Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

The Right-Wing March of The Tribune

The Right-Wing March of The Tribune

khalsa_force · 15 Oct 2005

The Right-Wing March of The Tribune Founded by Sardar Dyal Singh Majithia. A letter to its Editor by Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann, President, Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar). Quilla S. Harnam Singh, Fatehgarh Sahib. 12th October 2005. To, The Editor, The Tribune, Chandigarh. Dear Sir, Please refer to your editorial “Beasts in Khaki” dated 11.10.05 of your esteemed paper. I think this editorial, which comes down hard on the Panjab police is totally incongruous with the new thinking of your paper, which is leaning more and more on making The Tribune an ultra-right wing paper of the Hindutva doctrine. During the period of Mr. Hari Jai Singh’s editorship, this paper liberally carried every shade of opinion. I think this was the purpose of Sardar Dyal Singh’s Majithia’s philanthropic design and hope. Recently in Kharar there has been a beastly murder of three young men and the rape of a young lady purportedly at the hands of a powerful land mafia and an extra-judicial murder of two young Kashmiri citizens by the Panjab Police in Pathankot. In the horror of Kharar the Ropar Police has taken no action against the accused or registered a rape case. In the latter your reporter Mr. Lalit Mohan has reported in detail. But both these dastardly crimes have not been reported in your paper. The minority point of view is being totally censored and obliterated by your paper. What finds notice in your paper is the hard Hindutva of the RSS and BJP and soft Hindutva of the Congress party. Any opposition to these two thoughts, propounded by either of these two parties does not find acceptance in your paper. Your foreign and defence policy writers can write anything on a right-wing state, but comments contrary to these writings are never printed. Right wing editorials denouncing concessions to Muslims by the Andhra Pradesh government or a hard hitting editorial against the Sikhs in the Kanishka air disaster are the rage. No one can challenge these editorials. Any comment to them is considered blasphemy. We hear of your correspondents traveling with Prime Ministers entourage, reporting from Washington DC that America has given a nuclear status to India. This is flashed as head lines news in your paper. Obviously it is not true on the day of reporting and not true till this day. Christians are not allowed to hold meetings in Panjab. Any condemnation of this anti secular view is not published. The Prime Minister is invited to a Tribune function. The Tribune represents all shades of opinion. But only supporters of Hindutva are invited. Any criticism of the Prime Minister’s Panjab visit is not printed. Sikh leaders like Parkash Singh Badal and Amarinder Singh who accept Hindutva are glorified but those of us who oppose this pernicious doctrine have become persona non grata with your paper. A British diplomat in Pakistan is expelled for having a liaison with a lady but your paper calls him a UN diplomat. You mention the Western Australian city as Pert, whereas it’s Perth. You say the French submarine is Scorpion, whereas it’s Scorpene. No one can challenge these howlers. There is a steep fall in the standard of good English in the paper. Grammatical, spelling errors and incorrect English has become standard practice. We Sikhs are ashamed, as this paper was founded by one of us and represents our region. The massacre of the Sikhs in 1984 is consistently referred to as a riot by The Tribune, though everyone knows that a riot is between two opposing religious, political, social or doctrinal groups. In 1984 only Sikhs were massacred by the Hindus. None from amongst the attacking Hindu groups was even injured. When Sardar Dyal Singh Majithia founded the Tribune Trust it was his desire that all South Asians whether Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians and Dalits would find employment within the administrative and journalist sphere of this paper. Today Hindus form 90% of the staff and reporters. The late Prem Bhatia also followed a very hard sectarian policy and was rabid in his views against the Sikhs. He along with Giri Lal Jain of the Times of India and Arun Shorie of the Indian Express were the leaders of the pack that denounced the Sikhs in the 1980’s and early 1990’s. Their ghost has now come to haunt the Tribune and a lot of journalists. The Tribune is the fourth pillar of the state along with the other press. We know the minorities have lost faith in the other three pillars, the legislature, judiciary and the executive. If the press becomes a victim of communal, sectarian and racist thought, it would not be good for South Asia. I am sure you at the Tribune want a strong India and not a strong Hindu religious nationalism. If you want the latter then a barbaric and corrupt police force is good for right wing nationalism as the Nazis and Fascists found and built. That is why in the neo Bhatia revivalism I say your editorial “Beasts in Khaki” is incongruous. Your paper has accepted the pardon the Governor of Panjab has given to the two police officers who committed the genocide of the Sikhs. As such there is no mention of this insensitive decision in your editorial “Beasts in Khaki”. Do you realize that none of the perpetrators of the genocide of the Sikhs, Muslims and Christians has been brought to book by the Indian state to date. There are two ministers in the Union cabinet, Mr. P. Chidambaram and Mr. Kamal Nath who have committed the genocide of the Sikh peoples. Your paper is on first class terms with them. Mr. Bhajan Lal another murderer of the Sikh peoples has got another term as the Congress President in Haryana. There will, obviously be no adverse comment. On page two today 12.10.2005 you report with aplomb of the birthday of Amitab Bachan. How are your readers interested in this news? I have met the press several times in various towns, Amritsar, Jallandhar, Patiala, Ludhiana, Barnala, Sangrur, Chandigarh, Chamba, Kharar about the human right violations and the futile visits of Mrs. Sonia Gandhi and Prime Minister. This news I am told can’t be printed as your paper has no space as other important news has to be given coverage. Extra-judicial murders, rapes and murders of innocents not registered by the police, the poor economic condition of the farmers and their suicides and the discrimination against Christians and penniless Dalit Sikh widows is more important than the birthday of Amitab Bachan. How callous, to the far right and irresponsible can the Tribune get? I call for an open dialogue between the minorities and your papers Trustees on the right wing march and poor standard of your paper. The communal imbalance in employment by your paper also needs to be corrected and debated. Thanking you, Yours faithfully, Simranjit Singh Mann, President, Shiromani Akali Dal (Amritsar)