Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

'Nihangs' with huge dumalla's?

'Nihangs' with huge dumalla's?

Your Humble Servant · 03 Oct 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! Why is it that people that call themselves "Nihangs" wear absolutely huge dumalla's? Whats the point? Isnt Sikhi supposed to be based on being practical? I've seen "Nihangs" walking around like they've got stiff necks. Whats practical about that? I've noticed in the UK, that a lot of young Sikhs are calling themselves "Nihangs" and wearing the huge dumalla's with several shaastars inside. Whats the practicallity and reasoning behind it? I understand in puraatan times, Gursikhs had to be ready for battle, but now things are different. Personally I feel that a lot of it is done just for show. The bigger the better! Maybe, but when you cant even do Matha Taek properly because your dumalla is about to tip forward, I think it maybe TOO big! (I've seen it!) Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: 'Nihangs' with huge dumalla's?

A Singh · 04 Oct 2005

Large Dumalas are usually an item for “display” during congregations, such as Nihang Major Singh in India. That said, the whole concept of a Dumala is not actually as puratan within Sikhi as is made out by Nihangs, AKJ, BKI and Tapoban. It is a latter development – Bhai Amritpal Singh is in the process of launching the next stage of his research on Nihangs which will cover the “Bana” of the Nihangs amongst other items – see http://amritworld.com/nihangs/ [www.amritworld.com – click on ‘what’s new’ and look for ‘nihang’ section if this link doesn’t work]. The Shasters in the Dumala, I’ve been told are for 2 purposes – (1) for ease of access during hand to hand combat / ground fighting (2) for 24-7 Shaster Namaskaran as part of the Nihang Singh’s Shaster or “chandi” puja, including the concept of Sarabloh Bibek depending on who you speak to… I would personally recommend that we keep a close eye on the referenced site, as Amritpal Singh, although himself independent, has on various occasions been accused of siding with the UK Nihangs / Sanatan Sikhs, other times with the AKJ against the UK Nihangs and yet at other times with the Taksal against the RadhaSoamis. In the end, one can judge his views by his works and this topic would appear to be crucial in the present day world of Nihang-enthusiasts (be they Nihangs or not). Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: 'Nihangs' with huge dumalla's?

Jpeg · 04 Oct 2005

It's a recent innovation. The dumalas they would have were impractical even in puratan times. It's just a case of my dumala's bigger than your dumala!

Re: 'Nihangs' with huge dumalla's?

Confused Khalsa · 04 Oct 2005

i wear a big one because it makes me feel good. i dont really think about the practicallity side of it, but when i tie it i feel like guru ji would be happy - only reason. dhan guru my interpretation of what guru ji wants is probably wrong, but this is just how i feel at the time. ho gosaaee dhaa pehilavaanarraa || I am a wrestler; I belong to the Lord of the World. mai gur mil ouch dhumaalarraa || I met with the Guru, and I have tied a tall, plumed turban. This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Siree Raag on Pannaa 73 http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=2782

Re: 'Nihangs' with huge dumalla's?

curious singh · 05 Oct 2005

Your Humble Servant, concentrate on your Sikhi. Let the 'Nihangs' with huge dumalla's concentrate on theirs. Vaheguru.

Re: 'Nihangs' with huge dumalla's?

A Singh · 05 Oct 2005

<> Thanks for quoting this shabd, it is one I am familiar with and see quite often quoted by pro-nihang bana groups to justify their view that this is an indication that Guru Sahib wished for us to dress in this manner. In actual fact the translation misconstrues the meaning of “dhumaalaraa” into “tall, plumed turban” when in actual fact it refers to something quote different. Keep an eye on the aforementioned site, I’m pretty sure given the headings provided under http://amritworld.com/nihangs/ show that this must have been one Shabd analysed amongst many for the assessment of Nihangs from Sikh text and from Guru Sahib. Gur Fateh! A Singh