Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

Facts · 13 Oct 2005

Were the Sikhs wrong in 1857 when they helped the British against the Sepoy mutiny in India also known as the first war for Intendance? Shouldn’t the Sikhs have helped the Sepoys instead of being the main reason for their defeat? Sikh historians tend to support the stance the Sikhs took in 1857 against the sepoys, but if the Sikhs had helped the mutineeing Sepoys and Indian nationalists like Tatya Tope, the British would have been OUT of India, and we could have regained our Sikh Raaj. What do you guys think? [%sig%]

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

Singh · 13 Oct 2005

No they werent wrong because the other side wanted the Mughals back I think?

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

** · 13 Oct 2005

mutiny of 1857 was not a war for independent india. it was a war for independent small personal kingdoms. sikhs lost their sikh raj because indians helped the british armies.

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

UK Singh · 13 Oct 2005

If you look at Indian history, The Sikh Kingdom was the last to be taken over by the British empire. Obviously what ever methods the British took over the Sikh Kingdom the Sikhs in their army were well treated and rewarded for their bravery. They soon became the most important part of the Empire army and thus became very loyal. However Sikhs never forgot the sepoys who were in the empire army. Thus the brutality that was set upon the sepoys by the Sikhs in the mutiny were sometimes described by the British Officers as frightning. It also put the status of the Sikhs in the Empire army even higher and even people in England knew of their strength and valour. But if anyone has more info on the mutiny and the Sikhs role in crushing it please post as this was a important part of Indian History. [%sig%]

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

Guru da Kookar · 13 Oct 2005

Payre Khalsa jio, Waheguru jee ka Khalsa, Waheguru jee kee Fateh. For more and very relevent information on this topic see a article by Veerjee Sukhpreet Singh Udhoke ( but one problems is there it is in Punjabi and if you know Punjabi your every question will be answered by this article regarding so callled first war on independace) on www.khalsaalliance.org. It is very insteresting article and will give you all the details whether sikhs were right or wrong and it will also let you know whether the 1857 Mutiny was a first war on india's independance or was it a ......................... Waheguru jee ka Khalsa. Waheguru jee kee Fateh. [%sig%]

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 13 Oct 2005

how could it have been a fight for "INDEPENDENCE" when all they wanted was to put the MUGHAL EMPEROR back on the Throne of delhi ?? Didnt the Mahartaas under Shivaji and the Sikhs fight to defeat the MUGHAL EMPIRE ?? How could the SIKHS accept a MUGHAL EMPEROR in Delhi ??.....and the HINDUS ?? didnt the HINDUS have enough of the Mughals even after 1000 years of SLAVERY ?? This so called mutiny was a rising of small kingdoms fighting for their own petty reasons....and they were not very good at it either...thats why they LOST.

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

Kulwant Singh Sandhra · 13 Oct 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Many people assert this beief that the Sikhs were in some way wrong in fighting alongside the British in 1857. What people often FORGET is that when the British fought with the Sikhs in 1846 and 1848 it was not just the British versus the Sikh kingdom BUT in fact the British plus ALL of India versus the Sikhs. The British were very clever in how they pursued their colonization of India. They started it in southern India, perhaps the most weakest area in all of India. The company's major ports were at Madras and Bombay. Slowly slowly the British progeressed towards the north of India and overtook the vast kingdoms of North India, for example Oudh. The fact of the matter is that all the kingdoms in India were GHULAMS and did not have the guts nor power to combat with the British. The only kingdom that took a strong stand against the British colonization was only the Sikh kingdom of Punjab. By 1846 the British had developed an awesome economic and trading power in India, the final step was to conquer Punjab. Everyone knows that at that time the Sikh kingdom was under scrutiny as the death of Maharaja Ranjit Singh brought the fall of the Sikh Raj in Punjab. The British couldn't find a better chance to take advantage of Punjab's weakness. So long behold the British (alongside with the rest of India) invaded Punjab but, the Sikhs did not give in that fast and fought TWO bloody gruesome wars with the British. Though the Sikhs were surprised that other Hindus and Muslims from India whom they thought were their own brothers could be such traitors. So in 1857 fighting alongside the British gave the Sikhs a chance for revenge. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

ekta · 13 Oct 2005

the mutiny was an act of ankh by the sikhs when they chose 2 side with the british. as the hindus aided the brits in punjab.

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

PSS · 13 Oct 2005

however the more of this matter you can read from this link: http://www.sikh-history.com/sikhhist/events/mutiny1857.html Fateh!! P.S.Sandhu

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

JS · 13 Oct 2005

The British were also aided in 1857 by Hindu Dogras, Gurkhas and many Hindu Kingdoms.Also Punjabi Muslims, Pathans and loyal Muslim Kingdoms helped the British. It must be understood that Punjab acted as an independent country, the concept of India did not exist. Shah Mohamed writes in the account of the Anglo Sikh Wars 'Jung Hind - Punjab' (War between India and Punjab). The sepoys during the 1845-49 Anglos Sikh wars had carried out attrocities on the Punjab population so there was no sympathy for them in 1857.

Re: 1857 Mutiny and the Sikhs

S Singh · 14 Oct 2005

It was a mutiny and not a war or independence as painted by biased writers. The Rani of Jhansi wanted the right to adopt a successor, she was happy with the british until she was denied the right to adopt a successor. Maybe the Anglo Sikh wars should be referred to as the wars of independence as if the dogra hindus and the same seepoys who undertook the 1857 mutiny etc had remained loyal to their brothers then the back of the east india company would have been broken resulting in independence.