Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

NJ Singh · 24 Oct 2003

Anandpur Sahib 1699 Did Akali Nihang Guru Gobind Singh Jee cut the heads of 5 goats or of the 5 Pyare? He DID come out with a blood dripping talwar.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

anonymous · 24 Oct 2003

Any sikh with sharda in his Guru would believe that our Guru Jee can bring the dead back to life and would not just put on a show by butchering goats. This event was recorded by a muslim spy who wrote that the 5 heads were cut out in the open.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 24 Oct 2003

he cut the heads offf the singhs no doubt...........

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

warrior*princess · 24 Oct 2003

NJ Singh sounds like a person from that anti-sikh site called shastervidya. Just wasnt exactly a nice statement to make at all !!!!!!!!!!!

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

PANTHIC · 25 Oct 2003

WELL, UNDERSTANDING THAT THE NANG AND CREW WENT DOWN TO NJ, IM SURE THEY OR AA FEW HAVE BEEN BRAINWASHED IS THIS NJ SINGH SEEMS TO BE. DIRTY NANGS!

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 25 Oct 2003

I was wondering how did people even get the idea that Guru Sahib cut off goats. Has this been written anywhere? I'm not talking about any naamdhari or other anti-Sikh books but something which might have a 'little' standing in the Panth.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

NJ Singh · 25 Oct 2003

>>>>NJ Singh sounds like a person from that anti-sikh site called shastervidya. Just wasnt exactly a nice statement to make at all !!!!!!!!!!!<<<< Actually no i am not. Sorry. I just picked it up from that site, they make a good point because all of the Leading Generals of the Khalsaa Fauj are considered AKALI Nihang (i.e. General). Its a military title. The Rankings of the Khalsaa Fauj were as follows: 1. Akali Nihang Singh 2. Nihang Singh 3. Singh.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

NJ Singh · 25 Oct 2003

<<>> How does one become brainwashed when one intelligently used the Martial Title Akali Nihang infront of Guru Gobind Singh like it should be? Don't be closed minded people.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

hjhhj · 26 Oct 2003

which spy was this? i have not heard that one before.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

A View · 26 Oct 2003

Sat Sri Akal: Baba Maan Singh, in his katha, makes a valid point about this issue. He states that if Guru Gobind Singh Sahib killed 5 goats, would the goats not have been given the status of Khalsa? It is the goats that gave their heads to the Guru then, not the Panj Pyare.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

... · 26 Oct 2003

i don't think we should be so harsh on JUDGING OTHER PEOPLE -- this person just asked a question, he's looking for an answer, he is not looking for someone to yell at him... people should be able to ask questions about whatever they want to without getting YELLED AT! it doesn't matter waht they ask -- sikhs need a place to go and ask questions when they are confused about ANYTHING... if you guys keep on judging every single person who posts, no ones gona come here anymore, and they'll stick to sikhawareness or whatever other supposedly nihang websites. U PEOPLE DON'T REALIZE THAT WHEN U ACT harsh, rude, discriminatory, judgemental, etc.., you're scaring people away, and when you do that, you can lose many people that could have made awesome Sikhs. Some AMAAAZING Gurmukhs of today were ONCE lost and confused drunkards with haircuts... If everyone had continued to tell them "you're wrong, you're bad, you're a manmukh, you're a patit", do you think they would've even wanted to adopt Sikhi??? They walked on to this path because of the LOVE they received... Hurting people will only make them walk farther away from Sikhi. Think about it. That's why people run away to other sangats, where others will actually love and understand them. it's better that he at least ASKED -- rather than assuming that this really happend -- and telling other people it's true. people need to chill a bit - we should judge ourselves before judging others. the "nangs" may be wrong and stupid, but if we were all actually proper Sikhs, we wouldn't use fowl words to describe ANYONE, and we would look upon EVERYONE as equal.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Indy · 27 Oct 2003

..., well said.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

v · 27 Oct 2003

well what is the title of supreme comander of the khalsa fauj in the times of Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Gobind Singh Ji...........to my understanding he was our GURU he was a GURU not a rank

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

my thoughts... · 27 Oct 2003

What does it matter if it was goats or 5 people....personally i think it was 5 pyarre...remember we are talking about our Guru...Guru sahib wanted to make a point on that day....it is 100% possible that guru sahib took the heads of the 5 pyare and then reattached them...for sure this is what happened....but nonefheless....what is the point of this debate...none of us was there...why don't we worry about the most important gift that guru sahib gave to us on that day?....worry about whether YOU have given your head to guru sahib...it is well known that guru sahib asked for 5 heads that day...why would guru sahib ask for 5 heads and take the five pyare, but instead take the heads of goats?....these are just silly rumours...we should have more faith in our guru sahib...if we had more faith then these silly threads wouldn't appear on messageboards...please discuss topics that will help us progress on the path of gurmat.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

warrior*princess · 28 Oct 2003

the veer/bhain jee '...' author made a very good point, you are right :)

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

...... · 29 Oct 2003

Sikhs are not allowed to Judge what Guru jee did. We should keep a parda on it, because Guru jee kept a Parda. Guru deeya Guru he Jaanae. We should not discuss such points. Guru jee did all this Kaaraj, in a PARDA, hence we should respect it. No one can think of what GURU jee wanted and what he did.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Son of Guru Gobind Singh Ji · 29 Oct 2003

According to Abu-ul-Turani, there was no pardaa :)

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Cali_Singh · 30 Oct 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh It is a well known fact in Sikhi that: ~ Baba Gurdita Ji Brought a Cow back to life ~ Baba Atal Ji Brought his dead friend Back to life ~ Baba Deep Singh picked up his own severed head in one hand fought with his Khanda in the other ( I've read books where Jogi's have brought back people from the dead) These are all Mahan Gursikhs with Immense Kirpa of GurSahib on them. But, they are not Guru! Guru Granth Sahib documents very clearly that there is no difference between Guru and God! Then why do we have so much trouble believing that Guru can bring somebody back to life? Don't get caught up in all these false stories that try to discredit our great Dashmesh Pita Ji! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh [%sig%]

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

simran_sewa_sacrifice · 30 Oct 2003

WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!! Guru Sahib Ji asked for 5 heads and thats exactly what he took 5 heads of 5 HUMAN beings ################################################ Abu-ul-Trafi was a enemy spy and spyied on Guru Gobind Singh for a year and a half. And recorded the following in his diary/journal "On the day Guru Gobind Singh Ji prepared Amrit in Anandpur, the attendance in the Diwan was about 35 to 40 thousands. The Mughals had four thrones (seats of Imperial Power), Delhi, Agra, Lahore and Kalanur, but the grandeur of Guru Ji's throne was in a class by itself. The grandeur of this throne was out of this world. Guru Ji came to the Diwan and, unsheathing his sword, spoke in his thundering voice that he needed a head. No questions or hesitation at all, Bhai Dya Ram came forward to Guru Ji. Guru Ji right in front of all, cut off his head from the body in one stroke. Every body present was stunned. Then Guru Ji again thundered and demanded one more head. Right on Guru's call, Dharam Chand got up, came to Guru Ji, bowed his head and said here is my offering of my head. Guru Ji, again, in one stroke cut off Dharam Chand's head from his body. Now there was a big commotion in the Diwan. But Guru Ji in his thundering voice went on demanding heads, one after the other. Himmat Rai, Mohkam Chand and Sahib Ram got up and offered their heads. Guru Ji cut off the heads of these three also. Many from the congregation went to Guru Ji's mother, and narrated the whole happenings in the Diwan to Mata Ji. Guru Ji cleaned up the blood from the five bodies and heads, and even washed the floor, Then the Guru of these infidels, stitched one head with other body, one by one. This process took about three hours. Then he covered these dead bodies with white sheets. The Guru of the infidels then took a cauldron made of stone and put an iron wok without handles on top of it. Poured water into the wok and started preparing the "Amrit" (Aab-e-hyat - Elixir of life). The infidel Guru kept churning the water with his sword and kept on reciting his Kalma (Gurbani). This process went on for 1.5 to 2 hours. During this time, a lady from Guru's house came and put something in that water. Now the Amrit "Elixir" was ready. From the corpses, he took the covering sheets off. First he sat on the head side of Dya Ram, and poured AMRIT "Elixir" in his mouth, then poured some on his head and sprinkled some on his body, and then he asked the dead body to say "Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh." As if on his Guru's Command, Dya Ram got up and repeated in his bold voice,"Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh." It appeared that in the entire congregation every body was so stunned and as if stopped breathing. There was pin-drop silence. All those present were mesmerized with their Guru's miracle. In the same manner, one after the other, Guru made the other four alive too. Then, he took all five of them inside a tent. After a while Guru Ji along with the five came out. The Five were now wearing new attire. Those five risen from the dead were standing in a line. Then Guru came in front of them and took the "Bir Asan" (Posture of the brave - kneeling on one knee) and asked for the Amrit "Elixir." At this point, these five asked, what are you offering to get this Amrit "Elixir." Then Guru said that I would sacrifice my parents and my sons for your sake. Then these five gave Amrit "Elixir" to Guru Ji, and his name was changed to "Gobind Singh." The word "Singh" was attached with other five's too - Dya Singh, Dharam Singh, Himmat Singh, Mohkam Singh and Sahib Singh. Abu-el-Trafi writes that I was very remorseful and cried like a baby. After that, thousands took the AMRIT "Elixir". Even, I was attracted by a magnetic force and with utmost regret fell on Guru's feet. I requested Guru to give me Amrit (Aaab-e-hyat) too. Guru Ji already knew about my role as a spy and a traitor, put his hand on my back, gave me Amrit and changed my name to Ajmer Singh. Just with this act, my sins of numerous lives got washed away. I participated in many wars. On that day, I sent my last report to Emperor Aurang Zeb. In this report I wrote my eyewitness account in details. I also warned Aurang Zeb in the strongest possible words not to dare challenge the incarnation of God, and desist from cruel policies and that if he did not listen to and act on my advise, then God forbid, he would lose all - his throne and family. Gyani Dalip Singh "Komal" of Dhaunola informed that this book is lying in the archives of Aligarh University." (Extracted from the unpublished, "History of Ramgarhias") ################################################ WAHEGUROO JI KA KHALSA WAHEGUROO JI KI FATEH!! [%sig%]

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

princess of power · 01 Nov 2003

surely this gianni would have reproduced the book, or at least kept it..he never gave it back surely....

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Amrit's Power · 01 Nov 2003

Sat Sri Akal: har a(n)mrith ras paaeiaa muaa jeevaaeiaa fir baahurr maran n hoee || Obtaining the Ambrosial Essence of the Lord, the dead are restored to life, and do not die again. Guru Raam Daas Ji Raag Aasaa 447

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Bhavjot Singh Meelu · 08 Apr 2004

All this discission or any body have adoubt about what ever Satguru je did 1699. when the master him self kept it a in side the Tent and without his permission who we are to look behind that Tent.Goat or no Goat if any body know about the behavier of Goats they can not be silent for long and they have to be brought some body after that lot of people were present their no body in those time have siad any thing about how it happend all this is like throwing aour arrows tward dark ness I am either a beliver or not.Being a believr I beileve what ever Satguru Have done it is all Truth notheg elese.Ad Sach Jugad Sach ,Hai Bhi Sahc Nanak Hosi Bhi Sach.What people and ignorent people who know nothing about the Phailosophy of Satguru let them say we do not care. Humbly Bhavjot Singh Meelu

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Surrey Singh · 08 Apr 2004

VAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA, VAHEGURU JI KI FATEH I think the idea of goats comes up in 'Suraj Parkash' by Kavi Santok Singh...the thing is this...in the starting of Suraj Parkash Bhai Santok Singh warned that the contents of the work will be altered by people, and told the Sikhs to preserve it...but that's exactly what happened...some hindus ended up changing some of the contents of the Suraj Parkash...this is what i've heard, and read in books...I MAY BE WRONG THOUGH. [%sig%]

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

??? · 08 Apr 2004

Surrey Singh, Couple of questions, 1) Suraj Parkash Granth You stated "in the starting of Suraj Parkash Bhai Santok Singh warned that the contents of the work will be altered by people" and that "some hindus ended up changing some of the contents of the Suraj Parkash". Please could you (or anyone else) provide the actual lines in which Kavi Santokh Singh states this. Also, what do you feel was changed in this text? This is something of a regular occurence about many of our traditional texts that they have all been manipulated by Bhramins. 2) Heads in the eye-witness account Personally, I feel it was the head of the Punj Pyare that were cut , however as per this infamous eye-witness account, to my knowledge this has yet to be found? Where exactly is this account? If it's so reliable, why is it not available? Anyone?

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 08 Apr 2004

punj pyare !!!!! WHAT'S WRONG WITH PEOPLE ?!?!? ! next thing they will say that Guru Arjan Dev Jee stood on a block of ice and had fabric softener thrown on him... and Bhai Mani Singh jee was given a lethal injection... and the chhotay sahibzadas fell down a well after slipping on some oil... and baba deep singh... his head was never cut off... he just got bruised while picking up some wood for the fire... WHAT'S WRONG WITH PEOPLE !??!?! has Kala Afghana got to you ALL ??? stories after stories to make our Guru Sahibaan look like liars and cowards.. people who do sant-ke-ninda will suffer, no doubt !!!! If Guru Gobind Singh jee asked for FIVE HEADS, he took five heads !!! And he gave each of the Punj Pyare a new life as the Khalsa there is NO doubt !!!!! there is no room to even EXERCISE OR DISCUSS this doubt !!!

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Summeet_Kaur · 08 Apr 2004

Vaaheguroo.. I must concur with veerji's points..What happened in that 'tent' it's not for us to 'lift that tent' and speculate. I am always disgusted by peopel who narrate that Guroo Jee took the blood from a goat..Guroo jee did 'kara-maath' (hope I spelled it right) which are miracles..miracles done to prove a point, not for any particular gain. Guroo jee asked for 5 heads, he took those 5 heads and the miracle made them all Singhs..Khalsa.. Do not think of sikhi with a closed-mind..this is the path of light after all!

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

JS · 28 Apr 2004

It is strange that we have accepted what we have been told and not asked our peers to explain where they got there knowledge on sikhi from, and ask again where there teachers got there knowledge etc etc. We are sikhs so we should be learning about history, not just for face value but trying to understand a deeper meaning. Else we do not live up to the title. Guru never authorised miracles, in fact condemed them.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Khalsa Soulja · 28 Apr 2004

HMM looks like even Nangs (or Nangnees as appropriate) appear to be unimpressed with the Goat story. To me its a non issue, but I can say that the Abdul Tarani story is probably fake. Otherwise all accounts of Vaisakhi would have that story - its not something which would have been forgotten easily.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

immortal Light · 28 Apr 2004

What do you mean 'even nangs or nangnees as appropriate appear to be unimpressed with the goat story'? What is the need to call people nangs or nangness? How can the moderators allow this if it in NO way relates to this powerful discussion? The goat story is exactly that..a story..Guroo jee showed us kala-maath (miracles) to teach us lessons, those pyarey punj gave their heads to Guroo Jee..mind, body & soul!

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Dal · 03 Mar 2005

The Turni story is very ineresting! has any one tried to contact AMU to see if such a manuscript exists? http://www.amu.ac.in/staff/history.htm I've mailed a couple of profs. at the Uni no reply just yet, but if enouhg of us showed an interest may they will look in to it for us an veryfiy if such documention is real.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

S Singh · 03 Mar 2005

>>It is a well known fact in Sikhi that: ~ Baba Gurdita Ji Brought a Cow back to life ~ Baba Atal Ji Brought his dead friend Back to life ~ Baba Deep Singh picked up his own severed head in one hand fought with his Khanda in the other When Guru Hargobind heard of the miracle he admonished his son saying that "How can anyone interfere with the ways of God?". Baba Atal Rai gave up his life for the life that he had saved. Yes they can be bought to life but how you reconcile that with what Guru Hargobind Ji said to Baba Atal Rai ?

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Baldeep Singh · 03 Mar 2005

Vaheguroo Ji Ka Khalsaaah, Vaheguroo Ji Ka Fateeeeh! PLEASE READ ALL OF THE FOLLOWING: In the book "The Sikhs" (1947) by Archer from pages 192 - 194 that author writes : "The actual initiation of the order was dramatic, an occasion of exacting trial for his followers whom he assembled about his tent amidst the mela. In the presence of the company he called for attention, drew from its scabbard his martyred father's blade (???!!!!), and asked as he poised the blade aloft if there was a Sikh who would yield himself to death then and there in the guru's stead to insure success to the cause for which the guru stood? There was no immediate response but silence on the part of all, as if no one fully understood. The Guru added that Durga required sacrifice, actual blood sacrifice, if the Sikh cause were to be successful, and this time there was at least thoughtful silence. Gobind spoke a third time in sincere, appealing vehemence and five men, one by one, responded, offering themselves . It was a solemn moment and Gobind expressed deep satisfaction. Then he led them at intervals, one by one, into his tent, the place of sacrifice. Each time there could be heard by those without the fateful cry, “Ya Durga!” (?????) and the sound of the falling blade-no other sound or utterance. Thereafter, on each occasion, Gobind emerged with the sword-blade dripping blood. The bystanders were at first awe-struck, soon many trembled in anxiety and at the last some fled in mortal terror. But the solemn rite was slowly executed, and five loyal Sikhs, apparently, had gone to death as willing victims to Durga’s pleasure. Then it was Gobind spoke again with reassurance to the company, and turning toward the tent called the five men out again-who came at once to meet a still wandering but transformed audience. They had not been slain, those five. The blood was goat’s blood, an animal dear to Durga as an offering, and the five willing, would be victims were yet alive, to live as influential heroes wherever the Sikh cause led. They had become the immortal nucleus of the Khalsa! They were, by name, Daya Ram, a khatri of Lahore; Dharam Das, a Jat shudra of Delhi; Muhakam Chand, a shudra cloth-printer of Dwarka; Sahib Chand, a Brahmin of Bidar, and Himmat, a shudra kahar, or bearer, of Jagannath-three shudras, a khatri and a Brahman, now in a new casteless fellowship. What these five men had endured as a test of loyalty had a great effect on all were assembled at the mela, and was destined to become a cherished, influential memory of all Sikhs. But there was need of something more continually effective if the Sikh cause was to prosper permanently. The Khalsa must depend on something more than newly kindled enthusiasm-such might wane-and the cherished memory of heroic acts and a sacrificial episode. Not that the sacrifice, even with the blood of goats, should be repeated and become habitual. This was hardly in keeping with the true Sikh religion…” the author goes onto state”…Gobind took pure water in an iron vessel, stirred it with a two-edged dagger as he recited some verses of the Japji and some other verses of his own composition, while his wife Jita threw in some sweets (patase)” Now, is this author taking factual information and adding additional false accounts to the incident becoming re-written history. Can we truly believe these so called scholars and historians when they are actually distorting fact with fiction! Firstly, he praises Durga which is completely derogative doctrines of Sikhi as we only believe in Akal Purkh. Secondly the slaughter of goats and thirdly Mata Jitoji adding patase? I presumed it was Mata Sahib Kaurji! We need to ourselves ask do we have faith in historians, scholar or our Guru Sahib?!!!!

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Kabadi · 03 Mar 2005

Guru Ji took 5 heads of the panj pyarai... if there were goats, dont u think they would make noise when standing there, and when seeing the heads of other goats cut off... it was the 5 pyarai who gave their heads

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

blue · 03 Mar 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh I understand some people have a problem when these Qs are asked but they need to accept the fact that we are not questioning the Gurus but asking what happened on that day. Now, like has already been said, goats do make a noise and if they were in the tent and Guru Ji went and killed one goat do u not think there would be a lot of goats making funny sounds in fear? Also, some say it was a miracle and how can this be that the Gurus would interfere with God's plans. Well the Q is did Guru Ji interefere with God's plan or did Guru Ji simply carry out God's plan. If I am correct then it says in Dasam Granth Sahib Ji that God sent Guru Gobind Singh Ji to create Khalsa that would only pray to the one God. With Akal Purakh's hukam then, Guru Gobind Singh Ji would have cut off the heads and fixed them together again to different bodies. Now, as 'A view' has already said, Baba Maan Singh Ji do say that if the goats gave their heads then they would have been made the Panj Pyare, afterall what is the justice in asking for my head and then killing a goat and giving me the credit? Bhul chuk maaf ji Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh ji!

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Akali Fauj · 04 Mar 2005

Mahaparsaade Jindabad! Sukha Murdabad! Akali Nihung Jindabad!

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 05 Mar 2005

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Now, as 'A view' has already said, Baba Maan Singh Ji do say that if the goats gave their heads then they would have been made the Panj Pyare, afterall what is the justice in asking for my head and then killing a goat and giving me the credit? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< YES WHY indeed ??..too many "hitches" in this goat theory. Are we "fool enough" to cast aspersions on our GURU ?? WHO brought the goats ?? wouldnt that person "reveal" the Truth later ?? How did the goats get into the tent ?/how were they kept quiet..."sedated heavily" may be ?? and would Guru Ji "kill helpless sedated goats ?? Then who disposed off the dead goats ?? How did this "secret" reamin a secret with more than 80,000 people gathered there ??That GURU JI would be just a cheap magician playing tricks....killing "helpless goats" in secret and then pretending he killed men ??..and what would the GOAT say to Guru Ji??? exactly ??...just as Bhai gurdass Ji relates in one of his vaars..the goat says he eats bitter weeds..and gets his head cut off...so did these "five goats" ask why guru Ji was cutting their heads and giving the "credit" to men ?? How FOOLISH can we be if we beleive such trash. ONLY GURU JI and the PANJ KNOW fro sure what happened in the TENT. Let it remain so...IF it is that important for us to know..GURU JI will reveal it to us ( on a need to know basis !!) jarnail Singh

Think!!!!!!!!!

bhavjot · 04 Jun 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Today when I opened this link ,I was astonished to find the topic of discussion going on here..while more important issues like increasing Beadabi ,patitpuna of our youngsters ,habitual drinking among sikhs,impact of bad western culture have been left.i think this discussion forum must have been created to discuss these contemporary issues and not what happened in the past.. Yes , We Sikhs should be aware about the history and make other people aware also , but prolonging this discussion will not take u people too far.. On 13 april,1699 Guruji gave us a different identity ,a religious code to follow ,abolished casteism ..The way he did so is not at all questionable.. Guru is supreme.Who are we mortals to question his supreme authority? Ponder over this thing,people...and think how can we spread the message of peace,love and brotherhood in this world.As in our ardas also we say Tere bhane Sarbat da Bhala

Truth or Deception?

jugroop singh · 04 Jun 2005

(abt 1/4 way down the transcript) Nijhak Singh – ...Look in the history and you will see that, at the time of initiating the Panj Piarey, Guru Gobind Singh ji slaughtered five goats by practising jhuttka. Gurprasad Singh – The truth is that Guru Gobind Singh ji did no such thing. Those historians who have recorded that serve to an agenda of their own, which is contrary to the Guru’s. The Guru had no need whatsoever to perform jhuttka on goats. Guru Gobind Singh ji, ruler of the universe, was not a person who did one thing and showed another. Whatever he said, he did. In a full congregation he said ‘I need one head. Come, one beloved of God give me your head.’ To say that He asked for someone’s head and then used a goat instead, is quite a ridiculous suggestion. This would really be an act of deception. Any historian who casts that image of Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji, is completely incompetent. Believing in such a deception is left to Sikhs who live in their own strange little world. Nijhak Singh – Well what are your thoughts, if Guru Gobind Singh ji didn’t kill the goats, what else did he do? Gurprasad Singh – It’s not just a thought but, a solid belief of mine that instead of taking the heads of goats, he took the heads of the Panj Piarey and after taking them, He resuscitated all five of them as a way of showing his wondrous miracles. Nijhak Singh – This miracle was then shown as wrath, why did the Guru need to show it then? Gurprasad Singh – Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji did not show the miracle, he kept it hidden. Not everyone was made aware of the fact that the heads of the Panj Piarey were removed, and that the five were then resuscitated.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

hunter_jatt · 04 Jun 2005

"the nangs may be wrong and stupid" - now what was the point of writing this very defaming and negative statement. It kind of contradicted everything you said prior to that.

Re: The Goats or the 5 Pyare?

sahibzaadiyan dee prerna · 25 Jun 2005

The letter/diary written by this Muslim Spy is still preserved in one of the Uni. in India. I'll come back to you with details