Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

singh · 02 Oct 2005

Happy Birthday to Mohandas Gandhi! Everyone calls the old pervert (slept naked with his nieces to prove his 'chastity') father of India. Bapu Gandhi. India's Bapu called our Dashmesh Pita a "misguided patriot" in a public forum. Bhai Jagat Singh (Bhai Tejinder Singh) came running to a Gursikh's house one day. Bhai Sahib was an Air Force officer who used to serve with his beard open and brought a lot of Singhs into the Akhand Kirtani Jatha. At the home of the Singh, there was a Gursikh Mata jee. Mata jee saw Bhai Jagat Singh running in and asked "What's the matter?". Bhai Jagat Singh answered, "I herad a speech by Gandhi today. He was talking about Guru Gobind Singh and said that though Guru Sahib had good intentions, he was in the end just a misguided patriot for having taken up the sword". Mata jee asked, "How could you just listen to that? Why didn't you slap him!" Bhai Tejinder Singh replied, "That's exactly what I did! I got up and slapped him across the face and now I'm running from the police!" In 1947, Bhai Tejinder Singh went out for a walk and headed towards the famous Birla Mandir. Seeing the crowd there , he went closer and saw Gandhi doing lecture. When he heard the remark about "misguided partriot", Bhai Tejinder Singh had gone up to Gandhi and smacked him across the face. The crowd tried to catch him and beat him, but he got away. The Indian police were searching for him everywhere for having insulted their great leader so badly. Later a deal was worked out where he was released from the Air Force and no action was taken against him in order to keep this event quiet. He then used to teach keertan in Chandigarh and later left India. Funny how everyone remembers the "misguided patriot" comment, but no one brings up the fact that Gandhi got slapped for it. And today we see this scene below. It's a disgrace. He insulted our Dashmesh Pita, and some Sikhs still revere him as their Bapu.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Gurpreet Singh · 02 Oct 2005

Didn't he apologise for that mistake?...I'm just curious. I heard that in one of Bhai Sahib Parminder Singh Ji's Katha

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

singh · 02 Oct 2005

no, I heard that in Bhai Parminder Singh's katha as well. Perhaps this was another incident but this one didn't involved Dr. Ganda Singh at all and Gandhi never stopped making derogatory comments about Sikhs and Guru Sahib.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

desidalip · 02 Oct 2005

That's horrible. Gandhi was a saint. It's stupid to attack him. THat guy who did that sucks.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

guy · 02 Oct 2005

desidalip, a guy who calls ur guru bad is not a saint. i personally believe he should of been assisnated at the spot for callin guru jee that.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

LS · 02 Oct 2005

It is worth resding this book to find out what a cheat and bad character Mohandas was. From Amazon.co.uk 'The Myth of the Mahatma: Gandhi, the British and the Raj ' Michael Edwardes . Availability: usually dispatched within 1 to 2 working days 7 Used & New from £10.99 Edition: Hardcover Product Details: Hardcover 256 pages (June 30, 1986) Publisher: Constable Language: English ISBN: 0094660700 Category(ies): History

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Singhstah · 02 Oct 2005

desidalip did u actually read the other part of the post, he called our dear father Sri Guroo Gobind Sngh Ji Mahraj a misguided patriiot, are you friggin crazy?

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

tarrandeep kaur · 02 Oct 2005

shut up, how can you call him a saint, if he insulted guru gobind singh jee???

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Zorawar Singh · 03 Oct 2005

Gandhi never belived in peaceful agitation. he always encouraged the Babbar Akalis, as they were the only ones who fought an underground campaign. But then Baba Kharak Singh started the Gurdwara Freedoom Movement. This involved 50-100 Sikhs doing Ardas as Siri Akal Thakht sahib, then going to various Gurdwaras and freeing them from British control with peaceful agaitation. The movement was so succesful, that in 1920`s the British had to hand the keys to all the Gurdwaras back to the Sikhs. Gandhi was shocked how successful sikhs were. He was also jealous of the popularity of Baba Kharak Singh. So he got Baba Kharak Singh jailed, and then announced he was starting a new movement to free India by peaceful agitation. It was Baba Kharak Singh jis policies that made Gandhi famous. gandhi being a typical brahmin, stapped Sikhs in the back and does everything to maintain power and popularity.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

SinghNature · 03 Oct 2005

>>Gandhi was a saint Dont make me laaaaf! Mohandas Randhi was much a Saint, as Hitler was a saviour of the Human Race.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

uk singh · 03 Oct 2005

FAO Desidalip, Interesting article. Even before Gandhi came to India in 1915, the Sikhs had been peacefully protesting for the right to run their Gurdwaras (after the Sikh kingdom had been annexed, the Gurdwaras had been turned over by the British to Brahmin Hindus to run). Gandhi was very critical of the 'Sikh way' of civil disobedience. He said: "The Akalis (Sikh Warriors) wear a black turban and a black band on one shoulder and also carry a big staff with a small axe on the top. Fifty or a hundred of such groups go and take possession of a gurdwara; they suffer violence themselves but do not use any. Nevertheless, a crowd of fifty or more men approaching a place in the way described is certainly a show of force and naturally the keeper of the Gurdwara would be intimidated by it." (Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi, Vol. 19 pg. 401). This is where I do not understand Gandhi's teachings. On the one hand Gandhi did not believe non-violent resistance should be "passive," but rather that it should be, in essence, a "force". On the other hand, he criticized Sikhs for practicing non-violent civil disobedience in seeking control of their Gurdwaras. Their methods were even praised by British leaders. Reverend C. F. Andrews wrote: "The vow (of non-violence) they (the Sikhs) had made to God was kept to the letter. I saw no act, no look, of defiance." As far as the spirit of the suffering they endured, the Reverend said "It was very rarely that I witnessed any Akali Sikh, who went forward to suffer, flinch from a blow when it was struck. The blows were received one by one without resistance and without a sign of fear." Still, Gandhi could not reconcile this manner of civil disobedience, for he decided that the Sikhs participating in it harbored "hatred in their hearts" and thus never gave his blessings to such forms of agitation. Gandhi could not understand why Sikhs would peacefully protest while wearing arms. To him, this constituted cowardice, that one carries arms while walking in peace. I completely disagree. Gandhi failed to realize the differences between non-violence of the weak, and non-violence of the strong. The importance of carrying arms was to show that they were indeed brave enough and capable of using them, but that they were instead consciously choosing not to. It is a discipline that only a few select can conquer. A coward who is weak and scared will never wear arms and walk in peaceful protest because, as soon as the first signs of oppression arise, he will be scared and use his weapons in haste. Similarly, the weak and the scared will never have the capacity to make non-violence their way of life. To them it will only be something useful when they are helplessly bound in shackles. To be able to wear arms and to not retaliate or show the slightest bit of anger or attempt self-defence against someone who is attacking you is the highest form of non-violent protest. It implies a complete resignation to peaceful ways and an absolute belief in the power of non-violent protest despite the ability of the protestor to respond violently. It is one thing to walk in peaceful protest that is born out of a feeling of helplessness and quite another to walk peacefully, inviting oppression and suffering upon himself despite being fully armed, while totally being able to fight back. The first constitutes a cowardice, the second a force. I can't help but think that the sort of non-violence practiced by Gandhi's followers in India was that of the weak, that of the helpless. I believe that most did not truly understand the principles of non-violence in the manner in which Gandhi preached it. Rather they just thought they would be unable to win independence through other means. I come to this conclusion because of the history of Indians both before and after Gandhi. An obvious fact is that Indians as a race have been oppressed for the last several hundred years by the Moguls (and later on by the British). Many of them never uttered a word of protect against the atrocities that were committed against their kith and kin, atrocities which were much worse than those perpetrated by the British. Even fewer actually took up actions against the Moguls (the major exception of course being the Marathas in the south). It was quite common for invaders such as Abdali and Nadir Shah to invade India, take Indian jewelry and Indian women and head back to Afghanistan. Yet there were very few strong voices that opposed this. This was because of fear. This fear is what stopped them from participating in any course of action besides submitting to their oppressors. It seems like over time most Indians have developed a "learned helplessness". Following Gandhi's ideas arose from this feeling of helplessness. Indians followed Gandhi's beliefs not because they thought non-violence was a superior weapon in dealing with social problems, as Gandhi had preached, but rather because they felt they had no other alternative. This in itself defeats the whole purpose of non-violence. It was quite common for Indians to one day be peacefully protesting and the next day to form lynch mobs. The only conclusion I can come to in order to reconcile these two thoughts is that they had no idea what the real essence of non-violent agitation was. The simple fact that after Gandhi his philosophy of non-violence has been completely abandoned by the people of India at large seems to point toward this conclusion. To me, Gandhi came across as being an uncompromising extremist. A non-violent extremist, but an extremist nevertheless. His letters to the British people during World War Two encouraging them to "allow yourself, man, woman, and child, to be slaughtered" by "peacefully surrendering" to the Nazis in order to further his fanatic ideas of non-violence is a perfect example (CW Vol. 72 pg 229 231, CW Vol. 72 pg. 177). When pressed even further, he went to the extent of calling Guru Gobind Singh, the Maratha Shivaji and George Washington "misguided patriots" for taking up arms in defense of their people (CW Vol. 26 pg. 486-492). Had Gandhi lived under the likes of Aurangzeb, in almost all likelihood he would have been arrested and hanged for even showing the slightest bit of defiance to the Mogul Empire. His non-violent ways worked because the British were not total tyrants, rather just concerned with exploiting Indians for their own economic gain. The aim of the British was not to annihilate them, as Aurangzeb and Hitler had attempted to do to their subjects. Thus the situation was ideal for the implementation of non-violent agitation. According to Gandhi, only "evil and violence" came about from those who use violence. He seems to totally disregard the idea of a "noble cause", basing his ideas of whether a movement was right or wrong on his narrow view of whether or not non-violence was being used. No doubt history has shown that those who used violence for the sake of unworthy causes ultimately did perpetuate violence and evil upon themselves. But, at the same time, those who used violence because of noble causes (as in defense of their people), the rule did not apply. There is a certain undeniable beauty in watching or reading about others who are fighting for noble and legitimate causes. Perhaps one of the best examples I can bring up is reading about the American Revolution. There is a certain magnificence, a certain holiness, about those people fighting for their rights. The fact that they used arms to achieve their freedom did not discount the righteousness of what they did.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

..... · 03 Oct 2005

Singh said "no, I heard that in Bhai Parminder Singh's katha as well. Perhaps this was another incident but this one didn't involved Dr. Ganda Singh at all and Gandhi never stopped making derogatory comments about Sikhs and Guru Sahib" ___________________________________________________ Who was Dr Ganda Singh & wot is the incidence that is referred to?

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

SinghNature · 03 Oct 2005

Nice Post and clearly shows Randhi in his true light as a feeble human being with a twisted intellect

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Lionking · 03 Oct 2005

UKSINGH - do u have a source for this? LS thanks for the name of the book - will have a look after it. thanks

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Bhudysut · 04 Oct 2005

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh Below is an article by Alice Basarke regarding the origins of the Non-violent (ahinsa) movement. Although Gandhi was accredited with the origins of this movement, it was in fact the Sikh's who instigated it. Just for general knowledge purposes, it was in fact Bhai Maharaj Singh who is actually officially recoginised as starting the peaceful protest. Also there is another very good book about Gandhi call Gandhi: The Mask Behind Divinity. by G.B. Singh (I highly recommend it). Dass Akaal Sahai Singh ORIGINS Of NON-VIOLENCE MOVEMENT IN INDIA (Alice Basarke) As fate would have it Mahatma Gandhi is credited with starting the non-violent movement to oust the British out of India. Gandhi deserves a lot of praise because he did implement the principles of non-violence, but he certainly was not the originator of that concept. He learnt that from the Sikhs. The Sikhs drew their inspiration from their very Gurus, two of who had suffered martyrdom in order to make their point. Over time, the principle of non-violence was used again and again. In 1861 the British had introduced the Waqf Act which gave control and management of the holy places to their respective communities. The Hindus and Muslims were given control of their places of worship. But in the case of Sikh Gurdwaras, the Act was not applied. The British knew full well that the Sikhs drew their strength and inspiration from their scripture and ideology. They also knew that Sikhs had a long history of fighting oppression and injustice no matter what the cost. For well planned political reasons, the properties of Sikh places of worship were transferred and given over to Hindu caretakers (Udasi Mahants) and who could be more easily controlled by the British masters. Most of these caretakers had very litte understanding Of Sikh religion and its practices. These caretakers received their instructions from the Deputy Commissioner, a Britisher. The government needed to maintain the Gurdwaras as channels of indirect control of the Sikhs. Naturally the Sikhs were not happy with this arrangement. It was a major factor in the first uprising against the British. At that rime there was a small group of Sikhs known as the Namdharis. Ram Singh (1815 -1885) was their leader. He once served in the army of Maharaja Ranjit Singh. In 1849 when the British annexed Punjab, his army unit was disbanded. Ram Singh hated the British whom he called ferengis (foreigners). He was further incensed at the takeover of the Gurdwaras in 1861 by the British, and the fact that nobody was able to do anything about this. He was very perturbed at the intrigue and duplicity all around him. Sikhs who fought and died to keep the British out of Punjab were now starting to admire all things British. The fact that they were most intolerant somehow did not register on the conquered Sikhs. Yet in the words of Brigadier-General John Jacob a leader of Indian cavalry, "the British were the favorites of heaven, the civilizeres of the world. They were masters of India because they were superior beings by nature to the Asiatic. Their superiority, both in science and religion, induced them to look down upon dark-skinned heathens". After the collapse of the Sikh Empire, Ram Singh turned to religion and meditation, on God's name, hence the name Namdhari due to his intense piety, he had many admirers. However, his military training and political preoccupation soon emerged as the main topic of his sermons. He started the non-violent movement to oust the British out of Punjab. He preached the Sikh gospel with great fervor, both to fight the progress being made by Christian missionaries, and to stop the evil political and cultural effects of foreign rule. He asked the people to boycott all British goods. "Do not accept service with the government; do not send children to government schools; do not go to court of law but settle disputes by reference to panchayats (village council); do not use foreign goods; do not use government postal services." His followers spun their own cloth and dressed in pure white cotton, and boycotted all that was even remotely British. His following grew very rapidly, which alarmed the British masters. The East India Company had a great monopoly going. Cotton was being shipped to England, where it was processed and made into cloth. British economy was booming. Every one had a job. The cloth manufactured in England was shipped back to India and sold at a great profit. Ram Singh's preaching was a threat to the British system. Moreover, he fed the people prophecies of a Sikh resurgence. He truly believed that it could be won by peaceful means. However, because his following grew too rapidly, he soon lost control of some members of the group. A small group of Kooka fanatics, as the Namdharis came to be known, murdered some Muslim butchers in Amritsar and Raikot (Ludhiana district). For this, eight of them were hanged. Though the passions of the Kookas were inflamed, Ram Singh was still able to persuade his followers to return peacefully to their homes. L. Cowan, the deputy commissioner of Ludhiana saw this as an opportunity not to be wasted. Using the pretext, of the above mentioned incident, he captured 68 Kookas, including 27 seriously wounded as they were making their way home. Smt. Hookmee, a popular preacher of this sect was one of two women also captured. Cowan sent a note to his commissioner, T.D. Forsythe, and without any further formality, or pretence of trial blew up 66 of the prisoners by tying them to the mouths of cannons. Two were hacked to pieces with a sword. Forsythe then joined Cowan at Malerkotla, where 16 more Kookas were rounded up and blasted off cannons. The reasons for this barbarism was not the murder of Muslim butchers as is evident in these words of Cowman: I propose blowing away from guns, or hanging, the prisoners tomorrow morning at daybreak. Their offence is not an ordinary one. They have not committed mere murder and dacoity; they are open rebels, offering resistance to constitutional authority, and, to prevent the spreading of this disease, it is absolutely necessary that repressive measures should be prompt and stern. I act for the best, this incipient insurrection must be stamped out at once." The commissioner T.D. Forsythe supported the action of his deputy. He wrote in a letter dated January 18, 1872; "My dear Cowan, I fully approve and confirm all you have done. You have acted admirably." For those who may wonder just what blowing from guns means, the following graphic description has been found- "Only those with the strongest stomachs, however, could remain unaffected when prisoners were blown away from the mouths of cannon, a punishment inflicted by the British in India. This was a "frightful sight", Dr. John Sylvester thought; and for the victims a peculiarly horrible punishment since, though hanging in itself was sufficient to make paradise uncertain, death by mutilation after defilement made its attainment even less likely. The victim was latched to a gun, the small of his back or the pit of his stomach against the muzzle, then "smeared with the blood of someone murdered by a member of his race if such could be procured". [Sylvestees diaries] When the gun was fired the man's body was dismembered. Usually the head, scarcely disfigured, would fly off through the smoke then fall to the earth, slightly blackened, followed by the arms and legs. The trunk would be shattered, giving off "a beastly smell", and pieces of the flesh and intestines and gouts of blood would be splashed not only over the gunners but also over any spectators who stood too close. Vultures would hover overhead and with grisly dexterity catch lumps of flesh in their beaks. "The pent up feelings of the bystanders found vent in a sort of loud gasp like Ah-h! Wrote an artillery officer who was required to supervise such an execution. "Then many of them came across the ditch to inspect the remains of the legs, and the horrible affair was over." This horrendous slaughter took place on January 11 - 12, 1872. Cowan was right. Ram Singh was a dangerous Sikh. Had he not been dealt with promptly and sternly, he would have gone down in history as the real father of the nation, for the British would have been thrown out almost a hundred years sooner. Many years later, Mahatma Gandhi had only copied the plans of Ram Singh to earn this title. Even the boycott of British cloth was copied. The spinning of cotton, and the wearing of only white, hand spun cotton was exactly as Ram Singh had prescribed. The second major non-violent revolt against the British was again enacted by Sikhs- It was known as the Singh Sabha movement and was started in 1873, only one year after the Namdharis were murdered so brutally by the so called civilized British. It took some rime, but the Singh Sabha movement steadily gained momentum. Things took on an added urgency when in 1919, 1,500 unarmed civilians, Mostly Sikhs) were shot down in cold blood at the Jalianwalla Bagh in Amritsar, on orders of the British General Dyer. Winston Churchill had described the massacre: "as a monstrous event, an event which stands in singular and sinister isolation in the annals of British history" The early 1920s were very difficult times for the Sikhs in Punjab. The Singh Sabha movement organized campaigns where groups of ordinary unarmed people would march to their places of worship and ask peaceably to be given possession of their shrine. Every day one hundred volunteers, men, women and children would march peacefully to make their demands known. The first groups were arrested. Each morning a new group was ready to take up the march. The policy of arrests was abandoned. Now the police took to beating the passive resisters. They were clubbed mercilessly, dragged by the hair and thrown in the mud. Still, wave after wave of Sikhs would go to their Gurdwaras and demand to be given their rightful control. First there was a disturbance at Taran Taran, which resulted in a few deaths. A month later at Nankana Sahib, 130 Sikh worshippers were butchered by the hirelings of the caretaker of that place. The campaign continued. Unarmed men and women suffered beatings with bamboo canes and faced gunfire, still they kept on coming. Thousands were arrested. Still they kept on coming. The Maharaja of Nabha was deposed because he made no secret of his sympathy with the cause. The police fired upon a batch of passive resisters, which marched to Jaito to offer prayers for the deposed Maharaja. At least 40 were killed. The struggle ended in 1925 with the passage of the Sikh Gurdwara Act. In the last 5 years of agitation for regaining control of their places of worship, 30,000 men and women had gone to jail. 400 had been killed and over 2,000 seriously wounded. The political results were far reaching. The British lost forever the support and loyalty of the Sikhs. The struggle for independence continued, and Sikhs made a tremendous contribution before independence, the Sikh community was only 1.1% of the total population of India. What they achieved is nothing short of phenomenal. Gandhi was there, watching when the Sikhs were struggling to regain control of their Gurdwaras, through non-violent means. Indeed he admired their courage and their tactics, sending congratulatory notes on more than one occasion. One such telegram dated Jan. 19, 1922 and addressed to the Sikh leadership, read: The first decisive battle for independence won. Congratulations.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

desidalip · 04 Oct 2005

Thanks for the posts in response. I always can appreciate a open discussion! I don't think Gandhi was saying Guru Ji was a bad person. I think Gandhi believed very strongly in non-violence and was suggesting that Indian indepdence should not be taken by the sword. I'm sorry but people on this board are crazy if they're attacking Gandhi. He may have misspoke but it is utterly ridiculous to compare him to Hitler. Are you drunk? Gandhi's ideology has freed people in South Africa, Poland, and even the United States from oppression the same kind of oprression our Guru Ji fought against. They are both good. You are stupid if you don't see that! Also, it's sickening that someone would call for Gandhi's assaination.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

most_liberal_extremist · 04 Oct 2005

Gandhi was a typical hindu who was into casteism and PURITY of high castes.He was a RACIST.Kindly read the following: http://www.thetruthseeker.co.uk/article.asp?ID=2419 What do we know about this “great man”? His motivations were to become “father of nation” but he never clarified what he meant by “nation”. Sikhs already have a father - Guru Gobind Singh Ji. If he was talking about hindus then since when did hindus become a nation? When British occupied rest of the India and went to war with Sikhs, one of the generals wrote “Now we are going to war with Sikh nation.” This is very important statement because he used the word “nation” only for Sikhs and not for any other hindu or muslim kingdoms. By 1930 Gandhi had started referring himself as “bapu”. He was quick in changing stances. At one time he would say “If I and congress..” and other time he would say “I am not in congress so I am not responsible for their actions.” For him Guru Gobind Singh Ji was a “misguided patriot” but at the same time he loved the stories of Krishna helping Arjun to fight his own brothers in the battlefield. Little did he know that whereas Guru Gobind Singh Ji fought for freedom and justice, his savior lords rama and Krishna fought for personal gains and preached nothing new. Their lifestyle was completely dedicated to caste system and idol worship. His lords fought wars and killed people by attacking from behind but he himself adopted non-violent method. Gandhi himself believed in caste system so how could he be “father of nation” since majority of the Indian people in his eyes were inferior to Brahmins (12% of Indian population)? Guru Gobind Singh Ji fought for human rights. Sikhs have all qualities of a Nation and thus their father Guru Gobind Singh Ji is the real Father of Nation. He also said “I ask Sikhs to give up Gurmukhi Lipi which has no foundation and uniqueness. They should adopt Devnagri which would prove their loyalty to the country.” . What he thought about his countrymen is expressed in his following words: "We [Indians] can only be granted the responsibility of freedom once we learn to civilze ourselves first. [like the British]" And further he said: "I would give up the finest sons of India to save the British empire in it's dying hour" A man who not only submitted to foreign rule but also tried his best to save that rule is a true coward. His barbaric and contradicting speeches make no sense whatsoever.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Straight Arrow · 04 Oct 2005

Author: most_liberal_extremist Date: 10-04-05 13:18 Gandhi was a typical hindu who was into casteism and PURITY of high castes.He was a RACIST.Kindly read the following: http://www.thetruthseeker.co.uk/article.asp?ID=2419 My dear most liberal extremist. Just one question. If only the typical Hindu believes in the purity of castes, then what are you? Your email Id is: [address removed] If that does not signify your underlying racism, I don't know what does. Please note: I am, in no way, trying to justify what Gandhi did or did not do, or whether or not the "typical Hindu" believes in the caste system but only to underline your duality. You are very quick to criticize but your own ID reeks of racism, else why have JATT in your email ID? Thank you.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

most_liberal_extremist · 05 Oct 2005

Dear brother straight arrow sat sri akal I am a worm among all the worms on this planet.Yes,i was into jatt jatt thing in my life and its then I made this Id.I have changed a lot now. I was wrong but GANDHI WAS WRONG TOO and the world doesnt know about it.Indian historians have made this hypocrat old man into a PEACE GOD. If gandhi was present during nadir shah and ahmad shah abdali times,his bald,small famine indicator head would have been removed in a second and this PEACE god would have rested in peace. I was over proud of my caste(thanks to the punjabi videos and punjabi environment in general) but I never thought of purifying people of low castes.Infact whenever i saw some old sikh driving richshaw etc I feel like giving him so much money so that he doesnt have to drive richshaw again. Jatt was more of a bravery and no fear type image for me rather than thinking in terms of upper caste and lower caste. take care KHALISTAN ZINDABAD

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

desidalip · 06 Oct 2005

You guys are all crazy. Literally and figuratively. On this message board you seem to have the majority of extremists but fotunately for all of us people like you do not run this world. It's too bad that none of you can see the dignity and peace of what Gandhi did. Guru Gobind Singh was not an advocator of pure violence, whenever you need to. Rather, only when it was an absolute necessity. For you though war is good, peace is weak. I don't understand that. In fact, Gandhi knew that India could not win independence through war. The British had the munitions and military technology and organization to win. That's how they had controlled India since 1857. The Battle of Plessy displayed the British's organizational strengths despite India's numerical advantages. Even if India did win independence at what cost? How many more lives would have been lost? Different times call of course for different measures and to suggest say that Gandhi was a bad person is not only ridiculous but ignorant. You people need to get out of your little worlds and go to the book store and buy and read some books.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Singh5 · 07 Oct 2005

Hahahaa - i got brought that book - Myth of the Mahatma - I havent read it yet but all i can say is the cover is quite funny - some may say harsh lol - whole book is in india flag colour then theres a pic of Gandhi's face on top of a hindu God statue with 8 arms - lol - opened the post in the morning and it gave me laugh an made my day lol soz 4 offending any ppl who may respect this guy who said bad things about the great supreme Kalgidhar Dasmesh Pita Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji!!!!!!!!

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Singh · 09 Oct 2005

desidalip, If he was such a great soul (mahatma) than why was he a proponent of the caste system? I find that most people who support Gandhi know of him only through the movie "Gandhi." If we're going by just the movie then I have to admit he was a great man. BUT, the movie is not based on facts and thus is purely a propaganda piece. In fact, a third of the cost of the movie was paid for by Indira Gandhi and the Congress Party. The best way to know Gandhi, or anyone, is to read their work or hear their speeches yourself. Read first hand material and you will see the true Gandhi. >>I don't think Gandhi was saying Guru Ji was a bad person. I think Gandhi believed very strongly in non-violence and was suggesting that Indian indepdence should not be taken by the sword.<< A myth surrounding Gandhi is that he was purely non-violent (like Ben Kingsley in the movie). This is false. Heres what he wrote in 1920. "I do believe that where there is only a choice between cowardice and violence I would advise violence. Thus when my eldest son asked me what he should have done, had he been present when I was almost fatally assaulted in 1908, whether he should have run away and seen me killed or whether he should have used his physical force which he could and wanted to use, and defended me, I told him that it was his duty to defend me even by using violence. Hence it was that I took part in the Boer War, the so-called Zulu rebellion and the late War. Hence also do I advocate training in arms for those who believe in the method of violence. I would rather have India resort to arms in order to defend her honour than that she should in a cowardly manner become or reamin a helpless witness to her own dishonour." (Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi 18, # 91, p. 132). So here hes saying violence is okay to use if you have to use it. Violence as a last means. So having read this, isn't he a hypocrit for saying Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji was misguided. This trend of hypocricy is seen over and over again throughout his life. He told the British that they should surrender to the Nazi's and be nonviolent (Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi 72, # 281, p. 230). He told the Jews that they should be non violent and that they should commit collective suicide (Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi 68, # 225, p. 191-93). But when war-time activity increased in Asia, he asked the Chinese not to submit to the Japanese, and when the Japanese came near the Eastern border of India, he called for the defense of India by all means, including the mobilization of Indian soldiers. (Maron, Stanley "The Non-Universality of Satyagraha, p 277). >>I'm sorry but people on this board are crazy if they're attacking Gandhi. He may have misspoke but it is utterly ridiculous to compare him to Hitler. Are you drunk?<< In a letter to the British viceroy Lord Linlithgow, he said, "You are losing; if you persist, it will only result in greater bloodshed. HITLER IS NOT A BAD MAN. If you call it off today he will follow suit." (Payne, Robert. The Life and Death of Mahatma Gandhi. p 488). So you see, he wouldn't have been offended by being compared to Hitler. >>Gandhi's ideology has freed people in South Africa, Poland, and even the United States from oppression the same kind of oprression our Guru Ji fought against. They are both good. You are stupid if you don't see that!<< Gandhi equated blacks with people of the lowest caste in India. In fact he said that blacks were even worse than the lowest caste. He joined the South African government in the Zulu rebellion to show them that High caste Indians are like the white people of South Africa. He wasn't offended by the treatment Blacks were getting, he was offended by the fact that he, a Brahmin, was being considered the same as a black. The truth is that he was a very clever lawyer and a politician who lied and used tact to further the cause of Hindu domination in India. He is the founding father of India and it is his policies that we see in work today in modern day India. >>You people need to get out of your little worlds and go to the book store and buy and read some books.<< You need to follow your own advice and buy Gandhi: Behind the Mask of Divinity from your local bookstore.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Singh5 · 09 Oct 2005

....or you can buy - The Myth of the Mahatma - ahhahahahahahahahaha - the front cover still kills me hahahahha lols but seriously.......as a Sikh - i or prob most other sikhs as well dont want anything to do or give respect to a person that has no respect for my father Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji!!! waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

DS · 09 Oct 2005

Mohandas once said when he met a person termed 'low caste' in the Hindu system 'I would like to be born a low caste person in my next life', the 'low caste' person replied 'why don't you live in my conditions now'. Mohandas had no reply to this.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

LionKing · 11 Oct 2005

All of these stories about M.K Gandhi - Where is the historical Proof? Which Book mentions these stories - i.e the one about the SIngh slapping him after he talked about Guru Ji, or the story "DS" just narrated with him saying he wants to be borna low-caste (I highly doubt the latter one) thanks =)

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

DSB · 11 Oct 2005

The quote about the low caste incident is from; 'The Myth of the Mahatma: Gandhi, the British and the Raj ' By Michael Edwardes

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

**- · 11 Oct 2005

Brother desidalip I urge you to leave this message board immediately! Everybody here hates Hindus and has nothing good to say about anyone that is a Hindu. According to them we are: -Cowards -Racist -Cruel -Intolerant -Stupid -Timid -Weak -Cheats Plus any other negative attribute invented by God. It is because of us [Hindus] that the world is plaugued with problems. If they had their way, the world would be Hindu-free. In fact nobody here will acknowledge anything good about Hindus/Hinduism. They are full of hatred towards us - which is a bit of a shame. But I think Sikhs need Hindus, I mean after all who else are they going to look down upon?

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

akmskm · 11 Oct 2005

**_ I think you're generalising now, all sikhs do not look down upon hindus but I wont deny I look down on Gandhi. That man was a loser and that is all I will say. But hindus, to call them all the list would be generalising and thats stupid .

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

DS · 11 Oct 2005

The criticism is of Mohandas not Hindus. Even the BJP and RSS have criticised him, in fact the RSS shot him dead. People should criticise leaders that way the corruption and human rights violations would be reduced for all religions.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

LS · 29 Dec 2005

RACISM OF INDIAN FOUNDER EXPOSED (Extensions of Remarks - December 13, 2005) HON. EDOLPHUS TOWNS OF NEW YORK IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES TUESDAY, DECEMBER 13, 2005 Mr. TOWNS. Mr. Speaker, the unveiling of a statue of Mohandas K. Gandhi in Johannesburg, South Africa, set off a discussion about the anti-black racism of the founder of India. When the eight-foot high Gandhi statue was unveiled, portraying him as a young human-rights lawyer, many leaders attacked Gandhi's anti-black statements. “Gandhi had no love for Africans,'' said one letter in The Citizen, a South African newspaper. “To him, Africans were no better than the `Untouchables' of India.'' As you may know, Mr. Speaker, the dark-skinned aborigines of the subcontinent, known as Dalits or “Untouchables,'' occupy the lowest rung on the ladder of India's rigid and racist caste system. The caste system exists to protect the privileged position of the Brahmins, the top caste. Although it was officially banned by India's constitution in 1950, it is still strictly practiced in Hindu India. Others have pointed out that Gandhi ignored the suffering of black people during the colonial occupation of South Africa. When he was arrested and forced to share a cell with black prisoners, he wrote that they were “only one degree removed from the animal.'' In other words, Mr. Speaker, he described blacks as less than human. We condemn anyone who says this in our country, such as the Ku Klux Klan and others, as we should. Why is Gandhi venerated for such statements? In addition, G.B. Singh, a Gandhi biographer, has looked through many pictures of him and never seen one single black person. Gandhi also attacked white Europeans. Gandhi is honored as the founder of India. These statements and attitudes reveal the racist underpinning behind the secular, democratic facade of India. It explains a worldview that permits a Dalit constable to be stoned to death for entering the temple on a rainy day, that allows the murders of over 300,000 Christians in Nagaland, over 250,000 Sikhs in Punjab, Khalistan, over 90,000 Muslims in Kashmir, tens of thousands of Christians and Muslims elsewhere in the country, including Graham Staines and his two young sons, and tens of thousands of Assamese, Bodos, Dalits, Manipuris, Tamils, and other minorities. It explains why the pro-Fascist, Hindu militant RSS is a powerful organization in India, in control of one of its two major political parties. India must abandon its racist attitudes and its exploitation of minorities. It must allow the enjoyment of full human rights by everyone. Until it does so, we should stop our aid and trade with India. Furthermore, Mr. Speaker, the essence of democracy is the right to self-determination. India must allow self-determination for Kashmir, as it promised the United Nations in 1948, in Punjab, Khalistan, in Nagaland, and wherever the people seek to free themselves from the boot of Indian oppression. We should put this Congress on record in support of self-determination for the people of the subcontinent in the form of a free and fair plebiscite on the question of independence. Khalistan declared its independence on October 7, 1987. The people have never been allowed to have a simple, democratic vote on the matter. Instead, India continues to oppress the people there with over half a million troops. Mr. Speaker, reporter Rory Carroll of The Guardian wrote an excellent article on the controversy about the Gandhi statue. I would like to place it in the Record at this time. www.khalistan.com -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- [The Guardian, Friday Oct. 17, 2003] GANDHI BRANDED RACIST AS JOHANNESBURG HONOURS FREEDOM FIGHTER (By Rory Carroll) It was supposed to honour his resistance to racism in South Africa, but a new statue of Mahatma Gandhi in Johannesburg has triggered a row over his alleged contempt for black people. The 2.5 metre high (8ft) bronze statue depicting Gandhi as a dashing young human rights lawyer has been welcomed by Nelson Mandela, among others, for recognising the Indian who launched the fight against white minority rule at the turn of the last century. But critics have attacked the gesture for overlooking racist statements attributed to Gandhi, which suggest he viewed black people as lazy savages who were barely human. Newspapers continue to publish letters from indignant readers: “Gandhi had no love for Africans. To [him], Africans were no better than the `Untouchables' of India,'' said a correspondent to The Citizen. Others are harsher, claiming the civil rights icon “hated'' black people and ignored their suffering at the hands of colonial masters while championing the cause of Indians. Unveiled this month, the statue stands in Gandhi Square in central Johannesburg, not far from the office from which he worked during some of his 21 years in South Africa. The British-trained barrister was supposed to have been on a brief visit in 1893 to represent an Indian company in a legal action, but he stayed to fight racist laws after a conductor kicked him off a train for sitting in a first-class compartment reserved for whites. Outraged, he started defending Indians charged with failing to register for passes and other political offences, founded a newspaper, and formed South Africa's first organised political resistance movement. His tactics of mobilising people for passive resistance and mass protest inspired black people to organise and some historians credit Gandhi as the progenitor of the African National Congress, which formed in 1912, two years before he returned to India to fight British colonial rule. However, the new statue has prompted bitter recollections about some of Gandhi's writings. Forced to share a cell with black people, he wrote: “Many of the native prisoners are only one degree removed from the animal and often created rows and fought among themselves.'' He was quoted at a meeting in Bombay in 1896 saying that Europeans sought to degrade Indians to the level of the “raw kaffir, whose occupation is hunting and whose sole ambition is to collect a certain number of cattle to buy a wife with, and then pass his life in indolence and nakedness''. The Johannesburg daily This Day said GB Singh, the author of a critical book about Gandhi, had sifted through photos of Gandhi in South Africa and found not one black person in his vicinity. The Indian embassy in Pretoria declined to comment, as it prepared for President Thabo Mbeki's visit to India. Khulekani Ntshangase, a spokesman for the ANC Youth League, defended Gandhi, saying the critics missed the bigger picture of his immense contribution to the liberation struggle. Gandhi's offending comments were made early in his life when he was influenced by Indians working on the sugar plantations and did not get on with the black people of modern-day KwaZulu-Natal province, said Mr. Ntshangase.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

R singh · 29 Dec 2005

FROM SIKH SANGAT, WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS? "source: bhramgyani daie bachan. So i was talking to nanaksar bhai sahib, mahatma gandhi topic came up , bhai sahib from nanaksar shared a sakhi of baba nand singh ji maharaj talking about past life about mahatma gandhi- baba ji said mahatma gandhi was traitor gungu bhramin personal cook of sri guru gobind singh.. even though he was traitor since he happen to did seva of sri guru gobind singh ji (guru avtar), he was given all the fame all around the world and known as mahatama gandhi... baba ji said, as gandhi that was gangu bhramin's last life as "human"...after that, he will send down to narak for thousands years in under hakum of akaal purkh because he betrayed Guru Ghar and he was namak of guru ghar. quite interesting sakhi..so i thought i'd share with the sangata." if this is true then gandhi wasnt so great was he...

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

?? · 29 Dec 2005

>>>>>>>>>>> in fact the RSS shot him dead. >>>>>>>>>>> What? Really??

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

Dogra · 01 Jan 2006

Very good post!

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

JEEVAN SINGH · 02 Jan 2006

KHALISTAN ZINDABAD !!!! KHALSA WILL HAVE RAJJ ALL OVER INDIA [%sig%]

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

GUNGU IN HIS OWN WORDS · 07 Jan 2006

A HYPOCRITE, LIER, RACIST, OPPRESSOR AND A BIGOT... IN HIS OWN WORDS! "Being a Hindu Gujrati myself… I only wish that institutions will crop up all over India and be the means of preserving the Aryan Religion in its purity!" .... ....from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.4 pg.407) [The Hindu, 28/10/1896 Visit to Hindu Theological High School] A baffoons idea about the formation of Sikhi ".. he [Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji] accepted the reasoning of Kabir and made similar attempts to fuse the two religions. But while doing so, he felt that Hinduism should be defended against Islam. This gave rise to Sikhism and produced the Sikh Warriors." ... .... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.4 pg.407) [25/3/1905, speech in Johannesburg] This prat will not let it go!! "The influence of Mohammedanism on Hinduism gave rise to Sikhism and it brought out one of the chief characteristics of the religion, namely, tolerance, in its true light and fullness." ... ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.4 pg.376) [11/3/1905, speech in Johannesburg] Gungu has the audacity in insulting our Gurus, desh mesh pita and obviously lacks knowledge or blessings of our Gurus. "The Sikh Gurus.. were all Hindus and that Guru Gobind Singh was one of the greatest defenders of Hinduism." ... .. from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.28 pg.263) [Young India, 1/10/1925] Pir bulle shah said aboujt Sri SatGuru Gobind Singhjee "I do not talk of the past, nor the future, I talk of now! If it was not for Guru Gobind Singh, the whole of India would have been circumcised and converted to a foreign faith" But what does ungrateful Gungu Ram say ... "..Guru Gobind Singh was a misguided patriot because he believed in warfare for noble cause." ... ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.26 pg.490) [Young India, 9/4/1925] Further insults... "..had I lived as their contemporary.. Including Guru Govind Singh..I would have called.. everyone of them a misguided patriot." ... ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.28 pg.263) [Young India, 1/10/1925] ABOUT UNTOUCHABLES CONVERTING TO OTHER FAITHS "I don’t mind Untouchables (Shudra) if they do desire, being converted to Islam or Christianity." ... ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.48 pg.98) WHAT ABOUT CONVERTING TO SIKHI? "Today I will only say that to me Sikhism is part of Hinduism. But the situation is different from a legal point of view. Dr Ambedkar wants a change of religion. If becoming a Sikh amounts to conversion, then this kind of conversion on the parts of Harijans is dangerous" "If you can persuade the Sikhs to accept that Sikhism is a part of Hinduism and if you can make them give up the separate electorate, then I will have no objections to Harijans calling themselves Sikhs." ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.63, pg.267) This shows that Gungu had unrelenting hatred for the Guru Panth and the Guru Granth. WHAT DOES "MAHATMA" GUNGU HAVE TO SAY ABOUT THE KIRPAN? "The Guru has not said anywhere that you must grow your beards, carry Kirpans(swords) and so on." ... ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.68, pg.2) [Talking to Khudai Khidmatgors-I on 15/10/1938] "Today the Sikhs say that if they give up the Kirpan they give up everything. They seem to have made the Kirpan into their religion. By discarding it, they think., they will become weak and cowardly. I tell them, this is idol fear!" ... ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.68, pg.2) [Talk to Khudai Khidmatgors-I on 15/10/1938] GUNGU AND GURMUKHI ".. I wish you would persuade enlightened Sikhs to take Devnagri script in the place of the Gurmukhi." ... ... from "(Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.64, pg.41) [Letter dated 14/11/1936 to Amrit Kaur] The COngress Leaders obviously have shown their true mettle.. "I venture to suggest that the non-violence creed of the congress party is the surest guarantee of its good faith… and our Sikhs friends have no reason to fear betrayal at its hands ..For the moment it did so, the Congress would not only seal its own doom but that of the country too. Moreover, the Sikhs are a brave people, they will know how to safeguard their right by the exercise of arms if it shall ever come to that. Why can you have no faith? If Congress shall play false afterwards you can well settle surely with it, for you have the sword. I ask you to accept my word. Let God be witness of the bond that binds me and the Congress with you." ... ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.45, pg.231-33) [Young India 5/3/1931] ".. We have not done justice to the Sikhs." ... ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.38, pg.315) [Young India 5/3/1931] LETTER FROM LALPAT RAI ... "Our Sikh friends deserve all the praise one can bestow on brave, noble, sufferers in the cause of truth." ... ... from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.22, pg.25) [Letter from Lajpat Rai dated 3/12/1921] GUNGU RAMS RESPONSE... "I fully endorse Lalaji’s tribute to the Sikhs. Their resolute behaviour, their religious fervour, their calmness and their suffering command my highest admiration"... .. from (Collected works of Mahatma Gandhi (Author), Vol.22, pg.25) [Young India, 15/12/1921]

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

jsb · 07 Jan 2006

thank you for those quotes, gives us a far better insight

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

KS · 09 May 2006

The West believes to much nonsense about Mohandas, he was Brahmin extremist , who looked down on other religions and lower caste hindus.

Re: When a Singh Slapped Gandhi

disgusting · 11 May 2006

what did ghandi do for india? indians or even the menwomenfolk of his own rleigion? india was not free the british just raped its resources for 190 years through their whit and charm being a minority ruling over the indian mass. The indian mass rebbellion was becoming stronger through various movements in different parts, thus making it harder for british to retain complete frontman control. The british then created their own puppets and sent them into power in 1947 while sitting behind curtains in london . it was never azadi. indian property was downvaluaed 70% overnight on the so called azadi. Thus foreign trade british pound v indian rupee and foreign exchange trade centre based from london with an exchange of 520 billion a day in 1995 alone would mean british keep a more subtle control over these indians. If anything ghandi nehru the congress are the biggest traitors of asia. The common indian has paid back with poverty while ghandi nehru pocketed under foreigners. ghandis ahimsa did not pay off anything.