Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

USING MOUTHWASH

USING MOUTHWASH

mouthwash · 29 Sep 2005

What is the Sangat's view on using mouthwash?

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

vichar · 29 Sep 2005

it contains alcohol, just like vinegar.........can we eat vinegar, i dnt use it but still what does tapoban singhs think?

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

S Singh · 29 Sep 2005

You can get a few brands of mouthwash that are alcohol free. If it is to keep your breath fresh, you could use other things like lechiya.

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

AS · 29 Sep 2005

as long as ur not drinking it to get intoxicated, I think it should be alright. People use products with alcohol in it to disinfect all kinds of things. I work in the hospital and we use alcohol for a lot of things such as cleaning skin before doing a venipuncture or administering an intramuscular injection, cleaning instruments, wiping surfaces, inserting urinary cathetars etc... So as long as ur not ingesting it and just using it to disinfect your mouth, why not use mouthwash?

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

Bundha · 30 Sep 2005

Alcohol is a chemical term. There are a group of chemicals termed as alcohols, just like Acids, Alkalies, Estas (these substances all smell like nail varnish) Benzoids (smell of rancid butter)etc - 'A' level Chemistry you know! The alcohol that is consumed -sharaab - is one of these, not all are used for intoxicant purposes. Mythalated Spirit is a very strong disinfectant but is also termed as an alcohol. Now, should we as Sikhs avoid all these substances? this is open to debate but the mere word 'Alcohol' scares me away and I will normally avoid things with 'alcohol' in. Having said that a lot of disinfectants or wipes etc do contain alcohol. [%sig%]

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

vichar · 30 Sep 2005

tomato ketchup, brown sauce, heinz beans, all contain alcohol........should we avoid? if you have doubt about whether something has vinegar in, but you eat it ....then find out it did contain vinegar do you need to pesh?

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

tarrandeep kaur · 30 Sep 2005

lol vichar, isher singh. we've spoken bout this, you have asked more than 3 chardi kala gursikhs, and they sed its ok. wat does the sangat think bout isher singhs situation?

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

kksingh · 30 Sep 2005

vingear is not alcohol.

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

khalsitani · 30 Sep 2005

vingear has alcohol in it? so its considered sharaab?

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

simple singhani · 30 Sep 2005

yea..thers different types of alcohol..the ones that is ..intoxicated are the ones..that shops sell beind the till.they wont beable to sell shrab jus to anyne will they!! n how cum ..young babies are a loud 2 drink and eat this stuff...its a different type of sharaab yea man..listen to the A-level science guy!

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

soooo · 30 Sep 2005

is doing mouthwash considered wrong or not?

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

... · 30 Sep 2005

It's been a few years since I've done chemistry but I'm pretty sure that while alcohol and vinegar are related, they aren't the same thing. What is the act that is against Gurmat? It's drinking sharaab. Now this means an intoxicant. I am quite sure you could drink quite a bit of vinegar and while you might feel sick you will not be drunk. Vinegar is not sharaab. At the same time, vinegar is not an acceptable substance for a bibeki to use. But again, I am quite sure it's not sharaab. So mouthwash; mouthwash contains alcohol and yes, you can indeed get drunk by drinking mouthwash. Hobos do it all the time. Alcoholics use a lot of perfume and mouthwash to conceal the smell because both are alcohols. So would I want this in my mouth? No, not really. I don't think mouth wash is acceptable. It's not necessary. There are countless other ways to clean your mouth and make it smell nice, so why use one that you're uncomfortable with?

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

098 · 30 Sep 2005

What is wrong with you people ? alcohol is just another chemical. we eat\drink alcholo every day when we take a pain killer, or cook certain foods at home. yes drinking hard liquour would be bad but our body do need alcohol for certain things.....

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

amarjeet singh · 30 Sep 2005

"but our body do need alcohol for certain things....." uhhhhhh. no it doesnt

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

S Singh · 01 Oct 2005

Vinegar does not contain any intoxicating qualities so what is the problem ? Vinegar can be made from apples, grapes, malt or barley. The vinegar is put through oxidising and filtering stages to remove the alcohol. I guess we should avoid apples etc if we want to go to extremes.

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

UKSINGH · 01 Oct 2005

Vichar - Ishar Singh U seem to worry about little things. Guru Mara talks alot about dubiya - doubt don't have doubts in your mind about something so minor as eating vinegar - :)))))

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

Jasmin · 01 Oct 2005

So does this mean that amritdarea must avoid pickles, mustards and most salad dressings? These post seem to somewhat contradict each other. Most posts seem to say yes to this question. However, S Singh seems to think vinger is o.k. Personally it would seem hard to avoid vinger while eating out because it may be in a sauce or salad dressing. WjkkWjkf

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

S Singh · 02 Oct 2005

>>Author: amarjeet singh Date: 09-30-05 22:42 >>"but our body do need alcohol for certain things....." >>uhhhhhh. no it doesnt Oh yes it does. Bacteria in the body produce a very small amount of alcohol in the gastrointestinal tract. Of cause this does not mean you need to drink a few shots of whiskey as the body makes its own non intoxicating alcohol.

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

vichar · 02 Oct 2005

im just looking at it this way, gore put wine in their cooking now if you eat some vegetable pie, some wine was used in it, the pie will not make you drunk as only small amount of alcohol will be in it, just like only small amount of alcohol is in vinegar but this doesnt make it ok does it? im jus asking i dnt know the answer just listening to my consciounce,

Re: USING MOUTHWASH

amarjeet singh · 02 Oct 2005

"it would seem hard to avoid vinger while eating out because it may be in a sauce or salad dressing." eating out implies eating from manmukhs and possibly smokers. not very gurmat