their gurus.Their present guru is Satguru Pratap Singh and recently they opened a big hospital in his name in Ludhaina,Punjab. In the recent version of Khandedhar,published by Damdami Taksal people,naamdharis have been showed to be doing HAVAN.They have lots of maryadas in contradion with SIKHS oF GURU GRANTH SAHIB MAHARAJ. The only positive thing about naamdharis is that they played a very important role in the independence of HINDUUUUUUUUU STAN and were part of kooka lehar. KHALISTAN ZINDABAD

Re: are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

LionKing · 21 Oct 2005

Nirankaris and Narakdhari's are the followers of Bachna papi, and are not the Same as Naamdhari's...

Re: are we allowed to associate with naamdhari's?

G SINGH · 21 Oct 2005

nakdharees (fake nirankarees) are excommunicated, NOT NAAMDHARIS