Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

how did tapoban start?

how did tapoban start?

singh · 03 Oct 2005

how and when did gurdwara tapoban starT?

Re: how did tapoban start?

.1.1.1 · 03 Oct 2005

i wanna know too!

Re: how did tapoban start?

Kulbir Singh · 03 Oct 2005

The following is based on my personal and limited intelligence. Gurdwara Sahib started about 3.5 years ago. Gusikhs in Toronto wanted get such asthaan from where they could run as much Gurmat as possible. For this reason, an ardaas was performed before Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee to enable Gursikhs to run Gurmat at a Gurdwara Sahib. The main aim was to personally follow Gurmat as much as possible and to do parchaar of Gurmat. Guru Sahib blessed his Gursikhs with this opportunity in the form of Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib. Singhs were feeling that many rehits are vanishing in Panth e.g. Sarbloh Bibek, Dastaara, Baana, etc. For this reason, this effort of establishing Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib was undertaken. Following are some of the Gurmat principles that Gursikhs have established at the Gurdwara Sahib: 1) Parkash of only Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee (Laridaar Saroop only) and to do parchaar of Laridaar Saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. 2) Accept no maya (money) for any sewa like Siri Akhand Paath Sahib, Kirtan program, etc. No other program to be done when Siri Akhand Paath Sahib is on. There are never more than one Siri Akhand Paaths at a given time. Sewa in Siri Akhand Paaths and langar is done by Tyaar Bar Tyaar Gursikhs only. 3) Run a Gurmat School where many children and youth learn Punjabi, Gurmukhi, Nitnem Paath, Siri Sukhmani Sahib, Siri Asa kee Vaar and finally paath from laridaar pothis of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. 4) Teach Gurmat Viyakaran (Grammar) which is a rare vidiya in Panth even today, to adults and mature youths. 5) Do parchaar of Dastar for both males and females. Promote baana by having baana as uniform for all students attending school at Gurdwara Sahib. 6) Establish Tatt Gurmat Maryada for langar, which includes Sarblohi langar cooked and served by Gursikhs. While doing this sewa at Gurdwara Sahib, omissions of Gurmat Maryada may occur. Sangat is bakshanhaar. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: how did tapoban start?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Oct 2005

Dhan Guru Ji Dhan Guru De Sikh. 1. Allowing only ONE..whether it be Kirtan/Katha/Akhand Paath at any one time is the Pure RESPECT and ADAB of GURBANI. To allow more than one is simply a case of "GREED"..and to allow as many as 500 Akhand paaths at one time..is beyond even Super Greed....i have no words for that. 2. Paraksh of Lareedar Sroop is Respecting the TRUE THRONE of Sacha Patshah Guru Granth ji Maharaj. Pad-chhedd sroop is "man-made" as declared on tis cover...IS beerh dee pad-chhed seva Gyani mewa singh sato galli ne ketee hai ji.." etc etc. Any one "reading paath" from THAT particular sroop WILL MAKE the SAME MISTAKES Gyani mewa Singh ji did.." 3. Parchaar of Dastaar is PARAMOUNT. NO Gurdwara in the world does that. 4. Parchaar of GURBANI VIAKARAAN is also Most Importtant for correct AArths...as more and more people come to know these arrths..the wrong interpreattion of gurbani will die off. 5. Sarb Loh Langgar and Bibek rehit....also a very good and commendable move. Dhan Dhan Guru Ji....KIRPA Rakhnee...din duggnnee ate raat chaugnnee trakee hoveh ji.

Re: how did tapoban start?

. · 03 Oct 2005

what does trakee mean? everyone uses it but i never know what it means [%sig%]

Re: how did tapoban start?

Harjinder Singh · 04 Oct 2005

In my humble opinion, based on my knowledge, Tapoban was result of the burning desire and efforts of Gursikhs who were committed to practice the Gurmat in their lives and were also committed to set an example by establishing an Institute cum Gurdwara Sahib where there will not be any compromises on GURMAT. I can vouch for this based on my experience during my limited visits to this unique place of inspiration in Toronto area. The most appealing thing I have found in all the founding Singhs of Tapoban Sahib is that they are always one hundred percent open minded to discuss any issue based on Gurmat to improve. All Singhs are down to earth humble and have immense love among them and they shower the same love on everyone who comes to this place. I have not found anyone being treated special and better. They take all decisions with Unanimous Gurmata from all the Sangat based on Gurmat. Only Guru Sahib is perfect and everyone else can make mistakes but at this place, I have seen perfect devotion and commitment to practice as much Gurmat as possible based on what they have learnt and what they are continuously learning with the blessing of Guru Sahib. 1) Parkash of only Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee (Laridaar Saroop only) and to do parchaar of Laridaar Saroop of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. This is the one of most urgent need of the hour and Guru Khalsa Panth is sleeping on this matter. I commend Tapoban Singh for their initiative and efforts to make our true Guru known and installed on the throne everywhere in the world. 2) Accept no maya (money) for any sewa like Siri Akhand Paath Sahib, Kirtan program, etc. No other program to be done when Siri Akhand Paath Sahib is on. There are never more than one Siri Akhand Paaths at a given time. Sewa in Siri Akhand Paaths and langar is done by Tyaar Bar Tyaar Gursikhs only. This asool is also very strictly followed so as to take maximum laha of Gurbani while keeping the maximum respect for the Guru Sahib. This also stops the anti-gurmat interference in pressure of money being donated. I wish the on going business of Gurbani Stops and we can see the same love and devotion at every Gurdwara Sahib by taking the inspiration from Tapoban Sahib one day. 3) Run a Gurmat School where many children and youth learn Punjabi, Gurmukhi, Nitnem Paath, Siri Sukhmani Sahib, Siri Asa kee Vaar and finally paath from laridaar pothis of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. This school is a big success and produced many outstanding products such as Balpreet Singh, Roop Kaur, Ranjit Singh, Sarabloh Kaur, Ujagar Kaur, Dalraj Kaur, Amitoj Singh, many more and almost 250 small kids in complete Gurmukhi bana are a big hope for the bright future of Sikhi. 4) Teach Gurmat Viyakaran (Grammar) which is a rare vidiya in Panth even today, to adults and mature youths. There is no doubt that this class is the best class offered by Tapoban Sahib and there are no words to express the appreciation for the efforts of the Singhs who work very hard to make it a success. Those are very lucky who live in Toronto area to take this advantage. 5) Do parchaar of Dastar for both males and females. Promote baana by having baana as uniform for all students attending school at Gurdwara Sahib. Parchaar of Dastaar is another most important need of the hour. It is unfortunate that Guru Khalsa Panth is sleeping on this matter as well. How can we dream about giving equal opportunities to our mothers/sisters/daughters in kind of Seva if they are not even given this privilege? A singhnee can never feel herself equal to a singh without a Dastar because she is not “Khalsa Mero Roop Hai Khas” without Dastar. I hope, other Sikh institutions take inspiration from Tapoban Sahib and encourage all our mothers/sisters/daughters to must wear Dastar just like the singhs do so that they have everything that they deserve not less than any other Sikh of Guru Sahib for the chardikala of Guru Khalsa Panth. 6) Establish Tatt Gurmat Maryada for langar, which includes Sarblohi langar cooked and served by Gursikhs. Guru Ka Langar is prepared/served with best possible respect while reciting Gurbani and Naam Simran in Sarabloh by Tiar bar Tiar Gursikhs. I must highly appreciate these Gursikhs to successfully continue this marayada in spite of the fact that there are not many tiar bar sevadars to handle different seva separately and these Gursikhs do immense seva themselves to make everything run and never even think about any compromise on GURMAT No one is perfect but the one who always strive for the perfection in Gurmat is a true Sikh of Guru Sahib. All I can say in the end is that Tapoban Sahib is truly a place where you will find the type of Gursikhs whose association is sought by every Sikh in his/her ardas at three times a day. This is true based on what I have experienced during my visits to Tapoban sahib. I pray that this phulwari of Sikhi grow day and night. [%sig%]

Re: how did tapoban start?

?? · 04 Oct 2005

Is kirtan sung according to gurmat sangeet i.e. Raags, Puraatan Instuments, no Simran in between? Vaaheguroooo!!!

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 04 Oct 2005

my personal view is runnig a gurdwara which follows bhai randhir singhs teachings is good this is my own 'mat' i emphasise i have spoken to a singh who knew bhai sahib well, in fact the singh is related to me directly he told me bhai sahib never wanted separate gurdwara to be set up by akhand kirtani jatha, as it will not do good for the panth as a whole it will also appear as a 'dhera' although you call youreself tapoban, you are a branch of akj.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Straight Arrow · 04 Oct 2005

Author: . Date: 10-03-05 21:08 what does trakee mean? everyone uses it but i never know what it means It means PROGRESS. Thank you.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Singh · 04 Oct 2005

vivek - do you ever have anything sensible to say? The Gurdwara does not follow Bhai Randhir Singh, it folows Gurbani. The Singhs bow to Gurbani, they do parchaar and teach Gurbani, and even Bhai Sahibs books are solely based on Gurbani. The common denominator is GURBANI.. But I think you knew that, but wrote your mail anyway...

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 04 Oct 2005

Singh Date: 10-04-05 13:11 vivek - do you ever have anything sensible to say? The Gurdwara does not follow Bhai Randhir Singh, it folows Gurbani. The Singhs bow to Gurbani, they do parchaar and teach Gurbani, and even Bhai Sahibs books are solely based on Gurbani. The common denominator is GURBANI.. But I think you knew that, but wrote your mail anyway well why is it i have heard several stories of bhai sahib, used as evidence by tapoban singhs to support parts of their rehit? sorry singh, obviously i donnot make sense to you, maybe thats just cause you havnt the iq to understand my reasoning

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 04 Oct 2005

singh why u attackin me? if u read my post u see i sed, i think its good but i sed a relative who new bhai sahib, sed what taapoban have done is not what bhai sahib agrreed with

Re: how did tapoban start?

Dalrajkaur · 04 Oct 2005

vivek ji, Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib is ran by Singhs that follow guru ji's rehit and hukum as best as they can. How is producting a gurdwara that actually follows guru ji's rehit as best as it can bad for the panth? This just indicates that the panth has a dhil in it. We do not call ourselves "tapoban". It is people like you that label us as "tapoban". Dalrajkaur

Re: how did tapoban start?

..... · 04 Oct 2005

Tapoban Sahib sounds remarkable...every Gurdwara should aim to be like Tapoban Sahib but as stated earlier until Keertan is not sung in pure Raag using the shasters blessed by our own Guru Sahibs... Tapoban Sahib is not completely adhering to Tat-Gurmat i was speaking to some AKJ & Taksali youth, both said they found Keertan sung out of Raag more appealing, & for a minute i thought maybe singing out of Raag under this circumstance its ok because "youth jurdhi-aa" but then i was reminded how Bhai Taru Singh preferred to have his kohpri removed rather than give up any Hukam given by Guru Sahib ie not to cut Kes. So when it comes to Keertan are we following Hukam? yeh,thats my suggestion, i say when you've gone so far in keeping Tat-Gurmat why not go all out to its fullest. "Kalyug Meh Kirtan Pardhanaa" anyway who am i to say anything i aint got no naam in me & i im a paapi

Re: how did tapoban start?

yo yo · 04 Oct 2005

WJKK WJKF I really don't understand Tapoban, is it a jathaa like Taksal or AKJ? because from my understanding tapoban only exists in Toronto, and most jathaas originate from india, so could you guys jus claify if you guys are a jathaa, and if you guys are do you hav a mukhi? WJKK WJKF

Re: how did tapoban start?

Dalrajkaur · 04 Oct 2005

"Vivek ji," I suggest you know the full story before talking and not judge by hearing stuff. Bhai Sahib ji followed rehit, so whats wrong with using him as a role model and using him as an example? Bhai sahib ji was a chardi kala singh that had darshan of guru ji, why would you not follow something that he says about rehit? Your point is baseless. Singhs use gurbani as well to prove their points about rehit. So I suggest you get your facts straight before talking. Singh's also use other singhs as examples as well, so what are you going to say about that? We have met Singhs that used to spend all their time with Bhai Sahib and say nothing is wrong with what is being preached and taught at Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib. The Gurdwara has sarbloh bibek langar, please tell me how Bhai Sahib would not agree to this when he himself was sarbloh bebikee? Gurdwara sahib believes larivaar saroop to be our guru ji, and Bhai sahib ji had the same view, so tell me how he would be against this as well? There are many gursikhs that are from Bhai Sahibs time that say that Bhai Sahib would eat from anyones hands, but Bhai Sahib himself writes in his books that he only ate from rehitvaan singhs. So who should we believe, Bhai Sahib ji or these other Singhs? People like to make up thier own things, I suggest you read what Bhai Sahib wrote before judging. Once again, there is nothing being done at gurdwara sahib that Bhai Sahib would object too. "..... ji," ---but as stated earlier until Keertan is not sung in pure Raag using the shasters blessed by our own Guru Sahibs... Tapoban Sahib is not completely adhering to Tat-Gurmat---- I personally don't believe that kirtan should only be sung in raag. I have heard many people do raag kirtan, and I sometimes don't understand what they are saying because they are too busy with their "aaaahhhhh...... eeeeee.... ooooooo" instead of actually singing the bani pungti. you hear more humming rather than the shabad. This is not the case for all raag kirtan, but for some. Dalrajkaur [%sig%]

Re: how did tapoban start?

singh · 04 Oct 2005

I think the "Tapoban Jatha" is not a real name. I think it's Singhs that go to Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib in Toronto and belong to the Akhand Kirtani Jatha. Their mukhi being Sri Guru Granth Sahib (the biggest mukhi of all).

Re: how did tapoban start?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Oct 2005

although i have not been there...imho this is a GURDWARA...where GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB is the MUKHI ( as should be in all Gurdwaras but it isnt becasue of Goluks and Managements..). It is just a coincedence that the Singhs running it are also ardent followers of Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji....( that btw is NOT a MINUS point..it is certainly a PLUS point because BSB jI is an extremely Good Role Model for Modern Sikhs and YOUTHS..) IF I had half a chance I woukld settle down in the vicintiy and send my children there.....its the SAFEST PLACE for GURMATT and GURBANI without my children wittnessing any goluck grabbings and fights that are so normal in our gurdwars today. To the Parbhandaks..I say Carry on the GURU JI's WORK with all your Hearts......Sewa nu Mewa millega Jio....Even IF all your efforts results in just ONE SIKH YOUTH becoming a GURU WALLAH..its worth it.. Best Wishes from malaysia Jarnail Singh

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 05 Oct 2005

FACT- Bhai Sahib did not want akj to run their own gurdwara in my eyes tapoban are akj, just use a different name, if i am wrong, why is there a pic of bhai sahib on the homepage why are the majority of pics in photo section of bhai sahib? Bhai Randhir Singh did not want this........as the tapoban site makes the gurdwara appear as a 'dhera' this is what a singh told me who knew bhai sahib well. why are you criticising me for telling you what bhai sahib said?

Re: how did tapoban start?

Harjinder Singh · 05 Oct 2005

IMHO, Kirtan based only on traditional Gurmat Sangeet is the thing, I have seen yet to be achieved at Tapoban Sahib. In Sikh history, we are currently in very unfortunate situation regarding the Gurmat Sangeet. Nowadays, it is almost impossible to find the Nishkam Singhs with both Gurmat Jeewan and Gurmat Sangeet due to long time continuous negligence on this important aspect of Gurmat. Gurmat Sangeet is the Gurmat way of Keertan ie the way Guru Sahib did the Keertan. Now it seems like a very uphill task to us because we do not readily have nishkam Gursikhs available to share this wealth with us. At Tapoban Sahib, I think this is possible only if there is enough capability in Kirtani sevadars. If you can not perform kirtan based on suitable tunes, it does not mean, you can not sing at all the praises of Waheguru by Singing Gurbani. Gurmat Sangeet has two components, Shabad and Sur. Shabad is most important that should be sung in suitable tune. Shabad should always be dominating the tune. If you do not know what kind of tune will be suitable for a particular shabad or time, you should at least sing it in very simple way and the tune should not be Chanchal like most of Indian Filmi tunes these days. I think at Tapoban Sahib, the kirtan is usually sung in very simple and loving tunes and also include some shabads in Raags as well very often. But the most important thing is that Kirsten at Tapoban Sahib is always Akhand Keertan and collective singing of only Gurbani shabads in front of Sree Guru Granth Saahib jee, with active participation by the Sangat. I think at present, there is no one over there who can properly give the training of Gurmat Sangeet although I have seen some of kids very interested in Gurmat Sangeet and are learning it as much as they can based on available resources. It is my understanding that if it is possible/feasible, the singhs at Tapoban Sahibs will always encourage and support the Kirtan to be sung in accordance with Gurmat Sangeet. Regarding Simran in Keertan, at Tapoban Sahib, Only Gurbani is sung without any dhuni of naam simran in between. Most of the Keertan is sung by very young kids who are still learning. Keertan is one of the most important things a Sikh has to learn and do but there are many other things without which a Raag based Keertan lacks the Gurmat and will not be fruitful. These days, most of the Keertanyas with great knowledge of Gurmat sangeet sing for money and are not rehatwan. So Gurbani Sung by such persons will also not be parvan keetran to Guru Sahib. I think sur is just one element which off course make a big difference but there are other things in Gurmat Rehat which comes first to seek the happiness of Guru Sahib. Kirtan can be listened or sung along with someone singing if one can not sing by himself but all the other rehets, every sikh can practice by himself and there is no exemption for anyone.So A Sikh who is not a Good Kirtanyeea by himself still can attain the happiness of Guru Sahib. I am personally a big fan of Gurmat Sangeet and I anticipate that required steps will be taken tapoban Sahib to make an arrangement to learn and implement this important tradition as well in future without any compromise on other essential aspects of GURMAT. IMHO, Gurmat Sangeet just like Sarabloh Bibek, Lariwar Saroop and Keski is also one of the lost rehat/essential of Guru Khalsa Panth and the more we continue to ignore it or delay in adopting it, the harder and longer it will be becoming to acheive it. We must take the advantage of learning the Gurmat Sangeet from very few rare singhs left today who are blessed with this Daat and will be willing do this seva nishkam or otherwise we must also be willing to pay whatever price it take to preserve/retain and pass on the invaluable Gurmat Sangeet based Kirsten. Regarding the deravad concern, I think being Jathebandak is according to Gurmat traditions. A Sikh Jathebandi is just a collection of some Singhs working as team to follow Gurmat. Only when an organization dissociates itself from Guru Khalsa Panth and follow the decision of just one person, it becomes dera. At a Dera, the command of one person run all the affairs but in a Jathebandi all the decisions are taken unanimously based on Gurmat by entire Jathebandi. In a Sikh jathebandi, every member has equal say but in a dera only one person make all the decision. The Jatha of the Singhs at Tapoban sahib always take everyone in confidence and take a Unanimous Gurmatta to take a decision. Even a very small decision is not taken without the collective consent of at least five singhs. The Taboban Singh off course take the most inspiration from the Jeevan of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh who was one of the most Rehatwan Singh of last century who made a unique and most significant contribution in reviving many old gurmat traditions such as Lareedaar Saroop, Sarbloh bibek, Keski for all sikh women, nishkaam collective singing of Keertan of only Gurbani by entire Sangat, sant sipahi panthic jeewan etc. but they always take the Gurmat based decisions collectively with the consent of all or at least the five Singhs. Guru Granth Sahib Jee is the only leader and they are committed to serve the Guru Khalsa Panth. I have no doubt they Gurdwara Tapoban Saahib is dedicated to preserving and practicing Tat-Gurmat Maryada and implement strict Khalsa rehit given by Guru Sahib as per their best knowledge and capability. I have learnt that this institution has big dreams and if Guru Sahib continue to bless them with more and more resources, we will see a big Gurmat Taksal where all aspects of Gurmat will be practiced and taught and will be made available to all the Sikhs worldwide one day. I am sure Tapoban Sahib will be a more and more successful and will serve the Sikh Nation as biggest GURMAT TAKSAL in every field one day. Guru Sahib Mehar Karan [%sig%]

Re: how did tapoban start?

?? · 05 Oct 2005

Harjinder Singh, FANTASTIC POST!!! DalrajKaur Bhaenjee, doing "aaaahhhhh...... eeeeee.... ooooooo" is NOT according to Gurmat Sangeet

Re: how did tapoban start?

singh · 05 Oct 2005

vivek wrote: "FACT- Bhai Sahib did not want akj to run their own gurdwara" Vivek, didn't Bhai Sahib have Gurdwara Tapoban in Solan? What about Singh Sabha in Ludhiana? Isn't that a gurdwara run by Jatha Singhs? Is it better to be pushed around by Gurdwara Committees telling you if you can or cannot read ragmala or when to begin and end your programs or if you're allowed to have a program at all?

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 05 Oct 2005

FACT- Bhai Sahib did not want akj to run their own gurdwara i need not say no more........

Re: how did tapoban start?

singh · 05 Oct 2005

vivek, you're talking in pure ego as though you are the thekedar of the Jatha and you know what the real Jatha is about and everyone else is confused. What do you know? Were you in conversation with Bhai Sahib? Did Bhai Sahib tell you that there should not be a gurdwara operated by the Jatha? Like I asked before FACT-In Bhai Sahib's time, Jatha Singhs operated Gurdwara Tapoban in Solan and Singh Sabha in Ludhiana. In Ranglay Sajjan it's written that Dr.Basant Singh had a Gurdwara Sahib in Sekhwan. If you talked to ONE companion of Bhai Sahib, what's the difference? There are a lot of Singhs who did sangat of Bhai Sahib. Many disagree with each other on various points. There are Singhs who did sangat ( a lot of it) with Bhai Sahib, know about Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib and support it. Get off your high horse and realise you aren't the be all and end all of Jatha.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Dalrajkaur · 05 Oct 2005

Vivek ji, Singh ji has answered your question about Bhai Sahib and gurdwaras. You are stating stuff that you have heard and saying that “that is what Bhai Sahib said”. I suggest you actually read his books and then quote him. You will see that whatever you have said that “Bhai Sahib has said so and so” is wrong. So whats wrong if Bhai Sahib ji’s picture is on the main homepage? How does this make gurdwara sahib look like a dhera? Malton gurdwara consists of pictures of Sant Jarnail Singh ji, are you going to say that Malton Gurdwara has become a dhera as well? -----FACT- Bhai Sahib did not want akj to run their own gurdwara---- Show me where Bhai Sahib has said this. I want proof from Bhai Sahib, and not from something that you have heard.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Singh · 05 Oct 2005

Vivek - Bhai Sahib wanted promotion of Gurmat. I am sure he did not wnt Gurdwaras run by Communists, Congreessi as many are run today, but he wanted them run by Rehitvaan Khalsa. By the way, your whole point seems to be more a reflection of something negative in your own mind.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Guru-Charan-Preet Kaur · 06 Oct 2005

why on earth would BSB Randheer Singh Ji .."NOT WANT" a Gurdwara run by Rehutwaan Singhs ?? Sound too far fetched to me ? Guru nanak ji said Ghar Ghar ander Dharamsaal.... every Sikh would want as many GURDWARAS as possible...why should BSB ji oppose such ?? I think MORE such Gurdwaras as Tapoban Sahib should be PROMOTED all over. Most Gurdwaras are run by commercialised atheists/goluk chors/and such un-sikh "sikhs" who want MONEY more than Gurmatt. For them Gurdwaras are money making schemes... GSK

Re: how did tapoban start?

Destination · 06 Oct 2005

***Admin cut: This post has not been approved since it is not relevant to the topic on hand.********

Re: how did tapoban start?

amarjeet singh · 06 Oct 2005

You are stating stuff that you have heard and saying that “that is what Bhai Sahib said”. I suggest you actually read his books and then quote him. mabye tapoban lot should use QUOTES when refering to what bhai sahib said as well, because i have had a lot of difficulty finding any of the storys that they have narrated about bindia and so on, so could someone from tapoban provide a page reference? thank you

Re: how did tapoban start?

Kulbir Singh · 06 Oct 2005

Veer Amarjeet Singh jeeo, -------- mabye tapoban lot should use QUOTES when refering to what bhai sahib said as well, because i have had a lot of difficulty finding any of the storys that they have narrated about bindia and so on, so could someone from tapoban provide a page reference? thank you --------- Please refer to page number 44-45 of Bhai Sahib's book "Gurbani diyaan Lagaan Maatraan dee Vilakhantaa", 1987 edition. I think the new edition would have the same page number. Bhai Sahib has written the saakhi of Bhai Mani Singh and Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj there. The saakhi clearly concludes that bindi should be placed where required. In the end of this saakhi on page 45 Bhai Sahib has clearly written that ones who don't use the bindi sound where needed are totally ignorant and misguided. They don't have the Tatt-Gurmat understanding about Gurbani and under their ego, they don't place bindi. If you read this whole book, you will find several places Bhai Sahib advises us to pronounce bindi. Earlier you wrote that Singhs from Tapoban had just made up this story about use of bindi. Now (reading the above paragraph) you know that you were misinformed about this. Just because you could not find this reference in Bhai Sahib's book does not mean that Singhs were lying. I know you are a Bibeki Singh. The least that we should have for each other is faith and trust. Instead of confirming with Singhs, you resorted to false allegations. Who ever has told you that Bhai Sahib wanted Congressi and Communists running the Gurdwara Sahibs as opposed to Gursikhs is a Maha-Moorakh. Bhai Sahib never intended this. Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib is simply a Gurdwara that is run by Gursikhs who try to follow Gurmat as much as they can. What is wrong with that? Your adviser or whoever has been telling you all this nonsense is ... Kulbir Singh

Re: how did tapoban start?

A Singh · 06 Oct 2005

What's the big problem here? Tapoban run a Gurdwara by rehitvan Singhs who seek to practice "tat gurmat" maryada as they see it. There is nothing particularly anti-gurmat about it, sure there are many things one may pick out as shortcomings (re: Gurmat Sangeet) however, the solution is simple: If you dislike it that much, don't go there! I personally may not see 100% on many topics with some of the Tapobani Singhs, like Bhai Kulbir Singh, however, have no problem with him, his beliefs or indeed the practice in vogue amongst the Tapoban sangat. They are doing what they see best for the practice of Gursikhi - if you can't handle their outlook, fine - no need to get wound up about it! There are plenty of Gurdwaras in Toronto you can get into... Give it rest and let's move on...and let the Singhs and Singhnees there get on with their jeevan.

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 06 Oct 2005

kulbir singh, so youre saying we should add bhindia underneath letters turning them from 's to sh' and 'j to z' etc etc ?? isnt gurbani perfect? why we should we alter it? shouldnt we read it as it was written? ie pronouncing all lagamantra.......but not adding our own if we have to add our own, gurbani is not perfect...that what youre saying? if we have to add our own who knows where or where not to add them? ive had bhai sahibs book checked for that story once already, i will check again

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 06 Oct 2005

i would also like to know which book bhai sahib says bibia can be in panj

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 06 Oct 2005

i would also like to know where the folling story is from - "bhai sahib used to wear dumalla, but dumalle were not allowed in army, sikhs who wore dumalle refused to wear gurmukhi dastar, then bhai sahib started wearing gurmukhi dastar to encourage those in army to, and show them gurmukhi dastar is also acceptable" this was narrated by a tapoban singh to me its nonsense, theres not a single pic at balbir singh (bhai sahibs son) house of him wearing dumalla ive seen a photo of bhai sahib in his teens wearing a gurmukhi, not dumalla. i have seen one painting of bhai sahib in dumalla, but not a photo, from the painting it looks like a pic before bhai sahib went to take control of that gurdawara, before arrest. i dont deny he may hav wore dumalla on such an occasion.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Raag Mastar · 06 Oct 2005

Kulbir Singh, Why does not Tapoban Gurdrawa Sahib do kirtan in raag? Thanks,

Re: how did tapoban start?

Balpreet Singh · 06 Oct 2005

Vivek, I could be wrong, but your writing seems very bitter. Why? The story about Bhai Sahib wearing a dumalla came from my conversation with Giani Harbhajan Singh jee. Giani jee told me this. It's possible I misunderstood, but I don't think that's the case. The painting you saw also is at his house and he told me that Bhai Sahib posed for it. You say it's "nonsense" since you haven't seen a picture of it at Bhai Balbir Singh's house. Use your budhi here. Think hard. What are the earliest pictures of Bhai Sahib? There is one of him being very young (before the Jatha formed). The rest are all after Bhai Sahib's release and most are from the 50s. The story of Bhai Sahib wearing a dumalla is quite early (though obviously after his teens). Probably (though I'm not certain) from his days before going to jail. There are no pictures of this. Though, in Lagan Matra(n) Dee Vilakhanta, I'm sure during your search for the Bhai Mani Singh story, you came across the story of the Granthi who the scholar corrected (pronouncing Gun na vs. gunan) and Bhai Sahib then corrected the scholar and said the Granthi was right. In that story, Bhai Sahib says the scholar thought Bhai Sahib was just some nihang who didn't know much. Now, just from deduction, it would make sense that if the scholar thought Bhai Sahib was a Nihung, he would have been wearing Nihung BaaNaa? What does this include? A chola, shastars, and yes, a dumalla. I've never seen a nihung wearing a 'noak valee' dastaar. Read the story and tell me what you think. As for your point about bindis and bani being perfect. Adding bindis is not changing the perfection of bani in any way shape or form. There have been a lot of discussions on this before and I encourage you to do a search. But just take the example of Zafarnama. It is written as "Jafarnameh". Have you ever heard it pronounced like that? Anyways, I could give 101 examples but I'll stop here. Just do a search and if you're still unsure, we can continue. Vivek, we are brothers and we share almost identical beliefs (I think), shouldn't it be a given that we speak and write to each other with a positive and loving spirit as opposed to trying to pull each other down? Think about it.

Re: how did tapoban start?

amarjeet singh · 06 Oct 2005

"Who ever has told you that Bhai Sahib wanted Congressi and Communists running the Gurdwara Sahibs as opposed to Gursikhs is a Maha-Moorakh. Bhai Sahib never intended this. Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib is simply a Gurdwara that is run by Gursikhs who try to follow Gurmat as much as they can. What is wrong with that? Your adviser or whoever has been telling you all this nonsense is" kulbir singh hu is this papragraph addressed to? [%sig%]

Re: how did tapoban start?

amarjeet singh · 06 Oct 2005

does the guru granth sahib ji at tapoban sahib include raagmala?

Re: how did tapoban start?

Kulbir Singh · 06 Oct 2005

------- does the guru granth sahib ji at tapoban sahib include raagmala? --------- As per decision by Siri Akal Takhat Sahib, yes the saroop at Tapoban Sahib includes Raagmala. Kulbir Singh

Re: how did tapoban start?

Kulbir Singh · 06 Oct 2005

------- kulbir singh hu is this papragraph addressed to? ------- To you and to Vivek. Kulbir Singh

Re: how did tapoban start?

--- · 06 Oct 2005

Kulbir SIngh Jee, you wrote: 'As per decision by Siri Akal Takhat Sahib, yes the saroop at Tapoban Sahib includes Raagmala.' Bhai Sahib, I am not having a go at you or Tapoban Sahib, but I thought that Shri Akaal Takhat Maryada states that you can read Raagnala or not, it doesn't say that you HAVE to include it in Guru Granth Sahib Jee. I mean, if you dont read it, whats the point of including this piece into Shabad? Am i right? PLease correct otherwise. Thanks

Re: how did tapoban start?

Raag Mastars Chela · 06 Oct 2005

kulbir singh, dont ignore this question: why doesnt tapoban gurdrawa sahib do kirtan in raag? this is purataan marayda

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 06 Oct 2005

i will do some more research, from info i have gathered so far, bhindia underneath letters were not placed under letters in sggsji therefore i say 'jap ji sahib' not 'zap zi shahib', i try my best to pronounce all laga mantra as specified in bhai sahibs book because gurbani is perfect, the sound is perfect, if in guru granth sahib its says gurpraSad .....then i say gurpraSad and NOT gurpraSHad

Re: how did tapoban start?

Harwinder Singh · 06 Oct 2005

WAHEGURU JEE KAA KHALSA WAHEGURU JEE KEE FATEH In my humble opinion, Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib is the best place to go in Greater Toronto area because Singh/Singhneeian there try to follow Tat-Gurmat rehat Mariyada. If worthless dog like me ever get a chance to live in Toronto by Guru's Grace, I'll consider my "Vadde Bhag" and gladly live close to Tapoban Sahib and send my kid's to this Gurdwara sahib for Gurmat learning. PS: MY BELOVED KHALSA JEE.....YOU ARE DOING A GREAT SEVA TO THE GURU AND KHALSA PANTH. PLEASE CONTINUE THIS NOBLE TASK. MAY AKAL PURAKH BLESS YOU ALL ! WAHEGURU JEE KAA KHALSA WAHEGURU JEE KEE FATEH -Dasan Dass Harwinder Singh Michigan, USA

Re: how did tapoban start?

Balpreet Singh · 06 Oct 2005

The Akal Takhat hukum is that no one should "dare" print a saroop that doesn't have ragmala until a panthic decision is reached. Vivek, Bindis are not put on every single letter. In puratan Gurmukhi, there were no bindis at the feet. They were created afterwards. Let me give you a non-Gurbani example. Shah Mohammed wrote the Jangama about the Singhs and their fight with the British. If you see the old text, he writes his name "Sah Mohammed". Clearly his name was Shah, but because there were no bindis, he didn't put one. People just knew where to put a bindi. Here's another example. Ardas we do, is from Vaar Sri Bhagautee Jee Kee. In it, it is written "Sree Harkrisan" but the entire Panth reads it "Sree Harkrishan" . Why? Because that's the name. So with words like Shabad and Sharan and Shaant, the bindis arise naturally. They were meant to be read in. That's how puraatan Gurmukhi works. Ask the Singhs you know from the time of Bhai Sahib how to read these words. Anyways I'm glad you're going to go do more research. But please have more faith in your fellow Singhs. I know that we Singhs here don't sit around concocting stories about Bhai Sahib or Gurmat. We're not so evil that we are purposely trying to mislead you or anyone else. Have some faith. We aren't Panth dokhis (panthic enemies). We're your brothers.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Kulbir Singh · 06 Oct 2005

-------- Kulbir Singh, Why does not Tapoban Gurdrawa Sahib do kirtan in raag? --------- I am assuming that when you say kirtan in Raag, you mean kirtan in Nirdhaarat Raag. Please let me know if you meant otherwise. Two reasons: 1) We believe that along with kirtan in Nirdhaarat Raags, it is okay to do kirtan in simple tunes. We have had vichaar on this and so far we have not reached a Gur-matta on doing kirtan only in nirdhaarat raags. We know for a fact that puratan Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee used to do kirtan in non-nirdhaarat-raag reets and we also know that Bhai Sahib was fond of Raag kirtan as is evident by one of his favourite kirtaniya - Bhai Dilruba jee. 2) We don't know how to do kirtan with string instruments and in nirdhaarat raags. Last Saturday, a Singh expert in Raags was supposed to do kirtan with a string instrument but he did not come. Hopefully, he will come this week. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: how did tapoban start?

Dalrajkaur · 06 Oct 2005

Why are you guys picking on Kulbir Singh? Raag Mastars Chela, How is Kulbir Singh ignoring the question when you did not even address it to him? Vivek, to me you seem like someone that has hate towards Kulbir Singh, Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib, or rehit in general. As suggested to you before, read Bhai sahibs books before quoting or saying that "bhai sahib said this".

Re: how did tapoban start?

do not know · 06 Oct 2005

i think raag kirtan is a very big learning curve for all the sikhs. based on views expressed by bhai kulbir singh ji, balpreet singh ji and specially harjinder singh ji, it seems that tapoban sangat is doing their best level to follow gurmat. i think it is very unreasonable to attack these gurmukhs for the things they have not achieved so far. only guru ji is abhul and we all bhularhar and will always be. but these singhs are doing a remarkable service and setting a unique example in the entire world specially in north america that tapoban is probabily the only gurdwara where all the prabandak sevadars reach gurdwara sahib for daily naam abiyas and nitnem before everyone in sangat and they do most of the seva by themselves more than anyone in the sangat contarary to what we see in other gurdwaras. all the leading sevadars are rehatvan bebeki singhs. whatelse we are looking for. it would be better, if someone is so serious about the proper kirtan maryada, he or she should provide the means to make it happen because raags can not implemented without first getting expertise. so i will ask these well wishers to contribute if they can otherwise just believe in these singhs that they are doing their best and are willing to improve and keep on. just my two cents. no offence pl. ** one more thing, there are many gurdwaras in and outside india managed by akj. tapoban is not the first and will not be last one. i wish all the sikh places are managed by singhs like those are managing tapoban. [%sig%]

Re: how did tapoban start?

Singh · 06 Oct 2005

It would be really good if Tapoban started doing Raag Keertan! And all Tapoban-haters worldwide would no longer have anything to cry about!

Re: how did tapoban start?

amarjeet singh · 06 Oct 2005

"Why are you guys picking on Kulbir Singh? Raag Mastars Chela, How is Kulbir Singh ignoring the question when you did not even address it to him? Vivek, to me you seem like someone that has hate towards Kulbir Singh, Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib, or rehit in general. As suggested to you before, read Bhai sahibs books before quoting or saying that "bhai sahib said this"." they arent pikin on kulbir singh theyre jus askin him questions cos evry1 recognises him as learned gursikh who knows his stuff

Re: how did tapoban start?

.. · 07 Oct 2005

< 1) We believe that along with kirtan in Nirdhaarat Raags, it is okay to do kirtan in simple tunes. We have had vichaar > Not good enough. Gurbani has been composed in Raags so it must be sung in Raags. We are all so quick to condemn Dharnaas but singing shabads in "simple tunes" is not good enough. [%sig%]

Re: how did tapoban start?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Oct 2005

** one more thing, there are many gurdwaras in and outside india managed by akj. tapoban is not the first and will not be last one. i wish all the sikh places are managed by singhs like those are managing tapoban. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> For me this SAYS IT ALL. I too wish ALL GURDWARAS were managed like Tapoban Sahib.. Granted that they are not "perfect"..but then all the others are TOO IMPERFECT...some have absolutley no GURMATT at all....all MANMATT. Jarnail Singh.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Jugraj Singh · 07 Oct 2005

If you want to discuss the validity of raag keertan as a rehit, then please start another discussion.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Harjinder Singh · 07 Oct 2005

>** one more thing, there are many gurdwaras in and outside india >managed by akj. tapoban is not the first and will not be last one. i wish all >the sikh places are managed by singhs like those are managing tapoban. singh wrote: I also pray that Guru Sahib bless every Gursikh a place like Tapoban Sahib reachable on a daily basis to enjoy the sangat of naam rangley gurmukhs and get only Gurmat feed.

Re: how did tapoban start?

tarrandeep kaur · 07 Oct 2005

dal raj kaur, penji how has vivek got hate towards rehit???? you do not even know this singh, he is a chardi kala gursikh who follows rehit. he is merely askin questions and justifications, just like every one else on this forum. :-) why cant we all have a sensible conversation without feeling angry ;-) after all we are all brothers and sisetrs :-) bhul chuk maaf karna vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: how did tapoban start?

Dalrajkaur · 07 Oct 2005

----they arent pikin on kulbir singh theyre jus askin him questions cos evry1 recognises him as learned gursikh who knows his stuff---- Fair enough to say that about others, but Vivek seems to have some hate towards Kulbir Singh or towards Tapoban Sahib in general.

Re: how did tapoban start?

LionKing · 07 Oct 2005

1) We believe that along with kirtan in Nirdhaarat Raags, it is okay to do kirtan in simple tunes. We have had vichaar on this and so far we have not reached a Gur-matta on doing kirtan only in nirdhaarat raags. We know for a fact that puratan Singhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee used to do kirtan in non-nirdhaarat-raag reets and we also know that Bhai Sahib was fond of Raag kirtan as is evident by one of his favourite kirtaniya - Bhai Dilruba jee. ______________________________ So tha would mean that BHai Randhir SIngh ji would be more important thatn the Raags written in Maharaj? woudl this mean that WHat BHai Sahib writes is more importan tha Bhai Satta and Balvant doign Kirtan in Raag in Guru ji's Darbar`? ___________________________ 2) We don't know how to do kirtan with string instruments and in nirdhaarat raags. Last Saturday, a Singh expert in Raags was supposed to do kirtan with a string instrument but he did not come. Hopefully, he will come this week. _____________________________ Hopefully this will lead to isnpiration of Raag Kirtan, and the most puratan and REAL KIRTAN. 60 odd years is NOT Puratan, so please don't say tha Puratan SInghs didn't do Raag Kirtan. Even today in Darbar SAHib you have to read the first Shabad in Raag (if I'm not mistaken)

Re: how did tapoban start?

Princess · 07 Oct 2005

////// therefore i say 'jap ji sahib' not 'zap zi shahib' ///// Vivek jee, how do you pronounce 'cup', 'cake' and 'cookie'? Like sup, sake and sookie or Kup, Kake, Kookie? And how do you pronounce 'cent', 'cease' and 'cyber'? Like Sent, Sease, Syber or like kent, keace and kyber ? Same way one letter of gurmukhi sometimes have more than one sound. Gurbani Grammer classes will be helpful to learn and understand Gurbani pronounciation as well as Gurbani meanings.

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 07 Oct 2005

lol, everyone needs to calm down im going through the book on laga mantra, and making sure i translate and interpret what bhai sahib is saying...... so far i have gathered that bhai sahib is explaining how laga mantra change meanings of words so far i have only come across 'bhinde', the dot above a letter which makes a nasal 'n' sound i accept gurmukhs will know when to pronounce this nasal 'n' (bhindi above) in circumstances where gurbani has not been copied from one bir to anouther accuratley however theres no mention of bhinde underneath letters turning s-sh and g-gh and j-z etc etc........ nor are these present in sggsji, however they are in dasm patshas bani eg akal ustat. as some words in dasm patsahs bani are derived from persian...and in persian they use z like zafarnama i have not made a conclusion....alllow me to go through the book, to ensure i dont misinterpret anything

Re: how did tapoban start?

Kulbir Singh · 07 Oct 2005

Vivek, when I referred you to that saakhi written by Bhai Sahib, I meant nasal sound only. I did not claim anywhere that Bhai Sahib in that saakhi has mentioned bindi under alphabets. So don't draw any conclusions from it. Now let’s talk about bindi underneath. Gurmukhi and Punjabi are two different scripts. When you learn Punjabi and then try to read Gurmukhi with the rules of Punjabi, you get all these questions that you are asking. In Punjabi there are 41 alphabets and has adhhak as well. Gurmukhi does not have adhak and has only 35 alphabets. No one can pronounce Gurbani without the use of Addhak. Everyone uses Adhhad. It is impossible to read baani without adhhak and I have met a single person who does not pronounce adhhak while reciting Gurbani. If you want to be so puritan, then stop using Adhhak also. Now coming back to bindi in the bottom. In Gurmukhi, there are more sounds but less alphabets. The fourth alphabet is sassa and shasha. In Punjabi you have two alphabets for the sounds of Sassa and Shasha but in Gurmukhi there is only one alphabet for two sounds. Why have you assumed that the fourth letter of Gurmukhi alphabet has only the sound of “Sassa”? Who has told you that it is not “Shasha” ? Stop using the rules of Punjabi on Gurmukhi. In Gurmukhi this alphabet has two sounds sassa and Shasha. If you want to read as it is written, why do you pronounce the first word of Mool Mantr as “Ikk Oankaar”? Where is “Oankaar” written? It is only a “OoRa” and a line. How do you know that it is Oankaar? If you want to pronounce it as it is written, then you should say Ikk OooRa. And why say it “ikk” and why not “Pehla”. When the number “ 1 “ comes after mahalla we pronounce it “pehla” but why do we pronounce it “ikk” when it comes before “oankaar”? In Gurbani at many places it just says “M:1” and we pronounce it as “Mahalla Pehla”. Why? Why not just say “mamma Pehla”? The bottomline is that ones who try to read Gurbani using the rules of Punjabi language use these kind of arguments as you are making. I have confirmed with Bhai Jodh Singh of Delhi and other singhs of times of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and they all have confirmed that Bhai Sahib used to use “Shasha” and “Zazza” where appropriate. Bhai Sahib had to. He was an expert in Farsi language and could not have pronounced words like uneducated people who pronounce “Mashakkat” as “Masakat”. All old Singhs from Jatha use Shasha and other such sounds. Don't know where you are getting these ideas from. This is not an issue in Jatha. Kulbir Singh

Re: how did tapoban start?

--- · 07 Oct 2005

Tapoban Sahib Sangat Jeeo, I am incredibly impressed that you guys try to practice Tat-gurmat maryada, and I am also impressed by the fact that you are trying to incorporate Gurmat Sangeet into the Maryada. GO FOR IT SINGHO! YOU HAV MY SUPPORT!

Re: how did tapoban start?

Singh · 07 Oct 2005

There are no Bindian underneath letters in Dasam Bani. Bindian came much later on. Check any Puratan Saroop; you will never find Bindian under letters anywhere.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Lionking · 07 Oct 2005

Singh ji If i'm not mistaken "Shahan Shah hai" has Bindi on the bottom - not 100% sure, will check the Gutka, but if I'm not mistaken "Shahaan Sha Hai" does have a bindi..

Re: how did tapoban start?

Singh · 07 Oct 2005

Check the Gutka it may well have a Bindi in it. But in the original text there is no Bindi.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Princess · 07 Oct 2005

Vivek jeeo, would you mind starting another thread on Gurbani pronounciation instead of trying to ruin this thread. Dhanvaad!!!

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 08 Oct 2005

ikk onkar, and other abreviations like 'mahela pela' are abreviations, its clear m1 means mahela pela you cannot compare this shorthand way which guruji has decided to use with some words, with the conversion of s-sh, g-gh, j-z gurbani came from 'above' there is no faults, if guruji wanted us to pronounce somewords with sh, he would have made a letter for the sh noise, or identified it in some other way there are several letters which can be changed by placing a dot underneath, we would not know where to start if we had to decide when to say 's' or 'sh', 'g or gh', 'j or z' , kh- khh think in every line of gurbani we will have to decide on which of the above sounds to make unless i were a bram gyiani, i would not know where to start Bhai Sahibs book laga mantra, is all about how how laga mantra change the meaning of words I pronounce gurbani as guruji has writen it (well try), so if theres no adhak, i do not say adhak (this is in sggsji) if in dasm patsahs bani, eg, akal ustat he uses adhak, then i will use adhak where he has placed them..............i do not think, dasm patsah has used adhak in his bani, so i will add some of my own into guru granth sahib............this is manmat i will go through bhai sahibs book, so far i understand the book is all about pronouncing all lagamantra, as it changes the meaning of each words i havnt come across anywhere where it says pronounce things which arent there therefore when i read gurbani from sggsji, i say gurprasad, not gurprashad because guruji has left no indication that i should pronounce something which isnt there.

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 08 Oct 2005

kulbir singh-Why have you assumed that the fourth letter of Gurmukhi alphabet has only the sound of “Sassa”? Who has told you that it is not “Shasha” ? ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- why have you assumed we say japji sahib and not zapzi shaib? i assume guru granth sahib is perfect i assume gurbani is perfect i assume guru ji wanted us to pronounce gurbani as he write it --------------------------------------------------------------------------- princess-Vivek jee, how do you pronounce 'cup', 'cake' and 'cookie'? Like sup, sake and sookie or Kup, Kake, Kookie? And how do you pronounce 'cent', 'cease' and 'cyber'? Like Sent, Sease, Syber or like kent, keace and kyber ? Same way one letter of gurmukhi sometimes have more than one sound. Gurbani Grammer classes will be helpful to learn and understand Gurbani pronounciation as well as Gurbani meanings. -------------------------------------------------------------------- do not compare gurbani with the english language, english language is not the truth, it is not perfect, gurbani is written in gurmukhi not english if gurbani doesnt read how it is written , who decides how to pronounce anything at all? if every one adds there own 'mat' variation would be huge. as you can pronounce s, kh, g, j, f differently in punjabi, every other word contains these letters, how wud you know if its kartapurakh or kartapurakhh, hajoor or hazoor, gurprasad or gurprashad, 'hukam rajai chalna' or 'hukam razai chalna' 'akhan jor' or 'akhan zor' 'furman or fhurman', 'khintha or khhintha' ............

Re: how did tapoban start?

a singh · 09 Oct 2005

dear tapoban singh's, i was wondering do you light a jyot at tapoban sahib?

Re: how did tapoban start?

vivek · 09 Oct 2005

i am still undecided, i dont think i'll be 100% sure one way or the other for sometime....i can also see youre point of view that letters may have 2 sounds, i havent come across anything inconclusive, so i am keeping an open mind on the matter..........

Re: how did tapoban start?

Kanwaldeep Singh · 09 Oct 2005

wahegurujikakhalsa wahegurujikifateh when I was a young lad going to school in Montreal some 20-25 years back there was just one gurdawara sahib to serve the community.My family like most others would attend the gurdawara every Sunday. There were usually 2-3 parcharaks per year. They would in there kathas often talk about the importance of rehat. We would hear stories about chardi kala gursikhs during guru sahibs time.I would often go home and wonder what it would be like to see rehatvan singhs in the flesh.....how they spoke.....how they respected GuruGranthSahibji.......how they respected each other. I searched for a long time.I met some Chardikala gursikhs over the years. When I first met singhs associated with Tapoban(before Tapoban came into existence) I must say I was overwhelmed with joy.They were very loving and above all their jeevans are very inspiring. I am no where close to their level of bhagti.Both of my children go there for the weekend classes and attend the summer camps.Its had a positive affect on them.I may differ on some points but I think as time passes these differences will become more minute. All I can say is please accept this benti from this murakh and please drop by and see the Tapoban experience for yourself. Feel free to ask any questions....don't be scared or shy......I guarantee you will come out of there with a better understanding than you had gone in with. So take the Tapoban challenge and enjoy Guru Sahibs blessings. bhul chuk maaf karo ji, daas kanwaldeep singh(Toronto) [%sig%]

Re: how did tapoban start?

singh-2 · 09 Oct 2005

vivek, if you only have to read gurbani the way it is written in guru granth sahib without any laga matran, what is the need for santhiaa then? think about this: even during guru sahib's time there were issues over correct pronunciation. for example why would guru hargobind sahib ask his sikhs for someone to read bani correctly? bhai gopala came forward and did shudd paath and later he wished for guru's horse as reward when guru was willing to give everything. but the main point is that there was no need for guru sahib to ask sikhs if anyone can do shudd paath if all is needed is to read it out simply as it is written because any kid with basic punjabi could do that. outside of taksal and some other sant sampardah most of the panth is agreed about issue of viakaran. you ask for bhai randheer singh's quotes for evidence of laga matra like somehow bhai sahib was one who invented the issue of viakaran. panth has since guru's times read bani with viakaran. listen to old recordings of keertan or kathaa etc from those born pre-47 and you will see how the old singhs of pre-partition punjab with knowledge of urdu and farsi pronounced gurbani. since 47 next generation has suffered from limitations of hindustani education coupled with lazy and uneducated sampardah who have not taken time to actually study gurbani and the results are there to see.

Re: how did tapoban start?

atl singh · 09 Oct 2005

Is there any way we could see some pictures of the Gurdvara and the Sangat.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Oct 2005

the Taksalis may not "officially" accept Gurbani Viakaran ( afraid to lose face)but as I have personally observed..( IN Kuala Lumpur) in their Gurbani Paath Classes.....their Baba ji's now stress on"correct" pronounciation ( according to Gurbani viakaran but they wont say so in straight words). The answer is obvious..they have found out that indeed there is such a thing as Gurbani Viakran Grammar..and Gurbani pronounced " as it is written" EXACTLY makes no sense at all..as such they have dropped their insistence on Pronounce EXACTLY as written..so they say....MUSHKAT with ADHAK..and not MASKAT as in Gayeh Mushakat ghaal.. Rassee sarr gayee par watt nahi giyah walee gal ansaar...the word "gurbani viakaraan" or Grammer is still anathema to them...but as more and more YOUTH learn from the Internet and Prof Sahib Singh Ji's Darpan and Bhai Joginder Singh ji Talwarras books on Gurbani Viakran...there is no choice but to accpet this FACT...so it is grudgingly accepted...NO MATTER as long as they accept it is OK..becasue it is the Means to an END..and the END is all that counts....that MORE SIKH YOUTHS UNDERSTAND GURBANI as GURU JI Meant it to be Understood.

Re: how did tapoban start?

question · 09 Oct 2005

gyani ji you said your father studied from Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji so did sant ji teach him to pronounce "as gurbani is written" because I met some of sant ji's students and they do pronounce adhak as taught by sant ji. one example would be that they pronounce "Mahalla" and 72 is "Bahattar". but just curious to know why you couldn't make your point without attacking taksal? I know some taksalis do believe in pronouncing gurbani "as it is written" but many others don't so your generalization is not correct.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Kulbir Singh · 11 Oct 2005

------- i was wondering do you light a jyot at tapoban sahib? ------ No.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Frank · 11 Oct 2005

question, "Gyani" is known for his Taksal views, don't pay attention. Everything somehow comes back to the Taksal. If you give him the chance he can draw the conclusion that the Tsunami was in fact caused by the Taksal. It makes me wonder why he hates them so much. But anyways you obviously have some issues buddy. Frankly speaking the Taksal do know and practice "Gurbani Grammer" those Singhs that have studies there and been with some of the elder Maha pursh's know this. People posing as Taksali's, whome have not studied there or just throw on a similar looking dress may be teaching the wrong message. Hey everybody is good whether it be Taksal, akj, tapoban, Rara sahib, nanaksar, etc, etc, etc hey even Gyani is good.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Princess · 11 Oct 2005

///// do not compare gurbani with the english language, english language is not the truth, it is not perfect, gurbani is written in gurmukhi not english //// What you mean? All languages are good and they have their own rules. I gave you examples of c letter because in Gurmukhi, there are some letters which have more than one sound like English and also other languages. In Gurmukhi, there are only 35 alphabets but there are 41 sounds. Where do we get those sounds from? My grand parents and other old members of our family were learned gurmukhi from Gurdwaras. They learned only 35 alphabets but 41 sounds and also they can only write laRidaar not separated words because that how they were taught to write Gurmukhi. ///// if gurbani doesnt read how it is written , who decides how to pronounce anything at all? if every one adds there own 'mat' variation would be huge. /////// To read Gurbani, we all should take santhyaa classes. Gurmukhs who know Gurmukhi and its grammer can tell you how to pronounce Gurbani correctly or Guru Sahib jee can if you have direct connection with HIM through jyot parkaash. Every language has it's own grammer and rules which don't allow anyone to use their own 'matt'. Otherwise, we can say it about any language why only about Gurmukhi? Vivek jeeo, I did benti in last post to start another thread for Gurbani pronounciation but you continued ruining this original thread about Taboban Sahib. Are you ignoring it on purpose or innocently? Just wondering.

Re: how did tapoban start?

Amrik Singh "boongawala" · 11 Oct 2005

I quite like the article Veer Kulbir Singh has written about the use of the bindis. It is true bindis are must in Gurbani, please read Bhai Sahib's book Gurbani dia luga matra vilhkhanta to expland knowlege on Gurbani. Vahiguru ji ka Khalsa Vahiguru ji ki fateh

Re: how did tapoban start?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Oct 2005

Author: question Date: 10-09-05 22:42 gyani ji you said your father studied from Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji so did sant ji teach him to pronounce "as gurbani is written" because I met some of sant ji's students and they do pronounce adhak as taught by sant ji. one example would be that they pronounce "Mahalla" and 72 is "Bahattar". but just curious to know why you couldn't make your point without attacking taksal? I know some taksalis do believe in pronouncing gurbani "as it is written" but many others don't so your generalization is not correct. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> YES Sant Ji did.....and the rest of it dad picked up from Prof Sahib Singh Ji's Darpan....and related books on Gurbani Grammar. ____________________________________________________________ Author: Frank Date: 10-11-05 11:17 question, "Gyani" is known for his Taksal views, don't pay attention. Everything somehow comes back to the Taksal. If you give him the chance he can draw the conclusion that the Tsunami was in fact caused by the Taksal. It makes me wonder why he hates them so much. But anyways you obviously have some issues buddy. Frankly speaking the Taksal do know and practice "Gurbani Grammer" those Singhs that have studies there and been with some of the elder Maha pursh's know this. People posing as Taksali's, whom have not studied there or just throw on a similar looking dress may be teaching the wrong message. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< There you have answered your own questions...." Taksalis" posing as taksalis/dressing up as taksalis/claiming to be taksalis...are the ones I "HIT" in my mails precisely becasue of what they do. The GENUINE TAKSALIS should come out and put things right...thats my message and endeavour. It is happenign already as Frank and Question mails have proved. So its all GOOD as far as I am concerned. Just for Your information...the Local "Taksalis" ( look alikes as i said above )did send out a Email Message on the Tsunami.....and it was centred around the Shabad..DUKH DAROO Sabh Rog Bhaiyah....claiming GOD sent the Tsunami as a DUKH so we could have an idea about DAROO and a whole lot of BS. I was immediately taken off their mailing list after i sent out the correct interpretation of this shabad. Their interpretation was so simialr to the one the local MULLAHS sent out claiming God was punishing evil-doers, drunkards, prostitutes etc etc !!! by sending the Tsunami... SO dera FRANK JIO..you are not that Far off the mark...The TSUNAMI was indeed caused by ???..and they sent out an email to prove it. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Anyway spread the LOVE...lols....i really dont hate anybody..just the wrong parchaar....

Re: how did tapoban start?

LionKing · 12 Oct 2005

Gyani Ji wrote - "DUKH DAROO Sabh Rog " Dukh Daru SUKH Rogh Bheya - Sukh not Sabh bhull chukk maaf

Re: how did tapoban start?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Oct 2005

Author: LionKing Date: 10-12-05 03:55 Gyani Ji wrote - "DUKH DAROO Sabh Rog " Dukh Daru SUKH Rogh Bheya - Sukh not Sabh bhull chukk maaf >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Thanks veer ji for the correction. Typo eror. Bhul chuk Maaf. Jarnail singh

Re: how did tapoban start?

question · 12 Oct 2005

So your father pronounced no adhak when he studied from Sant Ji? What about a whole panktee of "Wah Wah Sacchay.." in Ramkali Vaar? Many other students confirm that Sant Ji taught adhak and other grammar rules. Sant Ji believed that gurbani was not limited to grammar which only gives you one meaning. Rather he believed that meanings from grammar were one of the ways to understand Gurbani.

Re: how did tapoban start?

moorakh · 02 Nov 2005

is every body invited like equal singhs in your tapoban sahib?

Re: how did tapoban start?

RoopKaur · 02 Nov 2005

>is every body invited like equal singhs in your tapoban sahib< Your wording is not right. You should not have put "your" infornt of Tapoban Sahib, because a gurdvara is guru ji's, not a person's. As for your question, I have never seen anyone stopped from coming in or discriminated against. I have only seen every person warmly welcomed. Why don't you come and see for yourself?

Re: how did tapoban start?

moorakh · 03 Nov 2005

i am sorry,i like the kirtan the singhs are doing there.

Re: how did tapoban start?

vir amrik singh · 03 Nov 2005

SGPC started it and let the AKJ go ahead, in 1987