Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

UKSingh · 06 Oct 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh ji Sangat ji, i know the ragmaalla debate has been 'debated many times' and i don't want to start another one. However, our veer Amarjeet Singh on another topic stated "some akj read raagmala?????????????????????????????? next you'll be saying some taksalis believe keski as the fifth kakaar" I have never classed/labelled myself as akj as i believe Panth comes above everything, and we should try to be khalsa Singh first rather than akj,taksali, Nihang etc etc. However i know many others will label/associatr me as "AKJ", as i go to the programmes in UK and intnational, Gursikhs in my family are associated with akj and I am married into a family that are well respected and been an intergral part of akj for many years and even though i have never classed myself as akj, I took amrit with Guru's kirpa from Panj pyarie who 'are seen as the panj pyarie' of the akj in UK. When i came into sikhi, i didn't know anything about different jathas, different views etc, as i came into sikhi from a total non sikh background and it was the pyar of Guru Maraj and other Gursikhs(from all backgrounds) that brought me into Sikhi rather than any jathabandis, so I just focus on what my panj pyarie told me and the panj pyarie never said anythign about ragmalla, and up to this point, any programmes we have had we have read ragmalla. so my point is, just because at this stage of my live, i can not reject rag malla, as i don't feel i have enough knowledge to make a decision' does that mean i can not be associated with the 'akj'? and also what does being akj actually mean? I don't want to start unnesccaery debate, and to be honest this is the 1st time personally i am raising this debate (anyone who knows me, will know Guru's di kirpa i try not to get into these discussions) but Veer AMrjeet Singh got me thinking!!!!! pls add comments (thats if the above makes any sense!!!!)

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

amarjeet singh · 06 Oct 2005

i know you dont i UK singh?

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

UKSingh · 06 Oct 2005

hahahaha Amarjeet Singh ji :)))))))))) you may know me :0 but that besides the point for the questions i asked, as your comments got me thinking :) it's good to think sometimes (but not too often!!!!1) and by the way there's more than one UKSingh who posts on here :)

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

vivek · 06 Oct 2005

uk singh you know me, who are you ?

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

we all got names · 06 Oct 2005

most people in sikhi now have all come into this room where we just fighting and then outside forces are coming in once in a while to keep the fire lit so we keep fighting and one day the whole house is gonna burn down its time to fight the real enemies of sikhi the five in us and the five in other people rss and all other groups we cant look at them as a group but as hate hate was once called mughals and then it changed its name to british and then hate became a woman and had a really bad hair cut and hate named itself indra gandhi what was up with the hair her hair looked evil so think how evil she was we got so many enemies this is still like back in the day when the mughals outnumbered us if we sit up in the forest and just keep fighting each other whats going to happen to the rest of the world uk singh good post brother

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Bundha · 07 Oct 2005

We All got names Ji, I sometimes despair about what the casual browser who happens to read this forum must think of us bickering and fighting and arguing. I am all for debate but when you get certain people hell bent on discrediting and denigrating others what must the outsiders think? You are right we should all come together and be one, in one big happy loving family. But how can we when there are issues that divide us so totally that we can never come together. I admire ‘members’ of AKJ totally they are all ChardiKala Gursikhs with a great love for Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Guru’s bani, I cannot be even like the dhoor of their feet. But when it comes to RaagMala and Keski as a Kakaar then I am at odds with them and we can never meet in the middle. Either you believe in Raag Mala or you don’t, either you believe Keski as Kakaar of you believe Kase as Kakaar, there is no half way it is either/or. ……………….and don’t get me started on the meat debate !!! So what is to be done? We NEED unity we need ekta so we can show a united front to those who eye us with envy or hatred. [%sig%]

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Stranger · 07 Oct 2005

If keski is the fifth K then there is no need for kesh - just wear the turban hmmmm kind of confused........help please

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Kulbir Singh · 07 Oct 2005

----------- If keski is the fifth K then there is no need for kesh - just wear the turban hmmmm kind of confused........help please ----------- You have forgotten that not cutting hair from any part of our body is one of the 4 bajjar Kurehits. The hukam of not cutting kesh is already included in the 4 bajjar kurehits; what is the point in including it in Kakaars? Now I ask you, what happens if an amritdhari Singh just wear 4 kakaars, has kesh but does not wear a turban? After all so many bibian don’t wear a turban and just cover their heads with a chunni. What would stop Singhs from doing so? What hukam will prevent them from not wearing a dastaar? If you do produce a hukam that specifically says that amritdharis should wear a turban, then what hukam would you find that says that we should exclude bibiyan from this hukam? I have written before and I do this benti again. We all should come to this agreement that whether we agree that dastar is a kakaar or not, we must agree that dastaar is a must for all amritdharis including males and females. Amrit should not be given to anyone who does not agree to wear dastaar at all times. Kulbir Singh

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

UKSingh · 07 Oct 2005

I know this topic could go down many paths, but could we try and answer the questions i aksed Basically What does being 'akj' or being associated with 'akj' actually mean and can you be associated with akj or be classed as AKJ if you read rag malla????

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Kulbir Singh · 07 Oct 2005

Akhand Kirtani Jatha as a whole does not believe in Raagmala being Baani and hence it does not read it. I personally consider a Singh to be tyaar bar tyaar if he keeps all other basic rehit but reads Raagmala. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

UKSingh · 07 Oct 2005

Kulbir Singh ji Thanks for your post As i said early when i took amrit, the Panj Pyarie never mentioned anything about Rag Malla. Obvioulsy to the Panj it is not a big issue either way then??

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

UKSingh · 07 Oct 2005

Gurfateh Kulbir Singh, so you still consider someone who reads Ragmalla a tyar bar tyar Singh as long as he keep basic Rehit!!! That's Chardi Kalal because there are Gursikhs out there who if they think you believe if Ragmalla will not even acknolwegde you, let alone speak to you. (This can also be said that their are also Gursikhs who if they think you don't believe in rag malla, will also think you are not a Sikh etc) AT end of day, we are all Singhs on a difficult path, and we need each others sangat regardless of difference of opinions on such issues Lets start looking at the good in all, especially our belowed fellow Gursikhs. At the end of day, there are not many of us :)))))))))))))))

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Kulbir Singh · 07 Oct 2005

UK Singh jee, Having said what I said in the previous post, I want to say this to dispel any misunderstanding that we don't believe in Raagmala as baani and don't read it at the end of Siri Akhand Paath Sahib. We also do parchaar that Raagmala is not a Baani of Guru Sahib. But if a Singh or Bibi is otherwise tyaar bar tyaar in rehit but happens to believe in Raagmala, we don't consider such Singh to be non-tyaar-bar-tyaar. That's all. And yes, the Raagmala issue should no prevent Singhs from different jathebandis to hug each other. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

gurcharan kaur · 07 Oct 2005

i'm akj - i go to all their rehnsbaees and do guroo guroo i'm taksali - i had santhiya from taksali singhs i'm nishkam sevak - i help out at soho road gurudwara i'm nanaksariya - i do bhog to langar and aarti i'm rare wale - i listen and sometimes sing dhaarna i'm nihang - i have dumalla and shastar what does that make me? - IT MAKES ME A KHALSA!!!!! NONE OF THIS JATHEBANDI STUFF - JUST KHALSA!!! [%sig%]

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

------- · 07 Oct 2005

you are a confused girl gurcharan kaur. you can't be everything. next thing you are going to tell us you are a hindu coz you go to mandir and you are a muslim coz you go to mosque. you cna't be everything.

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

UKSingh · 07 Oct 2005

Vah Vah Gurcharan kaur So wondeful Vah Vah :)))))))) your post has brought tears to my eyes :)))))

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Gurpreet Kaur · 07 Oct 2005

Yeah Gurcharan Kaur, best post Ive seen in a long time, well done! :)

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

AS · 07 Oct 2005

I think Gurcharan Kaur has set it straight and has spoken for the majority of GurSikhs all over the world. Thank You RAJ KAREGA KHALSA

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

.... · 07 Oct 2005

Gurcharan Kaur bhenji... that was wicked!!!!!!!!!! Wicked post!!

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

LionKing · 08 Oct 2005

Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 10-07-05 08:00 Akhand Kirtani Jatha as a whole does not believe in Raagmala being Baani and hence it does not read it. I personally consider a Singh to be tyaar bar tyaar if he keeps all other basic rehit but reads Raagmala. Daas, Kulbir Singh _________________________________ What is Akhand Kirtani Jatha's view on Partakh Darshan? I personally don't believe in it as that would not acknowlage Guru Sahib to Be "Pargat Gura Ki Deh...." So I'd like to find out What AKJ's stand is on this issue... Also What is AKJ's stand on Dasam Granth and Sarbloh Granth? What is AKJ's stand on RehRas Sahib Ji da Paath - is it from Har Jug Jug, or Dukh Daro, or So Dar. So to put it Short - Is Rehras Sahib like Akal Takhat (.e Sodar, 25 Pauri Chaupie, up to Mundavani Mahala 5, os is it like the Sant Samaj => Har Jug jug (alt Dukh Daru) with long Chaupie and up to "Tis Sahib ki tek..." What is AKJ's stand on these issues. Please educate me (Specifically to Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji ) thanks =)

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

amarjeet singh · 09 Oct 2005

akj's stance on rehras is that it is from so dar to salok mehla 5. (tera kita jato nahi)

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

???? · 09 Oct 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji Once a very lovely Uncle ji told me that we shouldn't say "Bhog Lao Ji" in ardas but to say "Parvan Karo Ji". How ever in hearts of hearts i have thought that, it is ones avastha that makes one believe whether to say "Bhog" or "Parvan". For example Baba Nand Singh ji one of the upmost loving Gursikhs, who truly found guru ji through naam and gurbani, use to have physical darshan of guru maharaj and do bhog as mentioned in 'Anand Chamtkars'. Then also at the Khalsa camp on hearing Bhai Surjit Singh ji using the same words " Bhog Lao Ji", in a way confirmed my inner beliefs, that perhaps it is ones avastha to believe in one or the other. However this is not a very big issue, with which i feel troubled. Also what i would like to know is that during one of the conversations with my father he said to me that the rehras sahib is meant to be done with the extended version of chaupi sahib. I then mentioned, that if that was compulsory then wouldn't all extended chaupai sahib's be the same as opposed to a different one in a nanaksar gutka or the takal one. He then said that it is not in guru granth sahib ji but it was later added on by Guru Gobind Singh ji. Now when my dad said that i believe he was refereing to it after having to read it from one of Baba Nand Singh ji's pustaks (Anand Chamtkars). I would like to hear opinions from tapoban singhs as well pls, like Kulbir Singh ji. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

simren · 09 Oct 2005

WELL DONE GURCHARAN KAUR!!!!.....great post from a bibi Well guys ...stop being ego.....be a humble sikh....dont bother about things that makes people sick all the time. Look into your jeevan and naam bani for the day rather than worring about maryada.

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

amarjeet singh · 09 Oct 2005

right, this thread has gon completly off topic

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

gursikh singh · 10 Oct 2005

chopai sahib should be full version - including kirpa kari hum par jag mata , and rehraas should be full with all dasam patshah's bani i don't know why they cut chopai short if you read triya charitar, from where chopai is, it includes 2 more Paoris. after these two paoris, guru gobind singh tells us benefit of chopai sahib, "sunai gung jo yaih su-rusnaa", followed by when chopai was written - "Sambat SatR Sehas Bhanijae"!!! how does sgpc justify shortening chopai sahib?

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

LionKing · 11 Oct 2005

Gursikh Singh - Are you saying your own view or the AKJ's Stance on this? BHai Kulbir Singh Sahib can you pelase respond to above questions?

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

gursikh singh · 11 Oct 2005

this is my view ... which is based upon having veechar on this matter with Singhs from Taksaal, Nanaksar, Hazoor Sahib Head Granthi and Nihang Singhs.

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Kulbir Singh · 11 Oct 2005

--------- What is Akhand Kirtani Jatha's view on Partakh Darshan? I personally don't believe in it as that would not acknowlage Guru Sahib to Be "Pargat Gura Ki Deh...." So I'd like to find out What AKJ's stand is on this issue... ------- I am not a spokesperson for AKJ but as far as I know, Partakh Darshan as interpreted by Nanaksar, is not something we believe in. Khalsa believes in Nirgun Bhagti and as such seeks Nirgun, Jyot-vigaasi darshan of Vaheguru. --------- Also What is AKJ's stand on Dasam Granth and Sarbloh Granth? -------- I am not aware of any official stand of AKJ on these granths. Different Singhs have different stands on these granths. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee did not write anything on this subject. He has quoted from Dasam Granth quite bit. All I know is that Jaap Sahib, Akal Ustat etc are from Dasam Granth and are Amrit Baanis of Guru Sahib. I have not done in-depth research on other baanis and as such cannot make a comment on them. --------- What is AKJ's stand on RehRas Sahib Ji da Paath - is it from Har Jug Jug, or Dukh Daro, or So Dar. So to put it Short - Is Rehras Sahib like Akal Takhat (.e Sodar, 25 Pauri Chaupie, up to Mundavani Mahala 5, os is it like the Sant Samaj => Har Jug jug (alt Dukh Daru) with long Chaupie and up to "Tis Sahib ki tek..." ---------- Some singhs start from "Har Jug Jug", some from "Dukh Daaroo". I don't understand the logic behind starting Siri Rehraas Sahib with the 24th Chhant of Asa kee Vaar and then with the first salok of 12th pauri of Siri Asa kee Vaar. But there can be no harm in doing extra baani. I at personal level start from “So Dar” and finish at Mundawani and its salok – Tera keeta jaato naahi. This is the maryada of Akal Takhat and this is what I follow. I personally believe Panth should do one Rehraas Sahib. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Kulbir Singh · 11 Oct 2005

As far as I know, AKJ does Chaupai up to the 25th pauri i.e. "KhaRagket main" Kulbir Singh

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

gursikh singh · 11 Oct 2005

why does akj not do full chopai sahib ? did bhai randhir singh just accept shortening of chopai sahib by sgpc ?

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

nandisher · 11 Oct 2005

_______________________ Kulbir Singh: Partakh Darshan as interpreted by Nanaksar, is not something we believe in. Khalsa believes in Nirgun Bhagti and as such seeks Nirgun, Jyot-vigaasi darshan of Vaheguru. _______________________ What, in your view, is Partakh Darshan that Nanaksar believes in? You have mentioned this before, and I thought it was something that Baba Nand Singh or Baba Isher Singh did not espouse. But before I misinterpret you, could you layout what you think it is that Nanaksar allegedly believes in?

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

nandisher · 11 Oct 2005

In reference to the above, what is Nirgun, Jyot-vigaasi darshan of Vaheguru?

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Kulbir Singh · 11 Oct 2005

-------- In reference to the above, what is Nirgun, Jyot-vigaasi darshan of Vaheguru? -------- Nirgun Jyot Vigaasi Darshan of Vaheguru are the darshan of his real form, that is beyond the 5 basic elements and this creation. This is the form of our aatma too. Kulbir Singh

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

Kulbir Singh · 11 Oct 2005

-------- What, in your view, is Partakh Darshan that Nanaksar believes in? You have mentioned this before, and I thought it was something that Baba Nand Singh or Baba Isher Singh did not espouse. But before I misinterpret you, could you layout what you think it is that Nanaksar allegedly believes in? -------- Partakh Darshan as far as I understand means the darshan of Guru Nanak Dev jee in flesh and blood i.e. in human body. Also, the Nanaksar maryada of getting actual bhog of Degh to the human form of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. Kulbir Singh

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

LionKing · 14 Oct 2005

Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 10-11-05 06:21 As far as I know, AKJ does Chaupai up to the 25th pauri i.e. "KhaRagket main" Kulbir Singh ____________________ Did Bhai Randhir Singh do this too, cause from the recording of Chaupie Sahib on Keertan.net BHai Jeevan Singhji doesn't Long Chaupie (beyond the 25th Pauri)

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

LionKing · 15 Oct 2005

Okay my last post was just a mess - Did Bhai Randhir Singh ji do Chaupie up to 25th Pauri, because the Recording of Bhai Jeevan Singh ji on keertan.net he does the LONG Chaupei, ie beyond 25th Pauri

Re: Comments made by Veer Amarjeet Singh

agyani · 15 Oct 2005

kulbir veer ji although guru nanak dev ji may of appeared to be made of the 5 elements with blood and flesh etc ...infact i think many gursikhs know that he was not made up of the 5 elements.