Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

little bro · 11 Oct 2005

have sent seller the follwing mail... __________________ bhaji, why do you propose to profit from the sublime, pure, sweet, universal and heavenly spoken words of the supreme creator of the universe? you have a kara on your hand and you are blessed to hold such an INvaluable body of the Guru in your posession. please grow some love in your heart and have a consience. i beg you to remove this pavittar item and instead approach a trust-worthy sanstha to allow you to show this amazing saroop (body) to the servants of the LORD (the Sikhs, your brothers and family) I hope you see the error of the action you are about to commit and pray that you do not put on yourself such a wicked karam. Waheguru Waheguru Waheguru

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

the link... · 12 Oct 2005

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/18th-century-miniature-sikh-guru-granth-sahib_W0QQitemZ7356688912QQcategoryZ2198QQssPageNameZWD2VQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

a reply and response... · 12 Oct 2005

from Bulla Singh... WGKK WGKF thank you for your advice. i would stop auctioning it. (1) i too dont want to sell this antique off, but since i am facing financial position i have decided to so. you gift me the said amount and i would not sell this. because singhji, its easy to give sermon than doing the job. and wat would you call that person who has advised me to do so ( and he too is a sikh and from U.K) and to that person who is bidding on it here at ebay. daas' replies... Bhai Sahib Ji, the eternal creator (your maker) takes all of our lekha. I know you know this. If someone has given you bad advice, it is on their lekha AND yours! Financial difficulties may be solved, but how many more difficluties for you will then appear, because of such a 'mara' karam that you're about to commit. Daas will also send mail to the bidder, but you must take responsibilty for your own actions. The sewa YOU have been granted is massive. To look after such a rare saroop. Your sewa, I am SURE, Guru Sahib will acknowledge and the rewards of which can NEVER be matched by any worldly finance. Imagine ever hearing of a Sikh of yesteryears, selling off Guru Ji to solve his own monetry problems. You are only looking at TODAY's financial difficulties. You should care about the future of the REAL you. Your aatma. BE Guru's sewak. Not sell him off! You have immense kirpa because you have the OPPORTUNITY to do the seva of this rare saroop. It is not up to me to do the job its YOURS.

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

LionKing · 12 Oct 2005

Also, in you're next mail, tell him to give his account details so that Sangat can help the parvaar.

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

!! · 13 Oct 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh my dear brothers and sisters...i have one question and one question only. why are you condemning this man for selling this priceless piece of history? is it because it is the guru granth sahib, because it is baani or simply because you think it is morally wrong? if you feel so strongly because it is the guru granth sahib or that it is baani or even if it is morally wrong....why do you allow the sale of the holy scriptures in shops? whether it be in written format, audio or otherwise? surely they all hold the same levels of respect as one another??? and please do not say that the holy book is not sold...nobody makes anything for free, especially in a world where everyone is out to make money. if this sale is wrong then surely the sale of mp3 format or 72 cd format of the guru granth sahib is wrong too? why has nobody raised an issue of other sales? there is an audio format currently on sale on ebay for anybody who is interested in making such a purchase. if this person is in need then surely he should be allowed to raise capital in a legitimate way. in the eyes of waheguru would this method not be a better solution than theft or robbery? this man has a gift that is bestowed him...if he sold the guru granth sahib privately no one would even be the wiser. finally...this is not directed at the seller but how do you know that he or any other future seller is a gursikh? just because he wears a kara you have no guarantee that this person shows these scriptures any respect, in this case would it not be better that the holy book went to a home where it was well looked after and cared for? [%sig%]

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

little bro · 13 Oct 2005

dear "!!", where above can you see that the seller has been condemned? he hasn't. he was simply asked to be aware of what he is doing. and ASKED not to proceed. secondly, surely you know difference between the SAROOP of Guru Sahib and audio recordings. do we have a cd on the tabia at the gurdwara? your question is non-sensical. at the same time though, you ARE correct, that those profiting from the sale of baani in ANY form are not doing their lekha any benefit. but yet, a gutka, whilst due all respect imaginable, is NOT Guru in complete form. the saroop is. the cd on it's own cannot be read. it is of no comparison. the REASON it is assumed the kara bearer (seller) is not just some disrespectee, is because he still has a saroop which is not over 200 years old. plus, he has replied with Gurfateh (albeit the shorthand), nevertheless can be safely assumed he is a Sikh. if you feel there is no problem with this selling just say so, but otherwise don't attempt to justify it with the mistakes of other shop keepers!! how do two wrongs make a right?? your questions and statements are merely argumentative and do nothing but throw negativity into the air with your wild assertions. the seller has MANY options, such as approaching a sanstha who could possibly sponsor him to enable to show the saroop to sangata, or, take over the sewa from him. SELLING Guru Ji's saroop is a DEEP mistake, a disrespect. there are many options. yet the seller is not being disrespected in any way by the sangats requests. so dear "!!", keep you spanners to yourself. Please. THANK you

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

!! · 13 Oct 2005

dear little bro first of all let me say that as this is a DISCUSSION forum - it means that i am also allowed the same freedom of speech as you and discussion is a way of resolvong arguments. secondly you seem to have mistaken the guru granth sahib - its physical form - to be guru. this is not the case, as the baani within its pages - the shabad are the true form of the guru. if you talk about saroop then it means that you bow to its physical form not its baani. guru nanak dev said himself ' shabad guru surat dhan chela' which means the shabad is guru not the pages of the holy book. if we see the guru granth sahib as sitting on the tabia (as if it were a throne) and not the baani within then we are worshiping an idol - something strictly forbidden by all gurus. i never said the seller is a disrespectee, i was giving an example. as i stated clearly that i was not making a direct statement of the person advertising the sale. how do we know that the seller and his family has had the book for 200 years. yes perhaps you do as you have contacted him but it may have been in his family and not in HIS possession. please do not make assumptions and present your reasoning clearly. and by the way, if you have true respect for baani then you should show the same respect for a gutka because jap ji sahib is the whole of the guru granth sahib. and i hope i do not have to explain why this is to you. if you and others are really THAT concerned then why don't you all do sewa and exchange the miniture granth for the said amount and donate the item to national sikh heritage? that would be giving this little holy book the greatest respect it truely deserves and safeguarding its future for generations to come. perhaps you should give this some thought and keep your spanners to YOURSELF. [%sig%]

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

khalsa · 13 Oct 2005

dear little bro just how little are you? and by little do you mean: 1. in height 2. in minded (small brain) 3 in age - mentally or physically? please do enlighten us. :) [%sig%]

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

. · 13 Oct 2005

You are right that Shabad is The Guru and Baani is The Guru. Akaal Purkh as Gur Joat is also present inside The Paviter Saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee and The Nirankaaree(Physical Matter Less) Gur Joat is The True Guru - The Sat Guru and because of that Gur Joat being present inside Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee, Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is The Guru since 1708 until present and The Future Before 1708 The Gur Joat was inside The Paviter Human Body of Siri Guru Gobind Singh Jee and That Time also The True Guru was The Gur Joat. The place of residence for The Gur Joat was The Body Of Siri Guru Gobind Singh Jee but since 1708 the Residence of The Gur Joat is The Body of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee. As Akaal Purkh resides on The True Throne in Sach Khand but while being there Akaal Purkh is shining bright in all The Vast Creation. (Sarb Viaapak) Same as above The same is for The Gur Joat while residing in the Body of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee The Gur Joat same as Akaal Purkh is also shining bright in all the Vast Creation. (Sarb Viaapak). The Worship of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is not Idol Worship (althouth The True Worship of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is through The True Shabad and The True Baanee). Bowing down to Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is bowing down to Akaal Purkh. The Written Gur Baanee inside Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee is All The Complete Virtues of Akaal Purkh and Gur Joat.

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

Prab · 13 Oct 2005

If people actually bothered to read the rehatnama they would see that it is Guru's hukam not to sell Gurbani for profit

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

singh · 14 Oct 2005

I remember somehting very similar, perhaps the same happening last year. Someone tried to sell a historic saroop of Guru Ji and claimed financial difficulties were the reason. Are you still in the same financial difficulties?

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

little bro · 14 Oct 2005

As per the post of ".", tha baani IS the GURU. but that did not mean that if lived in Guru Arjan Dev Ji's time, i could take a pothi of Japji Sahib and consider it my Guru, and not care a fig for the current pargat Guru. Dhan Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji implanted His (Guru Nanak Dev Ji's/Akaal Purkhs) Light into Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The saroop IS deserved of respect along with the baani As combined THEY ARE GURU. Whereas this is a discussion group, it is still pointless to debate the very basics of the fundamentals of Sikhi! If you wish to use this board to roll a stone and then throw your arms in the air to what you've seen, then very well, but daas still feels it necessary to uphold respect for Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji's saroop. The forum is to share Gurmat and have CONSTRUCTIVE debates. Not question the very basics. To make baseless comments like "then why don't you care for gutkae?" or "if you're really THAT concerned.. buy it" is an indirect way of saying you couldn't care less about the saroop being sold. And you have wasted my time by tangenting off into this pointless babble talk. If you wish to question the status of Guru, twisting words to suit a seemingly logical arguement (albeit anti-Gurmatt), then carry on, and I don't really care to read your posts. If I were to know the contents of Guru Granth Sahib Ji off-heart, that would NOT make me Guru. The Light has is invested in THAT pavittar form in it's entirety and does NOT mean i don't consider a separate sheet of baani with disrespect. If you wish to spiral into tit for tat arguements rather than engage in posts where you might actually learn or teach something worthwhile, then carry on. I bid you Gurfathe. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fathe Dear "Khalsa", in response to your post, i am little on all three ways. Gurfathe.

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

LionKing · 14 Oct 2005

Big brother PLease don't be discouraged - keep up with the Good effeort of not allowing anyone to do beadbi of the Saroop. I too shall email the Singh Sahib, and i hope more people from the Snagat will do the same.. =)

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

LionKing · 14 Oct 2005

Okay I just noticed that you have to be a member of ebay to email, and I'm not a member of ebay, so bhaji could you either post bhaji's email on the forum, or email it to me so that I can send a letter to bhaji too. thanks a lot =)

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

singhstar · 14 Oct 2005

whats wrong with u people ???? If the guy wants to sell the SGGS let him. If hes in financial diffucluty theres nothing wrong in selling, also the person who purchases it will lookafter it and go to a better home. None of you understand that there is a huge market for sikh antiques, and its better that they come to light and are bought so they can be look aftered properly or housed in museums. Also those who are so concerned about the SGGS , inform your local sangat or Gurdwara and they will tell you where to goand not to waste thier time. The commitees of these Gurdwara are only interested in paying themselves high salries and spending money on marble floors or on something useless letalone buy a sacred rare copy of the SGGS. So if you are so concerned goto your local sikh temple and lets see what they say...they dont care about Guru Ji only about pocketing the sikh communities money in their own pockets...print this message and show it to them...get a whole group of you to makesure the Gurdwara to buy this rare Granth......but most people just talk the talk ................

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

LionKing · 15 Oct 2005

Sínghstar, some of us actually have love for our Guru Ji, and therefore don't treat our Guru like an object- "the SGGS"

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

singhstar · 15 Oct 2005

its just an abreviation - if u have so much love lets see u raise awarness to the sangats and lets see how much love sikhs have for thier Guru Ji ....

Re: 18thC miniature sikh guru granth sahib FOR SALE ON EBAY

S Singh · 15 Oct 2005

The famous book shop (Jiwan and Chathar) in Amritsar sells our Guru Ji openly. I read a while back that they were selling on the internet and willing to send via courier. The same firm also sold ang of Guru Ji as scrap due to so called printing errors.