Re: Akali Nihung Baba Nihal Singh Ji
Zorawar Singh · 11 Oct 2005
I think there is a detailed interview done by Waheguru network and Fort Panth Khalsa. It is on one of the websites. It answers all the questions posed above.
Re: Akali Nihung Baba Nihal Singh Ji
KHALSA SINGH · 11 Oct 2005
wahguru ji ka khalsa wahguru ji ki fateh,
can someone write the transcript of the interview,because my audio doesnt work.i cant hear anything.i know many people have asked for info about baba nihal singh ji,but no one really gives any info out on him.i know many sikhs in surrey know about baba ji's life so post ur info please.give us the info give us the info,thank u
wahguru ji ka khalsa wahguru ji ki fateh
Re: Akali Nihung Baba Nihal Singh Ji
Confused Khalsa · 12 Oct 2005
http://allaboutsikhs.com/history/his0522.htm
1964 11 Sikhs were gunned down at Paonta Sahib (Himachal Pradesh) by the Mahant's henchmen.
The sangat of Poanta Sahib had requested head of Tarna Dal (not Nihal Singh, but the one before him) to visit the Gurdwara. They complained that the residing masand was abusing the Gurdwara premises through drinking, raping women that came alone, and making prostitutes dance inside. After several such requests Babaji decided to visit Poanta Sahib accompanied by 13 GurSikhs. They left, from Gurdwara Haria Welan Hoshiarpur, riding horses and horse drawn carts. When they arrived near Gurdwara Poanta Sahib, two GurSikhs carried Babaji's message for the masand requesting initiation of a Akhand Path at the Gurdwara. The masand did not give a definitive answer, instead assured to respond before the next morning. Meanwhile the masand confided with the local police chief, one of his corrupt friends who endorsed and permitted his evil acts.
Babaji started the Akhand Path next morning which proceeded uninterrupted for 2 days. On the 2nd day, the masand came with the police. They arrested Babaji who was outside at that time and fired at the GurSikhs inside, who were conducting the Akhand Path. The GurSikhs had no guns. For they had not come with the intent to fight, but rather to hear the sangat's concerns. As a result they were brutally massacred. Eleven died and two survived. As each Pathi was shot while reciting the Guru Granth Sahib, another simply pushed his body and continued the uninterrupted recitation of Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Nihal Singh, 21 at the time, continued with his choar sewa (even when he had been shot 3 times) until the last GurSikh was shot. As the Akhand Path was interrupted, Nihal Singh finally fell. The only survivor was the youngest GurSikh, a 11 year old, who was found hiding behind a nagara (drums). Besides him all others were presumed dead. It wasn't until the bodies were being loaded up in a cart that a small child saw Nihal Singh breath and informed the local sikhs. The local sikhs who had gathered by now, screamed to get him some medical attention. Fortunately they succeeded in their efforts. He received medical attention and survived with Vaaheguru's grace. He was subsequently honored by many gurdwaras as "Jinda-Shaheed" Jathedar. The masand was finally removed. Akhand paths are held each year in the commemoration of this event.
Re: Akali Nihung Baba Nihal Singh Ji
KHALSA SINGH · 12 Oct 2005
we need the info sangat ji,please post
Re: Akali Nihung Baba Nihal Singh Ji
Niranjan Singh · 14 Oct 2005
Many Singhs in the 1990s were under the same impression as "singh" asked him in person about his alleged pro-GOI role. I think it is best if you guys approached Baba Nihal Singh in person asked him this face to face, rather than making such assumptions.
>>>>nihal singh capitulated and made public remarks in support of the indian government.
"singh" can you please provide the exact quote of those remarks ? I am not aware of those remarks, but do know that he did not agree with Baba Jarnail Singh using the Akal Takht Sahib basement as a residence and a battle ground. I beleive most of the Panth would agree that should have never been done. Staying in the rest of complex is fine, but living inside Akal Takht Sahib or Sri Darbar Sahib is unprecedented.
The Babbars lived in the residental parts of the complex, but never inside the historic Gurduaras. Even the Babbars agree to that, and thus decided it was better to take the battle outside, for the long term. That is why Babbars are still around doing battle with India. What is wrong with Baba Nihal Singh expressing a similar opinion ?
According to his own account, when he made the statement about Akal Takht Sahib, he had been tortured drugged, and kept literally in the dark for days in prison cells. He has no idea what had occured at Darbar Sahib. After being drugged, he was taken in a van to Amritsar Sahib and shown a glimpse of Akal Takht Sahib.
Imagine not knowing what had occured in the past few days, and not knowing what else is hapenning in Punjab, and being drugged and tortured, and shown a glimpse of Akal Takht Sahib. Simply saying that Baba Jarnail Singh should have taken the battle elsewhere does NOT mean he was supporting the government.
Baba Nihal Singh is Jathedar of Tarnal Dal which has historically been under the command of Buddha Dal. Baba Nihal Singh broke ranks with Santa's Budha Dal (which had never been done before) and declined to work with Santa. He openly ciriticized Santa for taking the pro-Indira stand.
Anyways, if critcizing Baba Jarnail Singh's decision to fortify Akal Takht Sahib, Baba Nihal Singh is a GOI toady, then I am afraid the Babbar Khalsa, and most in the Akhand Kirtani Jatha, and many other Sikh institutions are also GOI toadies since they too did not agree that fortifying the Takht Sahib was the best viable option during the Dharam Yudh Morcha.
Re: Akali Nihung Baba Nihal Singh Ji
he is a lion among men · 14 Oct 2005
I don't think I have met anyone like Baba Nihal Singh ji - he is a Singh the way Singhs were meant to be.
Yes, he did say something under duress but I can't believe it was due to personal torture alone. This is the man who willingly sat in the line of fire when he was barely a man and accepted death in those moments in Paonta Sahib.
I have thought on this question for way too long and my own conclusion, my own feeling is that the police threatened to do something to some one else and Baba Nihal Singh ji chose to accept the personal ignomy of being labelled traitor and weak than see that "something" happen.
To my knowledge, Baba ji has never tried to justify what he said with any excuses or even tried defending himself over what others said.
It has been many years since I have spoken or met with him - perhaps over a decade but I remember an amazing Gursikh - so much pyar for everyone.
Before throwing any dirt on him, I suggest people actually spend some time with him. And please, have the sense NOT to bring up the topic of what he said in 84 or why - who knows how many times those questions have been thrown in his face. Get to know the man, and make your own assessment.
I will consider myself blessed if I could be half the man he is.
Bhul chuk maaf karni
[%sig%]
Re: Akali Nihung Baba Nihal Singh Ji
Tarnveer Singh · 14 Oct 2005
VaahegurooJeeKaaKhaalsaaVaahegurooJeeKeeFateh!
Does it ever end? Why don't we (as a Panth) try reading once in a while instead of just propagating what we've "heard from xyz?" All those who believe in this myth of a grand Damdami Taksaal - Akhand Keertani Jathaa anymosity should really do some research before further spreading such half-truths.
Read the following interview with Bibi Amarjit Kaur Jee:
http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=17357&t=17357
Here is just a small part of it...
"Usually in the media and in the religious-political groups, you are presented as having been opposed to Sant jee. How much truth is there in this?
-There is no truth in this at all. I truly respected Sant Giani Jarnail Singh jee from my heart and will continue to do so. He used to have a lot of respect for me as well. I remember that when we used to meet in the Parkarma, he would say Fateh first and would say over and over, “Well Bibi jee, are you well? Is there any seva…if you need anything let me know. My head bows before you and because you are the wife of a Shaheed, I respect you from my heart.” end quote
Like many of you, I know many Taksaalee Singhs and many Jathaa people. I have never seen this kind of anti-Taksaal or Anti-AKJ sentiment from anyone who is a true student of the Taksaal (who actually studyed at Chowk Mehtaa), nor have I seen it from any of the Rehatvaan GurSikhs who kept sangat with members of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee's jathaa. It only seems to exist amongst the youth, and even then, mainly on the internet.
So.... I myself took Amrit from Panj who were "Taksaalee Singhs"... and I was blessed with NaamDriRh from Panj who were "Akhand Keertanee Singhs." Should I start hating myself and arguing with myself now?
VaahegurooJeeKaaKhaalsaaVaahegurooJeeKeeFateh!
Tarnveer Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Akali Nihung Baba Nihal Singh Ji
The Khalsa Fauj · 14 Oct 2005
Excommunicate both jathaybandis for going against Panthic maryada. Also excommunicate nihungs who take drugs.