Must we obey the Hukam of the Panj Pyare???
clarification · 07 Oct 2005
Jarnail Singh Arshi said... "For your INFO i am NOT "anti sant baba jarnail singh ji"..He is a GREAT Shaheed and Sant Sipahi...but your other pet babas told lies about his shahedeee and reduced it to their own level."(Post on Ranjit Singh's done it again) __________________________________________________________ OK, Sant ji did an ardass in front of the Akhal Takht and said if the GOI army/tanks entered the Durbar Sahib complex he would give shaheedi. It is well known he said this.. but if Guru Ji in the roop of the Panj Pyare commanded Sant ji to leave the Durbar Sahib complex, could he have said no...yes he may have thought.. but iv done an ardass but the Panj had commanded... thats it i've heard Radhoswamis says why did Guru Gobind Singh Ji leave the Quila in his Singhs clothes(disguise) he shoulld have laid down his life, but even Guru Ji had to accept the command of the Panj, Sant ji was no exception. The Panj that commanded Sant ji to leave would not have been like me but true Gursikhs... for they were there defending the sanctity of the Darbar Sahib. So Jarnail Singh are you saying that there is no chance the Panj told Sant ji to leave.. and if he did, then in your opinion he's wrong.. whose opinon counts more YOURS or the Panj Pyare. Jarnail Singh is there no possibility this could have happened, and if you still don't agree then was Guru Gobind Singh Ji wrong to take the roop of one of his Singhs? Some may say that we can't compare the Panj that asked Guru JI and Singhs of today.. & your right, what Karam somone must have had to be a Khalsa at the time of Guru Ji... but if that reasoning is taken then no one today would ever beable to recive the gift of Amrit because no-one would be considered worthy of the Panj Pyare. PS the 'Ranjit Singh does it again' has been closed so i hope admin allows this post to be posted because the statement maybe seen offensive.... ("but your other RET BABAS told lies about his shahedeee and reduced it to their own level")...yes everyone is entitled to have their opnions & this instance in no expection.... but if a statement is made... it should be clarified.