Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

kuri · 12 Oct 2005

What are the differences between amritdhari.. and then AKJ ones?

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

dsingh · 12 Oct 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. there is no differance between an amritdhari and an member of akhand kirtani jatha.akj is just a group of sikhs who gather together to sing kirtan and spread gursikhi,that is also what a true amritdhari sikh does,gathers with their friends and the saadh sangat ji and sings kirtan and preaches gursikhi,so there is no difference,so please dont make any.akhand kirtani jatha is just a jathebandi,there is many different jathebandi(groups),but all of theirs sole aim is to be united with waheguru ji,its time for panthic ekta,we have to get along,hating each other,and fighting is what they want,those who try to destroy the faith of the guru ji's,are sitting back laughing at us,because their thinking that they dont even have to work at dismembering the sikh faith,because sikhs are already doing it.we have to stick together,like i like to say"united we stand,divided we fall,bolay so nihal,sat sri akal," waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

JB · 13 Oct 2005

sorry but i dont agree with the above. there are differences in beliefs of AKJ and other jatha's. eg) women wearing keski, the raag mahalla, SGPC rehat maryada etc... im not an expert, but from what i've seen, the beliefs do differ. i aint saying who's right or who's wrong, jus saying there is a difference.

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

kuri · 13 Oct 2005

yeh thats what i thawt JB n like dont AKJ do mool manter onli up 2 "jaap" ?? so anyone kno the real answer to my question?

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

/ · 13 Oct 2005

RNT AKJS MORE...EXTREMIST NOT IN A BAD WAY...JUST MORE U NO..

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

kuri · 13 Oct 2005

i thawt they do what panj pyareh said do in guru gobind singh jis time? while now the 1s like at soho hav changed it 2 fit in with society.. e.g. make up is ok

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

Amrik Singh "boongawala" · 13 Oct 2005

Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa Vahiguru ji ki fateh Dear Kuri no offence but the best thing for you is a basic Sikh book, learn how the Gurus and the Guru's Sikhs defended dharam, not only Sikh Dharam but other Dharams, look at the history of your Gurus. Not saying im the best scholar around (far from it) but instead of asking questions of jathabandhees first learn about the main jatha of Sikhism which is Khalsa panth. Regarding your question. >>n like dont AKJ do mool manter onli up 2 "jaap" ??<< Akhand Keertani jatha do jaap of mool mantar up to Gurparsaad. >>What are the differences between amritdhari.. and then AKJ ones?<< The first thing is that AKJ is a name of a jatha of Singhs and Singhnees who get together and do kirtan and have different view-pionts in certian aspects of Sikhi. Your question doesn't really make sence you ask for the difference between an Amritdhari Sikh and a group of Amritdhari Sikhs who do kirtan together. What could be the difference between 2 differnet Amritdharis accept for naam-kamai and rehit? Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa Vahiguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

anotherSingh · 13 Oct 2005

So AKJ try to follow Gurbani more than the accepted level by the SRM..... Since when has that become a crime? I thought the idea was to follow our Guru as much as possible...

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

Singh · 13 Oct 2005

The AKJ are a ground of Gursikhs who do Keertan together, usually in Rainsabaes (all night Keertans). There are some Gursikhs who are regular attenders of these Samagams who have extremely high Kamai levels. Thus at these Rainsabaes, Amrit Sanchars are organised where the tradition of keeping Gursikhs with strong Rehat and a high spiritual level in the Panj Pyare. At these Amrit Sanchars, the Panj clearly state that you have taken Amrit from the Khalsa Panth, not any particular Jathebandi. At Amrit Sanchars organised by AKJ, a Rehat inkeeping with the times of Guru Sahib is given - make up, alteration/bleaching of hair, meat, etc is all strictly forbidden. Proper Panj Kakkars, including Keski, must be worn at all times, for both men and women. Naam Drirrh, or the implantation of Naam, is also given. In accordance with the handwritten Mool Mantars of many of the Guru Sahibs and Bhai Gurdas's Varan, at these Amrit Sanchars, the Mool Mantar finishes, as it should, at Gurparsad. These are the differences. An Amritdhari who took Amrit during an AKJ-organised Rainsabae, is a normal Khalsa. He/she is not an AKJ Khalsa.

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

Zorawar Singh · 13 Oct 2005

If you compare what AKJ follow with the SRM, and compare what other jathas follow in comparison to SRM. You will find AKJ is the nearest. Others have differences such as:- No Nishan Sahib, Moolmantar up to Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach, Kacchi Bani, Sant-pad lineages, bowing to sants, discrimination to women doing seva, different rehras, jyots, sampat paths, different rehits for bibian, kirpan amrit for bibian, sant put his jhoot in Langar or dheg, putting blood on shasters and nishaan sahibs, bhang, Moorti puja, paintings of Guru Nanak, Gutkas saying only those who follow nanaksar are Sikhs, Gurudooms, as in case in Namdharis, creation of Paddched birs so many more, but I think this makes the point. So why are you looking at AKJ, when they are following Rehat of Guru. What is above is serious, yet no one seems concerned about that.

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

JB · 13 Oct 2005

i think what "kuri" was asking is: "What are the differences between AKJ amritdhari and amritdhari's from different jatha's?" also, majority of ppl on here are AKJ, so there's obv gona be bias replys...

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

khalistani · 13 Oct 2005

see an answer like akj is a group of gursikhs who get together and do kirtan AND MOST MEMBERS, NOT ALL REMEBR THA, of akj and affiliated jathai do not read raag maala, and do not belive it is gurbanee, andbelive keski is the kakaar and not kesh as kesh is higher than all kakaars, and this maryada was first practiced by bhai randheer singh je, or to akj thi maryada was REVIVED bak into the panth by bhai sahib tha wud be nice answer when u start atacing other jathai on there maryada thas not kool y u dissin nanaksar on no nishan sahib DO U KNO THE REASONS like seriously, just dont post if u dontkno or ask if u sincerly want to learn y to make akj look good u gotta criticse other jathai dont forget nanksar has done parchaar which has benifited the panth a lot, an this world likes of baba nand singh je dont come and go everyday and LOL bt most of this post is directed to zorawar singh je u say akj doesnt belive in joth maryada? i remebr reading in this book about bhai sahib, maybe undhitee duniya, that bhai sahib kept utmost maryada of akhand paath, such as lighting joths, everythingthe maryada kept by akj by bhhai sahib was no different than wat sant gurbachan singh je did, cept the fact akj dont read raag maala at akhand paath bhog when did akj stop lighting of joth? i dunt kno wher u get ure facts abotu akj from, i think me and u and evryone on thsi forum shud go and get some books by bhai sahib and have a good read, like there sik books u really see wat bhai sahib was like, tru gurmukh and benti to everyone and answer such as akj r amriadhree wud have answerd bhenjee questions, singhs who do kirtan stop bniging in other jathai to make it look like akj is the best everyones the best they all follow SAME GURU same banee same simran now lets practice the banee, do some simran, and stop fighting over same issues well never unite if we keep on fighting, if u disagree with someone, fine let them go on there own path if they hurtin the panth then defend it but nansaksar and other jathai, akj included, are all gems of the panth so let sjus chill out bhula chuka maf

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Oct 2005

Years ago when it was time for one of my studnts to go to Uni....he asked me... why all the FUSS about HARVARD/YALE/MIT...OXFORD/CAMBRIDGE ?? wHATS SO SPECIAL ABOUT THEM THAT OTHERS DOENT HAVE... ALL UNIS ARE TO PROVIDE A degree...BUT THEN SOEM LIKE HARVARAD/oXFORD ETC HAVE AN AURA OF THEIR WON..BECAUSE THEY ARE more strict..MORE EFFORT IS NEEDED TO PASS THROUGH THEM ETC ETC..BUT THEY ARE STILL UNIS... Everybody that chhaks Khande Batte Dee Pahul is a KHALSA PUTTAR of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI and Mata sahib kaur Ji. Its just thta soem PUTTARS are so much "into" it that they want VOLUNTARIULY to do MORE...than the required BASIC... and there are soem who dont want to do even the BASIC !!!..some dont want to do anything at all...believing that the mere act of Amrit Chhak is a Permanent IRREVOCABLE VISA to enter SACH KHAND !!..Well all that is PERSONAL....the more or less you love GURU JI..the more or less you do what the PUNJ told us.... The ONLY thing that DIFFERENTIATES SIKHEE from harvard oxfrd etc in my EXAMPLE is that to get into harvard etc there are RESTRICTIONS..But to enter the SCHOOL of KHALSA..there are NO RESTRICTIONS...all are WELCOME....and the more you "studY" the BETTER your GRADES...soem of us who DONT want to put in the "extra effort"....take it out on thsoe who DO IT..and call them.. names like AKJ/"Brahmins"/this and that. The TRUTH is NOTHING stops US from Doing ALL that they do..and achieving the SAME STANDARDS... the AKJ/Taksaal/etc who observe STRICT PURATAN MARYADA...DO NOT place any RESTRICTIONS on the entrance of anybody...remember a BRAHMIN has to be BORN BRAHMIN... a Shudar no matter if he can read the Vedas Puranas backwards from memory can NEVER be a BRAHMIN....and a born Brahmin...if doesnt know a word of Sanskrit or cnat read asingle tuk from the vedas is STILL a BRAHMIN..IN GURMATT there is no such thing... a SHUDAR is just as able to become a Puran Khalsa..as can a brahmin/jatt whatever. I am not a AKJ/Taksali..( but i wish i was)..but i keep most of the puratan rehit and am geared up towards keeping it all ( at least before i die)...but that doesnt mean i am "better" or "worse" than the next singh..I am WHAT I AM..and the rest are what they are...but the Bottom line is we are all SINGHS of the SAME GURU JI. ( as of a few days ago i have stopped insisting that all MUST stick to the same rehit..in matter of MoolMantar up to Gurparsaad or Hosee bhi sach..long or short rehras..etc. I now leave it to the SINGH....if he is happy to recite longer banis let him..i will do my own thing.) That is the Maryada I follow is FOR ME..the one you follow is for you...BUT NO CONTRA MARYADAS. Bhul Chuk Maaf Jarnail Singh.

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

Zorawar Singh · 14 Oct 2005

Khalistani - how is my post attacking other groups. I just pointed out their differences, compared to AKJ ones. Stop being so paraniod. It is just worth comparing to see what is valid and what is not. You can concentrate always on keski, etc. But these are seen as positives not negatives. Insisiting on keski does not compare to not having Nishaan sahibs, or discriminating against women, or matta tekking. I was just putting things in perspective. So Khalistani keep your keski on! :)

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

Harjinder Singh · 14 Oct 2005

So true and well said by Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" Ji. In my humble opinion, Pathic Ekta requires this apporoach with such a tolerance towards each other where the one who follows more rehat is loved(/respected) more by other fellow sikhs. We must understand and respect that we all will not be at the same level at one time but We all must have one goal ie continous journey on Gurmat Path. Bhul Chuk Maaf Harjinder Singh

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

AKJ · 14 Oct 2005

Khalistani there is extreme paranoia on your part. People are discussing what AKJ is and it seems you can't take it. Shameless self-promotion is rife throughout Taksal in the form of concocted lineages and a claim of a "Puratan" Sampradha. But this is not complained about all the time. What Gyani and Zorawar Singh have said is correct - the facts are stated. Let people make up their mind for themselves on what AKJ is.

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

'akj' singh · 14 Oct 2005

>everyones the best they all follow SAME GURU same banee same simran now lets practice the banee, do some simran, and stop fighting over same issues< Very well said.... and yet the last post still seems to find a way to attack a jatha. >Shameless self-promotion is rife throughout Taksal in the form of concocted lineages and a claim of a "Puratan" Sampradha. But this is not complained about all the time.< Thas noo good! Dont hate appreciate (all panthic jathas)

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

khalistani · 14 Oct 2005

akj, and zorawar singh je in ure post u said look at some jathai tha o these and now u see the akj who practice the TRU maryada wat was the need of saying this OBVIOUSLY ure attacking nanaksar for not putting up a nishan sahib, which they do have a reason y and some of the facts u stated were incoccrect from wat ir ead, maybe i remeberin wrong, if so im sure singhs have read many books on bhai sahib and wil be willing to correct me but in one of there books they talked bout holdin akhand paath for this ghost, remeber int he haunted house, and they did it with maryada, such things as pure ishnaan before paath role, and lighting of joath as well if akj has stopped this,y , or of if i read wrong, please corrct me i hant attacked akj in anyway through my posts i just said let all jathai go there own way, if akj doesnt belive inr aag maala, fine ask em once there opinion, and stop arguging no point in the same deabte over and over i cud MAKE akj sound like a horrible jatha but y the hell wud i do tha when its a gem of our panth when its given shaheedi and o im doing benti im gettin sick of people saying well we aint doing any nindya, then in next sentence saying its TAKSAL tha does this, man taksals messed, and mocking taksal if u have such a rpoblem with taksal, take ure posters of sant je down if u have such a problem wih taksal, then u better remebr the fact who gave a massive amount of shaheedi and remebr sant je, sant kartaar singh je, sant gurbachan singh je, all who gave MASSIVE countributations to the panth NO ONE can bring down taksal, it has given to much to this panth over the time it started and has contuinied toprove itself even now in present times and see this topic is now going in another direction all i did was ask people to just answer the question, and ask zorawar to not attack other jathai on THERE VIEWS, but just say THIS IS AKJ WEREAMRIADHREES TOO BUT WE HAVE SOME DIFFERENT BELIEFS but y mmake HUGE LIST on some things other jathai do , and then say see only we akj have tru purtaan maryada theres no need in sayin tha resepct ALL jathai as gems of khalsa i mean both akj, taksal has done so much nanaksar has done SO MUCH rara sahib has done SO MUCH so many jathai like these have done som uch y do we need to start attackin them? and zorawar singh je benti please just go on ure path have u gotten complete elightment wher eu can challenge the avasthas of baba nand singh je? when u do let me kno even bhai randheer singh je held sant slike them in great resepct bhula chuka maf

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

gabroo · 15 Oct 2005

khalistani ji if babaji gurbachan singh ji and others rejuvenated panth, it was GURU SAHIB's kirpa through baani and baana, not the jatha. if bhai randhir singh ji brought back reality to the sikh masses, credit goes to GuRu not jatha. lets forget about the jatha names and taking offence at the labels because all these gursikhs followed the ONE. not a jatha. but we today are doing different. if someone cusses a jatha, let him, it's HIS head that gets paap. but if we respond upsettedly, we're succumbing to anger and attachment too. those who recognise the good in all are truly blessed. forgive mistakes.

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

MS Singh · 15 Oct 2005

The Akhand Kirtani Jatha I believe are Singh Sabhias who follow a more puritanical life style, in other words Sikhi in its pure form with out any of the external influences which have crept into Sikhi after Guru Gobind SIngh Jee left. Some of these influences I believe are the following: -Unnecessary rituals which have nothing to do with Sikhi. -Idolatory i.e. worshiping pictures of Gurus -Worshiping tombs and the rest is mentioned by Zorawar Singh At the same time, I believe the AKJ also tries not to get influenced by external influences from the west, which the rest of the Singh Sabhias have succumb to such as the lack of Shardha for Bana in favor of western attire such as Pants.

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

khalistani · 15 Oct 2005

ms singh je benti please take a look at bhai sahibs bana yes gabroo je it was due to kirpa of guru je but guru je choose THEM to do kirpa on, so that in itself gets them huge resepct theres no poin in NOT gtiving someone respect when they desrever it give respect to all jathai the point is NOT getting rid of jathai even if u get rid of the labels THE MARYADA WILL STIL BE THERE i think this is wat people stil dont realise fine if someone stopped calling themselves akj does that mean they will start belive in raag maala, or for taksali vice versa no the answer for panthic ektha is RESPECTING all jathai, as brothers with the same goal, and not fightign over issues, but understadin they have diff. point of view akj, taksal, nanaksar, rara sahib, nihangs are all apart of the panth RESPECT ALL OF THEM dont resepct on and forget the other if we respct all, we can unite and fight the anti panthic forces on our panth today but the only way we can truly unite, and not only through words, is if we try our bet to respect all jathai in the panth, and have love for all gursikhs bhula chuka mafr

Re: amritdhari and AKJ- differences?

Zorawar Singh · 16 Oct 2005

Khalistani - you have spent years saying Taksal is everything. No here has even disrepected Taksal, yet you have still got vexed! Stop being so touchy! All I said was if you want t compare differences between SRM and AKJ, then you will see AKJ has just increased the level to make is more strict. Yet other jathas are not even accepting the basics, such as equality for women or nishaan sahibs. Their maryadas have not increased rehit, created differences between it. It is about perpectives... If we chose we could go through each one in detail, and even you know you have not a leg to stand on. But what the point, we know what the same old songs we will get back, like do not question mahapurshs, etc...