Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

don't marry a non amritdhari

don't marry a non amritdhari

no one · 07 Oct 2005

to all sangat only marry amritdhari and never ever marry a non amritdhari. i'm currently going through a divorce and my other half was not amritdhari, and they will not heed any advice even gurmatt related. someone who has not taken amrit can not be expected to give any sort of commitment. and they have no real relationship with guru as they have not given their head to him. so please sangat-ji don't make the mistakes i did. vahguroo

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

Stranger · 07 Oct 2005

Have you stopped and thought maybe you and your soon to become ex partner were not compatible rather then put it down to the point of amrit? Many Amritdhari men and women have messed up their marriages due to their own fault - and yet they are also ready to give their head to the Guru. I don't think you can make such a sweeping statement

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

il vostro padre · 07 Oct 2005

stranger maybe amrit was one form of compatabilty? guru sahib says taht a munmukh and gurmukh can never stay, let alone get marrried, together.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

no one · 07 Oct 2005

Er yes i have thought about it. They were moving away from Sikhi and will not even listen to advice from either Sikh or Guru now. For amritdharees to go through divorce i think is disgraceful. They have made a vow in front of Guru so for better or for worse, except his command. Unless either partner was committing hedious sins and would not change, on that note separation is the option. No such thing as divorce or am i the only one thinking this.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

??? · 07 Oct 2005

stranger very well said "no one" and his wife are not compatible that is the only reason. her being not an amritdhari is more important than the vow you have taken in front and in the presence of "GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI". don't make amrit an excuse. i think you are trying to hide behind amrit. you might be at more fault than your wife. she might be inocent. you are only making an excuse.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

il vostro padre · 07 Oct 2005

??? what r u a marrige consulant? how can u make such assumptions from a paragraph? i also like how u say "i think" alot, but i think ur an idiot and wrong.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

098 · 07 Oct 2005

I am a non amritdhari but does that mean I am a bad person ? I have not given my head to any guru but to god only and what does that have to do with divorce ? How would you feel if you ex-partner to be is giving out advice that never marry a amritdhari ??? **admin cut for writing nonsense****

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

reply to 098 · 07 Oct 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh 098 you are clearly not a sikh so do not comment on sikh matters that you do not understand. you comppletely give away you are not a sikh by the fact that you say ''any'' Guru, you mean GURU JI as for committment, I have known amritdharis to walk away from an ardas which promises the GURU that we will marry but they walk away from it. So about that I dont believe it. Everyone can be commited and everyone can lack commitment. But I can understand that the person beign divorced is going through a lot and so I can understand the comments made by him and then help and advice he is offering is due to genuine concern for sangat. 098 if you cannot type anything respectful then dont bother, you are only wasting admins time. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

RoopKaur · 07 Oct 2005

>I have not given my head to any guru but to god only and what does that have to do with divorce ?< It depends. I think this person is talking about a marriage in Sikhi, which would be an Anand Karaj. And he is totally right, an Anand Karaj is only that when it is between two amritdharee individuals, otherwise it is not an Anand Karaj. Your above statement clearly states that you are not a Sikh, so this issue of Anand Karaj would not apply to you.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

??? · 07 Oct 2005

il vostro padre u r talking about yourself without giving any reason u can not pass ur judgement

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

il vostro padre · 07 Oct 2005

yea it does, guru sahib sed a person who has no guru, even his name is bad. so technically according guru sahib "098" cud be used in the same sense as baywaakoof, or moorkh.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Oct 2005

ABSOLUTELY and 110% RIGHT. An Amrtidharee and Non- Amrtidharee cannot MIX...its like oil and water. For some "oil" and "water" may co-exist...( maybe for an entire life time)..that is the "Amrtidharee partner" does his/her thing and the other one his/her thing..and they roll along...BUT this is NOT really a SIKH/GURMAT way. The GURMATT WAY clearly specifies that the Amrtidharee partner MUST try and get hsi better half to Chhak Amrit..learn Punjabi/Gurmukhi/Gurbani..keep rehit..etc etc...and IF he/she FAILS in this he/she will have to answer to GURU JI for thsi FAILURE. An Amrtidharee is also Enjoined in our Rehat maryada to Teach his children Sikhee/gurmatt/gurbani/punjabi etc...and if the Mother/Fatehr is NON Amrtidharee..this one way thing wont work either..as the non-A will always discourage it....Why waste time yaar..bani wich kee piyah ..avenhee time khraab karee jandeo ...aao kuch peeo ate bhangrra paoo..etc etc I understand many things can be INCOMPATIBLE and cause a rift in a marriage..BUt this AMRIT REQUIREMENT is one of the FOUNDATIONS of a Gurmatt Couple...so if the very foundation is "shifting sand"...the walls will come tumbling down sooner or later.. Marriage is a ONE TIME THING....especially in GURMATT...tread carefully. Rather than go for an non-Amrtidharee and make a messs out of it...maybe better to stay single...this is not to say that a mess cant be made by another "amritdharee" as well...but that is FATE/KARMA....marrying a NON-Amrtidharee is seeing the khooh and jumping into it with eyes open !! Jarnail Singh

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

agyani · 08 Oct 2005

i agree with jarnail singh 111% ....i dont know where these youngsters are getting there "ideas" from ive read on other boards that its OKAY to marry non-amritdharees < HELLO guru sahibs haukam is that khalsa marrys khalsa.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

Kaur · 08 Oct 2005

how can you just say amritdharee and no amritdharee sikhs cannot mix? TOTTALY ILRELAVANT! i totally disagree because i am marrid to a no amritdharee sikh and we have been living together for 7 years nearly! my partner buts his haor and drinks but we have an understanding which

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

Jasvir Singh · 08 Oct 2005

Ideally according to the Panthic Sikh Rehat Maryada (although I know most people here follow thier own rules) both partners should be Amridhari. However it is wishful thinking to think that Amridharis have perfect marriages. In-fact it appears especially in the West that the rate of Amridhari marriages breaking up appear to be on the rise. Best to know the person properly before marriage, I guess the rest is in Waheguru's hands.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

Jasvir Singh · 08 Oct 2005

no one Thank you for your advice, i really appreciate it as i am getting married soon. Please can you let me know if the Bibi you got married to was not into sikhi at all when you got engaged etc. Was she someone who had all the knowledge of sikhi etc and was practising, hence clearly on the way to Amrit, rather than someone who was not neccassarily into sikhi. Also was she from India, if you don't mind me asking. Thanks

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

098 · 08 Oct 2005

I am not sure why admin and others here are upset with what I said, I guess the liberal and independetn thinking is not being promoted on this site. 1. Few people have said I am not a Sikh, well who are you to decide if I am Sikh or not. 2. someone also mentioned that "Khalsa Mary's Khalsa", On this point I would like to make it clear that having panj kakar does not make you Khalsa until your thinking and your actions don't became pure. 3. Some said you need a Guru, Well Guru Nanak Ji never had a guru and he very clearly stated that you don't need a guru (agent) to find truth and god. People on this site need to come out of their shells and explore the truth at their own. I hope the ADMIN is strong enough to publish my thoughts.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

no one · 09 Oct 2005

jasvir singh my partner was 'sort' of into sikhi - and was trying to get towards chaaking amrit. until they started doing things contray to what a person getting ready for amrit would do. now all they tell me is that we are on different wave lengths -but guru jis hukam is the same, dont matter how u think about it. veer ji - all i advise now is to make sure ur future partner is really firm in their rehit and simran. pls dont make the stupid blind decisions i did.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

crazy · 09 Oct 2005

even having the knowledge of sikhi is not enough.... they need to have faith.. and believe!

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

vSingh · 09 Oct 2005

098, Guru Nanak's Guru was akaal purakh and he was initiated in Sach Khand when he disappeared into the river for 3 days. As for Guru Nanak saying you don't need a Guru: what are you thinking? It says over and over and over "bin satgur kinai na paaiyo bin satgur kinaai naa paaiyaa" meaning "without Satguru, no one will find God and no one without Satguru has found God in the past" Mool Mantar tells us that Vahiguru is "Gur Parsaad" ie. achieved by the grace of the Guru ONLY. You need Guru Nanak to meet God. No other way.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

stranger · 10 Oct 2005

1. Anand Karaj is only taken by the those who are Amritdhari - the rest just sit in front the Great Guru and pretend to have a marriage!! 2. Amritdhari / Non-Amridhari marriages do not last!! 3. Anyone not following the 'bibek' way are not sikhs!! What planet do you guys reside on? Pretty pathetic points are they not???? To prove you all wrong: About point 1 - it does not state anywhere in the Akal Takhat Rehit that only Amritdhari Sikhs are allowed to do Anand Karaj About point 2 - I have many friends in that combination HAPPILY married with kids and their marriages are prefect. In fact I know quite a few whose marriages have fallen apart and they happen to both be Amridharis status couples. About point 3 - what can I say.................sad!!!!!!

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

agyani · 10 Oct 2005

098 just lol at u. It is clear YOU need a guru; and clearly someone to explain sikhi to you.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

098 · 10 Oct 2005

agyani, and VSingh Ji Thank you for your comments, I will research more into it.. maybe I am wrong as I am not perfect. Maybe I am not able to explain what I am trying to say. I do beleive Guru Granth Sahib Ji as Guru and Baba Nanak Ji as my Guru, but what I am trying to say is that I do not need to wander around to find truth, or go after human guru's eg: modrend ay "Baba's" and "Dera's" to find god. I beleive nature is god, and we have god everywhere around us and withing us that means we must not say that either Amritdhari's or non-Amrithdhari's are bad people. Baba Ji said that everything is created by god and by his order (hukam) then who are we to say who is good or who is bad......that's all I am saying, I don't like when people say non-amrithdhari's are bad..don't marry them. A True Sikh would never hurt a fellows feelings. NOTE: These day's we are celebrating Bhai Jinda's Saheedi day, he was a mona and a non amritdhari Sikh until he was arrested and put in jail...same goes with Bhai Harbhajan Singh Ji Halwara but these both MONA and NON AMRITDHARI sikhs have done what a Amritdhari Sikh was not able to do. NOTE2: Dear agyani Ji, you may lol at me as you mentioned but i have seen the true Siki. I know a young NON-AMRITDHARI sikh's having a hot melting iron rod put into his feet, I have seen a NON-AMRITDHARI sikh who was hung upside down until the blood came from his eyes by Punjab Police but non of them said a word about their jathebandi's secrets. My apologies if I have said anything wrong.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

..... · 10 Oct 2005

I think this messageboard is currently being targetted by some sharratee people who have an agenda to just write anything, no matter how sad, just to cause conflict on every thread. It seems that thread about UKPHA has hit some nerves.... Oh well I guess they will pretend to be independant thinkers now like all the different things they were on different forums before.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

stranger · 11 Oct 2005

Dear ..... What is wrong with being an 'independant thinker'? Your assumption is wrong my dear friend. There is alot of hatred on this forum towards: 1) Sikhs who not taken Amrit 2) Sikhs who have taken amrit non - Tapoban style 3) Sikhs who question anything and refuse to blindly follow the translations as done by tapoban.........! How much do you know about me or my faith? Only Waheguru can be the judge of that not you or anyone else. 098 was mistreated on this thread for stating what he was thinking. Hence the reason I stepped in and made a few points. Your last point '...Oh well I guess they will pretend to be independant thinkers now like all the different things they were on different forums before.' Abit hypocritical of you is it not - hiding behind ..... ??????????? [%sig%]

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

Ek Kaur · 11 Oct 2005

Prior to marriage I led a Gursikh way of life though I had not taken Amrit. I recited my Nitnem daily. I attended the Gurudwara daily at Amrit vela. I did Seva and Kirtan whenever I could. I never ate meat and I’d never touched alcohol. My goal was to take Amrit upon completing my education. When I was introduced to my partner, he told me that religion meant a lot to him and that although at the time he did drink alcohol he wanted to work his way to pursuing a Gursikh jeevan. After marriage I realised that actually he was quite content living the manmukh life that he always had. I had two choices. Break the bond I had made with him in front of my Guru or show him the beauty of Sikhi and bring him into a Gursikh way of life. I chose the latter and it was no bed of roses!!! But three years on we’re making a little headway. He’s given up alcohol and he’s starting to practice Nitnem. We are hoping that we will be ready to take Amrit together within a year. The thing that motivates us is that when we have them, we would like our children to pursue a Gursikh jeevan. My view is that marriage through Anand Karaj is unbreakable. You make a bond. You keep it. Marriage is a lifelong commitment and at the best of times is not easy, it’s hard work. The thing that always brings me back when things are tough is… “If he was my son, would I walk away from him because he wasn’t living life the way I wanted him to?” The answer is always… “No, I would educate him and work at it” I personally think that divorce is not an option for a married Gursikh. I say this because my Amrit dhari parents were married through Anand Karaj and are now divorced. My father married three times in a quest for the right partner. He’s never been happy. Makes a bit of a joke of Anand Karaj doesn’t it?! I agree whole heartedly that Amritdhari should only marry Amritdhari but at the end of the day we all receive what Waheguru had meant for us to receive I think we should accept it gracefully and work at it. This is just my opinion and it’s the way I have chosen to lead my life. I am merely sharing my experience and views, please do not take this to mean I wish to impose my values regarding marriage on to others. In other circumstances stated here it may not even be the Gursikh partner who instigates divorce proceedings.

Re: don't marry a non amritdhari

reply to 098 · 11 Oct 2005

I didn't realise 098 was a sikh, it was the way 098 wrote that made me think this person was a non sikh so sorry about that. Yes this board does have this attitude of I'm right so you can go away if in disagreement. Its all about luck I guess when it comes down to marriage but yes we should marry someone we believe is similar to us in religion.